MONDAY, NOVEMBER 27, 2023
...until this very morning: We ourselves wouldn't have written the headline that way. That said, headline included, here's part of the Washington Post's news report about the latest shooting, this time in Vermont:
Man arrested after three Palestinian students injured in Vermont shooting
[...]
The victims’ parents identified them in a statement as Hisham Awartani, Kinnan Abdalhamid and Tahseen Ahmed. The American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC), a civil rights advocacy group, said it believed the students were targeted because they are Palestinians. Police said two are U.S. citizens and one is a legal U.S. resident.
Many others have noted a basic issue concerning identity. If two of these victims are U.S. citizens, is it accurate to headline them as "Palestinian students," full stop?
We might have been inclined to headline these young people as "college students," then to let the facts unfold from there. That said, here's another part of the Post's news report:
A Palestinian high school in the West Bank, Ramallah Friends, said all three of the men had attended school there before enrolling in U.S. universities.
We'd never heard of Ramallah Friends until this very morning. The leading authority on the school offers this somewhat inaccurate thumbnail account:
Ramallah Friends Schools
The Ramallah Friends Schools are two private schools founded by Quakers in the city of Ramallah, in the West Bank. The Friends Girls' School was inaugurated in 1869; the construction of the Friends Boys' School began in 1901 and the school opened in 1918. The Schools were run by American Quakers. The schools are now co-educational and divided into Senior and Junior sections...
At its own web site, Ramallah Friends describes itself as one school, in the singular. It offers this account of its mission and its values:
School Mission
Guided by Quaker principles and values, enriched by being in Palestine, and strengthened by collaboration within the school community and with external partnerships, Ramallah Friends School (RFS) offers children and youth with an academically rigorous, balanced, engaging and inclusive learning environment of the highest quality standard, every day.
We inspire our students to become a living expression of a spiritual life, and to be in constant search for God in all human situations. By doing so, we nurture confidence and intellectual curiosity through experiential learning and innovative application of knowledge and skills, enabling our students to become independent, adaptable but principled, socially responsible, and internationally-minded citizens.
RAMALLAH FRIENDS SCHOOL strives to be a leading educational institution in the Palestinian community. The Lower and Upper Schools were founded in 1869 and 1901 respectively, for the purpose of offering Palestinian youth a rigorous program guided by Quaker principles.
Central to Quaker education is a vitality that comes from being a living expression of a religious life. A Friends School education seeks to promote a constant search for God to all human situations and to cultivate ethical, moral and spiritual values.
[...]
Equality
Quaker education believes that all people are equal before God regardless of gender, creed, culture, color or social status. Since our beginning, we have focused on the education of women to develop their potential and realize their opportunity to be equal members of their community. Quaker education is built on the belief that all are children of God and that within each person here is that of God to be nurtured.
We don't have religious beliefs ourselves. That said, good people trying to do good things are found all over the world. As every sane person knows, an incredible number of Jewish institutions also serve the wide-ranging interests, all over the world, of us in the human race.
Good people are found all over the world. Also, troubled people are commonly found. Tragically, some are inclined to be violent.
A school was founded in Palestine in 1869. Apparently there were Palestinians in 1869.
ReplyDeleteLottery is something Everyone wishes to win, not only winning the lottery, but they want to win big bulks, i have been playing the lottery for couple of years now, but i haven't really win big, personally i always think there is something behind all those winners who always win big, because my intense always tell me that so i manage to get in contact with one of the biggest lottery winner in Manchester, i asked him about the success, and he referred me to a very powerful voodoo doctor, (Dr Aziba), he is indeed a great man who i explain to , without no hidden details , (i really want to win the lottery so bad ) he put to work and few days latter he gave me some figures that never failed, i played and i won 50 thousand pounds , (Dr Aziba) is blessed with so much gift, This is the secret and it worked for me. Get in contact with Doctor Aziba via Email Priestazibasolutioncenter@gmail.com or WhatsApp +2348100368288 for Lottery Winning Numbers.
DeleteLottery is something Everyone wishes to win, not only winning the lottery, but they want to win big bulks, i have been playing the lottery for couple of years now, but i haven't really win big, personally i always think there is something behind all those winners who always win big, because my intense always tell me that so i manage to get in contact with one of the biggest lottery winner in Manchester, i asked him about the success, and he referred me to a very powerful voodoo doctor, (Dr Aziba), he is indeed a great man who i explain to , without no hidden details , (i really want to win the lottery so bad ) he put to work and few days latter he gave me some figures that never failed, i played and i won 50 thousand pounds , (Dr Aziba) is blessed with so much gift, This is the secret and it worked for me. Get in contact with Doctor Aziba via Email Priestazibasolutioncenter@gmail.com or WhatsApp +2348100368288 for Lottery Winning Numbers.
ReplyDeleteMost of what you typed today, Bob, is the quintessential meaningless claptrap. Tragically.
"Tragically, some are inclined to be violent."
Also, people who resist heavily armed settler-colonial thugs are inclined to be violent.
In Vermont?
Delete
DeleteWell, I have the impression that Bob's explanation for all the violence in the world is "troubled people", some of whom "are inclined to be violent". If so, that is, imo, meaningless claptrap. But if I misunderstood, I apologize.
What is this bizarre fixation driving some commenters here to find something to criticize about Somerby's essays no matter how meaningless and trivial?
ReplyDeleteWhat is the bizarre fixation that you have with what other commenters choose to comment on?
DeleteOh, but that's the real subject of this blog: the relation of the comments to the post. They rarely fail to demonstrate the point.
Deletemh - Good question. I read other blogs and the commenters generally have a civilized discussion about the topics raised by the host. Comments in this blog are extraordinary because a pack of Anonymice have determined that they must save us gullible liberals from the deceits and deceptions of our corrupt host, and in service to this mission they constantly distort and misrepresent everything he says. I find that fixation bizarre.
DeleteUnless you think there is a hidden agenda, the subject of the blog is stated at the top: “musings on the mainstream "press corps" and the american discourse”.
DeleteDS - I've often suspected the same thing.
DeleteOk. What is the “point” that Somerby is really making, since it isn’t what he lists at the top?
Deletemh - Do I get this correctly, that you criticize the fact that the topic of Somerby's essay today lies beyond the scope of topics he lists on his masthead? Why are you driven to criticize something so meaningless and trivial?
DeleteI think "the american discourse" covers it.
DeleteI think it is very weird for Somerby to feature some school and praise it because it is non-violent when schools are not supposed to be violence in general and the oddity is when a school IS violent, even in Palestine.
Delete“today?” Bob lost interest in the Press Corps decades ago, and stopped writing about them completely when he realized people saw thru his BS. Here, the comment section might have helped. In any event, his only real purpose is to dump on liberals who know more than him about one subject or another, which kinda drives him crazy.
DeleteDogface actually thinks he’s engaged in some act of courage by calling himself “Dogface.” Sad.
DeleteHow did two become citizens so quickly?
ReplyDeleteOperation 26:
ReplyDeleteDebrief operative Fanny Manlove
61FE1
ReplyDeleteAmiclear