As usual, pundits seem to know nothing at all!

MONDAY, OCTOBER 10, 2016

Clinton cites Spielberg and Lincoln:
Based on blather we saw last night and this morning, we suspect it may become the pundit corps' favorite "laugh line" from last night's debate.

The children always need their standard bits of conventional wisdom. Here's how it debuted on CNN, shortly after midnight:
LEWANDOWSKI (10/10/16): Look, I think Donald Trump was disciplined tonight. He was fast on his feet. He was specific on issues. He clearly won this debate.

If you go and look at it—and he asked Hillary Clinton specifically to talk about the two Hillary Clintons, right? The one in the private and the one in the public. You know what her answer was? Abraham Lincoln. This is a movie I watched from Steven Spielberg and that's what I was talking about. It's completely egregious.

And the point is, once again, he pointed out the hypocrisy of the media. It shows that she's not being truthful.
Granted, that's Corey Lewandowksi, the former Trump campaign manager. But the notion that Clinton made an "egregious" statement about that Spielberg film—a statement which showed (what else?) that she's untruthful—seemed to be gaining purchase among the pundit class this morning.

Clinton made a ridiculous statement about the Spielberg movie! It's the kind of simple-minded script the American pundit class loves. It easy to memorize, easy to clown to. In the early hours today, we saw pundits adopting it as their entertaining new way to repeat a mandated saw—You Can't Trust Hillary Clinton.

For what it's worth, Lewandowski was referring to something Clinton actually said during last night's debate. During the debate, she was asked about one of the leaked excerpts from her paid speeches.

Here's the transcript from the debate, including Candidate Trump's instant know-nothing rejoinder:
RADDATZ (10/9/16): This question involves WikiLeaks' release of purported excerpts of Secretary Clinton's paid speeches, which she has refused to release, and one line in particular, in which you, Secretary Clinton, purportedly say you need both a public and private position on certain issues. So, Tu from Virginia asks, is it OK for politicians to be two-faced? Is it acceptable for a politician to have a private stance on issues? Secretary Clinton, your two minutes.

CLINTON: Well, right. As I recall, that was something I said about Abraham Lincoln after having seen the wonderful Steven Spielberg movie called "Lincoln." It was a master class watching President Lincoln get the Congress to approve the 13th Amendment. It was principled, and it was strategic.

And I was making the point that it is hard sometimes to get the Congress to do what you want to do and you have to keep working at it. And, yes, President Lincoln was trying to convince some people, he used some arguments, convincing other people, he used other arguments. That was a great—I thought a great display of presidential leadership.

[...]

RADDATZ: Mr. Trump?

TRUMP: Well, I think I should respond, because—so ridiculous! Look, now she's blaming— She got caught in a total lie. Her papers went out to all her friends at the banks, Goldman Sachs and everybody else, and she said things—WikiLeaks that just came out. And she lied. Now she's blaming the lie on the late, great Abraham Lincoln. That's one that I haven't—

[LAUGHTER]

OK, Honest Abe, Honest Abe never lied. That's the good thing. That's the big difference between Abraham Lincoln and you. That's a big, big difference. We're talking about some difference.
By this morning, pundits were acting like Clinton's reference to the Spielberg film was a ridiculous, comical claim, one she'd likely dreamed up on the spot. In fact, though, that's exactly what Clinton was talking about in the excerpt to which Raddatz referred.

Raddatz's question was one of the flimsiest of the night. The dozen excerpts in question were compiled by a Clinton staffer who was looking for things she had said in her paid speeches that could be used against her.

The staffer wasn't trying to provide full context for the dozen excerpts he grabbed. He wasn't suggesting that Clinton had actually said something "wrong" in her speeches, merely that the dozen excerpts could be spun that way.

Below, you see the full excerpt in question, from a speech in 2013. It isn't entirely easy to know what Clinton was actually talking about. But instantly, she did in fact cite the Spielberg film, just as she said last night:
CLINTON (4/24/13): You just have to sort of figure out how to—getting back to that word, "balance"—how to balance the public and the private efforts that are necessary to be successful politically, and that's not just a comment about today. That, I think, has probably been true for all of our history, and if you saw the Spielberg movie, Lincoln, and how he was maneuvering and working to get the 13th Amendment passed, and he called one of my favorite predecessors, Secretary Seward, who had been the governor and senator from New York, ran against Lincoln for president, and he told Seward, "I need your help to get this done." And Seward called some of his lobbyist friends who knew how to make a deal, and they just kept going at it. I mean, politics is like sausage being made. It is unsavory, and it always has been that way, but we usually end up where we need to be. But if everybody's watching, you know, all of the back room discussions and the deals, you know, then people get a little nervous, to say the least. So you need both a public and a private position. And finally, I think—I believe in evidence-based decision making. I want to know what the facts are. I mean, it's like when you guys go into some kind of a deal, you know, are you going to do that development or not, are you going to do that renovation or not, you know, you look at the numbers. You try to figure out what's going to work and what's not going to work.
That's the full excerpt, as recorded by the Clinton staffer. Clinton seems to be talking about what a politician has to do when he or she is in the midst of an extended negotiation.

Based on the excerpt as provided, it isn't entirely clear what Clinton was actually talking about. It also isn't clear how this general topic came up. That said, she seems to be talking about the art of the deal—for example, the need to maintain a hard line in your public discussions, even if you're willing to explore other possibilities in private.

(Obama was frequently criticized for not doing this enough, for "negotiating against himself." Now, Clinton is being criticized for taking the opposite stance.)

If that's what Clinton was talking about, it isn't especially thrilling or novel or interesting. It sounds to us like this was part of a Q-and-A session, rather than a formal excerpt from a formal speech.

But speaking in early 2013, when Spielberg's film was still drawing big buzz, Clinton instantly cited the film, just as she said last night. We mention that because, as of this morning, we saw pundits acting as if this was some crazy notion Clinton simply dreamed up, on the spot, in the middle of last night's debate.

We get the feeling that this could catch on as a standard pundit script. If you see pundits taking that line, you can draw one instant conclusion. Those pundits didn't do their homework when the speech excerpts were leaked.

If they had actually read the excerpts, they would have known that Clinton referenced Spielberg's film. When we saw them chuckling and clowning last night and today, we knew they hadn't done their jobs. But then, what else is new? This gang includes some of the biggest slackers in recorded history.

You can feel fairly sure that Candidate Trump hadn't read the actual speech excerpts. We'd be surprised if Raddatz had read them either.

At any rate, the irony here is this. The Clinton staffer assembled twelve passages which, especially taken out of context, could be spun in negative ways. At the New York Times, Amy Chozick instantly did just that in a typically hapless report. Inevitably, the rest of the children began to follow her lead.

Before long, Eric Levitz was writing this. ("If Her Opponent Weren’t a Sexual Predator, Clinton’s Leaked Speeches Would Be Devastating.") Eric Levitz had gone ahead and purchased the bulk of the guff.

Who is Eric Levitz? He graduated from Johns Hopkins in 2010 with a degree in creative writing. He spent two more years at JHU getting a master's in the same field, then spent one more year teaching creative writing.

Obviously, there's nothing "wrong" with any of that. But for some reason, New York Magazine has him writing major political pieces after less than three years as a journalist. He may be very bright, but he's also very young and very inexperienced.

In the post to which we linked, Levitz seems to have bought the party line from the New York Times. Entities like New York Magazine save money when they hire young inexperienced scribes, but the public is often badly served in the process.

The New York Times is most at fault here, but the lambs were sure to follow. Raddatz followed the story-line too, asking a rather hackish question about a rather innocuous, murky statement from 2013.

The IQ of our uper-end press corps is extremely low. They might score well on an IQ test, but they also love to adhere to Standard Silly Officially Mandated Pundit Corps Story-Lines.

Back to that reference to Spielberg and Lincoln. By this morning, the usual pundits seemed to be implying that Clinton had dreamed that up on the spot during last night's debate.

It could become a standard play. We thought you ought to know that.

Levitz versus Drum: In Kevin Drum's judgment, the dozen excerpts were mainly a nothingburger. Click here, with a link to a previous post.

We'd have to say that Levitz bought the package. At Mother Jones, a seasoned Nestor type wisely said, "Not so fast!"

("He always gave the best advice," Homer said of Nestor and Drum.)

Cable channel turns into The Kellyanne Show!

MONDAY, OCTOBER 10, 2016

And no, it wasn't Fox:
As always, we were struck by pundit reaction to last night's debate.

This morning, we were struck by Mika's most overwrought meltdown to date. She scolded Republicans who withdrew their support for Trump over the weekend, angrily declaring, again and again, that they were "spineless."

Mika's work is routinely incoherent. This morning, the level of anger at those "spineless" folk combined with the incoherence to create a very strange brew on our strangest "cable news" program.

Last night, we were equally struck by MSNBC's programming post-debate. More specifically, we were struck by the massive amount of time the fiery liberal channel devoted to Trump spokespersons.

The debate ended shortly after 10:30 PM Eastern. At 10:45, Brian and Rachel brought on Trump campaign chairman Kellyanne Fitzpatrick, their first post-debate guest.

Conway was interviewed, without commercial interruption, for the next twenty minutes. Making matters worse, she was interviewed by Chris Matthews, who seemed incapable of challenging her representations in any serious way.

By 10:52, Conway was citing Megan Twohey's appalling "news report" in last Monday's New York Times. We warned you about that report all last week. Career players knew not to do so.

Conway's segment went on and on, and then it went on and on. When her twenty-minute infomercial was finally done, she was thanked by Rachel Maddow for being such a "good sport." Most amazingly, Chuck Todd then offered an unsolicited judgment:

Conway is "a very good person," Todd very weirdly said.

Conway ran nonstop from roughly 10:45 to roughly 11:05. At 11:08, James Carville came on to offer a view of the debate from the Clinton side.

Carville was interviewed for three or four minutes. At 11:15, on came the terminally deranged Rudy Giuliani for six more minutes of pro-Trump pivots and rants.

Matthews' fawning to Conway to the side, the allotment of time was remarkable. We'll assume this was a decision from "corporate," a decision with which all the overpaid children of course complied.

Matthews' obsequious interview of his fellow you-know-what seemed to come from a late-1990s time capsule. At that time, Matthews was the most demagogic of all "cable news" Clinton/Gore/Clinton-haters. In accordance with Hard Corporate Pundit Law, that part of Matthews' history is simply never mentioned at all. Last night, he made us recall his astonishing work from that era, work which cannot be discussed.

(At roughly 12:11, Maddow weirdly asserted that the wondrous Matthews "has always been the same person" down through the years. It was a very strange thing to say about Matthews. We know of no one on "cable news" who has been so thoroughly reinvented over the past twenty years.)

Back to the basic question! What explains the strange distribution of MSNBC's time post-debate? We'll assume the order came from corporate. Tomorrow, we'll try to bring you some transcript excerpts from Matthews' performance with Conway. We'll definitely show you what she said about that ridiculous "news report" in the Times.

Kellyanne is East Coast Irish Catholic from the Philly area too. At one point, she reminded Chris of this tribal fact as her filibuster infomercial ran on, and on and on.

Still coming today about pundit behavior: Yes, Hillary Clinton actually was talking about Spielberg's Lincoln film! Predictably, exactly none of your cable pundits seemed to know that last night.

Also, who is Eric Levitz? And why should this question matter?

WHERE THE TEST SCORES ARE: Series to resume!

MONDAY, OCTOBER 10, 2016

Previous report in this series

Series resumes tomorrow: Starting tomorrow, we'll be resuming our ongoing series, Where the Test Scores Are.

In the third week of the series, we looked at the way Americans students have performed, as compared to the rest of the world, on the Trends in International Math and Science Study (TIMSS), one of the two international testing programs in which most developed nations participate. In this week's reports, we'll examine the way American students have performed on the other major testing testing program—the Program for International Student Assessment (PISA).

We'll be starting with a quick review of our basic finding to date about the international achievement gaps. More precisely, we'll start by restating this basic point:

If you look at American scores on the TIMSS, it's hard to support the claim that American schools are an embarrassing mess as compared to those in the rest of the world.

That said, American students haven't scored as well on the PISA. This week, we'll review the international "achievement gaps" on that second major testing program, and we'll "disaggregate" American scores, letting us see how different groups of American students perform on both the TIMSS and the PISA.

All this week, we'll do something else. We'll focus on The Smartest Kids in the World, an influential book by Amanda Ripley which appeared in 2013.

In her critically-acclaimed book, Ripley engaged in some of the selective reporting practices which have tended to mislead the public about international achievement gaps. We'll focus on those sleights of hand as we see how different groups of American students have performed on both the TIMSS and the PIRLS as compared to their peers in the rest of the world.

How have different groups of American students performed on the PISA? How have they performed as compared to South Korea, Japan, Taiwan? As compared to miraculous Finland? As compared to larger non-Asian nations?

Ripley's slippery sleights of hand succeeded in confusing some very basic issues. Our work this week will clarify some basic points, and will lead to our final week of reports in this ongoing series.

Starting tomorrow: Where the PISA Gaps Are

Next week: Where the Challenges Are

Chozick jumps the latest shark!

SATURDAY, OCTOBER 8, 2016

Badger gets it right:
We never thought we'd see the day we finally saw last night.

We never thought we'd see the day when cable news channels passed on the chance to pretend to report on a storm.

Normally, hurricane coverage constitutes a "snow day" for cable reporters. They get to stop pretending to cover major political news. They get to tackle much simpler tasks instead.

They get to ask questions of this general type: "When you saw the roof of your house blow away, how did that make you feel?" They get to stand where the breakers crash and drag and demonstrate that the wind blows hard in a hurricane, and that it tends to rain hard.

These are among the only skills these TV stars ever master. Remarkably, they abandoned the chance to display these skills when the Trump tape took over last night.

This latest tape featuring Donald J. Trump is indeed quite unattractive. That said, it's instructive to see that our journalists think it's much more significant than all the videotape in which this same Donald J. Trump conducted his years-long birther scam.

The latest tape is an assault on the dignity of half the nation's people. The birther scam was an assault on everyone's intelligence, and on the integrity of the national discourse.

(In fairness to Donald J. Trump, the latest offensive remarks were made in private. That said, the remarks are bad for all children to hear—for boys as well as for girls.)

On cable, major stars reacted instantly to the latest tape. By way of contrast, it took them years to show an interest in the ugly, monstrously stupid Donald J. Trump birther scam.

For the first year of Trump's formal candidacy, these players ignored it completely. Trump said he no longer discussed the scam. Our scribes scurried into the woods.

Why were our journalistic stars so slow to react to that monstrously stupid scam? We include the New York Times, whose front-page report on the birther scam avoided some very basic questions. (Did Donald J. Trump ever send investigators to Hawaii? Did they ever report that they were shocked by what they had found? Or was Donald J. Trump just lying all along?)

Why were our journalistic stars so slow to react to that monstrously stupid scam? It seems to us that the answer is simple:

Our mainstream press corps is itself deeply sunk in The Culture of Phony and Stupid. Starting with the New York Times, our upper-end mainstream news orgs have promoted this culture for decades. (In 1993, Katherine Boo warned the world about this trend, calling it "Creeping Dowdism.")

Career liberals have agreed not to notice or complain, but the Culture of Stupid has dominated the New York Times roughly forever. The Culture of Dissembling has also played a key role at these big "news orgs."

This may explain why the New York Times showed remarkably little interest in that very basic question: Was Donald J. Trump, the birther king, just lying that whole time?

Yesterday, the Blitzers scrambled to react to the latest tape. The videotape which they had acquired did show an extremely unattractive side of Trump. But we'll take a wild guess:

Trump's behavior on that tape is much more common than the conduct he displayed when he made himself king of the birthers. It's just that people like Blitzer actually know about topics like sex, or about the power of such topics, while they don't have the slightest interest in the integrity of the national discourse.

People like Blitzer have made a joke of that discourse for decades. In this regard, they were deeply engaged in Trumpism long before Candidate Trump came along. For that reason, Trump's clowning in the birther days seemed like old hat to them. They had clowned in a million such ways long before Trump ran his scam.

Should Trump's (private) conversation with Billy Bush have provoked such giant coverage? We're going to say that's a matter of judgment, although the banter in which they engaged was extremely unattractive.

That said, Trump's earlier array of scams constituted attacks on the basic integrity of the American discourse. But so what? Our press corps quit on that discourse long ago, a fact they've demonstrated a thousand ways, almost always under the cover of career liberal silence.

This morning, Amy Chozick has jumped the latest shark in the New York Times. That said, her account of Hillary Clinton's speeches will excite little attention. Career liberals all understand that they mustn't notice such things.

We may review that latest shark-jump on Monday. Meanwhile, the analysts came to us yesterday with a question about Emily Badger.

"Who is Emily Badger?" they asked. "And how did she get that intelligent piece into the New York Times?"

As best we can tell, Badger—a 2003 Northwestern graduate—is brand new to the Times. Her highly intelligent piece concerns the concept of "implicit bias."

(We did think it was perhaps a little bit snarky towards Pence.)

We read it yesterday on page A18 of our hard-copy Times. That said, Nexis doesn't seem to know that the piece exists. Nor is it included by the Times in the "Today's Paper" listing for Friday, despite the fact that it's right there on A18.

At the Times site, you have to go to the Upshot blog to find Badger's piece. Yesterday, it jumped out at us as we read the paper because it was so intelligent, and thus so unlike the Times.

"Careful, Badger!" one analyst cried. "You managed to sneak this past the eds. But they aren't likely to tolerate such insolence in the future."

(With apologies to Jackie Calmes, whose work always strikes us as sane.)

ROAD MAP TO THE CURRENT LOATHING: No murders as far as Stephanopoulos knew!

FRIDAY, OCTOBER 7, 2016

Part 3—Also, Carl Bernstein declares:
Later today, we're going to take a good, long shower. We'll be washing away the residue which comes from having read Megan Twohey's front-page report.

Donald J. Trump had been making dire threats, so the New York Times swung into action. The result was a heavily cherry-picked "news report" about famous old claims by Gennifer Flowers, claims with which our childish "press corps" long ago fell in love.

In her lengthy, front-page report, Twohey picked and chose her facts rather heavily. This was done with the permission of her unnamed editors, of course.

In the process, Twohey misled readers about the credibility of Flowers' thrilling claims from years long past. If we're all still speaking English, she flatly misinformed readers about what Bill Clinton eventually said about his relationship with Flowers.

Most significantly, she gave an utterly silly account of Hillary Clinton's reaction to Flowers. She also gave a gonzo account of earlier claims by "rock groupie" Connie Hamzy (Twohey's description).

All in all, Twohey assembled the type of "news report" which ought to get journalists fired. Later today, we'll be trying to wash away its effects.

That said, let's be fair! In her 2900-word front page report, Twohey played the same journalistic games her colleagues have played for decades. As of 1998, the children who pose as our "mainstream press" had adopted the appalling Flowers as one of their honored truth-tellers. From that day right up to this, they've been putting their asp's cheeks on the scales to keep Flowers' stories alive.

The career liberal world has just sat and stared as this gong-show has unfolded. It's what the Chaits, the Dionnes, the Marshalls and even the Krugmans have done for the past twenty-four years. This has led to the current state of loathing of Candidate Clinton, a state of loathing which means that Candidate Trump could still emerge as the winner of this year's White House campaign.

Career liberal silence has been persistent; so has mainstream clowning. Consider two high-profile books about Hillary Clinton—books which have often been cited as Donald J. Trump has advanced his new threats and claims.

Briefly, let's consider All Too Human, George Stephanopoulos' 1999 memoir. At the time, Stephanopoulos was trying to execute a fairly tricky transition. Earlier in the decade, he had been Bill Clinton's press spokesman. Now, he was trying to gain acceptance as a mainstream TV news star.

Stephanopoulos was already on the scene when Hamzy and Flowers made their claims about Bill Clinton (in November 1991 and January 1992, respectively). In recent months, the RNC and the Trump campaign have cherry-picked his accounts of these matters to create a pleasing charge—to claim that Hillary Clinton launched ugly attacks on those brave truth-tellers.

The New York Times has cherry-picked Stephanopoulos too; Twohey did so in Monday's report, especially with regard to Hamzy's thrilling claim. That said, we were struck, when we reread All Too Human, at the careful way Stephanopoulos positioned himself with respect to his former boss, who was now regarded very negatively by Washington's press elites.

In our view, Stephanopoulos may have gone a bit out of his way to reassure that establishment concerning his view of Bill Clinton. Instantly, he mused about Clinton's "shamelessness" in his brief, three-page prologue. Beyond that, it seems to us that he may have gone out of his way to avoid reporting the implausibility of Flowers' claims, and to avoid discussing her general all-around craziness.

By now, Flowers had been adopted by the corps as one of their truth-telling heroes. It seems to us that Stephanopoulos may perhaps have tried to avoid rocking that particular yacht.

That said, a person can only laugh, then cry, at the way Stephanopoulos opened his book. Believe it or not, this is the first paragraph in Chapter 1, a chapter called Background Check:
STEPHANOPOULOS (page 7): On the Sunday before Christmas 1992, I was feeling lucky. A few weeks earlier, with my help, Bill Clinton had been elected president—and soon I'd be working for him in the White House. But first I had to visit the Rose Law Firm. If you've read John Grisham, you've got a pretty good idea of what Rose Law was like—Little Rock's version of "The Firm." Not that anyone's even been murdered there (as far as I know), but its pedigree, power, and aura of buttoned-down mystery had made it a force in Arkansas for than a century. It was Hillary Rodham Clinton's firm.
No one had ever been murdered at Hillary Clinton's firm—as far as Stephanopoulos knew! A person should weep for the dead of Iraq when he or she sees this classic climber kissing the ascot of power this way as he claws his way toward the top.

No one was murdered as far as he knew! With that dog whistle in his first paragraph, a former press hack may perhaps have been worming his way toward a much brighter light.

Eight years later, in 2007, Carl Bernstein published a lengthy biography of Hillary Clinton, A Woman in Charge. To this day, Bernstein is the go-to guy on mainstream TV regarding the life of Hillary Clinton. Routinely, he's asked to pontificate on the basis of that high-profile book.

Well, here we are in 2016, and Gennifer Flowers is back again, on the front page of the Times. We decided to revisit Bernstein's book, to recall what he said about the claims which made Flowers wealthy and famous.

Amazing! In a thoroughly researched book—a book which ran 554 pages—Bernstein had virtually nothing to say about this important episode.

Go ahead—check it out! On page 10, in his prologue, Bernstein makes a single, parenthetical reference to Flowers—a glancing reference in which he doesn't even attempt to explain who Flowers is and was.

His next reference to Flowers comes on page 163. Completely out of nowhere, this is what he wrote:
BERNSTEIN (page 163): Later, Gennifer Flowers, the nightclub chanteuse with whom Bill had an affair, said their relationship began in 1977 and that Arkansas newspaper reporters were making inquiries about it toward the end of his first term as governor.
How odd! In this, his first real reference to Flowers, Bernstein simply announced that she and Bill Clinton "had an affair." But how odd! In 554 heavily researched pages, Bernstein never explained what he meant by that claim, or how he knew it was true.

Later, Bernstein notes that Flowers originally filed an affidavit saying that she hadn't had a sexual relationship with Clinton. But in all his 554 pages, Bernstein never explains why we're supposed to disbelieve that original claim, in favor of the later claim for which Flowers was richly rewarded.

As best we can tell, Bernstein never reports what Bill Clinton said when he was compelled to testify about his relationship with Flowers. He never describes the narrow definition under which he was forced to testify, or the extremely limited "confession" he made.

In all his 554 pages, he never mentions the reams of craziness surrounding Flowers' long-standing behavior. He simply asserts the factual claim which his guild so ardently loved: Bill Clinton and Gennifer Flowers excitingly had an affair!

To all appearances, Bernstein's book was thoroughly researched. In most respects, it seems to be thoroughly "journalistic." But by the time his book appeared, the guild had established the appalling, ridiculous Flowers as one of their beacons of truth. And it's just as we've told you down through the years:

When the guild has a story it deeply loves, no one will ever move to disrupt it. Dearest darlings, use your sense. It simply isn't done!

Bill Clinton "had an affair" with Flowers! By now, this had ceased to be a claim; it had become sacred writ. And so Bernstein declared that Clinton had that affair, as if reading from one of the tablets.

As for Stephanopoulos, no one was murdered at the Rose Law Firm. No one as far as he knew!

Twohey kept pouring it on this week, advancing the stories her childish guild so deeply and childishly loves. Jonathan Chait sat meekly by, as did the rest of his ilk.

These boys all know that they mustn't speak up. We'll dream of Chait and his well-behaved ilk as we stand in the shower today, washing away the residue of Twohey's cherry-picking.

There are brighter sides to this "all too human" story, of course. People are dead all over the world, but Twohey and Chait and the rest of the gang have their puny careers!

ROAD MAP TO THE CURRENT LOATHING: Did Governor Clinton have affairs?

THURSDAY, OCTOBER 6, 2016

Part 2—The "press corps" [HEART] "trailer trash:"
Long ago and far away, before he ever ran for president, did Bill Clinton, then governor of Arkansas, have extramarital affairs?

On Monday morning, this exceptionally tedious question returned to the front page of the New York Times. It returned in the form of a 2900-word "news report." The news report focused on the way Hillary Clinton reacted, long ago, to claims by Gennifer Flowers.

Long ago, in the tabloid Star, Flowers claimed a torrid 12-year affair with Bill Clinton, the handsome hunk who Flowers said was the love of her life. Flowers was paid a six-figure fee by the Star for her thrilling claims. Her claims were always highly improbable, though Megan Twohey, the Times' star reporter, did her best to keep her readers from understanding such facts.

Twohey also misdirected readers concerning Bill Clinton's eventual testimony about his interactions with Flowers. In fairness to Towhey, "reporters" like her have been playing these games for the past quite a few years, helped along by the misconduct of their unnamed editors.

The Times' renewed interest in Gennifer Flowers is part of a long, sad story. In fairness to the sheet-sniffers at the Times, they were enabled, in this iteration, by the ludicrous conduct of Donald J. Trump, who has been pretending to be upset by the way Hillary Clinton, long ago and far away, treated people like Flowers.

In the Times' latest lengthy "news report," Twohey did her best to mislead readers about that topic too. But let's return to our opening question:

Long ago and far away, before he ever ran for president, did Bill Clinton, then governor of Arkansas, have extramarital affairs?

To the extent that we're forced to consider that question, we'd assume that the answer is yes. In 2007, Carl Bernstein wrote a lengthy biography of Hillary Clinton in which he discussed such topics at some length and, in certain cases, with apparent care.

Bernstein reported that one affair led the Clintons, way back when, to consider divorce. In the New York Times' review of Bernstein's book, Jennifer Senior presented his account of this matter, but she named no names.

On page A1 of the Washington Post, in a 2255-word report, Baker and Solomon were less circumspect. This was their summary of Bernstein's account:
BAKER AND SOLOMON (5/25/07): The women who also figured in Bill Clinton's life in Arkansas make a return appearance in the book, most notably Marilyn Jo Jenkins, a power company executive he fell in love with and almost left his wife over, according to Bernstein. Jenkins has been linked to Clinton before—she was spirited into the governor's mansion at 5:15 a.m. for a final, furtive meeting with him the day he left for Washington to assume the presidency—but Bernstein's account makes clear her pivotal role.

Bill Clinton wanted to divorce his wife to be with Jenkins in 1989, Bernstein reports, but Hillary Clinton refused. "There are worse things than infidelity," she told Betsey Wright, the governor's chief of staff. The crisis frayed Wright's relationship with Bill Clinton too, and she told Bernstein that she arranged for the two of them, Wright and Clinton, to see a therapist together.

Hillary Clinton, meanwhile, turned to her best friend, Diane Blair, obliquely raising the prospect of divorce during a long walk. "She was thinking that they had not made much money," Blair told Bernstein before her death in 2000, and she was concerned about her daughter. "Chelsea was there now. What if she were on her own? She didn't own a house. She was concerned that if she were to become a single parent, how would she make it work in a way that would be good for Chelsea."

The Clintons stayed together, but out of "anger and hurt" she considered running for governor in 1990, when he presumably would step down to prepare his 1992 presidential campaign. The idea ended after consultant Dick Morris conducted two polls showing she had no independent identity with Arkansas voters and compared her to George Wallace's wife, who ran to succeed him in Alabama—an analogy that offended her.

By the time Bill Clinton was running for president, Hillary Clinton suggested to Blair that victory would be good for the marriage because her husband's sexual compulsions would be tempered by the White House and the ever-present press corps, Bernstein reports—a flawed assumption, as it would turn out.
This link is the best we can give you.

How accurate was Bernstein's account? If we were forced to make an assessment, we wouldn't be able to tell you.

That said, according to Bernstein's notes, his account was built out of detailed interviews with the Clintons' closest friends and associates. At any rate, Bernstein gave a fascinating account of this alleged episode, in which, according to Bernstein, Hillary Clinton encountered "an attractive, accomplished, rich antagonist with whom Bill believed himself to be in love."

Bernstein's book has long been treated as the definitive biography of Hillary Clinton. On that basis, Bernstein is frequently cast on cable news as the leading authority concerning her life.

But how odd! According to a Nexis search, the name of the woman who played that "pivotal role" in the Clintons' lives has never appeared in the Washington Post in the almost nine years since that front-page report. The name has appeared in the New York Times just once, in 1998, in connection with the latest search for the truth by Kenneth W. Starr.

The mainstream press has shown little interest in examining what seems to have been a real part of the Clintons' actual lives. But dear lord! How they love to revisit the thrilling claims made by the ludicrous Flowers! How they love to pick and choose the facts you're allowed to hear about that! Or about "rock groupie" Connie Hamzy!

An unpleasant person would suggest an unpleasant motive for this. It would involve the two sides of Bill Clinton's life—his roots in white working-class Arkansas, versus his vast success in the upper-end, Rhodes scholar/Yale Law School world.

An unpleasant person would make an unpleasant suggestion about people like Twohey and her unnamed editors. He would suggest that they love to tell tales about the "trailer trash" side of this story, but that they defer to, and avoid discussing, accomplished, rich power company executives who are beautiful to boot.

They love to toy with the trailer trash. They avoid the rich and the powerful.

An ungenerous person would tell you that this pattern has obtained with a range of alleged affairs involving other major political figures. Our journalists seem to shy away from rumors about upper-class presidents and candidates with upper-class love interests. But they love love love to toy and to play with figures like Hamzy and Flowers.

By 1998, the life forms who people the mainstream press had decided that they [HEART]ed Gennifer Flowers. They began to pretend that they somehow knew that she had been telling the truth all along. They made it a point to keep you from knowing how ridiculous she actually was.

When she went on Hardball in 1999, Flowers spent the bulk of her half hour discussing the Clintons' many murders. In the Washington Post, Howard Kurtz mentioned the fact that she had appeared, but forgot to say a single word about how crazy her appearance was.

Her appearance on Hardball had been so nuts that she was instantly rewarded with a full hour on Hannity & Colmes. She continued to talk about the Clintons' many murders—and about the first lady's gigantic lesboism, the added topic which let her fill her full hour.

As best as we've ever been able to tell, no one in the American press corps ever mentioned the crazy behavior by Flowers on these major programs. By then, Flowers had been cast as a truth-teller by the children who pose as our "national press." To this day, they continue to pick and choose their facts to mislead you about her improbable claims and about what Bill Clinton testified to way back in the day. People like Twohey select their facts to make you suspect that Hillary Clinton abused her.

Jesse Jackson tried to "keep hope alive." Those who pretend to be our press corps have had a different mission.

They've worked to sustain a set of selective tales about "white trash" accusers like Hamzy and Flowers. They try to make you think that Bill Clinton testified to having an affair with Flowers. They keep trying to make you think that Hillary Clinton slimed these two in some inappropriate way.

They ignore Bernstein's apparent top-level reporting about the real lives of the pre-White House Clintons. Instead, they pick and choose facts to advance their mission:

Keep thrilling stories alive!

Gennifer Flowers has always been a ginormous piece of work. As part of the post-accusation Penthouse spread for which she was richly paid, she was even quoted saying this:

"I dare Hillary to bare her butt in any magazine. They don’t have a page that broad."

Well-bred types like Megan Twohey love to toy with this trailer park world. They have worked, for many years, to keep their favorite stories alive. The public gets conned in the process.

Sadly enough, Bernstein played a role is this affair. So did Stephanopoulos.

Tomorrow: No murders that he knew of!

One of the strangest analysts ever!

WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 5, 2016

Mika does it again:
In our view, Morning Joe continues to be one of the strangest discussion shows in all of cable news history.

In the sixteen months since Trump declared, a lot of the strangeness has come from Joe. But yesterday morning, Mika Brzezinski hauled off and did it again.

Mika belongs on a cable news program in much the way we belong in the director's chair at the Bolshoi Ballet. Frequently, it seems she simply isn't comfortable stating and arguing points of view.

Despite her discomfort, she plows ahead. Yesterday morning, she authored one of her strangest performances ever.

You have to remember—on Morning Joe, Mika is cast as the liberal Clinton supporter. Joe is the former Republican congressman who likes to talk about his old campaigns. Mika is there to give the impression of a vague balance between the left and the right.

Is Mika planning to vote for Clinton? Frankly, we can't tell. There's nothing "wrong" with that, of course, except she keeps saying she plans to.

Yesterday morning, Mika really jumped the shark in her backhanded support for Clinton. The candidate had been seeming confident out on the trail since her first debate with Trump, and especially since that news report about Trump maybe not paying taxes.

Yesterday, Mika complained about that. Please try to follow the logic:
BRZEZINSKI (10/4/16): So I've just noticed a confidence here that I don't think should be there among the [Clinton] campaign, I'm sorry. But I mean, you think about this tax thing, unless—

Were laws broken? Did The New York Times find that any laws were broken?

HALPERIN: No.

BRZEZINSKI: Were any laws broken?

SCARBOROUGH: No.

HASKELL-GEIST JR.: No.

BRZEZINSKI: OK, so [Trump] talks about brilliantly using this system? Right! Hillary Clinton could have had that same reaction to her speech money. That she says she's going to change Wall Street, "But you know what, I used the system to make millions of dollars."

But instead she hides it. Donald Trump just doesn't hide it. He's very comfortable with the fact that he followed the law and made a lot of money. She also followed the law and made a lot of money and for some reason it's OK to look at that speech money and somehow we just let it go because she's—her campaign keeps it kind of under—

It's the same thing! And that's what people see! People see somebody being honest about it, and someone kind of like, not mentioning it but still doing it. What's the difference? Does anybody want to explain to me, because I think voters like what they saw from Donald Trump and I'm very worried about that.
You can watch the whole discussion here, all thanks to Media Matters.

In case you're wondering, yes! In that passage, Mika was saying that Trump has been open and "honest" about his taxes, while Clinton has been "hiding" her speaking fees. She said that in spite of the fact that Trump won't release his tax returns, while Clinton's speaking fees were always public information.

Mika didn't entirely seem to be making perfect sense at this point. By the time she angrily asked if Trump had broken any laws, the boys already seemed to be scared, as you can tell by their meek recitations of "No" in response to her query.

Mika actually seemed upset. The boys seemed to be a bit scared.

It's true that Trump isn't known to have broken any laws in this matter. And it isn't clear to what extent voters will care about this. But especially from a Clinton supporter, Mika's insistence that Donald was honest, while Clinton was hiding, really did seem a bit odd.

Sure enough! In case anyone thought she must mean something else, she hauled off again moments later:
BRZEZINSKI: I think the reaction to this New York Times story on Donald Trump's part was brilliant. And the thing is he didn't even think twice about it, he just went there, while she has been hiding this speech money, hiding this foundation stuff, hiding this email stuff, and trying to get around it, "Mistakes were made." And I'm telling you, people don't, they are not feeling a complete connection with her, and this didn't help to get all high and mighty. Get off your high horse about this tax thing. Unless laws were broken, it's not an issue. You guys cancel each other out.
Mika agrees with Christie and Rudy and with Trump's kids. Trump's reaction to the Times story really has been "brilliant," she now declared. And now, the self-professed Clinton supporter expanded her brief about Clinton's secrecy.

Clinton's been hiding the speaking fees and the "foundation stuff," Mika said. But the speaking fees were public info, and so was the gigantic bulk of the "foundation stuff." Just for the record, Clinton has also released tens of thousands of emails.

By way of contrast, Trump has been open and honest about his tax returns, which he won't release.

After telling Clinton to get off her high horse, Mika remembered that she's been cast as Morning Joe's Clinton supporter. Clinton and Trump "cancel each other out," the fiery Clintonista now said.

Morning Joe is constantly like this. In our view, it's one of the strangest discussion shows in the history of "cable news."

Quijano opens with a Matt Lauer!

WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 5, 2016

Parallel construction fails:
We're still watching the videotape of last night's VP debate. An initial reaction:

It's often intriguing to watch a debate after you've heard the punditry. So far, about forty minutes in, the debate we're watching doesn't seem enormously like the debate we heard described.

In a world awash in punditry, often from people with little to say about a bunch of non-events, Excited Pundit Overstatement is a frequent problem. We may have heard some EPO concerning last night's debate.

That said, we were struck by one aspect of the moderator's first substantive questions. It involves a dog which didn't bark.

Elaine Quijano started with a softball-style question which let each hopeful discuss himself. She then produced her first real questions for Kaine and Pence. In order, here's what she said:
QUIJANO (10/4/16): Senator Kaine, on the campaign trail, you praised Secretary Clinton's character, including her commitment to public service, yet 60 percent of voters don't think she's trustworthy. Why do so many people distrust her? Is it because they have questions about her e-mails and the Clinton Foundation?

[...]

QUIJANO: Governor Pence, let me ask you, you have said Donald Trump is, quote, "thoughtful, compassionate, and steady." Yet 67 percent of voters feel he is a risky choice, and 65 percent feel he does not have the right kind of temperament to be president. Why do so many Americans think Mr. Trump is simply too erratic?
American history isn't likely to change due to the oddness there. But as a bit of journalistic practice, the oddness there strikes us as odd.

Presumably, that pair of questions was intended to be fair-and-balanced. In theory, Quijano asked Kaine a challenging question about Candidate Clinton. In theory, she then asked Pence a parallel question about Candidate Trump.

That isn't exactly what happened. We were struck by the curious lack of parallel construction in those opening questions. Also, we thought of Matt Lauer.

Here's what we're talking about:

When Quijano asked Kaine about Candidate Clinton's standing with the public, she cited two specific factors which might explain the low regard in which she is held. "Is it because they have questions about her e-mails and the Clinton Foundation?" she specifically said.

Quijano named two punishing topics right in that opening question to Kaine. But when she asked Pence about the low regard in which Candidate Trump is held, she didn't mention any possible explanations.

It would have been easy enough to do so. ("Is it because of his frequent misstatements and self-contradictions? Is it because of his insulting comments about so many people?") But Quijano didn't cite any possible factors. Kaine was hit with two punishing topics, Pence heard none cited at all.

A person might think that Quijano balanced that off by citing two negative polling numbers for Trump, as opposed to just one for Clinton. But we were struck by the lack of parallel construction in what was essentially her first pair of questions.

It was similar to what Matt Lauer did at the Commander-in-Chief Forum. At the start of his interview with Candidate Clinton, Lauer directly suggested that her email procedures may have been "disqualifying" for her as a candidate.

In our view, Lauer showed poor judgment by inserting such an aggressive suggestion into that opening question (or into any question at all). That said, it was notable that he did nothing similar when he questioned Trump.

(Beyond that, the first audience question to Clinton was harshly accusatory. No such audience question was directed at Trump. We assume the questions were screened.)

So far, we've watched forty minutes of last night's debate. Kaine and Quijano both seemed confused, right off the bat, concerning Pence's right to speak for two minutes without being interrupted.

That confusion arose in the heat of battle, but those opening questions were prepared in advance. Quijano announced what Clinton's done wrong. Weirdly enough, when it came to Trump, she drew a total blank.

ROAD MAP TO THE CURRENT LOATHING: Times readers acknowledge that Clinton was mean!

WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 5, 2016

Part 1—Watching Times readers get played:
In this morning's New York Times, three readers discuss Megan Twohey's 2900-word, front-page report about the way Hillary Clinton savaged her husband's accusers back in the glorious day.

Twohey's report appeared on the front page of Monday's Times. It focused on the (highly improbable) claims made by Gennifer Flowers in 1992, when Twohey was in the tenth grade.

The thrilling story still gives Twohey strange wonderful feelings today. That said, her report struck us as plainly deceptive—as baldly dishonest work.

As we noted in this post, Twohey seemed to pick and choose her facts with great deal of care. This was true when she wrote about the accusation by Flowers, and when she discussed an earlier accusation by "rock groupie" Connie Hamzy.

Perhaps most strikingly, Twohey seemed to pick and choose her facts when she told her readers that Bill Clinton eventually confessed to "having 'sexual relations' " and to "having sex" with Flowers. In our view, Twohey's careful presentation strongly suggests that she, and her editor, were deliberately telling Times readers much less than they actually knew.

Did Bill Clinton confess to those cultural crimes? If we're all still speaking English, we'd have to say he didn't. But Twohey picked and chose with great care, telling the story in a way which has long thrilled high-end "journalists." In three letters in today's Times, we see the cluelessness which can result when New York Times readers get played.

Two of the letters come from supporters of Hillary Clinton. The first such letter comes from a woman right here in Baltimore. She blames everyone for the continued existence of this story—everyone but the New York Times and the rest of the mainstream press corps.

In her letter, she blames Candidate Trump—and she blames "the right-wing." She shows no sign of thinking that she has been played by Twohey and by the New York Times.

The second letter comes from a Hillary-hater in Florida. He is devoted to "the truth," which Hillary Clinton fought:
LETTER TO THE NEW YORK TIMES (10/5/16): Hillary Clinton fought back against the truth, and she either was willfully blind to the truth or considered it a mere inconvenience to be swept away.

When “Mrs. Clinton expressed pleasure to her friend that she and her husband were able to drive ‘their adversaries totally nuts’ because they did not appear to be suffering,” she also expressed what a Clinton Restoration will mean for the future—suffering for the rest of us.

The Clintons may have a high threshold of pain, but the nation should not have to endure the pain and suffering of another Clinton presidency.
According to this truth-loving reader, Hillary Clinton "was willfully blind to the truth or considered it a mere inconvenience." It doesn't seem to have entered his mind 1) that Hillary Clinton may have known the truth about the accusations of Flowers and Hamzy, namely that their claims were false; or 2) that Hillary Clinton may not have known the truth about her husband's relationship with Monica Lewinsky, in part because there had been so many false claims in the past.

(Full disclosure: We don't know what Hillary Clinton thought about the claims concerning her husband and Lewinsky. Neither does that fellow in Florida, until he gets played by the Times.)

The third letter comes from another Clinton supporter. He seems to accept, and even assert, a central premise from Twohey's deceptive report—the premise that Hillary Clinton "was mean" to her husband's accusers:
LETTER TO THE NEW YORK TIMES: After exhaustively chronicling Benghazi and Hillary Clinton’s email transgressions, now you run a story on how she grappled with her husband’s infidelity. Really?

This is not news. If the point of your article is that Mrs. Clinton was mean to the women who accused her husband of having sex with them, so be it.
Does this suggest that her regard for women is the same as Donald Trump’s? Hardly. She was an irate wife, fighting to save her marriage, and their careers.

Politically and professionally, she has spent her career championing the rights of women and minorities. Mr. Trump has focused on enriching himself at the expense of others, while denigrating women for fun.
For the record, that was "the point of [Twohey's] article." Amazingly, Twohey implied that Hillary Clinton was mean for assembling affidavits in which three witnesses swore that Hamzy's story was bogus.

(Unmentioned by Twohey: Hamzy was using her thrilling claim to promote an upcoming appearance in Penthouse.)

In those three letters, Times readers react to Twohey's highly deceptive, lengthy front-page report. In our view, they chronicle the way this newspaper's readers have been misled, misinformed and deceived down through the many long years since Twohey was maybe 15.

When Gennifer Flowers first appeared on the scene, mainstream newspapers largely rejected her claims. A Newsweek report by Jonathan Alter provided strong reasons for doubting or rejecting her claims. The earlier claim by Hamzy had also been rejected, on the basis that Hamzy was a well-known national nut.

That said, by 1998, the press corps had come to [HEART] all Clinton accusers. They found themselves thrilled by a new possibility, a possibility which actually turned out to be true.

This new possibility involved a "21-year-old intern" who was neither 21 nor an intern—but they loved loved loved their new story so much that they kept describing her that way. In the process, they even resurrected the ludicrous Flowers, who would go on to tell the world about the Clintons' many murders, while reminding TV viewers to please visit her play-for-pay site!

(Chris Matthews to Flowers during one such appearance, on Hardball, in August 1999: “Well, you know, I gotta pay a little tribute here. You're a very beautiful woman, and I—and I have to tell you, he knows that, you know that, and everybody watching knows that. Hillary Clinton knows that. How can a woman put up with a relationship between her husband and somebody, anybody, but especially somebody like you that's a knockout?...It's an objective statement, Gennifer. I'm not flirting.” Flowers went on to discuss the deeply troubling murders. Her half-hour appearance was so crazy that she was quickly rewarded with a full hour on Hannity & Colmes.)

Even today, at age maybe 40, Twohey gets mysterious feelings in her body when she dreams about this old tale. On Monday, she and her editor put their thumbs and their asscheeks on the scale as they retold the thrilling story of the accusations lodged by Hamzy and Flowers.

They picked and chose their facts with care, keeping their thrilling old stories alive. In the process, they seem to have convinced some readers that Flowers and Hamzy were telling the truth, and that Hillary Clinton had somehow been "mean" to her husband's accusers.

The public has been played for many years by a collection of people like Twohey. This morning's letters help us see the way the public can get misinformed when the major news orgs they trust play such remarkable games.

Tomorrow, we'll consider an affair which actually may have occurred during the years encompassed by Flowers' highly implausible claims. On Friday, we'll review the slick and slippery way two major journalistic stars played you about Gennifer Flowers in two high-profile books.

It's hard to believe that this conduct exists. Yet it plainly does exist. It has typified our mainstream "journalism" for a very long time.

People are dead all over the world because these life forms behave in these ways. On the brighter side, telling these tales can make our scribes feel good.

Mysterious feelings may still emerge when scribes dream about these thrilling old tales. If voters get badly misled in the process, it may seem like a small price to pay.

Tomorrow: An affair you may not have to misremember

Friday: As far as George Stephanopoulos knows, no one was murdered at Rose

Nixon still won on the radio!

TUESDAY, OCTOBER 4, 2016

The press corps loves its old tales:
Brian Williams will be in action tonight, killing time before and after the ballyhooed Kaine-Pence match.

We were struck by something Brian said to Michael Beschloss after last Monday's debate. We thought the corps had stopped telling this treasured old story.

As it turned out, we were wrong:
WILLIAMS (9/26/16): And Michael, what about the conversation Rachel and I were having at the top of the evening? We were talking about Nixon-Kennedy, and all kinds of aspects of Nixon-Kennedy, Nixon's sweatiness for television viewers, but radio listeners believing that he had won on substance.
Nixon won on the radio! It's one of the press corps' favorite old tales. It almost defines the start of the modern era, in which so much of what we hear has simply been made up by the children who pose as our press corps.

Alleged historian Michael Beschloss let Brian's famous old story pass. That said, the notion that Nixon won on the radio has been on the junk heap for years.

On the fiftieth anniversary of that famous first Kennedy-Nixon debate, historian David Greenberg discussed the topic at Slate. Citing the academic research, he shot down the tale, as others had done before him.

Here's a chunk of what he said. Cover the eyes of the children:
GREENBERG (9/24/10): [T]here's almost no evidence to support the claim that it was Kennedy's looks—as opposed to his overall performance—that gave him the edge. For decades, it has become part of the folklore of the debate to say that in contrast to those who watched the debate on TV, radio listeners judged Nixon the winner...it turns out there's no good reason to believe that assertion is true, either.

Virtually all of the evidence for Nixon's alleged superiority on radio is strictly anecdotal—and there isn't even much of it.
Can David Greenberg say things like that? Not on MSNBC when there are hours to kill!

Large amounts of what journalists tell us are, to use Greenberg's term, "folklore." That's routinely true about policy matters. It's gigantically true when these giants start spouting off with their favorite campaign/debate tales.

(Remind us to tell you about the way John Dickerson handles the dangerous claim that Muskie wept in his new play-for-pay, please-like-me book, Whistlestop.)

Nixon won on the radio! When Brian and Rachel are forced to kill time, the famous old story's still true, though he wasn't shot down in Iraq.

A few other favorites: George Bush 41 looked at his watch! Dukakis should have punched Bernie Shaw!

Bush was fooled by that scanner machine! The tears were streaming down Muskie's face! Dean screamed, Gore endlessly sighed!

[Bill] Clinton Derangement Syndrome!

TUESDAY, OCTOBER 4, 2016

The weirdness of the press:
If you write about the mainstream press, you will end up sounding crazy.

That's because of the masterful strangeness of our high-end press. If you write about their work, it's hard to avoid wondering if they're secret invaders from some foreign realm.

That makes it seem like you're the nut. We'll cite two recent examples.

The first example comes from the Outlook section of Sunday's Washington Post. We refer to the strange review of Joe Conason's new book, Man of the World: The Further Endeavors of Bill Clinton.

Conason writes about Bill Clinton's activities since leaving the White House. Because he isn't gripped by Clinton Derangement Syndrome, he tends to excite the antipathy of mainstream figures who are.

In this case, that figure is the lofty Carla Anne Robbins, a member of the New York Times editorial board from 2006 through 2012. Robbins didn't like Conason's book at all. Early on, she displayed her displeasure like this:
ROBBINS (10/2/16): The book enthusiastically chronicles Bill’s philanthropic efforts since he left the White House: slashing the cost of AIDS treatments; improving health systems in Africa; getting sugary drinks out of American public schools; rallying the great and the near great at the annual Clinton Global Initiative to commit hundreds of millions of dollars to their own charitable projects. Much of this has been covered in more lively and skeptical reporting in this newspaper and others, and at a time when the Clinton Foundation’s many good works are dismissed as merely pay to play, Conason’s hagiography won’t correct the record.
Already, derangement may be showing. That said, another familiar old motive will quickly come into play.

According to Robbins, Conason is "enthusiastic" about philanthropic efforts which slash the cost of AIDS treatments and improve health systems in Africa. In particular, he's said to be enthusiastic about the Clinton Foundation's efforts in these areas.

The Post has covered the topic better, Robbins writes, offering links to no such work. Conason's enthusiam is therefore dismissed as "hagiography."

So far, we have nothing but Robbins' assertions to go on. Is it fair to dismiss Conason's book this way? We've been given no examples of his objectionable work.

Just like that, our second motive appears. As she continues, Robbins pisses and moans about the way Conason treats her own magnificent guild. After the standard tears of rage, we get our first alleged example of his ridiculous work:
ROBBINS (continuing directly): The real contribution comes from watching Conason’s exertions as he tries to justify the Clintons’ more dubious actions. I’m convinced that he must be channeling their denial, injured pride and conviction that the ends not only justify the means, but anyone who questions their means is part of a right-wing conspiracy or, in the case of the news media, a tool of those conspirators.

In just one such flight, Conason describes Bill Clinton’s “lashing” by his “adversaries in politics and the media” after his parting pardon of financier Marc Rich. “If anything, the compulsion to pursue their old quarry seemed to be swelling, now that he was no longer the leader of the free world but just another defenseless citizen.”
Is it possible that Conason is right? Is it possible that "the news media" did perform poorly in some way in their treatment of the Rich pardon?

Within the realm from which Robbins types, we're sorry, but no—that simply isn't possible. By definition, any such claim just has to be wrong. The guild will defend the guild, and they'll do so quickly!

We don't mean to commit the offense with which we're charging Robbins. It's always possible that Conason's treatment of this episode really is unfair and unbalanced—that Robbins' perception is right.

That said, we'll show you Robbins' full attempt at explaining what's wrong with Conason's presentation. Conason spends several early chapters of his book on the Rich pardon. But this is all Robbins provides to justify what she has said:
ROBBINS: Consider a few of this book’s arguments/rationalizations:

•The Rich pardon had nothing to do with campaign and library contributions from Rich’s former wife, “all of which she had given months and years before she approached him on behalf of her ex-husband.” Bill was doing a favor for Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak, who had asked him to “consider” the case because of Rich’s service to Israel.
Amazingly, that is Robbins' full analysis of Conason's treatment of the pardon. She starts by snarkily calling his work an "argument / rationalization." She then makes exactly zero attempt to justify her apparent claim that his assessment is wrong.

Did Bill Clinton pardon Rich as a favor to Ehud Barak? The claim is hardly new to this book. But is it wrong or right? And how does Conason argue his case?

As you can see from that excerpt, Robbins makes exactly zero attempt to argue the matter one way or the other. Conason has criticized the press. Within the guild, his basic human rights all ceased to exist at that point.

Within the mahoganied world of the guild, the adept must only engage in some snark about such a man, then display an eye roll. The rest of the guild will quickly agree—the offending claim has been sent to the fires of Hell!

As we've noted, Conason's book begins with the Rich pardon; so does Robbins' review. But she makes exactly zero attempt to construct an argument about whatever it is that Conason actually said. Handily proving Conason's point, she doesn't even pretend that she is engaged in journalism.

This is the way the mainstream press reviewed Gene Lyons' 1995 book, Fools for Scandal: How the Media Invented Whitewater. To the extent that it was reviewed at all, the book was reviewed in precisely this way, with snide dismissals that didn't resemble real journalistic work.

In 2000, Lyons and Conason wrote The Hunting of the President: The Ten-Year Campaign to Destroy Bill and Hillary Clinton. The New York Times found a different way to review that effort. It discussed the parts of the book which chronicled Republican attacks on the Clintons, ignored the parts which chronicled similar work by the press.

A basic law guides the conduct of life-forms like Robbins. You simply mustn't attack the guild. The guild will always get the last world, and the guild will play it this way.

Tomorrow, our second example: [Hillary] Clinton Derangement Syndrome—Mika on Hillary Clinton

WHERE THE ACHIEVEMENT GAPS ARE: On to the PISA!

TUESDAY, OCTOBER 4, 2016

On to the PISA next week:
Are U.S. public schools an embarrassing mess as compared to schools in the rest of the world?

How about as compared to schools in the rest of the developed world? Are American schools an embarrassing mess as compared to them?

That impression is constantly given within the American discourse. It's done through comparisons to the miracle schools of miraculous Finland, a small, middle-class, unicultural nation whose kids tend to outscore their American peers on international tests.

It's also done through comparisons to the world's other nations in general. That said, it's hard to conclude that American schools are an embarrassing mess by looking at scores from the TIMSS and the PIRLS, which constitute one of the two international testing programs from which all our data flow.

On the TIMSS (math and science) and the PIRLS (reading), American students tend to score rather well, except when compared to a handful of Asian nations and city-states which tend to outscore everyone else in the world. If we look at results from the TIMSS and the PIRLS, American students and American schools don't seem to be a horrid, embarrassing mess.

Perhaps for that reason, we rarely hear about results from the TIMSS and the PIRLS. When American "opinion leaders" talk about the public schools, they tend to discuss the wonders of Finland—and they tend to discuss test scores from the PISA.

(Note: By all accounts, Finland is an admirable nation which functions extremely well. We would only criticize the misleading way its education ministry tends to promote itself.)

The PISA (the Program for International Student Assessment) is the other major international testing program. On the one hand, we have the TIMSS and the PIRLS. On the other hand, we have the PISA, which conducts tests in reading, math and science.

Compared to kids from other nations, American students haven't ranked as well on the PISA as they have on the TIMSS/PIRLS. Perhaps for that reason, advocates of certain types of education reform tend to discuss results from the PISA while completely ignoring results from the TIMSS and the PIRLS.

We'd planned to discuss "achievement gaps" on the PISA today, but we've decided it can't be done in a single report. We want to show the size of the gaps between the U.S. and other nations. But we also want to "disaggregate" those gaps. That is, we want to show what the gaps look like on the PISA (and on the TIMSS) when you report the divergent average scores of American students from our major population groups.

In Part 3 of our current report, we recorded the large achievement gaps of that type which obtain on our major domestic testing program, the NAEP. Despite large score gains by all major groups, large achievement gaps persist on the NAEP.

In our view, you can't fully understand American scores on international tests unless you see what scores look like for those different major groups. In our view, the data are painful, but instructive. That "disaggregation" makes our nation's educational challenges that much more stark and more clear.

It doesn't make sense to try to do all that in one post. Instead, we'll reshape our ongoing series, which was originally planned to last four weeks in all.

Next Monday, we'll start a new four-part series, Where the PISA Gaps Are. we'll look at the gaps between the world's nations, and between different groups of American kids.

We could try to cram it all in today. We could do it, but it would be wrong.

For today, you might want to look at Kevin Drum's capsule summary of these matters. In this new post, Drum offers an overview of some of the data we've been discussing.

That said, we do have a question about this highlighted point:
DRUM (10/3/16): [A]s Somerby points out, one of the striking things about these tests is that a small clutch of Asian countries do far better than us. In fact, they do far better than everyone, something they accomplish through a combination of cherry picking the students who take the test and a monomaniac culture of test prep. So let's take that as given, and just look at the rankings outside of the Asian tigers...
We'll have occasion to discuss that "monomaniac culture of test prep" again next week. That said, we don't think we've ever seen anyone claim that the high-scoring Asian nations "cherry-pick the students who take" the TIMSS and the PISA.

Drum may be referring to the limited case of Shanghai, which took the PISA as an independent entity in 2009, producing extremely high scores which set off paroxysms in the American press. It was almost like Shanghai's kids had put a new Sputnik in orbit.

As it turned out, Shanghai's student population, and its public schools, are highly unrepresentative of the Chinese system in general. It was a bit like testing kids from Groton and Choate and acting like you'd tested a representative sample of American students.

Once the gorilla dust had settled, the PISA was criticized for letting China participate in the program in such a misleading way. That may be the situation to which Drum referred. Aside from that, we're not aware of claims that South Korea, Japan or Taiwan arrange for an unrepresentative sample of students to be tested. Perhaps some such allegation exists, but we don't think we've ever heard about it.

Asian tigers to the side, American students score pretty well on the TIMSS and the PIRLS. They seem to stack up less well on the PISA.

Next week, we'll do a four-part report about American scores on the PISA. Along the way, we'll break American scores down by groups, and we'll look at how certain states performed on the PISA as independent entities.

In our view, these practices give us a clearer picture of the educational challenges we face. Aside from standard assertions of script and cant, these topics are very rarely discussed. We want to end up with a detailed report which makes lots of basic information available all in one place.

We're sorry for the delay. But we've come to believe that the PISA's gaps deserve a week of their own.

The Times continues the Flowers craze!

MONDAY, OCTOBER 3, 2016

Megan Twohey's slickness:
Did Bill Clinton ever have an affair with Gennifer Flowers? Did they have a 12-year affair, the way Flowers so thrillingly said?

(Back in 1992, Flowers hauled in more than $500,000 for making the thrilling claim. By 1999, she was reduced to doing hour-long TV appearances, discussing the Clintons' many murders and telling the world that Hillary Clinton was the world's most gigantic lesbo. The gruesome Chris Matthews gushed and fawned about how super-hot she was. The mainstream press corps accepted this gruesome gong-show, which they'd enabled and peddled for years.)

Back to Bill and Gennifer! Did they ever have "sexual relations?" Did they ever "have sex?" Did Bill Clinton ever confess to such things? To having "an affair?"

If we're all still speaking English, we'd say the answer to all those questions is no. That said, it's easy enough to explain what we know about this ancient matter. Last week, it became fairly clear that the New York Times actually knows these basic facts:

Gennifer Flowers claimed that she and "her Bill" had a torrid, twelve-year affair. In 1999, under oath, Bill Clinton said they interacted sexually on one occasion. He was forced to testify under a sprawling technical definition of "sexual relations"—a definition which encompassed a lot of behavior which fell short of intercourse, or even of oral sex.

For the pitiful details, see last Friday's report.

After Clinton testified to that one interaction—sorry, to that one incident of "sexual relations" under Technical Definition One—a Clinton spokesperson said that he was talking about a single grope-and-grab session. That's the full extent of what Bill Clinton ever said.

Nothing else is known about whether these two people ever did or didn't engage in conduct that would normally be described as sexual relations. Flowers never backed away from her thrilling claim, but as we recalled last week, she is a truly horrible person. Unless we're just complete utter fools, there is zero reason to believe anything a nutcase like Flowers says.

Last week, the New York Times published several reports which indicated that they know and understand these facts. This morning, though, the Times has published a 2900-word, front-page report which wallows in the Flowers mess and grossly misdirects readers.

The reporter, Megan Twohey, works hard to disguise the known facts of this matter. It's the kind of piece which has often made us wonder if life forms like Twohey are human.

Twohey isn't some clueless kid typing in her pajamas. She's been a full-blown journalist for 18 years. In 2014, when she was still working for Reuters, she was even a finalist for a Pulitzer prize.

That said, her piece today seems baldly dishonest—and it's an example of the way the experienced "journalists" work.

Twohey is busily pimping the claim that Hillary Clinton did terrible things to the women who accused her husband of extramarital activity or of sexual misconduct. Gennifer Flowers is the clear focus of her endless piece.

As noted, Twohey's piece runs 2900 words. But very quickly, early on, we get handed this:
TWOHEY (10/3/16): Confronting a spouse's unfaithfulness is painful under any circumstance. For Mrs. Clinton, it happened repeatedly and in the most public of ways, unfolding at the dawn of the 24/7 news cycle, and later in impeachment proceedings that convulsed the nation.

Outwardly, she remained stoic and defiant, defending her husband while a progression of women and well-funded conservative operatives accused Mr. Clinton of behavior unbecoming the leader of the free world.

But privately, she embraced the Clinton campaign's aggressive strategy of counterattack: Women who claimed to have had sexual encounters with Mr. Clinton would become targets of digging and discrediting—tactics that women's rights advocates frequently denounce.

[...]

By the time Mr. Clinton finally admitted to ''sexual relations'' with Ms. Flowers, years later, Clinton aides had used stories collected by the private investigator to brand her as a ''bimbo'' and a ''pathological liar.''
According to Twohey, Bill Clinton eventually "admitted to 'sexual relations' with Ms. Flowers." Her placement of quotation marks around the key term can only be called slippery, disingenuous—slick.

In that passage, Twohey gives the impression that she is quoting a free expression made by Clinton himself. What she's actually quoting is the term used in an extremely broad definition under which Clinton was forced to testify about his interactions with Flowers.

You can tell that Twohey knows that; she just never explains it to her readers. She also knows that, contrary to Flowers' sweeping claim, Clinton testified to having "sexual relations" (as defined in Deposition Exhibit 1) on only one occasion. Just once, in all those twelve years!

Twohey understands that. But she doesn't tell her readers until paragraph 69, deep inside her highly selective report. And when she does drop this puzzling buzzkill, she just can't help it! She gets all slick again:
TWOHEY: Mr. Clinton later admitted, during a deposition in the Paula Jones sexual harassment case, that he had sex with Ms. Flowers once.
Be sure to note Twohey's slickness there:

When he testified in that deposition, did Bill Clinton really say that he "had sex" with Flowers, even on one occasion? Not as the term is normally understood! On two occasions as he spoke, he stressed the fact that he was only talking about "sexual relations" as defined in the very broad definition he'd been given by the Ken Starr gang. His spokesperson later clarified the matter further, saying that he was talking about a brief grope-and-grab session.

Twohey could have explained all that, of course, but she chose not to do so. Either that, or she couldn't find a way to explain it in the 2900 words she had to work with.

How dishonest does Twohey seem to be? Try to believe the disgraceful construction shown below, from early in her report. In this passage, she is describing the first accusation of sexual misconduct which greeted Bill Clinton's announcement, in late 1991, that he was running for president.

The charge was made by a world-class nut. Twohey never quite cops to that fact:
TWOHEY: [T]heir first taste of trouble came in a Penthouse magazine story by a rock groupie named Connie Hamzy, who claimed Mr. Clinton had once propositioned her at a hotel in Little Rock, Ark.

Mr. Clinton brushed off the story, saying that Ms. Hamzy had made a sexual advance toward him, George Stephanopoulos, the communications director of the 1992 campaign, recalled in his book, ''All Too Human.''

But Mrs. Clinton demanded action.

''We have to destroy her story,'' she said, according to Mr. Stephanopoulos.

In what became a common tactic, affidavits were collected, from an aide and two others who stated that they were with Mr. Clinton at the hotel and that Ms. Hamzy's story was false. (Contacted recently, Ms. Hamzy said she stood by her account.)

When the work was done, both Clintons called Mr. Stephanopoulos, together, to offer their thanks.
But Mrs. Clinton demanded action? Of course Mrs. Clinton demanded action!

"In what became a common tactic?" Pseudo-journalist, please!

In context, Twohey is plainly suggesting that this was part of the roughhouse conduct—the "aggressive strategy of counterattack"—in which Hillary Clinton engaged. Truly, there's nothing these life forms won't say and do to maintain the stories they love.

Let's give credit where due! Twohey is at least willing to describe Hamzy, somewhat unfortunately, as a "rock groupie." In fact, she may have been the most famous "rock groupie" in the country at that time. (A major group had written a song about her.) She was also an Arkansas-based clown whose crazy story no one believed, as Stephanopoulos' book seems to make clear.

According to Stephanopoulos, Hamzy had come up to Clinton at the hotel in question years before and she'd proceeded to flash him. In the affidavits to which Twohey refers, that's the incident to which the three witnesses were swearing.

According to Stephanopoulos, the Clinton camp was justifiably concerned about a (false) claim of this type at the start of Bill Clinton's campaign. In response, they did what anyone would have done; Stephanopoulos collected sworn statements concerning what actually happened.

Let's review! Hillary Clinton's husband had been falsely accused by a person who was widely known to be a nut. (As Stephanopoulos noted in his book, Hamzy was using the allegation to promote her upcoming appearance in Penthouse.)

In response, the Clinton campaign collected sworn statements as to what had really occurred. In the full context of this morning's report, Twohey makes this thoroughly sensible conduct sound like some sort of nefarious attack. Truly, these life forms will do and say anything to keep treasured stories alive.

Almost surely, Hillary Clinton knew that Hamzy's claim was false. Almost surely, she assumed the same about Flowers' grossly improbable claim of a 12-year affair.

(Uh-oh! In 1990, Flowers had sworn, in an affidavit, that she never had sexual relations with Bill Clinton. The claim had originally been made as an act of revenge by Larry Nichols, a crazy former state employee who had been fired by Governor Clinton for making 140 phone calls to the Nicaraguan contras on the state of Arkansas' dime. When Nichols made his charges—he named four other women who he said had had sex with Clinton—Flowers and the other women all swore that his claims were false. Twohey didn't find space to mention these facts in her 2900 words, though they're all in Stephanopoulos' book. If we might borrow from the late Richard Ben Cramer, life-forms like Twohey will do "what it takes" to foul our White House campaigns.)

Please understand—Hillary Clinton almost surely knew that her husband had had affairs. In his 2007 biography, A Woman in Charge, Carl Bernstein reported that Bill Clinton had had a long and serious affair with a Little Rock woman in the years leading up to his 1992 campaign. Bernstein describes the painful, pained negotiations which led to the Clintons' decision to maintain their marriage.

Unless Bernstein's reporting was crazily wrong, Hillary Clinton knew that her husband had had affairs. Presumably, though, she didn't believe the crazy stories of local clowns like Hamzy and Flowers.

Today, though, a bottom feeder at the Times is working hard to keep these treasured old chestnuts alive. She picked and chose her facts with care to keep her readers from understanding either one of these episodes.

In the case of Flowers, Twohey worked slickly to keep her readers from knowing what Bill Clinton actually testified. In the case of Hamzy, she made it sound like defending oneself against a false charge is some sort of "counterattack" against the person bearing false witness.

It's very hard to come to terms with the behavior of people like Twohey. Most people couldn't imagine doing such things. It simply doesn;t occur to us that others do.

For the record, Twohey grew up with all the advantages. She went to Evanston Township High, then Mother and Father sent her to Georgetown. She graduated in 1998. Eighteen years later, she's crawling on her belly through a barrel of misleading, slick old slime.

Amazingly, the New York Times has played these games forever. There is no chance they'll ever stop, or that career players will ever challenge their endless conduct. Even in the face of a possible President Trump, their slippery conduct goes on and on. As we've told you:

Trumpism started at the Times long before the world ever dreamed of a Candidate Trump.

Normal people don't understand that life-forms like this exist. Twohey has done a very slick thing, as she did last year with Michael Barbaro in a semi-sliming of Trump.

Who the heck is Twohey's editor? Is her editor human?

WHERE THE ACHIEVEMENT GAPS ARE: In search of embarrassing international gaps!

MONDAY, OCTOBER 3, 2016

Part 3 in this series

Part 4—On the TIMSS, they're hard to find: In June of last year, Donald J. Trump was discussing an important, terrible problem.

It was June 16, 2015; Trump was announcing his White House campaign. After explaining that Mexico was "sending us" a lot of rapists, he talked about some embarrassing achievement gaps in the international realm:

"We're twenty-sixth in the world," the new candidate thoughtfully said. "Twenty-five countries are better than us at education. And some of them are like third-world countries. But we're becoming a third-world country," the thoughtful candidate said.

The previous evening, Rachel Maddow had assured us that she had nothing against Mr. Trump. Birtherism be danged!

Over the course of the next few weeks, Maddow barely mentioned Trump's comments about all the rapists we were being sent. She didn't mention his comments about education at all, and she never will.

Were Trump's comments accurate? Granted, such comments have been quite familiar in recent years as we hear about the "embarrassing decline" in our public schools—an embarrassing decline which is said to have occurred even as our domestic test scores have shown "truly spectacular gains."

We hear such comments all the time, but were Trump's comments accurate? Is it true that twenty-five countries "are better than us at education?" Might this state of affairs even suggest that we are becoming a third-world nation? Was that familiar assessment fair and balanced?

Such claims can only be judged by results from two international testing programs: the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS), an international program which started in 1995 and now operates on a four-year cycle; and the Program for International Student Assessment (PISA), which started in 2000 and is administered every third year.

The United States participates in both programs on a regular basis. Most of the world's developed nations have participated in each of these programs to some degree.

Information about academic achievement, and about achievement gaps, can only come from these two programs. For today, we'll concentrate on data from the TIMSS, the granddaddy of them both.

(The TIMSS tests math and science. A companion program, the Progress in International Reading Literacy Study, or PIRLS, conducts and international test in reading. We've hit all the acronyms now.)

As we noted earlier this series, one fairly obvious achievement gap obtains in both sets of international tests. A small number of Asian states tends to outperform all other developed nations on both the TIMSS and the PISA.

We refer to Japan, South Korea and Taiwan, along with Singapore and Hong Kong, a pair of smaller city states. As you can see in data from both the TIMSS and the PISA, students in these education systems tend to outscore their counterparts from around the world in reading, math and science, by fairly significant margins.

As a general rule, American students don't score on the level of their counterparts in these Asian tigers. Then again, neither do students from anywhere else in the world.

That said, it's hard to find embarrassing achievement gaps when students in American schools are compared to their peers from all other developed nations on the TIMSS or the PIRLS. Because Americans are rarely permitted to hear such facts, we'll concentrate today on results from those programs.

The TIMSS tests students in Grade 4 and Grade 8 in both math and science. The PIRLS tests students in Grade 4 in reading. The most recent TIMSS testing occurred last year, but those results aren't available yet. Today, we'll review the results from 2011—the results which have been available to journalists over the past four years.

Below, you see some average scores from the Grade 4 math test. For simplicity's sake, we're not including the handful of Asian states which tend to outscore the rest of the world.

We're including the major developed nations of the rest of the world, along with a selection of the smaller developed nations. In Grade 4 math, we'd be inclined to say that Americans kids scored surprisingly well, especially when you consider the profusion of disparaging comments one constantly hears about our hapless failing schools:
Average scores, Grade 4 math, 2011 TIMSS
Finland 545
England 542
Russia 542
United States 541
Netherlands 540
Denmark 537
Portugal 532
Germany 528
Canada 525
Australia 516
Hungary 515
Austria 508
Italy 508
Belgium 505
Sweden 504
France 499
Norway 495
New Zealand 486
Spain 482
Poland 481
Among the larger nations, American students matched their peers in England and Russia, outscored their peers in Germany, Canada, Australia, Italy, France and Spain.

They scored a few points behind the miracle kids of miraculous Finland. They soundly outscored their peers in such smaller nations as Austria, Belgium, Sweden, Norway. To our propagandized eyes and ears, those are surprising results.

For the fuller set of results, click here. We can't give you a rule of thumb with which to judge the size of those score differentials, but the National Center for Education Statistics shows you which of the average scores are considered "different [from the U.S. average score] at the level of statistical significance."

As you can see from the fuller results, the five Asian tigers substantially outscored all other nations. For reasons we'll briefly cite below, American students did surprisingly well as compared to everyone else.

The picture was roughly the same in Grade 8 math, though many fewer nations took part. The PISA tests 15-year-old students in reading, math and science. For that reason, some nations take part in the TIMSS on the Grade 4 level, skip the Grade 8 tests:
Average scores, Grade 8 math, 2011 TIMSS
Russia 539
Finland 514
United States 509
England 507
Australia 505
Hungary 505
Italy 498
Sweden 484
Norway 475
That's a substantially smaller set of comparison nations. (Again, the five Asian entities substantially outscored everyone else.)

According to the NCES, Russian students outscored the U.S. at the level of statistical significance; the students of miraculous Finland did not. According to the NCES, Finland, England, the U.S. and Australia were statistically indistinguishable on this test.

Results were roughly similar on the TIMSS science tests. In Grade 4 science, only Finland and Russia outscored the U.S., aside from the Asian nations. American students outscored England, Germany, Italy, Australia and Spain, along with a long list of smaller developed nations.

(France and Canada didn't take part. It seems clear that the U.S. would have outscored Canada, based on scores from three provinces, including Ontario and Quebec, which participated as independent entities.)

In Grade 8 science, the United States was outscored by Finland and Russia at the level of statistical significance. The American average score was indistinguishable from those of England, Hungary and Australia. American students outscored their peers from New Zealand, Sweden, Italy and Norway.

The PIRLS tests reading in Grade 4 only. Asian tigers aside, American students outscored the bulk of the developed world. For fuller results, click here:
Average scores, Grade 4 reading, 2011 PIRLS
Finland 568
Russia 568
United States 556
Denmark 554
Ireland 552
England 552
Canada 548
Netherlands 546
Sweden 542
Italy 541
Germany 541
New Zealand 531
Austria 529
Australia 527
Poland 526
France 520
Spain 513
Norway 507
On this test, American students were right on the tail of the Asian nations.

We're looking today at the most recent scores from the TIMSS and the PIRLS—the scores available to American journalists over the past four years. At the Grade 8 level on the TIMSS, international participation wasn't all that it might have been.

That said, results from the TIMSS and the PIRLS are surprisingly good, considering the gloomy assessments one constantly hears in the American public discourse. No one matches the academic results of South Korea, Japan and Taiwan. But on the 2011 TIMSS and the 2011 PIRLS, American kids performed rather well as compared to the rest of the world.

In our view, the results are also surprisingly good considering some of the demographic challenges created by our nation's brutal racial history and by some of our current social and educational policies and practices. It has always been especially silly to compare American test scores to those of Finland, a small, middle-class, unicultural nation whose schools face few such challenges. But American journalists have been eager to do so over the part fifteen years.

Why have our journalists done that? We'll postpone such considerations until the final week of this four-week report. Tomorrow, we'll continue our search for embarrassing international gaps as we examine results from the PISA.

Our mileage has varied on the PISA. Why the heck is that?

Tomorrow: Achievement gaps on the PISA

"Moral equivalence" at the Post!

SATURDAY, OCTOBER 1, 2016

The journalists can't help it:
When it comes to promoting "moral equivalence," the journalists just can't help it.

Just consider the headlines which sit atop a featured piece in this morning's Washington Post. We refer to David Weigel's lengthy piece about the opening of the new season of the famously tedious TV program, Saturday Night Live.

Weigel's lengthy piece dominates the front page of the paper's Style section, the only section anybody ever actually reads. It sits beneath a large double headline. Rather plainly, those headlines promote a "moral equivalence" between Candidates Clinton and Trump:
This year; [sic] is it still a laughing matter?
As Saturday Night Live starts again, the pressure's on to sketch Trump and Clinton in starker terms
Especially within the context of the current election, any dope can understand what that headline implies. We have the two worst candidates in history! The pressure is on to sketch Clinton and Trump in the harsh way they deserve!

It's classic "moral equivalence." It also baldly misstates the entire thrust of Weigel's intriguing piece.

(At present, we can offer no link. See below.)

Weigel's piece does not report that the pressure is on to paint Clinton and Trump in starker terms. Weigel reports that the pressure is on to paint Trump in starker terms—to stop normalizing Trump while demonizing Clinton, as the program is alleged to have done last year.

Whatever you think of Clinton or Trump; whatever you think of the program's past work; that is the pressure Weigel describes in his 1500-word piece. But how typical! As a familiar warm liquid began to run down his leg or her leg, some editor placed a headline atop the piece which completely reversed its content.

Whatever you think of the program's past work, Weigel describes complaints about an alleged double standard in its profiles of Clinton and Trump. He reports that advocates of Candidate Trump and Candidate Sanders thought last year's profiles of those candidates were helpful to their campaigns. He reports that Clinton supporters thought Kate McKinnon's portrait of Candidate Clinton took things a whole different way.

Whatever you think of this program's past work, that's the claim which Weigel discusses. Whoever wrote the headlines either 1) doesn't know how to read or 2) is unable to get through the day without the requisite dose of fresh-squeezed "moral equivalence."

For ourselves, we think Saturday Night Live is a low-IQ blight on the political culture—a low-IQ blight which occasionally produces a skillful, entertaining impression of some political figure. When that happens, the success of the impression flows from the performance skills of some individual performer.

Having said that, beware! Just because those featured performers are skilled, that doesn't mean that they have insightful political perceptions, or any such perceptions at all. At least on the surface, this point seems most clear in Weigel's account of his interview with McKinnon.

Midway through his essay, Weigel quotes Bernie Sanders himself. Sanders says that Larry David's ballyhooed, utterly pointless impression of Sanders "was a positive in the campaign, absolutely," last year.

Weigel continues from there. We can give you a link down below:
WEIGEL (10/1/16): McKinnon's Clinton, a breakout character, was less of an obvious boon to the campaign. A typical sketch had her promising anything that voters wanted, with a rictus and wild eyes. "Aren't we such a fun, approachable dynasty?" she asked in an early sketch about a "spontaneous"-looking campaign video. In last season's finale, she and "Sanders" shared a drink at a bar over how the primary was "so rigged"—an impression that continues to cost Clinton votes from her left.

McKinnon, who thanked Clinton in her Emmy victory speech, told the New York Times' Maureen Dowd in 2015 that Clinton was "a brilliant intellectual, a crusader for things I care deeply about." Asked about the idea that her impression could swing the election, McKinnon called it "the worst thing I could ever imagine," and described the impression as a joke more at society's expense than the candidate's.

"If you had a man saying the same things, that would not qualify as a comedic character, and I think that's deeply problematic and speaks more about our culture than it does about her,"
McKinnon said. "She's a staunch, passionate lady, and in our culture, unfortunately, there's something funny about that. There shouldn't be anything funny about that, but that tickles us for some reason. So that's what I've been working with, and her zeal is what I find delightful about her."

McKinnon isn't the only comedian with regrets that the election has been framed as a choice between a relatable buffoon and a power-hungry dynast...
Could McKinnon's portrait of Clinton actually effect the campaign? In principle, yes, it plainly could. In practice, there will almost surely be no way to tell.

That said, McKinnon—at least as presented by Weigel—shows little sign of understanding the way this dynamic might work. (For what it's worth, it seems clear that SNL's sketches after the first Bush-Gore debate did affect the subsequent conduct of the Gore campaign.)

At least as presented by Weigel, McKinnon offers a lofty, overthought analysis of what the public's reaction to her portrait "really" means. It "speaks more about our culture than it does about [Clinton]," she loftily, thoughtfully says.

It's society's fault, McKinnon says, at least as presented by Weigel. Meanwhile, the image of McKinnon discussing these topics with Maureen Dowd creates an image which will be hard to get out of our analysts' heads.

In terms of its politics, SNL has been an extremely low-IQ show almost every step of the way. In our view, writer-for-life Jim Downey is a very decent guy—you can see us jousting with him in this C-Span videotape—but his politics could hardly be more simple-minded.

At one point, Weigel says this: "Other comedy shows might get didactic; Saturday Night Live aims to mirror and parody what voters already know."

Translation: SNL aims to mirrow what voters think they know. The program deals in the dumbest forms of conventional wisdom, an obvious fact which Weigel was too professionally cautious to say.

(Similarly, there is no sign that Weigel challenged McKinnon about her airy analysis of the possible problem he is discussing. Translation: McKinnon is a major star. Weigel's a mid-level journalist.)

Could SNL effect the election? Actually, yes—it could. In his lengthy, high-profile essay, Weigel discusses an intriguing criticism which has been aimed at the low-IQ network show.

Some headline writer came along. As a journalist, he just couldn't help it.

Many Post readers will scan those headlines. Many, many fewer people will read the Weigel report.

Our kingdom for a link: At we post, Weigel's essay can't be found on the Post's web site. It's the lengthy, featured piece in this morning's Style section, the only section anyone reads. But it doesn't seem to be available to anyone but Post subscribers.

Does anyone have the slightest idea how this newspaper works?

BREAKING! The missing link: Using Google, we found this link. If you go to the Post's web site, there is no sign that this intriguing essay even exists.

On-line, the headline reflects what the article says. In this morning's hard-copy Post, the very prominent double headline turns the piece on its head.

Does anyone have any idea how this newspaper works?