THE 77 PERCENT CONFUSION: Observing a basic bone-simple distinction!

WEDNESDAY, APRIL 16, 2014

Interlude—Are journalists up to the task: How much less do women get paid for doing the same or equal work?

On a sweeping societal basis, it isn’t easy to say.

In the court case which became famous, it was fairly easy to say how less Lilly Ledbetter got paid, as compared to men in her office who held the same position. According to the Supreme Court record, Ledbetter was making $3,727 per month, while men doing the same job were being paid between $4,286 to $5,236 per month.

It isn’t obvious that this would be wrong in every imaginable case. People who hold the job title may not be equally productive.

That said, Ledbetter was being paid less than her male counterparts. But that involved just a few people working in just one office. On a sweeping societal basis, it’s hard to say how much less women get paid, on average, for doing the same or equal work.

Estimates do exist! Wikipedia (and others) will send you to a study for the Labor Department which estimates the gap to be 4.8 to 7.1 cents on the dollar for doing the same work.

In this piece for the Daily Beast, Christina Hoff Sommers said the gap narrows to five cents for doing the same work when all relevant factors are considered, “and no one knows if the five cents is a result of discrimination or some other subtle, hard-to-measure difference between male and female workers.”

At Salon, Katie McDonough has cited a 2003 GAO study which seemed to say that the gap remained at 20 cents after accounting for relevant factors. McDonough has also linked to this post, which seems to suggest that the gap is roughly 12 cents for the same or equal work.

We don’t know what the number should be! As best we can tell, it’s hard to say how much less women get paid, on average, for doing the same or equal work. Different people will have different ideas about what factors must be adjusted for. And the incomes of at least a hundred million people are involved in this analysis.

How much less do women get paid for doing the same work? It’s hard to answer that question for at least two other reasons:

As we’ve noted, our biggest news division have pretty much refused to report or analyze this important topic. And uh-oh:

Beyond that, many journalists have been unwilling or unable to observe the bone-simple distinction which lies at the heart of this question.

Two different “gender wage gaps” are in play when we tackle this question. There is the most famous gender wage gap, in which women earn just 77 cents for every dollar earned by men.

That is a real statistic. But as everyone we’ve cited agrees, it isn’t a measure of how much women get paid for doing the same or equal work. Instead, it’s a measure of total annual income for the average man and the average woman, before adjustments are made for such factors as hours worked, type of work and seniority.

As such, that famous statistic isn’t a measure of “discrimination.” It represents a total annual income gap. But as everyone on earth agrees, it isn’t a measure of lesser pay for the same work.

To measure that second “gender wage gap,” you have to make those basic adjustments, as is done in all the studies we’ve cited. Among other things, you have to adjust for hours worked, for seniority, for basic type of employment. (Almost everyone seems to agree that those basic adjustments should be made.)

We’re speaking here about a bone-simple distinction. The famous statistic—77 percent—tells us how much women earn, on average, as compared to men.

Some second statistic tells us how much women earn, on average, for doing the same or equal work. The two statistics are not the same. They measure two different things.

The distinction between those two statistics is a bone-simple distinction. But given the way our discourse works, major journalists constantly fail to observe this basic distinction.

Deliberately or through incomprehension, they wander back and forth between the two different types of measure, creating confusion wherever they go. They fail to observe that bone-simple distinction, in which we try to determine how much of the “gender wage gap” is actually due to discrimination or unequal treatment.

Can we talk? In one area after another, our public discourse is deeply unintelligent. In recent decades, there hasn’t been a topic so simple or so basic that our “press corps” was up to the task of explaining it.

That was true back in 1995, in the press corps’ pathetic attempt to clarify the year-long Medicare debate. Was the GOP proposing Medicare cuts? Or were they proposing to slow the rate at which the program would grow?

The press corps wasn’t up to the challenge of sorting that out. Today, they don’t seem to be up to the challenge of discussing the gender wage gap.

Tomorrow, we’ll offer some high-profile examples of their maddening conduct.

How much less do women get paid for doing the same or equal work? The question is important. It’s going to be discussed all year.

But in order to answer that question, we have to observe a bone-simple distinction. Are American journalists up to that task?

As always, the answer would seem to be no. Tomorrow, some cases in point.

Tomorrow: Warning! Experts at work!

67 comments:

  1. These are two different measures. Somerby suggests that everyone agrees an adjustment should be made (to equate hours worked, type of work, seniority) in order to figure out the amount attributable to discrimination. That is only true if you are focused solely on pay for the same work. But that is not the only important form of discrimination.

    When I started my work life, I applied for a job as a management trainee at a major corporation. I met all the advertised criteria. I was instead tested for and offered a job as a supervisor of a clerical work group, at a much lower salary and with very limited advancement prospects. That occurred solely because I was female. Is that discrimination? According to Somerby's criteria, everyone agrees that the type of work should be equated -- a supervisor of clerical staff should not be compared to a management trainee because they are two different types of work. So it would be entirely justified to say men and women are being paid equally. But what about the fact that I could not be considered for that higher pay job description, despite meeting the qualifications?

    This particular situation was remedied as the result of an EEOC complaint and class-action lawsuit. However, there are many other situations exactly like it that keep women out of higher paying jobs. Are these not also discrimination? Why are these routine situations being deliberately set aside, ignored, in order to focus only on "the same pay for the same work"?

    It makes me suspect that neither Somerby nor the people he is discussing are truly interested in discrimination against women in the workplace.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Don't forget this corker in trying to explain away why Lily Ledbetter, with 20 years on the job, was paid less than every man holding the same job:

      "It isn’t obvious that this would be wrong in every imaginable case. People who hold the job title may not be equally productive."

      Right, Bob. The reason women consistently make less than men -- across all occupational, education and professional lines -- is because women are less productive as a rule.

      Gee, that is so "obvious."

      Delete
    2. I'm pretty confident Somerby is interested. However, I still have the same problem with his analysis as you do.

      Even if an analysis fully accounts for all the "pay gap" does not mean that there is no discrimination. There may be sex discrimination in hours, education, occupation, promotion.

      Obviously, we'd like to know how much of the gap is due to discrimination in wages, and "77 cents" is not necessarily the right figure.

      On the other hand, we also do not know that equal pay for equal hours, education, etc, means equal pay for equal work. It could be that women with similar hours, education, seniority, etc. are more productive than their male counterparts because they have to prove themselves in order to overcome these other forms of discrimination.

      That means even the "Pay Act" may not solve the problem of pay discrimination, let alone all such discrimination. But we might expect it to address 5-12 cents worth of the 77-- whether pay discrimination truly accounts for 2 cents or 50 cents on the dollar.

      Point is, workers should have access to information which may point to discrimination, but also people need be more careful about using either the "77 cents" or the "5 cents" and in either case take more care when connecting it to the "Pay Act"

      Delete
  2. 11:30 - Somerby may not be truly interested. But he is discussing the liberal press corps here - not the discrimination issue.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. How can anyone read this post and say, with a straight face, that all the minimizing, explaining away, even about the Ledbetter case, is only about the "liberal press" and not about discrimination.

      Delete
    2. You have to take away your preconceived notions and think about it.

      Delete
    3. Good advice for Somerby to, as he tries to minimize the Ledbetter case to "just a few people working in just one office."

      What kind of "preconceived notion" could possibly lead anyone to say something that stupid?

      Perhaps Maddow Derangement Syndrome?

      Delete
    4. Hi 12:27. I read it as him comparing "just a few people working in just one office." to all of society. The 77 cent number is used to discuss the press corps reaction to the macro level problem.

      Delete
    5. Do you also think that the Lily Ledbetter case was so isolated as the Congressional action it took to give women access to legal remedies was not required?

      After all, that's what Bob "seems" to say when he says it was "just a few people working in just one office".

      Delete
    6. Hi again - no I don't think that.

      Delete
    7. Bob seems to think so. After all, it was "just a few people working in one office" and "it was hard to say" if it were occurring on a "sweeping societal basis."

      Delete
    8. You clearly can't comprehend what you read, 3:26. Whether you are male or female, that poor reading comprehension will hold you back.

      Or else you're just a bullshit artist. In which case, keep up the good work!

      Delete
    9. And here comes the well-worn "poor reading comprehension" insult.

      I guess you, like your Master, are unable to come up with new schtick.

      Delete
    10. The case itself manifestly was about only a few people. To observe this does not minimize the case, or its impact. One requires no master to see this. You have an axe to grind.

      And you can't read well. May be an old shoe, but it fits you.

      Delete
    11. That's like saying the next mass shooting itself manifestly will be about only a few people -- the shooter and his victims.

      If you truly think the Ledbetter Act was only about Lily and her 15 male co-workers with the same job at higher pay, then you've lost your ability to think.

      Delete
  3. Here are some important facts about the Lilly Ledbetter case that Bob disappears and minimizes because "that involved a few people working in one office."

    Lily Ledbetter was one of 16 Goodyear "area managers." The other 15 were men. She made less than all 15 men -- substantially less -- despite the fact she had been doing that job for nearly 20 years, and many of those men had far less seniority.

    She only discovered that years later. She sued under the 1963 Equal Pay Act. Her case was dismissed because she didn't file it within 180 days of received her first paycheck. She filed suit only after she learned about the pay disparity.

    That's why we have the Lily Ledbetter act to remove that statute of limitations and makes it possible for women to sue when they find out that their pay is less because they are women.

    Does Somerby object to that?

    Also, this whole "wage gap" debate is raging over the proposed Paycheck Fairness Act which also would close some loopholes in the 1963 law. It is now stuck in the Senate on party-line votes and unable to break the Republican filibuster and get it to the floor.

    What is Bob's position on that bill? Unnecessary, perhaps, because his shrewd analysis which closely mirrors Republican talking points, shows that the problem isn't really all that bad, and that women are being discriminated against only a little bit?

    Of course, Bob's few fans will now rush to his defense and say it is not the shrewd media analyst's job to say whether he favors policy changes that will close the gap between the earnings of men and women.

    Nope, it is his job only to bitch and moan about Rachel Maddow and how she is deceiving America with all this "unequal pay for equal work" shinola, even if that means becoming a part of right-wing echo chamber and dutifully repeating all the talking points because he can't think up any new ones on his own.



    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Perhaps if you're trying to convince people on an issue, lying about its nature isn't the best approach.

      But carry on.

      Delete
    2. Matt, instead of swallowing the right-wing talking points Somerby is feeding you, try to do some independent research to learn the truth before you accuse anyone of lying.

      You won't wind up looking like such a toady. And who knows? You might even learn something.

      Delete
    3. "That's why we have the Lily Ledbetter act to remove that statute of limitations and makes it possible for women to sue when they find out that their pay is less because they are women."

      "Does Somerby object to that?"

      There's certainly no reason to suppose so on the evidence in today's commentary, no.

      Delete
    4. There is no reason to "suppose" that he supports the Ledbetter Act or the pending Paycheck Fairness Act which is at the root of the renewed discussion on gender pay inequity.

      In fact, in his seal to minimize the gap and explain it away, he uses the exact same arguments as those who vigorously oppose both the Ledbetter Act and the Paycheck Fairness Act.

      Delete
  4. Great analysis, Bob. I can use this for class, crediting you of course.

    AJ

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, your poor students!

      I got a better idea, professor. Instead of pulling material off blogs, how about having your students research this issue themselves?

      Delete
    2. What makes you think he isn't the student?

      Delete
    3. Good point. Now I pity the poor student who cites Somerby as a source for anything.

      Delete
  5. Anon @ 11:39 Can we talk?

    You are demonstrating a mastery of the lessons here from the OTB at TDH. You write:

    "he is discussing the liberal press corps here."

    We note, and others may as well, that BOB never used the word "liberal" in this post. Alas, not once!

    That means in your reading, he implied the journalists to whom he was referring were part of the "liberal press corps." This is excellent. Reading words that are not there, determining the implication in your own mind, then writing something as if those words are clear to all is exactly the technique which is a hallmark of BOBism. It can be seen clearly throughout his stellar work on this very topic of the gender wage gap.

    However, you miss a bone simple distinction necessary to be a faithful follower of BOBism. You must, before incanting nonexistent words or phrases, use a Magical Modifier. These are considered magical because they cover your posterior from accusations you are, dare we use the term, prevaricating.

    We have already used one, "implied". Others might be "suggested" "seems" or "inferred." If you want to get to a higher level "clearly" can be added to any of the magical modifiers.

    Example: BOB seems to be tired of getting his hindquarters kicked on the substance of the issue of the gender pay gap, so he wrote a transition post suggesting he will cover that bruised posterior in an effort to divert attention back to his favorite target, the press corps, which he and others often imply is liberal.

    KZ

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good point. I shouldn't have said liberal. He is covering the "mainstream press corps" here and the American discourse.

      Delete
    2. You must go to confessional, young commenter! BOBists never admit error or doubt in their faith in magical implications.

      KZ

      Delete
    3. Can I play the Bob game, too?

      Bob "seems" to "imply" that he opposes the Paycheck Fairness Act that can't seem to break the Republican filibuster because he recites all of the opposing "analysis" of it, and dismisses all arguments in favor out of hand.

      But we don't know. He won't say. That is because he is uniquely positioned as a "liberal" to tell the "liberal" press what not to say, even if his own brilliant analysis is nothing more than regurgitating everything said on Fox News or Rush Limbaugh's show about the bill.

      Delete
    4. Except, of course, that Bob certainly "seems" to have narrowed his definition of "mainstream press" he pays attention to in rather extreme fashion.

      Delete
  6. Once again, Vice President Al Gore, April 3, 1998: "It is not merely a matter of women with the same positions as men getting lower pay, it is also a matter of women with the same merit as men getting lower positions. Women in almost all types of jobs make less than men."

    Bob started this blog two days earlier, and there is no indication of him saying anything about his old roomie's comments about equal pay and opportunity for women.

    But of course, he may have been distracted in those earliest days by all the thoughts running through his head.

    So during the campaign of 2000, Gore frequently repeated his concern for the inequality of earnings between men and women, even citing the then true, "73 percent gap" in his campaign literature.

    Again, crickets chirping on TDH.

    But then again, that was years before the Rachel Maddow Show debuted.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Was that a big issue in the media then?

      Why are you trolls incapable of grasping that?

      Delete
    2. Yes, as a matter of fact, equal pay for women was a big issue then in the media. I got the 1998 Gore quote off CNN.

      But explain this, in addition to going after Maddow, et al, Bob also went after Obama and what he said in the State of the Union address, going so far as to take his words out of all context and accuse him of "misleading" the people.

      Then he also accused Democrats of using this issue solely to pander to women voters.

      Now if he were truly limiting himself to "media" criticism why would he have anything at all to say about Obama, or what the Democratic Party motives are?

      While of course, ignoring that his ol' college roomie was saying the same things years ago?

      Delete
    3. The crickets always chirp here when The Howler commits a howler of his own -- such as this bone-simple contradiction you have identified a few times. Doesn't exactly do wonders for credibility.

      Delete
    4. So when did Bob first start howling about the "gender wage gap" and that "misleading" but true, statistic? Before or after Rachel Maddow took to the air?

      Delete
    5. Go to his search engines here an at the Incomparaable Archives.

      Delete
    6. I did. Found nothing when Al Gore was citing a misleading statistic and using it to pander to women voters.

      In fact, can't find anything about "gender wage gap" until recently, when Maddow started in on it.

      Of course, the statistic Gore cited then is misleading now, when Maddow cites it.

      Delete
    7. Did Gore say that the "73 cents" was due to discrimination in pay? Quite plainly, your quote says the opposite-- that it was also a matter of women getting "lower positions." That is, he explicitly pointed out the kind of thing that gets controlled for in these 5-12 cent studies.

      In other words, Gore did provide exactly the kind of context for his figure that Somerby would like to see provided by others. So why should Somerby have "howled" at Gore?

      Delete
    8. And, of course, women getting "lower positions" can't possibly be a matter of discrimination, can it?

      Delete
    9. With whom are you arguing, exactly?

      Delete
  7. Matt, when did you first learn the word "troll" in the blogging context, and what do you think it means?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Can one of the Usual Trolls take a guess, ul?

      Delete

  8. THIS IS HOW MY RELATIONSHIP WAS SAVED BY DR BRAVE !


    Hello to every one out here, am here to shear my unexpected miracle that has happen to me three days ago,My name is Mrs Judith Thompson am from USA,Florida. i want to use this opportunity to thank my great doctor who really made my life a pleasurable one today. This great man DR.Brave brought my husband back to me, i had three lovely kids for my husband, about four years ago i and my husband has been into one quarrel or the other until he finally left me for one lady. i felt my life was over and my kids thought they would never see their father again. i tried to be strong just for the kids but i could not control the pains that torments my heart, my heart was filled with sorrows and pains because i was really in love with my husband. Every day and night i think of him and always wish he would come back to me, until one day i met a good friend of mine that was also in a situation like me but her problem was her ex-boyfriend who she had an unwanted pregnancy for and he refused to take responsibility and dumped her. she told me that mine was a small case and that i should not worry about it at all, so i asked her what was the solution to my problems and she gave me this great man email address. i was doubting if this man was the solution, so i contacted this great man and he told me what to do and i deed them all, he told me to wait for just two day and that my husband will come crawling on his kneels just for forgiveness so i faithfully deed what this great man asked me to do and for sure after two days i heard a knock on the door, in a great surprise i saw him on his kneels and i was speechless, when he saw me, all he did was crying and asking me for forgiveness, from that day, all the pains and sorrows in my heart flew away,since then i and my husband and our lovely kids are happy.that's why i want to say a big thank you to DR.Brave spiritual temple. This great man made me to understand that there is no problem on earth that has no solution so please if you know that you have this same problem or any problem that is similar, i will advise you to come straight to this great man. you can email him at:bravespellcaster@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. Great post! I am impresed to read your blog It takes me almost half an hour to read the whole post. Definitely this one of the informative and useful post to me. Thanks for the share. you also visit my site  Affordable Accountant At intouchaccountants We are dedicated to providing a professional yet affordable and efficient service to small and medium sized business.

    ReplyDelete
  10. My Name is Susan williams, From United States. I wish to share my testimonies with the general public about what this man called Dr Dahiru has just done for me, this man has just brought back my lost Ex husband to me with his great prayers, I was married to this man called williams we were together for a long time and we loved our self's but when I was unable to give him a child for 2 years he left me and told me he can't continue anymore then I was now looking for ways to get him back until a friend of mine told me about this man and gave his contact email, then you won't believe this when I contacted this man on my problems he prayed and bring my lost husband back, and after a month I miss my month and go for a test and the result stated am pregnant am happy today am a mother of a baby girl, thank you once again the great Dr Dahiru at arewaspecialisttemple@yahoo.com for what you have done for me, if you are out there passing through any of this problems listed below: (1) If you want your ex back. (2) if you always have bad dreams. (3) You want to be promoted in your office. (4) You want women/men to run after you. (5) If you want a child. (6) You want to be rich. (7) You want to tie your husband/wife to be yours forever. (8) If you need financial assistance. (9) How you been scammed and you want to recover you lost money (10) Cure for HIV - you can contact him via: email: arewaspecialisttemple@yahoo.com

    ReplyDelete
  11. I am Victoria, I promise to share this testimony all over the world once my boyfriend return back to me, and today with all due respect i want to thank DR.ATILA for bringing joy and happiness to my relationship and my family. I want to inform you all that there is a spell caster that is real and genuine. I never believed in any of these things until i loosed my boyfriend, I required help until i found a grate spell caster, And he cast a love spell for me, and he assured me that I will get my boyfriend back in two days after the spell has been cast. two days later, my phone rang, and so shockingly, it was my boyfriend who has not called me for past 4 years now, and made an apology for the heart break, and told me that he is ready to be my back bone till the rest of his life with me. DR.ATILA released him up to know how much i loved and wanted him. And opened his eyes to picture how much we have share together. As I`m writing this testimony right now I`m the most happiest girl on earth and me and my boyfriend is living a happy life and our love is now stronger than how it were even before our break up. So that`s why I promised to share my testimony all over the universe.All thanks goes to DR.ATILA for the excessive work that he has done for me. Below is the email address in any situation you are undergoing a heart break, and I assure you that as he has done mine for me, he will definitely help you too. that is his email address atilahealinghome@yahoo.com

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thank you for sharing valuable information. Nice post. I enjoyed reading this post. The whole blog is very nice found some good stuff and good information here Thanks..Also visit my page  Affordable Accountant Intouch Accountants aims to provide an affordable, timely, clear and concise accounting service for small and medium businesses.

    ReplyDelete
  13. BE CAREFUL HERE NOBODY CAN HELP YOU HERE OR EVEN SUGGEST HOW YOU CAN GET YOUR EX OR LOVE BACK,ANY TESTIMONIES OF MOST SPELL CASTER HERE MUST BE IGNORE.BECAUSE MOST OF THEM ARE SCAM I MEAN REAL SCAM WHICH I WAS A VICTIM AND I GOT RIPPED OF THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS BECAUSE I WAS SO ANXIOUS TO GET MY WIFE BACK AFTER SHE LEFT ME FOR OVER 2 YEARS WITH MY 7 YEARS OLD SON JERRY,I HAVE APPLIED TO 7 DIFFERENT SPELL CASTER HERE AND ALL TO NO AVAIL THEY ALL ASK FOR SAME THING SEND YOUR NAME YOUR EX NAME ADDRESS AND PICTURE PHONE NUMBER ETC WHICH I DID OVER AND OVER AGAIN AND MOST OF THEM WERE FROM WEST AFRICA UNTIL ISAW A POST ABOUT MAMA ANITA SPELL AND I DECIDED TO GAVE HER MY LAST TRAIL.SHE ASK ME FOUR THINGS MY REAL NAME,MY EX AND MY EX MOTHER NAME AND $180 AND SAID MY EX WILL COME BACK IN 24HOURS, I HAVE PAID OVER $3000 ON SPELL CASTING AND COURIER AND NOTHING HAVE WORK FOR ME AFTER 3 DAYS I WAS THINKING ABOUT HOW MUCH I HAVE LOST SO FAR SO I SAID LET ME GIVE HER A TRY SO I CALLED HER AGAIN AND SEND MY REAL NAME,MY EX AND MY EX MOTHER NAME AND THE $180 BECAUSE I SWEAR IT WAS MY LAST TRY SO I WAS WAITING AS SHE TOLD ME TO WAIT TILL NEXT DAY AND I COULD NOT SLEEP THAT NIGHT BECAUSE I REALLY LOVE MY WIFE AND WANT HER BACK AT 9PM THAT DAY I SAW MY WIFE ON LINE ON FACE BOOK AND SHE SAID HI AT FIRST I WAS SHOCK BECAUSE SHE NEVER TALK WITH ME FOR THE PAST A YEAR AND 9 MONTH NOW I DID NOT REPLY AGAIN SHE SAID ARE YOU THERE? I QUICKLY REPLY YES AND SHE SAID CAN WE SEE TOMORROW I SAID YES AND SHE WENT OFF-LINE I WAS CONFUSED I TRY TO CHAT HER AGAIN BUT SHE WAS NO MORE ON LINE I COULD NOT SLEEP THAT NIGHT AS I WAS WONDERING WHAT SHE IS GOING TO SAY, BY 7.AM THE NEXT MORNING SHE GAVE ME A MISS CALL I DECIDED NOT TO CALL BACK AS I WAS STILL ON SHOCK AGAIN SHE CALL AND I PICK SHE SAID CAN WE SEE AFTER WORK TODAY I SAID YES SO SHE END THE CALL IMMEDIATELY I GOT OFF WORK SHE CALL ME AND WE MEET AND NOW WE ARE BACK AGAIN I CALL MAMA ANITA THE NEXT DAY THANKING HER FOR WHAT SHE HAS DONE IN FACT I STILL CALL HER AND THANK HER AS MY LIFE WAS NOT COMPLETE WITHOUT MY WIFE PLEASE BE CAREFUL HERE I HAVE BEEN SCAM THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS IF YOU WANT A TRUE LOVE SPELL THEN CONTACT MAMA ANITA (mama.anitatruelovespell@gmail.com)

    ReplyDelete
  14. My name is Maria and i want to testify of the good work done by a faithful Dr Osoba, a spell caster. in my life i never thought there is such thing as spiritual intercession. my problem started nine months back when the father of my kids started putting up some strange behavior, i never knew he was having an affair outside our matrimonial home. it dawn on me on that faithful day 19th of july 21st 4:23pm when he came to the house to pick his things that was when i knew that situation has gotten out of hand and he then told me he was quitting the marriage which i have built for over five years, i was confused and dumbfounded i called on family and friends but to no avail. two months after i started having problem with my kids welfare rent-age and all of it, i really went through hell. until a day i was browsing on the internet and i happen to meet a spell caster i never believed on this but i needed my man back so i gave the spell caster my problem at first i never trusted him so i was just doing it but you know a problem shared is half solved after a week my husband called me telling me that he his coming back home and that was all. now we are living happily and i still do contact him on this email: osobaspelltemple@yahoo.com

    Contact him via email:osobaspelltemple@yahoo.com

    THANKS,
    MARIA

    ReplyDelete
  15. My name is Camille bruno Valdez my partner and I have been trying for a baby for over two years now, We were going to a fertility clinic for about 5 months before somebody told us to contact this spell caster who is so powerful, We contacted him at this email; arewaspecialistttemple@gmail.com , for him to help us, then we told him our problem, he told us that we will either conceive in February 2014 or March 2014,but after two years of trying we were at a point where we were willing to try anything. And I'm glad we came to Dr Dahiru, Because his pregnancy spell cast put us at ease, and I honestly believe him, and his gods really helped us as well, I am thankful for all he has done. contact him via email: arewaspecialistttemple@gmail.com if you are trying to get a baby or want your lover back. he has powers to do it, he has done mine, you can as well add him on facebook (Drdahiru Arewa) To enable you have a taste of his nice work too.

    ReplyDelete
  16. My name is Mr Cardenas,my wife was having affair with a senior secretary in her office. I love this woman so much that i would not want to share her with any body. i told her to retire from the job and i would take care of all her needs but she would take it because she is been embraced by everybody in her office, this normally leads to quarrel every-time. i tried all i can to please her and she will promise to be good , some days later she will turn back to her normal way.
    i was nearly loosing out, i could not focus in my job, my whole life was full of sorrow and i was thinking i should kill the other man my self and put an end to all this until i saw a testimony from a blog on how DR EDIONWE could cast a love spell to bring lovers back no matter what is behind the disappointment. so i decided to write him via email. edionwesolutiontemple@yahoo.com and now all my wishes are exactly as i wanted. She told me everything that has happened secretly in the past and i forgave her as DR EDIONWE instructed me to and she loves me and care for me as i ever wanted. i know there are many spells that do not work but i want to assure all you out there no matter what you have been trough to have faith and believe that this is the final solution to your problem.
    Even if my job is taking most of my time, the little free time i have , i will share the good news to everyone in the world because i know that with love brings happiness and hope for a long life.

    ReplyDelete
  17. My name is Camille bruno Valdez my partner and I have been trying for a baby for over two years now, We were going to a fertility clinic for about 5 months before somebody told us to contact this spell caster who is so powerful, We contacted him at this email; arewaspecialistttemple@gmail.com , for him to help us, then we told him our problem, he told us that we will either conceive in February 2014 or March 2014,but after two years of trying we were at a point where we were willing to try anything. And I'm glad we came to Dr Dahiru, Because his pregnancy spell cast put us at ease, and I honestly believe him, and his gods really helped us as well, I am thankful for all he has done. contact him via email: arewaspecialistttemple@gmail.com if you are trying to get a baby or want your lover back. he has powers to do it, he has done mine,

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hello to you all here, i am Kisten Wilson. and i here to share to you all my testimony about this man called Dr ABULU , last year i got married to my husband Wilson Jefferson and we both have a body so we were both living happily together ever since we got married until early this year when my husband traveled to Australia for business trip and he told me and kid that he will be coming in two months time and he left , it was just 2 weeks when my husband stoped calling me and the kid so i was suprise and i started to wonder what is wrong until i heard that he is with a lady there and he was even planing to marry her and push me and my child out so i reported to his family but they could not stop him this time he has send me message to live the house before he return so i was so confused and do not know what to do so a friend of my mummy directed me to this man DR ABULU of abuluspiritualtemple@gmail.com, for help and solution and i quickly rush to contact him through his mail and he told me what to do and i did it and after two days mu husband called me and started begging me to forgive and forget all that he must have done to be that he was not his self so that is how i manage to save my relationship so with this great work done for me by DR ABULU i promised to share this to the world in-case any one is there with similar problems should contact him as well for solution and i know you must be saved okay
    email;abuluspiritualtemple@gmail.com
    website;abuluspiritualtemple.webs.com
    KIRSTEN WILSON

    ReplyDelete
  19. Hello my name is Andrea from canada My life is back!!! After 5years of marriage, my husband left me and left me with our two kids. I felt like my life was about to end, and was falling apart. I contacted Dr. ABULU on his email: abuluspiritualtemple@gmail.com and after I explained to him all my problem. In just 2days, my husband came back to us and show me and my kids much love and apologize for all the pain he have bring to the family. We solved our issues, and we are even happier than before you are the best spell caster Dr. ABULU, i really appreciate the love spell you castes for me to get the man i ever loved back to my life i will keep sharing more testimonies to people about your good work Thank you once again in case you are in any problem you can contact this man for help he is always there in his temple to help you solve your problem

    ReplyDelete
  20. Am Stella Robeson From London few days ago, so i emailed PROPHET AMEDE about my bad relationship condition, how my lover left me, how he was with another girl, so PROPHET AMEDE told me it would take 3 days to get my boyfriend back, i waited for 3 days, unbelievable my boyfriend came to my house asking me if we could try things out again. He broke up with the other girl and we rekindled and got back together, he now show me care and attention. PROPHET AMEDE was my last hope, my last chance after all the spell casters I tried before,PROPHET AMEDE kept his promise! he is the greatest spell caster on the internet, His email is{ amedehealingtemple@yahoo.com}

    ReplyDelete
  21. I want to share a great testimony on this website on how great Priest Babaka help me in falling pregnant,me and my husband have been trying to have a baby for over 4years,but they where no luck so we decided to contact the family doctor and after all the test have been done,he said to us that my fallopian tube is not functioning.then one day i was in the office when a friend of mine who have the same problem with me, fall pregnant after she contacted Priest Babaka .she directed me to him and when i contacted him through his email and he did the purification on the pregnancy spell and in 2weeks time i was feeling some how and i went to meet the family doctor who told me that i am pregnant.if you know that you have a similar problem like this, or any fertility issue and you want to be pregnant you can contact Priest Babaka via Email:babaka.wolf@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  22. Useful information.I am actual blessed to read this article.thanks for giving us this advantageous information.I acknowledge this post.and I would like bookmark this post.Thanks
    mahjong connect |geometry dash pc|agar.io hulk games |pacman games my little pony games | sniper games

    ReplyDelete
  23. Very good write-up. I certainly love this site. Keep writing!
    this blog is really helpful. i found very interesting things here.
    - minecraft games
    - happy wheels
    - happy wheels
    - tetris
    - brain games
    - puzzle games
    - agario hi
    - abcya
    - fnaf 4

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thanks for sharing the information. It is very useful for my future. keep sharing. Can you play more games at :
    red ball 4 | hola launcher | cooking fever | paradise bay | agario

    ReplyDelete
  25. Nice information. Thanks for sharing this article. It helps me much :) Please keep sharing us the latest information
    Signature:
    messenger indir | messenger download |messenger indir | messenger | messenger indir | download messenger | messenger indir | messenger indir

    ReplyDelete
  26. Great stuff. This is really a fascinating blog, lots of stuff that I can Get into. One thing I just want to say is that your Blog is so perfect!

    swords and souls 2 | subway surfers download | goodgame big farm | ninjago games | strike force

    kitty 2
    | agario

    ReplyDelete
  27. Very helpful advice in this particular post! It’s the little changes that make the largest changes. Thanks for sharing!
    swords and souls game | ninjago games | hola launcher | agario | cooking fever | goodgame big farm | red ball 4 | agar io | subway surfers | paradise bay | strike force kitty 2

    ReplyDelete
  28. Great stuff. This is really a fascinating blog, lots of stuff that I can Get into. One thing I just want to say is that your Blog is so perfect!
    run 2 game | slither.io | atari breakout

    ReplyDelete
  29. I would like more information about this, because it is very nice., Thanks for sharing.
    red ball 4 | ninjago games | swords and souls | strike force kitty 2 | run 2 | slitherio | wings.io | atari breakout

    ReplyDelete
  30. i am giving this testimony cos l am happy My name is mrs. Lara Mark from Houston,taxes.i never believed in love spells or magic until i met this spell caster once. when i went to Africa in July this year on a business summit. i ment a man called dr. UKO.He is powerful he could help you cast a spells to bring back my love’s gone,misbehaving lover looking for some one to love you, bring back lost money and magic money spell or spell for a good job.i’m now happy & a living testimony cos the man i had wanted to marry left me 3 weeks before our wedding and my life was upside down cos our relationship has been on for 2 years… i really loved him, but his mother was against me and he had no good paying job. so when i met this spell caster, i told him what happened and explained the situation of things to him..at first i was undecided,skeptical and doubtful, but i just gave it a try. and in 6 days when i returned to taxes, my boyfriend (is now my husband ) he called me by himself and came to me apologizing that everything had been settled with his mom and family and he got a new job interview so we should get married..i didn’t believe it cos the spell caster only asked for my name and my boyfriends name and all i wanted him to do… well we are happily married now and we are expecting our little kid,and my husband also got a new job and our lives became much better. in case anyone needs the spell caster for some help, email address ukospelltemple@yahoo.com Great UKO i thank you very much thank you in 1000000 times.. if not you i would have been losted and wasted thank you. please make sure you contact him for any financial difficulties okay.. What a powerful man such as Dr UKO.. he is so much powerful..\\ email him for any difficulties.. ukospelltemple@yahoo.com or his website: ukospelltemple.wixsite.com/mysite

    ReplyDelete