It's all at Rosenthal's restaurant: How dumb is the modern New York Times?
In its political coverage, the famous upper-class Gotham rag is spectacularly dumb. Just consider three major offerings in today's editions, all in the "National" section.
Atop the paper's hard-copy front page, Amy Chozick writes a Tolstoy-length summary of the latest leak from Moscow. Chozick's basic report runs an interminable 1922 words. It's accompanied by hundreds of words of additional text, aimed at subscribers who are especially sleep-resistant.
The mind-numbing dullness of this piece could only have come from Chozick. As noted, it starts atop the paper's front page. Inside the paper, it consumes the whole of page A12, what with its accompanying photos and pointless additional text.
Readers, let's be fair! Chozick's piece is a cancer cure compared to what's found on page A18. The entirety of that page is consumed by two reports. The first examines the body language displayed at Sunday evening's debate. The second is the usual high-flown piddle about Candidate Clinton's clothes.
The report about the body language is written at second-grade level. Alan Rappeport, who's widely believed to be human, starts his report like this:
RAPPEPORT (10/11/16): From the opening handshake that did not happen to the stone-faced stares and surly scowls, it was evident from watching Donald J. Trump and Hillary Clinton share a debate stage on Sunday night that their political differences have become personal and that the mutual distaste that they feel is very real.Forget about the candidates' "words!" Let's round up a passel of "experts" and scan their actual language!
With the candidates unshackled from lecterns by the town hall format, the window into their feelings opened a bit wider. As much as their words, it was the physical movements of the candidates that captivated viewers and body language experts.
This sort of feature is so dumb it's long since been abandoned on cable. First Chris Matthews, then Bill O'Reilly, decided to let their "body language experts" go. Stupidity abhorring a vacuum, the New York Times may have its eye on this prize.
How expert are these particular experts? Only a man with a string of Ph.D.s could have come up with this:
RAPPEPORT: According to Bart Rossi, a political psychologist and body language expert, Mr. Trump’s facial expressions were more revealing. The disdain that he feels for his opponent could not have been clearer.No one else would have caught that! Meanwhile, don't miss Ruth Sherman's ruminations on "the forces of 'proxemics.'" Saddest of all was this:
“He had almost a frightful face at times,” Mr. Rossi said, pointing out how Mr. Trump’s brow remained furrowed as he squinted for much of the debate. “He was agitated and angry."
RAPPEPORT: Ms. Sherman said that some of Mrs. Clinton’s subpar reviews could be the result of how she carried herself on the stage, clenching her thumb against her forefinger while speaking and looking down more than usual.Of course! The Clinton-loathing will never cease, not as long as Clinton insists on clenching her thumb while speaking!
“It’s something people do when they’re thinking, but I think it conveyed a bit of defensiveness,” Ms. Sherman said.
Alan Rappeport's pre-IQ piece burns up more than half the page. It's swollen out by four big photos, which seem to show Candidate Trump standing where he was supposed to be, right next to his chair, despite the mandated cries which came from some of the experts.
The rest of the page was burned by Vanessa Friedman's hopeless posturing about Candidate Clinton's clothes. Is Rush Limbaugh on loan from God? Friedman was on loan from Fashion. As always, she was an upper-class poser. She started out like this:
FRIEDMAN (10/11/16): Has Hillary Clinton found her dresser in chief? It would appear that way.Forget about the candidates' words! Let's focus on what they wore!
While the Twitterverse was busy parsing the possible subtexts of Melania Trump’s decision to wear a hot pink Gucci pussy-bow blouse to watch her husband, Donald J. Trump, during the second presidential debate Sunday evening (given his recently revealed lewd comments about women from 2005), it was actually what Mrs. Clinton wore that seemed meaningful to me.
Deliciously, Friedman managed to smuggle a P-bomb into her take on the hot Mrs. Trump. This is why we're shelling out that $8 every Sunday!
Trivial emails and body language, with Vanessa Friedman on pussy bows! The New York Times is a low-IQ, upper-class mess, though it tends to be hard for us the humans to process this obvious fact.
When Somersby thinks you're not being concise, you got a problem.ReplyDelete
Nonverbal communication is a legitimate field of study with an established scholarly literature (with findings that are based on scientific research). To mock this field because (1) you don't understand it, or (2) you confuse it with the folk wisdom, charlatans or pop practitioners, is both unfair and unwise.ReplyDelete
Trump's nonverbal behavior on stage was odd and just as distracting as this NY Times article suggests. People were noticing it and attributing meaning to it all over the comments on various blogs after the debate. Everyone noticed it. This is very different than the mind-reading and negative comments routinely made by partisan "experts" based on scant evidence. Trump's behavior was bizarre and his looming over Clinton appeared both deliberate and menacing.
It is tiresome when Somerby dismisses an entire field of study as trivial or nonsense. No one would do that about the other aspects of language (studied by linguistics or psycholinguistics) but for some reason they feel free to trash the analysis of nonverbal behavior. Somerby is displaying his ignorance, in my opinion.
I found myself wondering whether the looming was created by camera angles or field compression that happens with telephoto lenses. But I saw versions of the debate using different cameras on different stations and he was actually stalking her (the term stalking describes what his proximity would mean if a stranger did it to someone at a bus stop).Delete
Anon. @ 4:42: Of course I could be wrong, but I believe it was Somerby's intent, not to belittle the science you defend as a legitimate field, but rather that the media is giving body language priority over the more important issues that our nation is confronted with, such as climate change, jobs, economic inequality, et cetera.Delete
Communication can be about any number of topics. Communication includes both the verbal and nonverbal components. For example, someone can entirely negate the semantic content of words with a facial expression, gesture, or by tone of voice, as in sarcasm.Delete
The media does tend to go meta instead of considering the policies and proposals of the candidates.
Alan Rappeport, who's widely believed to be human.....ReplyDelete
Alan Rappeport's pre-IQ piece .....ReplyDelete
I agree with Somersby. For at least the last 20 years the NYT has caused me to seriously consider the possibilty that poking out my own eyes with an ice pick might be a more preferable outcome than finishing one of their articles. They race between being overly pedantic to trifling at an incredible speed--whiplash tends to be my Monday curse.ReplyDelete
Ridiculous; it's a decent newspaper overall. Not perfect, but so what.Delete
You mean the War Cheerleader? Or were you talking about their cooking section?Delete
!!! How (Dr.Goodluck) Help Me Save My Marriage & Avoid Divorce !!!ReplyDelete
What a wonderful and a straight forward spell caster that has brought back joy and happiness into my life i was devastated when my husband left me for someone else i was hurting REAL bad and i needing him back coz he was my joy 2years later when going trough the internet i saw a post on how he helped a lady called Mandy Divanna from UK restore her relationship, i decided to contact him for help when i told this God sent man Dr. Goodluck on how my lover left me for 2 years without calling nor texting me,When i shared this my sad experience with Dr Goodluck he said everything would be okay within 17hours i was like am i sure what this man is saying is real,So i decided to give a try and what even surprised me the most at first i was also thinking he was a scam i taught he was like other spell caster who come online to add pain to peoples pain not knowing there feelings but to make money,But this great man Dr Goodluck is never like that his own is for good and make people to be happy with the one they love,Am just so happy,Even before the 17hours i just got a call from a man who has left me for 2years saying he his sorry and that he wants me back to his life i was so happy,He invited me for a dinner which i meant him there and we bought talked and he said he wants to prove that he would never leave me for any other lady he engaged me and also make me had access to all his account am so happy all thanks goes to this great man Dr Goodluck a man who has brought back joy to my life,Please friends that needs help i would advice that Dr Goodluck is the right man and not those fake ones who are online to make money and not to help here is Dr Goodluck private mail firstname.lastname@example.org you can also whatapp him or call with his mobile +2349059610309 or also his website. http://goodluck05spellcaster.yolasite.com
I was so looking forward to DinC's rationalizations for why it's a positive that Trump is causing civil war within the GOP.ReplyDelete
Not germane to this piece, but please cover the thirsty, credulous scrambling to pin Donna Brazile to the wall for allegedly feeding town hall questions to Clinton. These guys are really hurting for a close horse race, and they're jumping to all sorts of conclusions about lack of a CNN transcript (not exactly airtight evidence that a TV producer didn't find time to cover a topic they asked panel participants to prepare for), and specificity of figures (death penalty activists have succeeded in framing the debate using the 1970's supreme court decisions regarding the death penalty, which is why you would see the exact same numbers over and over again, tracking state executions isn't the hardest thing in the world).ReplyDelete
It's been scary seeing the media jump on scoops without really allowing time to establish the basic facts of a story, but not very surprising to anyone who reads this blog.
@ 9:08 AM - get help soon!ReplyDelete
My husband said he stop loving me in January. He loves me but not in love with me. In February I knew he was going to visit his sister and mother. When. He returned from his visit he was acting strange. Like distance. Five days later he asked for a beak from each other. I was surprised but it wasn’t him talking. I had a feeling something was up. April 7 he returned home so we can talk on why this separation. He said met someone and had an affair. I’m trying to figure how when we are together like most of the time. He hasn’t seen her since he told me. Apparently she’s married too in a verbal situation. I been trying to save my marriage. This past Wednesday 4/23 was our wedding anniversary. Today 4/25 he sends me this text after I asked him a financial questions. He replies and asking for a divorce by testing me. He is a cowatd.ReplyDelete
I text him why and upset and angry. He said I love you and care about you but I am not in love with you.
I send him this text I’m fine. I love you, you know where I stand and what I’m willing to do. So I’m honoring your need for time to make a finally decision. I hope in the near future we can talk about this in person. When your ready.
He . replies
OK. Thank you. And I’m sorry.
I adore and love him. The kicker he abandoned our marriage by moving to LA that’s terrible. I been crying almost daily. Not sure what do anymore. ..so i carried and search online one day, if i can save my marriage with my husband and so luckily i come across some wonderful post of Dr happy on how he help people to fix up their broken Marriage,relationship and get ex lover back. so i contacted and give him a try, with-in 48hours of his promise, my husband call to apology and come back to me and the family. all thanks to Dr happy he was like a father to me when i loose trust on my husband plz if you need help, you can reach him via email email@example.com or add him up on Whats-pp +2348133873774
This is a Wonderful testimony on a Spell caster called DR OWOLABI that Just helped me and Brought My Ex Husband
back within 2Days with his Love spell. I am Kim Madar from United States, Life has being very Difficult for me
Since my Husband Left me and my Two Kids. My Kids and I and had being Missing My Husband and I cried almost
Everyday because of him, One Faithful Day, Someone Directed me to This man DR OWOLABI and I Contacted him VIA Email
and He Casted a Love spell for me and Told me that i will see the Results within 2DAYS, My Husband That Left me
For about 3years, Called me And Started opposing and he even sent me an apologizing Text. From that Moment,
I and My Family had being Living happily. Readers Out There, Who are in Pains and have Great Pleasure in Contacting
this Man should do that On this Email: DROWOLABISOLUTIONHOME@GMAIL.COM
You Can also Reach Him or Contact him On His NUMBER +16828086703or+2348124209863...
I want to thank Dr.Agbazara for his job in my family, this is man who left me and the kids for another woman without any good reasons, i was pain and confuse,till one day when i was browsing through the internet with my computer then i saw Dr.Agbazara contact, then i contaced him and he help me cast a reunion spell, since I then the situation has changed, everything is moving well, my husband who left me is now back to his family. reach DR.AGBAZARA TEMPLE via email if you have any relationship problem at:ReplyDelete
( firstname.lastname@example.org )
OR whatsapp or call him on +2348104102662
Am here to testify of a great spell caster who is very straight forward with his words of casting spells. When my Wife left me for another Man i was so confused,but one day a friend of mine gave me the email address of this great spell caster called Awo Babatunde, I contacted this man and explained to him all that i was going through,he then told me to be calm and not worry anymore because my case is a very easy one. At first i never believe all that he was saying until when my wife returned home two days later begging me to forgive him all that he has done to me and to please accept him back into my life,I was so amazed,I never believe it was going to happen that fast.ReplyDelete
This man is truly great indeed. Contact him today for a perfect solution to your love problem, Awobabatunde50@gmail.com or whatsApp him +2349045101972