Languid Times foppist churns snark: Over at The Atlantic, Peter Beinart is obeying the rules of mainstream press corps press criticism.
Beinart makes the statement shown below concerning the coverage of Candidate Sanders. To us, his claim seems slightly strange—and he provides no examples:
“Media coverage of Sanders has been fawning, partly because many journalists harbor sympathy for his anti-corporate message but mostly because they’re desperate for a contested primary.”
Has media coverage of Candidate Sanders been fawning? That wouldn’t have occurred to us, and Beinart provides no examples to show us what he means.
In this way, he obeys his guild’s relentless code of silence. Dearest darlings! No names are allowed! The word “fawning” isn't polite!
For ourselves, we wouldn’t say the coverage was fawning on the front page of Saturday’s New York Times. Live and direct from Philips Exeter, Yale and London, the wondrously self-involved Sarah Lyall was languorously rolling her eyes at the early and silly youthful young pre-candidate.
Lyall seems like a real piece of work. Headline included, her profile of Sanders started like this:
LYALL (7/4/15): Bernie Sanders’s Revolutionary Roots Were Nurtured in ’60s VermontDid Bernie Sanders “go to Vermont in the late 1960s to help plan the upending of the old social order?”
When he came to Vermont in the late 1960s to help plan the upending of the old social order, the future presidential candidate Bernie Sanders brought with him the belief that the United States was starkly divided into two groups: the establishment and the revolutionaries. He was a revolutionary.
Lyall seems to make that claim in her opening sentence—and she already seems to be snarking. It’s a version of the “Creeping Dowdism” which was established, decades ago, as the standard way this terrible newspaper wends its highly privileged way through its strikingly low-IQ life.
Lyall, now maybe 52, seems like a real piece of work. She and her husband, Robert McCrum, seem to have spent an inordinate amount of their professional time talking about themselves in an array of forums.
Check Lyall’s strange Wikipedia page for a sense of the foolishness here. Or read this fawning spread by Susannah Butter, who tells us that the marginal Lyall and her husband “are one of the more recognisable social couples on the London literary scene, she with her blonde hair and American warmth and he with his literary gravitas.”
Let us guess that Lady Lyall never went to Vermont, or anywhere else, intent on upending, reforming, ameliorating or improving any established social order of any discernible kind. Perhaps for that reason, it seems to have jumped into her small head that Sanders went to Vermont, long ago, “intent” on the “upending” she seems to have garnished with snark.
Is that why Sanders went to Vermont? In her front-page profile of Sanders, Lyall makes no apparent attempt to establish the truth of that assertion. Indeed, it’s striking to list the various things you still don’t know about the Sanders of the era in question after reading her weak imitation of the journalist’s art:
When did Sanders move to Vermont?
How old was he at the time?
Why has he said he moved to Vermont?
What had he done in the years before that? Had he gone to college? If so, where?
On its front page, the Times included a photo of Sanders with a young child, a photo which carried this caption:
“Bernie Sanders held his son during a meeting in 1971 with colleagues from The Vermont Freeman in Burlington, Vt.”
Was Sanders married? To whom? How many kids did he have?
Despite the presence of the photo, you don’t learn those sorts of things in Lyall’s profile either. Basic info is basically AWOL in this eye-rolling piece.
Let’s fill in a few of those answers. According to the leading authority on his life, Sanders moved to Vermont in 1968, at age 26 or 27. (He was born in September 1941.)
In an earlier profile of Sanders, Times reporter Mark Leibovich was able to provide some basics concerning the way he got there. Somehow, he also managed to tell a human tale:
LEIBOVICH (1/21/07): Sanders’s parents were Jewish immigrants from Poland. His father, Eli, a struggling paint salesman who saw his family wiped out in the Holocaust, worried constantly about supporting his wife and two sons. His mother, Dorothy, dreamed of living in a “private home,” but they never made it beyond their three-and-a-half-room apartment on East 26th and Kings Highway. She died at age 46, when Bernie was 19. “Sensitivity to class was imbedded in me then quite deeply,” Sanders told me.According to this profile from Chicago Magazine, “he and his college girlfriend, who became his first wife, bought 85 acres of woodlands in Middlesex, Vermont for $2,500” before moving to the state. Neither profile says that he was intent on upending the old social order, although he may have been.
Sanders spent a year at Brooklyn College before transferring to the University of Chicago, where he studied psychology and helped lead protests against racially segregated housing on campus. He spent time on a kibbutz in Israel after graduation and then moved to Vermont with his first wife. “I had always been captivated by rural life,” he says. As a child, Sanders attended Boy Scout camp upstate and used to cry on the bus as it returned him to New York at the end of the summer.
In the main, Lyall’s profile is devoted to quoting silly-sounding things Sanders wrote in the early 1970s, while marveling at the fact that he didn’t have much money then. Did we note the fact that the writer is straight outta Exeter/Yale?
In fairness, quite a few people were saying somewhat silly things in the era in question. That said, we wouldn’t necessarily put our faith in Lyall’s paraphrasing and transcription of Sanders’ free-lance articles.
She says his pieces numbered like twelve, including the “diatribes.”
Lyall’s talent seems to be her ability to say silly-sounding things even now. For endless YouTube visits with the scribe, you can just click here.
We like Bernie Sanders’ politics a lot. We can also imagine him losing 49 states.
That said, we judge journalists here, not pols. Lyall’s front-page profile strikes us as snarky, unfinished, inept.
It doesn’t seem fawning to us. Think Maureen Dowd in a can, except Lyall isn’t that bright!
The Times is foppish all the way down. The paper brands itself as literary, upper-end, sophistiqué, insightful.
That branding is an endless charade. Concerning the Times, one imperative reigns:
Train yourself not to be fooled.
Beinart wrote an interesting piece. Somerby opens with it. He does not analyze most of what is said in the Atlantic article, however. It is there as set decoration. It's only purpose is for Somerby to drop his "G" bomb on all journalists before launching on the target d'jour.ReplyDelete
It isn't what it should be. It isn't what it claims to be. And it isn't what its supposed critics (Hi, Mister Beinart!) say it is.
But we have a bigger problem: The tics and foibles of this blog pointing that out.
Trolls! -- To your keyboards!!!
Yes! How dare the "trolls" comment about the contents of this blog in this blog's comment box! Who do they think they are?Delete
Tic = sudden repetitive non-motor movement or vocalization involving discrete muscle groups.Delete
Foible = a minor weakness, eccentricity or flaw in a person's character; the top 1/3 of a fencing foil.
Tick = Bernie Sanders inspiration for his 90% tax rate
Foible:= HRC's cackle
@ cicero - a 5-cent troll.Delete
Bloggerman Somerby seems to have his finger on "Lady Lyall's" essence. He maybe knows how old she is and suggests a familiarity with how she and her husband spend their time.ReplyDelete
"Lyall, now maybe 52, seems like a real piece of work. She and her husband, Robert McCrum, seem to have spent an inordinate amount of their professional time talking about themselves in an array of forums."
We are not told when they began talking about themselves, or to whom. And while no exact amount or percentage of time is specified as to the boundary for appropriate and inappropriate self centeredness in one's professional talking, Somerby is straight out of Harvard so we presume he should know.
Check out Somerby's strange Wikipedia page. It eschews any detail and instead directs you to the Howler page. The Howler page reads almost if written by Somerby himself. It is a fawning piece, written by someone who uses that adjective as if it were a required predecessor to any article which lacks any level of vituperation.
It is hard to say for certain how large Somerby's head is. We know it is of sufficient size to fit several imaginary analysts and still maintain sufficient space for a memory bank which can summon every insult ever uttered against Al Gore since the beginning of the War Against Him. Because he does not judge pols. Just the snarky inept overpaid
guild members who defame his favorite ones.
A pissed off Lady Lyall apologist. LOLDelete
Yours must be Bob-sized.Delete
If so there is wasted space.Delete
I can hardly wait until Somerby presents the work of the fearless professor he mentioned yesterday. The one who, after years of entreaty from Somerby, is doing what our Howler wants and is attacking this "straight out of Yale" fop who is married to the English literary twit.ReplyDelete
Best I can tell the Professor Bromwich is straight out of Yale (by way of Yale & Yale) and is a professor of English literature. Like Bobo Brooks he loves him some Edmund Burke. Just the kind of guy to tell the Times where to get off it's "literary, upper-end, sophistiqué, insightful" arse.
"They (GOP POTUS candidates) range across a spectrum of being either begrudgingly welcome or hostile towards immigrants." HRC interview with CNN's Brianna Keilar. July 7, 2015ReplyDelete
Hillary believes Jeb Bush relationship with his Mexican wife Columba Bush is either begrudgingly welcome or outright hostile. She must be channeling her own relationship with Willie.
"Cicero believes anyone gives a cat's crap about what he/she/it believes Hillary believes."Delete
Thank you for taking the time to provide your opinion on a subject you couldn't care less about.
Columba wasn't an immigrant. The "lightening" struck J. E. Bush when he met her in León, Guanajuato, Mexico. (If Clinton's right, it never would have happened that way in Texas- and for sure not with Barbra Bush around.)Delete
People are still immigrants to the U.S. regardless of whether their spouse initially met them in their home country.
But she is Mexican. So she brought drugs. Crime. She's a rapist. She might be good people though.Delete
Thanks for explaining that to me. Guess I should always think my arguments through carefully whenever I want them to be taken seriously.
Then she would be living in a sanctuary city as endorsed by Francisco Sanchez.
"Foppish" is apt. Good piece.ReplyDelete
It certainly provoked a mordant chuckle in our quarters. Bet it even aroused a twinkle in the oft tear stained orbs of an analyst or two.Delete
I thought foppistry was the second most damaging false charge leveled against Candidate Gore. Maybe I was just lactating.Delete
"That said, we wouldn’t necessarily put our faith in Lyall’s paraphrasing and transcription of Sanders’ free-lance articles."ReplyDelete
I agree with Bob. That is why I recommend the latest work from Tim Murphy over at Mother Jones, whose work on the Sanders archives beginning in May Somerby has, for some reason, chosen to skip.
"You Might Very Well Be the Cause of Cancer": Read Bernie Sanders' 1970s-Era Essays
How Bernie Sanders Learned to Be a Real Politician
A portrait of the candidate as a young radical.
Yes, every Somerby post must be a comprehensive review of the literature on a topic or he deserves severe criticism! And if he overlooks someone, it must have been deliberate.Delete
Linking to complimentary topics is severe criticism?Delete
Oh, wait. I see. Instead of "for some reason" I should have written "seemingly to save space, but we don't know."
My apologies. To you and Somerby.
I don't think you should apologize. Clinton apologist Somerby, who keeps comparing Bernie Sanders to McGovern deliberately skipped this fine comparison of Sanders to other candidates.Delete
I get it!
michael kors outlet stores michael kors outlet online sale michael kors outlet michael kors outlet online michael kors 2015 michael kors outlet michael kors outlet stores mbt Shoes discount mbt Shoes mbt shoes sale mbt shoes online Buy mbt shoes online mbt shoes shopping mbt footwear new mbt mbt usa mbt canada coach outlet coach outlet stores coach outlet online coach factory coach factory outlet coach factory online coach outlet store online coach outlet online coach factory outlet coach outlet coach outlet stores coach outlet online coach outlet store online coach outlet online coach factory outletReplyDelete