What is Bill Keller talking about!

MONDAY, AUGUST 19, 2013

Persistently, the New York Times simply defies belief: Bill Keller’s column didn’t appear in today’s hard-copy New York Times. For that reason, we hadn’t seen it until we saw Paul Krugman’s link.

We clicked the link and started reading. In paragraph 5, we hit this:
KELLER (8/19/13): [The Common Core] is an ambitious undertaking, and there is plenty of room for debate about precisely how these standards are translated into classrooms. But the Common Core was created with a broad, nonpartisan consensus of educators, convinced that after decades of embarrassing decline in K-12 education, the country had to come together on a way to hold our public schools accountable. Come together it did—for a while.
“After decades of embarrassing decline in K-12 education?” Which decades is Keller talking about?

There is, of course, no perfect way to measure educational attainment. But it’s astounding to see a person like Keller making a statement like that without any apparent sense that it needs explaining.

Every journalist at Keller’s paper—and he was in charge of the paper through 2011—cites the National Assessment of Educational Progress (the NAEP) as the “gold standard” of educational testing. But the NAEP shows very large gains in reading and math over the last several decades. As a general matter, American students have shown similar progress on international tests, although the NAEP goes back farther. (It dates to 1971.)

We’ve often said this about the NAEP: Everybody praises the NAEP, and no one ever reports what the NAEP data show. Meanwhile, every hack and his low-IQ uncle has spent the last X numbers of years moaning about the alleged decline in our public schools—even though NAEP data, which everyone swears by, seem to show precisely the opposite.

Bill Keller was executive editor of the Times until September 2011! Concerning this basic part of American life, he seems to have no idea what he’s talking about.

There’s nothing especially new about that. This is a persistent general fact about your “press corps.”

To Keller’s credit, his headline rhymes. War on the Core, his headline skillfully says.

56 comments:

  1. I was appalled when I read Krugman and then Keller. They just do not know the data.

    ReplyDelete
  2. All of TDH's criticism of Keller is on target. Even so, that's the best column Keller's ever written.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I took a look at the standards for probability and statistics. If high school students can really grasp that stuff, it will be terrific. There are some subtle and important things on that curriculum.

    I think it will be a challenge to get teachers able to teach that stuff effectively and for students to really understand it. I taught some of that material to adult students who were going to night school at Fairly Dickenson University to get a Masters degree in Computer Science. Many of them were able to do the problems mechanically, but didn't really understand it.

    I don't know why a novel approach should be introduced countrywide. It would be safer to try it in a few locations. If it works well, other locations can switch to it. If it doesn't work or if it needs to be modified, then only those few locations would be messed up.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Ourfailingschools has become one word because it is repeated so often by the corporate run media, the privatizers and all the billionaires who want to dismantle our public school system because, well, they hate public schools, they hate the whole idea of a commons and a common good funded by tax dollars. Though most of this anti public school crap was hatched by right wing libertarians, both parties are on board for the CC, charter schools and school vouchers. Obama's Race to the Top is an abomination just as bad as Bush's NCLB. Cory Booker is just as bad as Chris Christie when it comes to public education. Both political parties are beholden to the money of the billionaires like Gates, Broad, Dell, Tudor, DeVos, Bezos, Icann, the Waltons, etc.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Whoops, I meant to say (Carl Celian) Icahn, not Icann, my bad.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Poo Poo Platter (What are Bill AND BOB Talking About?)

    Yep, that is quite an error Keller made statistically based on the NAEP analysts at sprawling TDH U. (which is not to be confused with Fairly Dickinson (sp.... We all not it is Fairly Dickensian U.,David in Cal).

    Unfortunately, whilst whittling down the trees as Bob sees 'em, he missed the damned forest again. Neither Keller or Somerby mention the real reason Common Core was adopted, which had nothing to do with the measurement of acheivement on standardized testing at the grade levels sampled by NAEP.

    And of course, in his effort to point out Keller's stupidity, Somerby overlooks the larger issue of stupidity which is what Keller's column focuses upon.

    I am sure someone will complain I am nitpicking the head nitpicker again.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What was the real reason Common Core was adopted?

      Delete

    2. It is hard to do justice to your question and be brief. This will be oversimplified, but I hope responsive.

      The decentralized education system of the United States was not producing enough high school graduates and those it was producing were not adequately prepared with the skill sets needed for future employment or success in higher education. In essence the American education system was not responding to the changes in the economy. If you look at all the documents used in the organizations that developed the Common Core you will find little reference to our "declining" education system based on testing at elementary or early secondary levels. Instead there was a desire to have a uniform curriculum that generated a measurable level of competence in pursuit of a goal of having universal high school graduation with a degree that qualified you to succeed in college or find a meaningul job with opportunties to advance.

      PPP


      Delete
  7. Thanks for this interesting records. I love studying and getting statistics from this blog. Article writing is a notable art and we all attempt to have the first-class writing but now not all of the humans are of the same excellent of their writing
    Mumbai escorts Mumbai escorts

    ReplyDelete
  8. Amazing articles We only essentially will will possess to need to various thanks for the Mumbai Escorts undertakings you have got designed in producing this fascinating

    ReplyDelete
  9. It provides an opportunity to acquire a better experience. With us you may surely likely to have a really memorable experience. Independent escorts Jodhpur provides you an offer of online booking from which you are able to readily communicate with our escorts to discuss your curiosity with her prior to availing the ceremony.
    Jodhpur call girls
    Udaipur escorts
    Goa Call Girls
    Jaipur Call Girls

    ReplyDelete
  10. Free classifieds in india - Schloka. Post Free ads For All over Cities of india with Escorts And Call Girls category. and Find Here Perfect Escorts Girls Just one Click in all Over India With Schloka.

    Kolkata Escorts
    Goa Escorts
    Ahmedabad Escorts
    Gurgaon Escorts
    Noida Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hello guys! Welcome to Neha Chopra luxurious and pleasurable Independent Russian Escorts Gurgaon . Our tempting Gurgaon Escort Service is always to serve you and make you astonish with some unbelievable attributes. No doubt you are going to spend your quality time with some of the best Russian Escorts Gurgaon.
    Escort Girls Service
    Escort Service In Delhi
    Mumbai Escorts Service
    Call Girl In Chennai
    Call Girl In Hyderabad
    Call Girl In Bangalore
    Our Partner : Refrigerator Repair Service

    ReplyDelete
  12. Love for me and my escorts’ girls sure to full fun we provide all type of escorts girls like collage escorts girls, housewife escorts girls, model escorts girls and airhostess girls with best price.
    Call Girls Escorts in Mumbai

    Call Girls in Hyderabad

    Call Girls in Hyderabad

    Call Girls Jalandhar

    Call Girl service in Chandigarh

    ReplyDelete
  13. I was waiting for such a post, I read your post, the content in it is very unique, thank you, I will be reading your post even further, good luck.
    Home Cleaning Products Indian Exporters
    Home Decorations Wholesale Exporters
    Tableware Cutlery Manufacturers
    Smoking Accessories wholesale Suppliers

    ReplyDelete
  14. If you looking for Hot and beautiful girls from Chandigarh. I am Nikita Rawat an independent female Escort in Chandigarh. You can call me if you want best girlfriend experience without any boundaries in a 5-star hotel or private room. Just call me at once and take my Escorts service In Chandigarh and feel the heaven.
    https://www.akshitasen.net/chandigarh-escorts.html

    ReplyDelete

  15. I am incapable of reading articles online very often, but I’m happy I did today. It is very well written, and your points are well-expressed. I request you warmly, please, don’t ever stop writing.

    Read More:-

    Satta king

    ReplyDelete
  16. If you want more details ,info and winner list of previous Satta King , then read more on SattaKing - All Info Leaked Code And Full Guide

    ReplyDelete
  17. I got wonderful information from your blog, I have been looking at this type of blog for quite a time. ​Thanks for share with us.
    Escorts Service Mumbai

    VIP Nerul Escorts

    Ghatkopar Call Girls

    Escorts in Panvel

    Call Girls in Belapur

    ReplyDelete
  18. If you are all ready for the same sorts of Gandhinagar escorts service then you have to ensure that you can take up the enjoyable Gandhinagar escorts service provides according to the requirement and demands as well.
    Gandhinagar Escorts Service

    ReplyDelete
  19. I am an alluring however a typical call girl in Delhi with the searches to not be taken lightly in Delhi and acting as a customer help official during a heading organization yet might want to not unveil my authority work obviously once i'm persuaded you're genuine.

    ReplyDelete
  20. If you are in Jammu, you should definitely hire Jammu Call Girls as they are the main ones who can save you the burden of desolation. They are extraordinary arbitrary girls of the close gender, but they are extraordinarily hot and playful Indian women and they are happy to go beyond conventional administrations to satisfy you both sincerely and intellectually.
    VIP call girls service in Jammu

    Female call girls service in Jammu

    best escort service in Jammu

    House wife call girls service in Jammu

    VIP call girls service in Jammu

    Female call girls service in Jammu

    best escort service in Jammu

    Cheap call girls in Jammu

    Model call girls in Jammu

    ReplyDelete
  21. To be linked to Escorts in City would be fine enough for you all since they have got a fine range of experience in this mentioned sector.

    Ahmedabad EscortS
    Call Girls in Ahmedabad
    Escorts Service in Ahmedabad
    Ahmedabad Escort

    ReplyDelete

  22. Moga be the most important journey of love for you all to remain in close relation to our darlings here.

    Moga Escorts
    Call Girls in Moga
    Escorts Service in Moga
    Call Girls in Moga

    ReplyDelete
  23. Patna service in City are some of the best of professionals to be hired into the lovemaking times. An incredible level of attachment you are ensured to benefit being in relation to anyone of these darlings

    FOLLOWS:-

    Patna Escorts
    Escort Service in Patna
    Patna Call Girl in Service
    Call Girl Service in Patna
    Escort Service in Patna

    ReplyDelete
  24. Mysore programs you wish to have the girls at our agency in arms, they are ready to face the challenges.

    Mysore Escorts
    Call Girl in Escorts Mysore
    Escort Service in Mysore
    Mysore Call Girl in Service

    ReplyDelete
  25. Get cheap independent Call Girls Services in Mumbai at affordable rates in Maharashtra. A debt of feeling is therefore as for visiting and taking High Profile Escorts Service in Mumbai anyplace in Maharashtra isn't anyone in Escorts Services. A leading firm of escorts who provide client satisfaction and desire at low rates close to me.
    Call Girls in Andheri

    Call Girls in Bandra

    Call Girls in Borivali

    Call Girls in Navi Mumbai

    Call Girls in Thane

    Call Girls in Juhu

    Call Girls in Powai

    Call Girls in Navi Mumbai

    Call Girls in Vashi

    ReplyDelete
  26. Hello, my name is Riya Salvani and I am a 23-year-old independent call girl. A hot and affectionate woman who is simple but beautiful and good at what I do. I am clean, sensible and would like to tend to your needs in bed,
    Call girl WhatsApp
    personal service
    Dating
    Relationship
    Call girls
    Call girl
    Female
    Call girls for party
    Hotel call girls
    Model
    Incall girls
    Outcall girls
    Escort service
    Female call girls service
    Erotic massage
    Call girls number
    Call girl number
    Call girls WhatsApp
    Call girl WhatsApp
    personal service

    ReplyDelete
  27. Mysore programs you wish to have the girls at our agency in arms, they are ready to face the challenges.

    Mysore Escorts
    Mysore Escort
    Call Girl in Mysore
    Mysore in girl Service
    Mysore in Escort Service

    ReplyDelete
  28. Independent Kondapur escorts function for themselves and their customers and do not intend to encounter any kind of pandering or intermediary. Most of the ladies are from Pan India, but you can find condapsur escorts from Hyderabad. Hyderabd accompanies service tours in Hyderabad, availability may vary. Banjara hills escorts
    Hyderabad escorts
    Somajiguda escorts
    Kondapur escorts
    Gachibowli escorts
    Jubilee hills escorts
    Bangalore escorts

    ReplyDelete
  29. Super-P-Force is an excellent combination of powerful drugs like Sildenafil Citrate and Dapoxetine. This drug combination is highly effective in relieving erectile dysfunction and even premature ejaculation. Super P Force has unbelievably helped several men combating premature ejaculation and ED disorders. This drug consists of an active component Sildenafil Citrate 100mg and Dapoxetine 60 mg which delays ejaculations and also provide erection for suffice time.
    Extra Super P Force 200mg is a new form of hybrid combination treatment for erectile dysfunction and premature ejaculation. Containing the active ingredients Sildenafil Citrate and Dapoxetine, patients can experience a healthy erection and more control over the length of intercourse. Dapoxetine is clinically proven and approved in many countries to treat premature ejaculation and allows intercourse to last longer.
    The active ingredients of Super P-force are Sildenafil Citrate and Dapoxetine. Sildenfil Citrate belongs to the PDE-5 family of vasodilators.

    Super P Force Oral Jelly is an excellent combination of powerful drugs like Sildenafil Citrate and Dapoxetine. This drug combination is highly effective in relieving erectile dysfunction and even premature ejaculation. Super P Force has unbelievably helped several men combating premature ejaculation and ED disorders. This drug consists of an active component Sildenafil Citrate 100mg and Dapoxetine 60 mg which delays ejaculations and also provide erection for suffice time.

    ReplyDelete
  30. I am looking for this informative post thanks for share it red tiger ทางเข้า

    ReplyDelete
  31. Find the best aluminium sliding doors manufactured by AGV System and here you can get also the latest designs of aluminium windows and doors.

    Visit here

    lift and slide door manufacturers

    ReplyDelete
  32. Kamagra 50 is an effective and potent medicine that helps enhance sensual functioning in men. Sildenafil 50mg is the active substance of the medicine.

    Email : sales@rsmenterprises.in
    Chat on WhatsApp with +91 9216325377

    Sildenafil 50mg
    Kamagra 50mg
    Mens Performance Pills Cheap Price

    ReplyDelete
  33. If you have erectile dysfunction or impotence, there is a remedy available to overcome this problem. It's a tadarise 10 pills. Tadalafil tadarise 10 acts as an active ingredient in tablets. This tablet works by increasing blood flow to the penile area and maintaining an erection during sexual intercourse. Tadarise 10 pills is proven to be the best ad drug mainly by men suffering from ED. Alcohol should not be consumed while taking this medicine.

    ReplyDelete
  34. There are many erection medications available if you are hoping to fix erection problems. The best and most effective of these is fildena 150mg!! A very good result can be achieved by taking this medicine only once. This drug increases the blood flow in the blood vessels in the penis of men and enables them to have longer sex with their partner with a strong erection during sexual activity. This drug usually gives effective results within 24-36 hours. This drug is usually the best medicine to be taken by men between the ages of 18 and 65. This drug helps you to enjoy their amazing sex life by removing your sexual problem very quickly.

    ReplyDelete
  35. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Luckily, the side effects normally vanish in a couple of hours. Learning and memory capability might be impacted for a delayed time frame period even after different impacts wear off.
    Order Bud Online

    ReplyDelete
  37. Narcolepsy is a Sleep problem that causes unnecessary daytime tiredness. Waklert 150 impacted individual might encounter exorbitant languor, Sleep loss of motion, visualizations, and now and again episodes of cataplexy (fractional or absolute loss of muscle control).

    Take this medication in the portion and term as exhorted by your PCP. Gulp down it as an entire. Try not to bite, pound or break it. Modalert 200 Tablet might be taken regardless of food, yet taking it at a proper time is better.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Artvigil 150 is a drug planned to build sharpness and alertness. It helps decrease unreasonable tiredness brought about by rest problems like narcolepsy, and obstructive rest apnea. It is likewise gainful for the people hoping to support their focus due to work requests. Waklert 150 is utilized in the treatment of unnecessary daytime lethargy (narcolepsy). It further develops alertness and assists you with remaining conscious and decreases the propensity to nod off during the day, hence re-establishing the typical rest cycle.

    ReplyDelete
  39. You can likewise save the document to your PC for sometime in the future. You can download pdftoolonline for nothing and attempt it for seven days. After the time for testing, you can restore your membership through online re-energizes. On the other hand, you can download the EPS arrangement executable record. You can likewise print the edited delivery Meesho label crop from your PDF solicitations with the free PDF driver programming.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Cenforce is efficient sufficient in treating Erectile Dysfunction or impotence however it's also beneficial in curing benign prostatic hypertrophy or other blood circulate-associated problems.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Erectile dysfunction (ED) is a very common problem for many men. This condition affects both their sex life and their relationships. It can also lead to serious health problems.
    Cenforce 100mg is a drug that can help treat ED. This medication contains sildenafil citrate and is effective in treating ED in most patients. It works by blocking an enzyme that breaks down cGMP in the blood vessels around the penis.
    Read More: Cenforce 150mg

    ReplyDelete
  42. Fildena 150 mg comes in the form of oral tablets. The standard dosage is one tablet taken orally with a full glass of water, approximately 30 minutes to 1 hour before sexual activity. It is important to follow the prescribed dosage and not exceed it unless directed by your doctor. Do not take more than one tablet within a 24-hour period.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Lipika provide best massage & is designed to relax you and reduce your stress. Deep breathing can increase the relaxation effect.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Your comfort and safety are my top priorities, and I will adjust my techniques accordingly to ensure a safe and effective massage.

    ReplyDelete