And other unverified tales: Should Greta Gerwig have received an Oscar nomination for Best Director?
We have no real idea. Like most people you'll see answering this question with total certainty, we have no real idea how to judge performances by directors.
Meanwhile, only five such nominations are given. Is it possible that Gerwig's direction of Little Women was the year's sixth best?
As modern conventional pseudo-liberals, let's not bother ourselves with any such question as that. As liberals, we're currently sounding off about the way the director was wronged—about the way she was snubbed because she's a woman who directed a female-oriented film.
At present, every modern conventional pseudo-liberal knows that we must say such things. In this morning's Washington Post, Stephen King even joins the crowd, as he tries to get himself off the hook for a recent remark which has apparently been criticized on Twitter.
Seeking to prove his tribal good faith, King says that Gerwig's Little Women isn't just good, it's "astoundingly good." On balance, we thought the chronologically jumbled film was deeply confusing and, in that sense, a bit of a mess. But these are always subjective judgments, until tribal script comes along.
Why did King proceed today to the claim that the film is astoundingly good? As we've often noted, in various contexts:
When everyone has agreed that they will all Say The Same Thing, the only way to distinguish oneself is by embellishing the preapproved script. In this way, Candidate Gore was eventually said (by Arianna) to be wearing suit jackets with four buttons, not just the constantly ridiculed three.
King now says that the new Little Women is astoundingly good. As he does, he also says that his first published novel, Carrie, was a paean to female empowerment, apparently assuming that gullible readers will be willing to buy even that.
Alas! Major anthropologists insist that members of our failing species were wired to behave in such ways.
We're not sure if these future experts are right, but the sheer stupidity surrounding the Gerwig question has been hard to miss. Once again, consider:
Gerwig has now directed two films—Lady Bird (2017) and Little Women (2019). Out in Tinseltown, each film was nominated for a Best Picture Oscar. Gerwig received a Best Screenplay nomination for each film.
Also, Gerwig received a Best Director nomination for Lady Bird. But when the same directors' branch of the Academy didn't nominate her this year, we're told that she has experienced a snub, a snub caused by their sexism.
They nominated her for Best Director for her first female-oriented film. But when they failed to nominate her for her second female-oriented film, this proved that they're sexist!
You can't get a whole lot dumber than that. Experts point to scripts of this type as proof of our failing species' hard-wired sub-rational essence.
Tomorrow, we'll return to the scripted claims being made about Little Women. Today, let's consider the way our tribe's latest toy is being employed in a much wider arena.
At present, our liberal tribe owns only one toy. It's the only toy we have. For that reason, we take it out, and play with the toy, in every possible circumstance.
The toy to which we refer is our newly-discovered opposition to racism and sexism, with misogyny thrown in as well. At present, this is our failing tribe's only known toy. We rarely leave home without it.
We rarely leave home without it! Presumably, this explains the transparently silly piece which dominated the front page of the Washington Post's Style section last Tuesday morning.
The heartfelt piece was straight outta script. In print editions, it appeared beneath these headlines:
DISMISSED WIT PREJUDICEThe humorous headline said "wit," not "with!" Things spiraled downward from there.
Why female candidates' attempts at humor are judged differently
We'll start with the obvious question. Is it true? Are attempts at humor by female candidates judged differently than similar attempts by men?
We have no idea—but then, we have an excuse. You see, we read the Post's lengthy piece, in which Ellen McCarthy essentially offered zero evidence in support of this pleasing claim.
Frankly, it gets even worse. Late in the piece, McCarthy noted that "two of the women still in the 2020 presidential race"—Candidates Klobuchar and Warren—"have routinely deployed humor throughout their campaigns."
She then quotes former candidate Hillary Clinton saying she wishes she had employed more humor during his 2016 run.
McCarthy also notes that Gretchen Whitmire, the current governor of Michigan, chose to employ a type of humor at one point during her successful 2018 campaign. Earlier, she quotes a political consultant recalling the way the late Ann Richards was famous for her wit:
MCCARTHY (1/21/20): It is possible for women to pull this off, he says. Neffinger points to former Texas governor Ann Richards—who once quipped that George H.W. Bush was born with a silver foot in his mouth—as an example of a woman who wielded humor to great effect. The fact that she was older and white-haired may have made her barbs more palatable, he speculates, and she did it with “the big ol’ Texas grin to take the edge off it.”Luckily, Richards' white hair and big ol' grin allow us to dismiss her success with humor. Still and all, a question arises:
Given the premise of this essay, how dumb must Klobuchar, Warren and Clinton be? The first two are still trying to use humor out on the trail in the face of societal prejudice. The third is so dumb that she's willing to say she should have used humor more!
According to major experts, so it goes when we humans take out our favorite toys and tell the stories we like. Our longing for a simpler world leads us to offer the types of claims which are pleasing within the tribe, but may seem, to everyone else, like artifacts of a "very stable dumbness."
Are these credentialed experts right? We can't tell you that. Nor can we tell you whether female candidates really do pay a price, on average, as opposed to men, when they use humor on the trail. We can't tell you if the price is large, if there's a price at all.
It's certainly possible that women pay a price for using humor—but it's also possible that they don't! Having said that, let's turn to the ugly episode which triggered the piece which dominated the front page of Style.
Elizabeth Warren was cast as the victim in McCarthy's tale. She'd offered a wondrously humorous set of remarks—and she'd been punished for it!
McCarthy started her piece by recalling Warren's remarks. Her full account went like this:
MCCARTHY: It played like a well-rehearsed stand-up routine.Despite the societal prejudice, laughter and whooping filled the room as Warren advanced the kinds of assumptions Others will inevitably see as elite condescension.
“Let’s say you’re on the campaign trail . . .,” the audience member begins.
“I have been, yeah, uh-huh,” Elizabeth Warren nods, affecting exhaustion. The crowd at the televised CNN town hall titters with laughter.
The man asking the question continues: “A supporter approaches you and says, ‘Senator, I am old-fashioned, and my faith teaches me that marriage is between one man and one woman.’ What is your response?”
“Well, I’m going to assume it’s a guy who said that,” parries Warren, the senator from Massachusetts and presidential candidate. (More chuckles.) “And I’m going to say: ‘Then just marry one woman! I’m cool with that!’ ”
Laughter and whooping fills the room. Warren leaves space for the laugh, coolly shrugging and cocking her head and resting for a few beats before twisting the knife:
“Assuming you can find one.”
Warren assumed that only men would hold the old-fashioned view of marriage she was mocking. This of course is false.
She then proceeded to suggest that the kind of man who held that view could never get a woman to marry him. In fact, many such men are married to women who hold the exact same view.
Indeed, President Obama still held that view as of 2012. The aforementioned Hillary Clinton didn't support marriage equality until her 2016 campaign. Our own tribe has come to accept marriage equality roughly in the last ten minutes, but people like Warren are out on the trail mocking the millions of laggards.
People like Warren produce "laughter and whooping" when they mock people who hold the views our own stars held until quite recently. With that in mind, if Warren's jibes produced all that laughter and whooping, what makes McCarthy say that female candidates are punished for using humor?
What made McCarthy express that view? Prepare to encounter a very stable dumbness:
MCCARTHY (continuing directly): Forget that the joke had been teed up—the person asking the question, Morgan Cox, was chair of the board of directors at the Human Rights Campaign and a donor to Warren’s 2018 Senate campaign—it was a well-performed series of zingers, and many of the people who watched the exchange on YouTube after it happened in October seemed to agree.Yes, she actually did it!
Scroll down far enough, though, and you see a different kind of response.
“What a (preplanned) snarky, mean-spirited response she made,” wrote one commenter.
“Scorn,” wrote another, “mockery, contempt, self-congratulation . . . but hey, worked for Hillary, amIright?”
The list of double standards women face on their path to public office is plenty long...
McCarthy skipped past some actual news—this whole exchange in this CNN town hall had been planned, pre-packaged! She then scrolled through some comments on YouTube—and after scrolling "far enough," she found two (2) comments critical of Warren.
McCarthy looked through comments on line; she found two which were critical! On this basis, she assembled her lengthy piece, and the Post was willing to print it.
The evening after this essay appeared, representatives of Future Anthropologists Huddled in Caves despairingly held their heads in the hands as they appeared before us. (They communicate with us through puzzling nocturnal submissions which the haters deride as mere dreams.)
"Our species was wired for this type of dumbness," the glum future experts explained. On this occasion, we could think of no way to tell them they were wrong.
Tomorrow: The vast stable dumbness, it burns!
But isn't this quite an old story, dear Bob?
ReplyDeleteAnyhow, a Fake Indian performing the ancient ritual of aggressive virtue-signaling -- what's so special here? That's, simply, what Fake Indians do.
Her father was an Indian janitor who performed tasks consistent with tasks Indian janitors perform. Nothing to see here. Start on page 33.
DeleteYeah. That Indian/ janitor stuff really gets you goat about Warren. Not that she wants to hold Elites accountable.
DeleteLOL.
Calm down Liz.
DeleteAnd why don't you start with holding yourself accountable for your brilliant 'womyn of color' career.
I'm shocked that Mao wants Warren to start with something other than a HUGE tax break for his Establishment Elite friends.
DeleteEven with all his phony nonsense about hating Hillary Clinton because she's too deferential to the Establishment, I still didn't see that coming.
Whoa. You sound exactly like the resident psycho-dembot, the chairman of my fan-club here, dear Lizzy. It's spooky!
DeleteWarren is an Elite. Her Wealth Tax is idiotic and almost impossible to enforce.
DeleteAlmost impossible? Meh. You'll have no one to enforce it on. Everyone with money will denounce their US citizenship and become a proud citizen of Cayman Islands or Switzerland, or some such. It's been tested in Europe.
DeleteBut don't worry, dear Lizzy is just blowing hot air.
Let them leave.
DeleteThe money the USA saves in not having to use the military to protect their global assets and profits, will more than make-up for the tax dollars lost.
Mao,
Remember back when you pretended to hate Hillary Clinton because she loved the Elite? Good times!
"Whoa. You sound exactly like the resident psycho-dembot, the chairman of my fan-club here, dear Lizzy. It's spooky!"
DeleteAs the 'economically anxious' say, "Learn English if you want to live here."
Hello everyone i am Mudaf Kyle from MALARIA , i am here to give my testimony about a great Best Herbal Penis Enlargement Medicine called Dr OLU, I was heartbroken and disappointed because i had very small penis, not big enough to satisfy or pregnant a woman, i have been in so many relationship, but cut off because of my small penis situation, i have used so many product,drugs,vaccines,herbs which doctors prescribe for me, but none could offer me the help i searched for. one faithful day i saw some few comments on the internet about how this great specialist called Dr OLU has been helping men enlarge their penis size ,pregnant woman and last longer in bed and i decided to email him on his email i saw on the internet,(drolusolution@gmail.com) so I decided to give his herbal product a try. i emailed him and he got back to me, he gave me some comforting words and steps to follow which i did with his herbal pills for Penis Enlargement, Within 1 week of it, i began to feel the enlargement of my penis, " and now it just 1 weeks of using his products my penis is about 10.5 inches longer in erection , and i had to settle out with my Ex girlfriend Stephanie, i was surprised when she opened her mouth and said that i almost killed her and she is satisfied with my sex and i have got a very Big penis now.Am so happy, thanks to Dr OLU I also learn that Dr OLU also help with
Deletepenis enlargement
weak erection
erectile dysfunction
breast pills and enlargement bums,
so if you have any of this problem or other do not hesitate to contact Dr.OLU now for help on his email via (drolusolution@gmail.com or you can call him on his mobile number +2348140654426 ........Dr OluTHANKS
EFFECTIVE AND POWERFUL LOVE SPELL CASTER AND LOTTERY SPELL DR.OJOKASPELLTEMPLE@GMAIL. COM OR WHATSAPP HIM :+2348144172934
DeleteMy husband left me for a younger woman and I was devastated. It was as if she had him under an evil spell, Paul turned against me overnight without any warning. It happened last year, I was desperate so I used every single spell casting website that I could find with no results. A friend sent me the link to Dr. Ojoka site and I contacted him. He started working with me on June. As a result from all of his wonderful work, my man and I are back together. I’m so happy and privileged to have such a great person like you on my side. Thank you! Ojoka contact drojokaspelltemple@gmail .com or whats app him +2348144172934
check his website http://Drojokaspelltemple.website2.me
EFFECTIVE AND POWERFUL LOVE SPELL CASTER AND LOTTERY SPELL DR.OJOKASPELLTEMPLE@GMAIL. COM OR WHATSAPP HIM :+2348144172934
My husband left me for a younger woman and I was devastated. It was as if she had him under an evil spell, Paul turned against me overnight without any warning. It happened last year, I was desperate so I used every single spell casting website that I could find with no results. A friend sent me the link to Dr. Ojoka site and I contacted him. He started working with me on June. As a result from all of his wonderful work, my man and I are back together. I’m so happy and privileged to have such a great person like you on my side. Thank you! Ojoka contact drojokaspelltemple@gmail .com or whats app him +2348144172934
check his website http://Drojokaspelltemple.website2.me
DeleteI want to give a big thanks to a great spell caster commonly known as DR TAKUTA for the great spiritual prayers he did in my life by bringing my ex-lover back to me after many months of breakup and loneliness. With this, I am convinced that you are sent to this word to rescue people from heartbreaks and also to help us get the solution to every relationship problem. for those of you out there who have one relationship problem or the other why not contact DR TAKUTA. that is the best place you can solve all your problems, including a lack of jobs and promotions, binding and marriage spells, divorce and attraction spells, good luck and lotto spells, he has herbal medicine to cure any type of diseases and infections and medicine for infertility, and pregnancy spells, and also the business success and customer increase, winning court cases and many more. contact him at takutaspellalter@gmail.com or contact mobile contact +27788634102
I want to give a big thanks to a great spell caster commonly known as DR TAKUTA for the great spiritual prayers he did in my life by bringing my ex-lover back to me after many months of breakup and loneliness. With this, I am convinced that you are sent to this word to rescue people from heartbreaks and also to help us get the solution to every relationship problem. for those of you out there who have one relationship problem or the other why not contact DR TAKUTA. that is the best place you can solve all your problems, including a lack of jobs and promotions, binding and marriage spells, divorce and attraction spells, good luck and lotto spells, he has herbal medicine to cure any type of diseases and infections and medicine for infertility, and pregnancy spells, and also the business success and customer increase, winning court cases and many more. contact him at takutaspellalter@gmail.com or contact mobile contact +27788634102
“You see, we read the Post's lengthy piece, in which Ellen McCarthy essentially offered zero evidence in support of this pleasing claim.”
ReplyDeleteSomerby’s use of the word “essentially” should set off alarm bells for his readers.
In fact, McCarthy cites the following:
1. ‘“We often say that when women run for office they face a likability tightrope. They have to be so nuanced — and humor is a really good example of that,” says Amanda Hunter, director of research at the Barbara Lee Family Foundation.’
2. “women can be punished for their jokes, according to a study published last year in the Journal of Applied Psychology. [led by Jon Evans, a doctoral candidate at the University of Arizona] Researchers asked a man and woman to each give two versions of a speech to employees. When the man included humor, he was rated higher in terms of status, performance evaluation and leadership capability. When the woman included the exact same jokes in her speech, she was rated lower on all three fronts.”
3. “At Maggie’s List, a political action committee that works to increase the number of conservative women elected to federal office, humor is seen as so risky for women that the group advises female candidates to tell jokes that would be appropriate only for a grade-school audience — or forgo trying to be funny altogether.”
That’s three citations, and, yes, the study is linked to in the article.
And despite Somerby’s attempts to isolate the discussion to liberals, the article cites a conservative women’s group that has come to the same conclusion as the liberals.
“It's certainly possible that women pay a price for using humor—but it's also possible that they don't! “
ReplyDeleteHa ha ha ha! How glib! How vacuous!
So, apparently the takeaway is: women, why even discuss this? It upsets conservative white males, so just can it, why doncha.
“King now says that the new Little Women is astoundingly good. As he does, he also says that his first published novel, Carrie, was a paean to female empowerment, apparently assuming that gullible readers will be willing to buy even that.”
ReplyDeleteStephen King is a liar! No one can possibly believe he thought Little Women was astoundingly good. After all, Bob Somerby hated it.
Also, what a liar Stephen King is. His novel Carrie is about “female empowerment”, says King in 2020. It’s certainly not possible to find such an assertion from the Liar King that predates 2020?:
“De Palma’s approach to the material was lighter and more deft than my own... it was that high school is a place of almost bottomless conservatism and bigotry... adolescents who attend are no more allowed to rise “above their station”. But there’s a little more subtext to the book than that, I think—at least, I hope so. If The Stepford Wives concerns itself with what men want from women, then Carrie is largely about how women find their own channels of power, and what men fear about women and women's sexuality...writing the book in 1973... I was fully aware of what Women's Liberation implied for me and others of my sex. The book is, in its more adult implications, an uneasy masculine shrinking from a future of female equality. For me, Carrie White is a sadly misused teenager, an example of the sort of person whose spirit is so often broken for good in that pit of man- and woman-eaters that is your normal suburban high school. But she's also Woman, feeling her powers for the first time and, like Samson, pulling down the temple on everyone in sight at the end of the book. Heavy, turgid stuff—but in the novel, it’s only there if you want to take it.”
This quote is from King’s nonfiction work Danse Macabre, published just a few years before 2020...in 1981.
“Warren advanced the kinds of assumptions Others will inevitably see as elite condescension.”
ReplyDeleteAh yes. Political correctness demands that sexists and homophobes not be made the butt of a joke.
On the other hand, Trump’s non-stop denigrating jokes at the expense of the rest of us must be allowed to soar free.
Of course, Right-wingers love political correctness.
DeleteThey've been accusing Liberals of being too PC for decades.
In other (non) news, every Right-wing accusation is really a confession.
Since almost all women talk about the discrimination they experience, wouldn’t Somerby, as a supposed liberal, try to listen, rather than berate? Isn’t his whole attitude a kind of sexism, the man who has never experienced things from a woman’s perspective, presuming to lecture them about what they should talk about and how they should talk about it?
ReplyDeleteAs with education, he tries to reduce sexism to statistics, as if it can’t be plausibly asserted outside of some unobtainable statistical proof.
I'm going to need you to shut the f up now, dumb b.
Deletehttps://dilbert.com/strip/2020-01-30
DeleteEFFECTIVE AND POWERFUL LOVE SPELL CASTER AND LOTTERY SPELL DR.OJOKASPELLTEMPLE@GMAIL. COM OR WHATSAPP HIM :+2348144172934
ReplyDeleteMy husband left me for a younger woman and I was devastated. It was as if she had him under an evil spell, Paul turned against me overnight without any warning. It happened last year, I was desperate so I used every single spell casting website that I could find with no results. A friend sent me the link to Dr. Ojoka site and I contacted him. He started working with me on June. As a result from all of his wonderful work, my man and I are back together. I’m so happy and privileged to have such a great person like you on my side. Thank you! Ojoka contact drojokaspelltemple@gmail .com or whats app him +2348144172934
check his website http://Drojokaspelltemple.website2.me
MY STORY HERE IS REAL AND GENUINE. My name is Adams Vienna and i am here to testify about Great Mother who brought back my man to me when he broke up with me because of another woman who he met at his place of work. Great Mother is a very powerful, real and unique woman with special powers. I tried to get help from many places and sources to bring back my man but nothing worked but when i contacted Great Mother, she made me smile again by bringing my man back to me with her special powers.. If you are experiencing any problems in your marriage, relationship, and you have any similar problem to this, contact this Great Woman now she will help you. Here is her website: Ourgreatmother1.com and here is her email address: Greatmotherofsolutiontemple1@yahoo.com and you can also contact her now on her own Whatsapp number: +17025514367 You can either contact her on her website, email or her whatsapp number. Thank you Great Mother.
ReplyDeleteHello everybody, thanks to Dr LOSA the spell caster i am from USA, i don't just Know the reason why some people is finding it difficult to believe that there is a cure for HIV, my son have been suffering from HIV since last three years but today i am happy that he is cure from it with the herbal medicine of Dr DR LOSA the great healer,i was browsing the INTERNET searching for help when i came across a testimony shared by someone on how Dr LOSA cure his herpes i was so much in need of getting his treatment but after all Dr LOSA brought a smile to my son face with his herbal medicine. i am so much happy today that we have someone like this great healer out there, so my people out there kindly contact this great healer on his email address: (dr.losaherbalhome@gmail .com) please sir keep your good work cause there are people out there who is in need of your healing medicine.once more email him now: (dr.losaherbalhome@gmail.com) you can call him OR WHATSSAPP HIM +2349056464736
ReplyDeleteDOCTOR LOSA CAN AS WELL CURE THE FOLLOWING DISEASE:-
1. HIV/AIDS
2. HERPES
3. CANCER
4. ALS
5. Hepatitis
6 Diabetes
7 LOVE SPELL
8 IF YOU NEED YOUR EX LOVER BACK TO LOVE YOU AGAIN.
Good day to all viewer online am so happy sharing this great testimony on how i was checking for solution in the internet then miraculously i came Across Dr.LOSA the powerful herbalist that Cure Numerous individuals Herpes Simplex Virus,so I contacted him base on the testimonies I?m seeing about him on the internet, I was cured too by him, kindly contact him actoday through his email he can help you email ; dr.losaherbalhome@gmail.com and so he can cure types of diseases like,HEPATITIS B,DIABETICS,CANCER,HPV,LOW SPERM CAM HIV/STDS FIBROSIS LOST OF WEIGHT .. all thank to you Dr LOSA for your kindly help in my life his Mobile number +2349056464736
ReplyDeleteHe cure listed diseases
CANCER
HEPATITIS A AND B
DIABETIC.
HERPES
My name is DOROTHY LISA, I want to share a great testimony on this website on how great a man called Prophet Abulele helped me in getting pregnant, me and my husband have been trying to have a baby for over 12 years, but they were no luck so we decided to contact the family doctor and after all the test have been done, he said to us that my Fallopian tube is not functioning. then one day I was in the office when a friend of mine who had the same problem with me, got her baby after she contacted Prophet Abulele. she directed me to him and when I contacted him through his email: prophetabulelehealingtemple@gmail.com and he prayed for me and sent me an herbal medicine, which I took for few days and in 3 weeks’ time, as he told me, i was feeling somehow and I went to meet the family doctor who told me that I am pregnant. if you know that you have a similar problem like this, or any fertility issue and you want to be pregnant you can contact Prophet Abulele: prophetabulelehealingtemple@gmail.com OR WhatsApp him on +2349022406159
ReplyDeleteLOTTO, lottery,jackpot.
ReplyDeleteHello all my viewers, I am very happy for sharing this great testimonies,The best thing that has ever happened in my life is how I win the lottery euro million mega jackpot. I am a Woman who believe that one day I will win the lottery. finally my dreams came through when I email believelovespelltemple@gmail.com and tell him I need the lottery numbers. I have spend so much money on ticket just to make sure I win. But I never know that winning was so easy until the day I meant the spell caster online which so many people has talked about that he is very great in casting lottery spell, . so I decide to give it a try.I contacted this great Dr Believe and he did a spell and he gave me the winning lottery numbers. But believe me when the draws were out I was among winners. I win 30,000 million Dollar. Dr Believe truly you are the best, all thanks to you forever