Supplemental: The mayor has been closing schools!


And the New York Times knows where they are:
To state the obvious, so-called race is a major force in all aspects of American life.

This is one of the legacies we’ve all been left by our ancestors. That said, we liberals don’t always do a sensational job picking our way through the mess.

Tomorrow, we’ll look at some of the ways Patricia Arquette got slammed for her Oscar night remarks. Some of the criticisms dealt with the way she discussed race.

For today, consider the way the New York Times tends to talk about race. We were struck by the latest effort on today’s front page.

Monica Davey and Julie Bosman were talking about public school closings in Chicago. These closings have played a role in Rahm Emanuel’s political problems as he seeks a second term as mayor.

Davey and Bosman discussed the school closings. Under a Chicago dateline, this is the way they began:
DAVEY AND BOSMAN (3/4/15): The sky-blue paint has begun to peel on the three-story building that was once Anthony Overton Elementary. Window air-conditioners are speckled with rust. Doors where children used to rush in and out are sealed with plywood.

The empty shell of this school on Chicago’s largely black South Side stands as a reminder of one of Rahm Emanuel’s defining acts as mayor: overseeing the closing of nearly 50 public schools deemed underperforming, underutilized or both. It was the largest closing of schools in memory, with many of them in black or Latino neighborhoods.
“Many of [the schools which got closed were] in black or Latino neighborhoods?” That is a very strange, yet very familiar framework.

What makes this familiar framework so strange? Only this—the fact that Chicago’s student population is less than ten percent white.

Chicago’s public schools are overwhelmingly black and Hispanic. Its schools are full of beautiful kids from “black and Latino neighborhoods.” If the city is going to close some schools, it seems obvious that “many” of the schools in question will be in these very neighborhoods.

But there the familiar framework sat, on page one, in paragraph 2 of today’s report. You had to read to paragraph 22 before Davey and Bosman mentioned the demographics of Chicago’s schools.

Was it a good idea to close these schools? People can differ about that. The financial reasons for the closings are detailed in the report.

But again and again, reporters in papers like the Times adopt this peculiar framework in their reports about urban school closings. Apparently, we’re supposed to be surprised—perhaps shocked—by the fact that the sky is blue.

Or are we supposed to be racially angered? The New York Times is in love with race. It likes to fret and fawn about racial matters, often in ways which don’t make much sense. This helps make us, the New York Times readers, feel upright, concerned, meritorious.

Many of the schools in question were in black or Latino neighborhoods! This is the most obvious state of affairs in the world. Why did it drive this report?


  1. "To state the obvious, so-called race . . ."

    So-called race? Do I really need to read on?

    1. That's what the plutocrats from Ore-Ida tell us.

    2. Race is a social construct. If you don't understand what that means, you don't know much about race. It is hard have a conversation about race when people don't understand basic facts about it.

    3. Ah, but what is "so-called" race? A "so-called" social construct?

    4. Is that a question or a pseudo-question?

  2. The troll is at its angriest when Bob talks about liberals who play the race card.

    1. No, the troll is at its angriest when flinging hot potatoes at critics of Bob.

    2. Bob does the flinging. I document the fact that you won't touch them.

    3. The "race card" was a term invented to describe an appeal to white voters based on racism. It is generally invoked today only by people it was invented to describe.

    4. Having made the rounds already this AM sputtering about spuds, Mr. Perez seems to have deliberately avoided your comment @ 9:50PM.

  3. How many majority white schools are there in Chicago? Did it make financial sense to close the schools? I will be back tonight to review how many times the troll dared touch any of these two hot potatoes. Warming: He doesn't like getting burned.

    1. Public or private?

      If you're Rahm, or you hate teacher's unions, or you luuv for-profit education.

      Back to the oven, plebe.

    2. The two questions are answered with another question as Dodger deems the temperature in the potatoes too high.

      Dodger seems to have never thought of the financial aspects of the closures prior to this day as he said peep about it. I will be back later to further analyze the performance of the race card players.

    3. Tots. Hot tots. The tot man is here. Hot tots. Red tots.

    4. Dodge the tots. Tots are hot. Hot for trolls.

  4. Bob (oh, who am I kidding, he never reads comments, even though he cites comments on other sites in his posts): The schools were closed in predominantly black neighborhoods, almost all on the city's South and West Sides. Chicago schools in predominantly white neighborhoods were left alone - even though those schools are predominantly filled with students of color. The selective enrollment schools that are predominantly white were also left alone. So predominantly black neighborhoods were the ones losing community anchors. That's a big reason why Rahm is now in a runoff. (In other words, the demographic nature of neighborhoods is different than schools. By the logic you employ here, *all* of Chicago's public schools would be located on the South and West Sides. But they are not. They are dispersed throughout the city, including white neighborhoods.)

  5. That last comment was by me. I'm don't need to be anonymous - in fact, I'm against it.

  6. A. Perez: It did not make financial sense to close the schools. Study after study of city after city that closes schools en masse finds that money is not saved, and quite often money is lost. The closing costs are enormous; just as many students have to be served; the "welcoming" schools had to receive investments of all sorts; logistical nightmare. All documented in the press, despite what Rahm keeps saying.

  7. I dedicate this comment to A."Tater Tot" Perez.

    Bob Somerby wants us to answer questions about Chicago's schools?

    Or does Bob wants us to question how the New York Times frames closures in Chicago schools almost two years after the decision was made?

    Baltimore Bob and his New York news fixation may have missed it, but two years ago when the Chicago school closings were news to people actually living with the impact on their lives and the lives of the children, the plan was flat out called racist by the head of the Chicago teacher's union, Karen Lewis. And the reason she did, as local media noted, was that almost all of the schools proposed for closure were in black neighborhoods, not black AND Hispanic neighborhoods, and the vast majority of the students in the proposed schools were black.

    Chicago has the third largest school system in the country. It has been home to the largest teachers strike and school closure since the election of Rahm Emanuel. You know how many posts Bob devoted to these events and their coverage? One. You know what the main topic of that post was? That Joe Nocera of the New York Times didn't properly report on progress on the NAEP.

    By the way, do you know how many times Karen Lewis has been mentioned in the Howler? Karen Lewis, head of the "ratty" teacher's union, who called the closure plan "racist" and Rahm Emmanuel "the Murder Mayor"? Once as well. Because she was mentioned in a block quote Baltimore Bob cut and pasted from New York Nocera's column about the doings in the Windy City schools.

    How many posts did Baltimore Bob do on one article about one school in one town in Alabama named Tuscaloosa?

    Baltimore Bob. See anything in today's post that shows he cares about kids, other than calling them "beautiful"?

    1. Urban legend goes Anonymous to repeat the fact that most these kids are minorities, which we all knew. . No analysis of the financial aspects. The hot potatoes go untouched.

    2. Hot potato or hot turd?

    3. 11:20, Bob only cares about kids to the extent that he can use them as clubs in his rhetorical war against "liberals." Oh, excuse me. "Pseudo-liberals." Our Own Harvard Blogger has told us repeatedly that he is the One True Liberal.

    4. Mr. Perez's Tots have passed their "Use By" date and he is apparently insufficiently equipped to understand that.

    5. Anon 11:20 apparently does not understand that Karen Lewis cannot get into this blog, since she is not part of the media. If she was misquoted badly enough, then Bob might point that out. The question at hand is whether the NYT was acting in a journalistic manner when they described the closing of schools "many in them in black or Latino neighborhoods" without pointing out that the majority of schools *are* in black or Latino neighborhoods. Is it fair for the NYT to put their thumb on the scales in a new article?

  8. As I see it so-called race is a major force in all aspects of American life. We’re all that's left of our ancestors. That said, we liberals don’t always do a sensational job picking our way through the mess in large part because of the bogus claims and gorilla dust thrown up by journalists, professors and “experts” over here in our camp.

  9. This comment box is infested with seething trolls who, at this late morning hour, are twitching for some more good stuff on one of the Arquette sisters who have become the Howler equivalent of the Hiltons or Kardashians.

    Can we have some more, sir?

    1. Poor Somerby. He has been scooped on both E-mailghazi and the latest Clinton jihad by Media Matters and the leftist "Crooks and Liars!

      Just shows you how these mainstream Maoists in the blogosphere fail to appreciate the importance of gorilla dust spreading professors in our discourse over Oscar acceptance speeches.

  10. Links: Start with these and go from there. //

  11. What's the opposite of a euphemism? These kids are "underperforming" because they're being compared to elite, heavily white/ middle class magnet schools, and the Latino kids here are often from immigrant backgrounds. That unfair comparison is the excuse to push them into the private sector. It's the only set of statistics they have that aren't fraudulent! Chicago is under pressure by the investment bankers to privatize everything, and to do this they're selling this story that schools are broken. But at the same time, they can't lie to themselves and say there's no resistance. So they come up with this half-truth that the lower classes just can't afford a good education. Test, test, test until the drones are all good efficient worker bees.

  12. Do You Need an urgent loan of any Amount? Then contact us now, we give out all
    kinds of loans with a very low interest rate of 2%. Contact us with your name,
    1)Full Names:................................................
    6)Marital Status:........................................
    8)Phone Number:.......................................
    10)Monthly income:....................................
    11)Next of Kin:..............................................
    12)Loan Amount Needed:.............................
    13)Loan Duration:...........................................
    14)Purpose of Loan:.......................................

  13. Hello every body....
    My name is Evalin Grishem, my family and i live together live in USA. It was after seven years i got to discover that my Husband was unfaithful to me. I didn't know what was going on at first but as he got deep in the affair with his new lover, i felt that our marriage was on the rocks. I notice that he no longer light up when i touch him or kiss him in his neck and his chest cos he really liked it when i did that, he also usually get naked in front of me but when he started seeing that woman he stopped it. I remember asking him if i have done anything that makes him feel irritated when i am around him then he gives silly excuses that he has been feeling stressed up and that he need space for a while. I know when you are been asked for space its usually because there is something fishy going on. I hired a private investigator to help find out what was going on. And in a week time he brought me prove that my Husband that i have lived with for seven straight year is cheating on me with his high school lover. I had picture of him walking out a of a restaurant with her and many other photo of them kissing in public like he will never be caught by someone that knows he is my Husband. I asked myself, even when we had a daughter together he could do this to me. That same night i showed him the pictures that i got from my private investigator. He didn't look at it before saying, that he is seeing someone and he know that i just found out about it. Then he said that he is in love with her. At that moment, i didn't know if to kill myself or to kill him but the button line is that if i was going to kill anyone it was going to be me because i was so much in love with him to even think of thinking to hurt him. As time goes on he asked for a divorce and got it and i got custody of our daughter and i weep everyday seeing my daughter with out being around her daddy. I just couldn't get my mind off my Husband and all i could think about was getting him back and live as every family should. For a year i tried all i could to get him back with the help of my seven year old daughter. Even at that all effect was in vain, i used the help of his friend but turned out all bad. I know most people don't believe in spell casting but believe me this was my last option and the result i most say was impressive. And i know it difficult to believe but A SPELL CASTER Dr iayaryi really made my life much better because he gave me my family back. He didn't ask me to pay for what he did for me all i was to do, was to provide the materials for the spell and i should believe that he had the power to help me. Like he said, he was going to do something that will make him reset his love and affection for me just as it has always been. My Husband told me he woke up and realized that he should have never left me that i am all he needs.To make thing clear, his life with his high school lover was great before Dr iayaryi cast the spell, they had no disagreement on anything. My Husband said it himself that why he broke up with her is something he can not explain just that he woke up on the same bed with her after a very romantic night saying he is breaking up with her for no reason at all. Only Dr iayaryi can do such a thing, contact him to solve your problem with his email


  14. Do you need a loan to pay your bills? You need
    personal or business loan? Need a loan for various
    other purposes? If so, please contact us today
    ( for a loan.
    We offer the largest loan in the amount of $ 5,000.000.00. we offer
    Loan @ 2.5% fixed interest rate for the entire term
    1-30 years. We give six months grace period to
    It begins monthly payment. So if you are interested,
    Please complete the form below and return to us as
    as soon as possible for processing.
    Full name: ……………….
    Gender: ……………….
    Age: …………………
    Address: …………….
    City: …………………..
    Country: ………………
    Loan amount: …………..
    Term Loan: ………….
    Phone number: …………….
    Occupation: ……………….
    Income: …………..
    Purpose of the loan: ……………..
    Have you applied for a loan before? ………….

    God Bless You All

    Mrs Loveth Miller

  15. Dear Sir/ Madam

    Do you need a quick long or short term loan with a relatively low interest rate as low as 2%? We offer Xmas loan, business loan, personal loan, home loan, auto loan, student loan, debt consolidation loan, Business loan e.t.c no matter the amount needed apply
    7.AMOUNT NEEDED..........
    8.LOAN DURATION:.........
    9.PURPOSE OF LOAN..........
    12.YOUR MONTHLY INCOME..........
    13.MODE OF REPAYMENT:..........,
    The Linenhall,
    32-38 Linenhall Street
    BT2 8BG , Belfast
    United Kingdom


    DIRECTORS Dr. Astrid JUNGE (Chairman), Alhaji D.N.Dangoze, (Vice Chairman), Pastor F C. Kumayor, Dr. Adam Smith Chief Wolfgang NIERSBACH (Director) Finance, Dr James Kelly, Steffi JONES (Secretary), Helmut SANDROCK
    Director) Finance, Dr James Kelly, Steffi JONES (Secretary), Helmut SANDROCKzz

  16. NAME: Kevin Hess
    do you need an urgent loan to slove problems, well we offer all kinds of loan such as Business loan,student loan,investment loan,housing loan,debt consolidation loan,company loan,car loan e.t.c. at a rate of 2%. we are legit tested and trusted lenders all around the world.hurry up now and contact us for your Loan today at our Email: or whatsapp us on +17609739252

  17. NAME: Kevin Hess
    do you need an urgent loan to slove problems, well we offer all kinds of loan such as Business loan,student loan,investment loan,housing loan,debt consolidation loan,company loan,car loan e.t.c. at a rate of 2%. we are legit tested and trusted lenders all around the world.hurry up now and contact us for your Loan today at our Email: or whatsapp us on +17609739252