NO STATISTICS NEED APPLY: Half the statistics disappear!

THURSDAY, APRIL 2, 2015

Part 4—“Reporting” the nation's schools:
Just as a brief aside, eleven “educators” are in prison today in Atlanta after a six-month trial

A six-month trial!

Don’t get us wrong! The conduct is which these teachers engaged was ludicrous, inane and baldly dishonest.

That said, we think this prosecution was giant overkill. In this Lenten season, you might even say that these teachers have died for the New York Times’ (statistical) sins.

These teachers were convicted of ludicrous cheating on Georgia’s statewide standardized tests. They even played the erasure game, systematically changing wrong answers to right after test sessions were over.

This is deeply ludicrous conduct, but it had been going on for decades by the time these teachers got caught. In large part, the practice had continued apace because of the incompetence (and/or the dishonesty) of the national “press corps.”

We have a personal history here. Quickly, let’s review it:

We first reported outright cheating to the Baltimore Sun in the early 1970s. In 1981, we published this op-ed column on the subject in the Baltimore Evening Sun.

By that time that column appeared, we had learned something which we found startling at the time:

Even back then, publishers of the big standardized tests would, for an extra fee, electronically scan a school system’s answer sheets looking for the erasure patterns which indicate widespread cheating.

More than thirty years ago, this phenomenon was well understood! (We were told about this practice by a high official at one of the large test batteries, but it wasn't a secret.)

It wasn’t just the fact that the big test publishers were providing that remarkable service. On a basic statistical basis, the scoring patterns at certain schools were clownishly obvious. Except to the nation’s “press corps,” which kept failing to report this ongoing phenomenon.

Inside the press corps, statistics are hard! Also, preferred narratives are powerful.

A bit more personal history:

In the late 1980s, we consulted with Dr. John Cannell about this general topic. He achieved ten minutes of fame by suggesting, through reference to his humorous Lake Wobegon Effect, that this sort of cheating may have been widespread at that time.

Cannell’s suggestions were widely reported, for roughly ten minutes. The topic was then completely abandoned—but wait, there’s more:

In 2006, we discovered a clownish statistical scam which was elevating “passing rates” at schools all over the state of Virginia. Quite forthrightly, the chairman of the state board acknowledged to us, in an on the record interview, that this remarkable conduct actually had occurred.

For background, just click here, with a link to earlier reports.

The Washington Post, and other Virginia newspapers, failed to report this news. A rather remarkable statewide scam went almost wholly unreported.

One more bit of personal history:

In 2007, a little-known person named Michelle Rhee was selected to become the head of the Washington D.C. schools. She arrived in Washington trailing dramatic claims about the sensational test scores she had produced in her three years as a Baltimore second and third grade teacher.

As we noted in real time, the test scores Rhee said her students recorded seemed absurd on their face. The Washington Post averted its gaze. A few years later, a cheating scandal matching Atlanta’s surfaced in D.C.’s schools.

Let’s give credit where credit is due! In this morning’s New York Times, Alan Blinder wrote the full-length news report about the Atlanta convictions.

In the hard-copy Times, Blinder’s report leads the National section. He offers this bit of history about the Atlanta case:
BLINDER (4/2/15): In 2009, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution started publishing a series of articles that sowed suspicion about the veracity of the test scores, and Gov. Sonny Perdue ultimately ordered an investigation.

The inquiry, which was completed in 2011, led to findings that were startling and unsparing: Investigators concluded that cheating had occurred in at least 44 schools and that the district had been troubled by “organized and systemic misconduct.” Nearly 180 employees, including 38 principals, were accused of wrongdoing as part of an effort to inflate test scores and misrepresent the achievement of Atlanta’s students and schools.
Decades after this basic problem was obvious and widely known, reporters at the Journal-Constitution actually did some reporting!

That paper deserves a lot of credit for its work. So does USA Today, which did the basic reporting on D.C.’s testing debacle.

Those newspapers deserve full credit for some belated work. But by the time of the Journal-Constitution’s reports, its findings could only seem “startling” to completely clueless reporters like the world-class stumblebums who work for the New York Times.

How is it possible? How could big newspapers like the Post and the Times remain so clueless about this matter for so long? Before considering last week’s work on the nation's schools, we’ll offer two possibilities:

Basic incompetence: Many “journalists” at these newspapers are almost completely incompetent. They lack even the most basic skills for processing even the simplest statistics. Last week’s report about the gender income gap among nurses represents a crowning example of a phenomenon which is widespread.

Devotion to narrative: These newspapers also tend to defer to the narratives which shape so much of our news. They’ve always loved ridiculous stories about miraculous test scores at low-income schools. These types of stories maintained preferred beliefs about the educational challenges we face and the reasons for the nation’s “achievement gaps.” At the same time, they never seemed to have a taste for reporting which may have undermined traditional, Dick-and-Jane era faith in the inerrant probity of teachers.

By today, preferred elite narratives about public schools are different, and so is the press corps’ clowning. Consider several events last week which had our youthful analysts gnashing what’s left of their teeth.

First, a small appetizer. On Sunday, March 22, Martin and Bosman authored a front-page report in the New York Times about Chicago’s mayoral race. Will anything ever stop our scribes from typing variants of the highlighted standard statement?
MARTIN AND BOSMAN (3/22/15): Another challenge for hard-line progressives is that Mr. Emanuel, while heavily funded by business interests and some wealthy Republicans, has a record of accomplishment that covers many liberal priorities. He may have angered the teachers union and many black residents by closing 50 failing schools in mostly minority neighborhoods. But he passed full-day kindergarten, a move similar to Mr. de Blasio’s expansion of prekindergarten. Mr. Emanuel also added free community college for high-achieving public school graduates...
The highlighted statement can be defended as “technically accurate.” Emanuel did close fifty schools; this did anger some residents. It’s also true that the schools in question were mostly in minority neighborhoods or, in a softer formulation, were “in mostly minority neighborhoods.”

That said, Chicago’s student population is 90 percent black and Hispanic. There's no way to close underutilized schools in Chicago without closing schools “in mostly minority neighborhoods.”

This situation obtains in urban systems all over the country. But at various major newspapers, reporters insist on feigning surprise at the fact that underutilized schools are getting closed in black and Hispanic neighborhoods.

These ace reporters seem immune to the simplest statistical observations. That silly script-read in the Times was just the latest example.

That was a minor if nagging example. Last Sunday, March 29, Fareed Zakaria swung from the heels in the featured front-page piece in the Washington Post’s Outlook section.

Zakaria painted a Mandated Thoroughly Standard Press Portrait of the state of the nation’s schools. “Every month, it seems, we hear about our children’s bad test scores in math and science,” he said as he started, understating the ubiquity of this mandated portrait.

As he continued, he made no attempt to challenge this gloomy portrait. Indeed, referring to scores attained by American students on international tests, he reinforced the mandated picture:

“My point is not that it’s good that American students fare poorly on these tests. It isn’t,” the serial plagiarist said.

(For the record, there’s no obvious way for anyone to cheat on these international tests, nor is there any apparent motive.)

As he continued, Zakaria reacted to his gloomy portrait in a surprising way. He said it doesn’t hugely matter if American kids score poorly on international tests.

You can read his piece to evaluate his reasoning. Here’s what had our youthful analysts gnashing their teeth:

Like everyone else is America’s press corps, Zakaria engaged in a bit of statistical sleight-of-hand. As everyone except our “reporters” knows, there are two major international test batteries in which most developed nations participate—the somewhat newer PISA, on which American kids score somewhat less well, and the somewhat older TIMSS/PIRLS, on which American kids score somewhat better.

Like everyone else in America’s “press corps,” Zakaria only cited scores from the PISA. Quite literally, he discarded half the data in reaching his Mandated Thoroughly Standard Gloomy Press Corps Portrait of These Kids Today!

Who except American “journalists” function this way? Who else conducts an analysis by ignoring half the data?

In the modern context, powerful figures seem to want this topic reported in the gloomiest possible way. Within the upper-end press, almost everyone does.

In truth, they’re all serial plagiarists! For reasons only they can explain, they’re typing the insider line, in which American kids are a pitiful mess thanks to the sloth of their unionized teachers.

Down in Atlanta, eleven teachers are in prison today. They died for the sins of the New York Times, which spent decades failing to report the fact that cheating was going on in some parts of the casino.

Today, our journalists keep disappearing the TIMSS. When it comes to test scores on the NAEP, they report the gaps but disappear the large gains, as we’ve explained a million times by now.

They keep discarding half the news! It’s how these life forms roll.

Tomorrow: The latest statistics on campus

28 comments:

  1. "NO STATISTICS NEED APPLY: Half the statistics get disappeared!"

    "Don’t get us wrong! The conduct is which these teachers engaged was ludicrous, inane and baldly dishonest."

    Bob Somerby

    "The dozen educators who stood trial, including five teachers and a principal...."

    New York Times

    Looks like Bob Somerby disappeared the statistics on half of those who were convicted.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you, 12:16, for optimizing the idle task.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. To paraphrase the blogger so many may esteem in silence:

      "the highlighted statement cannot be defended as technically accurate."

      Delete
  3. Education is failing. Adult liberals lack the basic education that should enable them to understand concepts like "sincerely held" religious beliefs, "compelling state interest." Ideas that permit one to recognize the difference between the legitimacy of government intervention that would compel a business to create a birthday cake versus a wedding cake for a gay person. The result is screaming, anti-intellectual liberals who reveal their ignorance every time they open their mouths on any topic these days. The combination of such an extreme level of ignorance with the lynch mob mentality of this group is dangerous.

    If you question whether the government should force a Christian gay printer to print GOD HATES FAGS signs for a Westboro funeral protest, the response is usually to question the motives behind the Indiana law, despite that motive is completely irrelevant.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jonny Scrum-halfApril 2, 2015 at 3:43 PM

      I hope that you understand that in the situation that you describe (whether a Christian gay printer must print signs for the Westboro Baptist picketers) the printer wouldn't be refusing to perform the service for religious reasons, and wouldn't be discriminating against the picketers on any legally protected basis. Presumably he/she would simply feel strongly that he didn't want to be associated with the picketers, and could refuse service on that basis - just as if I owned a pizzeria I could refuse to serve a neighbor who I didn't like. I don't believe that there's a law that requires service no matter what, but rather simply forbids discrimination on certain specified grounds.

      Delete
    2. There's room at the next post if you guys want to really get it on.

      Of course, there is plenty of room here. Plus you might get tips on that job you wanted, baby you can't conceive, or gay spouse you lost.

      Delete
    3. "Education is failing."

      And 2:25 PM does provide compelling evidence that the statement might be true.

      Delete
    4. @ Johnny the example presumes the gay Christian print shop owner is motivated by his religious faith that prohibits him from producing material promoting the statement "GOD HATES FAGS" even though the Westboro customer believes the message to be righteous and moral.

      Presumably you would like the US government to force the Christian gay printer to produce the signs if his resistance is founded in his religion.

      Presumably you would like the US government to force a Jewish baker to produce a cake reading "Death to Israel" for a radical Muslim gathering if the resistance is founded in his religion.

      Delete
    5. "Legally protected basis." There is no legal protection of behaviors such as gay marriage, heterosexual cohabitation, funeral picketing, or any number of other, legal behaviors a religious person could not promote without violating his faith.

      Delete
    6. Except that there are. Many states have added "sexual orientation" as a protected class along with race and religion, and laws specifically against gay marriage. There is even legal protection of funeral picketing under the First Amendment.

      As far as "violating his faith," well that gets into individual interpretation unless a person can specifically point to a tenet of his faith that forbids him from even "remote participation" (and that is a moral theology term) in an activity that is considered sinful.

      Take my own Roman Catholic faith as an example. The church teaches a lot about marriage, including divorce and remarriage. Can't do it.

      But it does not tell, say, Catholic wedding photographers that they are under any moral obligation not to take pictures at the wedding of a divorced Presbyterian and a divorced Methodist.

      Delete
    7. Didn't finish a thought there. "Laws against gay marriage are falling all over the country." That makes it "protected".

      Delete
    8. 8:06 the point is there are several legal behaviors that are protected, and so is the right not to promote them. Whether one's specific sect prohibits him from remote participation isn't a test, only whether his belief that the act would violate his faith is sincerely held. There is no requirement to specify a specific tenet regarding remote participation. Hobby Lobby's participation would have been remote in the form of funding birth control and abortion and it was not required that they be forced to produce a document from a church, only to declare it violated their conscience as in conflict with their sincerely held faith. State interests and least restrictive means were also required considerations. All of those tests are cleared for the baker who refuses to cater a gay wedding where they likely would not clear a refusal to cater a birthday party for a person who was gay.

      Delete
  4. "(A) small appetizer. .... Will anything ever stop our scribes from typing variants of the highlighted standard statement?

    MARTIN AND BOSMAN (3/22/15): .... He may have angered the teachers union and many black residents by closing 50 failing schools in mostly minority neighborhoods.

    The highlighted statement can be defended as “technically accurate.” Emanuel did close fifty schools; this did anger some residents. It’s also true that the schools in question were mostly in minority neighborhoods or, in a softer formulation, were “in mostly minority neighborhoods.”

    That said, Chicago’s student population is 90 percent black and Hispanic. There's no way to close underutilized schools in Chicago without closing schools “in mostly minority neighborhoods.”

    This situation obtains in urban systems all over the country. But at various major newspapers, reporters insist on feigning surprise at the fact that underutilized schools are getting closed in black and Hispanic neighborhoods.

    These ace reporters seem immune to the simplest statistical observations."

    Bob Somerby

    First, being "technically accurate" in an analysis of a mayoral race not a school closure article is all these reporters need to be on the issue of school closure. They are not immune from statistics, they don't need them for the purpose of the article.

    Second, they are not "technically accurate" from a political standpoint since they reference "minority neighborhoods" instead of "black" neighborhoods. The political charges brought against Rahm Emanuel by teachers groups was that he was closing schools in only black neighborhoods. This has been noted in the Somerby combox before.

    Third, the article did not reference the closure of "underutilized schools" as Somerby twice called them. They referenced closure of "failing" schools. There is a big difference between the two.

    Fourth, there is no way Somerby can know if reporters are surprised about anything unless they write that they are unless he is "feigning" being a mind readers.

    That is a lot of mistakes in one "small appetizer."


    ReplyDelete
  5. "In 2006, we discovered a clownish statistical scam which was elevating “passing rates” at schools all over the state of Virginia....The Washington Post, and other Virginia newspapers, failed to report this news. A rather remarkable statewide scam went almost wholly unreported."

    Bob "Strawberry" Somerby

    Just think, if the WaPo and other Virginia newspapers had been like the Atlanta Journal Constitution, Governor and Mrs. Ultrasound might be sharing a cell with some educators. Don't get me wrong. I think that might be prosecutorial overkill. None of this is all that heinous. Nobody can prove anyone was really harmed or benefited all that much. At least in the Governor's mansion.

    ReplyDelete
  6. "Zakaria ... the serial plagiarist ...."

    Sounds like something I'd say. Wait a minute, I did, and long before Somerby did. Does that mean ....?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Actually it sounds like something Captain Queeg said when Strawberry Somerby was just a boy running around Boston in his short pants."

      "Zakaria ... the serial plagiarist ....In truth, they’re all serial plagiarists!"

      "He was no different from any other officer in the ward room, they were all disloyal."

      Delete
  7. "Who except American “journalists” function this way? Who else conducts an analysis by ignoring half the data?"

    That said, who but Bob Somerby continues to ignore a third of the results of the NAEP, the so called Gold Standard of testing?

    Say, isn't the part he ignores given to students about the same age as the ones who take the PISA exam?

    ReplyDelete
  8. If you Somerby haters are so clever and wonderful why aren't you writing your own blog instead of dumping on this one?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Maybe I am. And it's getting more traffic than this one, which is a mighty low bar.

      Delete
    2. @ 12:51 sounds like "Go Away" gal/guy is back in fine form.

      Delete
  9. How I Get My Husband Back With The Help Of Dr Brave

    An amazing testimony on a spell caster who brought my husband back to me. My name is Natasha Johnson,i live in Florida,USA,and I'm happily married to a lovely and caring husband ,with three kids. A very big problem occurred in my family seven months ago,between me and my husband .so terrible that he took the case to court for a divorce.he said that he never wanted to stay with me again,and that he didn't love me anymore.So he packed out of the house and made me and my children passed through severe pain. I tried all my possible means to get him back,after much begging,but all to no avail.and he confirmed it that he has made his decision,and he never wanted to see me again. So on one evening,as i was coming back from work,i met an old friend of mine who asked of my husband .So i explained every thing to him,so he told me that the only way i can get my husband back,is to visit a spell caster,because it has really worked for him too.So i never believed in spell,but i had no other choice,than to follow his advice. Then he gave me the email address of the spell caster whom he visited.{bravespellcaster@gmail.com}. So the next morning,i sent a mail to the address he gave to me,and the spell caster assured me that i will get my husband back the next day.What an amazing statement!! I never believed,so he spoke with me,and told me everything that i need to do. Then the next morning, So surprisingly, my husband who didn't call me for the past seven {7}months,gave me a call to inform me that he was coming back.So Amazing!! So that was how he came back that same day,with lots of love and joy,and he apologized for his mistake,and for the pain he caused me and my children. Then from that day,our relationship was now stronger than how it were before,by the help of a spell caster. So, i will advice you out there to kindly visit the same website { http://enchantedscents.tripod.com/lovespell/},if you are in any condition like this,or you have any problem related to "bringing your ex back. So thanks to the Dr Brave for bringing back my husband ,and brought great joy to my family once again. { bravespellcaster@gmail.com }, Thanks..

    Sent from my MetroPCS 4G Wireless Phone

    ReplyDelete
  10. I want to use this golden medium to appreciate Dr.Bola a great spell caster for helping me retrieving back my relationship with my ex boyfriend when he ended and turned back on me for quite a long time now.I embarked on a search online for a solution to my problem because i love him so much that i will not let anyone to take him out of my life,luckily for me i met dr Bola who performed a spell for me and within 48 hours after the spell had been cast I receive a text from my ex saying that he is sorry for the pains and tears that he had caused me and that he will not do such thing to me again in his life. I was surprised but later accepted him back again. Anyone that is in the same line of problem or different one that want to contact a spell caster should happily email him: drbolaspellcaster@hotmail.com or Call him through his mobile number +2348059723809,I am so happy Using this post to say a big thank you and to also encourage people to contact Dr.Bola for help his email:drbolaspellcaster@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  11. who ever is reading this testimony today should please celebrate with me
    and my family because it all started like a joke to some people and others
    said it was impossible. my name is Michael i live in Chicago i am happily
    married with two kids and a lovely wife something terrible happen to my
    family along the line, i lost my job and my wife packed out of my house
    because i was unable to take care of her and my kids at that particular
    time. i manage all through five years, no wife to support me to take care
    of the children and there come a faithful day that i will never forget in
    my life i met an old friend who i explain all my difficulties to, and he
    took me to a spell caster and and the name of the temple is called, DR
    Okundonor, i was assure that everything will be fine and my wife will come
    back to me after the wonderful work of Dr Okundonorgreatspell, my wife
    came back to me and today i am one of the richest man in my country. i
    advice you if you have any problem email him with this email:
    ( drokundonorgreatspellcaster10@gmail.com ) and you will have the best result. take
    things for granted and it will be take from you. i wish you all the best.

    Contact:( drokundonorgreatspellcaster10@gmail.com )
    ( drokundonorgreatspellcaster10@gmail.com ), or call he with this phone number,
    +2348137828640

    ReplyDelete

  12. How to solve relationship and married problem !!

    I can say am the happiest woman on earth because of what Dr Frank Ojo has done in my life for restoring happiness and love back to my family. My name is Helene Wilson. I'm happily married to a lovely and caring husband with two kids. A very big problem occurred in my family seven months ago,between me and my husband .so terrible that he took the case to court for a divorce.he said that he never wanted to stay with me again,and that he didn't love me anymore.So he packed out of the house and made me and my children passed through severe pain. I tried all my possible means to get him back,after much begging,but all to no avail.and he confirmed it that he has made his decision,and he never wanted to see me again. So on one evening,as i was coming back from work,i met an old friend of mine who asked of my husband .So i explained every thing to him,so he told me that the only way i can get my husband back,is to visit a spell caster,because it has really worked for him too.So i never believed in spell,but i had no other choice,than to follow his advice. Then he gave me the email address of the spell caster whom he visited.{Templeofloveandprosperity@gmail.com}. So the next morning,i sent a mail to the address he gave to me,and the spell caster assured me that i will get my husband back the next day.What an amazing statement!! I never believed,so he spoke with me,and told me everything that i need to do. Then the next morning, So surprisingly, my husband who didn't call me for the past 9 months,gave me a call to inform me that he was coming back.So Amazing!! So that was how he came back that same day,with lots of love and joy,and he apologized for his mistake,and for the pain he caused me and my children. Then from that day,our relationship was now stronger than how it were before,by the help of a spell caster. So, If you have any problem contact him, I give you 100% guarantee that he will help you, Thanks to Dr Frank Ojo for bringing back my husband ,and brought great joy to my family once again, SO HERE HIS EMAIL ADDRESS { Templeofloveandprosperity@gmail.com } WEBSITE ADDRESS : http://lovespell2.yolasite.com, Thanks you Dr Frank Ojo, i Helene will always be testifying about your good work.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Dr Malaika doesn’t ask for testimonies and he doesn’t charge. His email is odogwumalaika@gmail.com He is genuine and people get to meet him by luck.
    But right now am your luck if you meet him. Every other testimonies of spell casters you read here are scams.
    Dr Malaika lives in Nigeria and I happened to meet him by chance after a friend told me about how he brought back
    her ex and restored her lost womb. She also told me about how Dr Malaika cures all forms of illness ranging from
    HIV to Cancer, Fibroid, and Infertility and also Money spells. I followed those other internet testimonies and was
    hugely scammed to the extent that I wanted to kill myself. Dr Malaika turned my situation around, He made my ex
    come crawling on his knees to have him back. His email address is odogwumalaika@gmail.com , mobile: +2347065448120
    but please don’t make him know that I published
    him on net. He is just wonderful and I wish whoever that finds him good luck.

    ReplyDelete