Great landslides of the American past!

THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 7, 2024

What ever happened to landslides? When all the votes have been counted, how will this year's presidential election look? Ezra Klein offers this in the New York Times:

Where Does This Leave Democrats?

[...]

Donald Trump’s victory was not one of the grand landslides of American political history. As I write this, estimates suggest that [Trump] is on track for a 1.5-percentage-point margin in the popular vote. If that holds—and it may change as California is counted—it is smaller than Barack Obama’s win in 2008 or 2012, Bush’s in 2004 and Bill Clinton’s in 1992 or 1996. It may prove smaller than Hillary Clinton’s margin in 2016.

It won't be "one of the great landslides," Ezra somewhat sardonically says. Indeed, if the margin turns out to be less than two points, it won't be a landslide at all.

Here's what the Times' Nate Cohn says:

How Trump Won, Again

[...]

Despite Jan. 6, the end of Roe v. Wade and a felony conviction, Mr. Trump won a clear victory. He is on track to win all seven battleground states. He made gains in every corner of the country and with nearly every demographic group: If you look at The Times’s map of what has changed since 2020, you’ll see a sea of red.

According to our estimates, Mr. Trump is also on track to become the first Republican to win the national popular vote in 20 years.

At the same time, the scope of his victory shouldn’t be overstated. This was no landslide. A one- or two-percentage-point victory in the national popular vote with roughly 312 electoral votes is not unusual. It’s not as large as Barack Obama’s modest win in 2012, and falls far short of “change” elections like Mr. Obama’s in 2008 or Bill Clinton’s in 1992.

Cohn mentions that felony conviction, the venerated object of Blue America's cable news over the past several years. The outcome constitutes "a clear victory," but it was "no landslide," he says.

Alas! Depending on circumstances, an election can change the world without having been a landslide. 

In 2016, Candidate Trump lost the nationwide vote—but that particular lack of a landslide allowed him to place three people on the Supreme Court. President Obama, who won elections by 7.2 and 4.9 points, only got to name two Justices over his eight years in office. 

(In a sign of what was to come, one Justice was stolen, of course.)

What ever happened to landslides? At one time, there actually were such beings. Let's take a look at the record.

Did the modern political era start in 1960? However you answer that question, that election was very close:

Nationwide vote, 1960
Kennedy 49.7%
Nixon 49.6%
(Turnout: 63.8%)

That was no one's landslide! According to Theodore White, Kennedy learned that he had won when he arose on Wednesday morning.

Four years later, the deluge! By now, President Kennedy had been murdered. We the people said this:

Nationwide vote, 1964
Johnson 61.1%
Goldwater 38.5%
(Turnout: 62.8%)

By American norms, that was a genuine, stone-cold landslide. The others which followed were these:

Nationwide vote, 1972
Nixon: 60.7%
McGovern: 37.5%
(Turnout: 56.2%)
Nationwide vote, 1984
Reagan 58.8
Mondale 40.6
(Turnout: 55.2%)

Turnout was sliding but landslides lived on, though that was the last of the breed.  

In 1988, President Bush the elder won by almost eight points. In 1992 and 1996, President Clinton won by 5.6 and 8.5 points, each time in a three-way field. 

As of 1996, turnout had declined all the way to a bit less than 52%. Since then, only Obama's margin, that one time, has exceeded five points.

Will Trump end up with a two-point win? We don't know at this point. That said, a relatively slender nationwide win could still end up changing the world. In Blue America, we badly need to understand how it ever got this far—though some such belated comprehension may no longer matter.

For the record, Kennedy's very narrow win had been preceded by a landslide. 

In 1952, Eisenhower beat Stevenson by almost eleven points, with a turnout of slightly better than 63%. Four years later, when they did it again, the numbers looked like this:

Nationwide vote, 1956
Eisenhower 57.4%
Stevenson 42.0%
(Turnout: 60.2%)

In 1960, Eleanor Roosevelt—FDR's widow—wanted to nominate the highly erudite Stevenson again!

Out of one of those elections, a famous story emerged. In all likelihood, the story isn't true, but the story goes like this:

Still Madly for Adlai

Like many of the best political stories, this one about Adlai Stevenson, the former two-time Democratic presidential nominee, is probably apocryphal. It was late in a long day on the campaign trail in 1956—or 1952, it varies with the telling—when a voice called out of the crowd: 

“Every thinking person in America will be voting for you!” 

“I’m afraid that won’t do,” Stevenson retorted. “I need a majority.”

We Blues! We've never quite stopped thinking that way. Our human wiring inspires us to truly believe that such thinking is plainly correct.

We Blues have never stopped thinking that way. In our view, it doesn't help. 

NEW NORMALS: It's hard to know how this story will end!

THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 7, 2024

The world awaits news normals: We've been recalling what Viktor Laszlo says at one point in Casablanca.

Lazslo is an important, world-renowned freedom fighter. On the run from the Third Reich, he has landed in Casablanca—and, by happenstance, he has walked into a gin joint run by the sardonic man his beloved wife secretly loves.

The details of a complex love story slowly unfold from there. Midway through the film, Lazslo speaks frankly to the Bogart character, the man his beloved wife loves. 

Lazslo speaks to Mister Rick. When he does, he tells him this:

LAZSLO (1942): I know a good deal more about you than you suspect. I know, for instance, that you are in love with a woman.  It is perhaps a strange circumstance that we both should be in love with the same woman. 

The first evening I came into this cafe, I knew there was something between you and Ilsa. Since no one is to blame, I demand no explanation.

So says the freedom fighter, midway through the film 

By now, Lazslo has discerned the basic outline of what happened in Paris. He has asked his wife if she wants to tell him the story, but he hasn't insisted.

"No one is to blame," he now correctly says.

Casablanca places one of film's greatest love stories within the vastly larger context of a fight to save the world. The heroic Lazslo demands no explanation from the Bogart character. 

The brilliantly insightful story, leavened with spectacular uses of humor, continues on from there. With the help of the Bogart character, Lazslo escapes from Nazi-held Casablanca, still determined to save the world.

This very morning, we thought of what Lazslo said as we watched the Morning Joe gang giving voice to tribal regularity with respect to President Biden. 

President Biden has come under criticism for what happened this Tuesday. Early in Morning Joe's first hour, Mika demanded regularity from the Washington Post's Gene Robinson. 

We jotted down this part of their exchange:

MIKA (11/7/24): Was his presidency a failure?

ROBINSON: No. He was a very successful president.

In fairness to Robinson, Mika was plainly demanding that me make some such declaration.  Under the circumstances, Robinson may have felt that he pretty much had to comply.

That said, as in Casablanca, so too possibly here! In Casablanca, people like Lazslo (and his wife) were trying to save an existing world order as a slouching beast drew near. 

Imaginably, so too today, as the nation—and the world—await the highly likely unfolding of a whole new set of new normals.

What will President Trump do in this second term? There is no way to answer that question, Imaginably, though, prospects are remarkably dour.

In our view, major elements of President Biden's behavior helped bring us to this precarious place. That said, it seems to us that there's no one to blame—or at least, it seems to us that we can't blame President Biden himself, who seems to us to have undergone a loss of cognitive power.

Other people disagree with that assessment. To date, there has been virtually no attempt, within the mainstream press, to examine the question of President Biden's possible cognitive state.

Has the president been the victim of some sort of cognitive shortfall during his term in office? Is it possible that there was some attempt to hide some such state of affairs from the American public?

If you live in Red America, you've seen such assertions being made all through the past several years. If you live in Blue America, you've seen no attempt to address any such possible point of concern.

At some point, someone will probably venture forth with some reporting about this matter. We'll guess that Bob Woodward may be gathering information even as we speak—statements offered under embargo, awaiting some later release.

At present, some are saying that President Biden should have announced, after the 2022 midterm elections, that he wouldn't seek re-election. 

Our own frustration with the president's conduct is somewhat different. It involves his remarkable failure to confront the two basic issues which made it so hard for Candidate Harris to prevail as his replacement, once he'd been persuaded to step aside after his debate debacle in late June of this very year.

We refer again to President Biden's remarkable silence. To wit:

What explains President Biden's feckless behavior with respect to the southern border during the first three years of his term? As far as we know, the president has never made any attempt to explain.

(We'll be offering our own speculation within the next week.)

Also, what explained the economic situation which was confronting many voters as this year's election drew near? President Biden never made any serious attempt to address that situation either. In our view, the sitting president had virtually disappeared.

We're inclined to assume that President Biden was struggling with cognitive issues. (Others disagree.) This may explain why he made so little effort to speak about these major topics.

In that sense, there may be no one to blame for his failure to speak. No one to blame except, perhaps, the people around him.

That said, those of us in Blue America now face a dangerous state of affairs. We were sorry to see the way the Morning Joe gang seemed to feel they had to persist with the mandated statement about what a remarkably successful presidency this president has performed. 

Was President Biden a remarkably successful president? There may be no one to blame, but the extremely strange fourth year of his presidency has left the nation and the world in a perilous state,

In the past twenty-four hours, we've heard a lot of insightful assessments of how those of us in Blue America managed to get to this place. We'll start to review those assessments next week. 

Right now, on this very day, we'll merely offer this:

There may be no one to blame for the mess which finally became impossible to deny during that June 27 debate. There may be no one to blame for what may have happened to President Biden. 

Beyond that, no one knows where Tuesday's result will in fact lead the nation and the world. That said:

In our view, the nation is now in the hands of a badly disordered group of people. An obvious question remains in search of an answer:

"How did it [ever] get this far?" How did we ever get to this place?

This is a story without an ending, the Bogart character says at one point, midway through Casablanca. 

It was a story without an ending. So too today, as the nation, and the world, await an array of new normals.

This afternoon: Landslide elections v. this

What was the matter with Iowa?

WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 6, 2024

That is, with the Iowa Poll: In the past, Ann Selzer's Iowa Poll had frequently landed pretty much right on the money.

Every four years, results of the final survey would be released on the Sunday before the election. This year, that final poll showed Candidate Harris ahead of Candidate Trump by three points statewide, 47-44 percent.

We'll say this for the Iowa Poll—when it finally missed the mark, it held little back. Here's the current report on the topic in the Des Moines Register:

Pollster J. Ann Selzer: 'I’ll be reviewing data' after Iowa Poll misses big Trump win

Renowned Pollster J. Ann Selzer said Tuesday she would be reviewing her data to determine why a Des Moines Register/Mediacom Iowa Poll released just days before the election produced results so far out of line with former President Donald Trump's resounding victory.

Trump handily won Iowa for a third time, defeating Vice President Kamala Harris by 14 percentage points with more than 90% of the vote counted―a sharp contrast to Saturday's Iowa Poll that had Harris leading by 3 points.

"Tonight, I’m of course thinking about how we got where we are," Selzer, president of Selzer & Co., which conducts the Iowa Poll, said in a statement.

"The poll findings we produced for The Des Moines Register and Mediacom did not match what the Iowa electorate ultimately decided in the voting booth today. I’ll be reviewing data from multiple sources with hopes of learning why that happened. And, I welcome what that process might teach me."

As Kevin Drum noted last week, there are many ways a survey of this type can go wrong. So-called "margin of error" is only the start of the possibilities. And by the way, just a guess:

No journalist could possibly hope to explain the way that statistical artefact works. We couldn't exactly do so either, but at least we'd know not to pretend.

Simply put, everyone talks about margin of error, but no one does anything about it! In fact, basic "sampling error" comes into play if you're simply pulling red and blue ping-pong balls out of a big giant drum. 

Sometimes, the sample you pull out of the drum will match the proportion of red and blue balls found inside the drum—but a fair amount of the time, the sample you pull out of the drum won't be a perfect match.

That's how it works with ping pong balls in a big giant drum. If you're polling a presidential campaign, other factors come into play, potentially messing things up.

Many people won't answer their phone when you try to reach them. Some people will answer their phone, but they won't answer your question.

Some people won't tell you the truth if they decide to answer your question. Some people may have changed their minds by the time they cast their votes.

The possible ways a poll can go wrong continue on from there. 

On 24-hour "cable news," the pundits spend a lot of time, before an election, puzzling over the polls. At some point, this becomes an excellent way to kill giant amounts of time—a way to pretend you're presenting "news" as part of a process called "journalism."

This past Sunday, the Iowa Poll had Candidate Harris up by three points, with nine percent still floating around in the ether. (Three percent had said that they'd be voting for Candidate Kennedy Jr.)

For one brief shining moment, that's where matters allegedly stood. According to this AP post, here's where the statewide vote in Iowa stands with 98 percent reporting:

Statewide presidential vote, Iowa 2024
Trump: 55.9%
Harris: 42.7%
Kennedy Jr.: 0.8%

Three other hopefuls got handfuls of votes. Eventually, though, the day had to come:

Trump won by more than thirteen points! The Iowa Poll got it wrong.

NEW NORMALS: "The American people are pretty sharp!"

WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 6, 2024

Except actually, no—we aren't: For at least a generation, it's been a standard bit of messaging from "highly educated," high-profile American pundits:

The American people are pretty sharp!

That has always made for excellent messaging. Whatever else may have been involved, repetition of this bromide helped pundits remain well liked.

The American people are pretty sharp? Actually no, we aren't! That includes this gaggle of "highly educated," high-end journalists—and who knows?

 In some cases, it's possible that some of those tribunes even believed what they said!

Last night's outcome wasn't a revolution—except to the extent that it may become one. Numbers changed in a limited way—in a way which makes total sense at a time when people feel, by a very wide margin, that the nation is on "the wrong track."

Tens of millions of neighbors and friends believe that we're on the wrong track. Having said that, so what?

In Blue America, we kept ignoring the still-unexplained, manifest strangeness which was allowed to transpire, for more than three years, at the southern border. To this day, we're still conflating the cost of living with the current inflation figure.

Our tribunes kept insisting that President Biden was sharp as a tack. Over on the Fox News Channel, they kept playing the pieces of videotape which seemed to debunk that claim.

Are we the people actually sharp? This morning, the C-Span web site has joined that of the Internet Archive. For a reason we can't explain, C-Span's website seems to be down. 

Has C=Span been hit by a cyberattack, like the Archive before it? We have no idea! But C-Span's failure to respond robs us of the chance to transcribe a trio of phone calls the network received during Sunday morning's broadcast. of Washington Journal.

How sharp are we the American people? Based upon our notes, the three calls were received, one after the other, starting at 8:55 a.m. Eastern.

The American people are pretty sharp? Here's what three callers said, one right after another:

Caller One: Caller One said that she would be voting for Candidate Harris. She cited the fact that Candidate Trump has had three wives as the defining point of concern.

Caller Two: Caller Two said that he would also be voting for Harris—and he was predicting a blowout. He noted the fact that Candidate Trump doesn't have a pet, while Candidate Harris has a dog.

Caller Three: Caller Three said she'd be voting for Candidate Trump.  Who was in office when the Dobbs decision was reached? "The Democrats," she sagaciously said, plainly suggesting that the Dobbs decision was therefore the Democrats' fault!

You'll think that we're inventing these calls. You'll think that, but we aren't.

To our ear, there was no sign that these callers were anything other than fully sincere. We can't link you to the audiotape of these calls because C-Span, like the Internet Archive, is now, for some reason, down.

When we listened to those phone calls, we heard America singing, if only in very small part. Rather, we were hearing the voices of three fellow citizens—three of the well over 100 million neighbors and friends who would be going out there to vote.

In all honesty, we the humans aren't especially sharp, and there's exactly zero sign that we ever were. That includes the class of experts who get dragged into Blue America's messaging venues to feed us the porridge we like.

Last night's outcome wasn't a revolution. Candidate Trump will almost surely end up winning the nationwide popular vote, but only by maybe three points.

That's a change from four years ago. On the other hand, it isn't a giant change, given the circumstances under which this campaign took place.

How did we Blues approach this election? Let us count (a few of) the ways:

For starters, we operated under an amazingly braindead bromide:

Don't ask, don't let them tell!

Please don't interview Trump voters, we said again and again. Please don't ask them how the world looks to them. Don't ask them why they're supporting Candidate Trump.

Any time a major news org dared to do some such thing, we Blues begged them to stop. It's hard to be much dumber than that, but we (highly educated) Blues were constantly willing to try.

We didn't leave things there. Starting at 4 o'clock Eastern each afternoon, Blue America's "cable news" channel focused its attention on this pleasing porridge:

Trump Trump Trump Trump jail!

Lock him up, our tribunes said, all day and then into the night. In the process, they completely ignored the facts of life which were driving the outlook of The Others.

They ignored the outlook of the deplorables who went out and voted yesterday, even possibly of the "garbage" out there.

(Once President Biden had blurted that latter term, we insisted that Red America had blown right past his implied apostrophe! It's hard to be more pathetic than that, but as a tribe, we've always been willing to try.)

In the end, one of those deplorables called C-Span with that ridiculous claim about the Dobbs decision. That said, this is who we the people are—and at some point, those of us in Blue America have to ask ourselves this basic question:

Do we like other people, or not?

All through the annals of human history, the general answer to that question has generally been no. We humans are wired to like our own, to refer to the Others as "trash."

That's where Candidate Vance just went, in the campaign's dying days. In part due to the landlocked nature of our own Blue American world, we are now looking ahead to rule by a gaggle like this:

The brain trust which has emerged: 
Donald J. Trump
Elon Musk
Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.
JD Vance
Tucker Carlson

Next in line will be fellows like Bannon. It was Bannon to whom Carlson made his latest confession—his claim that our problems with hurricanes stem from our many abortions. That followed his account of the way he was bloodied in bed by unseen demons, even as his wife and his four dogs soundly slept.

We've now purchased rule by that peculiar crew, and on downward from there. To us, those people all seem to be disordered—but the mental giants in Blue America all agreed, from beginning to end, that any such medical possibility must never be mentioned or discussed.

So it was decided by Us—by the plainly brighter class among us the rational animals.

Are we humans "the rational animal?" Is it possible that we ever were?

Isn't it pretty to think so! A decade ago, writing for the New York Times, Professor Horwich shot that notion down.

Interpreting the later Wittgenstein, the professor brought in the mail. The highest achievements of western world thought were really "the misbegotten products of linguistic illusion and muddled thinking," the professor said that the later Wittgenstein had said.

We think the professor got it pretty much right! Over here in Blue America, we motored ahead into an era when we pleasingly wiped away the age-old distinction between misstatements and lies.

So it went with our own muddled thinking, with a thousand examples to follow. Over there in Red America, the others were routinely able to see what our tribunes kept choosing to do.

On our side, we wanted to lock him up. The business types inside our own tribe's "cable news" channel kept using that as the pretty idea which would keep us returning for more.

On and on and on we went. On our side, we're so dumb that we somehow managed to convince ourselves that Stormy Daniels was a "feminist hero," based on the way she struggled and strained to shake Trump down for cash.

It's hard to be much dumber than that; we were willing to try. Over there, in Red America, the lesser breed was persistently able to see what we, the finer people, were haplessly trying to do.

What will President Trump do this time around? We have no way of knowing.

If he goes ahead with his apparently lunatic tariff plan, the economy may get very bad. If that happens, it will take a lot of violent rhetoric and action, in other areas, to keep us the people in line.

(Or he may just dismiss Jack Smith, then go play golf for four years. We have no way of knowing what the fellow will do.)

That said, there will likely be a lot of new normals in the days ahead. Almost surely, there's one thing which will never change:

We Blues will never understand the way we look to Others. According to a handful of actual experts, our human wiring doesn't equip us for some such task.

We humans aren't built for that task! Is a new beast slouching toward Bethlehem now, as one anthropologist foretold?

We the humans just aren't super-sharp! At some point, we Blues may have to ask ourselves this. It's a question straight outta Bill Clinton:

Do we like other humans, or not?

We've seen that claim again and again!

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 5, 2024

The Times keeps looking away: We've just returned from a two-block hike to our voting place. Based upon the votes we cast after perhaps a three-minute wait, Harris and Walz will be elected today, along with Senator Alsobrooks.

Kweisi Mfume will return to the House. That said, our focus here will be this:

On a totally separate topic, Kevin Drum has presented (at least) his second post about EV charging stations—and about the ongoing, round-the-clock efforts to misinform us the people. 

Kevin starts in the manner shown below. We're omitting several graphics, which you can see at his site:

EV charging station update

Remember the old meme about how the federal government has spent $7.5 billion on EV charging stations but only three had been built? The meme needs to be updated. As of June, 17 stations have been built:

[Graphic] 

Hmmm. Still not very impressive, is it? But this is like looking at Hoover Dam in 1933 and being indignant that the government has spent a billion dollars and only poured one bucket of concrete.

At this point, we'll offer this:

In fact, we do remember that "old meme" about the EV charging stations! We remember it because we've seen the boys at the Fox News Channel pimp that mandated script again and again and again!

According to the standard messaging, it's just as Kevin relates! According to the children at Fox, the federal government has blown billions of dollars on this project—but almost no charging stations have ever been built!

(Was the number of charging stations as low as three at some point in time? In this report by Kevin from back in July, the number in the standard meme apparently stood at eight.)

We've seen Gutfeld and Watters sell that story again and again and again. As we've noted in the past, we've also seen Gutfeld refer to climate change as a "hoax," but also as "one of the major hoaxes."

That said, Kevin says this messaging about EV stations been nothing but bunk. Continuing directly, he concludes his new report with this:

The EV charging station project was designed from the start to finish in 2030. Here's how it looks if you extrapolate the current growth rate:

[Graphic]

We probably won't hit a thousand stations until the end of 2025. That's just the way exponential growth goes. But like Hoover Dam, the EV project is actually ahead of schedule even though there isn't much to see yet.

A project of this sort can't be accomplished overnight. Today, as back in July, Kevin reports that the project is proceeding as designed, or is perhaps a bit ahead of schedule.

On our own, we know nothing about this topic. That, of course, would also be true of almost everyone else. including the millions of people who (unknowingly) receive their programmed misinformation from the Fox News Channel.

Once again, Kevin is saying that the project in question is actually ahead of schedule. Assuming his report is accurate, Gutfeld and Watters have been misinforming us the people as they've laughed and smirked and chuckled and clowned about the completely ridiculous lack of charging stations which have been built to date.

We've seen this again and again on Fox. We've never seen this conflict reported, or resolved, by the high-minded keepers of the flame at the New York Times.

To appearances, the New York Times simply doesn't want to scuffle with the lesser breed over at Fox. Corporate tools like Gutfeld and Watters are allowed the run of their playpen, as long as they stay Over There, misinforming Red America's voters.

We live in two Americas now. Over there, on the Fox News Channel, the flyweights can do and say whatever they like. Under current arrangements, they 're allowed to behave this way without any fear of correction.

How much are these flyweights paid for this service? It's considered a breach in protocol if you even ask!

(This is a problem at Blue cable too. We'd say it's much worse Over There.)

NEW NORMALS: Candidate Harris is "trash," he said!

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 5, 2024

Did Yeats get it right? No one can say that this incomparable site isn't shaping the national discourse.

This very morning, Morning Joe began with a reading from The Making of the President 1960, the iconic book by Theodore White. We're forced to tell you this:

Inevitably, the reading came from the very first page of the famous book—from White's account of the voting that year in Hart's Location, the Dixville Notch of that day.

The leading authority tells us this about that northern hamlet:

Hart's Location, New Hampshire

Hart's Location is a town in Carroll County, New Hampshire, United States. Since 1948, the town has frequently been one of the first places to declare its results for the New Hampshire presidential primary and U.S. presidential elections.

The population was 68 in the 2020 census. It was incorporated in 1795.

[...]

New Hampshire law allows towns with fewer than 100 residents to open the polls at midnight and close them as soon as all registered voters have cast their ballots...The tradition of first-in-the-nation voting in Hart's Location dates back to 1948.

That's how it's done in the Granite State. You may recall the famous old saying: 

As goes the state of New Hampshire, so goes no one else!

Fuller disclosure! According to that same authority, the population of Hart's Location was actually 7 (seven!) back in 1960. 

This seems to mean that someone is confused or misinformed in some way. We say that because White's famous book begins with this passage, as read over patriotic music on today's Morning Joe:

The Making of the President, 1960

It was invisible, as always. 

They had begun to vote in the villages of New Hampshire at midnight, as they always do, seven and a half hours before the candidate rose. His men had canvassed Hart’s Location in New Hampshire days before, sending his autographed picture to each of the twelve registered voters in the village. They knew that they had five votes certain there, that Nixon had five votes certain—and that two were still undecided. Yet it was worth the effort, for Hart’s Location’s results would be the first flash of news on the wires to greet millions of voters as they opened their morning papers over coffee. But from there on it was unpredictable—invisible.

That's the way the book begins. The population of the village was seven—but according to White, Kennedy's men had managed to locate twelve voters there! 

(In the end, how did Hart's Location vote? White's book hurries on, doesn't say.)

We ourselves had planned to quote from White's famous book today. We had planned to focus on the ways we now live in a vastly changed nation—in a nation which is much larger, to cite one basic example.

Candidate Kennedy won Texas that year, but he did so quite narrowly. Meanwhile, Texas was a different critter at that point in time.

Below, you see population figures for three Sunbelt states, but also for the United States as a whole: 

Total population, then and now:

Texas 1960: 9,579,677
Texas 2023 (est): 30,503,301

Florida 1960: 4,951,560
Florida 2023 (est.): 22,610,726

California 1960: 15,717,204
California 2023 (est): 38,940,231

United States 1960: 179,323,175
United States 2024 (est): 335,893,238

There were many fewer Americans then. Except during spring training, the modern-day state of Florida was virtually uninhabited!

This year, Nevada is an important swing state. It was basically empty back then:

Nevada 1960: 285,278
Nevada 2023 (est): 3,194,176

We were a much smaller nation. We were also much less "diverse," and given the way our brains are wired—given the way we humans are built—running a diverse democracy tends to be a challenging task. 

(Something else is true, and it's quite important in the current circumstance. Given the limits of human discernment, there is no well-intentioned impulse which can't be unwisely pursued. We'll expound on this fact in the days ahead—and that fact is even true over here in our own Blue America.)

Time moved slower in 1960, Harper Lee once almost said. Also, with a potent, shoe-banging external enemy inspiring everyone to cohere, it was somewhat easier to run a "democracy" then.

It was also easier because we didn't have national talk radio. Also because we didn't have "cable news." 

We didn't have any 24-hour imitations of news. We didn't have the Internet, and we didn't have social media. 

Huey Long had said that every man (sic) should be a royal. Thanks to the democratization of media, the watchword today is this:

Every nutcase a king! Also, every flyweight comedian!

Every nutcase, but also every "beast?" We'll offer examples below.

Candidate Kennedy squeaked out a win in 1960. Candidate Nixon narrowly lost. 

Last night, Dixville Notch split its vote—three votes for Candidate Harris, three votes for Candidate Trump. Meanwhile, is a beast slouching toward Bethlenem? We refer to the gloomy Yeats.

In the wake of the First World War, Yeats was perhaps a bit gloomy. His famous poem, The Second Coming, was written in 1919. The leading authority on the poem offers this overview:

The Second Coming (poem)

“The Second Coming” is a poem written by Irish poet William Butler Yeats in 1919, first printed in The Dial in November 1920...The poem uses Christian imagery regarding the Apocalypse and Second Coming to describe allegorically the atmosphere of post-war Europe. It is considered a major work of modernist poetry...

The poem was written in 1919 in the aftermath of the First World War and the beginning of the Irish War of Independence in January 1919, which followed the Easter Rising in April 1916, and before the British government had decided to send in the Black and Tans to Ireland. Yeats used the phrase "the second birth" instead of "the Second Coming" in his first drafts.

To understand Yeats′s cosmology it is essential to read his book A Vision, where he explained his views on history and how it informed his poetry. Yeats saw human history as a series of epochs, what he called "gyres." He saw the age of classical antiquity as beginning with the Trojan War and then that thousand year cycle was overtaken by the Christian era, which is coming to a close. And that is the basis of the final line of the poem: "And what rough beast, its hour come round at last / Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?"

According to Yeats, a beast was slouching toward Bethlehem. Today, more than a century later, we can't quite say he was wrong.

Are beasts advancing on our own culture, such as it is? In this, our vastly changed semi-nation, we will start with this:

Yesterday, during a rally in Atlanta, a candidate who was severely mistreated as a child and as a youth gave voice to his pain in this way:

VANCE (11/4/2024): The citizens of this country are not garbage for wanting to afford groceries and a nice place to live. But in two days, we're going to take out the trash in Washington, D.C. And the trash's name is Kamala Harris.

AUDIENCE: [Cheers, applause]

VANCE: All right. So let me leave you with one final thought...

"In a clearing stands a boxer?" Fuller lyrics below.

For now, to see the candidate call his opponent "trash," click here for the C-Span videotape. Then, move ahead to minute 55.

For better or worse, none of the candidates called anyone "trash" during the 1960 campaign. Regarding Vance, we've made this suggestion before:

A child who is mistreated in the remarkable ways he describes in his own famous book may show the effects of such abuse at later points in his life. This seems to be another way we humans are built. It isn't the fault of the child.

Candidate Vance was calling her trash. During the now-famous Garden Party, she was portrayed as a prostitute. Also, the persistently thoughtful Hulk Hogan seemed to portray her engaging in oral sex.

In Blue America, our tribunes quickly disappeared this array of gender-based insults. This instant abandonment of the woman also seems to be part of the way we human beings are wired.

As of yesterday, Candidate Vance was calling her trash! Meanwhile, Tucker Carlson is now offering this account of our problems with stormy weather:

Tucker Carlson Says Abortions Cause Hurricanes in Election Eve Broadcast

Tucker Carlson, a top surrogate for former President Donald J. Trump who spoke at the Republican National Convention this summer and made racist claims at a Trump rally last week at Madison Square Garden, said on Monday that the increased occurrence of hurricanes in the United States was a consequence of abortion—which he characterized as “human sacrifice.”

Appearing on a podcast hosted by Stephen K. Bannon, a right-wing political strategist and Trump ally who was just released from prison, Mr. Carlson repeatedly portrayed abortion—a medical procedure—as a kind of religious human sacrifice. He dismissed scientific research that links global warming to the increased potency and frequency of hurricanes, saying instead that “it’s probably abortion, actually.”

“I’m sure I’ll be attacked for saying this, but I really believe it,” Mr. Carlson said, adding, “You can’t participate in human sacrifice without consequences.”

Throughout his 25-minute appearance on Mr. Bannon’s “War Room” podcast, Mr. Carlson described himself as a secular person but spoke of politics in starkly religious terms.

Mr. Carlson also described nuclear weapons as “demonic,” adding that they were created by “not-human forces,” and asserted that the U.S. military had “consistently” targeted and killed Christian populations since the end of World War II.

The account of this fellow's "bizarre remarks" in the past few years continues on from there. 

For better or worse, the Times still hasn't reported Carlson's recent bombshell disclosure—his revelation that he was attacked and bloodied by demons in the middle of the night while his wife and his four dogs continued to sleep, without awakening, right there in the same bed.

Trump and Vance and Carlson oh my? Let's throw in Elon Musk, who has become a major player in the ongoing "democratization of media"—in the process designed to make every fruitcake a king.

Stating the obvious, there's no perfect way to run a "national discourse." The discourse wasn't perfect in 1960. Grudgingly, White seems to acknowledge this fact at one point in his book.

Today, the discourse is an unmistakable joke. (Frequently, it's a "dirty" joke.) Part of the joke involves the way the finer elements in the news business have agreed to avert their gaze from the encroachment of the possible beasts.

Trump and Vance and Carlson oh my! Are beasts slouching toward our own Bethlehem as we go to the polls?

On Morning Joe, Joe was reading a passage about a village during a simpler time. 

White's book describes the start of a political era. Is that major political era slouching toward a very dangerous end?

This afternoon: Unreported far and wide! Gutfeld and Watters edition

Fuller lyrics: Fuller lyrics, from Paul Simon (1968):

In the clearing stands a boxer
And a fighter by his trade
And he carries the remainders
Of every glove that laid him down
And cut him till he cried out
In his anger and his shame
“I am leaving, I am leaving”
But the fighter still remains...

 Simon's song is deeply humane. We've suggested that you pity the child but strip the adult of power. 


What explains the way Iowa votes?

MONDAY, NOVEMBER 4, 2024

Also, Semafor tattles: How does the state of Iowa vote in presidential elections?

In recent years, the state's pattern has been hard to explain. Here's the way the state voted in 2008:

Iowa presidential election, 2008
Obama: 53.9%
McCain: 44.4%

Obama won by almost ten points. Here's where things went from there:

Iowa presidential election, 2012
Obama: 52.0%
Romney: 46.2%

Iowa presidential election, 2016
Trump: 51.2%
Clinton: 41.7%

Iowa presidential election, 2020
Trump: 53.1%
Biden: 44.9%

Offhand, we can't puzzle that out. Consider the shift in statewide voter sentiment from 2012 to 2016:

Nationwide, the Democratic candidate lost a bit less than three points from 2012 to 2016. The party went from Obama's 51.1% nationwide vote in 2012 down to Clinton's 48.2% four years later.

Statewide in Iowa, the Democratic candidate lost more than ten points over that same period—from Obama's 52.0% all the way down to Clinton's 41.7%.  That was a very large drop—almost four times the nationwide norm. Four years later, Biden only won back three points.

Offhand, we can't explain that statewide voting pattern. Now, the Iowa poll suggests that Candidate Harris might actually win the Hawkeye State! (Or possibly not, of course.)

In our view, tis a dream devoutly to be wished. Is it going to happen? We have no idea.

Meanwhile:

On this very morning, fire trucks from the New York Times arrived at the scene of the fire.  As noted this morning, we refer to this "News Analysis" piece from the front page of today's print editions:

NEWS ANALYSIS 
Trump’s Wild Claims, Conspiracies and Falsehoods Redefine Presidential Bounds

It took just two minutes for former President Donald J. Trump to utter his first lie of the evening, claiming once again that the 2020 election had been stolen.

By four minutes into the televised interview on Thursday night, he was claiming that this time around “we’re leading by a lot” in the polls, setting up another false claim of a stolen election should he lose on Tuesday.

[...]

Truth is not always an abundant resource in the White House under any president, but never has the Oval Office been occupied by someone so detached from verifiable facts... 

The analysis piece goes on at great length. It arrives at the scene of the conflagration clownishly late in the game.

As we've long noted, the endless misstatements of Candidate Trump should have formed a major "news hook" long ago. As we've frequently noted, when a major party nominee makes so many crazy misstatements, that behavior should count as front-page news every time it happens. 

(Stating the obvious, endless unsupported claims about past and future "stolen elections" should be viewed as especially noxious, given the basic structure of our failing American system.)

The Times has arrived at the scene of the blaze just as the ashes fly. Apparently, some people inside the New York Times may have agreed with this assessment as this candidate's lunacy—and the silence about it at the Times—continued to move along.

This morning, Semafor tattles! At that site, Max Tani describes the apparent unrest in a lengthy report which starts in the manner shown:

In a frank internal meeting, The New York Times wrestled with its political role

With the 2024 presidential election a few weeks away, one question was top of mind for staff at The New York Times: Had the paper’s leadership noticed how many Democrats had become furious at it over its coverage of Donald Trump?

The Times, and the American media at large, absorb endless vitriol from the right. At a rally Sunday, Donald Trump joked that he wouldn’t mind if another would-be assassin had to “shoot through” the press pen to get to him.

But when the country’s most influential newsroom assembled at the paper’s New York headquarters for a nearly 90-minute-long off-the-record Q&A with the paper’s top editors on Oct. 24, some of its journalists voiced a different set of concerns about the 2024 election and how its outcome might shape the paper’s future.

Semafor obtained a recording of the meeting, which offers extraordinary insight into a key American institution under intense external scrutiny and internal pressure...

The report is there for all to peruse. To read the report, click here.

The Times has arrived at the scene of the crime. Election Day is tomorrow.

In our view, this silence has been a form of journalistic inanity pretty much all the way down. We leave you with this week's top question:

Might this journalistic failure to perform also turn out to be one of our nation's deeply destructive "new normals?"



NEW NORMALS: 30,000 people at 3 in the morning!

MONDAY, NOVEMBER 4, 2024

Then, as now, new normals: Way back in 1960, at the dawn of a new political era, it was apparently part of an array of new normals.

Theodore White wrote the book about that year's storied presidential campaign. At one point, he described the sudden arrival of "the jumpers." 

To this day, White's book carries a famous title: The Making of the President 1960. At one point, White says that the jumpers arrived on the scene after that campaign's famous first TV debate:

WHITE (page 331): One remembers, of course, the jumpers. The jumpers made their appearance shortly after the first TV debate when from a politician Kennedy had become, in the mind of the bobby-sox platoons, a “thing” combining, as one Southern Senator said, “The best qualities of Elvis Presley and Franklin D. Roosevelt.” The jumpers were, in the beginning, teen-age girls who would bounce, jounce and jump as the cavalcade passed, squealing, “I seen him, I seen him.” Gradually over the days their jumping seemed to grow more rhythmic, giving a jack-inthe-box effect of ups and downs in a thoroughly sexy oscillation. Then, as the press began to comment on the phenomenon, thus stimulating more artistic jumping, the middle-aged ladies began to jump up and down too, until, in the press bus following the candidate, one would note only the oddities: the lady, say, in her bathrobe, jumping back and forth; the heavily pregnant mother, jumping; the mother with a child in her arms, jumping; the row of nuns, all jiggling under their black robes, almost (but not quite) daring to jump; and the double-jumpers—teenagers who, as the cavalcade passed, would turn to face each other and, in ecstasy, place hands on each others’ shoulders and jump up and down together as a partnership. The most endearing jumping I saw on the long campaign occurred in Florida—in Miami. One of the schools had trooped its children out onto the lawn to see the Presidential cavalcade go by, as was the custom in most communities for both candidates. By some misjudgment of logistics, the school authorities had put the older children—the seventh- and eighth-graders—in the front row while the tiny kindergartners and first-graders were drawn up several paces behind the big ones on the grass. The big girls jumped, of course, as was to be expected. But one could see behind them two files of little ones in their gay-colored jumpers and smocks, jumping up and down in their ranks as if they were colored balls being bounced by an unseen hand. The little ones could see nothing at all over the shoulders of the seventh- and eighth-graders, but they were jumping nonetheless.

Two decades earlier, bobby-soxers had reportedly squealed for Frank Sinatra too. But as part of a presidential campaign, we're willing to guess that the jumpers were part of a new normal.

Were the jumpers a figment of White's imagination? Apparently not. The oral history of the campaign includes recollections of this conduct by other people who, like White, were actually physically present. It was a bit like the Beatles before the Beatles, observers have sometimes said.

Arguably, the jumpers were part of an emerging new normal. Elvis had already hit. The Beatles would soon arrive.

In White's view, this was the first election of the emerging TV era.  For the record, Candidate Kennedy was a bit of a dreamboat in the eyes of many observers. That would include our own (Boston-born) mother and older sister, assuming that memory serves.

For the record, it was a much different country then. The country had a much smaller population, and the population was much less racially and ethnically diverse. Meanwhile, our own emerging political era has been defined by the so-called "democratization of media"—by the emergence of technologies which forcing us to adopt a modernized version of Huey Long's famous bromide:

Every crackpot a king.

Every crackpot a king! This may end up as the new normal of this dangerous time.

The TV era has come and gone. The current election campaign is playing out in the era of the Internet and social media—and in the age of cable TV, with its round-the-clock imitations of TV "news."

The current election campaign is playing out in a much larger nation, but also in the era of the unfettered fruitcake. Still and all, the enthusiasm was apparently great on the final weekend of 1960, when Candidate Kennedy returned to his native New England for his last two days of campaigning.

Realities were quite different then! The Democratic candidate, John F. Kennedy, swept to victory through much of the solid South, winning North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Louisiana, Arkansas and Texas. 

(Neither candidate won Alabama or Mississippi that year. Those states were won that year by a straight segregationist ticket.)

Candidate Kennedy reached the White House thanks to the pre-civil rights South! At the same time, the Republican candidate, Richard M. Nixon, won all three Pacific coast states—Washington, Oregon and California—and he took three of the six states in Kennedy's native region.

Candidate Kennedy spent the last two days campaigning right there in New England. The nation was much smaller then, but the enthusiasm in lower New England was apparently quite high. White describes what happened when Kennedy arrived at the airport in Bridgeport, Connecticut shortly after midnight on that last Saturday night:

WHITE (page 339): From the airport to Waterbury, where Kennedy was to rest that night, is only twenty-seven miles; yet it was to take two hours to drive that twenty-seven miles. Every child, every man, every woman, every grandmother and grandfather on whom [Governor] Bailey and his organization had a string of loyalty, was there in the damp to greet the returning hero. Up the Naugatuck Valley’s old Route 8 they went—through Shelton, Derby, Ansonia, Seymour, Beacon Falls, Naugatuck, Union City, through all the craftsmens’ villages of this seed bed of American technology. There at every crossroads, at midnight and at one and at two in the morning, they were waiting with torchlights and red flares to cheer and yell “We love you, Jack.” Outside every fire station on the route, the Bailey men had lined the fire engines, their red beacons and red winkers flashing and revolving in salute in the night...

He arrived at the Roger Smith Hotel in Waterbury, Connecticut, at three o’clock in the morning, and 30,000 people waited on the old New England green before the hotel to yell for him. He was tired; it was three o’clock in the morning; but they wanted him. So he climbed out on the balcony of the hotel, with the spotlights illuminating him from below, and from high on the balcony he spoke over the crowded green...

It was a much smaller nation then. But according to White, 30,000 people were standing there at 3 in the morning, wanting to hear Jack speak.

After three hours of sleep, the campaigning began again, in what was plainly a different political nation. Judging from appearances, the candidate felt that he even had to battle for victory in the states of lower New England—in Connecticut and Rhode Island, and in Massachusetts as well:

WHITE (footnote, page 341): All the last Sunday and Monday of the Kennedy campaign were spent in New England except for four hours touching down at rallies in Long Island and the northern New Jersey slums. The schedule, to be precise, read over the forty-eight hour period: Waterbury, Wallingford, New Haven, Bridgeport, Suffolk County, Teaneck, Jersey City, Newark, Lewiston (Maine), Providence (Rhode Island), Springfield (Massachusetts), Hartford (Connecticut), Burlington (Vermont), Manchester (New Hampshire), and Boston (Massachusetts).

Even in New Haven and Hartford, Providence and Springfield, Mass.! So it went as an array of new normals were taking shape at the start of a new political era.

That was the first election of the TV era. Ours is the era which bears this challenging banner:

Every crackpot an influencer. 

We're going to learn, in the next few days, if that earlier era has fully reached its end. We're going to learn if a whole new set of normals now obtains.

Concerning one point, there can be little doubt. The inane behavior of the New York Times has been part of the current new normal. 

On the front page of this morning's print editions, this "News Analysis" by Peter Baker appears above the fold. With the sirens of its fire trucks screaming, the Times has arrived at the scene of the fire comically, clownishly late:

NEWS ANALYSIS 
Trump’s Wild Claims, Conspiracies and Falsehoods Redefine Presidential Bounds

It took just two minutes for former President Donald J. Trump to utter his first lie of the evening, claiming once again that the 2020 election had been stolen.

By four minutes into the televised interview on Thursday night, he was claiming that this time around “we’re leading by a lot” in the polls, setting up another false claim of a stolen election should he lose on Tuesday.

By five minutes into the program, he had turned to assailing his successor’s record in office and was claiming that in the last few years the country had experienced “the worst inflation we’ve ever had.”

None of that was true. And that was just the first 300 seconds. For the rest of the evening, Mr. Trump spouted one statement after another that was fanciful, misleading, distorted or wildly false. He rewrote history. He claimed accomplishments that he did not accomplish. He cited statistics at odds with the record. He described things that did not happen and denied things that did.

[...]

Truth is not always an abundant resource in the White House under any president, but never has the Oval Office been occupied by someone so detached from verifiable facts...

Never has the Oval Office been occupied by someone so detached from verifiable facts? 

It isn't Baker's fault, but the New York Times has arrived on the scene comically, clownishly late. It has finally arrived at the scene of the blaze with this "News Analysis" concerning one part of what may turn out to be our flailing nation's new normal. 

Later, the tragicomedy continues as Baker offers this:

“No one in American politics has ever lied on this scale,” said Bill Adair, a Duke University professor and author of “Beyond the Big Lie,” published this fall. “His impact is not just in the volume and repetition of lies that he tells but also in the way that he has affected the culture of the Republican Party. He has made it more acceptable to lie, and that’s clear when you listen to debate on the House floor and you hear his lies get repeated, or you watch Fox and you hear his lies get repeated."

Let us start by noting that neither Baker nor Adair knows if this candidate's endless wild misstatements actually qualify as "lies," or if they might the product of a wildly distorted discernment—a distorted discernment of a type the Times (and the rest of the upper-end press) has steadfastly refused to contemplate or discuss.

No one knows of those endless wild misstatements are actually "lies"—and no one has been willing to interview the kinds of (carefully selected) medical specialists who might be able to offer an informed judgment about this important possibility. To that we'll add an additional point, one we've repeatedly noted:

You watch Fox and you hear his [misstatements] get repeated? 

We the people do in fact hear those wild misstatements repeated, on an hourly basis, all over the Fox News Channel. Along with the rest of its journalistic avoidance, the Times has agreed that this basic fact of modern life—this basic "new normal"—must never be reported, analyzed or discussed. 

Within the realm of the New York Times, no one should ever say the names of the Fox News Channel stars! Also, no one should ever report the things they've repeatedly said and done.

The Times has agreed to disappear the existence of that new normal. For better or worse, it has also agreed to bury the sweeping possibility concerning the possible medical / psychiatric disorder which may have produced the endless wild misstatements it describes today as "lies."

Last night, on CNN, Lulu Garcia-Navarro finally said it. "It's not normal," she said, speaking of the peculiar behavior of this particular candidate on this campaign's final weekend.

We'll try to link you to tape of that exchange. At Raw Story, Kathleen Culliton describes that discussion here.

The cyberattack on the Internet Archive may mean that we won't be able to show you what Garcia-Navarro said. Sadly, that successful cyberattack may turn itself out to be one of our "new normals."

As a nation, we seem to be encountering quite a few potential "new normals" as we await the outcome of tomorrow's vote. That said, it's all over now but the waiting! 

Tomorrow, we'll offer a few more notes about the respective arrays of new normals—the new normals of 1960 as opposed to the potential new normals now.

A new political era arrived on the scene in 1960. Let's borrow today from Yeats as we contemplate our own new normals. We'll let sacred Yeats frame our basic question:

To what extent is a rough beast, its hour perhaps come round at last, slouching towards our own Bethlehem, hoping to be born?

This afternoon: Semafor squeals—tattles, blows the whistle


SUNDAY: Has the underdog taken the lead in Iowa?

SUNDAY, NOVEMBER 3, 2024

Not built for this line of work: As we awoke this very morning, the youthful analysts were struggling to memorize the lyrics of a major Beatles hit.

"Let It Be," the youngsters were singing. They pointed us toward the new poll reported by the Des Moines Register in a startling news report which appears today beneath this dual headline:

Iowa Poll: Kamala Harris leapfrogs Donald Trump to take lead near Election Day. Here's how
The nationally recognized Iowa Poll shows Kamala Harris picking up support from women to surpass Donald Trump in a ruby-red state he has won twice

In recent elections, this particular poll of Iowa voters has a strong record for accuracy. 

Can it possibly be? Has Candidate Harris gone ahead in the Hawkeye State, with abortion rights being offered as a possible explanation?

At this site, we have no idea. It's all over now but the waiting!

As for us, our regular entertainment experience was undermined this morning. For unknown reasons, the regular gang on Fox & Friends Weekend was kicked to the curb today, replaced by the less entertaining gang from the weekday Fox & Friends.

The weekend gang is more Christianist and is therefore more entertaining—and also perhaps more instructive. We really think the time has come to start saying their names:

Fox & Friends Weekend, regular friends
Rachel Campos-Duffy
Pete Hegseth
Will Cain

This morning, those three had been kicked to the curb, replaced by the weekday message dispensers:

Fox & Friends (week days), regular friends
Brian Kilmeade
Steve Doocy
Ainsley Earhardt
Lawrence Jones

Of the seven. the genial Campos-Duffy is the most (Catholic) Christianist, and therefore the most intriguing. She's the most genial person on the face of the earth—until she starts discussing the Communists, Marxists and pagans she can spot under every bed.

With respect to such Others, a different persona prevails. She won't say the actual name of the political party to which such Others belong. Even now, she won't stop mispronouncing the first name of their presidential candidate. 

This is the way this genial person reacts in the presence of Others. This reaction is "human all the way down," major experts have routinely now said.

At any rate:

With respect to "all this now too much for us," we make this one suggestion:

It's time for tribunes in Blue America to start saying those names! It's time for those trusted tribunes to stop averting their gaze. 

Also, it's time for the rest of us somnolents to stop accepting the self-serving behavior of Blue American news orgs and pundits who keep playing this "Nothing to look at" game.

It's time to start saying their names! It's time to start reporting and discussing what those friends say and do. It's time to stop seeking safety in vastly overpaid careers. 

With this comes an obvious warning:

Our tribunes aren't going to stop behaving those ways! It's what these comfortable, overpaid stars are strongly inclined to do.

We offer one last point about this morning's offerings. Below, you see some of the shrieks of concern offered today by Maureen Dowd.

For the record, her headline refers to Tucker Carlson's recent announcement that he was clawed by demons last year, even as his wife and his dogs continued to sleep before the campfire he keeps going in the family cave. 

Needless to say, Dowd's newspaper hasn't reported this coming-out announcement by Carlson. As she mentions Carlson's announcement in passing, her column offers a basic description of Candidate Donald J. Trump:

All the Demons Are Here

[...]

Donald Trump’s private life is marked by a cascade of sordid episodes. But so is his public life. Trump simply has no character.

When I asked a scholar what Shakespearean figure Trump most resembles, he replied that Trump is not complex enough to be one. You have to have a character to have a tragic flaw that mars your character.

And that raises the question: How did the America of George Washington never telling a lie, the America of Honest Abe, the America of the Greatest Generation, the America of Gary Cooper facing down a murderous gang alone in “High Noon”—how did this America, our America, become a place where a man with no character has an even chance of being re-elected president?

[...]

Donald Trump is a human algorithm, always ratcheting up antagonism. He’s a personification and exploiter of all the things creating anxiety in people’s lives.

I sat in Madison Square Garden for eight hours last Sunday, working my way through a box of popcorn, a large pretzel and two bags of peanut M&M’s. I was surprised when some commentators reacted with shock at some of the insults slung that day.

For me, it seemed like a pretty typical Trump rally: ugly, dark, crude, denigrating, racist, misogynistic. (Sid Rosenberg, a conservative radio host, helped kick things off by calling Hillary Clinton “a sick son of a bitch.”) Speakers included Elon Musk, R.F.K. Jr. and Tucker Carlson, who thinks a demon clawed him while he was in bed last year.

[...]

It’s no surprise that Trump provided last-minute evidence of the character he lacks. As he said about being the Protector of Women, he will do it “whether they like it or not.” That’s the way it is with Trump and women—whether they like it or not.

I would have been more shocked if Trump had used his big moment at the Garden to offer a sunnier vision...

[...]

But that would have been the human thing to do. And Trump doesn’t care about human niceties. He just wants to be the biggest beast in the jungle, to take whatever he wants, in any way he can get it.

Trump can play it round or square, pro-choice or anti-abortion, pro-TikTok or anti-TikTok, pro-crypto or anti-crypto. He has no philosophy, except: What’s in it for him? The only thread of continuity in his life is self-interest. 

[...]

He wakes up obsessing on how to reward himself and his family and friends and how to punish his enemies. He wakes up plotting how to pit people against one another.

Maureen Dowd is a good, decent person. She's also extremely human.

In today's column, she has chosen a certain way to describe Candidate Trump. He is "a man with no character," she says again and again.

He wants to be the biggest beast. He doesn't care about being human!

How did we ever get to the place where some such candidate could be elected again? In some part, the answer lies with the fairly obvious pro-Trump slant which was evident in Dowd's work during the 2016 campaign, the apparent product of her loathing of that year's Candidate Clinton.

Meanwhile, there exist certain medical / psychiatric terms for the type of person Dowd describes in this morning's column. That said, and for better or worse, people like Dowd have reached certain guild-wide agreements:

They've agreed that the names and behaviors of the Fox News friends must never be reported or discussed. Also, they've agreed that that we must never discuss one of the obvious possible explanations for the portrait she draws of the bedeviled Candidate Trump.

We humans! We simply aren't built for this line of work! 

The anthropologists Cummings and Brabender have described this problem best—but the self-serving silence of Blue America's "journalistic" elite keeps our nation pinwheeling down on this latest Sunday before we choose.

Could the beast lose the Hawkeye State? We have no idea!

Pepperidge Farm remembers: On the Sunday before the 2000 election, Dowd opened her column with an extended portrait of Candidate Gore. The candidate was portrayed standing before a mirror singing "I Feel Pretty" as he contemplated his bald spot.

If memory serves, that was the seventh (7th!) column Dowd had built around the candidate's troubling Spot. "If I rub in a tad more of this mahogany-colored industrial mousse, the Spot will disappear under my Reagan pompadour," she pictured the giddy candidate saying, right at the start of her column.

So it went in the New York Times on that Sunday before an election! This was part of the endless gong-show Dowd created in subsequent years in which she weirdly kept saying that Democratic Party women were actually men, while Democratic Party men were actually women. 

According to experts, those columns about the Spot were human, all too human. Needless to say, none of Blue America's other stars said a single word! 

Dearest darlings, use your heads! As the nation spirals down, it simply isn't done!


SATURDAY: The Five and the friends have been pushing back hard!

SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 2, 2024

Out of many mouths, one: E pluribus unum! The leading authority on the traditional motto starts by telling us this:

E pluribus unum 

E pluribus unum ( Latin for "Out of many, one") is a traditional motto of the United States, appearing on the Great Seal along with Annuit cœptis (Latin for "he approves the undertaking") and Novus ordo seclorum (Latin for "New order of the ages") which appear on the reverse of the Great Seal; its inclusion on the seal was suggested by Pierre Eugene du Simitiere and approved in an act of the Congress of the Confederation in 1782. While its status as national motto was for many years unofficial, E pluribus unum was still considered the de facto motto of the United States from its early history. Eventually, the U.S. Congress passed an act in 1956 (H. J. Resolution 396), adopting "In God We Trust" as the official motto.

That the phrase "E pluribus unum" has thirteen letters makes its use symbolic of the original Thirteen Colonies which rebelled against the rule of the Kingdom of Great Britain...

In Latin, it even has thirteen letters! So the authority says.

Out of many, one! It was once considered to be the national motto. Today, it could be the motto of the Fox News Channel, whose many mouths have swung into action defending Candidate Trump with respect to what he recently said about nine rifles shooting at the face of the "very stupid" Liz Cheney.

Our of many corporate noggins, one uniform point of view! This is also a bit of a problem on the programs of MSNBC, the channel which spent year upon year pushing the now-abandoned desire to lock Donald Trump up.

Candidate Harris walked away from that standard theme, which had been beaten to death on MSNBC over the endless long years. We'll guess that the framework didn't poll especially well, a point we'd been suggesting for years right here at this site.

Whatever! Let's return to the tragicomic, soul-crushing problem which is found wherever the Fox friends roam.

Under the sway of a modern practice—it's known as "Segregation by viewpoint"—almost everyone who appears on a Fox News Channel program will agree, in every particular, with almost everyone else. And so it was, this very morning, on the sad show, Fox & Friends Weekend, with the three regular friends seated right there on the couch:

Fox & Friends Weekend: November 2, 2024
Will Cain: regular co-host
Rachel Campos-Duffy: regular co-host
Pete Hegseth: regular co-host

They're all extremely regular! Quite reliably, these friends will agree with each other on every conceivable point. 

As with MSNBC panels, so too on this ersatz news program. "Seldom is heard a discouraging word" as the messaging moves forward.

Presumably, the Murdochs could save a lot on salary if they assigned just one of the three friends to go on the air and read the day's mandated points. We'll take a guess:

Apparently, it looks more like a panel discussion when a trio of friends appear.

Is there some discernible point to this standard cable procedure? Is there some point to assembling a four- or five-member panel, if every member of the panel is guaranteed to agree with everyone else on every conceivable topic?

Presumably, there's major propaganda value to that procedure. There's propaganda value there, but not a whole lot else.

At any rate, the friends were very busy this morning defending Donald J. Trump. The same mandate had been observed yesterday afternoon at the start of The Five.

The Five is the most-watched program in all of cable news. It's also one of the programs on which the panelists don't all agree.

The popular program achieves its frisson from the inclusion of one liberal panelist who may well disagree. The fun starts with "the killing of the pig"—with the way The Four will interrupt and overtalk The One if the dissenter starts making a point which is perhaps a bit too sharp.

At such moments, the program recalls a seminal scene from the 1946 Hitchcock film, Notorious. In that scene, the Ingrid Bergman character suddenly realizes that she's being poisoned by the group of Nazis she has infiltrated through an insincere marriage. 

(When she mistakenly reaches for the cup of coffee which hasn't been poisoned, several of the Nazis respond in alarm, thereby creating an unmistakable "tell." For the record, we're speaking here of literal "Nazis;" there is no question of overwrought rhetoric. The Nazis have been slowly poisoning the Bergman character because they've learned that she's an American agent. The drama spools forward from there.)

To watch that seminal scene from Notorious, just click here. For us, the behavior of the four scripted players on The Five often recalls that scene, in tragicomic fashion.

Yesterday, the scripted players began the program with a defense of what their candidate said, the day before, about Liz Cheney. The lineup looked like this: 

The Five: November 1, 2024
Judge Jeanine: regular co-host
Jesse Watters: regular co-host
Greg Gutfeld: regular co-host
Martha MacCallum: substitute co-host
Jessica Tarlov: The Other

Jessica Tarlov was cast as The One, sitting among The Four. MacCallum was sitting in as a guest co-host, replacing the eternally compliant Dana Perino.

The various players were in place! Here's the way MacCallum started, still at 5:00 sharp:

MACCALLUM (11/1/24): ...Matt Drudge, blaring out this headline: "Trump calls for Cheney's execution." And other outlets quickly following suit as they mischaracterized some comments by former president Trump, made last night, about Liz Cheney being a war hawk. But listen to this closely:

At this point, Mccallum aired videotape of Candidate Trump's remarks to Tucker Carlson about "the very stupid" Cheney. And no! Unless you've gone around the bend, the former president wasn't literally calling for Cheney's literal execution.

Unless you've gone around the bend, he wasn't doing that!  He was doing something different—he was employing remarkably violent rhetoric as he savaged a "very stupid person" with whom he disagrees.

In his comments to Carlson, the former president wasn't literally calling for Cheney's literal execution. That wasn't the problem with what he did. At this highly fraught time—a time riddled with violent behavior by suggestible people—the problem was something different.

McCallum had played the videotape of what the former president said. She now offered this:

MACCALLUM: So the press wasted no time to follow Drudge's lead and did twist those comments. Watch this:

KASIE HUNT (videotape): Violent rhetoric. Donald Trump going after political foe Liz Cheney.

The press did twist Trump's comments, MacCallum assertively said. She then played that clip from CNN's Kasie Hunt—and that was the entire clip from Hunt. 

In the clip, Hunt hadn't "followed Drudge's lead" regarding execution. She had merely said that Trump used "violent rhetoric," which is of course what he did.

Under current arrangements, product like that is "close enough for Fox News Channel work." At any rate, the tightly edited video clips continued on from there. 

Of the five additional clips which MacCallum played, we'd have to say that only one even seemed to "follow Drudge's lead" in the manner described. That said, on a program like The Five, mandated corporate dogma will routinely take the place of competent journalism. 

At this point, four of the panelists took their turns insisting that the candidate had been viciously wronged all over "the media." In this unusual instance, Tarlov's response was so ineffectual that there was no need for everyone to interrupt her all at one, Notorious poisoning style.

The whole thing started up again when Fox & Friends Weekend convened. The trio of friends defended and defended and defended Trump again and again, an apparent sign that his use of violent rhetoric was perhaps doing him harm.

The friends took turns saying what they're paid to say. Stating the obvious, this sort of thing is a parody of journalism. It constitutes a fairly obvious "cancer on the democracy."

Thanks to the cyberattack on the Internet Archive, we can't link you to this morning's clowning. If you have the right sort of cable connection, you can watch last evening's edition of The Five simply by clicking here.

We'll close today with an observation about Fox friend Campos-Duffy.

Even now, months later, she still refuses to pronounce the name of the Democratic candidate in the way that person's name is correctly pronounced. Campos-Duffy is extremely genial among her friends, but is willing to behave this way with respect to Others.

With respect to Communists, Marxists, pagans and Others, the good cheer of this genial person quickly disappears. According to experts, this behavior is "human, all too human." 

It's human all the way down.

At any rate, the friends and The Four have been pushing back hard. The implied motto of such programming is clear:

Out of many (mouths), one!


HOW WE GOT HERE: Clawed by demons as his dogs slept!

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 1, 2024

Is Donald Trump mentally ill? Is the Republican candidate, Donald J. Trump, (some version of) mentally ill? 

We regard that as one of the major questions to emerge from the current campaign. A second major question would be this:

Are we the people—are we humans—really built for this line of work?

By that second question, we mean the following:

Given our basic wiring, are we humans built for the task of running a modern "democracy?' Are we built for the (relatively recent) task of adhering to "Enlightenment values?"

Also are we built for the task of maintaining a "rational" discourse? Or is something else possible?

Is it possible that certain new realities—the so-called "democratization of media; the relative ease of international travel—have created a world which is "now too much for us," to borrow an old phrase from Frost? 

Have those new realities created a world within which we aren't equipped to function? So it goes as we ask you, once again, if Donald Trump may be "mentally ill."

Is Donald Trump "mentally ill?" We've routinely put such terms inside scare quotes because the very concept of "mental illness" remains remarkably fuzzy. 

Is "mental illness" simply a metaphor, in which we draw a fuzzy comparison with the more straightforward concept of physical illness?

No one doubts that measles is real, but is "sociopathy" (to cite one example) some equivalent manifestation? Or is "sociopathy" (to cite one example) simply a form of bad behavior? 

Is "mental illness" just an excuse? Here's part of the leading authority's profile of Thomas Szasz:

Thomas Szasz

Thomas Stephen Szasz (1920 – 2012) was a Hungarian-American academic and psychiatrist. He served for most of his career as professor of psychiatry at the State University of New York Upstate Medical University. A distinguished lifetime fellow of the American Psychiatric Association and a life member of the American Psychoanalytic Association, he was best known as a social critic of the moral and scientific foundations of psychiatry...

[...]

Mental illness is a myth

In Szasz's view, people who are said to have a mental illness only have "problems in living." Diagnoses of "mental illness" or "mental disorder" are passed off as scientific but are judgments (of disdain) to support certain uses of power by authorities. In that line of thinking, schizophrenia becomes not the name of a disease entity but a judgment of extreme psychiatric and social disapprobation. Szasz called schizophrenia "the sacred symbol of psychiatry" because those so labeled have long provided and continue to provide justification for psychiatric theories, treatments, abuses, and reforms.

He argued that psychiatry is a pseudoscience that parodies medicine by using medical-sounding words...

And so on from there. That said, we restate our first question:

Is Donald Trump some version of mentally ill? In our view, this is the one of the seminal questions which has emerged from the current campaign. Nor is he the only major public figure concerning whom this question might well be asked.

Is Trump some version of mentally ill? As we've repeatedly noted, it's a question our high-end journalists have agreed that we must never explore. That too is part of the second question we ask:

As a species, are we humans built for the current task? As a species, are we humans built for the modern world's ongoing moral and intellectual challenges?

Is the one candidate mentally ill? We think it's a seminal question! 

However you want to parse that question, there he sat, just yesterday, saying such things as you can see below. We compliment the Washington Post for the way it has chosen to report this matter:

Trump suggests ‘war hawk’ Liz Cheney should have guns ‘trained on her face’

GLENDALE, Ariz. — Former president Donald Trump appeared to suggest on Thursday that former congresswoman and longtime Trump critic Liz Cheney should be subjected to gunfire as he called her a “war hawk,” saying during a live event with Tucker Carlson, “Let’s see how she feels about it,” with guns “trained on her face” as a target.

Trump went on a tangent about his pardon of Lewis “Scooter” Libby, a former top aide to Vice President Dick Cheney, and then talked about Liz Cheney—the former vice president’s daughter, who broke with the GOP to denounce Trump over the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol.

“His daughter is a very dumb individual, very dumb,” Trump said. “She’s a radical war hawk. Let’s put her with a rifle standing there with nine barrels shooting at her, okay? Let’s see how she feels about it. You know, when the guns are trained on her face.”

“They’re all war hawks when they’re sitting in Washington in a nice building, saying, ‘Oh gee, let’s send 10,000 troops right in the mouth of the enemy,’” he added.

We'll note that the headline understates what the candidate seems to have said. 

The candidate didn't simply say that Cheney "should have guns trained on her face." In his usual jumbled fashion, he also seemed to say that she should have to stand there "with nine barrels shooting at her."

She should have to face, and be shot by, a firing squad! That said, the Post's report about the candidate's behavior continues directly as shown:

Trump also attacked several other prominent Republicans who have criticized him, closing out one of his final days on the campaign trail with an event that seemed geared toward his base rather than swing voters.

He called his former national security adviser John Bolton a “nut job” and a “moron.”

“I could see his face get red, red, red, with that stupid white mustache, and he’d be ready to explode,” Trump said. “When Kim Jong Un saw him, he said: ‘Oh s---. I think the guy wants to go to war.’ So he was great for me to negotiate with.”

He mocked “crying Adam Kinzinger,” the former Republican congressman who was part of a Democratic-led House select committee that investigated the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol by a pro-Trump mob.

“They’re not select—they’re scum,” Trump said of the committee.

And he went after Rep. Adam Schiff (D-California), describing him as a “watermelon head,” “real scum” and “unattractive both inside and out.”

For better or worse, this is highly unusual conduct by a major party presidential nominee. In our view, the New York Times has broken its back, down through the years, in its refusal to treat this departure from American norms as a major front-page news framework.

This kind of behavior by Candidate Trump's represents a giant departure from traditional American norms. We think such departures from long-standing norms is major news whenever it happens. But does it suggest the possibility that the candidate is mentally ill?

For better or worse, the entire upper-end press corps has agreed that we must never ask. That said, Trump was speaking to Tucker Carlson yesterday when he made those unusual remarks. As reported at Mediaite, here is the latest on him:

Tucker Carlson Says Demon Attack Left Him Bleeding In His Bed With ‘Claw Mark’ Scars

Tucker Carlson said that he was “physically mauled” by a demon a year and a half ago that left him bleeding and with still-visible scars on his body from “claw marks” in a clip posted by the “Christianities?” YouTube channel on Thursday.

Asked by his interlocutor, John Heers, if he thought “the presence of evil is kickstarting people to wonder about the good?” Carlson answered “That’s what happened to me,” before recounting the story.

“I had a direct experience with it,” said Carlson.

“In the milieu of journalism?” asked Heers.

“No, in my bed at night,” replied Carlson. “And I got attacked while I was asleep with my wife and four dogs and mauled, physically mauled.”

“In a spiritual attack by a demon?” inquired Heers.

“Yeah, by a demon,” affirmed Carlson. “Or by something unseen that left claw marks on my sides.”

In his report at Mediaite, Isaac Schorr transcribes more of Carlson's remarks. 

Carlson's remarks are part of the trailer for a forthcoming documentary film. You can see the videotape of Carlson's fuller remarks at the Mediaite report, or simply by clicking here.

Was Tucker Carlson clawed by a demon eighteen months ago? Did he "rise from his warm bed," bleeding, while his wife and his four dogs slept?

So the gentleman has now said. Yesterday, he was the conduit for Candidate Trump's array of insults—and for his evocation of violence against Cheney.

All in all, riddle us this:

Are we humans, as a species, built for this modern world? Given our basic wiring, are we built for a post-Enlightenment world? Are we built for a world in which we are assumed to be "the rational animal?"

It seems to us that these are the basic questions which have emerged from our current campaign. It seems to us that our major news orgs have refused, every step of the way, to address these basic questions.

Is it possible that Trump is mentally ill? "Mental illness" is a fuzzy concept, and our high-ranking journalists seem happy to keep it that way.

(Quite often, these journalists "went to the finest schools." As we've noted in the past, we're not always entirely sure why they bothered to do that.)

Is it possible that Candidate Trump is mentally ill? We've long assumed that he is.

We've always recommended pity for people so afflicted, if that is the appropriate term—for the loss of human potential brought on by such afflictions. We've often suggested that Bob Dylan foresaw the coming of this particular beast way back in 1967:

I pity the poor immigrant

I pity the poor immigrant
Who wishes he would've stayed home
Who uses all his power to do evil
But in the end is always left so alone

That man whom with his fingers cheats
Who lies with every breath

Who passionately hates his life
And likewise fears his death

[...]

Who eats but is not satisfied
Who hears but does not see
Who falls in love with wealth itself
And turns his back on me

For those inclined to become upset, "immigrant" is a metaphor here. This prophetic song wasn't a news report. 

In our view, Candidate Harris has shown herself to have what Oliver Wendell Holmes once described as "a first-class temperament" during this campaign. (Holmes was speaking of President Franklin D. Roosevelt.)

She has often seemed to do a very poor job answering basic questions. That said, she's never lost her cool or abandoned her basic decency. We've come to greatly admire her for that.

 We're hoping that she emerges next Tuesday night as the winner of this election—though if she does, the civil war will only be starting then.

We'll almost surely have more on "mental illness" next week. We may even recall our many radio appearances with Professor Richard Vatz, who literally wrote the book about Szasz while qualifying as the nicest guy in the world.

"Mental illness" seems to be all around us at present! In certain obvious ways, the term may seem to be a metaphor. That said, it cloaks a much more basic question:

Are we the people—are we humans—built for this modern assignment? In Lincoln's words, are we equipped to succeed with "a task before [us] greater than that which rested upon Washington?"

Are we humans built for this work? Also, is it possible that one of our candidates may be mentally ill?

This is what we've been talking about!

THURSDAY, OCTOBER 31, 2024

Atlantic writer muses: In a new essay at the Atlantic, Megan Garber muses about what Candidate Trump said.

We invite you to take the Garber's Construct Challenge. Does this presentation make sense?

WHAT ORWELL DIDN'T ANTICIPATE

[...]

Earlier this month, Donald Trump mused aloud about the violence Americans might anticipate on November 5. If Election Day brings havoc, he told Fox News’s Maria Bartiromo, the crisis would come not from outside actors but instead from “the enemy from within”: “some very bad people,” he clarified, “some sick people”—the “radical-left lunatics.”

The former president further mused about a solution to the problem. “I think it should be very easily handled by, if necessary, by the National Guard,” he said, “or, if really necessary, by the military.”

A presidential candidate who may well retake the White House is threatening to use the military against American citizens: The news here is straightforward.

For the record, Trump "mused aloud about the violence Americans might anticipate on November 5" because he was specifically asked about that possibility by Bartiromo.

He didn't raise the topic himself; Bartiromo raised the topic. After Trump's one brief response, the two moved on from there. 

At any rate, ponder the logic of that construct. According to Garber, Trump was "threatening to use the military against American citizens" in his response to Bartiromo's question. The problem there seems fairly obvious:

Trump won't be president on November 5! President Biden would be able to call out the National Guard (or the military, "if really necessary") to deal with some type of "havoc" next Tuesday, but Candidate Trump wouldn't be able to do that.

He wouldn't be able to call out the Guard! With that in mind, in what way was he "threatening to use the military against American citizens" in his brief response to Bartiromo's hypothetical question?

"The news here is straightforward," Garber says. In our view, her logic pretty much isn't.

In sum:

Trump has said at least a million crazy things by now. That brief Q-and-A with Bartiromo struck us as a major nothingburger.

At that point, in our view, creative outrage took over. That said, the vast majority of the mainstream press has gone along with this construct.

(At the Times, they seem to know that this construct doesn't make sense. They just keep fact-checking around it!)