CRITICAL MATTERS: Goldberg breaks every rule in the book!


Also, Drum recalls the past, with anthropological insights: In Tuesday morning's New York Times, Michelle Goldberg joined the fray.

Goldberg discussed the ongoing dispute about the teaching of American history in public schools. Her column appeared beneath this headline:

The Maddening Critical Race Theory Debate

Goldberg said the debate has been "maddening." Subscribers had no way to know it, but the columnist was about to break every rule in the tribal book.

Readers of the Washington Post had already been told, in a series of columns, that the whole thing was just a "hissy fit" being staged by The Others. The central question was how we, the good smart people here in Our Town, should deal with all the "hot air" coming from a bunch of people so dumb that they can't even define the obscure academic framework known as "critical race theory!"

Over at the Washington Post, everyone had said it! Now, Goldberg decided to enter the fray—but at one point, the columnist broke every rule in the tribal book.

Is Goldberg allowed to say these things? This is what Goldberg said:

GOLDBERG (6/29/30): My own position is basically anti-anti-critical race theory, in that I disagree with some ideas associated with C.R.T., especially around limiting speech, but am extremely alarmed by efforts to demonize and ban it. There’s certainly some material that critics lump in with C.R.T. that strikes me as ridiculous and harmful. I’ve seen the risible training for school administrators calling worship of the written word “white supremacy culture.” There’s a version of antiracism based on white people’s narcissistic self-flagellation that seems to me to accomplish very little.

Is Goldberg allowed to say such things? Just consider what Goldberg said:

Goldberg said that she disagrees [sic] "with some ideas associated with critical race theory!" She said she disagrees.

Yes, that's clearly what she said. And after that, it got worse.

She said there's some material that critics lump in with CRT—i.e., some material which is specifically being criticized—which strikes her as "ridiculous," and also as "harmful." Plainly, this implies that some of the The Others' complaints may in some sense be valid!

The running dog didn't stop there! She said she's seen training for public school administrators which she regards as "risible. " Such risible conduct comes from the side of this non-debate which originates here in Our Town! 

She even said there's a version of the antiracism at issue which seems to accomplish very little. Incredibly, she said these unhelpful formulations are based on the "narcissism" of some people who live here in Our Town.

This would suggest that somewhere, someone among The Others might have a reasonable complaint about something which may be happening in our public schools! As a prelude to these shocking statements, Goldberg had even offered this:

GOLDBERG: In a recent piece in The Week, Damon Linker criticized the left for being what he called “anti-anti-critical race theory,” sidestepping legitimate objections to what he described as a “pernicious” phenomenon.

Parents protesting critical race theory, he wrote, “do not want their children taught, in state-run and state-funded schools, that the country was founded on an ideology of white supremacy in which every white child and family today is invariably complicit regardless of their personal views of their Black fellow citizens.” He compared the anti-anti-critical race theory camp to leftists in the 1950s who, while condemning McCarthyism, dismissed justified concerns about Soviet Communism.

That someone as smart as Linker, author of an essential book on the Catholic right, would analogize Communism to critical race theory strikes me as a sign of a moral panic, but leave that aside for a moment...

Good God! Goldberg had even said that someone who seems to be very smart disagreed [sic] with Our Town's basic stance in the current debate. This very smart fellow seemed to think that The Others might have some legitimate concerns about the way their children are being portrayed in their public schools.

In the end, Goldberg found a tangential way to cast this smart person's presentation as part of "a moral panic." In this way, she may have reunited herself with The Tribe. 

But is Goldberg allowed to say such ridiculous things in the first place? If she does, might this mean that the current debate isn't The Oldest Story in The Book, in which, as always, all the merit lies on Our Own Town's side?

Rather plainly, Goldberg had broken every rule in the tribal playbook. Rather plainly, she had suggested that the goodness and truth in the current dispute may not all rest with Our Tribe!

Throughout the course of human history, heretics have been burned at the stake, or dunked in the pond, or possibly pulled into four different pieces, for expressing such inappropriate views. According to major anthropologists, we're wired to behave in this unhelpful way:

We're wired to split into two warring tribes, then seek pathways to tribal war. All the merit lies on Our Side, each tribe will be wired to claim.

There's more to Goldberg's column than what we've cited so far. For now, let's move to Kevin Drum's new post, in which he recalls another dispute along these same lines—a dispute which started way back in 2014.

Back in 2014, "the folks who make up curriculum guidelines for the AP history course decided to update things," Drum writes. "This prompted dismay from conservatives and got a fair amount of press coverage."

We don't recall the incident. But Drum proceeds to offer an account of the incident by David Casalaspi, "a mainstreamish liberal who's an education policy analyst for the National Governors Association."

According to Drum, Casalaspi is "a mainstreamish liberal" and he's a policy specialist. But how weird! Drum provides this puzzling excerpt from the gentleman's later account:

CASALAPI (5/3/16): The maligned 2014 framework represented a first attempt by the College Board to produce a coherent narrative of American history which would encourage teachers to stop teaching history as a collection of trivia facts and instead teach the subject more thematically. In doing so, though, it pressured teachers to adopt racial and gender conflict as the dominant paradigm of historical development.

In this way, the 2014 framework listed “Identity”—with an emphasis on racial and gender grievances—as the first of seven “organizing themes” for the teaching of American history. Additionally, the framework was littered with references to “white Americans,” “white settlers,” “white pioneers,” and their racial biases. The concept of Manifest Destiny, for instance, was described as “built on the belief in white racial superiority.” And one of the only things students had to know about World War II was that the dropping of the atomic bomb and the internment of Japanese citizens led to the questioning of American values.

....I am a liberal, but I often found myself agreeing with conservatives on this issue because I am wary of any U.S. history curriculum that both infringes upon the free speech of teachers and proffers a narrative of history which encourages identity-building through the balkanization of student populations along racial and gender lines. The long-standing purpose of social studies is to help students understand each other as citizens, not as members of competing tribes of with irreconcilable cultures.

By our reckoning, Casalaspi "pulled a Goldberg" with respect to that earlier dispute. Even as he improbably claimed to be a liberal, he improbably said that he "often found [him]self agreeing with conservatives" about the proposed curriculum!

Improbably, he said the proposed curriculum "encouraged identity-building through the balkanization of student populations along racial and gender lines." Even as he posed as a liberal, the rather obvious running dog was pretending to believe that!

According to Casalaspi's peculiar account, The Others might have had some valid concerns back in 2014! As he continued, Drum said this about that:

"The curriculum was changed in response to complaints, and everyone seemed to be relatively happy with the final 2015 product."

By our reckoning, Drum almost seemed to be doing it too! He almost seemed to be saying that a dispute had broken out, a dispute in which The Others might not have been totally wrong!

In response to some of The Others' complaints, some changes had been made in the proposed curriculum. Everyone was pretty much happy with the final product—and yes, we're supposed to believe that!

Anthropologists came to us last night, discussing this presentation. Just look where Kevin took things from there, these disconsolate scholars all said!

They also commented on some of the comments to Drum's intriguing post. Our "human race" is wired this way, these top experts told us again, for what seemed like the ten millionth time.

Tomorrow: Ways to remain aligned with the tribe

Still coming: The current eighth-grader's tale


  1. "Is Goldberg allowed to say such things?"

    No, she's not, dear Bob. But then you're the only one reading her drivel, so who cares. thing we all can be certain of: should a liberal-hitlerian enforcer frown at her for 5 seconds, she'll stop fucking around and start spewing liberal-hitlerian talking points as usual. No doubt about that, dear Bob.

    1. You were funnier when you pretended you didn't love the Establishment.

  2. Somerby works extra hard to put words into Goldberg's mouth. Goldberg says:

    "There’s certainly some material that critics lump in with C.R.T. that strikes me as ridiculous and harmful."

    Then Somerby reinterprets what she said:

    "She said there's some material that critics lump in with CRT—i.e., some material which is specifically being criticized—which strikes her as "ridiculous," and also as "harmful." Plainly, this implies that some of the The Others' complaints may in some sense be valid!"

    Notice how Somerby glosses over the "critics lump in with" part of her sentence, transforming those lumped in non-CRT things into "material being specifically criticized". Somerby ignores that much of what the critics lump in with CRT has no relation to it at all. Goldberg seems to understand that, but Somerby pretends she is just talking about CRT specifics, not extraneous things.

    And then Somerby claims that her comment "implies" that The Other's complaints have validity. It does no such thing. She cannot give validity (or take it away) from anyone else's criticisms because she is nothing more than an individual with an opinion. She doesn't speak for liberals, she is not an education expert, she is not a historian, and she has no basis for giving or taking away validity from right-wing complaints. She is just one person with an opinion.

    But Somerby thinks that if the least liberal joins in a conservative viewpoint, then the right wing has credibility. No, it more likely means that the liberal in question is deviant from mainstream liberal thought in some way. And that is certainly true for Michelle Goldberg given other opinions she has written. And no one has elected her as the spokesperson for liberal thought.

    But Somerby really really wants to endow those conservative complaints with validity. Why? No liberal works that hard in support of The Others.

    Don't be fooled by Somerby's sleight of hand with words. It is dishonest.

    1. I would not be fooled by Somerby's sleight of hand with words but you cannot give validity (or take it away) from his criticisms because you are nothing more than an individual with an opinion. You have no basis for giving or taking away validity from his complaints. Your comment means nothing. You are just one insane fool with an opinion.

    2. So, you agree with me then. That is nice for a change.

  3. Here are all seven of the organizing themes presented by the College Board for the 2015 AP History Framework:

    o American and National Identity (NAT)
    o Politics and Power (POL)
    o Work, Exchange, and Technology (WXT)
    o Culture and Society (CUL)
    o Migration and Settlement (MIG)
    o Geography and the Environment (GEO)
    o America in the World (WOR)"

    Here is the link to the framework itself:

    Note that the "identity" theme is only one of seven important ways of thinking about and organizing American History. It is not the major way. Further, national identity isn't only about minorities and slavery, but also about other aspects of national identity. Leaving it out entirely would be wrong. So, what exactly, are conservatives complaining about?

  4. In the US, educational standards are set and controlled by individual states and counties. This means that some student's educations will be determined by the likes of charlatan televangelist preachers like Trump's "spiritual adviser" Paula Michelle White-Cain. People who live in areas where this medieval-minded Christian-Taliban is in control don't have much choice other than to move to an area where Enlightenment values exist. So there's really no use in whining about what some particular intellectual shit-hole part of the country is teaching their kids. This is the country you live in:

  5. To be clear on pt 3, Somerby is a liar because he claims to be a liberal, but is a Trumptard. Kevin is a liberal who admits it.

  6. Maybe Michelle feels a little guilty for telling us we should shun Bill Clinton for the rest of his life based on the claims of obvious nut job Jaunita Broaddrick. In any event, the fact that Bob is so shocked a liberal can express a bit of maturity suggests he actually is still watching MSNBC.

  7. มาพบกับความสนุกหรรษาไปกับเงินตรามากมายมีโบนัสแจกให้ทั้งสมาชิกเก่าและสมาชิกใหม่พบกันเลย Egypt's Book of Mystery รออะไรล่ะสมัครกันเลยที่รีวิว/egypts-book-of-mystery-slot/ มีทีมงานคุณภาพคอยให้คำแนะนำและอยู่เป็นเพื่อนของท่านตลอด 24 ชั่วโมง

  8. แจกเงินกระจาย รับเงินกันได้แบบไม่อั้น หันมาลงทุนเล่นเลยที่เกม Medusa 2 เกมสล็อตที่มาพร้อมกับธีมเมดูซ่า คอยรอมอบของรางวัลและฟีเจอร์พิเศษมากมายให้กับนักเดิมพัน อยากลงทุนเกมดีๆแบบนี้ คลิกที่นี่ เป็นเกมที่มีไลน์คงที่มากสูงสุดถึง 30 ไลน์ จะเริ่มจ่ายเมื่อสัญลักษณ์ ปรากฏบนรีลที่ 3 – 5 นักเดิมพันสามารถเข้ามาเล่นได้ทุกที่ทุกเวลาตลอด 24 ชั่วโมง

  9. คลีโอพัตรา ราชินีองค์สุดท้ายของเมืองอียิปต์โบราณ มีเงินรางวัลมากมายให้ท่านเป็นเจ้าของอยู่ที่เกม Secrets of Cleopatra เกมสล็อตที่มาในธีมของคลีโอพัตรา มีเงินรางวัลและของขวัญพิเศษมากมายมามอบให้กับนักเดิมพันทุกช่วงเวลา สนใจเชิญคลิกเข้ามาร่วมสนุกกับเราได้แล้วตอนนี้ เพียงท่านสปินพบกับ 1 ในสัญลักษณ์ทั้ง 11 ของเทพรา รับเงินค่าตอบแทนมากสูงสุดถึง 70 เท่า คุ้มค่ากว่านี้ไม่มีอีกแล้ว

  10. เปิดประสบการณ์ใหม่ของเกมออนไลน์ สล็อตออนไลน์ Slot สนุกเร้าใจ ลุ้นเงินรางวัลก้อนใหญ่ได้บนมือถือ สล็อตโจ๊กเกอร์ แล้วคุณจะฟินไปกับเรา เกมพนันออนไลน์ เล่นแล้วได้ชัวร์ ไม่ต้องกลัวโดนโกงต้อง Slot joker สล็อตโจ๊กเกอร์ สล็อตออนไลน์ มีทุกเกมทุกค่าย แตกจริง แตกง่าย ได้ชัวร์

  11. สมัครสมาชิกใหม่วันนี้ ไม่ต้องฝากก็ได้เครดิต500บาท ชวนเพื่อนมาเล่น รับฟรีเครดิต 50% โปรแรงรับลมฝน เรามีเกมให้เลือกเล่นจากทุกค่าย Slot Online เกมสล็อตออนไลน์ miga888
    Sign up today No need to deposit, get 500 baht credit. Invite friends to play and get 50 % free credit. Hot promotion for wind and rain. We have games to choose from from all online gaming camps miga888. Slot online

  12. ฟรีโบนัส100% โปรแจกฟรีไม่มีเงื่อนไขจาก เว็บพนันออนไลน์ ที่จะทำให้คุณอาจกลายเป็นเศรษฐีในข้ามคืน เพราะเราคือบริการที่มั่นคง ซื่อตรงและจริงใจ เรามีบริการเกมพนันออนไลน์ทุกรูปแบบ ไม่ว่าจะเป็นสล็อต รูเล็ต ยิงปลา บาคาร่า และเกมสล็อตออนไลน์ทุกค่ายเกม มาเล่นกับเราซิคะ สล็อตออนไลน์

  13. เปิดประสบการณ์ใหม่กับเกมสล็อตออนไลน์ที่ทันสมัยที่สุดกับ สล็อตโรม่า Roma slot สนุกเร้าใจ แล้วลุ้นเงินรางวัลก้อนใหญ่ไปกับเรา เล่นไม่ถึง10นาทีโบนัสแตกง่าย จ่ายไว เล่นแล้วได้ชัวร์ ไม่ต้องกลัวโดนโกงต้อง สล็อตโรม่า เรามีเกมจากค่าย joker Game ทุกเกมพร้อมบริการแล้วตลอด24ชั่วโมงที่นี่ที่เดียว Roma slot


  14. แหล่งรวมเกมสล็อตที่มีคนเล่นเยอะที่สุดในปี2021 จนถึงทุกวันนี้ มาพร้อมกับบริการด้วยระบบฝาก-ถอน ออโต้ ที่ทันสมัยและรวดเร็วทันใจที่สุด สมัครเข้าเล่นวันนี้รับฟรีเครดิต100%ฝากไม่มีขั้นต่ำ อยากเท่าไหร่ได้หมด PG SLOT pg888

  15. เราคือ เว็บพนันออนไลน์ ให้บริการแบบครบวงจรสมบูรณ์แบบที่สุด สล็อต เป็นเว็บไซต์ที่ได้รับการแต่งตั้งจาก ยูฟ่าเบท เป็นเว็บแรกและเว็บเดียวเท่านั้น

  16. Excellent, your website is very helpful. I read and really like your website.

  17. It is a fantastic post The process of carrying out a loft conversion
    superslot wallet
    the information you posted is very helpful
    apollo pg

  18. ปัจจุบันหลาย ๆ คนอาจจะอาศัยอยู่ในพื้นที่จำกัดอย่างคอนโด อพาทเม้นท์ หรือหอพัก ซึ่งเมื่อเรากลับมาที่บ้านแบบเหนื่อย ๆ แล้วนั้นคงจะอยากมีตัวช่วยที่ทำให้หายเครียด เเละเป็นเพื่อนรคลายเหงาได้อย่างเเน่นอน ข้อมูลเพิ่มเติม evanasa ได้รวบรวมสุนัขน่าเลี้ยง สายพันธุ์เล็ก สามารถเลี้ยงได้ในคอนโดรับรองว่าถูกใจอย่างเเน่นอน.

  19. It is a fantastic post The process of carrying out a loft conversion the information you posted is very
    joker123 net

  20. it isgood amazing story amazing the information you posted is very good. it isgood amazing story amazing the information you posted is

  21. Thanks for sharing the post

  22. Thanks for sharing the post Hello! Someone in my Myspace group shared this website with us so I came to look it slotgame666

  23. in doing this after registration You must make a deposit in the desired currency first. that change to the desired currency in the wallet tab in the profile of the game account After that activate 100 free spins to scroll through. if for some reason The bonus is not credited in the required currency. You should contact support เว็บพนันออนไลน์ on Online gambling websites give away free credits and ask for 100 free spins to get credit in the desired currency.

  24. which mainly focuses on the needs of the players Bonuses and promotions from UFABET offered to both new players and registered players To make it easier for you to understand all the bonuses offered by Wawada Casinos. We've sorted them เว็บพนันออนไลน์ตรง</a on the shelves in this review. Bonuses and promotions from online gambling website UFABET100 Free Spins in Wawada Casino For registration using the referral link

  25. If you try to activate the second bonus until the first bet is made. The first bonus will be cancelled. Exception: bonuses wagered in parallel in different currencies. The betting process can be seen from the computer. You must move the mouse cursor to การพนันกีฬา< the bonus wagering level in the Bonus tab in the game account profile. The amount of bets already made will be displayed.

  26. First of all, the main balance is spent on wagering. Then when making a deposit Bets are taken from the bonus amount. Wagering winnings are generated from the bonus balance. Winnings cannot be withdrawn until the bonus wagering has been completed. If you try to withdraw When the bonus has not been wagered until the การพนันออนไลน์โดยตรง end The bonus will be canceled along with any winnings received. Even if the player does not use the bonus

  27. Both big bonuses in online gambling websites UFABET, bonuses to high-level players. best tournament Plenty of deposit methods Game library in online gambling website UFABET and features of online gambling website UFABET if we consider the design of the website. and website features You won't see anything new การพนันออนไลน์ here. Everything was arranged in a simple and clear manner. 888 Online Betting Sites Open Quickly From PC and Mobile Devices

  28. The bonus will still be burned on the first withdrawal. If the bonus amount is used up first are usually canceled automatically. When the bonus is wagered and transferred to the main balance. 10% cashback will be credited on the 1st of every month เว็บพนันออนไลน์ตรง to all eligible players. you can win money back at his own expense without deposit General information about the bonus program

  29. Types of bonuses that bonus hunters accumulate. Don't assume the bookmaker gives no fool bonuses in the market from that side. But there are three types of bonuses that you should pay attention to. It's worth looking out for from them. no deposit bonus These are free bets that the bookmaker credits immediately after registration and account verification. You don't need แมนเชสเตอร์ซิตี้ to transfer money to your account. You can bet now and if she wins, withdraw the profit. There are more such bonuses. recently Actually, the size of the free bet is not more than 2,000 baht.

  30. Manchester City insiders have told the media that the coach believes Wenger Ozil's role is too similar to Fabregas, after spending so much on Ovil he hopes there will be more. the most There are plenty of fresh Manchester City เว็บเกมสปินออนไลน์ first-team players to tackle next season, but the current situation makes it difficult for Wenger to buy back Fabregas. And his first priority is to reinforce the ball for the rest of the team.

  31. Types of bonuses that bonus hunters accumulate. Don't assume the bookmaker gives no fool bonuses in the market from that side. But there are three types of bonuses


  32. wife and i got quite From the tons LOTTSOD.NET or huaysod


    Your article is very interesting huaysod

  33. pg slot ซื้อฟรีสปิน ซื้อฟีเจอร์ดีอย่างไร มีเกมที่ของ PG ที่ซื้อฟรีสปินได้บ้าง วันนี้เรา ได้ยก 10 เกมที่สามารถซื้อฟีเจอร์ฟรีสปินได้ ไปดูกันว่า การซื้อฟีเจอร์ดีอย่างไร คุ่มค่าแค่ไหน

  34. each web that investors choose to bet with There are still many promotions and special bonuses ready to give. In order to support for the extension to create that เกมสล็อต

  35. I just like the valuable info you supply in your articles. I will bookmark your weblog and test once more here regularly. I’m relatively certain I will learn many new stuff right here! Best of luck for the next!