TUESDAY, APRIL 21, 2026
...we may be a more mature people: We'll start by quoting Gretta Conroy, from the famous Joyce story, The Dead:
“He died when he was only seventeen. Isn’t it a terrible thing to die so young as that?”
You can read the full novella here.
To see Anjelica Huston perform the scene in question, we advise you to click right here. Cast as Gretta Conroy, she's describing the death of the young Michael Furey in the 1987 film adaptation of the famous Joyce tale.
"Isn’t it a terrible thing to die so young as that?” she says. But for today, as we start, we offer a somewhat analogous question:
"And isn't it a terrible thing for a person to die when he's still in his thirties?"
The question takes us back to our days as a fifth grade teacher, and to the loss, a bit later in life, of a plainly troubled child. We've been thinking of that plainly troubled child in the course of the past week.
You could even say, all these years later, that we've been mourning his loss. While planning to defer to privacy concerns, we may explain in more detail before the week is over.
We've been thinking of the early death of that troubled child, but also of President Trump. By the end of his seventh grade year, the future president was apparently a visibly troubled child--so much so that he had to leave the local private school where his father sat on the board of directors:
Isn't it a terrible thing, to be so troubled, to be so disturbed, at such a young age as that?
We'll recall the facts of that unfortunate case before the week is done. But as we mourn the fate of any such child who doesn't get the help he needs, we turn today to a more immediate question:
Should we the people be concerned--should we be actively fearful--about the possible mental state of the sitting president?
Should we be fearful about the president's mental health? About a possible cognitive decline? About the possibility that, in addition to any such decline, the president may be "somebody who for decades now has had serious, undiagnosed and untreated psychiatric disorders, which are only going to worsen?"
That's what the president's niece has recently said--and she's a doctorate-holding clinical therapist who has known the president ever since she was a child. With almost three years left to go in the president's current term, should we the people, Red and Blue, be worried about the possibilities to which the niece has given voice?
In our view, the obvious answer to that question is an obvious yes! That said--at the present time, we as a people simply aren't up to the challenge of discussing such possibilities.
Somewhere ages and ages hence, we may have matured to the point where we, as a people, are able to discuss such a state of affairs. But we aren't able to do so now--and we think that inability helps create a very dangerous state of affairs.
Please understand! Our major news orgs do employ some journalists who are experienced in the coverage of such medical issues. In this recent report for the New York Times, Ellen Barry briefly describes her own journalistic career (dual headline included):
A Secret History of Psychosis
Cohen Miles-Rath heard voices telling him to kill his father. After they passed, he spent years retracing the path of his delusions.
[...]
I’ve reported on mental health for much of my career, and frequently find myself writing about crimes committed by people in psychosis.
These make up a small percentage of violent crimes—around 4 percent, researchers have found—and the vast majority of people in psychosis are never violent. But they are the kind of crimes that newspapers cover: inexplicable, horrifying in their suddenness. Sometimes they are random; a commuter is shoved into the path of a subway train. But often they occur within the four walls of a home, as with Nick Reiner, who was charged with the fatal stabbing of his parents earlier this year. (Mr. Reiner, who had been diagnosed with schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder, has pleaded not guilty to two counts of first-degree murder.)
In that lengthy recent report, Barry discusses the history of a particular (and initially horrifying) case of "mental illness." She uses that specific term at five separate points in her report.
Barry knows how to write about incidents of "mental illness." But under prevailing rules of the game, no such possibility can be discussed with respect to major political figures:
It's a long-standing rule of the road, and, for better or worse, our news orgs are sticking to it!
In that recent report in the Times, Barry is discussing a person who was gripped by the most terrifying kind of psychosis. No one has suggested that the sitting president is sunk in some similar affliction at this point in time.
That said, some medical specialists have long alleged that the sitting president's "untreated psychiatric disorders" have created a very dangerous situation, and that those medical disorders "are only going to worsen."
The fact that medical specialists have said it doesn't mean that it's true! But the fact that our news orgs refuse to discuss this state of affairs shines a light on the immaturity of our public discourse at this point in time.
Should we be worried about the president's mental health, even as his Truth Social posts seem to become stranger and more desperate? To read about those new Truth Social posts, you can click to read these reports:
Trump Drops Jaw-Dropping Attack On Democrats Opposing Iran War: ‘TRAITORS ALL
Mediaite. To read the report, click here.
Trump rages against Democrats, the media over Iran: ‘I’m winning a War, BY A LOT’NJ.com. To read the report, click here.Trump rages at Iran war criticism: "Time is not my adversary"Axios. To read the report, click here.
Isn't it a terrible thing to be as helpless as that?
It is difficult to agree with Somerby or disagree with him when he omits details and tells us next to nothing about a few situations he says disturb him. He stacks the deck by telling us his conclusions without giving us the chance to form our own opinions.
ReplyDeleteSomerby feels sorry for Trump because he was "shipped off" to a "reform school" for his last two years of high school. Somerby claims he didn't get the help he needed. But isn't sending Trump to such a school a form of help? Those schools do not regard themselves as punishment but as a way of rescuing kids. The phrase "reform school" refers to juvenile detention facilities for kids who have broken the law, not the place a rich kids' parents send him when he respects no boundaries. And who is the victim in such a situation? Sometimes it is the hapless parents who cannot control a child, not the child in question. If Trump is a psychopath, why isn't the latter the more likely scenario?
But Somerby provides too little info to allow his readers to participate in evaluating Trump's situation. It could be the case that Trump got plenty of help, which is why he finished high school and went to college instead of to jail. Maybe Trump got too much help.
It seems odd to me that Somerby equates (by juxtaposition) being sent to a private high school with death at an early age. I find that insulting to the parents to dead children, and insulting to those with real problems. Somerby pities Trump, perhaps because he himself was shipped off to California for his high school years. Did he feel exiled? Does he assume Trump felt the same way? Maybe Trump liked it in his military school. Does anyone know?
If Somerby cannot separate his own life from that of Trump, that makes him a poor biographer, not a sage observer. I do not see anything to excuse Trump's horrific acts as president here. Our nation is suffering because of Trump's abuse of power, his dementia and his inability to govern properly. Somerby's pretense at empathy is misplaced. The American People are the victims, not Trump.
When will Somerby come to the obvious conclusion that Trump needs to be removed from office?
ReplyDeleteFrom Hullabaloo:
ReplyDeleteCNN: A deal to end the Iran war seemed close. Then Trump started posting on social media
Nobody in Washington, D.C. seems to be attempting to stop the bleeding.
**************
Somebody please take the fucking keys away from demented grandpa who has never learned that fucking lying all the time is bad.
"(Mr. Reiner, who had been diagnosed with schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder, has pleaded not guilty to two counts of first-degree murder.)
ReplyDeleteIn that lengthy recent report, Barry discusses the history of a particular (and initially horrifying) case of "mental illness." She uses that specific term at five separate points in her report."
Here is the point that Somerby misses (or glosses over). Mr. Reiner was "diagnosed," which means he was evaluated by qualified medical practitioners who concluded he was mentally ill. Schizophrenia is a serious medical problem, not a matter of personality. Mr. Reiner will be evaluated again before his trial.
Donald J. Trump has not been evaluated by medical practitioners and found to be mentally ill. (Or if he has, those results have not been made public, as they certainly should have been.) In the absence of a diagnosis, Somerby's repeated suggestions about Trump's mental health are meaningless. Until Somerby deals with that issue, his repetitious claims about Trump have nothing to back them up.
It is as likely that Trump is a criminal, a sexual abuser and a greedy con artist, not any kind of public servant, and that his only focus is self-aggrandizement and grifting a public expense. He is an awful, evil person who has no self control and who observes none of the restraints of normal people (even normal politicians) because of his enormous wealth and inflated ego. None of that is to be pitied. We must protect outselves and our nation from men like him, not offer them pity and excuses (buried in childhood) the way Somerby does.
How on earth can Somerby justify writing this bilge? What is wrong with Somerby that he thinks about this class-A freak this way? If Somerby writes this stuff to yank our chain, then Somerby is the one with mental problems. If he is doing this for money, then Somerby should have a troubled conscience given the outcome of Trump's actions. There is no situation where writing this kind of thing about Trump is justified by reality. So why does Somerby do it? I don't think there is a good explanation for that.
It is a travesty that Somerby would use the killing of Rob Reiner and his wife to justify what Trump has been doing to this country. Somerby should be ashamed of himself.
ReplyDeleteS is not justifying Trump. Learn to read.
Delete"But that discussion isn't going to happen--and that's on us, the American people..."
ReplyDeleteThat discussion has been happening all over the place. Somerby wants us to conclude that Trump is mentally ill, but what then? Somerby is unwilling to take the obvious next step, which would be to remove Trump from office.
We could have stopped Trump at the polls. Somerby was too busy criticizing Kamala Harris, to think about the consequences if Trump were reelected. He didn't want to let Biden continue a second term, despite his obvious success as president dealing with covid and fixing our broken economy. Biden earned another term, but Somerby didn't want to reelect him. So we got Trump instead.
I would just once like to hear Somerby say he made a horrible mistake when he undermined the Democrats and helped put Trump back into office. That obvious statement isn't going to happen, for whatever reason keeps Somerby writing garbage here every day. Just as he doesn't seem to have the courage to follow his own thoughts to their conclusion -- that Trump must be removed from office.
Somerby should be working to elect as many Democrats as possible, ahead of impeachment efforts after the midterms. I have never heard him say that here. It is the obvious solution to our current problems. In fact, the Republicans and Democrats in Congress need to join forces and prevent Trump from doing any more damage to our nation. Whatever is going on with Trump, Republicans are unwilling to take the obvious steps to stop him. I never hear Somerby chastise them for that. It is as if we had no Congress, the way Somerby never mentions a single elected official. Why is that, when it is the obvious solution?
Ho Hum
ReplyDelete"Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer is out of President Donald Trump’s Cabinet, after multiple allegations of abusing her position’s power, including having an affair with a subordinate and drinking alcohol on the job."
Good riddance.
Delete"With that in mind, we leave you with one final question:
ReplyDeleteIsn't it a terrible thing to be as helpless as that?"
Perhaps this is Somerby's real purpose in writing today. He wants us to feel as helpless as the dead children he has described. What an asshole Somerby is.
We are not helpless. We are the resistance. There are still many things we can and should be doing, among them:
1. Vote for Democrats in all elections.
2. Support candidates with donations.
3. Work on a local level to strengthen help for those who need it in our communities, including immigrants, jobless, unhoused people and our libraries, schools, businesses and institutions under threat from Trump.
4. Contact our elected representatives at all levels to oppose Trump's oppressive acts.
5. Participate in marches, boycotts, strikes and demonstrations against Trump and his policies.
6. Support our military families and those serving in uniform.
7. Talk to friends and neighbors and urge them to do the same (steps 1-6).
8. Unite behind Democratic candidates and our party to defeat the right wing. Save criticism for behind closed doors. Do not engage in "Democrats in disarray" circular firing squad behavior, as occurred against Harris last time.
9. Speak out against Trump's specific acts, not just his overall personality problems (as Somerby does).
10. Support women's issues and #metoo, call for release of the Epstein files, do not support those who abuse women, hold boys and men to a higher standard than that displayed by Trump's appointees.
11. Continue to live a lifestyle that supports environmentalism and helps to prevent climate change.
12. Be kind to others.
Doing these things will help YOUR mental health because it will allay any feelings of helplessness we may be experiencing. The right wants us to be afraid and feel helpless because then we can be controlled and they can do as they please. We can and must resist, for our own sanity. If we do these things together, we are safer and more likely to prevail against Trump and his forces of evil. The more we do, the less helpless we are and the better we will feel about ourselves and our world.
Confirmation hearing in Senate for King Orange Chickenshit's new sock puppet at the Fed. Because, fuck you, what are you going to do about it.
ReplyDeleteName calling is puerile. Did you get past 7th grade?
Deleteare you calling me a name
Delete"Should we the people be concerned--should we be actively fearful--about the possible mental state of the sitting president? "
ReplyDeleteYes, but very few people care to know psychology, let alone abnormal psychology. Most live with blinders on
acting out day after day without insight. So how can they be expected to comprehend the actions of a Trump
or of a Charles Manson? After all he was elected by many who based their vote on the price of eggs.