HEALING: Safely returned from the Dalmatian coast...

TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 29, 2026

...we consider the need for healing: As you've probably noticed, we aren't all that "well read." But it's one of our favorite passages from literature—from literature of a certain type.

The passage comes from Abraham Lincoln: The Prairie Years, the two-volume biography published by Carl Sandburg in 1926. Fourteen years later, Sandburg won the Pulitzer Prize for History for Abraham Lincoln: The War Years, a four-volume extension of this earlier work.

We'll let the leading authority on the matter sketch the lay of the land:

Abraham Lincoln: The War Years

Abraham Lincoln: The War Years encompasses volumes three through six of Carl Sandburg's six-volume biography of Abraham Lincoln; these volumes focus particularly on the American Civil War period. The first two volumes, Abraham Lincoln: The Prairie Years, were published in 1926 and cover the period from Lincoln's birth through his inauguration as president. The final four volumes were published together in 1939, and won the 1940 Pulitzer Prize for History.

Abraham Lincoln: The Prairie Years and Abraham Lincoln: The War Years are collectively considered by many to be "the best-selling, most widely read, and most influential book[s] about Lincoln." The books have been through many editions, including a one-volume edition in 1954 prepared by Sandburg.

Sandburg was a poet historian, what you might call a blank verse biographer. In ways which some scholars haven't admired, he let his story of the American giant, Abraham Lincoln, flow from his own prairie heart.

We're thinking today of our favorite passage from The Prairie Years. The passage comes quite close to the end of that initial two-volume work.

Lincoln has now been elected president, in the first of the two elections from which he wouldn't return. He's still in Springfield, waiting to travel to Washington—but first, he travels to rural Coles County for his final meeting with Sally Bush Lincoln, the (step)mother who initially saw his great promise.

Presidential travel was different then. Right there in Chapter 163, Sandburg describes the way Lincoln set out from Springfield on a commercial passenger train.

After that, this:

Abraham Lincoln: The Prairie Years 
Chapter 163

[...]

Whitney got off the train at his station, Lincoln rode to Mattoon, missed connections with a passenger train, and took the caboose of a freight train to Charleston. The engine stopped at the station for orders, and Lincoln, with a shawl over his shoulders, and his boots in slush, mud, and ice, picked his way in the late evening dusk alongside the tracks the length of the freight train to the station, where a buggy was ready. Friends met him and took him to the house, where he was to stay overnight; the next morning he would go out to say good-by and have his last hour with his stepmother, Sally Bush Lincoln.

So the passage begins. Lincoln rode in the caboose of a freight train on his way to take part in what Sandburg called that "last hour."

He'd soon be trying to save a nation. Continuing directly, Sandburg, a poet historian, portrays who the president was:

[Continuing directly from above]
Among those who came to see Lincoln that evening was a lawyer, A. P. Dunbar, who had met and talked with Lincoln hundreds of times. But now that Lincoln was in five weeks to be inaugurated President, Dunbar didn’t know whether he ought to be familiar and easy as in the old days. “If he is dignified and formal, I must act accordingly,” said Dunbar. He knocked at the door of the house where Lincoln was staying; the family was finishing supper; Lincoln had eaten and was in the front room sitting before the fire; he heard the knock at the door and opened the door himself. In a flash he had Dunbar’s right hand in his, and, resting another hand on Dunbar’s shoulder, he burst out, “Lord A’mighty, Aleck, how glad I am to see you!”

Another man came in with Dunbar. They sat by the fire. Lincoln was soon drawing out one and another of his yarns, and nicely started on the fifth or sixth one, which was about a girl whose family kept a cow and who each evening would hunt up the cow and drive it home. “One day,” said Lincoln, “she rode a horse bareback to the woods. On the way home the horse, frightened by a dog or something which darted from behind a bush, made a wild dash ahead, the girl still astride, when suddenly—A knock came at the door and Lincoln halted the story, stepped across the room, opened the door, and welcomed in the Presbyterian minister, his wife, and two other ladies. Other callers arrived, the evening party began, and Dunbar and his friend went away without hearing the rest of the story.

That's Sandburg, portraying Lincoln as a regular person, at home in the presence of regular people. Dunbar never heard the end of the story, but he did hear this:

“Lord A’mighty, Aleck, how glad I am to see you!”

As Sandburg finishes this short chapter, he briefly describes Lincoln's visit to Sally Bush. As his chapter ends, he pens an evocative passage about the sources of "healing and strength" which might serve to sustain the profoundly challenged American nation during the years to come.

We'll move on to that passage tomorrow. For today, we offer this point:

If we Americans escape the danger of the next several years—the years which will follow November's elections—we'll need to conduct a search for healing in our badly afflicted land.

Given the madness of the time, disaster could be looming. But even if disaster is averted, we'll need to find ways to heal. 

Are we aware of that challenge? How are we planning to do that?

Tomorrow:  "The sunshine of the prairie summer..."  (Poet historian speaks.)


137 comments:

  1. This is nothing a "Truth and Reconciliation Commission" can't fix.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Will need strategic Esso station lightpost-like treatments to keep the politicians in line.

      Delete


  2. Dubrovnik? Hey, I was there just a couple of weeks ago. Nice place. But it has to be not quite a beach weather there now; there was getting cold as we were leaving, on the 11th of Sept.

    As for your idol Lincoln, did I see somewhere recently that he was, while in office, the most hated president in history? What do you think, Bob? Assuming you Dumbocrats do think...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lincoln is never ranked as the most disliked president, by scholars or by the public.

      Delete
    2. Here, Dumbocrat:
      "The Unpopular Mr. Lincoln: The Story of America's Most Reviled President is a 2009 historical study written by Larry Tagg that examines the harsh, widespread criticism Abraham Lincoln faced from his contemporaries during his lifetime."

      Delete
    3. And yet he is never ranked among the worst, the men who failed to prevent the South from leaving the union and botched Reconstruction.

      "Historians note that it was primarily his assassination in 1865 that dramatically transformed public perception, elevating him from a reviled and embattled wartime leader to a martyred national hero."

      Why do you consider this a partisan question? Is it because he freed the slaves and restored the union? I can see how the South might have disliked that, but we, as a nation, now consider slavery bad and being a unified nation good, except for right wing cranks and neo-Nazis.

      Delete
    4. And the fake fucking Christians 11:49, that never quote Christ cause he is too fucking woke.

      Delete
    5. Larry Tagg, a former high school English teacher and two bit musician, wrote a book based on supposition.

      It is not a peer reviewed work and is not cited by professional historians. It was not published by a university press, but by a fly by night independent publisher that happens to be a friend of the author. A little known historian was hired to review it and he gave a highly critical review.

      In reality, Lincoln was relatively popular at the time he was president. Obviously the South can be discounted. Lincoln was elected twice, successively.

      There was no polling back then.

      When you are reduced to searching for a crumb of evidence, and that crumb is crusty and moldy, you have no credible point to make.

      Furthermore, the extent to which Lincoln was unpopular, outside of the South, was related to how he was managing the ongoing civil war. It was not related to his worldviews or to corruption or criminality.

      Delete
    6. Roosevelt was hated ... in Germany. In Japan.

      This troll exists to make dumb trolls look smart by comparison.

      Delete
    7. Triggered, Hillary?

      Delete
    8. Nah, but you clearly are.

      womp womp

      Delete
    9. I am retarded

      womp womp

      Delete
    10. You'll get no argument on that.

      Delete
    11. Weirdo trolls, keep shooting themselves in the foot.

      Delete
  3. Our culture is losing its capacity to extend ordinary human empathy to imperfect people.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Holding people accountable for their crimes is not the same as lacking empathy. Calling something like rape of children an "imperfection" is ridiculous and shows how far the right has abused common understanding, norms, and even truth/reality.

      Delete
    2. That fucking pig Paxton bragging about imprisoning a gross ass convicted child rapist for a whole sixty days instead of one, when the perv served 30. This whole MAGA sickness needs crushed. Vile fucking weirdos.

      Delete
    3. Triggered, Hillary?

      Delete
    4. This is the Republican equivalent of "what's the matter, can't you take a joke?" Trolls are scum.

      Delete
    5. Cope, Hillary. Try to touch your asshole and sniff the finger. It helps.

      I am Corby.

      Delete
    6. Have you hugged your Hitler today?

      Delete
  4. "In its simplest definition literature is a body of written works. However, the name has traditionally been applied to those imaginative works of poetry and prose distinguished by the intentions of their authors and the perceived aesthetic excellence of their execution."

    The controversy concerning a new generation of historians concerned whether it was OK to invent dialog and details of situations that the historian did not witness, were undocumented, and thus could not have known about. Did Lincoln actually say: “Lord A’mighty, Aleck, how glad I am to see you!” Did he leave that story unfinished? Sandberg portrays Lincoln as "a regular person," which leaves a lot of latitude. Which of Sandberg's choices were accurate?

    AI/Wikipedia: "Carl Sandburg’s landmark six-volume biography of Abraham Lincoln (The Prairie Years, 1926; The War Years, 1939) is highly contested for its historical accuracy."

    Somerby prefers his history fictionalized and laud's Sandburg's poetical style. That approach would be frustrating to someone who truly wanted to know Lincoln as a man. In Sandburg's books, how much is Lincoln and how much is Sandburg? Somerby doesn't care. In that, he scorns the primary goal of actual historians -- to know the historical truth and reality of a past time.

    Somerby says: "If we Americans escape the danger of the next several years—the years which will follow November's elections—we'll need to conduct a search for healing in our badly afflicted land."

    I believe that there is so much about our times that is fictionalized, so many lies, that there remains insufficient truth to support a democratic system that depends on facts and knowledge to enable optimal decision-making by voters. We need to rediscover the truth, especially on the right where lies have been used to gain power and manipulate voters. We do not need an essay from Somerby about a highly glossed historical figure who is made larger than life by writers like Sandburg. We will need a period of discovery and commitment to reality to counteract the mess Trump has made of reality. That is a prerequisite to healing. As memes abound and anything fake can be presented as real, we need to figure out who did what, put the right villains in jail, and restore sanity to public discourse.

    Somerby does not help with that today.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And Biden had a cold and Trump colluded with Russia.

      Delete
    2. No one listened to Biden's explanation for his poor performance. And yes, there is proof that Trump colluded with Russia in several elections. That these partisan lies are offered in this context illustrates the problem. The media is supposed to hold liars accountable, so no wonder Trump is trying to both ban and undermine the press.

      Delete
    3. I still find it hard to believe it would take an enemy government (Russia) to get Republican voters amped-up about voting for white supremacy.
      Seems like a waste of Putin's time, though having a Russian asset lead the USA might have been too tempting to leave to chance.

      Delete
    4. There's no proof Trump colluded with Russia. That is not true, nor is it a fact. It's a fictionalized lie made up to manipulate voters.

      Delete
    5. From Thom Hartmann:

      "It was October 13, 2018, just 24 days before the midterm election, and then-President Trump held a rally in Richmond, Kentucky for Republican candidates. He told the crowd:

      “Thanks to our strong trade and economic policies, Braidy Industries recently broke ground on a new billion-dollar aluminum mill that will create up to 1,500 jobs right next to Ashland, Kentucky.”

      Kentucky Republicans thanked him effusively and built the promise of a new Russian-financed Russian-oligarch-owned aluminum plant into their remaining campaign ads, getting a big boost from the announcement. And then, of course, after the election the whole scheme collapsed."

      Delete
    6. The Mueller report has proof Russia interfered on Trump's behalf. The "no collusion" rubric is a distraction from the evidence of Russian interference in every single election, to help Trump.

      Delete
    7. Exactly. As I said, there's no proof Trump colluded with Russia. That is not true, nor is it a fact. It's a fictionalized lie made up to manipulate voters.

      Delete
    8. The lie that Trump colluded with Russia was one of the most elaborate, successful propaganda campaigns in the history of the world.

      Delete
    9. If it worked so well, why was Trump reelected?

      Delete
    10. Is it colluding when your first meeting with a foreign leader is Putin and you tell the translators and note-takers to leave the room and make no recording of what was said? Then Trump did unthinkable things such as trying to weaken NATO and telling Russia he didn't care what they did in Europe. Shortly after he gave the oligarchs back impounded funds and removed sanctions on trade with Russia. And then Trump went out of his way to humiliate Zelensky, telling him to "negotiate" to end the Ukraine war (where Russia invaded Ukraine).

      Delete
    11. Putin's envoy to China, friend of the oligarchs, pays for Jr's fucking lavish island wedding party and you dumb cucks are still trying to sell no collusion? Trump insists on evil warmongering Putin attending the G20 and you chuds still think no collusion? Get the fuck out of here you fucking weirdos.

      Delete
    12. Yes, none of that is collusion. Sorry.

      Collusion was a narrative made up and disseminated by the highest levels of power.

      Delete
    13. Trump does collude with Putin, it is an ongoing affair.

      Mueller, a Republican, barely put any effort into investigating Trump, but even so found an entire volume of evidence that demonstrated Trump colluded with Putin. Mueller used some weasel words because he is a Republican and will only go so far in damaging the GOP. Using those weasel words to then weasel out of the fact that Trump colludes with Russia, exposes the emptiness of such an argument.

      In fact, Trump has been colluding with Russia, a now defunct nation, since Trump married the daughter of a major KGB operative. That was Trump's first marriage, he is now on his third, having cheated on all of his wives, including his current one, the genius Melania. Poor Melania, once mildly attractive before meeting Trump, now she looks like a man dressing up as a woman (she literally looks like Michael Caine from Dressed To Kill). That is what Trump does. To be fair, Trump routinely expresses an attraction for certain males. Sometimes he does worse: his first wife mysteriously died falling down stairs in her own house but somehow the cause of death was blunt trauma to her abdomen. This poor woman was raped by Trump during their marriage, but after death she was unceremoniously dumped in an unkempt grave in the back-end deserted part of his golf resort in attempt for Trump to get a tax write off.

      Melania is counting on outliving Trump, but Trump is clinging to life because he knows he is headed for that Lake of Fire.

      Delete
    14. Russia-Trump collusion was made-up by the corporate media as the reason Republicans would elect a white supremacist to be President of the United States of America.
      Not surprisingly, it got more traction from the public than the media's first attempt to excuse the bigotry of Republican voters; economic anxiousness on the part of voters who know nothing at all about economics.

      Delete
    15. One of Trump's other longtime buddies besides Epstein is Giuliani who went after the Italian mafia to then allow the Russian mafia to replace them.

      Recognizing the longtime collusion between Trump and Russia in no way cuts against the correct position that Trump voters are primarily motivated by racism, and other similar oppressions.

      Delete
    16. Mueller never found any collusion. No collusion was ever found. It was propaganda that you fell for. Sorry.

      Delete
    17. Remember that time Ghoulish Giuliani was running around Ukraine with two KBG agents looking for dirt on Hunter Biden's his t pecker.

      Delete
    18. 5:58 I can understand why you want to change the subject.

      Delete
    19. Please explain how Trump's personal lawyer running around Ukraine with Russian agents to dig up dirt on his opponents son to use against Biden in the election is not collusion? God you folks are fucking stupid.

      Delete
    20. How anyone could be so gullible to fall for the media's lies about how it took Russia to get Republicans to elect a white supremacist to be President of the United States of America, is beyond me.

      Delete
    21. 8:12,
      It could always be worse. They could be so gullible they thought Republicans were amped-up by Trump because they were economically anxious.
      LO Fucking L.

      Delete
    22. Troll answering his own trolling comment. You're a loser. I hope you know that.

      Delete
    23. Some weirdo tried to tell me they knew of a Republican voter who wasn't a bigot. Some friend of someone their cousin works with.
      When pressed, it turned out (of course) they were lying.

      Delete
    24. 8:12 because it doesn't establish Trump knowingly entered into a criminal conspiracy with Russian intelligence. (Giuliani was doing that in public, he wasn't keeping it a secret.)

      Delete
    25. Haitian immigrants ate Republican voters ability to not elect white supremacists to lead the country.

      Delete
    26. I can see why you want to change the subject. "I have no way to prove my collusion claims so I will just poison the well with trite accusations of racism.".

      You're a loser and a dick.

      Delete
    27. "Collusion was a narrative made up and disseminated by the highest levels of power."

      In exchange for elites in the corporate boardrooms of the media disseminating lies about bigoted Republican voters, Trump gave them two huge tax breaks.
      Perhaps, that's the collusion being referred to here.

      Delete
    28. 8:24,
      If it wasn't Russia which got Republican voters to salivate over Trump's bigotry, what do you think it was?

      Delete
    29. Calling Republican voters "racists" is the oldest truth in the book.

      Delete
    30. Facts not in evidence at the time, asshole. You argue like a typical Charlie Kirk asshole. "Uh-Oh: Giuliani’s “Biden Sources” Charged With Being Putin Agents". Fuck off.

      Delete
  5. Trump: "“Lord A’mighty, Xi, how glad I am to see you!”

    Trump's grace is to be a billionaire many times over and yet remain a common man. Why finish that "sir story" about the big strong steel company president who approached him with tears in his eyes, begging Trump to let him build a huge plant in Iowa? We all know how it ends. (Right, no steel mill, just another empty promise.)

    Would it enhance Trump's legacy to think of him as a flawed man, in the sense of Sandberg's Lincoln? "Not you, piggy" Trump says, displaying his impatience with female journalists. These human details enhance the reality of Trump the man, amirite? His inability to walk a straight line down a red carpet rolled out for a Communist Chinese dictator. These details endear Trump us, even his political enemies. Is that what Somerby is suggesting today? If so, he is so very wrong. Hunger is reaching new levels in our country and foodbanks are tapped out. Trump doesn't care. That is our reality, no matter how sycophantic poets later portray Trump.

    ReplyDelete
  6. When historians write about our times, there will be plenty of documentation of Trump's flaws -- no need to invent dialog. Tiedrich writes daily about Trump's activities:

    "Mad King Donny continues to deteriorate before our very eyes.

    Yesterday, sweaty and unsteady on his feet, he shambled into the Oval Bordello, half an hour late for the dog-and-pony show that his minders had set up for him.

    Surrounded by his Emotional Support Flunkies, Dear Leader sat down at his Big Boy Resolute Desk and struggled to read from his prepared text.

    And, of course, as soon as someone else started speaking, the narcoleptic old fart factory fell fast asleep, and started crop-dusting the room with the pungent aroma of ass music.

    The whole event was a clownfucktacular shit-show — or, as we call it around here, Monday.

    Dozy Donny should have stayed asleep — because after he woke up, he doubled down on his five-thousand-dollar bribe.

    [Trump said:] “Because of tariffs, we— are— taking in HUNDREDS of billions of dollars of dollars— of profits. It’s one of the reasons I can offer, if— Republicans win the— HOUSE and Senate. $5,000 to every adult. And we can do it and the Democrats can’t, because the Democrats don't have any income.”

    [Tiedrich:] Holy shit. Every word that just seeped from Donny’s rancid anus-mouth is either a fever-swamp fantasy, an outright lie, or just a basic failure to understand how money works. It staggers the mind when you consider that this low-wattage fuckwad is in charge of our entire nation’s economy."

    Historians are already listing Trump as the worst president ever. The midterms will confirm that the voters agree about that. He should have quit while he was ahead, but he is far too greedy for that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tiedrich:

      "A $5,000 payment to every US adult would cost about $1.25 trillion. The government collected $195 billion in customs duties in FY2025. Net tariff revenue turned negative in some months of 2026 due to Supreme Court-ordered refunds. Analyses show tariffs cannot fund it." Taxfoundation.org

      Got that? There isn’t enough money to give every adult in America five large. It’s just not there, no matter how many times Donny clicks his bloated cankles together and wishes it were so."

      Delete
    2. Agree.

      Tariffs are a tax on American consumers, and they do not receive any refund.

      Still, some Americans are dumb enough to fall for the scam.

      Delete
    3. @2:48 I agree that tariffs are a tax on a country's citizens, but tariffs also protect local businesses and local jobs. That's why every country has tariffs and other protectionist measures. In fact, many countries have severe interference with importation of American goods.

      Delete
    4. None of this rescues Trump’s gibberish.

      Delete
    5. Thanks David. Now can you explain the strategy and formula used to maximize domestic industrial growth while minimizing the tax on US consumers? While you are at it, can you explain. the President abandoning his own recently agreed to trade policy with Mexico and Canada? No you can't, because your President is a toddler who shits his diapers. And breaks the law constantly fly while stuffing billions of ill begotten monies into his pockets. You folks are such weird cultists. Sad.

      Delete
    6. @6:06 - the explanation is simple: What Trump did worked. The US is indeed growing its manufacturing. The recently announced enormous steel mill is just the last in a huge number of projects that were motivated by the tariffs. More manufacturing means more good jobs, more prosperity, and more security in case of some breakdown in international trade.

      Delete
    7. David in Cal,
      Do us all a favor, and wait by your mailbox for the $5,000 check Trump promised you.

      Delete
  7. "...ww consider the need to heal"

    meanwhile we consider the need to proofread...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. People who fuck around and find out, like many right wingers, suddenly want to talk about healing.

      Sorry Somerby, we are all out of fucks for right wingers.

      They dug their own grave.

      Delete
  8. When Somerby talks about returning from Dalmatia, no one thinks he actually went there, so what lie is he trying to slyly advance? AI says one meaning of references to Dalmatia is this:

    "In older biblical commentaries, the Greek name for Dalmatia was sometimes mistranslated or glossed with symbolic or folk definitions like "deceitful", though it strictly denoted the Roman provincial district." Otherwise, the name refers to Sheep or "Land of Sheep". Next Somerby may be calling his readers Sheeple, like Limbaugh did. Or maybe Curtis Yarvin has assigned some meaning to the name.

    Or perhaps Somerby, in his dotage, just likes the name and thinks it would be clever to refer to an obscure place instead of admitting he was back in the hospital again, moving to an old folks home, or in bed with the flu.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Playing games with words is another way of obscuring meaning. In a time when there is so little agreement about what is true, fooling around has dangers. These cutesy references are annoying to me but may be confusing to others and we surely do not need more confusion in our country.

      Delete
    2. I’m so happy to see Bob. I don’t remember him being gone this long before and I was getting concerned.

      Delete
    3. Your performative concern is noted.

      Delete
    4. I remember him being gone this long. It was due to a medical problem.

      Delete
    5. Cecelia, do you send similar health-related messages of encouragement to Trump? That is how Natalie got her job. Think twice about it though. Changing an adult man's diapers is not as charming as changing a baby.

      Delete
    6. Anonymouse 2:01pm, moms and dads change diapers all the time and they never get expensive jewelry for it. I’m just doing it right.

      Delete
    7. Anonymouse 12:09pm, real concern always demands performance.

      Delete
    8. Dads change a lot fewer diapers than moms.

      Delete
    9. Next time a loved one is in the hospital, make sure to perform your concern by ensuring everyone sees how concerned you are.

      Delete
    10. Cecelia is a man pretending to be a woman.

      Nothing he says is genuine, or worth responding to.

      Delete
    11. Anonymouse 2:43pm, we can all settle for anonymices’ performative concern over my concern for Somerby. After all, you’ve offered up a butt-load.

      Delete
    12. Your performative concern for Somerby. It isn’t genuine.

      Delete
    13. Somerby said at some point he was working on another project, and it wasn’t medical related. But we all know how concerned “cecelia” was.

      Delete
    14. Anonymouse 3:00pm, but anonymouse animosity towards Somerby and the people who enjoy his work is the ugly, frank, and real thing.

      Delete
    15. I am old enough to remember Somerby showing no empathy, no pity, and no mercy in attacking horrible right wing journalist Michael Kelly after he died in the war that Kelly was gung ho in supporting.

      People have more fingers on one hand than the number of people that "enjoy" Somerby's "work".

      Delete
    16. Anonymouse 3:12pm, cute goal post repositioning and all… but there are other people here who don’t agree with Bob, but who have respect for him. Your highly performative, but low salaried anonymouse work- aside.

      Delete
    17. How can you "enjoy" lying and misinformation?

      Somerby is pretending he is the real James Bond:

      "Into the Lion’s Mouth: The True Story of Dusko Popov: World War II Spy, Patriot, and the Real-Life Inspiration for James Bond (Berkley Caliber), 2016.

      Whatever he really is, Somerby is not a good decent person. There is no reason for those of us who realize that to "enjoy" his work. Somerby has earned all the animosity directed toward him here. So have his various trolls, who are on the wrong side of history.

      There is no way for Somerby to propose healing without it being self-serving, because he has committed the propaganda wrongs that have upset those of us who are demanding that Trump go, now.

      I could make a list of Somerby's wrongs, but there should be no need, given that I have identified them in the moment over the years.

      Animosity is not wrong when it is justified by the ugly behavior of people here, especially Somerby. Failure to show animosity permits evil to thrive, just as it did in Hitler's reich. Animosity toward Somerby here is a sign of integrity.

      Delete
    18. Anonymouse 3:22pm, exactly. You’re not worried that someone is insincere in their esteem for Bob, you’re driven nuts by the fact they honestly like the guy.

      Delete
    19. Cecelia says: "real concern always demands performance." This is a contradiction in terms because the nature of performance is that it is not real, but simulated. Real concern evokes empathy and help, not a show put on for an audience.

      Delete
    20. Anonymouse 3:30pm, “real concern” can evoke all sorts of emotions, including negative ones. You are truly concerned over Somerby and this blog. Concerned enough to be part of an organization that promotes and pays for your sort of “performative” blogboard trolling service.

      Delete
    21. "Failure to show animosity permits evil to thrive, just as it did in Hitler's reich."

      There you have it. The Somerby-Haters are on a mission from God, smiting Evil Incarnate!

      Delete
    22. So, you are walking back the stupid remark you made? Even if you want to say that emotion motivates action, it doesn't always and you have no idea what you are taking about.

      I don't pay anything and I am paid nothing for writing responses to Somerby's idiocies. There is no "organization" on my side. You are perhaps reflecting your own situation?

      Delete
    23. DG, that was addressed to Cecelia, not you.

      But, one purpose of religion is to teach believers to lead moral lives, to know right from wrong. I do agrree that to the extent that Somerby haters are addressing evil, that is consistent with the preaching of many (if not all) religions. Whether evil is incarnate or it works through people is a matter of theology. I have not called any Republicans demons but I do believe that Trump is evil, as manifested by his words and actions. I also believe that one important function of society is to constrain evil by defining it, prosecuting and punishing evil-doers. God didn't tell me that Somerby is evil -- no one had to do that. Can you seriously say that you do not consider a man who raped a 13 year old to be evil? Have you even read any of the Epstein victim statements? These are not matters of political disagreement but of tolerating an evil man in a position of power without doing anything to remove him, while he continues to hurt people.

      Delete
    24. Trump's interactions with Epstein and his victims is only the most obvious example of Trump's evil. There are others, such as his violation of every single one of the 7 Deadly Sins (venal sins that send you to hell, according to Catholics). His blithe cancellation of aid programs worldwide, causing thousands of deaths without justification is evil. His lack of concern over bombing that Iranian girls school is evil -- that happened because he thinks his appointees should look good, not actually be able to do the jobs. Trump's persecution of immigrants is evil because it has nothing to do with any policy goal or paperwork violations much less criminal acts, but is a raw exercise of power, showing that his ICE troops can shoot protesters with impunity. Persecution of minorities as a display of power is evil (every dictator does it). Trump's cancellation of science-based research and monitoring of the environment is going to doom future Americans to unpleasant deaths due to warming and extreme weather. I expect air travel will disappear for everyday people. Ignoring the science that has made all of our lives better, is evil. Same for measles deaths, refusal to prepare for future pandemics, medical treatments and research, denial of medically necessary abortions, health insurance, and progress toward a better quality of life for all. Denying what we already had in place, is evil because there is no benefit to it for anyone. Not even DOGE.

      How do you justify defending Somerby when he ignores the huge amount of harm Trump does? I don't see how you can life with yourself.

      Delete
    25. The Trannytroll Ho gotta go!

      Delete
  9. Looking for that promised change in tone, but I can't find it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yup.

      Nearly impossible to unwind a right wing shift.

      Delete
  10. Mediaite's new conservative opinion writer Brad Slager is back with a column saying the BBC is calling nude fingernail colors virulently racist. Hint: the BBC didn't do that. This is more culture war nonsense invented by the right. This one is akin to Haitians eating cats and dogs in its made-up silliness.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Slager's a hack.

      Delete
    2. He is dishonest because of the way he attributed foolish "woke" ideas to the BBC that they did not express and likely didn't consider.

      Delete
    3. @1:41 - Sorry, but here are some specific quotes showing the BBC doing just that.

      The BBC is catching heat for an article suggesting unpainted nails is a white supremacist dog whistle, and an affront to communities of color.
      The outlet spoke to beauty journalist Kristina Rodulfo, who had no trouble connecting the seemingly innocuous beauty choice into a malicious act targeting communities of color.

      Bare nails, Rodulfo bafflingly claimed, “really promotes blankness and this kind of sameness and erasure of culture and identity that is so important to black and brown communities.”

      “They are often called elegant or tasteful, and these are often usually euphemisms that perpetuate white supremacist standards of beauty,” she continued.

      Rodulfo pointed the finger at “white women or celebrities” for perpetuating the fad, claiming they “often conflate class and taste with that bareness.”


      https://nypost.com/2026/09/28/world-news/bbc-roasted-for-linking-unpainted-fingernails-to-white-supremacy-in-woke-article/

      Delete
    4. No, there are attributions made by Slager. There are not BBC statements that they believe any of that is true. Go back and read the article more carefully.

      Rodulfo is not the BBC. She is one person looking for a moment in the spotlight, perhaps promoting her business. Or maybe she is a right wing fruitcake. She is not the beauty industry or the BBC or white women in general and she doesn't speak for women of color. She is a nutcase.

      For example, how bizarre is it that she would say that the words "elegant" or "tasteful" are euphemisms for white racism, perpetuating white supremacist standards of beauty. That is gonzo. It only serves Slager's desire to mock "woke" and the fact that he got a shill to speak nonsense that no one else believes changes nothing about this hit piece on the left.

      I hope Mediaite gets rid of him quickly. But this illustrates how the right creates culture war items in order to complain about blue America. This is as made up as the idea about Haitians eating cats and dogs and the idea that schools put litter boxes in their halls for furry students. Not real.

      Delete
    5. David is a DiC. And a coward.

      Delete
    6. @4:52 - unless I am missing something Rodulfo made these statements on the BBC. Are you drawing a distinction between what someone on the BBC said vs what the BBC said?

      Delete
  11. If Somerby cares about our American prairie heritage, he should be dismayed by Trump's opening of protected public lands to development, his removal of Buffalo from their histoic grazing plains, and his threat to build a baseball stadium in Grand Teton National Park (which includes both peaks and meadows where wildlife roam, deer and antelope, moose and yes, Buffalo).

    There are less than 600,000 people in the entire state of WY, including babies and grannies with no interest in baseball. There is no airport near the park to bring in teams, much less fans. The nearest town, Jackson, is prohibitively expensive for tourists, and the next closest, Laramie, is a college town with fewer than 30,000 residents. How will such an area support a baseball team, never mind fill a stadium? This is a huge boondoggle arising from Trump's ignorance of geography. Or he is yanking the chains of environmentalists, but also of patriots who are proud that the words of God Bless America are literal when it comes to wildlife and majestic views, currently unobstructed by fast food signs.

    Even if I didn't already hate Trump, this would do it for me. Other presidents who visited such areas went back to Washington determined to protect them from exploitation. Trump's instincts are different. This is the man who sees an unspoiled 13 year old and wants to rape her.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree. These are terrible ideas of Trump

      Delete
    2. Fuck you straight to hell, dickhead

      Delete
    3. Build it an they will come man. So David, these dirty cocksuckers are tearing up our cherished parks for profit. You gonna vote these corrupt mofos out?

      Delete
  12. Lying by individuals is encouraged by organizations and billionaires who will pay them to spread misinformation. We will need to remove those corrupting influences in order to clean up the widespread lying.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You talking about Missouri Senator Eric Schmidt? I mean you are talking about stupid Republican dipshit cultists, right?

      Delete

  13. I touch my asshole and I sniff my finger and I post a long retarded word-salad. My destiny is fulfilled!

    I am Corby.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. “Our investigation developed proof beyond a reasonable doubt that President Trump engaged in serious crimes against our nation. If asked whether to prosecute a former president today based on the same facts, I would do so regardless of whether that president was a Republican or a Democrat. The charges against President Trump were the result of the evidence.”

      — Former special counsel Jack Smith, quoted by Mediaite. in testimony before the U.S. Senate."

      When something stinks like this, it stinks.

      Delete
    2. Trump Stench is real.

      Delete
    3. How does Somerby or Cecelia imagine that Corby would be able to forgive them for their behavior here at this blog? It might seem like fun to bully others, but the victims do not forget and do not forgive, and many of them do get even. Trump is going down and no one is going to forgive him in the name of "healing" the way Somerby urges.

      Trolls only have a week or two to enjoy being trolls, given that the new AI.gov website is going to "out" them.

      Delete
  14. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Carville thinks it is OK that Peltola yells at her staff because no one should be in politics unless they are tough. I disagree. If a politician cannot handle their own stress without taking it out on their staff, THEY do not belong in politics.

      This idea that the function of underlings is to be abused when their bosses are in a bad mood, is unacceptable. When women are the targets of such abuse, it perpetuates stereotypes about women being emotional sponges whose job is to comfort their grown man-baby bosses (and husbands). That is called "emotional labor" and unless it is explicitly part of a person's job description, it is worker abuse.

      Peltola should apologize. Bullying is not OK in any workplace, for Republicans or Democrats. If Democrats care about workers, they should be sticking up for them in this situation, not agreeing with Carville, who is a major jerk himself.

      Delete
    2. Agree. Carville is a loon.

      Delete
  15. “we'll need to find ways to heal. 
    Are we aware of that challenge? How are we planning to do that?”

    Somerby asks this in the context of writing about Lincoln. In Lincoln’s day, the country was split apart, and as many as 750,000 people died. Healing had to wait until the war was over, and in Lincoln’s view, the war was over when the confederacy was crushed and the north had won. He contemplated healing and magnanimity as the victor; you can’t be magnanimous as the loser.

    Trump and the gop have rewarded corruption, lying, and unlawful acts, such as attempting to overturn a free and fair election. There will always be unscrupulous people in any society who seek power, and lying, corruption ,and lawbreaking are accelerants to that end. This is all on top of the enormous influence that money has on our politics.

    Perhaps Somerby should suggest some way forward, other than pitying Trump, cause that won’t cut it. You shouldn’t pity anyone or any political party engaged in corruption, lawbreaking, lying, and attempting to steal elections.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Too many right wing actions were motivated by "owning the libs". That stupid cage match for example and his destruction of Kennedy Center. The right deliberately provoked emotional responses in order please right wingers. How do you come back from that? There is no punishment of Trump, no apology he could make, that would remedy the destruction he has inflicted on our nation. And yes, that includes Trump's Epstein crimes, his racism, and what he has done to our schools. There is no way for him to make up for that. That's why there needs to be serious change in our nation, whether it pisses off the right or not. Republicans are complicit. Then need to atone too.

      Delete
    2. Biden is responsible for far more illegal acts than Trump. Biden encouraged around 10 million illegal immigrants to come here. He also allowed tens of millions to illegally stay here.

      Delete
    3. In his 4 years as President, Biden has encouraged around 10 million illegals to commit civil violations.
      Meanwhile, automobile company advertisements have encouraged over 40 million speeders to commit civil violations annually.

      Any non-Republicans out there, who can tell us if 10 million in 4 years is more than 40 million per year?

      Delete
    4. Illegal immigrants are harder workers and way more honest than Americans.
      Don't take my word for it. Ask any corporate hiring manager.

      Delete
    5. I am tired of providing facts about Biden when these zombie lies just come back. Somerby could moderate his blog but he doesn’t care. Why should any of us care about him?

      Delete
    6. Donald Trump is the kindest, bravest, warmest, most wonderful human being I've ever known in my life.

      Delete
    7. "In his 4 years as President, Biden has encouraged around 10 million illegals to commit civil violations."

      He did what now?

      Delete
    8. DiC is perfectly fine with Trump and his corrupt family and his cabinet goons tripling their wealth at our expense, lying about everything, as long as those brown people suffer. Trump and the gop have shat over everything they claimed to believe in: fiscal responsibility, family values, honesty, good governance, democracy, etc. And yet, here’s DiC. It’s almost as if they never believed any of that.

      Delete
    9. Hundreds of thousands of our neighbors kidnapped by our Government. Never forget

      Delete
    10. America hating Republican leadership and media screamed that the border was open as a strategy to hurt Biden. It's all you heard from your lying media you dipshits.

      Delete
    11. You're half right, @4:54. "Improper entry into the United States is considered a crime, specifically a misdemeanor, while unlawful presence is not a crime but a civil violation."

      Delete
    12. Trump is the least popular president since polling was introduced. He is a narcissistic ghoul interested only in himself. You should be ashamed DiC. But you aren’t capable of that. Your so called conservative principles turned out to be absolute lies.

      Delete
    13. Trump is deporting people who have the legal right to be here. What crime is that?

      Delete
  16. Somerby seems amazed with admiration that Lincoln cared for his family and told stories.

    That is a remarkably low bar.

    Somerby keeps trying to be abstract in pushing his right wing agenda, but it keeps failing. He is howling at the moon.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Even Tucker Carlson has a story now about Trump's nihilism.

    MTG is spilling the tea too.

    Trump is going to die, we all do, but he is killing the GOP as well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The GOP is a collection of interests. They can't be killed. It's kind of like people thinking the collapse of the NRA would end, or even weaken, the gun lobby's power in Washington. The gun nuts + the gun manufacturers just shift to and create other outlets to press their agenda.

      Delete
    2. Interests include Trump before Party, Party before Country.

      Delete
  18. At least today Somerby is not doing his usual whining about how Gutfeld is bad for Republican branding.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Perhaps all this healing nonsense is Somerby's way of frightening Trump's red voters into voting red in order to prevent the blue retribution that is surely coming.

    But it isn't about revenge. It is about righting the wrongs against the American people wrought by Trump's cuts and policy changes and mean-spirited decrees. If red voters are only motivated by self-preservation (avoiding blue change) then they are not particularly noble people either. But that is an important difference between reds and blues. We blues are motivated by the common good whereas reds are motivated by greed and self-preservation. When Trump stops protecting right wingers, there is no reason why we should be particularly nice to them, unless they want to expreess contrition and change their ways.

    ReplyDelete

  20. I touch my asshole and I lick my finger. And I post more retarded word-salads.

    Look at me, please look at me! Please-please-please look at me!

    I am Corby.

    ReplyDelete