WEDNESDAY, JULY 2, 2025
...no one said a word: Arrivals of the type under review have occurred all through human history.
As Professor Knox described, such arrivals sometimes succeed due to a lack of preparation (or will) on the part of the invaded society. So it was in the lesson learned from the violent assault which took down sacred Troy:
The images of that night assault—the blazing palaces, the blood running in the streets, old Priam butchered at the altar, Cassandra raped in the temple, Hector's baby son thrown from the battlements, his wife Andromache dragged off to slavery—all this, foreshadowed in the Iliad, will be stamped indelibly on the consciousness of the Greeks throughout their history, immortalized in lyric poetry, in tragedy, on temple pediments and painted vases, to reinforce the stern lesson of Homer's presentation of the war: that no civilization, no matter how rich, no matter how refined, can long survive once it loses the power to meet force with equal or superior force.
It was a vicious, rage-fueled arrival. Troy's civilization had been more refined—but after ten long years, the sacred city wasn't able to hold off the murderous, rage-filled assault
Last Friday evening, PBS debuted an 83-minute American Masters program which described a different arrival. We refer to the disastrous arrival which swallowed much of Europe starting in the 1930s.
Starting at the 20-minute mark, the program broke one of our current society's major journalistic rules. It directly compared the early years of that arrival to the arrival which is playing out today within our own flailing nation.
Tomorrow, with Independence Day approaching, we'll show you what American Masters said about the early years of that earlier arrival—and about the way that early arrival seems to resemble our own.
For today, we'll direct you to this:
Many warfighters have come over the walls as our present arrival continues. One such player is Kristi Noem, President Trump's Secretary of Homeland Security.
Today, the New York Times reports a rather strange presentation by Noem. This happens early in a news report in today's print editions:
On Pivotal Day for His Bill, Trump Leaves Washington for ‘Alligator Alcatraz’
While the fate of his entire legislative agenda was being decided on Tuesday, President Trump traveled a thousand miles away from Washington to hang out in a makeshift detention center for migrants that had been thrown together on an old airstrip in the Florida Everglades.
The place had already been nicknamed “Alligator Alcatraz” by Republicans, on account of the fact that it’s surrounded by miles of marshland seething with reptiles. Mr. Trump instantly thrilled to the alligator alliteration—as he said on Tuesday, “I looked outside and that’s not a place I want to go hiking anytime soon”—and ordered up a tour.
[...]
Ms. Noem told a story about a recent detainee. “The other day, I was talking to some marshals that have been partnering with ICE,” she said. “They said that they had detained a cannibal and put him on a plane to take him home, and while they had him in his seat, he started to eat himself and they had to get him off and get him medical attention.” (The Department of Homeland Security did not respond to questions seeking clarity about the episode Ms. Noem described on Tuesday).
“These are the kind of deranged individuals that are on our streets in America,” she said.
The facility is surrounded by gators; also, Noem was there. Along the way, she told what seemed to be a very strange story about one recent detainee.
To its credit, the New York Times reported her very strange story. Also, the Times is seeking comment or clarification from DHS, though we'll guess that the paper will never mention this strange tale again.
With this peculiar tale, we may have moved away from the type of vicious arrival executed by the Achaeans. We may have moved instead to the type of arrival described in the 1997 feature film, Men in Black.
Do highly unusual creatures secretly live among us? More to the point, are such creatures the ones who are being detained? Or is it possible, in some cases, that these highly unusual beings are the ones who are locking the detainees up?
Not long ago, Secretary Noem published the story of the time she shot and killed her disobedient puppy. She may have failed to understand the way the story would seem to many of her fellow citizens.
Yesterday, she repeated a very strange story. It's a story she originally told last Friday night on what may be the most extraterrestrial of all current "cable news" programs.
For videotape from yesterday, we'll direct you to this news report by Mediaite's Zachary Leeman. (Headline: "Kristi Noem Shares Jaw Dropping Story at Trump Presser About Detained Cannibal Migrant Trying To Eat Himself.")
The migrant tried to eat himself! So said this member of the wedding—and her story did sound a bit odd. Indeed, it sounded so odd that Fox News Digital, like the New York Times, says it has asked three federal agencies—DHS, ICE and the U.S. Marshals—to provide further comment.
(For the Fox News report, click here.)
At any rate, so said the cabinet member, perhaps from somewhere within her own private Everglades. As we try to find better ways to describe the participants in the current arrival, we thought you should see the original way she told the story, speaking to one of the skillful corporate messenger fellows who now drive what's left of our national discourse.
Noem appeared last Friday night on Jesse Watters Primetime, the second highest-rated program in all of "cable news." Inevitably, Watters started talking about the "bad hombres" who are being detained and deported.
Soon, the cabinet member said this:
SECRETARY NOEM (6/27/25): Listen, Jesse, you calling these guys "bad hombres"—they really are. I was talking to a U.S. Marshall just yesterday, and he was talking about the fact that they were deporting a planeload of illegals and one of them was a cannibal.
And he kind of said it off-handed, and I said to him, 'What do you—what do you mean, it was a cannibal?" And he said, "Well we put him on the plane, put him in his seat, and he started to eat his own arms, he was such a deranged individual."
This is the kind of people that President Trump is getting off of our streets—people who are murderers and rapists and, and are deranged individuals, that we are working to get out of the country as fast as possible.
Apparently involuntarily, Watters briefly raised his hands to his head as her story started. Even Watters seemed to be taken aback by what he initially heard.
The gentleman quickly regained self-control. Soon, with Watters back to playing the fool, Noem's strange story continued:
WATTERS: Secretary, was this bad hombre handcuffed to something, and he was trying to chew his arm off so he could escape? Or was he just hungry?
SECRETARY NOEM: No, what bothered me the most was that this U.S. Marshal just said it like it was normal. These are the kinds of people they have to work with every single day when they're deporting people out of this country.
So they had him—put him on the plane and had him in shackles for the flight because he was such a dangerous individual. When he got back to his seat, and put another individual in the seat close to him, he said he was literally eating his own arms—that, for him, that is what he did. He called himself a cannibal, ate other people, and ate himself that day.
Her jumbled story doesn't quite parse. That's often the case with extemporaneous speech.
That said, is something wrong with Kristi Noem? As background, we offer this:
At least as a matter of theory, (almost) everything is possible. That said, does it sound like the member's tale actually makes any sense?
According to Noem, the men and women of her department aren't just working with murderers and rapists—they're also working with cannibals! That includes the kinds of cannibals who may start eating their own arms!
In fact, "these are the kind of people they have to work with every single day." So said Kristi Noem, speaking to the ridiculous Watters.
Does that story seem to make sense? For example, to the extent that any such people exist, do cannibals actually eat their own arms? Does some such representation seem to make any sense?
Noem seemed to think that her story did make sense. Though startled, Watters engaged in the kind of slippery pseudo-discourse which now forms the basis of much of our "cable news."
Many people have come over the walls in the course of the current arrival. For the record, these people often have legitimate complaints about the frequently ridiculous conduct of our own Blue America.
But as in Men in Black, so too here, or can it sometimes seems. It can sometimes seem that certain beings are living among us who may dwell in their own private Everglades.
What is the world was Secretary Noem talking about? Yesterday, when she told her story at a major press event, the New York Times and Fox News found her story so peculiar that they sought further comment.
By way of contrast, consider what happened last Friday night.
When Noem told the puzzling story last Friday night, she did so on one of the most-watched TV shows in all of "cable news"—and no one said a word about what she had said! No one reported the weird thing she'd said. No one discussed her strange story, or wondered about what it might meant.
As we've told you, what happens on the Fox News Channel is allowed to stay within the Fox News Channel. That said, it also spreads all through Red America, fueling the current assault.
Blue America's orgs agree to avert their gaze from that realm. To appearances, no one wants to tangle with Fox. Putting it a different way:
No civilization can long survive once it loses the power (or the will) to defend itself against an assault.
Tomorrow, we'll turn to American Masters, and to the disastrous arrival which started in the 1930s. For today, is something wrong with Kristi Noem? As part of the ethos of Blue America, no one is permitted to ask.
In closing, also this. Sacred Thoreau said it long ago, right at the start of Walden:
I, on my side, require of every writer, first or last, a simple and sincere account of his own life, and not merely what he has heard of other men’s lives; some such account as he would send to his kindred from a distant land; for if he has lived sincerely, it must have been in a distant land to me.
In the comedic Men in Black, visitors from a distant land have already staged an arrival—are already living among us. From what sort of distant land did the secretary's story emerge?
Tomorrow: Why do certain arrivals gain purchase?