Slate great amazes the elders: Remember when Jesus amazed the elders, sitting right there in the temple?
Last Thursday, a bright young kid over at Slate pretty much did the same thing.
The scribe in question is Susan Matthews, Slate's science editor. In her piece, she critiqued an on-line report by the New York Times concerning climate change.
"Critiqued" the piece? She left it for dead! In the process, Matthews did so many things right our analysts almost lost count.
Did we mention the fact that Matthews challenged the New York Times in her piece? You may have thought that, by law, that's never done. Slate's headlines looked like this:
The New York Times’ Coal Miner Interview Is Why We Won’t Stop Climate ChangeOur analysts loved the fact that she challenged the Times—and they loved her sense of doom.
Journalists must serve facts, not emotions.
Did we say that Matthews challenged the Times? In fact, she challenged a ranking Timesman—challenged him by name.
Truly, this is never done—and land o' goshen, look who she picked! This is the way she started:
MATTHEWS (3/30/17): The problem with journalism, we were told after the election, is that we in the media focused too much on the facts and too little on the people, their stories, and their feelings. Coastal elites holed up with their precious data and forgot about the middle of the country.Good God! Why don't other journalists do it like this, our gobsmacked analysts asked.
So on the Thursday installment of the New York Times’ daily podcast, host Michael Barbaro attempts to do his part to fix this problem. His plan? To interview a coal miner named Mark Gray. It’s a miraculous 10 minutes of radio, ending with Barbaro crying while realizing that he really doesn’t understand coal country at all, and perhaps if he just visited a mine he would have an entirely different perspective on the situation.
It is emotional and compelling storytelling. But it isn’t the kind of journalism we should prioritize going forward. In fact, it’s irresponsible to the point of bordering on unethical.
I don’t blame the coal miner. I blame Barbaro.
We have a few complaints. For ourselves, we don't think Barbaro's audio piece was even good storytelling, let along a "compelling" example of same.
That said, Matthews broke every rule in the book as she composed her piece. Graded on a curve, her piece is nonpareil. It ought to be the norm.
You can read the piece yourself to see the things Matthews has done. Basically, he let a misinformed miner repeat all kinds of crap without ever telling Times readers that his statements were factually wrong.
We're going to repeat a key basic point—Matthews challenged a major Times player by name. This is simply never done within the careerist press corps.
We're going to mention something else Matthews did. She composed a thoroughly competent, accurate transcript of several parts of Barbaro's interview with the misinformed miner.
That may seem like a journalistic given. It's very rarely done.
We'll offer one more semi-critique. Matthews says Barbaro is "crying" by the end of his interview with the misinformed miner. She says that in the passage we've posted. She says it again in her transcript.
(Note the way Matthews handles the misinformed miner. She tells us that he's misinformed, but then she kicks up, not down.)
Was Barbaro crying by the end of his telephone session? We're not sure we'd make that claim quite so unambiguously. But based upon the aural evidence, it's hard to say that Matthews' statement is wrong. For unknown reasons, it sounds like Barbaro's blubbering by the time the interview's done.
(Sneaking suspicion: The Times has started personalizing itself in pages A2 and A3 of its hard-copy editions. They're presenting some very silly work. This may have been part of the package.)
Deference to major news organs has long been a serious sickness of the mainstream press. People are dead all over the world because careerist strivers have refused, for the past thirty years, to challenge the work of such major orgs. Amazingly, you never see journalists do what Matthews did in this piece.
Final point: Susan Matthews isn't a graybeard on her way to retirement. She's in her sixth year out of Dartmouth. In the eyes of the world, she's still a kid on the way up. She proves that younger journalists can produce the kind of competent, challenging work you'd normally expect to see from a dissatisfied class of younger practitioners.
The last time someone broke the rules this way, it was Katherine Boo in the Washingtonian. In 1992, Boo warned the world, at considerable length, about the growing journalistic menace she described as "creeping Dowdism."
Boo was a rising young journalist then. Today, she's been relegated to the junk heap—to the class of people forced to write serious books.
The guild knows how to deal with her type. They hand awards to Boo's serious books, then ignore every word she has said.
At any rate, Matthews got it right last week. As long-time readers will surely know, we've rarely said that around here!
Susan Matthews got it right. She won't be mistaken for Chris!
The Barbaro school of journalism: As you may recall, we've been down on Barbaro since 2011, when he joined with Ashley Parker to wrote a front-page profile of Candidate Romney's hair stylist.
You say they were assigned to do that? We push such piddle aside!
IMHO the world is not going to reduce the percentage of CO2 in the atmosphere by people making sacrifices. Various county's response to the Kyoto and Paris Agreements show that there is no willingness to make such sacrifices for the common good.ReplyDelete
The better approach is a positive one: develop more sources of energy that don't cause CO2 emissions. Today, that means nuclear, wind, and solar. But, some breakthrough is probably needed, whereby some entirely new energy is developed.
Comrade DinC graces us with another one of his "we can't do it, therefore we shouldn't make every effort" to mitigate the problem. Fuck you DinC, you vote for the party that doesn't even acknowledge the science that recognizes CO2 is a problem.Delete
DinC may not realize it, but the world in fact *is* moving toward renewable energy sources and I think we have to acknowledge that global warming fears have motivated nations to act, however slowly. He also does not appear to see that by switching to other energy sources, those poor coal miners are out of work, just like Hillary was saying. The difference is that the current Trump administration is not going to do anything for them when their jobs ultimately disappear.Delete
I agree with DavidinCal: America isn't really exceptional.Delete
I am basically writing you back to give you all of my thanks. Ever since I finished working on the first (Love Me Again), my results have been excellent. All I can say is YES, YES YES!! You have been a great help to me and very patient as well. That is so important. When people start working on things that are new to them, there is so much that they don't know. Especially since working on such kits you are calling on spirits for help and you don't want to make any mistakes because you're afraid that anything could go wrong if the work is not done right (such as myself) and I know that I have questioned you a lot. I can admit that I was having some doubts at first and that I was just hoping that this relationship could be helped due to all of the negativity in the relationship. Now I know that there was help and hope for us once again. You have been the best as far as love spell is concern and responding to questions in a timely manner. And I can also tell that you as the support staff are very bright and well educated people. I just wanted to leave you with this note. But mainly you. Even though I know that there are other spell caster, you have been the one that i have really seen a good result from the casting of the spell....thanks once again Dr Okaya , OKAYASPELLHELP@GMAIL.COM OR call/Whatsapp +27814506790Delete
Lets see what hapens to her career as a consequence of violating norms.ReplyDelete
This is one of Somerby's stupidest posts of all times.ReplyDelete
Thank you for your post. This has to be one of the most insightful and concise criticisms of any blog that I have ever seen. The depth of your knowledge of the subject and the detailed presentation of your case is truly breathtaking. It was truly a pleasure to read your response and I look forward with great anticipation to your future work. (not)Delete
Actually, the dishonesty of the podcast lies in the fact that the journalist doesn't push down to. The guy seems obsessed with Obama.ReplyDelete
Bob, I think you meant to say "Barbaro" instead of "Matthews" in this sentence:Delete
"You can read the piece yourself to see the things Matthews has done. Basically, he let a misinformed miner repeat all kinds of crap without ever telling Times readers that his statements were factually wrong."
Was this Minor actually misinformed, or did he simply stubbornly stick to his alt facts as he had been programed to? Has Bob himself ever tried engaging any of these people?Delete
Hello, i am Jessica Wayne from TX, USA. Life without my husband was a real mess for me and my children I am so happy to get my Ex back through the help of Dr Noble the spell caster . My greatest surprise was that 48 hours after the Doctor prepared the spell for me, my husband who has abandoned me for 4 years suddenly called me unexpectedly and am so happy that we have come to become one again through the help of Dr Noble and am so happy to be with my husband once again. Dr Noble is a very wonderful spell caster, you can contact him if you need his assistant because i know he can also help you. contact him through his email: firstname.lastname@example.org immediately
Greetings to every one that is reading this testimony. I have been rejected by my husband after three years of marriage just because another woman had a spell on him and he left me and the kid to suffer. one day when i was reading through the web, i saw a post on how this spell caster on this address OKAYASPELLHELP@GMAIL.COM , have help a woman to get back her husband and i gave him a reply to his address and he told me that a woman had a spell on my husband and he told me that he will help me and after 48 Hours that i will have my husband back. i believed him and today i am glad to let you all know that this spell caster have the power to bring lovers back.Win Lottery, because i am now happy with my husband. Thanks you Dr Okaya His email: OKAYASPELLHELP@GMAIL.COM Or call/Whatsapp +27814506790Delete
I felt like ending it i lost my husband to another woman 2 weeks ago after 27 years of marriage . We had a lovely marriage but he started a relationship with a co worker who chased after him . He is living away near his work, and he refuses to talk to me or to come home . I am devastated and am finding it hard to cope i was emotionally down . I wish I did not love him and that I could move on but I can't . I don't know how to stop feeling like this I wish I could and its eating me away and I m starting to feel ill. I have degraded myself begging him to come home all to no avail. I became very worried and needed help. As I was browsing through the internet one day, I came across a website that suggested that Dr Noble can help solve marital problems, restore broken relationships and I also came across several testimonies about this particular man so on. So, I felt I should give him a try. I contacted him and he did a spell for me. two days later, my husband came to me and apologized for the wrongs he did and promise never to do it again. Ever since then, everything has returned back to normal. I and my family are living together happily again.. All thanks to Dr Noble . If you need a spell caster that can cast a spell that truly works, I suggest you contact him. He will not disappoint you. if you have any problem contact him, I give you 100% guarantee that he will help you, This is his details, E-mail: email@example.com , Web blog: http://drnoblespell.blogspot.com.ng/. Thank you all for reading.ReplyDelete
Caroline Elizabeth Diem USA California
Hey guys my wife and I have been married for 15 years. For over five years I have been dealing with jealousy issues because of flirting and her having emotional type affairs with other men. I felt like my masculinity was in question and if I said the way she was acting bothered me, it seemed to make matters worse or I was accused of being controling. During this period I did state I wanted a divorce if the behavior was not going to end: texting men a night, leaving for the weekend without letting me know where she was going or not responding to messages. We do have a son and basically it's been him and I for the last year on the weekends. She disconnected completely from being a good wife and mother. In April she said she wanted a separation and I said no we need to get into marriage counseling. We did try that, but she was not very responsive and didn't give any effort. Afterward she was adamant about separation and divorce. I continued to say no and that we needed to save our family. She presented a separation agreement and I had to hire a lawyer. Because of the above behavior my lawyer suggested a private investigator. The investigator discovered my wife was having an affair with a close friend of the family who also is married with children. We know the extended families. I feel like I should tell this man's wife about what happened. This adultery has devastated me emotionally, I feel betrayed and I'm physically drained. I know my wife is passionate in terms of her sexuality, and I can't get the thought of them out of my head. It makes me question my own manhood, and I feel very inferior or that he must be a better lover or what ever. The problem is my wife pursued him. She would go to him and she lured him into this adultery. I felt this was coming for some time and could not stop it. She was not only lying to me but also to our son about what she was doing and where she was going. My family is important, my son loves her and as crazy as it sounds so do I. Can you respond with a course of action on how to proceed? I was still have a very huge place in my heart for her. so i searched for help online and I came across a website that suggested that Dr Ahmed can help solve marital problems, restore broken relationships and so on. So I felt I should give him a try. I contacted him and he told me what to do and i did it then he did a spell for me. 28 hours later, my wife came to me and apologized for the wrongs she did and promise never to do it again. Ever since then, everything has returned back to normal. I, my son and my wife are living together happily again.. All thanks to Dr Ahmed. as it is a place to resolve marriage/relationship issues, do you want to be sure if your spouse is being faithful to you or Do you want your Ex to come back to you Contact.: E-mail: Ahmedutimate@gmail.com or call/Whats-app: +2348160153829 save your crumbling home and change of grades its 100% safe. I suggest you contact him. He will not disappoint you.ReplyDelete
David L. Ollis, 43yrs, UK
This is a very joyful day of my life because of the help Dr.Okaya has rendered to me , I am out here to spreed this good news to the entire world on how I got my ex love back just yesterday i contacted dr okaya for help ,I was going crazy when my love left me for another girl , But when i met the Email address of Dr Okaya (Okayaspellhelp@gmail.com ) the great messenger to the oracle that he serve,I narrated my problem to Dr Okaya about how my ex love left me and also how i needed to get a job in a very big company. He only said to me that i have come to the right place were i will be getting my heart desire without any side effect .He told me what i need to do After it was been done,In the next 24 hours,My love called me on the phone and was saying sorry for living me before now and also in the next one week after my love called me to be pleading for forgiveness,I was called for an interview in my desired company were i needed to work .I am so happy. Contact this great man too for help, his contact: OKAYASPELLHELP@GMAIL.COM OR PHONE/WHATS APP : +27814506790Delete
Thanks to Dr, KEN for bringing back my lover in just 48-hours, when my lover left me i was sad i wanted to kill my self because i love him so much i try to do what i can to get him back nor of them work,i told all his friends to help me beg him that am so sorry for what i have done but it never work. when i was browsing on my face-book i saw some of this great man comment how he help people to bring back their lost lover, so i contacted and explain every thing to him on his email and he gave me instructions on what i should do,and i followed all what he instructed to my greatest surprise in just 48-hours my story change my lover that left me for one year came back and beg me to forgive him i am so happy that he is back to me, all my appreciation goes to Dr, KEN for bringing back my lover. You can contact Dr, KEN via email firstname.lastname@example.org OR CALL +18038451572ReplyDelete
With so much in my heart i am here to express myself, on how priest azuka saved my marriage from divorce. Myself and my husband were having some misunderstanding and it was tearing our marriage apart to the extend my husband was seeking for a divorce. So i have no option than to go to the internet to seek for solution to my problem it was there i came across priest azuka details and about how he has helped a lot of people by restoring there relationship. I contact him and in less than 48 hours my husband cancelled the divorce papers. Now myself and my husband live together in peace and harmony all thanks to priest azuka for saving my marriage from breaking up. priest azuka contact information are via email: email@example.com...you can also skype with him on hangout
I am basically writing you back to give you all of my thanks. Ever since I finished working on the first (Love Me Again), my results have been excellent. All I can say is YES, YES YES!! You have been a great help to me and very patient as well. That is so important. When people start working on things that are new to them, there is so much that they don't know. Especially since working on such kits you are calling on spirits for help and you don't want to make any mistakes because you're afraid that anything could go wrong if the work is not done right (such as myself) and I know that I have questioned you a lot. I can admit that I was having some doubts at first and that I was just hoping that this relationship could be helped due to all of the negativity in the relationship. Now I know that there was help and hope for us once again. You have been the best as far as love spell is concern and responding to questions in a timely manner. And I can also tell that you as the support staff are very bright and well educated people. I just wanted to leave you with this note. But mainly you. Even though I know that there are other spell caster, you have been the one that i have really seen a good result from the casting of the spell....thanks once again Dr Okaya , OKAYASPELLHELP@GMAIL.COM OR OKAYASPELLHELP@OUTLOOK.COM call/Whatsapp +27814506790ReplyDelete
I have always wanted the best for me and my lover We live together so happily that we had never have issues which we can't resolve. He was the best for me. We have been married for over 2 years now. I was lost in confusion when he told me he don't want our marriage anymore, this happened when he came back from his trip with all the saying that he has found another woman he love so much and want a divorce. I pleaded with him and he should please consider our kids too. My words where so useless to him. I was so confused that I have to seek for help and solution when I came across this prophetess. he told me what I need to do so I did and after 48 hours my lover came back apologizing for everything he has done and want us back again. Now I happy to share this with everyone for what @Drbowsolutionhome has done for me. You can also seek help from him by contacting him on WhatsApp+2348121786772 or email address firstname.lastname@example.orgReplyDelete
I want to thank of great Dr. Todd he brought my boyfriend back to me. i had seen many people to get him back but nothing, Dr. Todd gave me a consultation and told me all truth, and I trusted Dr. Todd and had him do the spells for me. it took awhile because it was very very messy between us. i had to wait for each spell to do its work. but once the last spell finally was working and the other spells had worked, that is when he called. we met. then it took many more meetings. but now we are back together and i can only thank Dr. Todd, he is the greatest, i will come to Dr. Todd for life. Todd took care of me like family. contact; manifest spell cast @gmail. com manifestspellcast.wordpress.com WhatsApp:+1 604 901 9747ReplyDelete