Atop the front page, the Times gets it right!

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 30, 2012

Your Howler keeps getting results: Right at the top of today’s front page, the New York Times gets it right!

In a report which is long overdue, Appelbaum and Gebeloff report about the way tax burdens have fallen in recent decades. Even better, they adopt a very important framework—they note the way we misinformed rubes may misunderstand such key points:
APPELBAUM AND GEBELOFF (1/30/12): Alan Hicks divides long days between the insurance business he started in the late 1970s and the barbecue restaurant he opened with his sons three years ago. He earned more than $250,000 last year and said taxes took more than 40 percent. What’s worse, in his view, is that others—the wealthy, hiding in loopholes; the poor, living on government benefits—are not paying their fair share.

“It feels like the harder we work, the more they take from us,” said Mr. Hicks, 55, as he waited for a meat truck one recent afternoon. “And it seems like there’s an awful lot of people in the United States who don’t pay any taxes.”

These are common sentiments in the eastern suburbs of St. Louis, a region of fading factory towns fringed by new subdivisions. Here, as across the country, people like Mr. Hicks are pained by the conviction that they are paying ever more to finance the expansion of government.

But in fact, most Americans in 2010 paid far less in total taxes—federal, state and local—than they would have paid 30 years ago. According to an analysis by The New York Times, the combination of all income taxes, sales taxes and property taxes took a smaller share of their income than it took from households with the same inflation-adjusted income in 1980.
American citizens have been aggressively disinformed about taxation issues for a good many years. This disinformation campaign has been pursued all over the talk-show and think-tank right.

The campaign has been very effective. Did you know that, if we lower tax rates, the government gets extra revenue?

We’ve begged and pleaded for work of this type. Today, once again, your DAILY HOWLER is getting results!

Much more work like this should be done. Whatever got into the New York Times, that it would dish key information?

40 comments:

  1. But in fact, most Americans in 2010 paid far less in total taxes—federal, state and local—than they would have paid 30 years ago.

    New York Times' statistical analyses have long been unreliable (except for Nate Silver). Take the above quote.

    I believe it's the case that most Americans in 2010 paid more total inflation-adjusted tax than they did 30 years ago. That comparison would indicate that today's taxes are too high. Therefore the Times didn't look at actual taxes paid. They looked for some other basis to "prove" that today's taxes are too low.

    The Times found an artificial construct -- taxes than would have been paid under a certain hypothesis. But, IMHO this hypothesis isn't a proper basis.

    Income went up during the last 30 years and more women entered the work force. Does that mean that taxes should have risen equally? I don't think so. Most of what the government does is the same, regardless of the increase in personal income. The fact that Americans now earn more money is no reason why we need to spend more on Defence, Social Security, Medicare, environmental protection, etc. So, as incomes rise, a well-managed governemnt should be reducing its share of national income.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would also note that you have cited nothing supporting either of your claims: that the NYT does unreliable statistical work in general, and that this particular analysis is wrong. Without that, your assertions should be simply ignored.

      Delete
    2. urban urban urban, you are smart so take your own advice and simply ignore him.

      Delete
  2. The people doing the work government is paying for should see their incomes rising just as fast as yours, and things it pays for are subject to inflation as well -- so, yes, what you pay in taxes for the same government activities should stay the same. If adjustments in marginal rates on income tax do not keep up with inflation, then you would expect to pay a higher percentage of your income.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A fool's errand chasing down the misinformation in a D-in-CA comment, I'm afraid.

      But, no. The premise is just horribly, horribly flawed from the ground up.

      People are *not* earning more. On an inflation-adjusted basis, most jobs haven't increased their pay in decades.

      There *have* been huge income (and wealth) gains in recent decades -- But they've been concentrated in the very highest-compensated positions.

      Further, the attempt to tie what we (our government) spends money on to personal income trends is specious anyway.

      There are many reasons for government spending to change -- personal income growth is only one. To expect average personal income to show a fixed relation to, say, "environmental protection" is nonsense.

      If healthcare is a significant component of government expenses (and it is), then trends in healthcare costs are much more important than those in salaries in general.

      Is there *anything* of merit in David's post?

      Possibly. But the idea that "what you pay in taxes for the same government activities should stay the same" certainly isn't it.

      Delete
    2. On an inflation-adjusted basis, most jobs haven't increased their pay in decades.

      Anonymous, you are correct. On checking the CPI index and average weekly wage, I see that inflation-adjusted wages haven't gone up since 1980.

      people doing the work government is paying for should see their incomes rising just as fast as yours, and things it pays for are subject to inflation as well

      urban legend, I agree that government workers should get the same inflationary pay increases. But, I was talking about the increase in wealth due, e.g., to more women working.

      Should the government spend more on Defense just because more women are in the workforce? I don't think so.

      Delete
    3. Your "argument" is in tatters.

      Your 6:26 post doesn't stitch it back together again.

      "Should the government spend more on Defense just because more women are in the workforce? I don't think so."

      Who are you arguing with, anyway, that you post such an absurd non sequitur?

      You're in a deep, deep hole, David -- stop digging.

      Delete
    4. Why do you feed this troll? He's/she's totally dishonest. Blow him/her off. Maybe he'll go plague somebody deserving, like Kevin Drum.

      Delete
  3. Wonder why NYT publishes this now? Why not six months ago? Three years ago?

    Elections have consequences.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Except they make the article about a guy making $250,000 who is whining about the rich and the poor. My own basic tax data says that only 5% of taxpayers make more than $160,000. So he's $90,000 more than that, but does not think of himself as "rich". Sure .1% make more than $1.8 million but 75% make less than $67,000. But the NYT lets him complain about the rich. Like he's just like all those people making less than $70,000. Go out an offer somebody making $60,000 a $250,000 job and see if they don't think they are rich.

    http://journals.democraticunderground.com/hfojvt/169

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi! I just wish to offer you a big thumbs up for your great info you have right here on this post. I will be coming back to your site for more soon.
    Download Instagram Photos
    TikTok Video Downloader
    online resize image

    ReplyDelete
  6. Login Your exness login Account To Read The Latest News About The Platform.s

    ReplyDelete
  7. Login Your Amitrade Account To Read The Latest News About The Platform.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Do You Now AximTrade Review Login Is A Secure, Multi-channel, Multi-factor Authentication System, Enabling Customers To Securely Access Their Accounts To Fund/deposit, Request Withdrawal, Update Or Manage Their Profile And More.

    ReplyDelete
  9. At Ranks In Forex . our SEO process will make sure your business or website is easily found by new potential customers. Let us help you harness the power of search engine optimization.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Online Stock Broker is a free service that aims to provide consumers the best online forex broker reviews. It includes unbiased comparisons of a large range of leading brokers and trading platforms, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses.

    ReplyDelete
  11. To view the real-time Hofv Stocktwits price and to get an overview of the key fundamentals, simply visit Our Servlogin Webpage. You'll get access to revenue, earnings, valuation, predictors, and technical analysis from experts, news, historical data and Much More.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Market Forex Net Is The Best And Most Reliable Forex Company In The Industry.. We Started Our Journey To Educate Traders And Help Them With Their Trading Techniques. We Review The Top Brokers And Share Our Insights With You To Make Informed Decisions Before Investing. We Also Offer Investment Tips, Guides And Much More To Improve Your Success Rate In Trading.

    ReplyDelete
  13. To view the real-time Siml Stock price and to get an overview of the key fundamentals, simply visit Our Servlogin Webpage. You'll get access to revenue, earnings, valuation, predictors, and technical analysis from experts, news, historical data and Much More.

    ReplyDelete
  14. To view the real-time Fxit Stock price and to get an overview of the key fundamentals, simply visit Our Servlogin Webpage. You'll get access to revenue, earnings, valuation, predictors, and technical analysis from experts, news, historical data and Much More.

    ReplyDelete
  15. At Market Forex Net , we believe in honesty, transparency and trust. We started Market Forex net to educate traders and help them with their trading techniques. We publish reviews of brokerages, strategies, investment tips, guides and much more.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I hope you're doing really well and enjoying the day ahead. We are a Forex Trading agency focusing on the Stock information Brokers Review And Login Details. Get Latest information On Uavs Stocktwits . Our goal is to provide you with comprehensive data and analysis on this stock in order to help you determine if it is a good fit for your portfolio.

    ReplyDelete
  17. At Ess Harristeeter Teeter Login, you will find everything that you need related to your account and your choices as as a customer. Complete information about, News & Events, Credit Cards, Bill Pay, Rewards, Customer Service and much more.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Tradingzy Is The Best And Most Reliable Seo Company And Offers A Wide Variety Of Crypto Seo Services , Including An Affordable Monthly Subscription Service, One-time Links, And Blog Comments. With Any Of These Services, You Can Be Assured That Your Site Will Rank Higher In The Search Engine Results Page And Receive An Influx Of Targeted Traffic.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Logijn07 Is A New Forex Trading Company That Helps Traders And Investors To Find The Right Brokers And Strategies For Online Trading. Along With Broker Review And Login Details At Forex Trading Reviews We Offer Guest Post And Blog, Content Marketing Services, Building Services, Investment Guides And Much More. On Logijn07 You Will Also Find The Latest Press Releases, Industry News, Price Quotes That Might Effect Investment Decision. Were Ready To Help You Start Your Business.

    ReplyDelete
  20. The Truff Stock Overview, keep track of all your favorite stocks in real time across multiple screens, tailored to only show information you need and see as it happens.

    ReplyDelete
  21. How many times have you found an amazing coin that you wanted to invest in, only to find out that the cost per coin is just too high? Trp Coin offers cryptocurrency investors a cost effective way to get their feet wet in the market. With a set price of $1.00, Trp Coin has made the value per coin equal the same as 1000 regular coins. Find out Where to buy Trp Coin today!

    ReplyDelete
  22. The Bfarf Stock Overview, keep track of all your favorite stocks in real time across multiple screens, tailored to only show information you need and see as it happens.

    ReplyDelete
  23. The Ecdp stock Overview offers real time stock price updates. All you need to do is open the application and you can view Streaming stock prices of your favorite stocks.

    ReplyDelete
  24. As a new forex trader you need to know what the best brokers offers and their How To Start Forex Brokerage before you begin trading and investing, Use this guide to learn about trading costs, leverage and leverage limits, spreads and execution times, custodial services and market maker spreads .

    ReplyDelete
  25. Stay In Touch With Clii Stock Price? Every Move With Our Live, Real Time Stock Market Overview. Here You Will Always Be One Of The First To Know When Clii Stock Price Is Increasing Or Decreasing. Our Live Information Is Delivered Right To Your Browser, Giving You All The Data You Need To Make An Informed Trading Decision. With This Information At Your Fingertips You Will Be Able To Make Quick And Educated Decisions While Keeping Track Of All The Latest Clii Stock Price Changes!

    ReplyDelete
  26. The Dbd Forums Overview offers real time stock price updates. All you need to do is open the application and you can view Streaming stock prices of your favorite stocks.

    ReplyDelete
  27. The most comprehensive guide to Forex Brokers and White Label Broker , showing you what you can save or earn by choosing the best broker for your needs – from Highest to Lowest Charges. Useful for both beginner and seasoned trader.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Are you a shareholder or investor in Ipof Stocktwits? Our Live, Real Time Stock Market Overview keeps you apprised of all the Ipof Stocktwits happenings during the day. Get comprehensive data on stocks such as price and volume. Our Live, Real Time Stock Market Overview lets you keep up to date on the stock market with no hassles.

    ReplyDelete
  29. White Label Forex Broker Meaning is a comprehensive guide to deciding on the best Forex Brokers, Trading Costs and Fees. Find out which brokers offer the best value for money?

    ReplyDelete
  30. White Label Partnership Forex is the next step in our Forex Trading Education products. The course was designed to be modern and easy to use so that it can be learned by anyone, at any computer, while still allowing your customers to interact with you remotely.

    ReplyDelete