Budget deal: Ashleigh Banfield goes batshit nuts!


CNN actually put this lunacy on the air: Republicans have been complaining about the budget deal Obama offered last week.

Guest hosting for Anderson Cooper last Friday, Ashleigh Banfield conducted a long and crazy discussion of Obama's proposal. Since she never really explained what Obama has proposed, we’ll give you Paul Krugman’s description:

“As his opening bid in negotiations, Mr. Obama has proposed raising about $1.6 trillion in additional revenue over the next decade, with the majority coming from letting the high-end Bush tax cuts expire and the rest from measures to limit tax deductions. He would also cut spending by about $400 billion, through such measures as giving Medicare the ability to bargain for lower drug prices.”

As noted, Banfield never offered any such description in her long, remarkable segment. That said, her performance was so bizarre we thought it should be memorialized.

As she started, Banfield basically failed to explain what Obama had proposed. Instead, she introduced her key talking point—the idea that Republicans feel “insulted” by his absurd proposal:
BANFIELD (11/30/12): In "Raw Politics:" With the country one day closer to the fiscal cliff, President Obama took his case to the public today. He used an event in Pennsylvania to ratchet up the pressure on Republicans to freeze taxes for the middle class while allowing the tax rates on the wealthy to go up.

OBAMA (videotape): If Congress does nothing, every family in America will see their income taxes automatically go up on January 1. That's sort of like the lump of coal you get for Christmas. That's a Scrooge Christmas.

BANFIELD: Hmm. In other words, the day after the White House puts its opening bid on the table, the president comes out swinging. That opening bid didn't have a whole lot of concessions in it to the Republicans, and the Republicans reacted as many would have predicted. They were mad, basically saying that that offer was an insult.
For her first guest, Banfield interviewed Republican congressman Lee Terry, who had spoken colorfully about the political fix his party finds itself in. She spoke to no Democratic pols.

In her opening question for Terry, Banfield made a startling suggestion. Maybe the GOP will have to play the “debt ceiling” card again!
BANFIELD: I love it when politicians talk from the hip, especially using colorful language like “we're screwed either way.” But I don't understand what you mean, because as I see it, there's still this extraordinarily powerful tool called the debt ceiling and y’all [sic] have to be on board for that. So how do you not see that as a good tactic for negotiating?
Ever so casually, Banfield suggested that the GOP should threaten to default on the debt once again. To his credit, Terry quickly moved away from this idea. Weirdly, this was Banfield’s final plea to the congressman:
BANFIELD: I hope y’all [sic] can come to some consensus because you’re costing me money as I sit here and everybody else watching us. And I think a lot of people are pretty frustrated with the people we’re electing to do something big and bold. Come on! Negotiate!
We don’t know what that highlighted statement meant. To watch Banfield’s session with Terry, you can just click this.

Now it was time for Banfield’s “political panel,” Paul Begala and Mary Matalin. To watch the bulk of that segment, click here.

Banfield spoke with Begala first. As she did, her point of view became increasingly clear:
BANFIELD: Paul, let me begin with you. This feels by most reporting to be a bit of an unfair offer, given the wholesale rejection, and even Mitch McConnell's purview, the comity of it. Is this a wise decision, to come at the Republicans with something that is so unacceptable right off the bat?
According to Banfield, “this feels by most reporting to be a bit of an unfair offer!” As she neared the end of her chat with the old Clinton hand, she challenged him thusly:
BANFIELD: Paul, where are the overtures, though? Where were the overtures with this deal that was presented to the Republicans? I mean, listen, you don’t have to be Mensa to know that delivering a deal like that was going to make Mitch McConnell laugh. Where were the overtures from the Democrats?
Now it was time for a chat with Matalin—and for Banfield’s weirdest statements. As she closed her discussion with Begala, Banfield explained how she could tell that Obama's offer was just insultingly wrong:
BANFIELD: Mary is shaking her head. And you know what? I am shaking my head, too. Listen, I’ve traveled enough in the Far East to know you bargain appropriately with respect. You don't come in knowing that something's laughable.

BEGALA: I don't travel in the Far East! You think people should just give up on their principles and the things that they campaigned on?

BANFIELD: No, but I think you do have to bargain from a position of respect.

Mary, is this something that was so disrespectful that you can't even counter, Republicans can't even counter-bargain here?
No, we didn’t make that up. Due to her travels in the Far East, Banfield could tell that Obama's proposal was disrespectful. It was no bad, the GOP can't even present a counter-offer!

In reply, Matalin admitted that she herself “was offended and felt disrespected yesterday,” when Obama made his proposal. After that, Banfield signed off with one last oddball remark:
BANFIELD: I will recommend that maybe Raoul Felder get into this and start bargaining some kind of settlement, because this is intransigence like I have seen before.

Mary Matalin, Paul Begala, it's always a pleasure. Thank you both.
Banfield has been all through the Far East. But Obama’s proposal represents intransigence like she’s never seen!

This is a nation of more than three hundred million souls. Plus, there’s Canada, from which Banfield hails, despite her histrionic “y’alls” when talking to Terry. There’s also England, where our news orgs go to procure their most erratic performers.

Given the talent pool at their disposal, it’s astounding to see the types of discussions our news orgs will put on the air.


  1. I guess Ashleigh learned her lesson during her long exile from the Kool Kidz Klub after she stupidly told the truth about them .

  2. If you Google "Ashleigh Bainfield," her own website (ashleigbainfield.com) is flagged with the following warning: "This site may harm your computer."

  3. I get the feeling folks in the media have never negotiated anything in their lives. What in the world is an "unfair offer"?

    These folks should watch Pawn stars or Hardcore Pawn.

  4. Does the media not remember ripping Obama a new anus for giving away the store on the ACA before it went up for a vote?

    Silly question. I withdraw it.

  5. because this is intransigence like I have seen before.

    Is there a "never" missing here?

  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

  7. There is a futuristic machine mutually owned by the cable networks that employees must enter whenever they are discovered telling the truth or being honest. Place the subject in the device and after a few minutes of: Do you value your job? Are truth and honesty functional concepts in a capitalist economy? Do you like hanging out with the boys with the most toys? Why "did" integrity mean more to you than going with the flow? Can you change that problem? Don't let foolish idealism get in the way of your future. After all, who signs your paycheck? and they will be what they should be.

  8. Bob repeats a comment often made during the battle over the debt ceiling, namely that refusing to raise the debt ceiling would have meant defaulting on the debt. I don't see why that's the case.

    Refusing the raise the debt ceiling would have meant that the government had to spend less money. But ISTM that the cuts could have been anywhere. E.g., they could have stopped paying Congressional salaries or military contractor costs or any other bit of spending. Why did everyone assume that the forced spending cuts would necessarily come from interest payments on the national debt?

  9. I think that everything said was actually very reasonable.

    However, consider this, suppose you were to create a awesome headline?

    I am not saying your information is not solid,
    however what if you added a title that grabbed folk's attention? I mean "Budget deal: Ashleigh Banfield goes batshit nuts!" is a little plain. You could glance at Yahoo's front page and watch how they create post titles to
    grab people to open the links. You might try adding
    a video or a related picture or two to get people interested about everything've got to say. Just my opinion, it could bring your blog a little bit more interesting.
    Also see my webpage - green coffee bean dr oz

  10. Excellent beat ! I wish to apprentice at the same time as you amend your web site, how could i subscribe for a
    blog web site? The account aided me a appropriate deal.
    I had been tiny bit familiar of this your
    broadcast provided shiny clear concept
    My page :: fantasy scifi

  11. At this time I am ready to do my breakfast, after having my
    breakfast coming again to read other news.
    Also see my webpage :: Buy Facebook Likes Cheap

  12. I believe which everything mentioned was actually very reasonable. However, consider this, suppose you are to make a awesome heading? I am not saying the information you have isn't sound, however let's say you added a new name in which grabbed folk's consideration?
    rs gold for sale
    Billig WOW Gold
    Cheap RS 3 Gold

  13. Asking questions are in fact fastidious thing if you are not understanding something entirely, however this article provides nice marble tile.

  14. I’m impressed very informative, you did well in your bathroom accessories. Pipe thank your for your blog, support you, hope you have a great day!

  15. When it comes to kitchen taps, it is important that the homeowners baddest amid the mixers or separates curtains according to their preference.Taps online The mixer curtains are a abundant best for the families with adolescent accouchement or with a affiliate who suffers from arthritis because it is simple to operate.Shower taps The separates are activity able as the users will not charge to use hot baptize if they don't wish to. Users can aswell acquisition absolutely a amount of designs that will clothing their kitchen designs.Bathroom accessories set They kitchen curtains should be proportional to the kitchen bore and should be the appropriate admeasurement to ensure that they are adequate if application them. Users can aswell go green, selecting the curtains that are baptize efficient.

  16. étiquette est l'une des choses Robinetterie vasque en capital à boulon absorption des clients, si elles robinetterie-cuisine sont les affaires de tout produit. Il fournit tous les conseils appropriés accompagnant le produit. Une fois que les consommateurs appréhendent et se facher du Lumineux LED Robinetterie Vasquedétail habitude qui est imprimé sur l'étiquette, ils juger d'acheter le produit précis.

  17. Si vous avez la chance de posséder des http://www.robinetsale.com/, vous serez étonné de la fa?on de générer une variété de robinet. Restez fidèle qualité, cuisine toute robinetterie cuisine filtre de robinet, pour voir si elles sont étanches. Malgré le Accessoires de salle est faite des meilleurs matériaux, mais ils se sentent encore le besoin de tester chacun. Donc, avant la livraison Robinetterie Vasque qu'aucune entreprise ne peut refuser de vendre au public.

  18. Découvrez tous nos produits Robinet salle de bain sur robinetso.fr. Retrouvez les grandes marques et références Robinetterie au meilleur prix. Livraison Gratuite. http://www.robinetso.fr

  19. Bathtub faucet : It is mounted on the top side of the tub for mixing hot and cold water open. Hot and cold can be Waterfall faucet by two pipes called duplex; hoist water lift spiral structure, metal ball-style, ceramic cartridge type and so on. Currently on the market is more single handle Faucet parts.