Supplemental: Eye-and-earwitnesses fail us again!

TUESDAY, MAY 19, 2015

The train derailment this time:
Why did that Amtrak train speed up as it approached that dangerous curve?

We’ll offer our speculation below. For today, we once again learn an important lesson about the limitations of eyewitnesses.

By the weekend, the following questions had arisen: Had the windshield of the train been struck by some object? Could that have played a role in the derailment?

For ourselves, we don’t know what occurred. According to murky reporting in today’s New York Times, an account from an earwitness has apparently turned out to be wrong:
PHILLIPS AND SCHMIDT (5/19/15): On Monday, as Amtrak restored service between New York and Washington, F.B.I. investigators traveled to a train yard in Wilmington, Del., where Amtrak 188 was taken for further study. Officials analyzed the windshield to determine if damage to the glass was caused by the derailment or a projectile, such as a rock.

The N.T.S.B. said it expected final results in the next few days.

“It could be completely coincidental, it could be causal, and that’s exactly what we are trying to find out,” Robert L. Sumwalt, a member of the N.T.S.B., said Sunday on the CBS program “Face the Nation.” Mr. Sumwalt said at a news conference on Friday that an assistant conductor said she heard an engineer on the Septa regional commuter line say in a radio transmission that his train had been struck by an object. She told investigators that she believed she heard the Amtrak engineer, Mr. Bostian, say that his train had been hit by something, too.

On Sunday, Mr. Sumwalt, appearing on several talk shows, said recordings of radio traffic showed that the engineer did not call dispatch to say his train had been struck,
nor did the Septa engineer recall having a conversation with Mr. Bostian.
It seems the earwitness was wrong about what she thought she heard. In a bit of a muddle, the Times report doesn’t explain which train the earwitness was on.

Last Friday, Jim Dwyer wrote an important piece in the Times about the limitations of eyewitnesses. In his “About New York” column, he described mistaken testimony from two eyewitnesses to an incident last Wednesday in which a man with a hammer attacked two police officers.

The two eyewitnesses gave separate accounts of the incident. Both were sure about what they had seen. Until they watched surveillance tape, which showed their accounts were wrong:
DWYER (5/15/15): Contrary to what Mr. O’Grady said, the man who was shot had not been trying to get away from the officers; he was actually chasing an officer from the sidewalk onto Eighth Avenue, swinging a hammer at her head. Behind both was the officer’s partner, who shot the man, David Baril.

And Ms. Khalsa did not see Mr. Baril being shot while in handcuffs; he is, as the video and still photographs show, freely swinging the hammer, then lying on the ground with his arms at his side. He was handcuffed a few moments later, well after he had been shot.

There is no evidence that the mistaken accounts of either person were malicious or intentionally false. Studies of memories of traumatic events consistently show how common it is for errors to creep into confidently recalled accounts, according to cognitive psychologists.

“It’s pretty normal,” said Deryn Strange, an associate psychology professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice. “That’s the hard thing to get our heads around. It’s frightening how easy it is to build in a false memory.”
The two eyewitnesses weren’t malicious, Dwyer emphasized. They were simply wrong—wrong about what they thought they saw during a brief, highly unusual incident.

The shortcomings of eyewitness testimony were brought to the fore in the Justice Department’s report about the death of Michael Brown. This material was widely ignored by those on our own liberal team.

The material was also widely ignored by some of the overpaid stars of “cable news.” In subsequent incidents, they quickly returned to a shaky practice—they interviewed excited eyewitnesses without warning viewers that such testimony, while well-intentioned, may often turn out to be wrong.

To name one name, Anderson Cooper has never met an eyewitness whose account he didn’t love. We were struck by the ease with which some cable performers returned to an irresponsible practice. Perhaps it’s what they get paid for!

Dwyer’s column was instructive. Regarding the train derailment:

In a medium driven by speculation, we’ve seen no one wonder if this could possibly have been a copycat incident. A copycat of what, you may ask.

Incomparably, we’ll leave it right there! But in a world driven by speculation, we’re often struck by the lack of imagination among those in our cable brigade.

14 comments:

  1. One element that suggests this was not a copycat is that the accident was so far from fatal for the engineer who was controlling the train. He did suffer a concussion and does not remember what happened, which is normal for someone with a head injury. Absent the kind of evidence available in the incident you are referring to, I think it is unfair to malign the engineer and perhaps injure his career with this kind of speculation. I'm sure investigators are focusing on that and many other possibilities, but I would hope the press wouldn't speculate along those lines. If they are personally doing so, perhaps some very appropriate editorial restraint is being exercised.

    ReplyDelete
  2. A reasonable person at this point would believe it likely that the engineer was at fault since the accident involved a fairly new train traveling at an extremely dangerous, illegal speed. Let's see how it plays out.

    ReplyDelete
  3. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GmHiGAegh_U

    ReplyDelete
  4. At first I thought you were referring to the Metro-North crash of December 2013, in which the conductor dozed off and approached the curve in the Bronx at 80 mph, resulting in four dead and 75 injured.

    But I guess you're referring to the suicide of Andreas Lubitz in the Germanwings crash in the French Alps.

    ReplyDelete
  5. "I am so happy to share this wonderful testimony about Dr Brave, my name is Mellisa Jefferson I am 34 years old, I live in Florida united states, I am happily married to Sowers Jefferson with three kids we got married in 2006 I am a banker but due to some certain family conditions I had to quit my job so I could have time for my family my husband works in a construction company not long ago around may 2015 my husband started to behave in a way i could not understand, i was very Confused by the way he treat me and the Kids. Later that month he did not come home again and he called me that he want a divorce, i asked him what have i Done wrong to deserve this from him, all he was saying is that he want a divorce That he hate me and do not want to see Me again in his life, i was mad and also Frustrated do not know what to do,i was Sick for more than 4 weeks because of the divorce. i love him so much he was everything to me without him my life is Incomplete. i told my sister and she told me to contact a spell caster, i never believed in all this spell casting of a thing. i just want to try if something will come out of it. i contacted Dr Brave for the return of my husband to me, he told me that my husband have Been taken by another woman, that she cast a spell on him that is why he hate me and also want us to divorce. then he told me that he have to cast a spell on him that will make him return to Me and the kids, he casted the spell and After 27hours my husband called me and He told me that i should forgive him, he Started to apologize on phone and said That he still loves me that he did not know what happen to him that he left me. it was the spell that Dr Brave on him that brought him back to me today, i and my family Are now happy again today. thank you Dr Brave for what you have done for me i would have been nothing Today if not for your great spell. i want You my friends who are passing through All this kind of love problem of getting Back their husband, wife , or ex boyfriend and girlfriend to contact him on this email: bravespellcaster@gmail.com , web site:http://enchantedscents.tripod.com/lovespell/ . and you will see that your problem will be solved Without any delay or effect cell number +2348072370762 Thanks for reading. ."

    ReplyDelete
  6. I am so happy to share this wonderful testimony about Dr Brave, my name is Mellisa Jefferson I am 32 years old, I live in Florida united states, I am happily married to Sowers Jefferson with three kids we got married in 2004 I am a banker but due to some certain family conditions I had to quit my job so I could have time for my family my husband works in a construction company not long ago around may 2015 my husband started to behave in a way i could not understand, i was very Confused by the way he treat me and the Kids. Later that month he did not come home again and he called me that he want a divorce, i asked him what have i Done wrong to deserve this from him, all he was saying is that he want a divorce That he hate me and do not want to see Me again in his life, i was mad and also Frustrated do not know what to do,i was Sick for more than 4 weeks because of the divorce. i love him so much he was everything to me without him my life is Incomplete. i told my sister and she told me to contact a spell caster, i never believed in all this spell casting of a thing. i just want to try if something will come out of it. i contacted Dr Brave for the return of my husband to me, he told me that my husband have Been taken by another woman, that she cast a spell on him that is why he hate me and also want us to divorce. then he told me that he have to cast a spell on him that will make him return to Me and the kids, he casted the spell and After 27hours my husband called me and He told me that i should forgive him, he Started to apologize on phone and said That he still loves me that he did not know what happen to him that he left me. it was the spell that Dr Brave casted on him that brought him back to me today, i and my family Are now happy again today. thank you Dr Brave for what you have done for me i would have been nothing Today if not for your great spell. i want You my friends who are passing through All this kind of love problem of getting Back their husband, wife , or ex boyfriend and girlfriend to contact him on this email: bravespellcaster@gmail.com , web site:http://enchantedscents.tripod.com/lovespell/ . and you will see that your problem will be solved Without any delay or effect cell number +2348072370762 Thanks for reading..

    ReplyDelete
  7. I am so happy to share this wonderful testimony about Dr Brave, my name is Mellisa Jefferson I am 32 years old, I live in Florida united states, I am happily married to Sowers Jefferson with three kids we got married in 2004 I am a banker but due to some certain family conditions I had to quit my job so I could have time for my family my husband works in a construction company not long ago around may 2015 my husband started to behave in a way i could not understand, i was very Confused by the way he treat me and the Kids. Later that month he did not come home again and he called me that he want a divorce, i asked him what have i Done wrong to deserve this from him, all he was saying is that he want a divorce That he hate me and do not want to see Me again in his life, i was mad and also Frustrated do not know what to do,i was Sick for more than 4 weeks because of the divorce. i love him so much he was everything to me without him my life is Incomplete. i told my sister and she told me to contact a spell caster, i never believed in all this spell casting of a thing. i just want to try if something will come out of it. i contacted Dr Brave for the return of my husband to me, he told me that my husband have Been taken by another woman, that she cast a spell on him that is why he hate me and also want us to divorce. then he told me that he have to cast a spell on him that will make him return to Me and the kids, he casted the spell and After 27hours my husband called me and He told me that i should forgive him, he Started to apologize on phone and said That he still loves me that he did not know what happen to him that he left me. it was the spell that Dr Brave casted on him that brought him back to me today, i and my family Are now happy again today. thank you Dr Brave for what you have done for me i would have been nothing Today if not for your great spell. i want You my friends who are passing through All this kind of love problem of getting Back their husband, wife , or ex boyfriend and girlfriend to contact him on this email: bravespellcaster@gmail.com , web site:http://enchantedscents.tripod.com/lovespell/ . and you will see that your problem will be solved Without any delay or effect cell number +2348072370762 Thanks for reading..

    ReplyDelete
  8. The Vintage Wholesale Company The Vintage Wholesale Company.Walson Rockabilly are a vintage wholesale company who focus on vintage fashion wholesale. WalsonRockabilly Vintage Clothing wholesalers are the UK's leading,Shop wholesale vintage dress, xxxx silk dress, vintage jewelry products from reliable vintage dress wholesalers on walsonrockabilly and get worldwide,We know wholesale vintage clothing. We're the only vintage clothing wholesaler that knows what it's like to be in your shoes,because we run stores ourselves.Always Vintage is a Wholesale Vintage Clothing Distributor. We offer more than ninety different categories of vintage clothing for you to choose from.
    cheap retro dress
    Waist Cincher
    Latex waist trainer

    ReplyDelete
  9. Really impressive post. I read it whole and going to share it with my social circules. I enjoyed your article and planning to rewrite it on my own blog.
    mahjong | agario | minecraft|halloween | pacman| kizi | hulk | mickey mouse games | sniper games

    ReplyDelete
  10. Replies
    1. Testimony By Wendy Owen ,How to get your ex back fast!

      I was hurt and heart broken when a very big problem occurred in my marriage seven months ago, between me and my husband . so terrible that he took the case to court for a divorce. he said that he never wanted to stay with me again,and that he didn't love me anymore.So he packed out of the house and made me and my children passed through severe pain. I tried all my possible means to get him back,after much begging,but all to no avail.and he confirmed it that he has made his decision,and he never wanted to see me again. So on one evening,as i was coming back from work,i met an old friend of mine who asked of my husband .So i explained every thing to him,so he told me that the only way i can get my husband back,is to visit a spell caster,because it has really worked for him too.So i never believed in spell,but i had no other choice,than to follow his advice. Then he gave me the Email address of the spell caster whom he visited. Templeofloveandprosperity@gmail.com. So the next morning,i sent a mail to the address he gave to me,and the spell caster assured me that i will get my husband back the next day. What an amazing statement!! I never believed,so he spoke with me, and told me everything that i need to do. Then the next morning, So surprisingly, my husband who didn't call me for the past 7 months, gave me a call to inform me that he was coming back. So Amazing!! So that was how he came back that same day,with lots of love and joy,and he apologized for his mistake,and for the pain he caused me and my children. Then from that day,our relationship was now stronger than how it were before,by the help of a spell caster. So, i will advice you out there if you have any problem contact Dr Frank Ojo, i give you 100% guarantee that he will help you.. Email him at: Templeofloveandprosperity@gmail.com ,or visit his Web site to know more about him: http://africatemple.yolasite.com ,and i lives in United Kingdom. Thank you sooooo much!!!

      Delete