MONDAY, NOVEMBER 16, 2026
We were instructed to love him: Really? Are we really supposed to actually love our neighbor?
Within the sprawling warrens of American politics, that can seem like a difficult ask. Sometimes, it can especially seem that way for those of us in Blue American precincts.
In some cases, it can almost seem like an absurdly unlikely request! Consider the case of the Republican congressman-elect from the state of New York—a man we encountered, for the first time, on last Thursday night's Gutfeld! show.
You're right! There aren't a lot of Republican House members from the blue, blue state of New York. Here you see the popular vote across that state in this year's House elections:
Popular vote, state of New York, 2026 House elections:
Democrats: 3.71 million (61.8%)
Republicans: 2.26 million (37.5%)
Memorably, "The trees grow high in New York State. They shine like gold in autumn." (That's what the McGarrigles said.)
However you assess those claims, the state of New York will have 26 House members in the next Congress. As a result of November's elections, only six of the 26 will hail from the GOP.
Sifting the info even further, only one of those six Republican reps will be new to the House next year. In his case, we Blues might be inclined, rightly or wrongly, to balk at the task of extending our "love" to the solon.
Who in the world is this new House member? The moving finger of the leading authority writes and then moves on:
Anthony Constantino (politician)
Anthony Thomas Constantino (born October 30, 1982) is an American businessman and politician who is the U.S. representative-elect for New York's 21st congressional district. A member of the Republican Party, he was elected in November 2026 to succeed Elise Stefanik. Constantino is the co-founder and chief executive officer of the custom printing company Sticker Mule.
Constantino is a vocal supporter of Donald Trump. He has commissioned a bronze statue of Trump, now placed at the Trump International Golf Club, and recorded a rap album titled Thank You President Trump.
[...]
Constantino defeated Democratic nominee Blake Gendebien in the November 3 general election by about 5,000 votes, or two percentage points, underperforming Republican gubernatorial candidate Bruce Blakeman who received 27,000 more votes in the district.
In a profanity-laden victory speech, Constantino called reporters who covered him "scumbags" and "fucking assholes," blamed their coverage for denying him a margin of 20 to 30 points, and ordered a WWNY-TV news crew to leave the event. He also used the speech to call on Trump to pardon the rapper Diddy, who was convicted of transportation to engage in prostitution in 2025; he later said that Diddy was a "job creator" who would "make New York exciting again."
Say what? The rappin' Republican is an ardent supporter of the sitting president? An ardent supporter who profanely name-called reporters, inanely blaming them for his slender victory margin?
A question:
Where in the bright blue state of New York might this love object's district be?
Warning! Rep. Constantino's 21st congressional district is the state's largest House district! Perhaps tellingly, it's said to be "based in the North Country and the Adirondack Mountains, and also includes parts of the Mohawk Valley."
You can marvel at that district's mammoth size simply by clicking here. The district is part of Americana, which we'll insist on describing as good.
With that, we return to our basic conundrum for the day. It involves the precept employed by Senator-elect James Talarico as he brought the political walls of red state Texas crashing to the ground.
Talarico won by twelve points across the once impregnable Lone Star State. Opposed by a more formidable candidate, Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa won the same state by seven.
Along the way, Candidate Talarico became famous for citing this ancient bromide:
Love thy neighbor.
Everyone saw him say it! Meanwhile, by one of the four surviving Great Lakes, Candidate Amy Acton was repeatedly saying this:
Decency is on the ballot in Ohio.
In this, a highly unusual year, decency won by eight points.
In Mississippi, Senator-elect Colom and his young supporters showed a devotion to their history-ravaged state. But are we really required to love our neighbor? Do we have to love our various neighbors, even as an act of gratitude in what was, admittedly, a highly unusual year?
That's what Talarico kept recommending—but what did he mean by that? Do we really have to love our neighbor, or is it possible that we could get by with something perhaps a bit less?
Tomorrow: As seen on that Gutfeld! program
This afternoon: Huddling with Jon Voight
ReplyDelete"An ardent supporter who name-calls reporters in profane ways, perfectly reasonably blaming them for his slender victory margin?"
Here, fixed that for you, Bob.
...as for that bronze statue of Trump, Bob, it's a matter of taste. You love one Abraham Lincoln, the most hated, during his reign, American president, presided over (some say) an unnecessary useless war killing almost a million people. And he likes Donald Trump. I know who I find most reasonable among you two...
"Some people" you mean the ones Sherman forgot to roast in their plantation home?
DeleteNot "most reasonable among you two", it's "more reasonable between you two" you dumbass.
DeleteLincoln was popular, even during his two terms.
Delete
DeleteYeah, right, just as he was bombing NYC, Boston, and Philadelphia.
Faceplant say what?
DeleteWait! — Is Mao a Lost Cause enthusiast?
DeleteThis guy's district is so large and red because it is rural. Districts are apportioned based on population, not acreage.
ReplyDeleteLoving your neighbor means sharing food and water with them during a hurricane, not voting for them. It means returning their lost cat, wearing that mask during a pandemic. It does mean you must think like them, share their interests, vote the same way they do, or even loan them money unless they are having a hardship.
ReplyDeletePastors in churchs help their parishioners interpret the scriptures as applied to modern life. Somerby's translation of this admonition to political settings is ridiculous because politics are a way of making decisions to affect our country. I suppose you could say that voting is an act of neighborly love because of being active in the process of governing our shared state, but it doesn't mean anyone must vote Republican because their neighbors do. It means taking the process seriously and doing the work to investigate and make informed choices on complex issues.
Somerby doesn't actually say what he thinks "love thy neighbor" means these days. He implies that we blues are not doing it well enough. But given that he never explains, who knows what he means?
In past years, Somerby argued that multi-culturalism and diversity were interfering with democracy because a more homogenous nation would be easier to find consensus with others in. Today, he emphasizes the word "various" when he says: "Do we have to love our various neighbors..."
I don't have to wonder what Talarico means when it comes to diversity, because he is a Democrat and supports treating immigrants and minorities as oneself. With Somerby, I have to wonder because he has violated Democratic principles such as supporting civil rights, helping immigrants and addressing women's issues. He is not a good Democrat in his various essays here.
Somerby has previously said that we Dems should be nicer to the Others, his word for Republicans. I don't take that to mean that we should be loving them during elections, at the expense of winning important races. I also do not take it to mean we should ignore assholes like Constantino, who used a string of swear words in front of small children in his acceptance speech. You can love the sinner but hate the sin, according to American religious belief. That applies to the appalling behavior of these right wing goofballs. I would help him if his car broke down in front of my house but I would never vote for him. If Somerby is suggesting we should be voting for these people, he belongs on another planet.
I do resent it when people use religion for political purposes, to try to manipulate people into voting certain ways. Talarico was a religious leader so he is neither introducing nor faking his religious behavior. Somerby is neither, so when he uses "love thy neighbor" to advance his own political views, it is cynical given that he has said many times he is not religious in that specific way.
But if Somerby is asking whether we have to treat Colom's black voters as if they were our neighbors and friends, and take a step further and treat them as if they were equal to ourselves and deserving of equal treatment under the law, of course we do. Why would Somerby even ask that (if he were an actual Democrat)? The answer is obvious to Democrats. This is another instance of evidence supporting my belief that Somerby is not a Democrat or liberal, but is here to attack Democrats, attack blue America, and today imply that we are not good Christians if we don't love all of those silly Republican assholes, such as Constantino.
DeleteIs Somerby seriously proposing that we should ignore the lack of decency on the right during elections, in the name of Jesus? I think Somerby's lack of church attendance is catching up with him. We don't set aside laws for lawbreakers out of Christian mercy. And no, we don't vote for assholes engaging in bad election behavior (like Ramaswamy did) out of Christian love either. We hold people accountable, especially for acts that hurt others.
When Somerby was reading philosophy at Harvard, he should perhaps have read some theology. These matters of how to apply Christ's teachings to the world's miscreants have been thoroughly discussed. Love thy neighbor does not mean you have to give the keys to your house to every burglar that comes along.
"we don't vote for assholes engaging in bad election behavior (like Ramaswamy did) out of Christian love either."
DeleteNothing Somerby has written suggests we should.
There's no hate like right wing Republican Christian nationalist love.
DeleteSomerby has his head in the sand.
The blue tsunami took away his oxygen.
“Is Somerby seriously proposing that we should ignore the lack of decency on the right during elections, in the name of Jesus?”
DeleteThat’s an easy one: No.
In fact, in this very post he details, rather than ignores, the indecency of a Republican. Perhaps you missed that.
DeleteYes, he details the indecency but never says how "love thy neighbor" applies in this political context. It is the same problem as yesterday, where he again never said how this applies.
DeleteSomerby likes to take his sweet time when developing his themes. That’s something of his signature style. If you’re in a big hurry for him to get to the point, maybe this blog is not for you.
DeleteDecency isn't the same as "love thy neighbor". Decency is socially constructed rules of behavior in a civil society:
ReplyDelete"Decency means polite, honest, and moral behavior that shows respect for other people and conforms to accepted standards of propriety, good taste, and fairness."
"The phrase "love thy neighbor as thyself" is a foundational ethical and spiritual commandment instructing people to care for, respect, and treat others with the same kindness and compassion they want for themselves." Otherwise known as The Golden Rule, akin to Kant's categorical imperative.
This Love Thy Neighbor stuff seems to be urged upon Democrats today by Somerby, but is not followed by those who lack empathy and compassion, which means it is ignored by many Republicans, especially Trump and his administration. And it is definitely not followed by wealthy people who treat others as a means to their own ends, in other words, using people to achieve their own goals or for their own purposes. For Trump and red politicians in general, voters are not people to be served but are the way to get elected, and also a way to grift and accumulate money with appeals for support. Government exists to make them rich, not serve the electorate by improving their lives.
So, Somerby is preaching to the wrong people about loving thy neighbor, while he ignores the ways in which the right uses religion without serving God and following the church's precepts. This is not a one-sided command and I see no evidence the right loves any Democrat neighbors much less their own red voters.
Jesus said we should first pluck the beam from our own eye. So perhaps we shouldn’t worry ourselves so much about the speck in the Others’ eye.
Delete"In this, a highly unusual year, decency won by eight points."
ReplyDeleteNo, Amy Acton won because she was the better qualified candidate and voters preferred her. Just because she said decency was on the ballot, referring to Ramaswamy's ugly campaign tactics, doesn't mean that was the reason voters selected her. If you compare her service background to Ramaswamy's supposed achievements, she was obviously the one most likely to use her office to achieve goals that would benefit her constituents.
Somerby seems to have a bizarre and distorted idea of why voters vote the way they do. He also has a bizarre idea of how right wing voters define decency. The right has portrayed reading Toni Morrison books, enjoying drag shows, and a live-and-let-live attitude toward sexual minorities as indecency. The left considers Ramaswamy's anything-to-win campaign tactics as indecent, but they were going to vote for Acton anyway.
Acton ran on getting rid of tax breaks for the wealthy, giving tax relief to working people, protecting Medicaid and Medicare, and general affordability.
DeleteShe's a centrist in a red state, but Ohioans like her policies and were turned off by Ramaswamy's corruption and connection with Trump.
I agree, Acton's win had little to do with "decency", she's a qualified candidate while her opponent was a far right loon. Acton is likely a good and decent person but of more a normie than whatever Somerby means by "decent".
"Do we have to love our various neighbors, even as an act of gratitude in what was, admittedly, a highly unusual year? "
ReplyDeleteThe Bible doesn't say to love your neighbor when they do something nice for you. It also doesn't apply a standard of similarity -- love the neighbors who are just like you but less so the others who are different.
I wouldn't like Constantino if he were a Democrat and I wouldn't love him just because he voted a particular way. I would help him if he were in need, but not because he is in any way deserving, but because he was needy.
It bothers me that someone Somerby's age, who spent 10+ years teaching inner city black kids, would not understand how empathy works and why you help everyone, not just those who you like. What kind of teacher was he?
Somerby asked the question, he didn't answer it. Try decaf.
DeleteSomerby was the kind of teacher that left the profession as soon as there was no longer a threat of being drafted into the military.
DeleteSomerby primarily only asks rhetorical questions. Maybe try some caffeine 12:16.
If Somerby taught for 10 years, he left well after any threat of being drafted.
DeleteDG, Somerby left exactly when the draft ended.
DeleteThe draft ended in ‘73. The leading authority says he taught for 12 years, implying he graduated from college around ‘61, when he was 14. Seems highly unlikely to me.
DeleteSomerby and Republicans in general have persistently described Democrats as elites who consider ourselves more moral, better people, than red voters. We get called sanctimonious and holier-than-thou for caring about other people in our party platform and governing principles. Somerby is doing that in a way today, as he emphasizes Talarico's remarks about Christian love.
ReplyDeleteBy juxtaposing Constantino with Talarico's remark, Somerby implies that we are hypocritical for electing Talarico because of his compassion while denigrating Constantino for his profanity (among other things, such as his political views and support for Trump). Obviously, caring about humanity doesn't mean we Dems must vote for assholes like Constantino. So what is Somerby's point? It seems to be an attack on the left based on a superficial understanding of a religious precept that has never meant that we must preserve evil in our world because God wants us to love our neighbors.
Perhaps red voters share Somerby's misunderstanding and that is why they tolerate hiding the Epstein files, Trump's rape and fraud convictions and his corruption, Hegseth's blood lust and encouragement of domestic violence and toxic male behavior, Paxton's thefts, unnecessary wars, Musk's drug-fueled destruction of our govt, and the way Trump has broken all of the 7 deadly sins repeatedly (daily) without remorse.
Somerby calling Constantino a "love object" is weird.
ReplyDeleteIs Somerby perhaps disagreeing with Talarico about loving thy neighbor? Is he saying that is a ridiculous precept given how unlovable some people are?
He's saying it's a difficult precept, not a ridiculous one.
DeleteThat's crazy.
DeleteMmmmmm such insight.
DeleteSomerby keeps saying that this is a highly unusual year. Yes, it is a swing back to Democrats after having elected Trump in alternating elections, but it is far from true that Democrats never win elections. We had Carter, Clinton, Obama, Biden and we have won majorities in congress before too. So why is Somerby making such a big deal?
ReplyDeleteTrump has been an extraordinarily bad president. It is no wonder even his own supporters didn't come out for red candidates given his poor performance and cognitive decline. Somerby insistence that this is something unusual, rather than someone explainable and positive for our nation, is getting old itself. Our focus is now on how to restore the nation to sanity and undo the harm done by Trump/Musk/Hegseth/Miller, not sit around in awe and wonder that Democrats could win a midterm election. Pundits are saying that the same sweep is going to happen in 2028.
"So why is Somerby making such a big deal?"
DeleteBecause the magnitude of the electoral swing was historically large.
It may be that this year is more a return to normal and that the Trump years have been highly unusual.
DeleteAgree
DeleteThis is the kind of essay that Somerby used to refer to as "muddled." If he delayed his lunch just 15 minutes, he might have explained what he was trying to say more clearly. Then we could have an actual discussion, instead of wondering what he means with every ridiculous sentence.
ReplyDeleteI don’t know, it seems clear to me:
DeleteAlthough Talarico says, “Love your neighbor,” can he possibly mean we should love an asshole like Constantino? And what would that “love” — if it were humanly possible — even mean? (To be continued.)
Why was the response different?
ReplyDeleteWhen a Colorado bakery refused to make a wedding cake for a gay couple, millions of soccer moms, activists, and Hollywood celebrities took to the streets in protest.
When a Muslim-controlled town in Michigan recently banned all pride flags on govt property, nobody said anything.
D in C - I somehow doubt that "millions" took to the streets over the Colorado baker's refusal. Where did you come up with that number?
DeleteThere's a cavity in the lower part of his anatomy....
DeleteYes, AC/MA and @1:29 -- "millions took to the streets" is hyperbole. But, what is your answer the question? Why was there a big fuss when a single person refused to accept gay marriage and no fuss at all when an entire town took an anti gay stand?
DeleteDiC has provided no facts. We are supposed to accept his vague characterizations as emblematic of … something.
DeleteIt is the same math that calculated the thousands of left wingers who publicly celebrated the death of Kirk.
DeleteThe town of Hamtramck Michigan banned all non -civic flags, including LGBT+Pride flags, religious, racial, ethnic and political flags. Which means it also banned Muslim flags on city-owned property. What a dick DiC is.
DeleteTDH writes an article about a House race in rural upstate NY and dickhead wants to start a religious jihad against Muslims. Fuck him straight to hell.
Delete1:51 PM, when you tell it that way it makes it hard for Dickhead in Cal to play the victim.
DeleteDavid, haven’t you made Aliyah yet? Why not?
DeleteThe bakery case had implications for the entire country, duh.
Delete"David" is such a dunce.
David, speaking hyperbolically is lying you fucking piece of shit liar.
DeleteWhat is another word for hyperbolically?
Adverb for untrue or hard to believe, typically made up. Color me surprised.
DiC is:
ReplyDelete1) lazy,
2)stupid,
3) a disingenuous bullshit artist
4) all of the above.
He’s senile.
DeleteHe a creep.
DeleteHe's a loser
DeleteMeanwhile, the town of Delray Beach has cancelled their St. Patrick Day Parade in strict accordance with the anti-DEI law passed by DeSantis and his lackey legislature. Which of course angered DeSantis, who intended that the law apply only to non-whites and other minorities.
ReplyDeleteSomerby seems impressed with the geographic size of that district - one of the most rural and sparsely populated districts in the country, apparently unaware of how districts are drawn.
ReplyDelete