Some human reactions go back a long way!


Teenaged girl shouldn't have come here:
Willa Cather moved from Virginia to Nebraska in 1883. She made the move with her parents. She was 9 years old.

In her highly autobiographical novel, My Antonia, Cather transforms herself into Jim Burden, her novel's (male) narrator. He meets, and forms a lifelong attachment, to a Bohemian immigrant, Antonia Shimerda.

Some fundamental human stories tend not to change over time. The book appeared in 1928, telling a story which begins in the 1880s.

When Jim is 10 and Antonia is 14 when the following exchange occurs. As we start, Antonia is describing her father's unhappiness during her family's first year in this new, strange, difficult land:
‘My papa sad for the old country. He not look good. He never make music any more. At home he play violin all the time; for weddings and for dance. Here never. When I beg him for play, he shake his head no. Some days he take his violin out of his box and make with his fingers on the strings, like this, but never he make the music. He don’t like this kawntree.’

‘People who don’t like this country ought to stay at home,’ I said severely.
‘We don’t make them come here.’

‘He not want to come, never!’ she burst out. ‘My mamenka make him come. All the time she say: “America big country; much money, much land for my boys, much husband for my girls.” My papa, he cry for leave his old friends what make music with him. He love very much the man what play the long horn like this’—she indicated a slide trombone. “They go to school together and are friends from boys. But my mama, she want Ambrosch for be rich, with many cattle.”’

‘Your mama,’ I said angrily, ‘wants other people’s things.’
Did we mention the fact that Jim is 10 at this point in the story? By the time he's 20, Antonia is delivering one of the book's most memorable lines, summarizing the somewhat mysterious connection between herself and her native-born friend:

"Ain’t it wonderful, Jim, how much people can mean to each other?"

As we reread the book last week, we were barely a week removed from Mister Trump's dimwitted suggestion that AOC and the rest of "the squad" should go back to the countries they came from.

Mister Trump's dimwitted statement was made in the year 2019. Jim, aged 10, was expressing a somewhat similar thought back in the 1880s.

The Nebraska of the 1880s was largely settled by immigrant families. In Cather's rendition, these largely European families were often viewed with a rather familiar type of disdain by their native-born neighbors.

We'll review Cather's account of this matter tomorrow. Her account will possibly sound familiar, especially to those of us who believe every word we hear on MSNBC, but one large irony will obtain:

The people being disregarded will be among the "whitest" people found anywhere on the earth. The "Danish girls" are so disregarded, and Cather convincingly describes their pink-cheeked beauty, along with their endless good cheer.

We humans may tend to demonize others quite freely. Such others don't have to be "brown."

Tomorrow: "I thought the attitude of the town people toward these girls very stupid..."


  1. "Mister Trump's dimwitted statement was made in the year 2019."

    And what's so dimwitted about it, dear Bob? Perfectly normal human reaction to 'I chose to come here, and I hate this place', or variants of thereof.

    You probably meant "non-PC"? But you see, dear Bob, we humans regard your zombie devotion to PC dimwitted. Tsk. In the eye of the beholder, as they say...

    1. Screw "political correctness" . You can't even call Conservatives "bigots" without someone whining about how in-PC it is.

  2. "The Nebraska of the 1880s was largely settled by immigrant families"

    Thus is accepted the myth of the "nation of immigrants". According to data here, the percentage of foreign born in Nebraska in 1870 was only 25%. Thus Nebraska of the 1880s was largely settled by people born in the US. People from such foreign places as Iowa, Illinois, Wisconsin, New York, etc.

  3. The unhappy father commits suicide in this book.

    The book also describes how immigrants were taken advantage of, as Antonia was when she became a household worker.

    The California of the 1880s was largely Mexican. In the 1880s you need to wuestion how well the census counted immigrants. Did they visit every rural farm? Did they have translators to count every immigrant in crowded NYC tenements? Undercounting has been endemic, leading to a mistaken beliefs about who settled or built what.

  4. “Mister Trump's dimwitted suggestion that AOC and the rest of "the squad" should go back to the countries they came from.”

    Dimwitted? It was strategic, nefarious, manipulative, borderline evil, cheered on by his crowds, and quite deliberate. It had its desired effect, which includes death threats against the “squad” and mass murder in El Paso.

    For Somerby to describe it with the innocent term “dimwitted” is to ignore the reality of Trump and Trumpism.

  5. Another excerpt from my memoirs rather cogently relates to such Trumpian rhetoric:

    "... and it was around this time that she reassured me that the unpleasant smell was merely the result of a slip of the fanny.

    I then proceeded to ask her the secret to producing such a foul-smelling gas. I could definitely use this trick when in the presence of my enemies.

    Such fanny-slips could prove very helpful to my cause."

    Stay tuned for more excerpts in future posts.


  6. I doubt Jim added 'then come back and teach us how it's done.' Funny how that second part of Trump's statement is always conveniently disappeared.

  7. LOTTO, lottery,jackpot.
    Hello all my viewers, I am very happy for sharing this great testimonies,The best thing that has ever happened in my life is how I win the lottery euro million mega jackpot. I am a Woman who believe that one day I will win the lottery. finally my dreams came through when I email and tell him I need the lottery numbers. I have spend so much money on ticket just to make sure I win. But I never know that winning was so easy until the day I meant the spell caster online which so many people has talked about that he is very great in casting lottery spell, . so I decide to give it a try.I contacted this great Dr Believe and he did a spell and he gave me the winning lottery numbers. But believe me when the draws were out I was among winners. I win 30,000 million Dollar. Dr Believe truly you are the best, all thanks to you forever