“ACADEMIA...PROBLEM?” Should we trust the judgment of our professors?

TUESDAY, JUNE 1, 2021

Our Town, we have a problem: Can Sarah Viren's wider claim possibly be accurate?

Professor Viren's wider claim appeared as part of her lengthy essay in Sunday's New York Times Magazine. According to Viren, there's been a whole lot of fakin'  going on within American higher education, and this has been true for some time.

Viren was referring to one particular kind of faking—the kind of faking she refers to as "ethnic fraud." She described the extent of this type of faking in this remarkable passage:

VIREN (5/30/21): It’s a problem that has been known at least since 1992, when, in an early use of the term “ethnic fraud” in a newspaper, The Detroit News published an investigation into what were then known as box-checkers: students who [inaccurately] identify as Native American on their college applications...It was accompanied by a shorter piece about similar lies by Native-identified faculty. Of the 1,500 university educators listed as Native American at the time, said Bill Cross, who helped found the American Indian/Alaska Native Professors Association, “we’re looking realistically at one-third of those being Indians.”  

Could that possibly have been true? As of 1992, were something like a thousand university educators falsely identifying as Native American in order to boost their careers?

For ourselves, we can't assess the extent of any such behavior. In her lengthy report, Viren focused on the case of Professor Andrea Smith, a "prominent academic" in the world of ethnic studies.

Smith is widely believed to have falsely identified as Native American (specifically, as Cherokee) in the course of her long career. Despite this fact, her career continues, as Viren reports in detail.

Has Professor Smith made bogus claims about her ancestry / identity? Viren goes into substantial detail on that question. For a more concise account of this matter, we'll recommend this report in The Daily Beast from back in 2015.

Along the way in Sunday's report, Viren cites a half dozen other specific cases in which professors seem to have been involved in varying types of "identity fraud." At one point, Viren—herself a professor, at Arizona State—described the nature of her interest in this general topic:

VIREN: When I began researching this article, I wanted to understand why stories like these seem to dominate one industry—my industry. As a white academic, I watched, aghast, as other white academics were outed for pretending to be scholars of color, both in real life and online. It seemed absurd to me at the time but also horrifying — in part because the outings coincided with a moment of national reckoning on questions of race and representation, and a number of universities, including mine, had recently committed to hiring more scholars of color. I kept wondering, as the former academic Ruby Zelzer posted on Twitter in September, “Academia, do we have a problem?”

“Academia, do we have a problem?” Viren says she found herself asking that perfectly sensible question.

Viren wondered why her industry—the industry called academia—seemed to be beset with so much fraud of this type. She also found herself saying this, as we noted yesterday:

VIREN: All of this was a little bewildering to watch from the sidelines. Academia is an industry, like journalism, that defines itself in large part by its ethical standards; we’re supposed to educate people and produce knowledge. So what does it mean that we’re also a haven for fakes? 

Like journalism, academia is supposed to be defined by its high ethical standards—and by its ability to produce actual knowledge. "So what does it mean," Viren asks, when we learn that academia also turns out to be "a haven for fakes?"

With apologies—at this point, we're largely repeating material we posted yesterday. For today, we want to do a better job defining the problem facing Our Town—the problem as we see it:

Does academia have a problem in the area of "ethnic fraud?" Based on Viren's reporting, it would seem that the answer is yes.

Presumably, it's also true that the vast majority of professors are not engaged, directly or indirectly, in some sort of "ethnic fraud." Presumably, that's true in the realm of ethnic studies, and it's true in all other fields.

That said, modern academia would have various types of "problems" even if no one was engaged in ethnic fraud at all. When it comes to the ongoing breakdown of our rapidly failing society, that may be especially true in the general realm of ethnic studies, and in related fields.

In the general realm of values, Our Town relies heavily on the modern professoriate. This is especially true in matters involving gender and race.

It's strange to hear that "ethnic fraud" is as widespread as Viren says it is. But the political problem afflicting Our Town is only tangentially connected to this narrower, though deeply embarrassing, state of affairs.

Every time a bell rings, an angel gets its wings! Also, every time an academic makes a silly claim about gender or race, it gets reported to viewers of the Fox News Channel. 

This heightens the political and cultural divide due to which our failing nation is sliding toward the sea. It subjects Our Town to ridicule. It drives other people away.

Might we speak frankly just this once? Our Town is full of silly claims and silly ideas which come to us from vaunted professors, possibly including the apparently fraudulent Professor Smith. 

If none of those people were "ethnic frauds"—and surely, the large majority aren't—the damage caused by their silly ideas would be no less daunting.

Starting this afternoon, we're going to drop the question of "ethnic fraud" and focus on the question of silly ideas. Those silly ideas are everywhere in Our Town's current journalism, and those silly ideas have largely made their way into journalism from the halls of academia.

Good intentions may lie behind silly ideas, but the ideas remain silly. Nor do silly ideas start making sense if their authors are not involved in acts of "ethnic fraud."

Viren said that academia, like journalism, is supposed to have high ethics. She said that journalism, like academia, is supposed to produce actual knowledge—is supposed to be smart.

Here in Our Town, we're badly burdened by a whipsaw between these two worlds. We'll offer examples all this week, starting this afternoon.

Judging from Viren's detailed account, some of Our Town's prominent professors haven't always been super honest. But a larger problem prevails:

A larger number of our professors may not have super good judgment.  And the silly judgments of academia leak out into Our Town's high-end, upper-class press corps.

In our view, the proliferation of silly ideas in our high-end press seems to be getting worse every day. (The Washington Post and the New York Times were both astounding this morning.) Meanwhile, according to experts, the die has already been been cast:

According to experts, it's too late—it's much too late—to expect this process to stop. Our nation has already split apart. 

According to experts, there's no obvious way to glue its various pieces back together again. All that's left is the anthropology, these disconsolate experts have said.

This afternoon: It has ever been thus...


17 comments:

  1. "Should we trust the judgment of our professors?"

    No, of course we shouldn't, dear Bob. Because at least 95% of them are complete morons.

    This has been another edition of easy answers to easy questions.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. LOTTO, lottery,jackpot.
      Hello all my viewers, I am very happy for sharing this great testimonies,The best thing that has ever happened in my life is how I win the lottery euro million mega jackpot. I am a Woman who believe that one day I will win the lottery. finally my dreams came through when I email believelovespelltemple@gmail.com and tell him I need the lottery numbers. I have spend so much money on ticket just to make sure I win. But I never know that winning was so easy until the day I meant the spell caster online which so many people has talked about that he is very great in casting lottery spell, . so I decide to give it a try.I contacted this great Dr Believe and he did a spell and he gave me the winning lottery numbers. But believe me when the draws were out I was among winners. I win 30,000 million Dollar. Dr Believe truly you are the best, all thanks to you forever












      LOTTO, lottery,jackpot.
      Hello all my viewers, I am very happy for sharing this great testimonies,The best thing that has ever happened in my life is how I win the lottery euro million mega jackpot. I am a Woman who believe that one day I will win the lottery. finally my dreams came through when I email believelovespelltemple@gmail.com and tell him I need the lottery numbers. I have spend so much money on ticket just to make sure I win. But I never know that winning was so easy until the day I meant the spell caster online which so many people has talked about that he is very great in casting lottery spell, . so I decide to give it a try.I contacted this great Dr Believe and he did a spell and he gave me the winning lottery numbers. But believe me when the draws were out I was among winners. I win 30,000 million Dollar. Dr Believe truly you are the best, all thanks to you forever


      Delete
  2. "As of 1992, were something like a thousand university educators falsely identifying as Native American in order to boost their careers?"

    It doesn't boost one's career to be identified as Native American. Even in academia.

    Careers are based on academia publications (scholarly research), ability to obtain grant funding, service to the university (committee work mostly), student and peer teaching evaluations, and participation in service to one's profession, such as organizing conferences and editing journals or reviewing journal submissions (peer review). Collegiality is also important, which refers to getting along with other professors in your department. None of that has anything to do with ethnic identification.

    Some universities, like the University of California system, explicitly forbid use of ethnic and racial identity in hiring and advancement.

    This is a pipe dream concocted by the right to malign academia and promote a false belief that it is dominated by PC, cancel culture, and CRT. Somerby participates in this big lie because it aligns with his personal motives for attacking professors (what did they do to him at Harvard)? I believe he suffers from an unhealed narcissistic insult to his adolescent ego when he got to Harvard and found out he wasn't the smartest kid on the block.

    We should be believing professors when they speak in their areas of academic expertise -- not when they talk about any other subject. The same goes for anyone else claiming expert status.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "It doesn't boost one's career to be identified as Native American. Even in academia."

      Lol. A good one, dear dembot.

      Delete
    2. Remedial reading for Mao about job discrimination AGAINST Native Americans:

      https://www.npr.org/2017/11/18/564807229/as-native-americans-face-job-discrimination-a-tribe-works-to-employ-its-own

      http://ftp.iza.org/dp12131.pdf

      https://www.eandblaw.com/employment-discrimination-blog/2018/06/14/native-american-racial-discrimination/

      https://www.dol.gov/sites/dolgov/files/ofccp/INAERP/files/INAERP_ESQA508c.pdf

      Delete
    3. If you're discriminated, dear dembot, stop whining and go to court.

      Delete
    4. Ha ha ha. As if Republicans haven't larded the court with bigot judges, who toe the party line, or else.

      Delete
    5. Yes, like Devin Nunes and Trump himself, everyone has the spare cash lying around to go to court when wronged.

      Delete
    6. We already discussed this dear dembot. Move to Africa, then, The Paradise. Everybody wins.

      Delete
    7. We already discussed this dear Mao. You were funnier when you pretended you didn't LOVE the Establishment. This lazy, warmed-over George Wallace routine you've turned to is Cecelia-level unfunny.

      Delete
  3. "possibly including the apparently fraudulent Professor Smith."

    Notice how quickly Somerby jumps on the bandwagon attacking Dr. Smith! He has no evidence that she is not part Cherokee and cites only a hit-piece, which he evaluates uncritically because it is attacking a female professor. Unless Somerby knows something no one else knows, he should stop throwing the word "fraud" around so freely.

    ReplyDelete
  4. "In the general realm of values, Our Town relies heavily on the modern professoriate. This is especially true in matters involving gender and race."

    If this were true, racism would no longer be a problem in our society. Unfortunately, all the professors in all the ivory towers from sea to shining sea have not been able to undo American bigotry.

    Liberals are more educated than conservatives (Kevin Drum has graphs demonstrating that this week), and they are less likely to be bigoted and also more supportive of social justice, but even liberals have a ways to go in addressing institutional and systemic racism. Professors may set the agenda but young people are advancing it and more young people support the left than the right.

    What bothers me about Somerby's whole line of attack today is that it is entirely consistent with the fascist attack on the intelligentsia and universities in the early days of every totalitarian regime. In a country that only recently booted out its fascist President and escaped Putin's interference, currently fighting a militia-based insurrection, also fighting off a right-wing attack on our free press, we don't need these continual attacks on the professoriate instigated by Somerby while pretending to be a liberal member of "Our Town" (whatever that means). Somerby needs to recognize the importance of what academics do and support their efforts, even if occasionally over-wrought in rhetoric, over-enthusiastic on behalf of social change or obscure in its use of discipline-bound jargon. These are not important criticisms in the face of a very real fascist assault on our liberties.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Somerby is far from being a facist. You keep repeating the same old garbage. Why do you come here?

      Delete
    2. Somerby repeats the grievances of fascists. Doesn't matter if he believes the cry-babying or not.

      Delete
  5. Natural herbs have cured so many illness that drugs and injection can’t cure. I've seen the great importance of natural herbs and the wonderful work they have done in people's lives. i read people's testimonies online on how they were cured of HERPES, HIV, diabetics etc by Dr Erayo herbal medicine, so i decided to contact the doctor because i know nature has the power to heal anything. I was diagnosed with Herpes for the past 3 years but Dr Erayo cured me with his herbs and i referred my aunt and her husband to him immediately because they were both suffering from Herpes but to God be the glory, they were cured too .I know is hard to believe but am a living testimony. There is no harm trying herbs, Thanks. Write him on WhatsApp on +2348151937428. @dr Erayo deals with
    (1)Alzheimer virus
    (2)Cancer
    (3)HIV
    (4)Herpes
    (5)Genital warts
    (6)ALS
    (7)Virginal infection
    (8)HPV
    (9)Hepatitis
    (10)Asthma
    Email him on drerayoherbalhome@gmail.com
    https://alternativeherbs.weebly.com

    ReplyDelete
  6. I was very pleased to find this web-site. I wanted to thanks for your time for this wonderful read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you blog post.

    Prisonstt.com
    Information
    Click Here
    Visit Web

    ReplyDelete
  7. LOTTO, lottery,jackpot.
    Hello all my viewers, I am very happy for sharing this great testimonies,The best thing that has ever happened in my life is how I win the lottery euro million mega jackpot. I am a Woman who believe that one day I will win the lottery. finally my dreams came through when I email believelovespelltemple@gmail.com and tell him I need the lottery numbers. I have spend so much money on ticket just to make sure I win. But I never know that winning was so easy until the day I meant the spell caster online which so many people has talked about that he is very great in casting lottery spell, . so I decide to give it a try.I contacted this great Dr Believe and he did a spell and he gave me the winning lottery numbers. But believe me when the draws were out I was among winners. I win 30,000 million Dollar. Dr Believe truly you are the best, all thanks to you forever

    ReplyDelete