And the New York Times instantly bungles: No one actually cares at this point, but Candidate Carson has finally unleashed his formal tax proposal.
For unknown reasons, Carson describes his plan as "a true flat tax." Before we discuss the problem with that designation, let's note the inevitable:
The New York Times has massively bungled its account of the Carson proposal.
As noted, no one actually cares about the Carson proposal. At the Times, they haven't even done a hard-copy report about the crazy effects of the Trump tax proposal, which was released in September.
That said, the Times did offer a quick blog post about the Carson proposal. No one actually cares what Candidate Carson has proposed. But if they did, it must be said that Alan Rappeport basically bungled his basic account of the plan:
RAPPEPORT (1/4/16): The proposal is centered on a 14.9 percent tax for people in all income brackets and for companies, while eliminating deductions for mortgage interest, charitable giving and local taxes. Mr. Carson also would do away with taxing capital gains or interest income. Low-income people and families, defined by having incomes below 150 percent of the federal poverty level, would have to make a smaller, unspecified payment.Nothing in that account is "wrong." That said, Rappeport omits a basic provision of the proposal:
The changes would mark sharp reductions from the top personal tax rate of 39.6 percent and the corporate tax rate of 35 percent.
Quoting Carson's formal proposal, "the flat tax applies only to income above 150 percent of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL). For example, a family of four will not pay the 14.9 percent tax on their first $36,375 of income."
That makes a rather large difference. Under Carson's actual plan, a family of four with a $40,000 income owes virtually no federal income tax—roughly $540. If we go by the report in the Times, it sounds like that family of four would owe almost $6000!
Is the exemption in question implied by what Rappeport wrote? Not exactly, no. That said, how hard is it to go ahead and state such a basic part of the plan?
It isn't hard at all! Bernie Becker even managed the feat at Politico, which is frequently feckless:
BECKER (1/4/16): Carson would only use the flat tax on income above 150 percent of the poverty level—exempting, for instance, the first $36,375 of income for a family of four. Taxpayers making below that level would face “a de minimis tax payment,” which was unspecified.That's a very basic part of the plan. Politico explained it quite clearly. Inevitably, the glorious Times failed to spell it out.
(In fairness, the Times doesn't care about things like tax rates. The Times cares about who has recently said the word "schlonged," and about the senses of humor of the various candidates. It cares about who's insulting who in what way, and about other such matters.)
You won't likely encounter much discussion of the Carson proposal. Candidate Trump seems to be headed for nomination, and the nation's major newspapers aren't even discussing his plan, which is manifestly crazy.
That said, it might be worth considering one last question. Why in the world would someone want to call this proposal a "flat" tax plan?
Plainly, it's a "single-rate" plan. But why would we call it "flat?"
Traditionally, the basic idea behind a "flat" tax involved a contrast to "progressive" taxation. Everyone was going to have to submit the same percentage of his or her income!
That doesn't happen with Carson's plan. A family of four earning $40,000 will owe less than two percent of its income. A family of four earning $100,000 will owe roughly ten percent. A family earning $1 million (or more) will owe almost 15 percent.
Under the Carson proposal, people end up submitting different percentages of their incomes, just the way it is at present. There is one major difference, of course: at the upper end of the income scale, people would presumably pay much less under the terms of this plan.
In short: when single-rate plans include a large standard exemption—in this case, $36,375 for a family of four—they end up being "progressive." Lower earners pay a very small part of their income. Higher earners pay a much larger percentage of their income, but at a 14.9 percent rate, they would pay much less than they pay under current law.
As such, the endless piffle about a "flat tax" is largely a sack of gorilla dust. Almost always, the claim of flatness is a distraction from the real goal—tax cuts for upper-end earners.
At any rate, the New York Times has messed up again. We can't stress this last point enough:
It isn't a competent newspaper.
One thing I would note. Under current tax law, that family of four making $40,000 pays zero federal income tax. They may even get a refund of part of their $2,000 child tax credit. Also, in 2012, such a couple would get an EIC of $406. So Carson is not only proposing to cut taxes for the rich, he is proposing to increase taxes for that couple (and people like them). That couple would be paying over $900 MORE under Carson's plan than under current law.ReplyDelete
For some reason nobody in the media says WTF? about that.
It seems likely that actual people making $40,000 or less would say that about a proposal to increase their taxes. Luckily for Carson and the Republican Party, such people will never hear about it from the M$M.
"Low-income people and families, defined by having incomes below 150 percent of the federal poverty level, would have to make a smaller, unspecified payment."ReplyDelete
What's the problem? The limitation is right there in Rapoport's piece. Is it that the actual payment for those below 150% of poverty is "unspecified"? This kind of carping about NYT reporting is tiresome.
What's the problem with your reading, skepto:Delete
It's NOT right there in the piece that there's any standard exemption for the first $36K of income for people who make more than that.
Here is the problem. The NY Times is trying to perpetuate the fiction that this is a flat tax by deemphasizing the low income exemption.Delete
It says: "The proposal is centered on a 14.9 percent tax for people in all income brackets and for companies, while eliminating deductions for mortgage interest, charitable giving and local taxes."
That is a mischaracterization intended to support the fraud that this is a flat tax. The exemption and de minimum tax levied on those below the poverty designation are described later and make it clear this is not a flax tax as claimed.
Claiming to enact a flat tax is a big deal among Republicans. Flat tax is a buzz word and it gets Carson votes. It is important to state that he is not actually planning to enact a flat tax.
MEJAQQ: AGEN JUDI POKER DOMINOQQ BANDARQ ONLINE TERBESAR DI ASIA
Well, to be fair, Rappeport attended the London School of Economics. They don't have our tax system over there, so Rappeport has probably not learned its ins and outs.ReplyDelete
I just wonder why simplifying to a flat tax wouldn't also mean rounding 14.9% to 15% - I can manage that one without a calculator.ReplyDelete
I am genuinely thankful to the holder of this web page who has shared this fantastic paragraph at here.ReplyDelete
I don't know what to say. This blog is fantastic. Thats not really a really huge statement, but its all I could come up with after reading this. You know so much about this subject. So much so that you made me want to learn more about it. Your blog is my stepping stone, my friend. Thanks for the heads up on this subject. Visit this site : professional cv writing servicesReplyDelete
Hi nice blog ... Good Stuff! I really enjoyed reading. I will be visiting often and telling my friends about this Hope to read more good articles.ReplyDelete
LINK ALTERNATIF DEWAPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF SAKURAPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF KUDAPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF KARTUPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF POKERBO
LINK ALTERNATIF SOBATPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF MEJAPOKER88
LINK ALTERNATIF POKERQIU
LINK ALTERNATIF SUNDULPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF POKERSAKTI
LINK ALTERNATIF EYANGPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF 389POKER
LINK ALTERNATIF POKERACE99
LINK ALTERNATIF QQDOMINO
LINK ALTERNATIF DOMINOBET
LINK ALTERNATIF JPPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF SENTAPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF POKERREPUBLIK
LINK ALTERNATIF HORASPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF REMIBET
LINK ALTERNATIF JAGOANPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF PASTIPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF POKERBOYA
LINK ALTERNATIF GADINGPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF MAHAPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF QQPOKERONLINE
LINK ALTERNATIF S78POKER
LINK ALTERNATIF ITUDEWA
LINK ALTERNATIF 99ONLINEPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF MOTOBOLAPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF INULPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF STARDOMINO
LINK ALTERNATIF REMIPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF SAGAPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF KARTUQQ
LINK ALTERNATIF DOMINO365
LINK ALTERNATIF INIDEWA
LINK ALTERNATIF TEXASPOKERCC
LINK ALTERNATIF QILINPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF DOMINOQIU
LINK ALTERNATIF AYO99
LINK ALTERNATIF JENIUSPOKER
LINK ALTERNATIF LIDEWAPOKER
MandiriQQ Agen Poker & Domino Online Terpercaya IndonesiaReplyDelete
Tidak hanya di lengkapi oleh Sistem yang Canggih, tetapi juga di MandiriQQ memberikan Bonus Terbesar Se Indonesia
Tidak Percaya? https://goo.gl/LxNkJ7
Bonus dan Promo Yang di Sediakan di MandiriQQ:
1. Bonus CASHBACK TERBESAR!! 0.5% Hanya di MandiriQQ
2. Bonus Referral TERJAMIN!! 10% + 10%
Selain itu, MandiriQQ juga Memiliki Permainan yang Sangat Menarik Berikut:
1. PLAY POKER
2. PLAY BANDAR POKER
3. PLAY ADUQ
4. PLAY BANDAR Q
5. PLAY DOMINOQQ
6. CAPSA SUSUN
NEW GAME : FISH HUNTER (TEMBAK IKAN)
GAME FAVOURITE : SABUNG AYAM ONLINE
RASAKAN SENSASINYA! https://goo.gl/LxNkJ7
BURUAN COBAIN, JANGAN SAMPAI KETINGGALAN DENGAN YANG LAINNYA !
Sistem Permainan yang di miliki MandiriQQ merupakan Sistem yang Murni 100% Player vs Player
Karena Kepercayaan dan Kemenangan Member adalah Prioritas Utama dan Kegembiraan MandiriQQ
Yang Jauh Mendekat.. Yang dekat Merapat ya.. https://goo.gl/LxNkJ7
Untuk Info Lebih Lanjut Kunjungi Website Kami www.MandiriQQ.com
BBM : 2BE2B4BA (Jessica)
Twitter : mandiriqq
Facebook : firstname.lastname@example.org
Yahoo : email@example.com
Phone : +85585796383
Skype : mandiriqq
Wechat : MandiriQQ
Sinidomino Poker & Kiu-Kiu Online Terbaik & Terpercaya 7 Game bisa dimainkan hanya dengan menggunakan 1 user idReplyDelete
- Play Poker, - Play DominoQQ, - Play AduQ, - Play Capsa, - Play BandarQ, - Play Bandar Poker, - Play Sakong
*Info Promo :
- Modal Rp.20.000
- Bonus Referral 20%
- Cash back 0.5%
- 100% NO ROBOT
- Jackpot Friendly
Layanan Servis 24jam Online Nonstop
Cek infonya disini:
- Pin BBM : D61E3506
- Website : Sinidomino,com / Maindisini.com
sangat bermanfaat gan artikel yang mudah untuk dipahami semoga bermanfaat bagi pembacanyaReplyDelete
mohon izin promosi sebentar ya gan !!
klik66 | Daftar Agen Bandar, poker online, dominoqq, bandar sakong, capsa susun
GAME WEB JUDI ONLINE TERBESAR:
Domino Qiu Qiu
Adu qq Online
BONUS MENARIK SUDAH MENANTI ANDA :
untuk bonus turnover 0.5% dan untuk bonus referral 20%, minimal deposit dan withdraw Rp 25.000,-
jadi tunggu apa lagi segera daftarkan diri anda dan rasakan sensai bermain semua permainan, hanya menggunakan 1 user Id.
UNTUK INFO LEBIH LANJUT HUBUNGI :
BBM : D8664D7C
LINE : klik66
WECHAT : klik66
WHATSAPP : +6287868532329
SKYPE : klik66
IG : klik66365
TWITTER : @Klik66365
FACEBOOK : @Klik66365
SEGERA BERGABUNG BERSAMA KAMI DI KLIK66, PELAYANAN YANG SANGAT BAIK AKAN DI BERIKAN OP YANG SANGAT BERPENGALAMAN 24 JAM NONSTOP.
AGEN CEME TERPERCAYAReplyDelete
AGEN BANDAR66 TERPERCAYA
Unik! 7 Bandara Dengan Keunik-Kannya Di Seluruh Dunia
Keren! Salah Satu Cafe Di Vietnam Berkonsep Unik, Dengan Lantai Kolam Ikan Koi
Tertangkap Kamera, 7 Fenomena Alam Yang Langka!
Di Berbagai Negara, Dilarang Untuk Memakan Makanan Ini!
Kami menerima banyak permintaan dari pembaca kami untuk meninjau sistem taruhan sepak bola tertentu sehingga kami sepatutnya wajib dan memutuskan untuk melihat sendiri apakah mungkin untuk membuat penghasilan bebas pajak yang konsistenReplyDelete
CrownQQ Agen DominoQQ BandarQ dan Domino99 Online TerbesarReplyDelete
Yuk Buruan ikutan bermain di website CrownQQ
Sekarang CROWNQQ Memiliki Game terbaru Dan Ternama loh...
9 permainan :
=> Bandar Poker
=> Capsa Susun
=> Bandar 66
=> Perang Baccarat (NEW GAME)
=> Bonus Refferal 20%
=> Bonus Turn Over 0,5%
=> Minimal Depo 20.000
=> Minimal WD 20.000
=> 100% Member Asli
=> Pelayanan DP & WD 24 jam
=> Livechat Kami 24 Jam Online
=> Bisa Dimainkan Di Hp Android
=> Di Layani Dengan 5 Bank Terbaik
=> 1 User ID 9 Permainan Menarik
=> Menyediakan deposit Via Pulsa Telkomsel & XL
Link Resmi CrownQQ:
Info Lebih lanjut Kunjungi :
Website : CrownQQ
Daftar CrownQQ : Poker Online
Info CrownQQ : Kontakk
Linktree : Agen Poker Online
WHATSAPP : +6287771354805
Line : CS_CROWNQQ
Facebook : CrownQQ Official
Kemenangan CrownQQ : Agen BandarQ
เราคือเว็บผู้ให้บริการ คาสิโนออนไลน์ เล่นบาคาร่าออนไลน์ คาสิโนผ่านมือถือไอโฟน ไอแพด รูเล็ต สล็อต และ แทงบอลออนไลน์ ที่ดีที่สุดReplyDelete
Bonus yang diberikan Pokervit :ReplyDelete
* Bonus rollingan 0.5%,setiap Jum'at di bagikannya
* Bonus Refferal 10%,seumur hidup
* Bonus Deposit Member Baru 20%
* Bonus Jackpot, yang dapat anda dapatkan dengan mudah
* Minimal Depo 10.000
* Minimal WD 50.000
idnplay qiu qiu domino
aplikasi idn lama
Nice & Informative Blog ! We offer welcome to Mila bulldogs. Check it out!...ReplyDelete
puppies for sale near me
British bulldog puppies for sale
where to buy
Totally loved your article. Looking forward to see more more from you. Meanwhile feel free to surf through my website while i give your blog a read.
welcome to Newsome frenchies
where to buy french bulldog puppies
frenchies bulldog puppies
Totally loved your article. Looking forward to see more more from you. Meanwhile feel free to surf through my website while i give your blog a read.ReplyDelete
welcome to Home With Cavalier King Charles Spaniel Puppies
where to buy Charles Spaniel Puppies
King Charles Spaniel Price
King Charles Spaniel USA
King Charles Spaniel puppies ready for their forever homes
welcome to Cavalier King Charles Spaniel puppies nearme