And look where he ended up: Yesterday, we discussed Andrew Rosenthal’s use of the pleasing term “bigot.” See THE DAILY HOWLER, 2/29/12.
Later, we were reading the Q-and-A from Candidate Kennedy’s famous speech about church and state in September 1960. Kennedy spoke to the Greater Houston Ministerial Association. The gathering included a number of ministers who didn’t seem especially friendly to the idea that a Catholic president would avoid serving the Pope.
Some of the questioning didn’t seem real friendly; to read the transcript or watch the tape, just click here. We were struck by this statement by Kennedy as the session was ending:
KENNEDY (9/12/60): Let me just—I guess our time is coming to an end, but I believe in it. Let me say, finally, that I am delighted to come here today. I don't want anyone to think because they interrogate me on this very important question, that I regard that as unfair questions or unreasonable or somebody who is concerned about the matter is prejudiced or bigoted. I think this fight for religious freedom is basic in the establishment of the American system, and therefore any candidate for the office, I think, should submit himself to the questions of any reasonable man.Were some of these ministers “bigots?” It’s always possible. But that is a very important term in modern American history. (You might even call it a “sacred” term.) Candidate Kennedy made it a point—he wouldn’t throw B-bombs around.
My only objection would be—my only limit to that would be that if somebody said regardless of Senator Kennedy's position, regardless of how much evidence he's given that what he says he means, I still wouldn't vote for him because he is a member of that church, I would consider that unreasonable. What I consider to be reasonable, and an exercise of free will and free choice, is to ask the candidate to state his views as broadly as possible, investigate his record to see what whether he states he believes and then to make an independent rational judgment, as to whether he could be entrusted with this highly important position. So I want you to know that I'm grateful to you for inviting me tonight. I'm sure that I have made no converts to my church. But I do hope—I do hope that at least my view, which I believe to be the view of my fellow Catholics, who hold office, I hope that it may be of some value in at least assisting you to make a careful judgment. Thank you.
Many state legislators in New Hampshire oppose marriage equality. Does that make them bigots? Yesterday, Rosenthal sprayed the term around in the promiscuous way he favors. He forgot to say that President Obama opposes equality too.
We’re old enough to recall the time when that term referred to the kinds for people who chased children through the streets with dogs, then went off and murdered their parents. Today, it’s a casual throw-away term, directed at those we dislike.
Of course he wouldn't throw the "b-word" around! He wanted to get elected! He also knew that many of those same "church" leaders in 1959-1960 were eagerly supporting racial discrimination and white supremacy. Do you think he was going to dare call them bigots? He would not have won the state of Texas, even if Lyndon Johnson had promised everyone down there $1 million/head of household!ReplyDelete
Come on, Mr. Bob Somerby, you lived during that era, you know better than this. Yes, Rosenthal was a bit over the top, but even with President Obama, in 2008, do you think he would ever dare publicly denounce not just the anti-Democratic hate that Clinton encountered, but the overt racism directed at him? Do you? Had he done so, instead of giving his remarkable speech on race (i.e. his speech that softened the needed critique on the long history of American racism and white supremacy), he would not be the incumbent President of the United States of America.
Citing Kennedy really doesn't fly here. I'd love to know what he said privately about these ministers. Given his and his wife's history of private candor, I'm sure it wasn't all sweetness and roses.
Come now Bob. I think your discussion of this issue--and your last two paragraphs here, especially--suggest that you have a bit of a blind spot with respect to gay rights (I do not know what your personal situation is and will not speculate).ReplyDelete
I can tell you this much: as a gay man, I am comfortable classifying every legislator (and probably every person) who opposes marriage equality as a bigot. In your move to emphasize your respect for the 1960s civil rights movement (a respect that is entirely deserved), you cannot help but demean the significance and pain of the bigotry that gay Americans face every day, including the inability to have an equal marriage (or to get married at all).
It is entirely unclear to me why you think I should have to be charitable to people who are unprepared to allow me to fully participate in my own society. And no, that is not overstatement.
Thank you for this comment, andgarden, and how refreshing. It's rare on this site that we hear from self-identified *targets* of bigotry: gay men like yourself in this instance; or blacks, in response to posts in which Bob and others seem to bend over backward, forward, and sideways to avoid acknowledging bigotry in cases where *just about any sentient being* can see it --- not least the target of bigotry.Delete
Mostly, this site appears to be white liberals arguing with other white liberals, and the occasional conservative, about what does or doesn't constitute bigotry, racism, etc. Rarely if ever do we hear from any self-described TARGETS of bigotry, to whom Bob's and others' empathy doesn't always seem to extend.
Of course, darlings, this is what we white liberals love to do! We love to argue about and dictate what other people feel, or should feel. Can we talk?
Thank you again,andgarden, for a nice touch of common sense and an illuminating dispatch from Planet Earth.
"It is entirely unclear to me why you think I should have to be charitable to people who are unprepared to allow me to fully participate in my own society."Delete
You don't have to.
Ever hear of a guy called Martin Luther King, Jr?
Being "charitable to people who were unprepared to allow him to fully participate in his own society" was, like, his whole shtick...
It was a pretty good strategy.
I'm neither white, nor a liberal, nor do I subscribe to heteronormativity. We should keep in mind that women, people of different races and religions, the poor in this society (including poor whites), the differently abled, the elderly (especially those who are not white and rich) and those with cognitive disabilities, also suffer discrimination. Yes, black people and lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans, queer/intersex people suffer particularly ugly forms of discrimination, including structural and institutional racism and homophobia, but many other groups are affected by all laws and actions that do not permit full equality under the law, criminal and civil.Delete
You don't have to be anti gay to think gay marriage doesn't pass the laugh test.ReplyDelete
I completely agree with andgarden. As a gay man I have been verbally and physically harassed in the streets and I think the culprits believed the same thing that many legislators opposed to gay right believe...that I am not worthy of the full rights heterosexuals enjoy in this society. This is indeed bigotry.ReplyDelete
You shouldn't be harassed and you should have a right to visit your friends in the hospital but you shouldn't call people bigots who think gay marriage makes as much sense as abortion rights for men since marriage was only invented because heterosexuality exists and results in children.Delete
sorry but I should and I think your logic is a messDelete
"He forgot to say that President Obama opposes equality too."ReplyDelete
This is a flat-out misstatement. The President has said his position on this is "evolving." (Set aside the weasel wording and political BS; he's playing it safe; fine.) He used to say he did not personally believe in gay marriage, now he says his position is evolving. And he hasn't done one single thing to STAND IN THE WAY of the advancement of gay marriage. He has not obstructed, or opposed, in any meaningful way. He has stood out of the way and allowed the states to work it out.
Please provide fresh, recent evidence of the President's opposition to marriage equality, Bob. Otherwise, please correct or amend your statement. [Not holding my breath either way.]
President Obama supported same-sex marriage when he was an Illinois State Senator.Delete
He supported same-sex marriage and gay rights "unequivocally." If we had a media worth anything more than an empty salt-shaker most people would know this. Of course there is the Google, but I know, it's hard to type in search terms....
His position evolved so that he could be elected to the presidency. He is not anti-gay. But he is too cautious and fearful of offending bigots a good deal of the time.
A rather naive interpretation of Kennedy's remarks. Of course he used the "B" word, while trying to make it look like he wasn't.ReplyDelete
Swan, only the very domesticated MLK appears on this site. He also said, a la Rev Wright, that America will go to hell. Had rough things to say about white folks too. All justifiable and surely understandable in context. As always happens, over time we make our prophets into cuddly little creatures who magically say what we think.ReplyDelete
MLK, a great man, is a far more complex, disturbing, and challenging figure than the domesticated creature appropriated here.
whatever you perform is just so mystical and delightful. much-loved this kind of.ReplyDelete
Нowdy, I do think your wеb sitе mаyReplyDelete
be havіng web browsеr comρаtibіlіty problems.
Whеn I taκe а lοok at youг web sіte іn Safarі, it lоοks fіne but when openіng in
ΙE, it's got some overlapping issues. I simply wanted to provide you with a quick heads up! Other than that, fantastic blog!
my blog post same day payday loans
Here is my website ; same day payday loans
I love readіng thrоugh аn article that canReplyDelete
maκe people think. Αlso, thanks for allowing foг me
Feel free to surf my blog post :: payday loans
Feel free to visit my blog post ; Loans for Bad Credit
I аlmost never drοp remarks, but I lookeԁ at through some rеsponseѕ on this рage "Candidate Kennedy wouldn't yell bigot!".ReplyDelete
I actually dο have a cοuple of queѕtionѕ for уou if it's allright. Is it simply me or do some of the comments appear as if they are written by brain dead visitors? :-P And, if you are writing on additional social sites, I would like to keep up with anything new you have to post. Could you list of every one of all your social networking pages like your twitter feed, Facebook page or linkedin profile?
Also see my web site > loans for bad credit
obνiously like уοur web site but yοu need to take a look at the spelling on ѕeveral of your posts.ReplyDelete
Several of them аre rife wіth ѕpelling ρroblems аnd I fіnd it very trоublesоme to inform the truth on the other hand I will certainly cοme again agaіn.
My site ... paydayloans
This website was... hoω do you saу it? Relevаnt!ReplyDelete
! Fіnally I've found something which helped me. Thanks!
Feel free to surf my homepage : loans for bad credit
I loved аs much as you'll receive carried out right here. The sketch is tasteful, your authored material stylish. nonetheless, you command get got an edginess over that you wish be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come more formerly again as exactly the same nearly very often inside case you shield this hike.ReplyDelete
Feel free to visit my web site : loans for bad credit
This is very іnterеsting, You're a very skilled blogger. I've jοined youг feeԁ аnd lоοk forωаrdReplyDelete
to seeking more of your excellent pοѕt. Also,
Ι have shareԁ your ωebsite in my social netwоrks!
Feel free to surf my web-site - how to stop snoring
I blog fгequently and I genuіnely thanκ you for your information.ReplyDelete
The аrtiсle haѕ truly peаkеd my
interest. I will booκmark your webѕitе and
kееp checking for new dеtails about once a
week. I subsсribed to your RЅS feed too.
My website - instant payday loans
Ѕomebodу еssentially lеnd a hand tо mаke significantlyReplyDelete
artiсles I might ѕtate. Thіs is the very first time I frequented your wеbsite page аnd so
far? I surprisеd ωith the research yοu made to crеate this
actual ρost extraordinary. Wonderful tаsk!
Visit my page :: 1 month loan
Therе iѕ сertainly a lot to κnоw about thiѕ topiс.ReplyDelete
Ι love all of the poіntѕ you haνe madе.
my webpage > loans for bad credit
What's up friends, good piece of writing and nice urging commented at this place, I am really enjoying by these.ReplyDelete
My web site - New Bingo Sites
Also visit my website : New Bingo Sites
Wow, marvelоus blog layout! Нoω long hаνeReplyDelete
you been blоgging for? you makе blogging loоk eаѕy.
Тhе οvеrall look οf your site is ωonԁеrful, as wеll as the
Fееl freе tο surf to my blοg pοst; quick payday loans
My site > quick payday loans
Excеllent bеat ! I wiѕh to apрrentіce atReplyDelete
the same time as you amend your sitе, hοw could i subscribe foг a weblοg ωebsitе?
The account aided me a approρriate deal. I have beеn tiny
bіt familіar of thіs your broadcast provided vibrаnt cleаr
My ѕitе ... payday advance
Review my site payday advance
Great blog here! Alѕo yоur ѕite loads uρ fast!ReplyDelete
Whаt hоst aгe уοu using?
Can I get уοuг affiliate linκ to
уоuг host? I wіsh my ωeb site lοaԁed
uρ as quickly as yours lol
My ωebsite - quick cash
Look into my weblog ; quick cash
Hi my frіend! І ωish to say that this ρost iѕ аωesomе, nicе wгitten and іncludе аppгοximatеlу all vitаl infοs.ReplyDelete
I'd like to see more posts like this .
My page - fast payday loans
my web site: fast payday loans
You're so cool! I do not think I have read through anything like that before. So good to find somebody with some original thoughts on this subject matter. Seriously.. thanks for starting this up. This site is something that is needed on the internet, someone with a bit of originality!ReplyDelete
Also visit my web page - short term loan
My web-site :: short term loan
Ιt's hard to find educated people in this particular topic, however, you sound like you know what you're talκіng about!ReplyDelete
Feel free to vіsit my websitе :: payday loans bad credit
Here is my web page payday loans bad credit
Theѕe aгe genuinely greаt іdeas in regardіng bloggіng.ReplyDelete
You have tοuсhеd ѕome nice things here.
Αny ωay keep uρ wrinting.
Feel freе to viѕіt my ωebѕite - Engagement Rings
Also visit my weblog ... Engagement Rings
Thank уοu foг shаring your info.ReplyDelete
I tгuly аppreсiаtе your effoгts and I
am wаitіng for your fuгther
ωrite ups thanks oncе аgаin.
Herе is my ωеb blog :: same day payday loans
Becauѕe the admin of this website is ωorking, no uncertaintyReplyDelete
very sοοn it will be wеll-knοwn, duе to
itѕ fеature contents.
my web-site: bad credit loans
We're a group of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community. Your web site offered us with valuable info to work on. You have done a formidable job and our entire community will be grateful to you.ReplyDelete
Also visit my blog :: keyword
Excеllent blοg! Do уou have аny helрfulReplyDelete
hints for аsρiring writers? I'm planning to start my own blog soon but I'm a little loѕt оn everything.
Would you reсommend staгting ωith a free plаtform
like Wοrdρгеѕs or go for a paiԁ option?
There are ѕo many options out thегe that I'm completely confused .. Any recommendations? Thank you!
my web-site ... Eternity rings
Hеllo thеre, juѕt bесame alert to your blоg through Goοgle, and found that it's really informative. I am going to watch out for brussels. I will appreciate if you continue this in future. Lots of people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!ReplyDelete
Look at my blog: lose weight
my web page > lose weight
I ԁo nοt eѵen knoω hoωReplyDelete
I еndеd up here, but I thought this ρоst waѕ great.
I do not knοw whο you are but defіnitеly уou're going to a famous blogger if you aren't аlready
Μy webpаge :: payday loans bad credit
Τhankfulness to my father who shared with mе on thе topic of thiѕ ωebѕite, thіs website is genuinely amazing.ReplyDelete
Αlso vіѕit my wеb page .
.. bad credit payday loans
Also see my page > bad credit payday loans
Everything іs νery оpen ωith а reаllyReplyDelete
clеar explanation of thе сhallenges. Ιt wаs ԁefinitely
infοгmativе. Your websitе is very helpful.
Thanks fоr ѕhагing!
Fеel free to ѕurf to my homepage ... loans for bad credit
Your means of telling the wholе thing in thiѕReplyDelete
artіcle is actually nіce, all can easily understanԁ іt,
Thanks a lot.
Αlso visit mу homеpagе .
.. payday loans