TUESDAY, MAY 26, 2026
Journalists averted their gaze: We're sorry to be tedious, but a statement as rare as Dr. Gartner's ought to be recorded.
The same is true of the statement made by roughly three dozen medical specialists—a statement recently inserted in the Congressional Record by Senator Whitehouse (D-RI).
We refer to statements which have been cited and reported by Farrah Tomazin of the Daily Beast. In the bulk of this recent report, Tomazin was describing the president's most recent recitation about the three cognitive tests he keeps insisting he "aced."
The absurdity of the president's claim has long been apparent, but he ran through the whole thing again last Friday, delivering a five-minute monologue on the subject during a rally on Long Island.
We'll offer a thought about that below. For now, here is Tomazin's report on the medical statements in question:
Trump Reveals the One Insult He Hates Most
[...]
The president’s latest comments [about acing the cognitive tests] come days before he is likely to take yet another cognitive test when he visits Walter Reed Hospital on Monday for his latest medical and dental checkup—his fourth publicized examination since returning to office. But while Trump was jovial during his speech, serious concerns about his mental fitness have nonetheless emerged, thanks in part to his erratic behavior and extreme comments.
A group of about three dozen medical experts sounded the alarm earlier this month, warning that the president was “mentally unfit” and must be removed from office “with the greatest urgency” amid escalating global tensions.
The group had not examined the president face-to-face, but it included neurologists, psychiatrists, and other physicians with extensive experience diagnosing cognitive disorders and evaluating patients.
Dr. John Gartner, a former Johns Hopkins University professor, also told The Daily Beast Podcast that as the president approaches 80, the signs that he has lost a step have become clearer.
“Anybody who has eyes, ears, and a brain… and hasn’t drunk the Kool-Aid or been bitten by a MAGA zombie, can see for themselves that this person is transparently mentally ill and cognitively deteriorating,” Gartner said.
We've mentioned Dr. Gartner before. He's the rare medical specialist who's still willing to use the (tragic) term "mental illness" when discussing President Trump.
In this instance, he told the Daily Beast that the president is "transparently mentally ill," with additional "cognitive deterioration" layered on top of that. He says that anyone who isn't drunk or blind would be able to discern such facts. (He may mean that any functioning medical specialist would inevitably form that assessment.)
As always, the fact that Dr. Gartner said it doesn't mean that it's true. That said, the sheer absurdity of the president's latest rambling account of those alleged cognitive tests—tests Obama could never have handled!—can surely speak for itself at this extremely late date.
We'll post a transcript at some point. Attention must (but won't) be paid.
Also this:
Tomazin also refers to the medical statement memorialized by Senator Whitehouse. Headline included, that lengthy statement starts like this:
Medical Concerns About President Donald J. Trump and His Fitness for Office
The following is not a political statement. It is a medical one, made by individuals holding both conservative and liberal ideologies, identifying as both Republicans and Democrats, from different backgrounds, races, ethnicities, and religions.
We are a group of neurologists, forensic psychiatrists, general psychiatrists, and other physicians, along with other mental health professionals, experienced in the diagnosis of cognitive disorders and in evaluating dangerousness to self and others. Among us are professionals whom the courts and criminal justice system regularly turn to for our expert opinion on these matters. We are also consulted by governments in matters related to national security and the psychological profiles of world leaders.
Prior to the presidential election in the Fall of 2024, a statement assessing Donald J. Trump's mental fitness for the presidency was issued. At that time, serious signs of cognitive decline were identified, and in our expert opinion, these signs warranted disqualification from office.
It is our professional opinion, based on previous and ongoing assessments, that Donald Trump's mental state since our 2024 statement has deteriorated even further...
The statement continues from there. The statement does not specifically refer to issues of "mental illness." It specifically refers to "mental fitness" and to "serious signs of cognitive decline."
That said, it does refer to various behaviors which may play a role in diagnosis of serious "personality disorders"—for example, this:
Grandiose and delusional beliefs, including assertions of infallibility, imagery of himself as Pope suggestive of a divine mission, being a mythical warrior hero, depicting himself as combat pilot—dropping feces on civilians, and claims that his decision-making authority is unlimited...
We've linked you to overviews concerning (diagnosable) grandiosity and delusional belief on various occasions. As we've noted, you have to hear about such matters from us because our professional journalists have agreed that they will never interview the medical specialists who could offer professional expertise with respect to such manifestations.
The Daily Beast is the rare site which is willing to mention such matters as these. This madness goes on and on and on—and we're referring here to the colloquial madness of our Blue American news orgs, not to any medical conditions with which the sitting president may be afflicted.
Senator Whitehouse inserted that lengthy statement in the Congressional Record. When he did, you know what happened next:
Nothing to look at! Move right along, Blue America'a journalists said.
As for the president's account of the way he allegedly aced those extremely difficult cognitive tests, his recitations become more pathetic, even more pitiable, as time slowly crawls along. To watch his ludicrous, five-minute ramble on that topic last Friday, just click here, then move ahead to minute 42.
("I'm the smartest guy you're ever gonna meet." That's the way the gentleman starts.)
That person is badly in need of help. So are the cowardly stars of our Blue American press corps.
" ... that he's lost a step ..."
ReplyDeleteGood one, Farrah. Worthy of the NY Times.
Trump bragging that he can pass simple cognitive tests, that most of his voters would fail spectacularly, doesn't make Trump sound mentally ill to me at all.
ReplyDeleteHe is a mentally fit child rapist and loser in war
DeleteDr. Gartner's concerns have been reported somewhere nearly weekly. Somerby's statement that the press has been avoiding them is flat out wrong when the NY Times has reported both Gartner's concerns and his those of his critics. Somerby himself has avoided reading blue sources and it is not the fault of blue media if Fox News does not give Gartner as much attention. Blue podcasts such as David Pakman and Meidas Touch have been repeatedly covering Trump's mental issues since he first took office. Gartner has his own podcast but has also appeared widely on other people's podcasts throughout independent media. Gartner is also mention in a paragraph in Wikipedia on the topic of Trump's health.
ReplyDeleteThe Wikipedia article on age and health concerns about Trump includes this:
"In 2017, psychologist John Gartner collected more than 41,000 signatures of mental health professionals on a petition, directed to then-Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer.[54][55] The petition asserted that Trump suffered from a serious mental illness and was "psychologically incapable of competently discharging the duties" of the presidency. Gartner asserted that Trump's mental handicaps are a mix of narcissism, paranoia, sociopathy, and sadism.[54]"
Now Gartner is referring to frontotemporal dementia not just personality concerns.
Somerby's strawman is that the blue media (by which he means corporate media owned by right wing billionaires) has not been talking about Trump's mental health issues. That is nonsense.
DeleteWhy does Somerby keep repeating this falsity? Because it gives him a reason for pretending to attack the media (over trivialities) while dumping all over Blue America and Democrats.
Today's essay isn't about Trump or his cognitive issues and it isn't about why Congress has done nothing at all to address Trump's cognitive decline -- we all know that is because of Republicans, who control both chambers of Congress. It is about how the press (which is NOT blue) is colluding to suppress everyone's knowledge about Trump's mental status -- which IS visible to all. Somerby might better ask why Republicans and Trump supporters keep pretending Trump is OK when it is so obvious that he isn't "right" in the head.
Somerby's self-defined purpose here is to portray the blue press as deficient, untrustworthy, not worth reading (which is a goal of every autocracy) and us blues as too deficient to participate in a democracy because we somehow let the press do what it does (as if we had any greater control of the NY Times than we do of the House of Representatives).
Blue sources have told the public what is wrong with Trump since he first came down that elevator (and before). WE are not the ones supplying fake news (that is FOX). We didn't attack Colbert (who told the public about Trump's issues) and we didn't do anything to make CBS another outlet for the Trump regime. We didn't destroy our country -- Somerby and his red buddies did that.
The party of free speech decided to execute a late night comedian because the fucking big fat felon didn't like his jokes about what a big fat fucking felon he is.
DeleteTrump, in describing the Montreal Cognitive test that he purportedly passed, recalled a complicated multi step mathematical problem that he answered correctly, apparently not aware that the test can be pulled up on the internet and contains no questions that are mathematical.of any kind. His MAGA audience was impressed, however.
Delete@6:46 - comedians are being literally executed. In France, a few years ago, a group of them who worked for a funny magazine were killed by Muslims.
DeleteAs long as anyone anywhere did something worse than Trump, then that excuses all of Trump's wrongdoing, amirite? This is the Hitler defense. Hitler killed millions during the Holocaust, so that makes Trump a-ok because he only killed several hundred thousand during covid.
DeleteWho or what is a Hitler?
DeleteI never heard of him/ her/ it, because there are no statues of Hitler, like there are of Robert E. Lee, where I grew up.
9;41,
DeleteReminds me of when the Right used to compare the USA with Saddam Hussein's Iraq, which would be called treason, if the Left had done it.
The gaslighting from social media is out of hand.
DeleteI recently had someone tell me Antifa isn't anti-Republican Party, even though it's right in their name.
SMDH.
DeleteI am just curious, Dickhead in Cal, were those Muslim terrorists you refer to using the full weight of the U.S. Presidency and all the agencies he holds under his leash to suppress free speech in this country, you fucking glib asshole?
Furthermore, Trump did fire not a comedian. His station fired him because his show was unsuccessful. Trump merely criticized him. Just as President Clinton criticized Rush Limbaugh.
DeletePerhaps @10:11 feels virtuous by exaggerating the "evil" of a President criticizing a comedian. @10:11 could be more truly virtuous by fighting a real evil -- a group that routinely murders people who say or do things they don't like
.
Trump was 'personally involved' in canceling Stephen Colbert, longtime late night reporter claims>/b>
DeleteBill Carter cited an AI-generated video on Trump's X account as evidence of his direct involvement in Colbert's show
Go fuck yourself, dickhead in cal.
Did the Zionists indict the former FBI Director twice already to make King Chickenshit happy?
We know why Colbert was canceled you fucking fascist freak
“his show was unsuccessful”
DeleteWhy do you Trump supporters lie to yourself, DiC?
“Stephen Colbert leaves late night as the king of the ratings, which made his cancellation even more confusing to industry observers. The Late Show with Stephen Colbert has ranked No. 1 among total viewers for years”
https://www.forbes.com/sites/tonifitzgerald/2026/05/21/stephen-colbert-ratings-over-the-years-he-leaves-as-no-1-in-late-night/
David in Cal needs to see at least a half dozen bankruptcies, before he feels someone is successful.
DeleteIs Hitler a person, place, or thing?
DeleteHitler is a noun.
DeleteDumb ass David, Colbert was a late night talk show host, not a comedian. CBS is a network, not a station. Trump's brown shirts have murdered dozens with no charges filed. You are a sick puppy.
DeleteJournalists have not been averting their gaze. That is why they keep getting called names by Trump.
ReplyDeleteAnd when one is insulted, the others change the subject, letting the ridiculous insult stand. Never once a question of why da fuck you talk to people like an ignorant jaggoff, you dumb ass? That's the question we want to hear!
DeleteOr how about, Jesus Fuck sir, what the fuck is up with your nasty ass hand and foul smelling diaper?
DeleteTrump’s corruption is vastly under reported. David Muir will do his “America strong” about a cat stuck in a tree and rescued, but never NEVER reports on Trump’s massive corruption, which should be a daily story and the subject of lengthy congressional hearings. It is a massive dereliction of journalistic duty, and fuck this idea of Somerby’s that the real problem isTrump’s mental illness, and pity the poor immigrant, and complaining about “Trump Trump Trump jail jail jail”. He’s quite purposeful with his corruption. Another story is Trump’s health issues that are being covered up by his toadies.
ReplyDeleteDr. Gartner?
ReplyDeleteSo glad you brought up his name. He's the fellow who says Trump is thirsty to nuke sumpin'. From just last week:
Dr. John Gartner, a psychiatrist and former professor at Johns Hopkins University, told Hugh Dougherty on a new episode of "The Daily Beast Podcast" that Rep. Thomas Massie's (R-KY) primary defeat on Tuesday may have emboldened Trump to do something that was once considered unthinkable. Trump may make the call to launch a nuclear strike in Iran or elsewhere, and there may not be anyone left around him who can stop it, he said.
Don't be silly.
DeleteDoes Trump come across as someone with the emotional maturity of a petulant 9-year old boy, who would blow-up the world because he doesn't get his way?
I'll come in again.
It's really bad when you can't even joke about it.
DeleteTrump should give all $1.8 Billion to Kilmar Abrego Garcia, just to troll the libs.
ReplyDelete“Anybody can see" "transparently" -- these and other phrases by Dr. Gartner are the kind of things one says when he doesn't have actual evidence to prove his contention.
ReplyDeleteGartner also doubles down by insulting anyone who disagrees with him.
I see you reject Somerby’s premise entirely. Why do you discount the evidence of Trump’s words and actions? Also, how does Gartner insult anyone?
DeleteAnyone can say there is a Republican voter who isn”t a bigot, but why would anyone believe such an outlandish theory without a shred of evidence?
Delete@10:39 - Here's the insult: Gartner says people who don't see things the way he does do not have eyes, ears, and a brain… or they have drunk the Kool-Aid or been bitten by a MAGA zombie.
DeleteStating facts is not insulting.
DeleteLook carefully at your eyes in the mirror David. You will see you are the walking dead. You have no thoughts of your own. Only what your cult leaders tell you to think is what you think.
Delete