The New York Times v. Rachel Maddow IN RE Carter Page: Exciting! On Monday afternoon, a young reporter for BuzzFeed gave the world an exciting way to pigpile on Carter Page.
In this morning's New York Times, Adam Goldman reports on this excitement. Headline included, this is the way he began his report. We'd call this a model of fairness:
GOLDMAN (4/5/17): Russian Spies Tried to Recruit Carter Page Before He Advised TrumpAccording to the New York Times, Page didn't know that he was interacting with a Russian spy. The Times said the Russian spy tried to recruit Page. It didn't say the spy succeeded, or even that Page ever knew that the man was a spy.
Russian intelligence operatives tried in 2013 to recruit an American businessman and eventual foreign policy adviser to the Trump campaign who is now part of the F.B.I. investigation into Russia’s interference into the American election, according to federal court documents and a statement issued by the businessman.
The businessman, Carter Page, met with one of three Russians who were eventually charged with being undeclared officers with Russia’s foreign intelligence service, known as the S.V.R. The F.B.I. interviewed Mr. Page in 2013 as part of an investigation into the spy ring, but decided that he had not known the man was a spy, and the bureau never accused Mr. Page of wrongdoing.
The court documents say that Mr. Page, who founded an investment company in New York called Global Energy Capital, provided documents about the energy business to one of the Russians, Victor Podobnyy, thinking he was a businessman who could help with brokering deals in Russia.
According to the New York Times, the FBI "never accused Page of wrongdoing." According to the New York Times, Page thought he was dealing with "a businessman who could help with brokering deals in Russia."
Goldman included all those disclaimers in just his first three paragraphs. We'd call that a model of fairness, even perhaps a bit more so. In our view, Goldman may have slightly overstated what those "court documents" actually "say." That said, if Goldman errs at all in this passage, he is erring on the side of fundamental fairness.
To see the way the other half lives, consider Rachel Maddow. Maddow tends to tilt the facts against those she opposes while trying to send them to prison.
On Monday night, Maddow went all in on Carter Page. Her fairness quotient was low.
Maddow devoted well over half her show to the thrilling story at BuzzFeed. She started with a typical rambling, entertaining segment about the exciting spy story, which involved Jared Kushner as well as Carter Page.
In her second segment, she intervewed Ali Watkins, the young reporter who wrote the underwhelming piece at BuzzFeed. This second segment finished at 9:31 P.M. on the clock. Given the way Maddow's program is structured, this means that Maddow devoted about two-thirds of the evening's broadcast minutes to the exciting spy tale.
(Watkins is in her third year out of college—Temple 2014. BuzzFeed often seems to be designed for the nation's second graders.)
This morning, in its first three grafs, the New York Times engaged in basic fairness. It reported that Page didn't know that he was interacting with a spy. The Times explicitly noted that Page was never charged with wrongdoing. He thought he was interacting with a Russian businessman, the newspaper said.
Maddow went extremely light on any such disclaimers. Instead, she staged one of her lurid story-telling sessions, with lots of entertainment value and endless insinuations.
She never attempted to nail down the points the New York Times carefully featured. At one point, she explicitly said that Page had been "successfully recruited."
Let's start at the beginning. Maddow started her show with an exciting claim about BuzzFeed's jaw-dropping report:
MADDOW (4/3/17): And thanks to you at home for joining us this hour.As always, Maddow was selling the car. She told us rubes that Ali Watkins had presented a "jaw-dropping" report. It had dropped in the past few hours!
BuzzFeed News reporter Ali Watkins has a sort of jaw-dropping scoop tonight about the Trump campaign. That story dropped tonight just in the last couple of hours.
We've got Ali Watkins here tonight to talk about that story. We've got her exclusively. You are going to want to hear that.
Maddow then set off on her entertaining tale. The story involved "this spy ring that got busted by the FBI, three Russian guys."
"Troubling enough," she said, "but now, BuzzFeed News adds their new scoop tonight."
She told the tale of the three Russians guys at work in New York City. They tried to "target college girls," but that didn't work out, she chucklingly said. "Where they did have some success was with 'Male number 1,'" she said.
She quoted from the official court document which was created when one of the spies was arrested in 2015. (BuzzFeed had posted the document.) She pretended that she knows all about the way Russkie spies work.
She read exciting passages from the court document which refer to "Male 1," one of the people the Russkies had tried to recruit (along with the college girls). After reading the entertaining material, she actually broadcast this:
MADDOW: I mean, this is—this is how they do it, right? And maybe it turns into something, maybe it doesn't, but you cultivate assets. This is what they do. This is why they're here instead of working at home in Moscow.Carter Page "was successfully recruited," our team's vile multimillionaire said. Page "handed documents and information [to the Russkie spies] to help them out and was enthusiastic about their relationship!"
Well, BuzzFeed News reports tonight that "Male 1" in that spy ring indictment is the Trump campaign foreign policy advisor Carter Page. He was recruited as an American asset by Russian spies in New York City in 2013.
He was successfully recruited. He handed them documents and information to help them out and was enthusiastic about their relationship.
That adviser, Carter Page, met with a Russian intelligence operative named Victor Podobnyy who was later charged by the U.S. government, alongside two others, for acting as unregistered agents of a foreign government.
Rachel made no attempt to explain who Page thought he was meeting with. She made no attempt to discuss what sorts of "documents" (scary term!) the successful recruit "handed over."
She made no attempt to explain what he believed he was enthusiastic about. She simply said that Page had been "successfully recruited" by a ring of Russian spies.
"BuzzFeed News has confirmed that 'Male 1' is Carter Page," Maddow later excitingly said. As she approached her first commercial break, she referred to "a Russian spy network in this country that among other things recruited a Trump foreign policy adviser as a Russian intelligence asset just a few years ago."
It was exciting stuff! At 9:21, she said the following as she finally broke for commercials:
MADDOW: BuzzFeed reporter Ali Watkins, who's the one who unmasked the Trump foreign policy adviser at the center of this Russian spy story, Ali Watkins joins us.Carter Page! He was the successfully recruited "Trump foreign policy adviser at the center of this Russian spy story"—the exciting spy story which had produced BuzzFeed's "jaw-dropping scoop!"
Maddow had spent her first twenty-one minutes telling this thrilling tale. In those twenty-one minutes, she made no attempt to mention any of the disclaimers which the New York Times cited today in its first three paragraphs.
Instead, she told a thrilling story, making a claim which would get a person sued if she didn't have the First Amendment to crouch behind while she counted her millions—while she counted her millions of liberal stooges, the gullible souls who are now flocking to Maddow's tribally pleasing show.
What happened when Watkins came on? Let's discuss what didn't happen:
Maddow didn't ask if Page suspected or knew, at any point, that he'd been approached by a spy.
She didn't ask if the FBI thought Page had engaged in wrongdoing.
She didn't ask who Carter Page thought he was talking to. She didn't ask what sorts of "documents and information" he "gave them to help them out."
Briefly, let's be fair. After Maddow returned from commercial break, she dropped one tiny disclaimer. If you blinked, you would have missed it. This is what she said:
MADDOW: Carter Page, who's he? That's what everybody said at the time when, unprompted, then-candidate Donald Trump volunteered him as the number-two name on his list of foreign policy advisors, the first time he had ever listed foreign policy advisors for his campaign.Did you catch that? Briefly, the word "unwitting" flew by, with "apparently" tagged on the front. It was now 9:26 P.M. This was the first fleeting hint of what, according to the New York Times, had actually occurred.
Well, now, BuzzFeed News reports that among the many other things that Carter Page turns out to be, he was also recruited in 2013 as apparently an unwitting American source for a Russian spy ring that was operating out of New York City.
Joining us now is Ali Watkins. She's a national security correspondent for BuzzFeed News, broke this story tonight.
Thank you for being here. Congratulations on the scoop.
Our Own Rhodes Scholar didn't belabor the point. As noted, she never asked Watkins, in basic fairness, to state her view of Page's guilt or innocence in this nothingburger affair.
What had that word "unwitting" meant? We weren't encouraged to think about that. More time was killed with pointless asides and silly non sequiturs. At 9:30, Maddow said the word again:
MADDOW: And even if Page was himself an unwitting cultivated asset, we know that he knows it happened to him because the FBI went and told him that's what happened to him when they interview at the time?Rachel Maddow never asked her guest if Page was, or wasn't, "unwitting." She managed to drop the word two times, while suggesting, right in this passage, that Page had still done something wrong even if he was some sort of "unwitting asset."
WATKINS: Yes, yes.
MADDOW: So, had he been vetted, even just being directly asked, "Have you ever been in contact with a foreign intelligence service," he would have had to say yes.
WATKINS: Presumably, yes, if you want to answer truthfully.
MADDOW: So, a great way to get to be a top foreign policy adviser to a presidential campaign. Ahhhhh!
Did Page do anything wrong at all? Maddow never asked, and Watkins never volunteered any information. Watkins is two years out of college; Rachel Maddow, simply put, doesn't belong on the air.
Rachel's numbers have gone through the roof as she has played these pleasing games in the months since Trump won the election. We liberals can't see her for what she is. The same problem obtains Over There, where people who are much like Us have long been unable to see through Sean Hannity.
Page was "successfully recruited," our greatest TV star thrillingly said. In truth, Rachel has been playing these games a long time. Something's a little bit wrong in her head. She doesn't belong on the air.
And yet herds of uneducated progressive viewers now believe Page was a recruited spy.ReplyDelete
He is a recruited spy on Trump's team who has played an active role in undermining our democracy. That brief encounter in 2013 doesn't exonerate him.Delete
"Endless insinuation" is Maddow's MO.ReplyDelete
In the world of high end corporate media this is how I rank them from the bottom:
Most repulsive POS- Bill O'Reilly, with Chris Matthews close behind in second place.
Newspaper/Print Division- Maureen Dowd
Special Citation for Most Unwatchable- Rachel Maddow
Mark Levin is pretty bad too, as is Hugh Hewitt. And why omit Sean Hannity? Greta Van Susteren is the one I cannot listen to.Delete
"0ur team's vile multimillionaire said...". Well, Obviously Bob is killing himself to remain fair himself.ReplyDelete
Page's involvement with the Russians didn't end with that 2013 incident. The concerns about Page occur in the context of his other Russian encounters and his role on the Trump team.ReplyDelete
Somerby is upset because Maddow didn't say "unwitting" every single time she mentioned Page.
Here are some facts:
1. Page was recruited.
2. Page turned over some documents to Russians who were in actuality spies.
3. The FBI investigated him but didn't press charges.
That all constitutes another Russian connection among Trump's campaign and transition team. There is more to Page than this. He was one of the people being paid large sums to travel to Russia and make presentations or attend conferences. He met with Kislyak in 2016 while affiliated with Trump's campaign. He refuses to state anything about the encounter and is idiotically coy about affirming that he did meet (in or about Cleveland).
Carter Page was on Sessions' list of Trump foreign advisors. Carter Page went to Russia in July 2016 and reportedly met with Sechin on sanctions and the head of Russian intelligence, Igor Diveykin, charged with hacking America’s election.
Politico reported that Carter Page also met Sergei Ivanov, “until recently Putin’s Chief of Staff”.
Carter Page is not just a witless nobody who unwittingly met with a spy in 2013. He has met with many Russians since and was Trump's foreign advisor, according to Sessions.
When Somerby pretends that this is a poor shlub being maligned by Maddow's "insinuations," he is being grossly disingenuous, unless he himself is ignorant of the scope of Carter Page's activities since 2013.
Why is Somerby pretending, like a good conservative would, that Carter Page is innocent of wrongdoing? I find it very hard to believe he didn't know who he was talking to back in 2013.
He's pretending no such thing. He's saying, quite truthfully, that Maddow framed this specific story as if Page had been recruited and subsequently gave sensitive information to the Ruskies. There is no evidence in this story that he was recruited, and the information he gave them appears not to be sensitive. The FBI cleared him of wrongdoing in this matter.Delete
It amazes me how many people here get upset with Bob's correction of the record. It's all premised on (among other things) the notion that putting out biased and disingenuous claims ends up weakening your case in the public sphere. If there's real incriminating material about Page, then isn't our case stronger if we confine ourselves to those facts? Bob frequently highlights not just the bad claims, but the strong claims that go unsaid. He's all about winning the argument for progressive politics. I think too many people would just rather hear stuff that affirms their anger than actually persuading others and making change. Emotional satisfaction trumping actual success. Sometimes it seems like Democrats would prefer to lose and feel outraged and superior instead of achieving real success.
Democrats are trying to make Russia-Trump collusion happen. It's not going to happen. It won't have happened just in time for Republicans to gain in 2018.ReplyDelete
Sure does seem like the whole "Russia hacked the election!" thing is just another excuse by the corporate-owned media to make believe the election wasn't about white supremacy.Delete
Whatever it was about, the outcome was better than the alternative.Delete
Well, 11:41, for one, has given up the ghost about Trump voters not really being bigots. Good for you, 11:41 (and welcome to reality), may I ask if it was because the thought it wasn't bigotry just too ridiculous for a thinking person?Delete
Whatever the reason or whatever a nonthinking resistance school pupil would say about what a thinking person would think, the outcome was better than the alternative.Delete
The thought that the election wasn't about white supremacy is far too ridiculous to even imagine, yet the corporate-owned MSM is still trying to push it.Delete
Nobody will bother to recruit Bob.ReplyDelete
Hello, i am Jessica Wayne from TX, USA. Life without my husband was a real mess for me and my children I am so happy to get my Ex back through the help of Dr Noble the spell caster . My greatest surprise was that 48 hours after the Doctor prepared the spell for me, my husband who has abandoned me for 4 years suddenly called me unexpectedly and am so happy that we have come to become one again through the help of Dr Noble and am so happy to be with my husband once again. Dr Noble is a very wonderful spell caster, you can contact him if you need his assistant because i know he can also help you. contact him through his email: email@example.com immediately
Hey guys my wife and I have been married for 15 years. For over five years I have been dealing with jealousy issues because of flirting and her having emotional type affairs with other men. I felt like my masculinity was in question and if I said the way she was acting bothered me, it seemed to make matters worse or I was accused of being controling. During this period I did state I wanted a divorce if the behavior was not going to end: texting men a night, leaving for the weekend without letting me know where she was going or not responding to messages. We do have a son and basically it's been him and I for the last year on the weekends. She disconnected completely from being a good wife and mother. In April she said she wanted a separation and I said no we need to get into marriage counseling. We did try that, but she was not very responsive and didn't give any effort. Afterward she was adamant about separation and divorce. I continued to say no and that we needed to save our family. She presented a separation agreement and I had to hire a lawyer. Because of the above behavior my lawyer suggested a private investigator. The investigator discovered my wife was having an affair with a close friend of the family who also is married with children. We know the extended families. I feel like I should tell this man's wife about what happened. This adultery has devastated me emotionally, I feel betrayed and I'm physically drained. I know my wife is passionate in terms of her sexuality, and I can't get the thought of them out of my head. It makes me question my own manhood, and I feel very inferior or that he must be a better lover or what ever. The problem is my wife pursued him. She would go to him and she lured him into this adultery. I felt this was coming for some time and could not stop it. She was not only lying to me but also to our son about what she was doing and where she was going. My family is important, my son loves her and as crazy as it sounds so do I. Can you respond with a course of action on how to proceed? I was still have a very huge place in my heart for her. so i searched for help online and I came across a website that suggested that Dr Ahmed can help solve marital problems, restore broken relationships and so on. So I felt I should give him a try. I contacted him and he told me what to do and i did it then he did a spell for me. 28 hours later, my wife came to me and apologized for the wrongs she did and promise never to do it again. Ever since then, everything has returned back to normal. I, my son and my wife are living together happily again.. All thanks to Dr Ahmed. as it is a place to resolve marriage/relationship issues, do you want to be sure if your spouse is being faithful to you or Do you want your Ex to come back to you Contact.: E-mail: Ahmedutimate@gmail.com or call/Whats-app: +2348160153829 save your crumbling home and change of grades its 100% safe. I suggest you contact him. He will not disappoint you.ReplyDelete
David L. Ollis, 43yrs, UK
I feel so blessed again in my marriage after Robinson Buckler brought back my husband that separated with me for good 6 months. Even if have mouths all over my body, it won’t be enough to thank Robinson Buckler for his help upon my life. My husband separated with me for the 6 months and have been in pains and agony without him. So, i searched for help everywhere but nothing worked out not until i met Robinson Buckler who i contacted online. I explained my situation to him and he promised that my husband will get back to me within 24 to 48 hours as far that my heart still beats for him. I believed in him and he prepared a spell for me and my husband called me exactly when Robinson Buckler said. He pleaded and said he needs me back and now we are living happily again for the past 9 months. Everyone out there reading my article that needs help should contact him… Email. Robinson Buckler via Robinson.Buckler@yahoo.com for more informationReplyDelete
Hello, everyone! I,m here to explore blogs and forum about the wonderful and most safe cure for (Herpes Virus).I was positive to the deadly virus called herpes and i lost hope because i was out casted and rejected even by my closet friends.i searched on-line to know and enquirer about cure for Herpes and i read someone testimony on how he was cured from Herpes so i decided to contact the same herbalist because i know that nature has the power to heal everything.i contacted him to know how he can help me and he told me never to worry that he will heal me with the natural herbs from God!after 2 days of contacting him, he told me that the cure has been ready and he sent it to me via DHL and it got to me after 3 days!i used the med as he instructed me (MORNING and EVENING) and i was cured!its really like a dream but i am so happy!thats the reason i decided to also add more comment of Him so that more can be saved just like me!and if you need his help, you can email him on firstname.lastname@example.org , or WhatsApp +2348050777527 I,m neme amber and you can get in touch with me via email@example.com ..Contact him for help at Herpes virus HIV/AIDS CANCER COPD BRAIN TUMOR All kind of virus and disease //...ReplyDelete
I was so anxiuos to know what my husband was always doing late outside the house so i started contacting hackers and was scamed severly until i almost gave up then i contacted this one hacker and he delivered a good job showing evidences i needed from the apps on his phone like whatsapp,facebook,instagram and others and i went ahead to file my divorce papers with the evidences i got,He also went ahead to get me back some of my lost money i sent to those other fake hackers,every dollar i spent on these jobs was worth it.Contact him so he also help you.ReplyDelete
text or call +1 4016006790
Hello everyone I want to introduce you guys to a group a private investigators who can help you with information you need in any situation in life and they are ready to follow you step by step until your case is cleared just contact +17078685071 and you will happily ever afterReplyDelete
powerful herbal healer called Dr. voodoo who use his natural herbs to cureReplyDelete
my HIV disease I suffered from 5years, but now I am a happy woman and i am
free from this disease that has been problem to my living, after using Dr.
voodoo herbal medicine within 1week i was diagnose negative, I will
recommend Dr. voodoo to everyone reading this article because this herbal
healer is capable to heal anything below.
2. HERPES 1/2
4. Lymphoma disease
5. Conceived a child
Email Dr voodoo at: firstname.lastname@example.org add Dr. voodoo on
DR EMU WHO HELP PEOPLE IN ANY TYPE OF LOTTERY NUMBERSReplyDelete
It is a very hard situation when playing the lottery and never won, or keep winning low fund not up to 100 bucks, i have been a victim of such a tough life, the biggest fund i have ever won was 100 bucks, and i have been playing lottery for almost 12 years now, things suddenly change the moment i came across a secret online, a testimony of a spell caster called dr emu, who help people in any type of lottery numbers, i was not easily convinced, but i decided to give try, now i am a proud lottery winner with the help of dr emu, i won $1,000.0000.00 and i am making this known to every one out there who have been trying all day to win the lottery, believe me this is the only way to win the lottery.
Contact him on email Emutemple@gmail.com
What's app +2347012841542
Hi Friends i am so glad to writing this article today to tell the world how Dr voodoo cured my HSV VIRUS,i have been detected with HSV-1 AND HSV-2 since five years ago, ever since then my life has been in complete bizarre and agony,i have used so many drugs that was prescribed to me by several doctors,but it didn't cure my HSV VIRUS neither did it reduce the pain,until a certain i was checking for solution in the internet,then miraculously came across Dr voodoo the powerful herbalist that cure numerous individuals HSV-1 AND HSV-2 INFECTION,then i contacted his whatsApp number at +2348140120719 or email: email@example.com i explained everything to him and prepared a cure that cure my HSV-1 AND HSV-2 disease totally after receiving his herbal medicine, so my friends viewers why wait and be suffer when there is someone like Dr voodoo that can cure any disease HIV/ CANCER/ HEPATITIS B VIRUS, you can contact his via : firstname.lastname@example.org or WHATSAPP +2348140120719ReplyDelete