MONDAY, MAY 11, 2026
Attention should be paid: Putting it mildly, the New York Times' Nicholas Kristof is in the middle of a very distinctive journalistic career.
Routinely, he describes the world we actually live in. With apologies for what follows, so it is today. Headline included, his essay starts as shown:
The Silence That Meets the Rape of Palestinians
It’s a simple proposition: Whatever our views of the Middle East conflict, we should be able to unite in condemning rape.
Supporters of Israel made that point after the brutal sexual assaults against Israeli women during the Hamas-led attack on Israel on Oct. 7, 2023. Donald Trump, Joe Biden, Benjamin Netanyahu and many U.S. senators, including Marco Rubio, condemned that sexual violence, and Netanyahu rightly called on “all civilized leaders” to “speak up.”
And yet in wrenching interviews, Palestinians have recounted to me a pattern of widespread Israeli sexual violence against men, women and even children—by soldiers, settlers, interrogators in the Shin Bet internal security agency and, above all, prison guards.
There is no evidence that Israeli leaders order rapes. But in recent years they have built a security apparatus where sexual violence has become, as a United Nations report put it last year, one of Israel’s “standard operating procedures” and “a major element in the ill treatment of Palestinians.” A report out last month, from the Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor, a Geneva-based advocacy group often critical of Israel, concludes that Israel employs “systematic sexual violence” that is “widely practiced as part of an organized state policy.”
That's the way today's essay starts. The testimony by victims, named and unnamed, begins after that. We suppose we should include some such material as this:
[Continuing directly from above]
What does this standard operating procedure look like? Sami al-Sai, 46, a freelance journalist, says that as he was being taken to a prison cell after his detention in 2024, a group of guards threw him to the ground.
“They were all hitting me, and one stepped on my head and neck,” he said. “Someone pulled my pants down. They pulled down my boxers.” And then one of the guards pulled out a rubber baton used to beat prisoners.
“They were trying to force it into my rectum, and I was bracing myself to prevent it, but I couldn’t,” he said, speaking with increasing anxiety. “It was so painful.” The guards were laughing at him, he said. “Then I heard someone say, ‘Give me the carrots,’” he recalled, adding that they then used a carrot. “It was extremely painful,” he said. “I was praying for death.”
And so on at length from there. This too is part of the world.
We're reminded of a discussion we had with a person whose memory we treasure when we were both 17. The topic that day was this:
If a person knows that suffering is happening around the world, doesn't that person have an obligation to go off into the world and try to address it?
We didn't want the answer to be yes, but it seemed to us that it was.
That was the spring of 1965. The eucalyptus trees would have been extremely fragrant. This next connection is much more recent:
Why have some young people, perhaps on college campuses, sometimes seemed to be less sympathetic to Israel (at least as Israel currently functions), and more "pro-Palestinian," than their elders may tend to be?
Several years ago, we suggested a possible answer. It could be that the younger people know certain things about that endlessly tragic situation that their elders may not know.
(Teach your parents well, the famous song suggested.)
The younger people may know things that their parents don't! That doesn't mean that the younger people will have perfect judgment concerning the things they know because, of course, they won't.
Nicholas Kristof is off in the world! Also, as we all know, reports like his long report today will almost always lead nowhere.
I wish Somerby felt half this much concern when women are raped.
ReplyDeleteWhere was Somerby’s “concern” before Israel invaded Iran?
ReplyDeleteSomerby says this now, but he hid from the world after college, draft dodging, fleeing to hide out with children in Baltimore where he still lives.
ReplyDeleteKristof presents an all too common view. The Palestinians can commit thousands of unthinkable atrocities and he quickly passes by them. But, the Israelis must be perfect.
ReplyDeleteThe moral difference between Israel and the Palestinians could not be more stark. That should be the overwhelming content of the story. Tell me about Israeli atrocities after you've written a thousand columns about Palestinian atrocities.
Really? You think the criticism here is that the Israelis have not been "perfect"?
DeleteI don’t think they are perfect. I’ll give them a B+ for running an apartheid state and previously running an open air prison of Palestinians in the now rubble that is Gaza, while juggling that with the difficult task of violently driving West Bank Palestinian farmers from their land. A solid B+ but you could talk me into an A with a few more atrocities.
DeleteDiC rejects any discussion revolving around times when Israel isn’t perfect. I’m beginning to suspect he simply doesn’t care when Palestinians suffer.
DeleteDavid the dolt again seizes on the best solution, neverending war to get even.
DeleteWanton rape falls slightly short of perfection? Got it.
DeleteApropos of nothing, some years ago I got to thinking why in Judaism the Jewish identity is conferred matrilineally. My thought was that back in the day, Israeli tribes wanted to be able to rape the women of the conquered tribes without taking ownership of the children. I guess it's still playing out in today's day and age.
First of all I am not convinced that "sexual violence has become, as a United Nations report put it last year, one of Israel’s “standard operating procedures” and “a major element in the ill treatment of Palestinians." The UN is notoriously biased against Israel. There is no documentary evidence of this supposed policy.
DeleteRegardless, the thousands of bad things done by Palestinians toward Israelis and toward other Palestinians and good things done by Israel toward the Palestinians get far too little attention, such as
-- the thousands of Israeli casualties from unpremeditated suicide bombings
-- Each of the1,000+ Oct 6 atrocities -- atrocities that WERE the official acts of the government.
-- the subjugation of millions of Palestinian women by Palestinian men.
-- the murder of gay Palestinians
-- deaths of Palestinians because Hamas purposely built military installations in hospitals and schools.
OTOH there are
-- hundreds or thousands of Palestinians who received medical treatment from Israeli doctors and hospitals.
--Gay Palestinians fortunate enough to live in Israel where they're free from harassment.
--Obviously all the Palestinian citizens of Israel who have full rights. The only right a Jew has in Gaza is the right to be killed.
Yes, wanton rape should be criticized IF it's actually happening. But, more attention should be given to the literally thousands of good things done by Israel. none of them reciprocated. And, the millions of dreadful things done by Palestinians to Israelis and to other Palestinians.
"... the millions of dreadful things done by Palestinians to Israelis and to other Palestinians."
DeleteSame could apply to whites.
There is no good reason why people shouldn't criticize American citizens for having a much higher crime rate than immigrants.
DeleteDiC - You'll deign to concede that a "standard operating procedure" of "wanton rape" would be deserving of "criticism," but you don't believe this widespread raping is actually happening, despite the horrendous reports by independent observers such as UN investigators or Nicholas Kristoff. So you feel we instead should be talking about the "thousands of good things done by Israel."
DeleteOK, shall we talk about how Israel conned Trump into joining it in an unprovoked and unjust war on Iran, dragging all of us down into a quagmire that may yet damn the world to a great depression?
There is no good reason to talk about the crime rate among immigrants. Legal immigrants are a different class of people than illegal immigrants. Separate rates should be shown for each of these two groups.
DeleteWhen you look at crime stats for legal and illegal immigrants separately, the crime rates are even lower for the illegals, because they do not want to draw attention to themselves and be deported because they have no legal status. This is the opposite of what you keep claiming about them, for the period 2012-2018. It changed slightly for 2024-2026, not because undocumented people were committing more crimes but because they were being incarcerated more due to ICE activities. Their crime rate remains about half that of native born people.
Deletehttps://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/fact-sheet/debunking-myth-immigrants-and-crime/
Cops in NYC were committing those kinds of rapes on immigrants back before Trump was elected to anything. Rape has long been an act of war. Somerby quotes in in Homer, but it also occurred in WWII on the border between Russia and Germany, in the Pacific theater, and by white settlers against Indians. Men rape as an act of aggression against both men and women. If you want to talk about why men consider their appendages to be weapons, fine with me. Women have been on the receiving end since the beginning of recorded time.
DeleteThink about prison rapes, David.
DeleteGeorge - We should talk about Israel's good things "in addition" not "instead" of the bad things. And, as I said, we should talk about all the bad things done by Palestinians.
DeleteIn other words, there's a huge double standard. E.g., we would all be horrified if Israelis treated a single Palestinian woman as badly as Palestinian men treat millions of Palestinian women all the time.
What kind of bad thing would justify being raped in this manner David?
DeleteAre you suggesting that Palestinian women are raped all the time? Do you have a source for that lie?
I am saying that Palestinian women are treated as second class citizens or even as sub-citizens
DeleteAI says, "Gender-based violence & protection: Domestic violence, child marriage, and honor-related abuses occur; reporting is limited by stigma, weak legal remedies, and scarce support services (shelters, legal aid), though local women’s groups and international agencies provide some assistance."
Child marriage is legal in 34 of our 50 states. The Republican states (red states) have the worst rates of domestic abuse in the USA and the least support services for abused women. The recent elimination of abortion in Republican states has caused increased maternal deaths due to inablity to obtan care for miscarriages and pregnancies threatening the mother's health to the point of death.
DeleteIt is astonishing that you would use these important women's issues to attack Palestine without caring what happens to women in the USA.
It’s fucking fascinating. As a Jewish Zionist atheist, DiC religiously supports white Christian nationalism, putting women in their biblical place
Delete@7:53 - No, the treatment of women in the US is not the same as the treatment of women in most Islamic communities, such as Gaza. I urge you to do your own research.
DeleteGive rapist Pistol Pete Hegseth time, dickhead, he’s only been on the job a year.
DeleteWhat kind of RINO thinks rape is a bad thing?
DeleteMAGA is all about women’s rights in an Islamic country but fully endorse DOGE cuts to humanitarian aid that will kill millions of children while Trump and his lackeys hit the US taxpayer up for a billion dollars to fund one of his vanity projects. It’s all performative bullshit for them. They are not serious people.
DeleteI am offended by white Christian Nationalists subjugation of white women.
DeleteI am offended by rapists running the government and the pentagon, shit for brains
Delete"we should be able to unite in condemning rape"
ReplyDeletejudging by the first four comments I guess we can't.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletePolymarket: Republicans surge past Democrats in Senate midterm odds, projected to remain in power.
ReplyDeleteMeanwhile, the odds that a Republican voter who isn't a bigot will be named is still 0%.
DeleteBetting markets don't have answers about anything before it happens. Odds are not predictions. They are statistics that fluctuate based on how those betting are placing their money.
Delete42% of Democrats - nearly half the party - believe the Trump assassination attempt in Butler was staged.
ReplyDeleteThis 42% of Democrats are mentally ill. There are many more mentally ill Democrats whose mental illness and delusion leads them to other ridiculous, faulty conclusions, but this is just one poll of a subset.
The party of violence and mental illness.
Trump:
DeleteThe boy who cried "Assassination".
Of course it was staged.
DeleteWhat kind of person would waste a valuable bullet on a piece of shit like Trump?
People don't trust the man who lies about every single thing. How the fuck could that happen?
Delete68% of Republicans think the 2020 election was rigged.
Delete47% of Republicans think COVID epidemic was planned.
31% of Republicans are more afraid of vaccines than the diseases they prevent.
75% of Republicans think white people are victims of racial discrimination.
76% of Republicans think climate change will have little or no effect on their communities.
lies
DeletePoll results might be embarrassing to Republicans but that doesn't make them lies. Real people answered the questions.
DeleteOnly feasible conclusion, Rebubs are the biggest fucking idiots on 🌎
DeleteCriminal behavior can't be controlled
ReplyDeleteof topic, dork
Delete"The White House social media team lashed out at a Reuters correspondent who shared a photo of President Donald Trump with his eyes closed.
ReplyDeleteFollowing a White House event on Monday, Reuters correspondent Idrees Ali posted a photo in which the president appeared to be resting his eyes.
"U.S. President Donald Trump attends a maternal health event in the Oval Office at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., May 11, 2026. REUTERS/Evelyn Hockstein," he wrote."
Would he sleep through an event discussing rape? Perhaps only if his name was not mentioned.
"President Donald Trump may have just said the quiet part out loud about his plans to rig the 2026 midterm elections, according to one analyst.
ReplyDeleteDavid Pakman, host of the liberal "David Pakman Show" on YouTube, argued in a new reaction video on Monday that Trump recently admitted in a "completely derranged" Truth Social post that he plans on militarizing polling places during the November election.
"During my Historic Election in 2024, when I won every single Swing State, and decisively won both the Electoral and Popular votes by wide margins, the Republicans had an Election Integrity Army in every single State to preserve the sanctity of each legal vote," Trump wrote in the Truth Social post that Pakman referenced. "We will be doing the same again in 2026, but it will be much bigger and stronger. All Americans should have their voices be heard by casting a vote. Be assured this Election will be fair!"
Pakman noted that the post seemed to suggest that Trump is planning on deploying another "election integrity army" ahead of the upcoming elections.
"The point of this is just to intimidate people," Pakman said. "It's to scare people, people who show up and they plan to vote, and then all of a sudden they're going to see this election integrity army, as Donald Trump is calling it. And Trump is hoping that this will, I guess, scare some people so that they won't vote."
Pakman pointed out that Trump and his Republican colleagues are underwater on several key issues as the election approaches, such as immigration and Trump's handling of the economy. That could help explain why the Republicans are not pushing back against Trump's plans, he added.
"They realize, as a result, they have to run a different election, and that is exactly what they're doing," Pakman said. "They are just going to run on, 'We're going to intimidate at the polling places.' No more talk about improving your lives, more talk about controlling the election. We can't let them get away with it." [Rawstory]
Digby describes Trump's treatment of a tenant back in 1980. As she points out, Trump has always been a monster. A case like this would disqualify any candidate for office because it shows unftness for office. I do not understand why Republicans are willing to tolerate stuff like this, and the ICE excesses and the mistreatment of govt employees by DOGE and all of the other awful behavior exhibited by Noem, Patel, Hegseth, Bondi, and Trump's other appointees, who are just as bad as he is.
ReplyDeletehttps://digbysblog.net/2026/05/11/he-was-always-this-way/
Today Trump sleeps through a meeting about maternal health issues. How are Republicans, and guys like Somerby, able to stomach this man's unfitness for office?
You don't understand why racists treat minorities like shit? Really? It's their credo.
DeleteSomerby doesn't care about racism in our country, so he pretends to care about Kristoff's essay on Palestine. He isn't fooling anyone with this. From Rawstory:
ReplyDelete"Rep. Jen Kiggans (R-VA), already one of the GOP's most vulnerable incumbents even after state courts struck down efforts to redraw her district to favor Democrats, landed in hot water on Monday after a clip went viral of her agreeing with a right-wing talk radio host telling Rep. Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY) to "get your cotton-picking hands off of Virginia" — a common colloquial phrase, but one with a deeply charged double meaning given that Jeffries is Black.
The moment immediately brought her under fire on social media, including from some fellow members of Congress.
"The hood is off," wrote Rep. Grace Meng (D-NY). "Apologize and get out or you will be shown the door in November."
"First, they gutted the Voting Rights Act," wrote Rep. Katherine Clark (D-MA). "Now they are using brazenly racist language to attack Black leaders. @JenKiggans should immediately apologize and resign."
"Hey, so what the f---?" wrote Texas-based Democratic youth activist Olivia Julianna.
"They keep proving Black folks were right all along about what MAGA really means underneath the branding," wrote strategist Christopher Webb."
if you ask this question you know NO GOP history
ReplyDeleteSomerby drags up Palestine and atrocities in order to distract from the blatently racist behavior of Republicans as they attempt to destroy fair districting under the guise of pretending it is racist when black people get to vote as a district, instead of being split up so that their votes are diluted by those of white people outside their communities.
ReplyDeleteThis is just like the way Republicans use other issues to distract from issues such as the Epsten files, of great concern to women and those of good character, but threatening to the right wing men who were Epstein's buddies, including men now serving in Trumps' administration.
Why not come out and say it: Somerby's post is racist and he's a racist for posting it to cover up the racist redistricting.
DeleteHey I hit the trifecta!
"Somerby's post is racist and he's a racist for posting it to cover up the racist redistricting."
DeleteDon't worry, some Somerby fanboy will be by shortly to let us know he's not really a Conservative.
Medical experts recently told a reporter with The Daily Beast that they are becoming increasingly alarmed at President Donald Trump's accelerating deterioration.
ReplyDeleteSarah Ewall-Rice, a reporter at the outlet, told Nico Hines, the Daily Beast's global editorial director, during a new episode of "The Daily Beast Podcast" that medical experts released a new statement expressing deep concerns about Trump's mental and physical health. They cited episodes such as Trump's threat to wipe out the Iranian civilization and his seemingly erratic behavior around the White House.
Hooray! Finally! "Blue elite media" have spoken to carefully selected medical experts about our president's deteriorating mental faculties!
But, uh-oh. I'm sure they did it wrong somehow.
Invertebrate Congressional Republicans will not get the memo, of course.
DeleteDaily Beast is "Blue Elite Media"?
DeleteAre these the same experts who told us to chop off our son's balls?
DeleteNo silly, your son's balls will be chopped off in the schoolroom's coatroom during lunch by the Demoncrat teachers union. Pay better attention to the threat.
DeleteThe inflation rate hit 3.8% in April. There’s plenty of room for that number to climb.
ReplyDeletePer the President's top advisors, you need to exclude energy costs.
DeleteConcluding the kids have wisdom the grown-ups don't is the consequence of too much crunchy hippie feminist "My teenage daughter convinced me to vote Democrat" and not enough Lord of the Flies.
ReplyDeleteFascinating, but stupid
DeleteI like politics.
ReplyDeleteI used to think so highly of you.
Delete