THURSDAY: "Lunatic," the headline says!

THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 3, 2026

Mental illness, conjured as insult: There he went again.

For starters, there's no reason to assume that anything the president said was actually accuratetrue. There's no reason to assume that the president actually has a friend who is "very obese" but is also "a brilliant guy"—is also "smart, vicious, wild."

Having offered that disclaimer, here was the president, at the White House, going there once again. He was telling his story about the friend who was forced to pay too much for Ozempic. 

Blue America has pushed back today. We join the president's rambling presentation in progress:

PRESIDENT TRUMP (9/2/26):  ...As an example, the United Kingdom. We had a very, very serious problem. 

United Kingdom would pay ten cents for a pill. And we pay two dollars for the same pillor for the fat drug, as I say.

You know, a friend of minevery, very heavy. He's a very obese person. I said, "You're an extremely obese person." But he's a brilliant guy. He's a Wall Street guy. He's a brutal, brutal man, butsmart as hell, but he's got a serious weight problem.

And he called me up, and he's from New Yorkhe's one of the top guys on Wall Street. He's begging mebecause I've told the story a couple of timesnot to mention his name because I'll destroy his reputation. But he's tough as hell and he's smart, vicious, wild. These are the people you have to deal with when you're president. 

He used to call me Donny, now he calls me president. He'd say, "Donny." Now he calls me "President." I'm shocked he does that, actually. That shows respect.

But he said, "You know, Mr. President, I was in London, and I paid $86 for Ozempic. And in New York, I pay $1,300 for the same thing."

That's a lot! That's a big difference. And I had it checked outcomes from the same factory, it comes from the same place, and then they have some other fat drugs.

I said, "Are you taking this stuff?"

"Yeah."

I said, "It's not working. You look like shit."

I said it's not working. But he got me going...

To watch this ramble in full, click here for the C-Span videotape. Move ahead to the 28-minute mark. We remind you that mental illness is a human tragedy, as is the loss of cognition.

The president rambled on from there, discussing the cost of various drugs here and in other lands. At Raw Story but also at HuffPost, reports criticized the president for his unusual remarks about his extremely obese, vicious friend.

Again, we know of no reason to assume that any such person exists. But from within the world of Blue American commentary, Aaron Rupar offered this reaction to Acyn's shortened, paraphrased text:

I continue to think the fact the president is a lunatic is the biggest story in politics. Your mileage may vary.

In principle, we agree with what Rupar said. We think the fact that the president may be suffering "obvious cognitive decline," layered atop "decades of untreated psychiatric disorders," is the biggest unreported, undiscussed story in the full range of world affairs.   

That said, consider the way Rupar chose to express his assessment. Consider his turn to the use of an insult.  Headline included, Raw Story started like this:   

'Lunatic': Trump's 'obese friend' rant at White House backfires instantly

President Donald Trump detoured into a bizarre rant about an obese "friend" while speaking at a dinner event he was holding at the Rose Garden on Wednesday.

"A friend of mine is a very obese person," said Trump. "I said, you're an extremely obese person. He's begging me not to mention his name because I'll destroy his reputation. He had some fat drugs. I said: it's not working—you look like (expletive)."

The comment triggered both mockery from commenters on social media, and a bit of speculation on who the friend in question was.

"Checking in on Trump's midterm messaging," said the official account for the liberal platform Meidas Touch.

"I continue to think the fact the president is a lunatic is the biggest story in politics. Your mileage may vary," wrote reporter Aaron Rupar.

"Lunatic," Rupar said. Raw Story went full headline.   

For ourselves, we would assume that the president's rambling presentation may fit within the category of "likely cognitive decline."  Rupar selected a word associated with mental illness and threw it out as an insult.

At this site, we've long suggested that a significant "mental illness" is an actual illness. We've long suggested that this would be a more intelligent way to discuss such phenomena.

Given our current state of cultural development, the concept still doesn't play that way in our own Blue American world. We think we Blues would get better results if we played it in accord with the shape of medical science.


16 comments:

  1. The term "lunatic" is not a diagnosis in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), which is published by the American Psychiatric Association.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It’s one of Trump’s favorite words.

      Delete
    2. The words crazy and insane that Somerby keeps using are no better.

      Delete
  2. Trump is not diagnosed with any mental illness. That means Rupar is not demeaning Trump with a disrespectful reference to his disability. When Trump’s medical staff confirms that he is mentally ill, Somerby’s complaint will apply. Meanwhile, Rupar has described Trump’s erratic behavior using an appropriate colloquial term.

    Trump needs to release his medical results.

    ReplyDelete
  3. So suddenly somerby is preaching political correctness.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Trump is an insult.

    ReplyDelete
  5. “ At this site, we've long suggested that a significant "mental illness" is an actual illness. We've long suggested that this would be a more intelligent way to discuss such phenomena.”

    You can’t discuss Trump’s mental illness in any terms when he has not been clinically diagnosed. Treating Trump like a poor sick guy without diagnosis sticks in my craw because it would excuse harm if he were found to be well but a bad person.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Would being mentally ill explain his cheating at golf or his criminal behavior?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Can Trump’s supposed mental illness be treated with a pill or medical intervention? Does it have an organic or physiological cause? If not, then a medical model is not the best way of discussing Trump’s misbehavior and oddity.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Why shouldn’t political opponents of Trump say insulting things about him, especially when true? There is no law saying we cannot disparage Dear Leader when he deserves it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We must pity Trump and not smugly attack him if we want to win.

      Delete
    2. Imagine the accusations of smug condescension if we said we pitied Trump. I’m not going to pretend to pity someone like Trump. Trump hasn’t even tried to be a good man. His name is all over the Epstein files. My pity goes to Virginia Guiffre and E. Jean Carroll and poor Greenland and Venezuela, not a bully and rapist like Trump.

      Delete
  9. I think we’re long past the point where the kind of fastidiousness that Somerby preaches here will make any difference at all.

    ReplyDelete
  10. “ Given our current state of cultural development, the concept still doesn't play that way in our own Blue American world. We think we Blues would get better results if we played it in accord with the shape of medical science.”

    This is insulting of Somerby to say about us blues. First, the left has shown greater advocacy for mentally ill people, parity for mental and physical illness, integration of mentally ill people into society, funding for NIMH research, than the right. Second, the left is more aware than Somerby about the evolution of thought beyond a simplistic medical model of mental health to one that considers neuroscience, genetics, environmental impacts, social interaction on behavior. Somerby’s insistence on treating mental illness like a disease is obsolete. Blues understand but Somerby does not.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In Somerby’s logic, if we fail to pity Trump it shows that we blues don’t care about mental illness.

      Delete
  11. TDH has diagnosed Trump as mentally ill - based largely upon on statements by Trump's niece, a licensed psychologist, and Wikipedia. TDH has never met Trump in private. Trump was shrewd enough to get elected POTUS twice - something rarely accomplished. Trump is a dominant attention getter in the media, he dominates discussion. He's carrying out things that the red tribe has thirsted for, very effectively. I think TDH's discussion on Trump's mental health is shallow and reductionist. I'm not saying that Trump doesn't have some type of mental illness or disorder - perhaps toxic narcissism. Colloquially, you could call Trump a "lunatic." There's no unanimity on that.. It's disappointing to me that TDH seems to be so married to his idea that Trump has a mental illness - and his unhappiness about this conspiracy of the media to not discuss it. I don't know how that would work, even if the 'media' did. What's even harder to swallow is TDH's urging us to "pity" Trump - of all the people on the planet, he's close to last in line when it comes to deserving "pity." I like TDH but not so much his obsession that the press should bring in all these psychiatrists to discuss their views on Trump's mental sanity. I don't know if TDH read the recent New Yorker story about how Trump is an acolyte of Roy Cohn. TDH - please read that, explains a lot about the pudgy POTUS, who to the regret of myself and millions of other managed to be elected POTUS not once, but twice.

    ReplyDelete