Part 5—Good news outscored by script: How well did American students do on last year’s international tests?
That can’t be easily answered. In reading, American students scored very near the top of the world. Among the large nations which took part, only Russia outscored the U.S.
In reading, American students outscored the vast bulk of the world! Unless you read major American papers, where this success was largely obscured.
In math, American students did somewhat less well—and without any question, a fairly small group of Asian nations tend to outscore the world by significant margins in math. That said, here’s a surprise:
In fourth-grade and eighth-grade math, American scores were “not measurably different” from the scores of students in Finland.
We mention Finland for an obvious reason. In the past decade, this small, middle-class, unicultural nation has been all the rage in America’s low-scoring press corps. Its strong performance on international tests has been a constant source of commentary from journalists who don’t have the slightest idea what they're talking about.
That’s why you might think it would count as news when the U.S. came close to matching Finland on last year’s international tests. Indeed, Finland was walloped by some U.S. states—states which took part in last year’s testing as independent “education systems.”
In eighth grade math, nine states participated in the testing as independent entities. Some of these states simply cleaned Finland’s clock. Here’s how the average scores looked:
Average scores, Grade 8 math, TIMSS 2011Massachusetts is one of our wealthier, whiter states—but it’s a glorious demographic stew as compared to middle-class Finland. But despite its larger demographic challenges, Massachusetts cleaned Finland’s clock in eighth-grade math, as did several other states among the nine which took part. And good lord:
Massachusetts 561
Minnesota 545
North Carolina 537
Indiana 522
Colorado 518
Connecticut 518
Finland 514
Florida 513
California 493
Alabama 466
The Bay State’s black kids outscored Finland, averaging 516 on this test! Given the perpetual gloom about our schools; given the brutal history of race in this country; given Finland’s well-deserved status as a high international scorer—you’d almost think it might count as news when scores like these occur.
If you thought that, you don’t understand the way your press corps works. In the Associated Press and the New York Times, the standard script about Finland prevailed. Here's the way the flying Finns were framed in the AP’s report:
LEDERMAN (12/11/12); American students still perform better than the global average in all subject areas, the study found, although students from the poorest U.S. schools fall short.Just for the record, Finland and Singapore are very small nations (five million people apiece). And despite what that highlighted passage says, Finland didn’t outscore the U.S. by much in last year’s reading test.
But the U.S. is far from leading the pack, a distinction now enjoyed by kids in countries like Finland and Singapore who outperformed American fourth-graders in science and reading. By eighth grade, American students have fallen behind their Russian, Japanese and Taiwanese counterparts in math, and trail students from Hong Kong, Slovenia and South Korea in science.
In math, Finland barely outscored the U.S. at all; the two nations’ scores were “not measurably different,” according to the official reports. As a result, math was dropped from this part of the AP report. The AP only mentioned science and reading as it extended the mandated script about how worthless our students are as compared to the greatness of Finland.
The New York Times also extended the script about Finland. Finding ways to stick to script is what our big newspapers do:
RICH (12/11/12): Students in Finland, which is often held up as a model education system for its teacher preparation and its relative absence of high-stakes testing, outperformed American students on all the exams. But students in countries with intense testing cultures also exceeded American students. ''Some of the high-performing math and science countries have extremely rigorous testing regimes,'' Mr. Buckley said.That’s true—students in Finland did “outperform American students on all the exams.” But in math, the two nations’ test scores were “not measurably different,” despite the much larger demographic challenges faced by American schools.
The New York Times didn’t tell readers that. The glories of Finland lived on!
Our view? Given the gloom which surrounds our schools in the press, it probably ought to count as news when American students score this well on international tests. Below, we’ll show you how hard the Washington Post worked at one point to keep you from hearing the good news.
But in two less glorious American papers, reporters took a different approach to the American scores—even to the greatness of Finland! In USA Today, Greg Toppo correctly saw that the American scores just weren't all that bad.
Toppo even chided the Finns, right in his second paragraph:
TOPPO (12/11/12): USA's schools move up in international rankingsSay what? Florida’s fourth-graders read as well as their peers in Finland? Toppo chided Finland a bit—and he seemed to think that an outcome like that actually counts as news.
Results from a pair of new international assessments released today show that American kids are holding their own in math, reading and other subjects. In a few cases, they're actually bypassing the rest of the world.
Who knew, for instance, that Florida fourth-graders now read as well as their peers in Singapore and Finland?
In the Christian Science Monitor, Amanda Paulson went a bit farther. Like Toppo, she saw the American glass half full—and she tweaked Finland right out of the gate.
But a bit later on, she directly whacked the ballyhooed middle-class giant:
PAULSON (12/11/12): What's also notable is who isn't among the very top scorers—most notably, Finland.Is Paulson allowed to say that about Finland? Within the scripted American press corps, the answer has long been no—and the AP and the New York Times largely stuck to the established script last week.
Based largely on its strong showing in the PISA (for Programme for International Student Achievement) scores, Finland has become a focal point for a number of education experts, who believe the US should use its system as a model.
But in the TIMSS data—especially on math—Finland wasn't all that different from the US.
"Finland's scores in math are statistically a dead heat" with the US, "which shows you how fragile that reputation, which is exaggerated, is," says Mr. Loveless—who notes that Finland's eighth-grade math scores have actually declined since Finland last took TIMSS, in 1999.
To their credit, silly stupid USA Today and the floundering Monitor didn’t.
Please understand: There is no formula which can extract the real news from these test scores. No formula can tell us whether the American glass was half empty or pretty darn full.
No formula can tell us what a paper should say about Finland, or if that one small middle-class nation should be mentioned at all.
But to our taste, our biggest news orgs worked rather hard to keep a gloomy old script alive as they reported these test scores. According to this gloomy old script, our pitiful schools are perpetually failing. They just don’t measure up.
How hard did the Washington Post seem to work to maintain this narrative? At one point, we chuckled as the Post withheld the good news, struggling to Keep Gloom Alive:
LAYTON (12/11/12): Several states that took the test independently scored higher than the U.S. average in eighth-grade math, including North Carolina, Indiana, Massachusetts and Minnesota. North Carolina also outscored the U.S. average in fourth-grade math. Massachusetts, Minnesota and Colorado exceeded the U.S. average in eighth-grade science.Good lord! In that first paragraph, Post readers were offered a fatuous point—several states scored higher than the U.S. average.
Even those high performers have much ground to gain on international leaders. In Singapore, for example, 40 percent of eighth-grade students scored high enough in science to be deemed "advanced." In Massachusetts, about one-quarter of students reached that mark.
Duh. In any testing, about half the states will exceed the national average; the other half will score below it. Unless you live in Lake Wobegon, this will always be true.
Pointlessly, readers were told that several states exceeded the national average. And then, it was back to the gloom and the doom! Immediately, the Post offered an invidious comparison, noting that our high performing states "have much ground to gain on international leaders." As an example, we were told that Massachusetts has a long ways to go to equal (tiny) Singapore.
Here is the larger fact the newspaper’s readers weren’t told:
Except for tiny Singapore, Massachusetts students outscored every nation in the world on that eighth-grade science test! They outscored their peers in Taiwan, in Korea, in Japan and Hong Kong—the other Asian giants. They outscored their counterparts in Russia.
They even outscored Finland, which is smaller and more homogeneous than Massachusetts.
On the very test singled out by the Post, Massachusetts outscored the entire world—except for tiny Singapore. But readers of the Post weren’t offered that larger, perhaps surprising fact. Gloomily, they were told that Massachusetts didn’t come close, in one respect, to one small city-state.
Rarely has a paper worked so hard to provide the smaller, less representative fact. Rarely has a paper worked so hard to pimp a gloomy script.
Did American students do well on these tests? That is a matter of judgment. But at the AP, the Post and the Times, we’d be inclined to say that script—and gloom—prevailed.
In our view, these papers displayed rather shaky news judgment—and an enduring love for the script. On Monday, conclusions and cautions: What lessons should we take away from these and previous test scores?
And Massachusetts and Minnesota are two of the most highly unionized teacher forces in the country. Whoops, I guess strong unions don't hold back educational excellence and improvements.
ReplyDeleteThis is an excellent post, getting to the heart of the matter. Thanks for writing!
ReplyDeleteIt is too bad the US media has forgotten what they should have learned in Journalism -- accurate reporting based on sound research. They are always trying to beat out their competition and fail to look for facts instead of sensationalism. Thank you for staying on top of a sensitive issue. Our Howard County, Maryland has just dropped the course reading causing their reading teachers to scramble and making them feel less than adequate. It will be interesting to watch the reading scores in 5 years, since we were once the top in the nation. Keep up the good work.
ReplyDeleteI'm gone to say to my little brother, that he should also pay a visit this webpage on regular basis to get updated from latest reports.
ReplyDeleteFeel free to visit my web blog Diets That Work
Great article. To be fair, though, urban legend, it should be said that North Carolina doesn't have teacher unions. Worth mentioning.
ReplyDeleteAmazing blog! Is your theme custom made or did you download it from somewhere?
ReplyDeleteA design like yours with a few simple adjustements would really
make my blog stand out. Please let me know where you
got your design. Appreciate it
Feel free to surf to my webpage :: Airplane Simulator game
Hi to every , for the reason that I am actually eager of reading
ReplyDeletethis blog's post to be updated regularly. It carries good information.
Here is my weblog - Testoril Reviews
I visited multiple blogs but the audio feature for audio songs current at this web site is really
ReplyDeletemarvelous.
Also visit my web-site :: Le Parfait Reviews
Hi there, I want to subscribe for this weblog to take hottest updates, therefore where can i do it please assist.
ReplyDeleteFeel free to visit my web page ... Home income kit
Good day! I could have sworn I've been to this blog before but after browsing through some of the post I realized it's
ReplyDeletenew to me. Anyhow, I'm definitely glad I found it and I'll be book-marking and checking back frequently!
Here is my webpage ... Xtrasize Review
I'm gone to convey my little brother, that he should also visit this blog on regular basis to obtain updated from latest news update.
ReplyDeleteMy blog post ... Working Online
Thanks for your personal marvelous posting! I quite enjoyed reading it,
ReplyDeleteyou can be a great author. I will ensure that I bookmark your blog and will often come back sometime soon.
I want to encourage continue your great work, have
a nice day!
Here is my blog post Grow XL Review
Igoot this wweb page from my buddy who shared with me onn the topic of this web page and
ReplyDeleteat the moment this time I am browsing this web site and reading very informative
posts aat this time.
Here is my weblog; battlefield 4 cheats pc multipllayer -
http://smart3s.co.kr/xe/?document_srl=750607 -
chanel handbags, coach outlet, kate spade handbags, burberry outlet, tiffany and co, air max, longchamp handbags, longchamp handbags, air max, louboutin outlet, tory burch outlet, michael kors outlet, michael kors outlet, coach purses, gucci outlet, louboutin shoes, prada outlet, michael kors outlet, louis vuitton outlet, polo ralph lauren, longchamp outlet, michael kors outlet, prada handbags, christian louboutin, michael kors outlet, coach factory outlet, nike free, ray ban sunglasses, kate spade outlet, louboutin, nike shoes, burberry outlet, louis vuitton outlet, tiffany and co, louis vuitton outlet stores, oakley sunglasses, oakley sunglasses, louis vuitton, true religion jeans, jordan shoes, oakley sunglasses cheap, louis vuitton handbags, ray ban sunglasses, coach outlet store online, michael kors outlet, polo ralph lauren outlet, true religion jeans
ReplyDeletelongchamp, marc jacobs, beats by dre, soccer shoes, reebok outlet, hollister, ugg, mcm handbags, instyler, ugg boots, canada goose, new balance shoes, vans shoes, bottega veneta, nfl jerseys, ugg pas cher, canada goose, ugg boots, valentino shoes, ugg australia, uggs outlet, nike roshe run, insanity workout, ghd, uggs outlet, celine handbags, abercrombie and fitch, rolex watches, herve leger, birkin bag, ugg boots, mac cosmetics, wedding dresses, nike huarache, north face jackets, canada goose outlet, north face outlet, soccer jerseys, chi flat iron, canada goose jackets, giuseppe zanotti, jimmy choo outlet, ferragamo shoes, mont blanc, lululemon outlet, asics running shoes, babyliss pro, p90x
ReplyDeletepandora charms, moncler outlet, canada goose uk, canada goose, moncler, moncler, canada goose, oakley, lancel, thomas sabo, toms shoes, hollister, ugg, moncler, coach outlet store online, montre homme, vans, louboutin, juicy couture outlet, moncler, gucci, iphone 6 cases, links of london, louis vuitton, juicy couture outlet, parajumpers, swarovski crystal, hollister clothing store, hollister, ralph lauren, air max, moncler, moncler, baseball bats, supra shoes, wedding dresses, converse, ugg, canada goose, converse shoes, karen millen, pandora charms, air max, rolex watches, timberland boots, ray ban, swarovski, pandora jewelry
ReplyDeletenike shoes, Cheap Jordans,Cheap Jordan Shoes,Cheap Air Max,Cheap Free Run Shoes,nike shoes,nike outlet,nike factory,nike store,nike factory outlet,nike outlet store,cheap nike shoes,nike sneakers, toms outlet, toms outlet,tom shoes,toms shoes outlet,tom shoes,toms wedges,cheap toms,toms.com, air jordan, air jordan,jordan shoes,cheap jordans,air jordans,jordan retro,air jordan shoes,jordans,jordan 11,jordan xx9,jordan 6,new jordans,retro jordans,jordan retro 11,jordan 5,air jordan 11,jordans for sale,jordan 4,jordan 1,jordan future,jordan 3,jordan 12,michael jordan shoes,air jordan retro, cheap jordans, cheap jordans,cheap jordan shoes,cheap jordan,cheap jordans for sale,jordans for cheap,jordan shoes,jordans,air jordan,jordan retro,jordan 11,jordan xx9,jordan 6,new jordans,air jordans,retro jordans,jordan retro 11,jordan 5,air jordan 11,jordans for sale,jordan 4,jordan 1,jordan future,jordan 3,jordan 12,michael jordan shoes,air jordan shoes,air jordan retro, jordan retro, jordan retro,jordan shoes,air jordan,air jordans,retro jordans,air jordan retro,jordans,jordan 11,jordan xx9,jordan 6,new jordans,cheap jordans,jordan retro 11,jordan 5,air jordan 11,jordans for sale,jordan 4,jordan 1,jordan future,jordan 3,jordan 12,michael jordan shoes,air jordan shoes, air max 90, air max 90,nike air max 90,air max 95,air max 2014,air max 2013,air max 1,nike air max,air max,nike air max 2014,airmax,nike air max 2013, air max 95, air max 95,nike air max 95,air max 90,nike air max 90,air max 2013,nike air max,air max,air max 2014,nike air max 2014,airmax,nike air max 2013, nike free 5.0, nike free 5.0, nike free trainer 5.0,nike free run 5.0,free running 2,nike free run,nike free,free running,nike running shoes,nike free trainer,free runs,free run 5.0, omega watches, omega watches,omega watch,replica watches,rolex watches,replica omega watches,rolex,watches for men,watches for women,rolex watches for sale,rolex replica,rolex watch,cartier watches,rolex submariner,fake rolex,rolex replica watches,replica rolex
ReplyDeleteralph lauren outlet, ralph lauren outlet,ralph lauren outlet online,polo ralph lauren outlet,polo ralph lauren outlet online,polo ralph lauren,ralph lauren,polo ralph,polo shirts,ralphlauren.com,polo outlet,ralph lauren polo, oakley sunglass, oakley sunglasses,cheap oakley,cheap oakley sunglasses,oakley sunglasses cheap,oakley outlet,oakley sunglasses outlet,oakley vault,oakleys,oakley.com,sunglasses outlet,cheap sunglasses,oakley prescription glasses,fake oakleys,oakley glasses,oakley store,fake oakley,oakley sale,cheap oakleys,discount oakley sunglasses, ray ban sunglasses, Ray Ban Sunglasses,Ray Ban Outlet,Ray Ban Sale,Cheap Ray Bans,Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses,ray ban sunglasses outlet,ray ban,rayban,ray bans,ray-ban,raybans,ray ban wayfarer,ray-ban sunglasses,raybans.com,rayban sunglasses,cheap ray ban, burberry, burberry,burberry outlet,burberry outlet online,burberry factory outlet,burberry sale,burberry handbags, chanel bags, chanel bags,chanel handbags,chanel sunglasses,chanel outlet,chanel purses,chanel handbags official site, coach outlet store, coach outlet,coach outlet store,coach outlet store online,coach outlet stores,coach factory outlet,coach factory,coach factory online,coach factory outlet online,coach outlet online, chaussures louboutin, louboutin,louboutin pas cher,christian louboutin,louboutin chaussures,louboutin soldes,chaussure louboutin,chaussures louboutin,chaussure louboutin pas cher,louboutin france, sac michael kors, michael kors,sac michael kors,michael kors sac,michael kors pas cher,sac michael kors pas cher,michael kors france, north face outlet, north face outlet,the north face,north face,the north face outlet,north face jackets,north face jackets clearance,northface
ReplyDeletenike shoes, Cheap Jordans,Cheap Jordan Shoes,Cheap Air Max,Cheap Free Run Shoes,nike shoes,nike outlet,nike factory,nike store,nike factory outlet,nike outlet store,cheap nike shoes,nike sneakers, toms outlet, toms outlet,tom shoes,toms shoes outlet,tom shoes,toms wedges,cheap toms,toms.com, air jordan, air jordan,jordan shoes,cheap jordans,air jordans,jordan retro,air jordan shoes,jordans,jordan 11,jordan xx9,jordan 6,new jordans,retro jordans,jordan retro 11,jordan 5,air jordan 11,jordans for sale,jordan 4,jordan 1,jordan future,jordan 3,jordan 12,michael jordan shoes,air jordan retro, cheap jordans, cheap jordans,cheap jordan shoes,cheap jordan,cheap jordans for sale,jordans for cheap,jordan shoes,jordans,air jordan,jordan retro,jordan 11,jordan xx9,jordan 6,new jordans,air jordans,retro jordans,jordan retro 11,jordan 5,air jordan 11,jordans for sale,jordan 4,jordan 1,jordan future,jordan 3,jordan 12,michael jordan shoes,air jordan shoes,air jordan retro, jordan retro, jordan retro,jordan shoes,air jordan,air jordans,retro jordans,air jordan retro,jordans,jordan 11,jordan xx9,jordan 6,new jordans,cheap jordans,jordan retro 11,jordan 5,air jordan 11,jordans for sale,jordan 4,jordan 1,jordan future,jordan 3,jordan 12,michael jordan shoes,air jordan shoes, air max 90, air max 90,nike air max 90,air max 95,air max 2014,air max 2013,air max 1,nike air max,air max,nike air max 2014,airmax,nike air max 2013, air max 95, air max 95,nike air max 95,air max 90,nike air max 90,air max 2013,nike air max,air max,air max 2014,nike air max 2014,airmax,nike air max 2013, nike free 5.0, nike free 5.0, nike free trainer 5.0,nike free run 5.0,free running 2,nike free run,nike free,free running,nike running shoes,nike free trainer,free runs,free run 5.0, omega watches, omega watches,omega watch,replica watches,rolex watches,replica omega watches,rolex,watches for men,watches for women,rolex watches for sale,rolex replica,rolex watch,cartier watches,rolex submariner,fake rolex,rolex replica watches,replica rolex, ralph lauren outlet, ralph lauren outlet,ralph lauren outlet online,polo ralph lauren outlet,polo ralph lauren outlet online,polo ralph lauren,ralph lauren,polo ralph,polo shirts,ralphlauren.com,polo outlet,ralph lauren polo, oakley sunglass, thomas sabo
ReplyDeleteoakley sunglasses,cheap oakley,cheap oakley sunglasses,oakley sunglasses cheap,oakley outlet,oakley sunglasses outlet,oakley vault,oakleys,oakley.com,sunglasses outlet,cheap sunglasses,oakley prescription glasses,fake oakleys,oakley glasses,oakley store,fake oakley,oakley sale,cheap oakleys,discount oakley sunglasses, ray ban sunglasses, Ray Ban Sunglasses,Ray Ban Outlet,Ray Ban Sale,Cheap Ray Bans,Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses,ray ban sunglasses outlet,ray ban,rayban,ray bans,ray-ban,raybans,ray ban wayfarer,ray-ban sunglasses,raybans.com,rayban sunglasses,cheap ray ban, burberry, burberry,burberry outlet,burberry outlet online,burberry factory outlet,burberry sale,burberry handbags, chanel bags, chanel bags,chanel handbags,chanel sunglasses,chanel outlet,chanel purses,chanel handbags official site, coach outlet store, coach outlet,coach outlet store,coach outlet store online,coach outlet stores,coach factory outlet,coach factory,coach factory online,coach factory outlet online,coach outlet online, chaussures louboutin, louboutin,louboutin pas cher,christian louboutin,louboutin chaussures,louboutin soldes,chaussure louboutin,chaussures louboutin,chaussure louboutin pas cher,louboutin france, sac michael kors, michael kors,sac michael kors,michael kors sac,michael kors pas cher,sac michael kors pas cher,michael kors france, north face outlet, north face outlet,the north face,north face,the north face outlet,north face jackets,north face jackets clearance,northface, yoga pants, yoga pants,lululemon,lululemon outlet,lululemon athletica,lululemon addict,lulu lemon,lulu.com,lululemon.com, beats by dre, beats by dre,beats headphones,beats audio,beats by dr dre,beats by dre headphones,dr dre,dre beats,beats by dr,dr dre beats,dre headphones,beats by dr. dre,cheap beats, ferragamo, ferragamo,salvatore ferragamo,ferragamo shoes,ferragamo outlet,salvatore ferragamo outlet,ferragamo belts,ferragamo belt,ferragamo outlet, nike blazer, nike blazer,blazer nike,nike blazer pas cher,Chaussures Nike Blazer,Nike Blazer Femme, nike air force, swarovski crystal, swarovski
ReplyDeletenike air force,air force,nike air force 1,nike air force one,air force one nike,air force 1,air force one, michael kors outlet, michael kors outlet,michael kors handbags,michael kors uk,michael kors,michael kors,michael kors bags, cheap jerseys, cheap jerseys,nfl jerseys,cheap nfl jerseys,jerseys from china,cheap jerseys from china, cheap nfl jerseys, NFL Jerseys,Nike NFL Jerseys,NBA Jerseys,Soccer Jersey,NHL Jerseys,Baseball Jerseys,Custom Jersey,Youth Jerseys,Women Jerseys,NCAA Jerseys,cheap jerseys,cheap nfl jerseys,basketball jerseys,jerseys,hockey jerseys, jerseys from china, jerseys from china,cheap jerseys from china,nfl jerseys,cheap jerseys,cheap nfl jerseys,jerseys,baseball jerseys,nba jerseys,hockey jerseys,basketball jerseys, burberry uk, burberry, timberland boots uk, timberland, oakley sunglasses, oakley sunglasses, oakley sunglasses cheap, ray ban sunglasses, ray ban sunglasses, polo ralph lauren, polo ralph lauren outlet, burberry outlet, burberry outlet, michael kors outlet, michael kors outlet online sale, michael kors outlet, michael kors outlet, michael kors outlet, michael kors outlet, christian louboutin, louboutin outlet, louboutin, louboutin shoes, tory burch outlet, gucci outlet, prada handbags, prada outlet, longchamp outlet, longchamp handbags, longchamp handbags
ReplyDeletejordan shoes, nike shoes, tiffany and co, tiffany and co, air max, air max, nike free, chanel handbags, kate spade outlet, kate spade handbags, louis vuitton outlet, louis vuitton outlet, louis vuitton, louis vuitton outlet stores, louis vuitton handbags, coach outlet, coach factory outlet, coach outlet store online, coach purses, true religion jeans, true religion jeans, true religion outlet, true religion outlet, air max, air max pas cher, air jordan, nike free pas cher, nike roshe run, sac longchamp, longchamp, polo ralph lauren, sac louis vuitton, sac louis vuitton, louboutin, michael kors pas cher, sac burberry, oakley pas cher, ray ban pas cher, hollister, sac hermes, vans pas cher, timberland, new balance pas cher, converse pas cher, north face, nike tn, polo lacoste, nike blazer, air force, sac guess, vanessa bruno
ReplyDeletelouis vuitton, hogan outlet, ray ban sunglasses, michael kors, michael kors, lululemon outlet online, louis vuitton uk, hollister, north face, mulberry, ralph lauren, nike air max, air max, nike free, abercrombie and fitch, barbour, nike roshe, nike trainers, nike huarache, longchamp, hollister, vans shoes, nike roshe run, mac cosmetics, abercrombie and fitch, birkin bag, north face outlet, north face jackets, new balance shoes, reebok outlet, lululemon outlet, nfl jerseys, rolex watches, wedding dresses, beats by dre, mont blanc, ferragamo shoes, giuseppe zanotti, instyler, babyliss pro, mcm handbags, chi flat iron, insanity workout, ghd, bottega veneta, valentino shoes, herve leger, asics running shoes, soccer shoes, soccer jerseys, celine handbags, p90x
ReplyDeletejimmy choo outlet, uggs, ugg boots clearance, ugg, ugg pas cher, ugg boots, canada goose, canada goose jackets, canada goose outlet, canada goose, canada goose, canada goose uk, moncler, moncler outlet, moncler, moncler, hollister clothing store, air max, baseball bats, iphone 6 cases, timberland boots, moncler, ugg, oakley, louboutin, ralph lauren, hollister, air max, vans, converse, gucci, ray ban, converse shoes, lancel, toms shoes, moncler, canada goose, canada goose, moncler, montre homme, karen millen, supra shoes, juicy couture outlet, juicy couture outlet, coach outlet store online, wedding dresses, rolex watches, hollister, louis vuitton, ugg, pandora jewelry, pandora charms, pandora charms, links of london
ReplyDeletePorno, Porno izle, Türk Porno
ReplyDeletePorno, Porno izle, Sikiş izle
Porno, Porno izle, Sikiş izle, Sikiş
Porno, Porno izle, Sikiş izle, Sikiş
Porno, Porno izle, Sikiş izle, Türk porno
Porno izle, Porno, Sikiş izle
Porno, Sex, Porno izle
Porno, Porno izle
Porno Sikiş, Porno, Porno izle
Porno, Porno izle, Sikiş izle
Porno, Porno Sex Sikiş, Porno izle
Porno, Sikiş izle, Türk Porno, Kızlık Bozma
Porno, Sikişme izle, Türk Porno, Kızlık Bozma
Türk Porno izle, Türk Pornosu, Türk Sex, Türk Sikiş
Porno Film izle, Türk Porno, Sikiş
Porno izle, Porno video seyret
Nice article, thanks for the information. It's very complete information. I will bookmark for next reference
ReplyDeletejaring futsal | jaring golf | jaring pengaman proyek |
jaring pengaman bangunan | jaring pengaman gedung
http://www.jual-jaring.blogspot.com/
http://www.agen-jaring.blogspot.com/
http://www.pancasamudera-safetynet.blogspot.com/
http://www.toko-jaring.blogspot.com/
http://www.pusat-jaring.blogspot.com/
http://jualjaringpengaman.blogspot.com/
https://pancasamudera.wordpress.com/
https://pasangjaringfutsal.wordpress.com/
https://jualtambangmurah.wordpress.com/
https://tokojaring.wordpress.com/
https://jualjaringfutsal.wordpress.com/
https://jaringfutsal.wordpress.com/