THE DUMBNESS OF THE WHALE: Verdict first, information never!


Part 3—Ahab in Wonderland:
It has long been a basic precept of our press corps’ consensus scandals:

Verdict first, information never!

Information must never intrude on the prearranged judgment which permits the fun of consensus scandal.

Analysis? What’s that?

Who is the Ahab of the current scandal—the scandal concerning air pressure of footballs? That Ahab would seem to be Ryan Grigson, general manager of the Indianapolis Colts.

According to the NFL’s official “Wells report” (see page 45), Grigson sent an email to league officials before last January’s playoff game against the New English Patriots. It included a note about the bad conduct of Grigson’s personal whale:
EMAIL FROM COLTS OFFICIALS: As far as the game balls are concerned it is well known around the league that after the Patriots game balls are checked by the officials and brought out for game usage the ballboys for the Patriots will let out some air with a ball needle because their quarterback likes a smaller football so he can grip it better, it would be great if someone would be able to check the air in the game balls as the game goes on so that they don’t get an illegal advantage.
Question: If it was “well known around the league” that the Patriots had been doctoring footballs, why had no one ever complained to the league before this?

The Wells report skips all such questions. In fairness, it did note this:

“The Grigson email did not contain any factual support for the suspicions raised, and the NFL was unaware of any factual support prior to the game.”

Lack of factual support is often observed at the start of our consensus scandals. Things spiral downward from there.

In this case, the NFL soon found itself seeking more information from the Colts. As a result, the Wells report goes on to describe the Colts’ previous encounter with their own personal white whale.

It happened in Week 11, the last time the Patriots played the Colts. Sean Sullivan is the Colts’ skillful equipment manager:
WELLS REPORT (page 46): During interviews, when asked to explain the source of their concerns about the Patriots game balls, Grigson, Sullivan, and other members of the Colts equipment staff referenced the Colts Week 11 game against the Patriots in Indianapolis. During that game, Colts strong safety Mike Adams intercepted two passes thrown by Tom Brady. On both occasions, Adams handed the footballs to Brian Seabrooks, an Assistant Equipment Manager for the Colts, on the sideline. Sullivan also examined the footballs because, as he described it, he always checks to see how other teams prepare their balls to “make sure no one is doing a better job.” Sullivan and Seabrooks said that the intercepted footballs appeared to be coated in a tacky substance and seemed spongy or soft when squeezed. They explained that even though they did not test the air pressure of the intercepted footballs at the time, based on their years of experience, the softness of the balls raised suspicions. They also cited unspecified chatter throughout the League that the Patriots prefer their footballs softer than other teams and that visiting teams should be on guard when playing at Gillette Stadium. They could not identify a specific source for this information or reference particular conversations.
Just for the record, “unspecified chatter” is also widely observed at the start of consensus scandals.

Back in Week 11, Colts personnel didn’t attempt to measure the air pressure of the highly suspicious footballs their player intercepted. They based their suspicion on “their years of experience” and their presumed expertise.

That said, it may be just as well that the Colts didn’t try to perform an actual act of measurement. During the playoff game in January, they did attempt to conduct such a measurement of a ball which was intercepted.

Despite their years of experience, their attempt at measurement didn’t go especially well. The Wells report continues the tale. As it does, our first statistic appears:
WELLS REPORT (page 63): At approximately 7:47 p.m., during the second quarter of the AFC Championship Game, Colts linebacker D’Qwell Jackson intercepted a pass thrown by Tom Brady. Following the interception upon reaching the sideline, Jackson handed the ball to David Thornton, the Colts Director of Player Engagement, near the Colts bench and Thornton immediately handed the ball to Assistant Equipment Manager Brian Seabrooks. According to Seabrooks, he believed that the ball felt similar to the footballs intercepted by Mike Adams during the Colts game against the Patriots earlier in the season, so he asked one of the team‟s equipment interns to locate a pressure gauge and test the inflation level of the intercepted ball. The intern used a digital pressure gauge similar to the gauge used by the Colts to set their footballs before the game, and reported that the pressure measured approximately 11 psi. Seabrooks then walked with the intercepted football to Equipment Manager Sean Sullivan, who squeezed the ball and agreed that it felt soft.
The Wells report doesn’t explain the basis on which the Colts believed they had the right to measure one of the Patriots’ footballs. Concern for the NFL’s sacred rules is selectively observed in this official report.

At any rate:

For unknown reasons, the Colts directed an intern to measure the pressure of the ball. The intern reported that it “measured approximately 11 psi.”

Conducting his own detailed probe, Sullivan “squeezed the ball and agreed that it felt soft.” But thanks to the intern’s work, we now had our first statistic.

We also had the start of a farce in which the NFL established the fact that it didn’t know how to measure air pressure as of the date in question.

Uh-oh! As events unfolded on the day of the playoff game, NFL officials proceeded to measure the air pressure of that same football.

In fact, they measured it three different times. Needless to say, they came up with three different readings, as revealed on page 70 of the Wells report:

11.35 psi; 11.45 psi; 11.75 psi.

The Wells report doesn’t say what air pressure gauge was used to produce that welter of readings. But by now, the NFL had nailed it down! The air pressure of the intercepted football was one of the values shown below. You can take your pick!

11.0 psi; 11.35 psi; 11.45 psi; 11.75 psi

It was like the old joke about the weather. If you don’t like the air pressure readings in New England, just wait a while!

Perhaps you’re starting to see our general point. Although it never bats an eye at the chaos it is describing, the Wells report goes on to describe ludicrous conduct by a gang which couldn’t measure air pressure straight.

For this one football alone, the Wells report presents four different air pressure readings, across a rather wide range. And the league’s attempts at data collection only became more clownish from there, as we’ve described in previous reports.

After its clownish attempts at data collection, the league proceeded to Step 2 in its probe—the dissemination of false information to the press corps and the Patriots.

A bunch of false statistics quickly appeared at ESPN and NBC Sports, attributed to “NFL sources.” And that wasn’t all! On page 100, the Wells report quotes a letter the NFL sent to the Patriots on the day after the game.

The letter was written by David Gardi, the NFL’s highly august Senior Vice President of Football Operations. This is part of what Senior Vice President Gardi falsely wrote:
LETTER FROM THE NFL TO THE PATRIOTS: The inspection, which involved each ball being inspected twice with different gauges, revealed that none of the Patriots‟ game balls were inflated to the specifications required under Rule 2, Section 1. In fact, one of the game balls was inflated to 10.1 psi, far below the requirement of 12½ to 13½ psi. In contrast, each of the Colts‟ game balls that was inspected met the requirements set forth above.
In fact, none of the footballs had been recorded at anywhere close to 10.1 psi on either of the NFL’s clownish dueling gauges. On page 101, the Wells report, seeing no evil in senior vice presidents, explains this small tiny completely understandable accidental minor pointless mistake:
WELLS REPORT (page 101): In fact, none of the Patriots game balls measured 10.1 psi when they were tested at halftime. We believe that there was an inadvertent error in communication of the results to Gardi. The NFL personnel providing the air pressure information to Gardi at the time did not have copies of the documents on which the measurements had been recorded by Richard Farley and were relying on memory alone. We do not believe that this error raises any doubt about the accuracy of the measurements recorded by Farley or any other relevant issue...In any event, with the knowledge and approval of League staff, we subsequently provided all of the air pressure data to counsel for the Patriots during the course of the investigation subject to a confidentiality commitment.
They relied on memory alone! At this point, you might also describe the NFL as “the gang that can’t write letters straight!”

The Wells report must be one of the most farcical documents ever released to the press corps. In the passage we’ve just posted, you see its authors blithely accepting a claim of innocence on behalf of the organization which was paying their very large fees—an organization which had apparently provided false information to the Patriots and to the national press corps.

Gardi was quickly given a pass for his astonishing conduct. But all through this same report, its authors turn backflips looking for ways to interpret every comment by their Patriotic targets in a criminal light.

On its face, this dual standard is farcical, and perhaps not obsessively honest. By the way:

Under the “confidentiality agreement” cited in the passage above, the NFL apparently told the Patriots that they couldn’t correct the false information which had appeared in the press. As of late March, the Patriots were finally allowed to see the real numbers—just so long as they agreed that the press and the public wouldn’t be told!

We’ve rarely seen a crazier document than the Wells report. It describes farcical conduct by the NFL, an organization which seemed to have no idea how air pressure works in footballs, or how it can be measured.

The Wells report describes farcical conduct by the NFL, but it never seems to notice. It also seems to describe dishonest conduct by the NFL. That too escapes its ken.

On its face, the Wells report has the look of a farcical document which isn’t obsessively honest. But by the time it was handed to the press, the outlines of our latest consensus scandal had already been settled.

Tomorrow, we’ll return to the New York Times to see how that famous newspaper presented the farcical problems which litter the Wells report. Let’s just say that these farcical elements were all disappeared by the Times.

Verdict first, information never! As the press corps happily clowned with its latest consensus scandal, an Ahab among the Colts met the Alice in Wonderland standards which have long prevailed across our “national press corps.”

Information never! Tomorrow, the pitiful Times.


  1. The metaphors are flying furious and fast mixing it up along the way. Now we have identified our Ahab, who is our white whale? For a while it seemed to be the press, but that didn't seem to make any sense in a Moby Dick context; the only person around here chasing the press is Mr. Somerby. Is it the various equipment managers? I am sure they are nice guys, but they are hardly of white whale stature. Is it the Patriots? Possibly, but why? What was the crime that justify giving it such mythic treatment? Under inflation of the ball? Or, as with Ahab, is it something else, something inherently and epically evil about the New England franchise? Ahab had only the one shoe to drop. Is it possible that the NFL investigator has two?

  2. Warning to casual readers of this blog: On Dec. 29, 1982, Kiss played their first concert with guitarist Vinnie Vincent, who took over for founding member Ace Frehley during the recording of their ‘Creatures of the Night‘ album.

    The opening night of Kiss’ 10th anniversary tour was meant to be two nights prior, in Rapid City, S.D. But according to, a severe snow storm cancelled that concert and made the 29th show at Bismarck, N.D., their kickoff instead. It was Kiss’ first time on a U.S. stage since a July 1980 New York City club date, which oddly enough served as the debut for new drummer Eric Carr.

    The combination of their new image and second straight impressive recording was finally enough to reverse the band’s fortunes. Yet, despite his impressive songwriting contributions, relations between Vincent and his band mates / employers continued to get worse. As a result, they parted ways prior to the release of 1984′s ‘Animalize,’ and a series of lawsuits and press battles followed. Vincent has largely been off the radar ever since.

  3. The Professors with deflated balls found the whale sleeping in the woods. The whale is sleeping in the woods where the liberals used to sleep before they emerged from the woods hurling R-bombs.

    1. Troll blather

    2. ...about nothing much that matters.

  4. Given the chaos about measurement of the air pressure in the balls, why did the Patriots withdraw their appeal of the NFL's penalties against them?

    1. Since Goodell is a dictator that will do whatever insane thing is necessary to appease the ESPN gods for better PR, would you want to get on his bad side?

    2. I suspect that it would serve to put the blame on the organization, rather than a single member (Brady). $1 million is probably less costly than having Brady sit out even one game.

    3. I don't think there is an appeal process for the team with regard to league imposed discipline. So there wasn't anything to withdraw. Essentially, Kraft has decided not to pursue other legal remedies through the US court system.

  5. If this how this NFL is going to act they should save some money and fire the worthless Goodell and just do whatever the hacks at ESPN prattle on about.

  6. One would think that the NFL will have to test footballs at halftime somewhat regularly now. How are they going to deal with the results routinely being the same as those for which the Patriots are now being penalized?

    1. I doubt they will tell anyone the results.

    2. BINGO! Top prize for 1:55 who actually understands what's happening.

      "How are they going to deal with the results" indeed.

    3. That could well be their strategy, since they're making up stuff on the fly. But it won't work.

  7. Thomas Friedman says in the NY Times today:


    Thomas L. Friedman

    Continue reading the main story Share This Page





    Continue reading the main story

    Continue reading the main story Continue reading the main story

    This story is included with an NYT Opinion subscription.

    Learn more »

    For a presidential campaign that has started so early, it’s striking how little most of the candidates want to engage with major issues of the day, let alone the future. Hillary Clinton won’t take a clear stand on two big issues she helped to negotiate as secretary of state: the free-trade deal with Pacific nations and the nuclear deal with Iran."

    He also explains the things Bush and Rubio are being asked about. Here's my gripe. Clinton has been laying out major policies about a range of issues no one has been discussing much, most recently heroin addiction. The pundits have been ignoring those statements and demanding she answer their questions about Benghazi, email servers, Foundation donations etc. Friedman thinks Clinton should take a stand on an issue where she was enacting Obama's policies. Anyone can see why she cannot do that -- she cannot repudiate Obama when she needs his support in her campaign and she cannot run by admitting she made mistakes as Sec of State (implied if she does criticize Obama's trade policies). It is ridiculous to claim that she has been avoiding talking about serious issues because she won't step into this particular trap.

    So, the latest meme seems to be that Clinton is evasive and won't talk to the press about serious issues. Never mind that she has been talking to the public about issues others have routinely ignored ever since starting her campaign. On last night's news (CBS Scott Pelley), she was shown responding to reporters' questions, then chastised because she only answer 7 while other candidates have been more accessible. So, apparently, whatever she does isn't going to be enough to disconfirm this meme.

    1. Sorry for the garbage inadvertently picked up when I tried to cut and paste the quote.

    2. You have to applaud Mrs. Clinton for coming out against heroin addiction and standing up to Big Heroin!

    3. "So, the latest meme seems to be that Clinton is evasive and won't talk to the press about serious issues."

      This is the mainstream media for the past several weeks:


      Then in the next breath,

      "Why won't Hillary talk to us?"

    4. Clinton's program is about how to deal with heroin addiction. It is corollary to reducing criminal penalties for drug use. It is traditional for liberals to address social problems like this. It is also traditional for conservative candidates to say they are opposed to heroin while refusing to fund intervention to help people struggling with addiction. I doubt you are aware that heroin is being abused by people who start with pain medication for an injury, become addicted to prescription drugs, then switch to heroin because it is cheaper. That means examination of overprescribing must be part of the solution.

  8. The deflategate/dumbness series is great. Unfortunately, if citizens are to be enlightened about their government and media sources, they will be required to work hard and READ that list of football pressures or its equivalent. And, unfortunately, we are dealing with a rube citizenry that prefers to be spoonfed manufactured scandal from FOX and MSNBC that makes a rube feel good inside.

    1. You read the series? You think it's great? But you are mostly worried about FOX and MSNBC?

      Ok, whatever.

      But look.

      It's hardly the fault of the "rube citizenry," most of them slaves to their jobs, that they don't have the time and inclination to undertake a research project to understand each significant issue that they and their children face.

      That's why it's a problem that the folks who think they aren't rubes (the pundits, the professors) are either co-opted by wealth or cowed into silence.

      Any blog dedicated to shaming Those people would be one I could get behind!

      Wait a minute....

    2. It might require more time than most people have to extensively research news reports for accuracy. But it takes no time at all to reject them until they can be verified to whatever extent one can verify them.

  9. Brought back my EX Husband Today was successful Love story of my Life when i was searching Randomly Online for Love tips to solve problem Am having in my Relationship Affairs i don`t believe in Miracle until i saw DR.AGBAZARA TEMPLE contact ( OR Tel (+2348104102662) , he Find a solution to my relationship problem and make it look better for me , Now am living happily with my Lover who left me before for another lady. Big Thanks to you Dr Agbazara if you need help in your Relationship please do contact him today on these details: OR call him on +2348104102662 and see for your self what i am talking about..

  10. Spot on with this write-up, I truly think this website needs much more consideration. I’ll probably be again to read much more, thanks for that info.
    cara menyembuhkan penyakit paru-paru basah
    cara mengatasi maag kambuh mendadak

  11. The next time I read a blog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as much as this one. I mean, I know it was my choice to read, but I actually thought youd have something interesting to say.
    pengobatan penyakit gagal ginjal
    cara mengobati tifus
    cara menghilangkan jamur di selangkangan
    cara mengobati radang pankreas
    cara menghilangkan kurap di kulit kepala

  12. Aw, this was a really nice post. In idea I would like to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and actual effort to make a very good article.
    cara mengobati bercak merah
    sayuran kaya serat
    cara menghilangkan biang keringat di wajah
    manfaat probiotik
    cara menyembuhkan infeksi saluran kemih pernapasan

  13. Can I just say what a relief to find someone who actually knows what theyre talking about cara menyembuhkan osteoarthritis on the internet. You definitely know how to bring an issue to light and make it cara mengobati penyakit penumonia important. More people need to read pengobatan gagal ginjal this and understand this side of the story. I cant cara mengobati luka ginjal believe youre not more popular because you definitely have the gift.

  14. I can only express a word of thanks, nothing else. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge Thank you very much has been sharing this information.
    Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health
    obat luka jatuh
    cara menurunkan gula darah

  15. I can only express a word of thanks, nothing else. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge Thank you very much has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
    cara mengobati busung air
    obat penghilang gatal akibat darah manis

  16. I can only express a word of thanks, nothing else. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge Thank you very much has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health
    cara mengobati sakit kepala


  18. I can only express a word of thanks, nothing else. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge Thank you very much has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
    obat batu ginjal alami

  19. I can only express a word of thanks, nothing else. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge Thank you very much has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
    obat pityriasis alba paling ampuh
    cara mengobati sakit pinggang

  20. I can only express a word of thanks, nothing else. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge Thank you very much has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
    obat Penyakit Uci Uci

  21. I can only express a word of thanks. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge I, thank has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
    cara mengobati penipisan lapisan otak
    cara mengobati selulit
    obat infeksi usus

  22. I can only express a word of thanks. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge I, thank has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
    cara mengobati hidrosalping
    cara mengobati selulit
    cara mengobati penipisan lapisan otak
    obat infeksi usus
    Cara Mengatasi Sakit Ulu Hati
    cara mengobati penyakit dompo

  23. I can only express a word of thanks. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge I, thank has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
    cara mengobati ambeien
    obat jantung berdebar
    obat penyakit hipertensi
    obat gondongan alami

  24. I promise to share this testimony all over the world once my boyfriend returns back to me, and today with all due respect I want to thank DR.ONIHA for bringing joy and happiness to my relationship and my family. I want to inform you all that there is a spell caster that is real and genuine. I never believed in any of these things until I lost my boyfriend, I required help until I found a great spell caster, And he cast a love spell for me, and he assured me that I will get my boyfriend back in two days after the spell has been cast. Three days later, my phone rang, and so shockingly, it was my boyfriend who has not called me for the past 6 years now, and made an apology for the heart break, and told me that he is ready to be my backbone till the rest of his life with me. DR.ONIHA released him to know how much I loved and wanted him. And opened his eyes to picture how much we have shared together. As I`m writing this testimony right now I`m the happiest girl on earth and me and my boyfriend are living a happy life and our love is now stronger than how it was even before our break up. So that`s why I promised to share my testimony all over the universe. All thanks goes to DR.ONIHA for the excessive work that he has done for me. Below is the email address in any situation you are undergoing, it may be a heart break, and I assure you that as he has done mine for me, he will definitely help you too.
    CALL/WHATSAPP : +16692213962.