MONDAY, APRIL 21, 2025
Last Friday, here's what he did: Way back when, in July 2020, Mary Trump published a big, beautiful book.
At the time, she was largely unknown. Her book became a major bestseller. Here's the thumbnail from Simon & Schuster:
Too Much and Never Enough:
How My Family Created the World's Most Dangerous Man
By Mary L. Trump
About The Book
In this revelatory, authoritative portrait of Donald J. Trump and the toxic family that made him, Mary L. Trump, a trained clinical psychologist and Donald’s only niece, shines a bright light on the dark history of their family in order to explain how her uncle became the man who now threatens the world’s health, economic security, and social fabric.
Mary Trump spent much of her childhood in her grandparents’ large, imposing house in the heart of Queens...
The overview continues from there. On the cover of our copy of the book, the author is presented as "Mary L. Trump, Ph.D," presumably to stress her background as a clinical psychologist.
(Also, that presentation distinguishes her from another woman named Mary Trump. We refer to President Trump's late mother, a major figure in her granddaughter's best-selling book.)
Could Simon and Schuster end up in CECOT this year? At present, experts aren't sure! That said, Mary Trump's book spent at least thirteen weeks on the New York Times' best-seller list, but only after debuting in the blockbuster manner described below:
Mary Trump’s tell-all memoir sells 1.35 million copies in blockbuster first week
A tell-all memoir by President Donald Trump’s niece—who claims he has world-endangering emotional problems stemming from childhood trauma inflicted by his parents—has sold 1.35 million copies in its first week, according to publisher Simon & Schuster.
Mary Trump’s “Too Much and Never Enough: How My Family Created the World’s Most Dangerous Man” is in its 17th printing, the publisher said Thursday...The sales figure, which includes all formats, puts the book on track to being one of the most popular books of the year.
Too Much and Never Enough was a "tell-all memoir," according to that report by CNBC. According to Simon & Schuster, it was "a revelatory, authoritative portrait" of President Trump and his family.
However you want to teach it, the book's Part One is laid out in this way in its Table of Contents,
PART ONE: THE CRUELTY IS THE POINT
CHAPTER 1: The House
CHAPTER 2: The First Son
CHAPTER 3: The Great I-Am
CHAPTER 4: Expecting to Fly
Chapter 3 is called "The Great I-Am." That refers to a nickname Mary Trump's father, the late Freddy Trump, once gave his younger brother, today's American president.
(In the book, Mary Trump refers to her father as Freddy. This helps distinguish him from Fred Trump, the president's father, but also from Frederick Trump, Mary Trump's brother, who she refers to as Fritz.)
Freddy Trump was, in fact, the "First Son" of Chapter 2. He was eight years older than his brother Donald. He bestowed the nickname on his younger brother when the latter was something like 11 or 12 years old.
We'll offer more detail as the week proceeds. For now, here's the key paragraph:
CHAPTER THREE
The Great I-Am
[...]
Encouraged by his father, Donald eventually started to believe his own hype. By the time he was twelve, the right side of his mouth was curled up in an almost perpetual sneer of self-conscious superiority, and Freddy had dubbed him “the Great I-Am,” echoing a passage from Exodus he’d learned in Sunday school in which God first reveals himself to Moses.
If accurate, that's a description of a growing misfortune manifesting itself in the life of a child. In this book's account, it started when the child's mother suffered an extremely serious medical incident when he was just two years old.
In her book, Mary Trump is able to pity that child, even as she voices something like contempt for the adult he became. In our view, that's one of the great strengths of her book—her ability to pity the child, even as she says that the child developed into "the world's most dangerous person."
With respect to that childhood nickname—with respect to "The Great I-Am"—can such accounts be trusted from an author who wasn't actually present on the scene at the time?
Early on, Mary Trump outlines the various sources on whom she draws for her accounts of this important family's history. Along the way, she was apparently told—possibly by her aunt Maryanne, the current president's older sister, now deceased—about "The Great I-Am."
For the record. something else happened to the young Donald Trump "by the time he was twelve." At the start of eighth grade, he was renditioned to the New York Military Academy, a boarding school sixty miles from his home, because he'd become "uncontrollable" at the private school in Queens he'd attended up to that point.
For the record, these is no doubt about the fact that the president was sent to NYMA at the start of eighth grade, or about the fact that he stayed there through his high school graduation.
There is no doubt that he was sent to NYMA by his domineering father. As the week proceeds, we'll show you Mary Trump's account of the background to that decision.
For better or worse, "The Great I-Am" was sent to what his siblings ridiculed as a "reform school." In Mary Trump's telling, this seems to have involved the start of a set of "psychopathologies" which, she says, remained on vivid public display during her uncle's first term in the White House.
Mary Trump is, in fact, a trained clinical psychologist, the holder of a doctorate. Obviously, the fact that she made certain assessments of her uncle doesn't mean that those assessment were automatically accurate, true or correct.
That said, consider what happened last Friday night with respect to the ruler in question. The incident's reverberations will be widely felt, but do any of Blue America's "well-adjusted" leaders care?
Last Friday night, her uncle may have engaged in one of his most remarkable acts of public deception to date. Or was he simply telling the truth?
We aren't in position to tell you. That said, also this:
As the American experiment may perhaps be coming undone, does anyone possess the intellectual skill and the moral commitment which might allow us the people to know what's true? For that matter, to what extent do Blue elites actually seem to care?
Human history includes many stories of conquest by the planet's most powerful rulers:
Starting around the year 1206, Genghis Khan "united the tribes." Almost a thousand years before that, Alexander the Great is said to have wept when he came to believe that he had "no more worlds to conquer."
Alexander died at age 32. There seems to be no evidence he actually made some such statement
Last Friday night, "the most dangerous person in the world" made his latest somewhat odd presentation. At issue was the question currently roiling the two American nations:
Was Kilmar Abrego Garcia ever a member of the criminal gang, MS-13? Is he some such affiliate even today?
There "The Great I-Am" now sat. situated in the White House. He displayed an apparent photograph of some person's left hand. As you can see by clicking this link, he offered this post on X:
Donald J. Trump
@realDonaldTrump
This is the hand of the man that the Democrats feel should be brought back to the United States, because he is such “a fine and innocent person.” They said he is not a member of MS-13, even though he’s got MS-13 tattooed onto his knuckles, and two Highly Respected Courts found that he was a member of MS-13, beat up his wife, etc. I was elected to take bad people out of the United States, among other things. I must be allowed to do my job. MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN!
The president was offering talk from the hand! According to the sitting president, the detainee in question has the letters and numbers "M S 1 3" tattooed right there on his knuckles!
There it was, for all to see! Apparently, no one had noticed!
A second post followed, from the generic White House account. It showed the same photo and reposted the president's text. Also, this White House post said this:
The White House
@WhiteHouse
If it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck
The text was so snarky it could have been written by President Bukele himself! According to this second post, the detainee in question quacks like an MS-13 gang member—or at least, he "probably" does.
Starting with the employees of the Fox News Channel, this new claim has been spread all across Red America since last Friday night. Almost three days later, major news orgs from Blue America have almost completely averted their gaze.
Nothing to look at, their three days of silence seem to have said. Let's talk about Hegseth instead!
Some bloggers quickly said that this alleged photograph of the hand had, in fact, been doctored. As of Saturday, New York magazine's Chas Danner had explicitly said the photograph was doctored, though his post was weirdly buried in such a way as to limit its exposure.
Elsewhere, Blue America sat silent. The Great I-Am had spread it around, and the great news orgs of our own Blue America had continued to take a gigantic pass with respect to the fairly obvious fact that something is wrong with this person.
Over time, every great ruler's giant empire has eventually come to an end. Is this latest incident one more episode in a related matter? Is it merely the latest way a certain human experiment is possibly coming undone?
More specifically, is that photograph actually real? Red America is being told that it is. To date, the major elites of Blue America have apparently—once again—chosen to turn tail and run.
For ourselves, we can't answer that question with certainty. Of course, it's possible be that fact-checking will eventually appear among Blue American troops.
That said, when he was maybe eleven years old, his older brother apparently mocked him as "The Great I-Am." Today, he sits in the White House, where, last Friday evening, he went ahead and offered a bit of talk from the hand.
He still claims he won the 2020 election. He would like to send "homegrowns" down south. He also claims he has a photograph of a certain detainee's hand.
Is it real, or it is just the latest "error?" Red America is being told that it's real. As has happened again and again, everyone else in this failing nation has been left by the side of the road.
Nothing to look at, our big orgs have said. The greatest rulers in human history have long said the darnedest things!
Tomorrow: More on this "BREAKING NEWS" allegation, which is now three days old...
There's more care in vetting who goes out than vetting who comes in. Which error is bigger?
ReplyDeleteborder czar Tom Homan tore into Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.) for prioritizing a suspected MS-13 gang member over the countless American victims of illegal immigration. Homan’s comments came in response to Van Hollen’s trip to El Salvador, where the senator met with Kilmar Abrego Garcia, an alleged MS-13 member, wife-beater, and human trafficker recently deported by the Trump administration.
“What bothers me more than that is a U.S. senator traveled to El Salvador on taxpayer dime to meet with a MS-13 gang member, public safety threat, terrorist,” Homan said. “And in the meantime, the day before he traveled, an illegal alien was arrested for murder, released to the streets rather than honoring an ICE detainer in his very own state.”
Homan didn’t stop there. He slammed Van Hollen for turning a blind eye to the border crisis throughout Joe Biden’s presidency.
Another Hegseth f*ckup:
ReplyDeleteHegseth shared attack plans in Signal chat including wife, brother, personal lawyer
“Let's talk about Hegseth instead!”
ReplyDeleteHegseth needs to be discussed in addition to the photograph.
Simon’s daughter Carly is a great singer-songwriter.
ReplyDeleteYou probably think you can see clouds in your coffee too, ugh you're so vain.
DeleteNobody does it better than.
DeleteCarly Simon is not related to Paul Simon.
DeleteGood catch Bob on the propagandistic weasel word from the Trump administration: "probably".
ReplyDeletelikely
possibly
probably
could have
may have
suggests
suggest
appears to
alleges
indicates
signals
Billions of dollars or more every year is dedicated to manipulating the public and keeping them divided through the written word using these tactics.
Anonymouse 11:49am, Somerby is doubtlessly well aware of weasel words. Anonymices routinely use them via their backhanded efforts to indict him for something or another.
DeleteCecelia, stay out of this, you idiot.
DeleteAnonymouse 12:15pm, when you go to a private board or take it to an email chain, I’ll have to. But not until then…
DeleteCecelia will pretend to be a woman as long as he can elicit responses here.
DeleteWhy do you pretend to be human? Everyone knows you're a bot.
DeleteGenghis Khan ( c 1162 - 1227 ) came along more than, not “almost”, a thousand years after Alexander the Great ( 356 - 323 BC ). One could say 1,500 years.
ReplyDeleteMath!
DeleteWho knew?
“Blue America had continued to take a gigantic pass with respect to the fairly obvious fact that something is wrong with this person.”
ReplyDeleteIf it’s a fairly obvious fact, why don’t the 77 million Trump voters see it, and why does anyone need media elites to tell them?
Anonymouse 11:59am, the way Bob causes you to defend Trump never gets old.
DeleteIn 2016, any hint of Trump's psychology was valuable in judging what kind of President he would be. Today we know. Voters dislike Trump or like him based on his actual performance. We don't need to know what he was like as a child 60 years ago.
DeleteCan you answer the question posed by 11:59, Cecelia? Why don’t trump voters see a fairly obvious fact?
DeleteBob called it a "fairly obvious fact," but that's just Bob's opinion. It's not a statement of objective reality. Bob may be wrong or 77 million Trump supporters may be wrong.
DeleteAnonymouse 12:20pm, they already have seen that Pres. Trump is a not conventional politician. That’s already been baked into the cake.
DeleteMy formulation as to Trump is much milder than Bob’s (perhaps too mild) , but politically active Democrats in general tend to deify their politicians and demonize their opponents. Anonymices routinely do that. Bob is aware that there is a middle ground that can be reached. Every year people are getting older… and can and will vote in the congressional elections…, etc. That makes a difference. That has a political impact. You ignore this because Bob is THE anonymouse target, Trump is ancillary to your goal.
DiC, Somerby says it’s a “fairly obvious FACT”. He doesn’t indicate that it is merely an opinion.
DeleteCecelia, If something is obvious, indeed an obvious fact, then everyone should be able to see it. That’s the meaning of “obvious.” Just because you’re an adherent of the emperor, and his opponents vilify him, doesn’t mean that he’s wearing clothes when he actually isn’t, even if his opponents say he isn’t.
DeleteAnonymouse 1:04pm, both Republicans and Democrats see that Trump is not the typical politician. Both sides see that he comes with a ton of baggage and without a lot of gravitas. THAT was already baked into the cake when Republicans voted for him. That is your answer as to— Why then do Republicans not see it, Bob….
DeleteNo, Cecelia. Trump voters do not believe there is something wrong with Trump. Quite the opposite. That means they do not see an obvious fact. You keep bringing up political sides.
Delete
DeleteFunny to hear about the emperor not wearing clothes from idiots who were enthusiastically praising a braindead man as 'sharp as a tack' nonstop in the previous four years.
Laughing at white people, who get totally outclassed by immigrants on the job market, is the comedy we all deserve.
DeleteAnonymouse 1:23pm, no, as in all human relationships…especially as to politicians… Trump supporters find the things they like about Trump to be more important than what they don’t like. I suspect you feel the same about Biden even when you’re here waxing ardent on his perfections and triumphs.
DeleteAnonymouse 1:31pm, here’s laughing at “whiter than white” you, kid.
DeleteAll white people are victims, obviously.
DeleteCecelia, There was a significant faction of Democrats who got together and confronted Biden and basically told him he needed to quit the race. Now you can argue that they needed to do that sooner, but you can’t argue that Democrats as a whole were oblivious to the problems. Where was that faction of Republicans, and where are they now, to confront Trump with the “obvious fact” that there’s something wrong with him? Bob Somerby has been saying this for a long time here at his blog which is ostensibly directed at liberals. But we liberals already know there’s something wrong with Trump.
DeleteAnonymouse flying monkeys must be so proud to have one of their own, David Hogg, as a vice chairman of the DNC.
Delete@CeceliaApril 1:32 PM
Delete" the things they like about Trump to be more important than what they don’t like"
What's not to like? Everything he does is brilliant.
And idiot-Democrats shitting bricks and squealing like pigs is a huge, UGE, bonus.
Anonymouse 1:42pm, I would never argue that the Democrats were oblivious to Biden’s mental decline. They and the media were fully aware of it.They thought they could continue finessing-managing it thru the campaign. If Biden was elected, Comma La could take over if it ever came to that. They would have never “stepped in”, but that there was no other choice.
DeleteBob, is talking/about to the media. He wants a drumbeat from them as to Trump being mentally unfit for office in all the ways that anonymices (and Mary Trump) are oh-so-aware of, but aren’t here to agree with Bob. Ever.
Trump has exhibited way more mental glitches and freezes and random wandering offs, than any politician - even more than Reagan.
DeleteIn reality, Trump is a typical Reagan Republican, and his edge lord style is nothing new, just it's widespread popularity among the increasingly desperate Repubs is what is new.
Biden's mental decline was made up (and strongly refuted by staff and journalists that interviewed him), and it was pushed by corporate media and Republicans and establishment Dems, because they all share a similar neo liberal agenda.
Duh.
Trump supporters view him as a Jesus/God like figure.
DeleteIncreasingly, they view Jesus with side eyes, growing tired of Jesus' wokeness and wuss concerns about the poor and the downtrodden.
It seems to be a truism: every Republican accusation really is projection/a confession.
Trump has given them permission to scrub Jackie Robinson from their sight and sing praises to high heaven for Hegseth. What more do you need to know?
DeleteIf you support Trump...you might be a racist.
DeleteWho knew?
Anonymouse 2:31pm, no one thinks that anyone in your party is dumb enough to have changed candidates for no real reason in the last months of a presidential campaign. Not even you.
Delete4:32,
DeleteWhy are all Republicans such outright bigots?
Anonymouse 7:45am, we’re not bigoted against goofy anonymouse flying monkeys, you have your place. In circuses.
Delete"...By Mary L. Trump"
ReplyDeleteYour endless demented regurgitating of this dumb shit is in really bad taste, Bob. Just sayin'.
Oh, that’ll convince everyone.
DeleteYou keep trying to convince others here you are a woman when you are actually a man pretending to be a woman, so...
DeleteAnonymouse 2:33pm, are you sure I’m not trying to convince folks that I’m a man and you’re only person dumb enough to believe it?
DeleteCecelia thinks she is clever when she writes nonsense like this. This is why comments fill up with hundreds of one-lines that add nothing to any discussion.
Delete
ReplyDeleteEstimated Savings: $160 Billion. +$5 Billion today!
Great job, DOGE. Keep it up, we appreciate it.
No Republican voters who aren't bigots, were found today.
DeleteWe're now over 26 years, and counting.
@1:13 what are you referring to? Do you have a link?
Deletehttps://doge.gov/savings
DeleteFor the people who are interested in Psychology, it may be interesting to have an insight into Trump's sociopathy. Trump is vile, and I am not particularly interested in how he's come to be this way.
ReplyDeleteDoes her book help us understand what we can expect from him and how it's best to gauge his next outburst? I am not sure.
What we ought to be keenly interested in is how to stop Trump. We need to develop strategies in how to deprogram the cult members who can be deprogrammed. More importantly, how to inform voters who are not immersed in politics just what a danger Trump presents to them.
While you have a decent point, I do not take your take on the roots of Trump (and right wingers in general) to be very encouraging; until we get to the root of the issue and try to solve that, we will just be spinning our wheels.
DeleteAnonymouse 2:35pm, his point wasn’t about “right wingers in general”, it was about “voters who are not immersed in politics”.
DeleteBut then you’re really only…solely…interested in disagreeing with Bob.
Understanding Trump does not mean anyone will be able to change him.
DeleteThe initial determination that Garcia is a member of the American gang MS 13 was based on the sweatshirt he was wearing.
ReplyDeleteTrump photoshopped in the "M S 1 3", and the tattoos Garcia does have are not indicative of MS 13.
There is no evidence that Garcia is in any gang, committed domestic violence, or engaged in human trafficking.
The Supreme Court has ordered Garcia to be returned.
Trump's defiance is an indication of his fascistic and dictatorial leanings.
Republicans love Trump, but they are a minority, most of America thinks he is terrible, and most of the world does as well.
DeleteI am a sad retard, and an expert in tattoos. My stockpiles of loony word-salads are endless.
I am Corby.
2:48 touched a nerve, in a snowflake.
DeleteWho knew?
The judge did not fully consider the evidence of gang membership when he made a bond ruling in advance of Garcia's hearing on asylum. Neither did the appeal of that bond ruling. They decided to err on the side of caution in the absence of evidence beyond the clothing and field officer report (later discredited). At the asylum hearing where the order protecting against removal was issued, the judge did hearing evidence from both sides and decided to let Garcia stay in the USA.
Delete
ReplyDeletePeople Who Bypassed Legal Process In Migrating To USA Demand Legal Process Before Being Kicked Out
Yup, per the Constitution.
DeleteThe Constitution doesn't give the President the power to choose to not enforce laws that he doesn't like. It was unconstitutional for Biden to let in millions of illegal aliens. IMO millions of unconstitutional acts by Biden is worse than one unconstitutional act by Trump.
DeleteDavid in Cal,
DeleteJust like no one can love you, until you love yourself. No one can believe your posts, until you believe them yourself.
Good luck.
Have to agree with Anon@4:33, David: it's really had to believe that you buy your own posts. Nothing of a kind happened.
DeleteFurthermore, law enforcement always picks and chooses its priority. The difference here is that Trump administration were violating the due process clause -- as well as habeas corpus -- and were told by the court to fix it, and they refused. This is qualitatively different from, say, not going after pot smokers as a matter of policy.
If each person coming to the US is being counted individually, then each person illegally deported must be counted individually too. So it is not one unconstitutional act, but now thousands, if not hundreds of thousands.
Delete"It was unconstitutional for Biden to let in millions of illegal aliens."
DeleteThe Supreme Court disagrees with you, David. See U.S. v Texas (2023).
@3:19: The Babylon Bee is not a news source.
DeleteAnother bloody day on Wall Street. Can't wait to see Dickhead in Cal twisting himself into a pretzel explaining the deep depression we are headed for.
ReplyDeleteThanks to David Duke in Cal, I now understand that bombing schools and hospitals to ethnically cleanse entire populations, is the main tenet of the Jewish faith.
DeleteTrump will spend the next year or so blaming Powell for the recession he created.
DeleteId wager that the real David Duke isn’t any more gracious to Jews than he is to Palestinians. Maybe go with David Ben-Gurion in Cal?
DeleteThe point of Mary Trump's book was that her father (Trump's brother) was mistreated because he didn't want to go into the family busness but wanted to be a pilot instead. So he became an alcoholic. Donald Trump is incidental to the main subject of her book, the dysfunction in the Trump family.
ReplyDelete"If it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck"
ReplyDeleteAutocorrect does that to me, too.