MONDAY, JUNE 29, 2026
...an old war cry was employed: On balance, we're inclined to agree with what Jessica Tarlov said last Tuesday, on the day when the city and the state of New York conducted primary elections.
Mayor Mamdani had endorsed congressional candidates from three different congressional districts. Two were members of the DSA—the Democratic Socialists of America. The third was a former member of that organization.
That very day, each candidate won the Democratic Party's nomination to serve in the House. As a general matter, we're inclined to agree with what Tarlov said that day.
We now jump ahead to Wednesday—to the day after The Mamdani 3 won those nominations:
On Wednesday's episode of The Five, a segment began with videotape of the sitting president calling these candidates Communists. A full reversion was underway within the American discourse.
The three nominees were Communists, the exercised president said. As the segment began on The Five, the chyron at the bottom of the screen said this:
COMMIE CRUSADERS
MAMDANI ENDORSES SOCIALIST CANDIDATES IN NYC PRIMARIES
Sad! According to producers of The Five, Mayor Mamdani had endorsed a trio of "Commie Crusaders."
On balance, we agree with what Tarlov had said, the previous day, about the trio of Commies. First, though, you ought to see what Jesse Watters now said.
On Wednesday's edition of The Five, Watters was plainly upset. Occasionally turning to address Tarlov, he started by saying this:
WATTERS (6/24/26): This is dangerous. You don't think these people can springboard to become governor, senator, AG? This is how it happens. You guys run your little power centers in Chicago, Los Angeles, New York. All of a sudden, you guys just populated all the higher offices in those states. And you guys are just going to sit back and do nothing with that power?
You're coming for us. You're coming for our money, you're coming for our people. You're coming for our way of life.
It's not socialism, guys. This is Communism.
You can't reason with these guys. You have to crush them. And we will, because we're not going to let our greatest city get destroyed. We're not going to let our civilization get destroyed. These people are going to steal from us. These people want to hurt us.
This isn't like your regular Democrat...One of the ladies said she wants to destroy western civilization. I don't know about you, I take that as a threat. Another woman says she wants to empty prisons. That sounds like a violent threat.
Abolish ICE. That means you can break into the country, rape, and stay.
I don't like that. I'm not going to go for it. And no one's going to go for it. And the way we're going to react is going to be a lot tougher than the way Trump is reacting. The way we're going to react is going to make Trump look like a kitten.
To our ear, it was Watters' assessment—and his pledge—which sounded a bit like a threat! That said, the gentleman wasn't finished. He continued along, eventually saying this:
WATTERS: These people don't believe in borders, capitalism, our founding fathers. They're here to steal, punish us, and then throw around welfare. This is a Third World takeover. This is what happens when you import the Third World.
Did you know that New York City is 70% nonwhite? 40% foreign-born? 50% of the apartments, they don't even speak English! Not even their first language!
These three women [sic] who Mamdani endorsed, weren't even born in New York City, weren't even raised in New York City. They're carpetbaggers. Carpetbaggers, Jessica!
...Communism is going to take over the Democratic Party, and then we're going to have to beat it, because you can't—
You can't do anything else besides beat it to a pulp.
Watters was ready for a fight—for what sounded almost like a street fight. He said his cadre was going to make President Trump look like a kitten.
He said his cadre was going to beat the Democratic Party to a pulp.
Meanwhile, Watters was, as usual, utterly clueless. He was so clueless that he seemed to think that Mamdani had endorsed three women for the House—and yes, that's what this cable star said.
For the record, Watters is the most-watched person in American "cable news," thanks to his dual role as co-host of The Five and host of Jesse Watters Primetime.
They're the two most watched shows in the entire realm of American "cable news." Watters is the driving force on each of these ludicrous programs.
Just to establish the record, we'll cite a few basic facts:
One of the three nominees, Brad Lander, is, in fact, a man. As is perfectly typical, Watters didn't seem to be aware of this remarkably well-known fact.
Lander was elected to citywide office in New York—to the office of New York City Comptroller—back in 2021, long before Mamdani was part of the story. Lander was raised in St. Louis. Of the two women Mamdani did endorse, one was raised in Lubbock, Texas. The other was raised in Florida.
We now move on to this:
As of last week, Watters seemed to be shocked to have recently learned that New York City isn't majority white. For the record, these were the basic numbers in 2024, according to Census Reporter (Census QuickFacts is down):
New York City race / ethnicity:
White: 31%
Hispanic: 29%
Black: 20%
Asian: 15%
There's nothing especially new about that. Watters recited his disturbing data on several occasions last week.
Meanwhile, Communist Communist Communist Communist Communist Communist Commies:
A familiar cry was bruited last week as the reversion was on.
On Friday, President Trump droned about the problem at a Faith and Freedom Coalition event. For Mediaite's report, just click here. But here's part of what the president said about the godless trio in question:
PRESIDENT TRUMP (6/26/26): As you saw with the Communists elected in New York City recently—they're Communists, they're not Social Democrats—they want to completely destroy the traditional American way of life...
It’s happening right now in New York and California. But you’ll start living in squalor. You’ll live in squalor. There will be no food. There will be no housing. There will be no military. There will be no law and order. There will be no nothing. There will be no nothing. You will be a third-world inhabitant in every way, and everyone will suffer or die.
You’ll suffer or die. That’s what happens.
[...]
These are not Social Democrats. These are hardcore godless Communists. They’re godless Communists.
All Communists are godless. They don’t believe in God. This is the most serious threat to our country since its existence, in my opinion, 250 years ago. This is a major threat to our country.
People don’t look at that— "Three people were elected!" No, no. It's many more than three people. And the other people are being swayed because they don’t have the sense to see what’s happening.
The nomination of the three candidates in New York City? It constitutes "the most serious threat" in this country's existence, the sitting president actually said.
For the record, are these three nominees actually Communists? We'll discuss that matter as the week proceeds. For now, we'll offer an obvious no.
That said, the old battle cry was widely bruited last week. For example, it was bruited by the most-watched person in "cable news" on Friday evening's edition of Jesse Watters Primetime.
The most-watched person played tape of the president's dire warning at the Faith and Family event. He then launched a lengthy jihad of his own about the greatest threat in history, the threat posed by the three "godless Communists."
We won't quote the various things our most-watched cable newsperson said. As a substitute, we'll start by offering a word count from that evening's opening segment:
Word count: Jesse Watters Primetime, 6/26/26
"Communist:" 24
"Communism:" 7
"Commie:" 5
Sad! To borrow from Joyce, the C-words were general over the pseudo-discussion.
And not only that! As this very strange fellow proceeded, some of the chyrons blared thusly:
Chyrons: Jesse Watters Primetime, 6/26/26
TRUMP DECLARES WAR ON COMMUNISM
COMMUNISTS INFILTRATE DEMOCRATIC PARTY
COMMIE PIRATE: HAKEEM IS WEAK
"HARDCORE, GODLESS COMMUNISTS"
DEM: "WE AGREE WITH COMMUNISTS"
COMMIE WAVE CRASHES INTO AMERICA
You can add those six additional usages onto the prior word count! But a "Commie wave" had crashed into America! Sadly, that's what the chyrons said.
Now for the rest of the story:
Fellow citizens, is it true? Godless or otherwise, had Mamdani endorsed three "Communists" to serve in the House of Representatives?
We'll examine that question as the week proceeds. Be prepared to encounter a "no."
Finally, what did Jessica Tarlov say, on Tuesday's edition of The Five, about the three "monsters" in question? (We're quoting Emily Compagno's choice of words on that same day's program. Inevitably, this star of stage and cable news scream also went with "psychopaths.")
What did Tarlov say about the three "psychopaths" in question? We'll show you that first thing tomorrow--but as a general matter, we'd be inclined to agree with what she said, especially about Darializa Avila Chevalier, one of the three nominees.
Communism Communists but also Commie Crusaders! In this, the dumbest of all possible worlds, an old battle cry was out.
That said, who was actually worse last week as the reversion began? The stars who clowned for Red America, or the stars over here in Blue America who averted their gaze once again?
Tomorrow: We wouldn't have chosen that word
Oh the irony!
ReplyDeleteHistorically one of the more prominent voices of communistic ideas is the mythical figure of Jesus.
Doh!
Typical of Republicans, these lost souls are fine with communism/socialism for the elites, but not for the common people.
To be fair, the OT endorses slavery and genocide and all manner of other horrors. Supposedly Jesus did say to follow every jot or tittle. But what’s religion without its massive contradictions?
DeleteRules for thee but not for me.
DeleteElites!
What can you do?
They hold all the cards.
One of the primary ways they hold all the cards is through religious indoctrination.
DeleteOof, Somerby.
ReplyDeleteIt was a lot more than 3 progressives/leftists that won primaries last week. (about ten times that)
Somerby is in cope mode.
Somerby, thumb, scale.
DeleteRinse and repeat.
If you didn’t catch that the commies are coming (in reality to diminish inequality, break up monopolies, and increase democracy in the workplace) to deny the Right the ability to avoid accountability in hoarding assets and freely engaging in racism, sexism, and xenophobia, then Somerby amplifies it well today.
ReplyDeleteIgnorance ain’t gonna manufacture itself.
DeleteSomerby did nothing to resist Trump getting elected, so he hasn’t a leg to stand on now as it all falls apart.
ReplyDeleteSit down, Somerby. You lost any credibility long ago.
Not only do old bloggers die, beforehand many fade into oblivion.
Somerby’s buyers remorse over Trump, is delightful.
DeleteWhat did Tarlov say that Somerby agrees with? Somerby never quotes or summarizes what she said. I'm glad Somerby finds people to agree with, but it would be more interesting to know what she actually said. This isn't the first time Somerby has done this kind of thing.
ReplyDeleteThese teases are one of Somerby's worst habts.
DeleteCoy Somerby, showing a little leg and then scowling that you looked.
DeleteWhat a weirdo he is.
The point of this tease is to send people over to Fox to see what she said.
DeleteA simple guess is Tarlov thinks Mamdani is too extreme and will cost Democrats votes (a reasonable position), but dealing with the topic here would overwhelm everything else Somerby says, plus it warrants a post all its own, so he's saving it for later (if, indeed, he does get around to it). Somerby is a born handwringer, so he's always going to agree with one of his kind, even when she (or he) is paid to be a handwringer.
Delete"What did Tarlov say that Somerby agrees with? Somerby never quotes or summarizes what she said"
DeleteSee that text that's in a different color from the rest? That's called a "hyperlink." If you move your cursor over it, the pointer changes shape to let you know you can click on it to see a different page.
And no, this one doesn't take you to Fox..
If you follow the link you will see that it does not answer the question at all. It leads to the entire Fox transcript as one long block of text. Unhelpful and not worth your condescending chiding.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteNew York is historically a city of immigrants, not only from other countries but also from other states. People from the heartland go to NYC to make their names, find like minds and get ahead in business, especially Wall Street. It is where journalists go to make it in the big time. For that reason, no one in NYC cares whether a candidate grew up in NYC or not. Talent seeks opportunity that is not available in rural or small town America. This brain drain from red areas may be part of the problem faced by Republicans.
DeleteTrump grew up in NYC, so it’s not necessarily something to tout.
DeleteGranted, Trump was “raised” by a dad that supported the KKK and the Nazi German Bund, and wouldn’t rent to black people, and couldn’t stand his son Donald so shipped him off to military school, but did later hand Trump $450 million and Trump proceeded to throw that all away on multiple bankruptcies, and instead spent his time as a sexual predator including preying on minors.
Being “from” NYC is not always a good thing.
When Somerby refers to "reversions" in his headline, is he talking about the right wing's retreat to labeling the left commie?
ReplyDeletePerhaps it is time to point out that Social Democrats are not Communists, they are more like the govts in European countries such as Sweeden, Norway, Denmark, UK and Canada to a lesser extent, Iceland. It has nothing to do with communism.
Somerby may take it for granted that people know that, but do they? This is a another big lie being told by the right. Those big lies need to be refuted, not repeated over and over as Somerby does today, without explaining that Mamdani is not communist and neither are any of the people who won in NYC.
Because Somerby will never tell you this:
"A social democrat is a follower of a political ideology that seeks to reform capitalism through democratic means, aiming to establish a society characterized by social and economic justice. Instead of abolishing free-market economies, social democrats advocate for a robust welfare state, heavy labor protections, and progressive taxation."
"A communist is an advocate or supporter of communism—a political and economic ideology aimed at creating a classless, stateless society based on the common ownership of the means of production."
Anyone comparing these two approaches can clearly see that they are different. That is why Somerby needs to educate readers and point this stuff out so that the Others who are consumers of Gutfeld's show will understand the nature of the lie.
Why does Somerby never do this? I think it is because his main mission here is to further right wing talking points. That is why he doesn't tell us what Tarlov said, why he doesn't explain the platforms of the three who won, doesn't explain what Mamdani has been doing in NYC and why he was elected, and doesn't tell anyone the truth about communists, now or in the past. Instead, he counts the use of the word "communist" and in the process uses the same word a few dozen more times, so that it is impossible not to see that the left is being smeared with a bad word. Somerby is no ally to Democrats. He is an asshole pretending to be left wing (by agreeing with Tarlov while not telling us what she said) while repeating the right's drum beat labeling Democrats as communists (which we are not).
Another barren seamstress heard from.
Delete"REVERSIONS: In this dumbest of all possible worlds..."
ReplyDeleteWhat has Somerby done to make the world a little smarter today? Absolutely nothing.
Nobody remembers WWl or ll. The Bolshies are seeing the beginning of the carnage at the hands of the monster they created.
ReplyDeleteBeginning?
Delete"The stars who clowned for Red America, or the stars over here in Blue America who averted their gaze once again?"
ReplyDeleteThe right is attempting to divide Democrats over the Palestine/Israel conflict because that is part of how Harris lost and Trump gained office in 2024. Somerby is abetting this by hinting about what Tarlov said about the views of one of those three endorsed candidates who won last Tuesday. Meanwhile, Trump's relationship with Netanyahu is stalling his peace deal with Iran because Israel keeps attacking Lebanon despite attempts at a ceasefire. Trump's inability to conduct effective foreign relations is the problem, not the individual views of a NYC candidate about Palestinian people.
Blue America has not averted its gaze. Different people hold different opinions on the left, just as they do on the right, where support for Israel is decreasing.
One need not agree with every position held by a candidate in order to support their election. If anyone is looking away from our country's best interests, it is Trump and the Republicans. Why on earth would anyone encourage Netanyahu and why would Trump allow himself to be goaded into going to war on Israel's behalf?
I’m a communist, but I’m not godless. I’m a Muslim.
ReplyDeleteYou’re leaking gender fluid.
DeleteJokes are rarely funny when repeated too often.
DeleteMajority Report right now talking about how the party of free speech is locking people up for decades for protesting ICE
ReplyDelete