WHERE THE TEST SCORES ARE: Final week in five-week series begins tomorrow!

MONDAY, OCTOBER 17, 2016

For today, a preview:
Tomorrow, we start the final week in our award-winning five-week series, Where the Test Scores Are.

This week's reports will carry this title: Where the Challenges Are. We'll focus on the journalistic challenges—on the journalistic practices which keep the public from gaining a clear-eyed view of the apparent status of American students, teachers and schools.

That said, how do our schools seem to measure up, as compared to schools in the rest of the world? For today, we'll offer one set of data as a bit of an intellectual challenge.

Below, you see the way one set of American students performed on one international test. In fairness, we're cherry-picking a bit:

We've selected the largest subgroup of American students. And we've selected the one subtest on which American students performed least well, in the aggregate, in the most recent round of international testing for which we have data.

In recent years, journalists and "education experts" have had two sets of international data on which they could draw. They could draw on three subtests from the 2012 PISA, a program which tests 15-year-old students in reading, math and science; on four subtests from the 2011 TIMSS; which tests students from Grade 4 and Grade 8 in math and science; and on one subtest from the 2011 PIRLS, which tests Grade 4 students in reading.

(Results from the 2015 TIMSS and the 2015 PISA should be released by the end of this year.)

Of those eight subtests, American students performed least well, in the aggregate, on the PISA math test. A cynic might claim that this explains why you see that one subtest cited most often among the eight.

Let's eschew such rank speculation! Below, you see the way one group of American students performed on that one subtest, the worst subtest of the eight. To help you assess the meaning of the scores you'll see, consider a rule of thumb:

In an endnote to her 2013 book, The Smartest Kids in the World, Amanda Ripley wrote that 39 points on the PISA scale "is considered the equivalent of one year of formal schooling."

Ripley worked closely with PISA World in writing her book. You should consider that rule of thumb in assessing the scores you see below—scores from the one subtest on which American students performed least well.

We include the three Asian test score superpowers, and the other large developed nations. Among smaller nations, we include miraculous Finland, the subject of vast amounts of American journalism:
Average scores, math literacy, 2012 PISA
Taiwan: 560
South Korea: 554
Japan: 536
Finland: 519
Canada: 518
Poland: 518
Germany: 514
United States, white students only: 506
Australia: 504
France: 495
United Kingdom: 494
Italy: 485
Spain: 484
Russia: 482
For a fuller set of scores, click this.

On this, their worst of those eight subtests, white kids in the United States scored thirteen points behind the miraculous children of Finland. Applying Ripley's rule of thumb, we can draw this rough conclusion:

At the age of 15, white students in the U.S. lagged their counterparts in Finland by the equivalent of 12 weeks' instruction! (One-third of an 180-day school year).

That was the gap on the PISA math test. On the PISA reading test, the gap with Finland was only five points. On the TIMSS and the PIRLS, white students in the U.S. tended to outperform Finland. On this basis, we pose a question:

On the basis of these data, can anybody justify the past dozen years of journalistic Finland chic, which now threatens to expand into Estonia chic?

On that PISA math test, white kids in the U.S. were outscored by the Asian tigers to a substantial degree (as was the rest of the world). But they weren't outscored by Finland by much—and on other major international tests, they weren't outscored by Finland at all.

Dearly propagandized, let's try to understand the basis for our own comparison, in which we're presenting the average score for our white students only.

White students in the U.S. are what we'd call "majority culture." They come from the majority so-called race. Especially on an historical basis, they hail from their country's dominant culture.

In Finland, virtually everyone fits this description! There are very few immigrant kids. There is very little child poverty. There is no "racial minority"—no group whose ancestors were subjected to centuries of brutal mistreatment, including an attempt to eliminate literacy from their group altogether.

In our view, that chart helps us understand where our educational challenges lie. Presumably, American schools could do a better job, in a million ways, with the nation's white students. Beyond that, the nation's white students, like the rest of the world, have in fact been outperformed on international tests, to a substantial degree, by kids in the three Asian tigers.

That said:

Once we "disaggregate" American scores, it's hard to know why American journalists keep denigrating American teachers and schools on the basis of endless, all-expenses-paid comparisons to the teachers and schools of Finland.

By almost all accounts, Finland is a very nice place to live. It's a sane, well-ordered country. (It provides universal health care at very low cost, a fact you'll never see reported, explained or analyzed in your favorite American newspaper.)

That said, Finland is a small, unicultural, middle-class nation with very few immigrant kids, no historically targeted group, and very little child poverty. As in Garrison Keillor's Lake Wobegon, all its kids are "majority culture!" And we're sorry, but when it comes to "majority culture" kids, Finland doesn't seem to outperform the United States by much, if it does so at all. In our view, it's surprising to see how mediocre Finland's performance can start to seem when we disaggregate American scores in this painful but instructive way.

In our view, those data help us see where the largest chunks of our nation's educational challenges lie. But alas! In our view, the challenges posed by our press corps tend to keep us from gaining a clear view of these facts.

Starting tomorrow, we'll ponder those challenges all week. Our history and our social practices present us with major educational challenges. Our "press corps" creates journalistic challenges which are at least as large.

Starting tomorrow: Where the Challenges Are! (There may be some repetition.)

Our pundits are able to focus at last!

SATURDAY, OCTOBER 15, 2016

Cooper in hog heaven:
In his column today in the Washington Post, Colbert King imagines the Clinton-Trump race as a series of boxing matches.

In the passage shown below, he refers to some possible knock-out blows, to the punches which may finish Trump. In this passage, King is describing events which occurred after the second Trump-Clinton debate:
KING (10/15/16): Altogether, Trump has received a sequence of consecutive punches for which he apparently was not prepared.

The combination came from House Speaker Paul D. Ryan (R-Wis.), who disinvited Trump from a Wisconsin rally...That was quickly followed by several Republicans urging Trump to drop out of the race, and news that 26 percent of Republican governors and members of Congress have refused to endorse him, according to a USA Today survey.

All that was before he got hit with the blows that may take him to the canvas—a succession of women punching back against his assertion during the second debate that he never did the lewd things he boasted about doing. Each claimed to have been sexually accosted by him.
In that passage, King suggests that the recent accusations against Trump may serve as a knock-out blow. That's certainly possible, of course.

In the main, King seems to be speaking about the way those accusations could affect Trump's vote total. That said, we couldn't help thinking about the way this wave of accusations has energized cable pundits.

Finally, after all these months, the Anderson Coopers of the world have found a topic which has galvanized their tiny ability to focus. Last night, the Coopers were thoroughly focused on these new accusations. "How far down your throat did he stick his tongue," they seemed to want to ask.

It seemed they could keep it up for days. Cable was in hog heaven.

We were struck by their sudden ability to focus. Again, we thought of the way these people have failed, during this campaign, to focus on much of anything else, except for Clinton's meddlesome emails and the ever-present latest batch of polls.

Trump's mental and moral disorder has been clear for some time. But until they got to ask a string of women about getting groped, the Coopers were never quite able to focus on this state of affairs.

They had the emails and the polls. They seemed to need little else.

Again, we find ourselves thinking about the most heinous conduct in which Trump engaged before this latest episode. We think of his reign as the king of the nation's birthers. We think of the refusal of people like Cooper to focus on that behavior.

The behavior which enervates Cooper today involves alleged assaults against individuals. Assaults of that type are a serious matter, of course. No one is wrong about that.

That said, Trump's reign as king of the birthers involved an assault on the national discourse, and on voters who were too gullible to know they were being played. But so what? The Coopers seem incapable of caring about such assaults, even of imagining that such an assault could exist.

Let's recall the history of this topic. Candidate Trump declared for the White House in June 2015. At that time, a few interviewers actually asked him about his birther claims.

He said he no longer discusses that topic. Suitably instructed, the nation's journalists folded their tents and crawled away.

To all intents and purposes, the topic disappeared. That said, consider what happened when the New York Times finally examined the topic.

Good lord! On Sunday, July 3, 2016, the Times ran a lengthy front-page report about Trump's birther career. By now, Trump had been a candidate for more than a year. The New York Times had finally decided to examine this poisonous matter.

Production of the 1800-word front-page report had been a family affair. Ashley Parker and Steve Eder were listed as the reporters. But according to an extended byline, Michael Grynbaum and Maggie Haberman had "contributed reporting." Kitty Bennett "contributed research."

More than a year after Trump announced, five reporters had rolled up their sleeves to report this remarkable episode. But how sad! In the course of their exertions, they never asked a basic question:

Had Trump been lying all along about this ugly affair?

We refer to one of the ugliest parts of Trump's assault on the discourse. We refer to his repeated claims in 2011 that he had sent investigators to Hawaii to probe Obama's birth.

"They cannot believe what they are finding," he had dramatically said on The View. Millions of people were watching the show. His claim ricocheted all around.

That said, had Trump really dispatched agents, or had that just been a lie? Amazingly, in the last two paragraphs of their lengthy report, the scribes finally offered these thoughts:
PARKER, EDER, GRYNBAUM, HABERMAN AND BENNETT (7/3/16): But for all of his fascination with the president's birth certificate, Mr. Trump apparently never dispatched investigators or made much of an effort to find the documents.

Dr. Alvin Onaka, the Hawaii state registrar who handled queries about Mr. Obama, said recently through a spokeswoman that he had no evidence or recollection of Mr. Trump or any of his representatives ever requesting the records from the Hawaii State Department of Health.
Say what? Trump "never dispatched [those] investigators?" That was a lie all along?

In best Times fashion, the "evidence" supporting this provisional claim was flimsy at best. But here's the part which should make inquiring minds resent the Times:

In all their 1800 words, there was no sign that Parker, Eder and the rest had ever popped that question! Did Trump send people to Hawaii? Or did he lie about that?

The Times Five interviewed three Trump associates in the course of their report. But how odd! There was no sign that they had asked any of these close associates if anyone went to Hawaii.

Trump himself declined to be interviewed for the Times report. That said, there was no sign that the Times had forwarded those questions to Trump, or to his official campaign. Had Trump been lying all along? Despite the suspicion they voiced at the end of their report, the Times reporters had been too polite to ask!

Donald J. Trump did a terrible thing when he ran that birther scam. He conducted an assault on the nation's discourse. Also on the gullible voters who failed to see through the scam.

A full year after he declared, the New York Times finally got around to writing about this episode. And when they did, they meekly agreed not to pose the key question:

Had Donald J. Trump been lying about this ugly affair all along?

Was Donald Trump lying all along? Admit it! To this day, you've never seen a single journalist pose that question to Trump.

Cooper has interviewed Trump again and again, especially during the primaries. But he never asked that obvious question. Dearest darlings, he seemed to know that such things simply aren't done!

Cooper was like a lazer last night. Everything else disappeared.

Coming Monday: President Clinton in Africa, via Gene Lyons' new column

Donald J. Trump, The Big He, JFK!

FRIDAY, OCTOBER 14, 2016

Where the non-discourse stands:
Is it possible that Ben Carson could be ever-so-tinily right?

During this year's primary campaign, Carson helped show the world how The Culture of Crazy has metastasized all through the discourse. To some extent, he kept it up on today's Morning Joe, the cable program where sanity, clarity and good faith go to die each day.

To watch this morning's segment with Carson, click here.

In our view, Carson's a nightmare manifestation of The Creeping Big Crazy. That said, we couldn't help sympathizing with his claim that the focus on Donald J. Trump's historical groping is keeping us from discussing the real issues in this campaign.

For the record, Donald J. Trump's historical groping is a real issue, at least of a type. That said, we have a hard time discussing such issues, except when such an issue gets tangled up in a presidential campaign.

Other than that, it doesn't much seem that we care.

Meanwhile, it's perfectly clear that we're incapable of discussing anything else, even in a presidential campaign. Our press corps wasn't even willing to discuss Trump's history of birtherism for the first fifteen months of this campaign. If the conduct doesn't involve sex or sexual aggression, our tiny small brains are no longer capable of focusing for more than a very few seconds.

Meanwhile, it's plain that we're going to discuss Donald J. Trump's historical groping for the rest of this campaign. No other topic will ever intrude. As a people, we're no longer capable of discussing anything else. Nothing could be more plain.

Let's be honest for once; sexual-themed misconduct/violence fires us up! (Check the exciting TV ad for The Girl on the Train. Dragged away by her very full head of hair! Accepted as delicious.) We know how to react to nothing else. By way of contrast, our cable entertainers will now be pseudo-discussing this topic all night, every night, for the next three-plus weeks.

Plus, they'll read the new polls.

In a small tiny way, we sympathized with Carson's complaint today. That said, we've been struck by how inept we are, even at discussing Donald J. Trump's historical groping.

All over CNN and MSNBC last night, we were told about the wonders of Michelle Obama's speech. No one seemed to have any idea how that speech will appear to those on The Other Side, not without valid reason.

With great passion, Michelle Obama was saying we can't allow a groper to get into the White House. What message will that send the kids, she asked. On its face, that looked like a sensible question.

Here's the problem. Over on The Other Side, everyone thinks that's what we're doing if we let the Clintons back in! What does Michelle Obama think about that? There's no chance she'll ever tell you. Over on The Other Side, people are noticing that.

Our team is skilled at reciting our current script: Bill Clinton isn't running for president. That's technically accurate, of course. But we don't seem to have any idea how this current state of affairs may look on The Other Side.

Please understand: those on The Other Side believe that Bill Clinton is an historical groper, and a rapist to boot. They've been told this for years and years. Now they're also being told that Hillary Clinton attacked the women her husband groped and raped.

Our team is too dumb to understand, or to care about, the way these claims have spread. We're too dumb to see the way the New York Times plays both ends against the middle with such delicious fare. We're too phony to ask ourselves if people like Broaddrick, Willey and Flowers could possibly be telling the truth. (For the record, Flowers has never claimed any misconduct by Bill Clinton. After all, her Bill was the only man she ever loved.)

In recent days, we've seen our corporate chew-toys go on CNN and MSNBC and pretend to "fact check" their claims. Our team is too dumb, and too uncaring, to see how poorly they do with this task. We're happy to yell at Donald J. Trump for his historical groping. We're too phony to confront, or care about, the way The Other Team feels about corresponding claims concerning William J. Clinton.

Personally, we regard Willey and Flowers as extremely non-credible accusers. But last week, the New York Times built Flowers' credibility up in an absurdly selective, 2900-word piece which appeared on page one. They even pimped Connie Hamzy!

Our weak-minded "liberal" boys didn't say a word. Dearest darlings, use your heads! It simply isn't done!

Just this morning, we saw Ari Melber pretending to explain and fact-check Willey's claims. He wasn't willing to tell his viewers that the Ken Starr gang formally reported that they considered charging her with perjury, she'd lied to them so much. He certainly didn't mention the time when Willey and Chris Matthews teamed up in a wildly irresponsible way to make a false accusation on the air, a provably false and crazy claim which almost got journalist [Name Withheld] killed.

(Pat Buchanan's brother, who was mentally ill, went to the journalist's house with a gun, where he was arrested. You see, Willey had been pretty sure that the journalist murdered her cat, as a warning. Matthews said the journalist's name for her on the air. As it turned out, the journalist had been in California on the night of the alleged murder. The grotesquely irresponsible Matthews is still a big corporate star.)

At any rate, the Starr gang formally said that they considered charging Willey with perjury? Our career players don't care enough to bother with information like that. They know that we'll accept whatever porridge they serve us. It's all about killing time for the hour. No one actually cares.

The Other Side has been told for years that Bill Clinton is a rapist. They've now been told, again and again, that Hillary Clinton savaged her husband's accusers.

We're too lazy to explain why those claims are wrong; to faux to wonder if such claims are right; too haughty to talk to People Like Them, who now believe these claims, especially in the face of our endless silence. In short, we're very unimpressive people. Despite the mountains of misinformation they've swallowed, people in The Other Tribe can sometimes spot this fact.

On Wednesday morning, the New York Times ran a front-page report about Trump supporters' view of the groping/assault charges. We sympathized with the people who made these remarks:
GABRIEL (10/12/16): There were equal numbers of women and men at the rally, and many dismissed as insignificant Mr. Trump’s private comments, caught on the 2005 recording, about being able to grab women by their genitals because he was a “star.”

“When all this baloney came out about Trump, I understand it’s a scandal,” said Brenda Stchur, 56, a Democrat from Hudson, Pa., who supports Mr. Trump. “But John F. Kennedy wasn’t innocent, either, and everyone loves John F. Kennedy.”

Marilyn Sevigny, a retiree from Lake Ariel, Pa., said that “as a woman, I don’t like what he said, I’m not defending it.” But she added that there was a double standard at work. “If a Democrat says it, it’s just words. If a Republican says it, it’s an assault,” she said.
We're sorry, but there is a double standard at work. There was a double standard at work in Michelle Obama's speech, where she begged voters to keep Trump out of the White House without ever saying how she regards the claims about Bill Clinton.

And yes, there's long been a double standard at work concerning President Kennedy. According to her well-written memoir, Mimi Alford really was a White House intern when she was sexually mugged by Kennedy after being procured by an aide. (She was 19, and sexually inexperienced.)

In large part because she isn't angry or a hater, Alford's book is extremely affecting. No one really seems to think it isn't true. Within the crackpot corporate realm which our team accepts from MSNBC, Chris Matthews has always adored his JFK, but spent years savaging the Clintons and Gore while fawning to Bill Clinton's more lunatic accusers.

He then pulled a full 180 when the bosses told him to do so. We're so pitifully undergrown that he is allowed to play this way without a question asked. He's always loved his JFK, thought Bill Clinton was vile.

Our team is untidy, undergrown, basically mush-headed, foul. The Others think we're very bad people. Although they've been disinformed about almost everything, on that point it isn't clear that The Others are wrong.

Our team is happy loathing The Others. We aren't prepared to go where they live and make an attempt to explain. They might insist on talking back! And as HRC made clear that night, we regard them as irredeemable, foul.

Do you think Bill Clinton did all those things? Here within our glorious tribe, why the heck does nobody ask? Isn't it abundantly clear that we don't actually care?

Tomorrow: Bill Clinton among the wretched of the earth

WHERE THE PISA GAPS ARE: A scam concerning immigrant kids!

FRIDAY, OCTOBER 14, 2016

Part 4—Big star hides the facts:
In the aggregate, American kids didn't rock the world on the 2012 PISA.

In the aggregate, American students scored less well than their peers from many comparable nations. That was especially true on the PISA math test.

Perhaps for these reasons, you tend to hear more about the PISA's math test than about its reading and science tests. Perhaps for similar reasons, you rarely hear about results from the 2011 TIMSS at all.

(On the TIMSS and the PIRLS, American students scored much better as compared to the rest of the world.)

In the aggregate, substantial gaps obtained on the PISA between American students and their peers from some comparable countries. As we noted yesterday, the picture may look different, even on the PISA, if we "disaggregate" American scores.

Here's how the PISA reading test suddenly looks, at least in part, if we "disaggregate" American scores. At least one international gap starts to shrink. As it does, our nation's educational challenges may start to become more clear.

We're including the major developed nations, plus Finland and its Nordic neighbors. For a full list of scores, click here:
Average scores, Reading literacy, 2012 PISA
Japan: 538
South Korea: 536
Finland: 524
Canada: 523
Taiwan: 523
United States, white students: 519
Australia: 512
Germany: 508
France: 505
Norway: 504
United Kingdom: 499
Italy: 490
Spain: 488
Sweden: 483
Russia: 475
Note: According to an endnote in Amanda Ripley's book, The Smartest Kids in the World, 39 points on the PISA scale "is considered the equivalent of one year of formal schooling." Now, back to those reading scores, where disaggregation of U.S. scores can teach some painful lessons.

Even on the PISA, white students in the U.S. don't seem to show up as an international embarrassment. Meanwhile, on the 2011 TIMSS, white students in the U.S. tended to outscore even miraculous Finland.

This helps us remember some basic facts about our educational challenges.

Presumably, our schools could do a much better job educating all our kids. It's also true than many black and Hispanic kids are doing wonderfully well in American schools.

On average, though, our educational challenges are most acute among our black and Hispanic kids. Black kids hail from a segment of the population which was targeted by centuries of brutal attempts to eliminate literacy altogether. Meanwhile, the average score of Hispanic kids is affected by certain immigration policies and practices, along with traditional racial practices.

The average scores of those two groups is also disproportionately affected by low income and poverty. We note these facts for a reason:

For the past dozen years, our journalists and opinion leaders have been flying off for a week in Finland, seeking the answers to our educational challenges in that miraculous land. There has always been an obvious problem with this ridiculous practice.

For starters, very few kids in Finland are affected by poverty. Beyond that, Finland has very few immigrant kids. Also, to their substantial credit, the Finns didn't spend centuries trying to eliminate the culture of literacy from one population group. Finland is saner than we are.

For all these reasons, it has always been rather silly to spend that enjoyable week in Finland looking for ways to address our American educational challenges. You might as well spend a week asking how Hawaii keeps its roads free from snow in the winter.

Demographically, Finland is very different from the United States! Today, let's examine one aspect of that difference—the role played by immigrant kids in the two nations' schools.

As we do, let's examine the lengths to which our opinion leaders will go to deceive the American public in service to standard elite narratives concerning "education reform." This returns us to Amanda Ripley's highly readable, widely-praised book from 2013, The Smartest Kids in the World.

Ripley took the standard trip to the Finland Station. She also traveled to educational super-power South Korea and to Poland, where she said a "Polish miracle" had occurred.

In Chapter 8 of her book, Ripley praised the incredible way Finland educates its immigrant kids. Based on a visit to one Finnish school ("the Tiistila school, just outside Helsinki"), she drew a series of invidious comparisons with the way American schools allegedly behave with their immigrant kids.

According to Ripley, thirty percent of the Tiistila school's 300 kids were "immigrant children" whose families were "poor." Her visit to this school seems to be the only source for the way she fawns about Finland's alleged success with its immigrant students.

Ripley devoted eleven pages to the topic of immigrant kids in Finland. For a good chunk of that time, she let a pair of educators from the Tiistila school praise their own educational greatness at interminable length. In the process, she created the clear impression that the Tiistila school, and Finland's schools in general, were performing brilliantly with their immigrant kids.

(Page 165: "Compared to the rest of Finland, the Tiistila kids performed above average. That was impressive. Better than average in Finland meant better than average just about anywhere else." In such passages, Ripley creates the impression that even the immigrant kids in Finland are outscoring the rest of the world.)

Assuming even minimal competence, Ripley seems to have performed a scam in this part of her book. On the brighter side, this let her denigrate American schools and teachers, thereby advancing mandated scripts about aspects of "education reform."

Ripley's discussion of immigration starts in promising fashion. In this introductory passage, she cites some basic facts, then asks an important question:
RIPLEY (page 158): The more time I spent in Finland, the more I appreciated the rare balance it had struck. Finland had achieved rigor without ruin. It was impossible not to notice something else, too: During my time in [Finland], I saw exactly one black person. In Kim’s classes, everyone looked basically the same. Nationwide, only 3 percent of Finland’s students had immigrant parents (compared to 20 percent of teenagers in the United States).

In fact, Finland, Korea and Poland were all homogeneous places with few immigrants or racial minorities.
Japan and Shanghai, China, two other education superpowers, were similarly bland. Maybe homogeneity was a prerequisite for rigor at scale. Did sameness beget harmony, which somehow boosted learning? If so, was Finland irrelevant to a big, jangling place like the United States?
In an endote, Ripley cites a specific OECD document in support of those accurate statistical claims. (Click here, scroll to Table A5.2.) As you can see from that chart, Finland had one of the lowest percentage of "students with immigrant parents" in Europe. (The precise percentage was 2.6%.) Essentially, Poland and South Korea had no immigrant kids at all.

Meanwhile, the percentage of immigrant kids in American schools dwarfed the percentage in Finland. On this basis, Ripley asked a very good question:

Given this type of demographic difference, "is Finland irrelevant to a big, jangling place like the United States?"

That's an extremely good question! That said, two important points should be stated concerning immigrant kids.

First, many immigrant kids are doing wonderfully well in American schools. On average, our immigrant kids score less well on academic tests than our non-immigrant kids. But as with black and Hispanic kids, many of our immigrant kids are doing very well in school.

Here's a second point: not all groups of immigrant kids are created educationally equal. Depending on their social class and their cultural background, some groups of immigrant kids may outperform the non-immigrant kids in the countries where they live.

In Canada, Australia and New Zealand, immigrant kids tend to outscore their non-immigrant peers on the PISA. In all likelihood, that's because the bulk of immigration to those countries comes from Asian countries with potent education cultures. This performance may also reflect the class background of the immigrant populations in those countries.

Ripley is aware of this basic dynamic. That is clear in the following passage, in which, assuming minimal competence, Ripley stages one of the great intellectual scams:
RIPLEY (page 159-160): Nothing was simple. Diversity could raise or lower test scores, and it did...

Overall, the gap between PISA reading scores for native and immigrant students in the United States was 22 points—better than Germany or France, where the gap was 60 points, but not as impressive as Canada, where the gap was zero. Much depended on the education and income of the immigrant parents, which had a lot to do with the history and immigration policies of a given country.

The rest depended on what the countries did with the children they had...
Ripley spends the next nine pages suggesting that Finland did wonderful things with its immigrant kids. The Tiitsila Two go on and on discussing their own moral and educational greatness. Meanwhile, Ripley gives the plain impression that Finland's immigrant kids are rocking the world on their academic tests.

She offers several ugly anecdotal putdowns of our "indoctrinated" American teachers. It's anecdote and propaganda pretty much all the way down.

According to Ripley, Finland is doing great things with its immigrant kids because teachers like the Tiistila Two pay no attention to concerns about issues like poverty. According to Ripley's presentation, they maintain "high expectations" for their immigrant kids in the way our hapless American teachers do not.

They don't accept any excuses, the way our stumblebums do. As she gushes about Finland's approach to its immigrant kids, Ripley touches some very familiar bases. She cites the points that will tend to keep a journalist well funded, given current funding regimes in the realm of public education.

Ripley gushes about Finland's greatness, denigrates our own teachers and schools. Below, you'll see two pieces of data she forgot to mention as she staged this apparent scam.

These data come from the source Ripley cites with respect to the passage we've just posted. (Once again, she cites that same Table A5.2. Click here, then scroll down.)

In that passage, Ripley seems to scold the United States for its 22-point achievement gap between immigrant and non-immigrant kids. But how strange! She forgot to say that Finland's corresponding achievement gap was more than three times as large:
Achievement gap, immigrant versus non-immigrant kids
Reading literacy, 2012 PISA

United States: 22 points
Finland: 70 points

Source: Table A5.2
How weird! In the passage we've just cited, Ripley scolds the United States for that 22-point gap. She forgets to say that the corresponding gap in miraculous Finland is a walloping 70 points!

By the way—Tiitsila's self-proclaimed greatness to the side, how well did Finland's immigrant kids actually score on that PISA reading test, as compared to America's immigrant kids? Here again, we're using the very table Ripley cites in her endnote:
Average scores, Reading literacy, 2012 PISA
Immigrant students only

United States: 484
Finland: 468

Source: Table A5.2
American immigrant kids outperformed their peers in Finland on the very test Ripley cited! From page 158 through page 168, Ripley works very hard to convey the opposite impression. We're not sure we've ever seen an apparent scam this large in a high-profile book of this type.

For the record, those comparative scores don't necessarily mean that American schools "did a better job" with their immigrant kids. It all depends on the background of the immigrant kids in question. One group of such kids may present a greater set of challenges, based (for example) on their culture of origin and the status of language issues.

Who knows? Finland's immigrant kids may have presented a special set of challenges. But Ripley plainly implies that Finland's immigrant kids were outscoring the world on academic tests. That claim is blatantly wrong. Her sneering about American teachers seems especially vile in the face of her two pieces of disappeared data. A cynic might say that these are the things our journalists do to stay on the good side of grants.

Here in the United States, our large numbers of immigrant kids do present educational challenges. But so does the type of outright dissembling featured in this part of Ripley's book.

Next week, we'll finish our ongoing five-week series with a final set of reports, Where the Challenges Are. For now, we'l only say this:

Some of our educational challenges exist in our classrooms, even in our homes. But other challenges exist in the wider world, where thumbs are routinely placed on the scale to advance gloomy, destructive, mandated claims about our embarrassing schools. (Donald J. Trump loves to repeat these destructive, mandated claims.)

Ripley's passage on immigrant kids is one of the worst we've ever seen. But as we'll note next week, she played similar games elsewhere in her book—in a book which was widely discussed and widely praised.

Alas! Perhaps because of the endless chase for foundation money supporting certain types of "education reform," these practices are quite persistent when our journalists pretend to tell us Where the Test Scores Are.

Next week: Where the Challenges Are

Bob Dylan takes a very large prize!

THURSDAY, OCTOBER 13, 2016

An enduring lesson in pity:
Bob Dylan has won the Nobel Prize for literature, or at least that's what the smart set is currently claiming. Most likely, it happened because we thought about him just this Tuesday morning.

In some ways, our favorite Dylan album is New Morning, because it's about discovering, fairly early in life, that you know how to be happy. But when we read David Brook's column this Tuesday, we thought about the Dylan lyric which comes to us more than any other:
BROOKS (10/11/16): Politics is an effort to make human connection, but Trump seems incapable of that. He is essentially adviser-less, friendless. His campaign team is made up of cold mercenaries at best and Roger Ailes at worst. His party treats him as a stench it can’t yet remove.

He was a germophobe through most of his life and cut off contact with others, and now I just picture him alone in the middle of the night, tweeting out hatred.

Trump breaks his own world record for being appalling on a weekly basis, but as the campaign sinks to new low after new low, I find myself experiencing feelings of deep sadness and pity.
For reasons he goes on to explain, Brooks is able to feel pity for the lost soul Trump. We think that's a good thing to do. It made us think of our most durable Dylan lyrics:
I pity the poor immigrant
Who wishes he would’ve stayed home
Who uses all his power to do evil
But in the end is always left so alone
That man whom with his fingers cheats
Who lies with ev’ry breath
Who passionately hates his life
And likewise fears his death

I pity the poor immigrant
Whose strength is spent in vain
Whose heaven is like Ironsides
Whose tears are like rain
Who eats but is not satisfied
Who hears but does not see
Who falls in love with wealth itself
And turns his back on me.
Who eats but is not satisfied, who hears but does not see. Who falls in love with wealth itself, and turns his back on me!

We recommend pity for lost fallen souls. It takes us much farther than hate.

Post editors spot a nothing-burger!

THURSDAY, OCTOBER 13, 2016

They may have had Chozick in mind:
On Tuesday morning, the Washington Post wrote a sensible editorial.

Like Kevin Drum before them, the editors said those WikiLeaks excerpts from Candidate Clinton's paid speeches were just a big nothing-burger. The editors criticized Clinton for refusing to release the transcripts of the speeches. But they said the dozen excerpts which were hacked from a John Podesta email were just a big pile of piddle.

At the end of their editorial, the editors described an increasingly familiar process. They explained how nothing-burgers of this type are turned into phony scandals:
WASHINGTON POST EDITORIAL (10/11/16): ...Then there’s her much-maligned view that “you need both a public and a private position,” which is playing as a confession of two-facedness but is actually a clumsy formulation of obvious truth: Nothing gets done in politics unless legislators can deliberate and negotiate candidly, outside the glare of publicity.

This whole episode illustrates that point. Ms. Clinton kept the speeches under wraps out of fear that they would be distorted for political purposes by her populist foes. Alas, that fear was amply justified in this populistic, polarized environment, as the manufactured uproar over their release proves. The fact that Ms. Clinton’s eminently reasonable and open-minded words regarding the issues and her opponents are being treated as scandalous is the real scandal.
The editors said that Clinton should have released the transcripts of her speeches. But at the end of their editorial, they made an obvious point. Given the way our discourse now works, any document, transcript or text will be demagogued loudly and dumbly.

For what it's worth, the Clintons surely came to this realization many years ago.

The editors criticized the "manufactured uproar" over those bland speech excerpts. According to the editors, Clinton's "eminently reasonable" remarks were being "treated as scandalous" when they actually weren't.

The editors were too polite to say what follows, so we'll say it for them. That is exactly the way Amy Chozick treated those excerpts in her New York Times news report about the leaked speech excerpts.

Let's consider one of the dozen excerpts from Clinton's paid speeches. Chozick gave this particular excerpt substantial play in her news report. Here's the excerpt in question, reproduced in its entirety:
CLINTON (2/4/14): And I am not taking a position on any policy, but I do think there is a growing sense of anxiety and even anger in the country over the feeling that the game is rigged. And I never had that feeling when I was growing up. Never. I mean, were there really rich people, of course there were. My father loved to complain about big business and big government, but we had a solid middle class upbringing. We had good public schools. We had accessible health care. We had our little, you know, one-family house that, you know, he saved up his money, didn't believe in mortgages. So I lived that. And now, obviously, I'm kind of far removed because the life I've lived and the economic, you know, fortunes that my husband and I now enjoy, but I haven't forgotten it.
That's the total excerpt. It's been pulled out of its larger context in Clinton's speech, whatever that larger context may have been. For that reason, Clinton's overall meaning in this excerpt isn't entirely clear.

That said, Clinton seems to be saying this:

There is a growing sense among many people that the game is rigged. During her own middle-class upbringing, she never had that feeling. When she was growing up, middle-class families had health care and access to good schools; they could afford to own their own homes. Today, Clinton is much wealthier, but she hasn't forgotten what middle-class life was like.

Can any sensible person explain why that statement would be objectionable? Presumably, no—but Amy Chozick knew how to make it seem that way.

In fact, Chozick behaved in exactly the way the editors describe. Here she is, in paragraph 4, referring to that particular excerpt and doctoring it a bit:
CHOZICK (10/8/16): In the excerpts from her paid speeches to financial institutions and corporate audiences, Mrs. Clinton said she dreamed of ''open trade and open borders'' throughout the Western Hemisphere. Citing the back-room deal-making and arm-twisting used by Abraham Lincoln, she mused on the necessity of having ''both a public and a private position'' on politically contentious issues. Reflecting in 2014 on the rage against political and economic elites that swept the country after the 2008 financial crash, Mrs. Clinton acknowledged that her family's rising wealth had made her ''kind of far removed'' from the struggles of the middle class.
Clinton said she hasn't forgotten the nature of life in the middle class. By dropping that part of her statement, Chozick seems to reverse the general thrust of that excerpt.

By saying that she hasn't forgotten the world in which she grew up, Clinton seemed to be sympathizing who those now feel the system is rigged against them. But Chozick omitted the part of the statement which seemed to convey that sympathy. In Chozick's account, Clinton simply said that she's "kind of far removed" from middle-class struggles. Full stop!

That isn't what Clinton said. Later, it became clear that Chozick always knew that:
CHOZICK: Such comments could have proven devastating to Mrs. Clinton during the Democratic primary fight, when Mr. Sanders promoted himself as the enemy of Wall Street and of a rigged economic system.

Several of the most eye-popping passages ultimately express more nuanced explanations of her views. When Mrs. Clinton describes herself as ''far removed'' from average Americans and their finances, she had just finished describing her growing appreciation for how ''anxiety and even anger in the country over the feeling that the game is rigged.'' And she reminds the audience that her father ''loved to complain about big business and big government.''
Even here, Chozick avoids the apparent meaning of Clinton's statement that she "hasn't forgotten." Even after taking two bites of the apple, Chozick never reports that part of Clinton's statement. And by the way, riddle us this:

If Clinton "described her growing appreciation for how 'anxiety and even anger in the country over the feeling that the game is rigged,'" in what way was this excerpt an "eye-popping passage?" Why would such a statement "have proven devastating" to her primary campaign?

The answer is obvious. That statement is "eye-popping" and potentially "devastating" only if you send it through the manufactured scandal machine, as the editors at the Post described. In that way, hacks like Chozick keep producing "manufactured uproars." They do it by doctoring nothing-burgers to make it sound like they're "scandalous."

Chozick subjected several of Clinton's remarks to this phony treatment. She makes it sound, at two separate points, like Clinton endorsed specific parts of the Simpson-Bowles plan—parts of the plan she plainly didn't endorse.

In the relevant excerpt, Clinton spoke well of the "framework" of the plan, not of its particular planks. Chozick manufactured outrage by blurring this very basic distinction—not just once, but at two separate points in her crappy report.

Chozick is easily the most horrible new upper-end journalist of the past several years. That said, her work is typical of the New York Times' approach to domestic politics in this, the age which has followed the era of "Creeping Dowdism."

The editors didn't cite Chozick by name. They described her work to a T.

WHERE THE PISA GAPS ARE: Large gaps within the American scores!

THURSDAY, OCTOBER 13, 2016

Part 2 in this series

Part 3—The shape of our demographics: In December 2012, results were released from the latest quadrennial administration of the TIMSS and the PIRLS.

This latest testing had occurred in 2011. As we noted yesterday, American students had performed rather well as compared to their peers around the world. Unless you read the New York Times, where Motoko Rich's news report started like this, gloomy headline included:
RICH (12/11/12): U.S. Students Still Lag Globally In Math and Science, Tests Show

Fourth- and eighth-grade students in the United States continue to lag behind students in several East Asian countries and some European nations in math and science,
although American fourth graders are closer to the top performers in reading, according to test results released on Tuesday.

Fretting about how American schools compare with those in other countries has become a regular pastime in education circles. Results from two new reports, the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study and the Progress in International Reading Literacy Study, are likely to fuel further debate.

South Korea and Singapore led the international rankings in math and fourth-grade science, while Singapore and Taiwan had the top-performing students in eighth-grade science. The United States ranked 11th in fourth-grade math, 9th in eighth-grade math, 7th in fourth-grade science and 10th in eighth-grade science.

Although the average scores among American students were not significantly lower than the top performers, several nations far outstripped the United States in the proportion of students who scored at the highest levels on the math and science tests.
"Several nations" did that! The New York Times was finding ways to see the glass slightly empty.

Technically, nothing in that passage is flatly false. Everything in that passage can perhaps be defended as technically accurate, although the claim about "lagging behind some European nations" was a substantial stretch.

Yesterday, we showed you how USA Today reported those same test results. The more plebeian, multi-hued newspaper saw the glass 90 percent full as it reviewed these newest international scores. Hewing to establishment narrative, the New York Times seemed to see the glass 10 percent empty.

Gloom-and-doom frameworks routinely prevail when the American press reports on American schools. In our view, the New York Times went a bit overboard in its gloomy assessment of those TIMSS scores. That said, when the latest PISA scores were released—those from the 2012 testing—American students performed less well as compared to the rest of the world.

Yesterday, we reviewed the achievement gaps which obtained on the 2012 PISA. That is to say, we looked at the international achievement gaps—the gaps which obtained between American kids (in the aggregate) and their peers from other countries.

On the PISA math test, American students performed less well than their counterparts in almost all comparable countries. On this second major testing program, American students stacked up less well than they had on the TIMSS and the PIRLS.

What explains the difference performances on these two testing programs? That question lies beyond the scope of this series. We'll only the note the heavier weight given by the American press to results from the PISA.

As in Amanda Ripley's high-profile book, The Smartest Kids in the World, American journalists tend to discuss the less impressive American results from the PISA while disappearing the more impressive results from the TIMSS and the PIRLS. This tends to advance a gloomy portrait of the way our schools stack up as compared to the rest of the world.

That said, substantial gaps obtained on the PISA between American students and some of their peers in the rest of the world. That was especially true on the PISA math test. But those are the international gaps. For today, we'll review the domestic achievement gaps which obtained on the 2012 PISA and on the 2011 TIMSS.

We refer to the gaps which obtained between different groups of American students on these international tests. It's painful to review these gaps, but they help us see the shape of our ongoing educational challenges.

Let's start with the PISA reading test, where the average score of American students basically matched the OECD average. Because Finland is so often used as a basis for international comparisons, we'll include that nation's scores in all the presentations which follow.

How did different groups of American students score on that test? When we "disaggregate" the American data, painful domestic gaps appear, although one other gap narrows:
Average scores, reading literacy, 2012 PISA
Finland: 524
United States, white students: 519
United States: 498
United States, Hispanic students: 478
United States, black students: 443
Over the past dozen years, Finland has been relentlessly praised, within the press, for its miraculous public schools. Routinely, journalists have flown to Finland for a week of brainwashing by Finland's education ministry, whose love of propaganda is the one negative trait we know about in that small, distant middle-class land.

Finland has been endlessly praised for its superlative schools. That said, white students in the U.S. essentially matched their peers in Finland on this particular test. In her PISA-friendly book, Ripley seems to say that thirty points on the PISA scale is roughly equal to one academic year. A five-point gap on the PISA scale is a rather modest amount.

On this test, a rather small gap obtained between white American students and their Finnish peers. That said, large gaps obtained between those white American students and their black and Hispanic American peers.

Those painful domestic achievement gaps help define our ongoing educational challenge. What explains their existence?

For ourselves, we'd start with American history. Our benighted ancestors spent several centuries trying to eliminate literacy from the black population. Their horrible efforts failed, but a nation can't spend centuries engaged in such demented practices without reaping the effects of what it so brutally sowed.

For ourselves, we'd start with American history. Other people will suggest other explanations for those large domestic achievement gaps—explanations involving current educational policies and current social practices.

The attempt to explain those punishing gaps lies beyond the scope of this series. We'll continue to explore the domestic and the international gaps in the remaining reports in this series, including such factors as poverty rates and immigration practices.

That said, equally painful domestic gaps obtained on the other PISA tests in 2012. White students were at least within hailing distance of their peers in Finland, where almost every student hails from the majority ethnicity and culture. Black and Hispanic students lagged far behind:
Average scores, math literacy, 2012 PISA
Finland: 519
United States, white students: 506
United States: 481
United States, Hispanic students: 455
United States, black students: 421

Average scores, science literacy, 2012 PISA
Finland: 545
United States, white students: 528
United States: 497
United States, Hispanic students: 462
United States, black students: 439
Those domestic gaps are painful and large. To the extent that anyone cares, they define a very large part of our ongoing educational challenge.

In Finland, almost every student comes from the majority culture. There's very little child poverty. As we'll note in detail tomorrow, there were very few immigrant kids in Finland's student population when these PISA tests occurred.

In the United States, white students—those from the "majority culture"—lagged behind their Finnish peers on the PISA, but not by gigantic amounts. The larger gaps obtained between different groups of American kids, those from our largest population groups.

So far, we've been looking at the gaps which obtained on the 2012 PISA. That said, the United States and Finland had participated, one year before, on the TIMSS and PIRLS.

In our view, what's sauce for the PISA is sauce for the TIMSS. Here's the way the results broke down on the TIMSS math tests:
Average scores, Grade 4 math, 2011 TIMSS
United States, white students: 559
Finland: 545
United States: 541
United States, Hispanic students: 520
United States, black students: 489

Average scores, Grade 8 math, 2011 TIMSS
United States, white students: 530
Finland: 514
United States: 509
United States, Hispanic students: 485
United States, black students: 465
At both grade levels, white students outperformed Finland on the TIMSS math tests. Black and Hispanic students lagged far behind, defining our ongoing challenge to the extent that we care.

Roughly similar patterns obtained on the TIMSS science tests, and on the PIRLS reading test, which is conducted in Grade 4 only.

By the way, those average scores for white students include all American white students. It includes white kids living in poverty in Appalachia. It includes students in certain states whose traditional stress on education may have lagged behind that in some other states. Even with those demographic challenges, white kids in the U.S. outscored Finland on the TIMSS, came fairly close on the PISA.

In our view, these "disaggregated" test results speak to two basic issues. For starters, they help us see the foolishness of the past dozen years of Finland public school chic.

Let's assume that Finland has wonderful schools. There may be lessons that someone can learn from such schools. But the heart of our educational challenge is built in the populations which don't really exist in Finland—populations affected by our brutal racial history, by our higher incidence of poverty, by the low-income immigration practices which don't exist in Finland.

When American journalists fly to Finland, they can't see such challenges addressed. By and large, such challenges don't exist there.

In our view, these data start to point to the foolishness of Finland chic. Beyond that, the punishing domestic achievement gaps found in these basic data helps us see where our challenges lie.

Can we learn how to address those challenges by having our journalists party in Finland? Tomorrow, we'll look at what Amanda Ripley wrote in her widely-praised book about Finland's alleged success with its immigrant kids.

We're not sure we've ever seen a bigger journalistic con in such a high-profile text. Truly, there's nothing elites won't say and do to advance their narrative about our sad embarrassing schools and the horrible terrible pitiful children and adults within them.

Tomorrow: Immigration here and there

Is Rachel Maddow out of her mind?

WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 12, 2016

It might be time to check:
Yesterday afternoon, Al Gore appeared with Candidate Clinton in Miami, where they discussed climate change.

In our view, Clinton gave about as good a speech as we've ever seen her give. Inevitably, though, the children searched for ways to gossip and snark about Gore.

We were amazed by Rachel Maddow's treatment of the event. Let's start with the peculiar way she teased her upcoming segment:
MADDOW (10/11/16): ...Ralph Nader went on for decades campaigning for consumer safety and for integrity and openness in government. And then he decided that he wanted to campaign for himself for president in the election year 2000. Liberals' knock on the nominee that year, Al Gore, was he was boring, he wasn't all that different from George W. Bush, but liberal Ralph Nader, he sure was different. He ran on a Green Party ticket. He grew crowds, he was a crusading hero especially with young voters.
Really? "Liberals' knock on [Candidate] Gore was he wasn't all that different from George W. Bush?"

We can think of only one "liberal" who argued that line. That was the ridiculous Frank Rich, who's often introduced by Maddow as "the great Frank Rich."

From March 2000 right on to through November, Rich kept insisting that Bush and Gore were just two privileged peas in a pod. It was a very stupid analysis, apparently part of Rich's endless Clinton-loathing. It helped send Bush to the White House.

Rich continued trashing Gore until he won the Nobel Peace Prize. (At that point, Rich pulled an instant 180.) In 2002, Rich trashed Gore as a fake and a phony when he urged against going to war in Iraq. In 2006, he trashed him as a fake and a phony when his film, An Inconvenient Truth, came out.

Rich is the only "liberal" we know who argued that Candidate Gore wasn't all that different from Candidate Bush. That said, the real absurdity came when Maddow talked about what Gore has been doing in the years since Campaign 2000.

Instead of discussing Clinton's speech about climate change, Maddow engaged in the usual lame-o gossip girl glop about earlier Clinton/Gore relations. After showing entertaining old footage of Bill Clinton at a McDonald's, she played Gore's concession speech from December 2000, then weirdly offered this:
MADDOW: Al Gore's concession speech in 2000. Since then we've not seen a lot of him at Democratic Party politics. He did speak at President Obama's convention in 2008, and he campaigned for President Obama that year. But he didn't attend the 2012 convention in Charlotte and he also skipped Hillary Clinton's convention this year. He said he had obligations in Tennessee.

That came after Al Gore basically sat out this year's Democratic contest entirely. He did finally endorse Hillary Clinton in a series of three tweets on the opening day of her convention. No rush.

Al Gore basically beamed himself out of Democratic politics after what happened to him in 2000. The last time he had a chance to campaign with a Clinton in 2000, he jumped away from that chance, not toward it. Now today, today he's back.
Maddow skipped Gore's endorsement of Howard Dean during the 2004 primaries. That was a fairly minor mistake, but she was snarking in some standard ways—the standard ways which, long ago, made it pointless for Gore to involve himself in politics.

Still, the full-tilt weirdness was yet to come. You can peruse it below, as Maddow poses her first question to her guest, E. J. Dionne.

Maddow played a blip of tape from Gore yesterday in Miami. Weirdly, she then said this:
MADDOW: Former Vice President Al Gore with Hillary Clinton today, naturally in Florida. Not to underscore the point too much, but in Florida. At a time when the Clinton campaign looks like it may, may be sewing things up in this election, why is today the day they brought Al Gore back? And what's he been doing anyway?

Joining us is the great and good E.J. Dionne,
Washington Post columnist, senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and a great all-around person. E.J., it's lovely to see you. Thank you for being here.

DIONNE: It's great to be with you, Rachel. Thanks so much.

MADDOW: Let me ask you if you know what Al Gore has been up to all of these years? We did see him briefly in 2008, but I feel like other than his climate activism, which I'm a little bit aware of, I don't know what he's been doing.
Did the increasingly ridiculous Maddow actually say that? Let's repeat what she said:

"Why is today the day they brought Al Gore back? And what's he been doing anyway?...Let me ask you if you know what Al Gore has been up to all of these years? We did see him briefly in 2008, but I feel like other than his climate activism, which I'm a little bit aware of, I don't know what he's been doing."

Can that possibly be what Maddow meant to say? Please note:

Just before "we saw him briefly in 2008," some of us "saw him briefly in 2007" winning the Nobel Peace Prize.

The year before that, in 2006, we saw him starring for almost two hours in the documentary film, An Inconvenient Truth. In 2007, we saw him in Hollywood, where the film won the Oscar for Best Documentary.

Maddow seems to have missed all that. Weirdly, she said she's "a little bit aware of his climate activism," but the great and good Dionne pretty much had to fill her in. The pair went on to offer an utterly pointless segment. The fault lay with Maddow, not with Dionne.

We're often struck by Maddow's cluelessness about the 1990s, which often seems to turn up as deeply under-informed disdain for Bill Clinton. Last night, she seemed to be extending her studied disdain and her cluelessness to Clinton's running mate.

Perhaps that wasn't intended. But what a ridiculous summary! And by the way, might we talk?

The mainstream press corps, Dionne and especially Rich included, turned Gore into a laugh line. It's a large part of the reason why he isn't especially helpful at this point as a political figure. It helps explain why it was easy for crackpot conservatives to turn his award-winning film on climate change into a punching bag.

It won an Oscar, then its author won the Nobel Peace Prize. But in the world presided over by corporate trolls like Maddow, it became the latest source of gong-show disputation. Gore and his film became targets of Trumpism long before we had a Candidate Trump.

How many political figures are ever right about anything at all, let alone about a deeply serious issue like climate change? Progressives actually ought to honor such unusual work.

Instead, along come corporate clowns like Maddow, eager to praise the greatness of the MSM hacks who helped make Gore an industry-wide punch line. She rubs against the legs of the figures who will in turn praise her today.

Has anyone ever displayed the corrosive power of wealth and fame in quite the way Maddow has? Elvis died on the toilet one day. "Dr. Maddow" has died before our eyes, right there on corporate air.

Candidate Clinton discussed climate change!

WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 12, 2016

The Times turned it into soap opera:
Yesterday afternoon, thanks to cable, we happened to see Candidate Clinton giving a rather good speech.

We're not sure when we've seen her give such a good speech. In Miami, she spoke about climate change. She delivered an informative speech with a good deal of natural energy.

Candidate Clinton discussed climate change. Unless you read the New York Times, where a lengthy non-report news report gave you a pile of soap opera.

You see, Candidate Clinton was accompanied by former Vice President Gore. In 2007, Gore actually won a Nobel Peace Prize for his work on climate change.

Rachel Maddow didn't seem to know that last night. She offered an amazingly strange recitation of Gore's post-White House career, in which she seemed to have no idea what Gore had done in that time. (We'll post her transcript later today.)

In this morning's New York Times, Matt Flegenheimer did know that Gore won the Nobel Peace Prize. But when it came to the challenge posed by climate change, he didn't much seem to care.

What the heck is Matt Flegenheimer? After reading his soap operatic report, we finally decided to check.

As it turns out, Flegenheimer graduated from Penn in 2011, just five years ago. At Penn, he had been a sports writer! At the Times, that's background enough to be sent on the trail as the world's most important topics are being discussed.

In this morning's report, Flegenheimer finally mentioned what Candidate Clinton said about climate science. More accurately, he mentioned a tiny part of what she said, starting in paragraph 29!

How did he kill the rest of his space before boring us silly with a tiny bit of serious talk? Simple! He wasted our time with silly soap opera musings from the Clinton White House years and from Campaign 2000.

How did Hillary and Al get along long ago, in their "fraught relationship?" Working from standard press corps tales, the silly lad was puzzling hard. But good God! By paragraph 17, he was even typing the first highlighted claim:
FLEGENHEIMER (10/12/16): After Bill Clinton's 1992 election, Mr. Gore and Mrs. Clinton quickly established themselves as rivals for Mr. Clinton's ear—a pair of policy wonks seeking influence in a new administration.

It was their similarities, at least in part, that seemed to compel Mr. Clinton to choose Mr. Gore in the first place. ''He reminds me of Hillary,'' Mr. Clinton told a former top aide, Paul Begala, according to Mr. Begala. ''When he gets hold of something, he never lets loose.''

Together with the vice president and his former wife, Tipper, the Clintons shared dinners and concerts, White House bowling outings and nights at Camp David.
Flegenheimer failed to provide the scores from those bowling outings. Regarding the claim that Bill Clinton was compelled to pick Gore to run for VP because he reminded him of his wife, the claim dates to this soap operatic news report from October 2000. The initial claim came from the pen of Melinda Henneberger, with extremely light documentation.

Henneberger was exploring the soap opera of the moment—the claim that Gore and Bill Clinton were on the outs as Campaign 2000 neared its end. The reporting on that opera continued after the November election, and after the election's outcome was finally decided.

By happenstance, we happened to gain a tiny first-hand insight, on the night in December when Gore conceded, into that highly fraught tale. It's how we ended up on page 934 of Clinton's slender memoir, My Life, identified only as "a friend [of Gore's] who was a professional comedian."

Can we talk? However fraught their relationship was, the principals were swapping jokes by trans-Atlantic phone on the evening of Gore's concession. (President Clinton was winging his way home from England.) To read about the way Bill Clinton emerged from the cabin of Air Force One to repeat the joke in question to the press that night, just read the final page of Roger Simon's deathless book about Campaign 2000, Divided We Stand.

(One week later, we went through the receiving line at a White House cattle-call Christmas party. Clinton repeated the joke to all around. "There's a great deal of truth to that joke," the president wisely declared.)

How fraught was that particular opera in December 2000? We have no idea, but the boys were swapping jokes on the night when Candidate Gore finally had to concede. For reasons like that and a million more, we're never strongly inclined to believe the manicured personality tales young fellows like Flegenheimer recite. That said, this is the type of silly, low-IQ, non-challenging stuff the New York Times simply adores when it pretends to report on domestic politics.

Clinton gave a good speech yesterday about a very important issue. Unless you read the New York Times, in which case you got diverted onto twenty-year-old bowling dates. And needless to say, when Gore's remarks in Miami were mentioned, Flegenheimer was required to hand you this, by the tenets of Hard Pundit Law:
FLEGENHEIMER: Mr. Gore, too, held forth on the cause of his postpolitical life, making his case as if reading from a slide show projection. He quoted Thomas Edison, warned of rising sea levels and lurched into a discussion of comparative solar energy commitments.

''Massachusetts installed more solar energy last year alone than Florida has installed in its entire history!'' he said.

''Ridiculous!'' someone yelled back.

''Yes, it's ridiculous!'' Mr. Gore said. ''That's exactly right.''

By then, some students had buried their heads in their phones.
It was required by Hard Pundit Law. According to its tenets, Flegenheimer knew he had to tell you how boring it is to hear the statements of a Nobel Peace Prize winner who's discussing a very serious topic. It's amazing how quickly These Kids Today are able to learn!

Can we talk? In the course of his political career, Gore committed the ultimate sin. He focused on a serious issue, and he got it right.

Within the addled realms of our upper-end "press," there's no greater sin than 1) being serious about something and 2) being right. They deeply resent the burdens thus placed on their silly childish heads, on silly heads which much prefer to muse about bowling dates.

Clinton gave a very good speech. A bright young fellow who wrote sports at Penn knows how to handle such trials.

WHERE THE PISA GAPS ARE: Substantial international gaps!

WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 12, 2016

Part 1 in this series

Part 2—The PISA conflicts with the TIMSS: In December 2012, a quadrennial event occurred.

Results were released from one of the developed world's two major international public school testing programs. The testing program in question was the Trends in International Math and Science Study (the TIMSS), which includes a companion test in reading achievement, the PIRLS.

The TIMSS had released results from its most recent international testing, which had been conducted in 2011. Given the nature of the results, American newspapers faced a choice:

Should they describe the glass as 10 percent empty? Or should they describe it as being 90 percent full?

Needless to say, the New York Times took the gloomier, mandated route. Because USA Today's Greg Toppo presented a more inclusive summary of the results, we'll enter the start of his report into evidence.

He took the road less traveled by. Upbeat headline included:
TOPPO (12/11/12): USA's schools move up in international rankings

Results from a pair of new international assessments released today show that American kids are holding their own in math, reading and other subjects. In a few cases, they're actually bypassing the rest of the world.

Who knew, for instance, that Florida fourth-graders now read as well as their peers in Singapore and Finland?

[...]

American students' average scores on the Third International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) in math were above the international average in both fourth and eighth grade, the findings show.

Among the 45 countries that participated in fourth grade, the average U.S. math score was among the top eight. In eighth grade, the USA was among the top 11 of 38 countries.

In reading, U.S. students scored 56 points higher than the international average, putting them in the top 13 on the Progress in International Reading Literacy Study (PIRLS). Only five nations or education systems had higher average scores—and one of those was Florida, which asked that its scores be compared with those of other nations.
With respect to the PIRLS, Toppo's reference to "the top 13" may have seemed to conflict which his more straightforward claim, in which "only five nations or education systems had higher average scores" than the United States. (In his claim about "the top 13," Toppo was including statistical ties.)

That said, you can see the full list of PIRLS scores here, with only Russia, Finland and Singapore (narrowly) outscoring the U.S. among the world's actual nations. Beyond that, you can derive a second point from Toppo's generally accurate, upbeat summary:

If we look at these, the most recent TIMSS/PIRLS scores, it's hard to support the familiar claim that U.S. schools, and the children and teachers within them, are a pitiful embarrassing mess.

American students outperformed their peers in most of the world on these international tests. Back in December 2012, Toppo gave an accurate summary of those new results.

Gloom and doom at the New York Times to the side, American kids seemed to have performed rather well on these TIMSS/PIRLS tests. They even came amazingly close to matching the scores of their peers in miraculous Finland, the small, middle-class European nation which had become the darling of propagandists and education journalists shortly after the start of this century.

If we had only the TIMSS and the PIRLS, advocates of certain types of education reform would be facing an uphill climb. In these most recent results from those tests, our American kids didn't seem to be a hopeless comparative mess.

Indeed, a sensible person might have found himself wondering about the educational performance of other nations. Why did American kids, in Grade 4 and Grade 8, create statistical ties with miraculous Finland in math? These were the results in question:
Average scores, Grade 4 math, 2011 TIMSS
Finland: 545
United States: 541

Average scores, Grade 8 math, 2011 TIMSS
Finland: 514
United States: 509
Given the way the TIMSS scale works, those differences are minor. From those scores, a sensible person might actually wonder what's the matter with Finland, a nation with much less poverty than the U.S., many fewer immigrant kids, and no national history in which centuries were spent trying to eliminate literacy from one segment of the population.

American kids had matched their peers from Finland in math? Given the demographic differences, a sensible person might have wanted to know why Finland hadn't scored better!

Why didn't Finland's kids score better on those TIMSS math tests? We can't tell you that. At least one Finnish math professor has complained about certain emphases in Finnish educational practice—emphases which, he has said, send Finnish kids into college with a shaky foundation in the basic math curriculum.

That claim to the side, we can't tell you how a major continental nation like the U.S. managed to match little middle-class Finland in math. We can tell you this:

Thanks to results from the world's other international testing program, such questions don't have to be asked by our education reporters.

That other international program is the Program for International Student Assessment (the PISA), which test 15-year-old students. When the PISA released its latest results, those from its 2012 testing, American kids stacked up less well as compared to the rest of the world.

When you hear the standard gloomy account of how poorly our hapless children perform on international tests, you're almost surely hearing about the PISA. Results from the TIMSS will go unmentioned, in line with prevailing standard elite press corps scripts.

How did American students perform as compared to the rest of the world on the 2012 PISA? Especially in math, their comparative performance wasn't especially good at all.

In reading and in science, the average score of American students basically matched the OECD average. In math, the average score of American students didn't match up even that well.

Because math is the subject in which U.S. kids performed least well on the PISA, that result is most frequently cited. Among OECD nations, here's how some of those math scores looked. We're including the larger OECD nations, plus a few of the usual suspects:
Average scores, Math literacy, 2012 PISA
Taiwan: 560
South Korea: 554
Japan: 536
Netherlands: 523
Finland: 519
Canada: 518
Germany: 514
Australia: 504
Denmark: 500
France: 495
United Kingdom: 494
OECD average: 494
Norway: 489
Italy: 485
Spain: 484
Russia: 482
United States: 481
Sweden: 478
That wasn't a great-looking performance. For full results, click this.

Remember, that was the worst performance by American students on the 2012 PISA. In "reading literacy" and "science literacy," American students basically matched the OECD average scores, and stacked up better as compared to their peers from other specific nations.

(For reading results, click here. For science results, click this.)

That was the worst performance by American students. Still, American students stacked up less well than they had on the TIMSS on all three parts of the PISA. Perhaps for that reason, the American public is constantly told about results from the PISA. Results from the TIMSS are routinely disappeared.

Does that selective presentation make some sort of sense? On the other hand, might it simply be a bow to certain current narrative preferences, in which certain elites prefer to advance a gloomy portrait of American schools?

We can't answer that question. You'll virtually never see it argued, so strong is the mandated journalistic preference for the gloom-and-doom perspective, in which the public is told about the PISA alone.

(In the realm of domestic testing, it's as we noted earlier in this series. The public is told about the achievement gaps, with the very large gains in scores being disappeared. The press corps' preference for gloom-and-doom is ruthlessly enforced. As in so many areas, the narrative must be advanced!)

American students seemed to score rather well on the TIMSS, substantially less well on the PISA. Perhaps because of the mandates of elite preference, the American public hears about the PISA results, with TIMSS results finding their way to the memory hole.

Does that selective presentation of data actually make some sort of sense? We'll briefly ponder that question tomorrow. But this is our week for reviewing the achievement gaps which exist in the PISA results.

On the most recent PISA, some large achievement gaps obtained between American kids and their peers in other nations. Tomorrow, we'll stay on that PISA road, and we'll take a horrible twist.

Tomorrow: Disaggregating the PISA!

The candidate's body language and clothes!

TUESDAY, OCTOBER 11, 2016

It's all at Rosenthal's restaurant:
How dumb is the modern New York Times?

In its political coverage, the famous upper-class Gotham rag is spectacularly dumb. Just consider three major offerings in today's editions, all in the "National" section.

Atop the paper's hard-copy front page, Amy Chozick writes a Tolstoy-length summary of the latest leak from Moscow. Chozick's basic report runs an interminable 1922 words. It's accompanied by hundreds of words of additional text, aimed at subscribers who are especially sleep-resistant.

The mind-numbing dullness of this piece could only have come from Chozick. As noted, it starts atop the paper's front page. Inside the paper, it consumes the whole of page A12, what with its accompanying photos and pointless additional text.

Readers, let's be fair! Chozick's piece is a cancer cure compared to what's found on page A18. The entirety of that page is consumed by two reports. The first examines the body language displayed at Sunday evening's debate. The second is the usual high-flown piddle about Candidate Clinton's clothes.

The report about the body language is written at second-grade level. Alan Rappeport, who's widely believed to be human, starts his report like this:
RAPPEPORT (10/11/16): From the opening handshake that did not happen to the stone-faced stares and surly scowls, it was evident from watching Donald J. Trump and Hillary Clinton share a debate stage on Sunday night that their political differences have become personal and that the mutual distaste that they feel is very real.

With the candidates unshackled from lecterns by the town hall format, the window into their feelings opened a bit wider. As much as their words, it was the physical movements of the candidates that captivated viewers and body language experts.
Forget about the candidates' "words!" Let's round up a passel of "experts" and scan their actual language!

This sort of feature is so dumb it's long since been abandoned on cable. First Chris Matthews, then Bill O'Reilly, decided to let their "body language experts" go. Stupidity abhorring a vacuum, the New York Times may have its eye on this prize.

How expert are these particular experts? Only a man with a string of Ph.D.s could have come up with this:
RAPPEPORT: According to Bart Rossi, a political psychologist and body language expert, Mr. Trump’s facial expressions were more revealing. The disdain that he feels for his opponent could not have been clearer.

“He had almost a frightful face at times,” Mr. Rossi said, pointing out how Mr. Trump’s brow remained furrowed as he squinted for much of the debate. “He was agitated and angry."
No one else would have caught that! Meanwhile, don't miss Ruth Sherman's ruminations on "the forces of 'proxemics.'" Saddest of all was this:
RAPPEPORT: Ms. Sherman said that some of Mrs. Clinton’s subpar reviews could be the result of how she carried herself on the stage, clenching her thumb against her forefinger while speaking and looking down more than usual.

“It’s something people do when they’re thinking, but I think it conveyed a bit of defensiveness,” Ms. Sherman said.
Of course! The Clinton-loathing will never cease, not as long as Clinton insists on clenching her thumb while speaking!

Alan Rappeport's pre-IQ piece burns up more than half the page. It's swollen out by four big photos, which seem to show Candidate Trump standing where he was supposed to be, right next to his chair, despite the mandated cries which came from some of the experts.

The rest of the page was burned by Vanessa Friedman's hopeless posturing about Candidate Clinton's clothes. Is Rush Limbaugh on loan from God? Friedman was on loan from Fashion. As always, she was an upper-class poser. She started out like this:
FRIEDMAN (10/11/16): Has Hillary Clinton found her dresser in chief? It would appear that way.

While the Twitterverse was busy parsing the possible subtexts of Melania Trump’s decision to wear a hot pink Gucci pussy-bow blouse to watch her husband, Donald J. Trump, during the second presidential debate Sunday evening (given his recently revealed lewd comments about women from 2005), it was actually what Mrs. Clinton wore that seemed meaningful to me.
Forget about the candidates' words! Let's focus on what they wore!

Deliciously, Friedman managed to smuggle a P-bomb into her take on the hot Mrs. Trump. This is why we're shelling out that $8 every Sunday!

Trivial emails and body language, with Vanessa Friedman on pussy bows! The New York Times is a low-IQ, upper-class mess, though it tends to be hard for us the humans to process this obvious fact.

Unfounded accusation gains purchase!

TUESDAY, OCTOBER 11, 2016

Thanks to the New York Times:
How do unfounded accusations gain purchase? Gain purchase, then start to worm their way into everyone's heads?

Consider a letter which was published in this morning's New York Times. The writer seems to be a Clinton supporter—but he's also a Trump enabler:
LETTER TO THE NEW YORK TIMES (10/11/16): Let’s assume that what has been charged by both candidates about how the other has treated women is true. That Donald Trump groped and forced himself on married women—because he could. That Hillary Clinton attacked the women her husband was involved with, to discredit them.

Mrs. Clinton acted (rightly or wrongly) out of loyalty,
to defend her husband, and to preserve their marriage and image. Mr. Trump acted for his own sexual gratification, despite his marriage, and to, in his mind, burnish his image. The difference should carry significant weight in that comparison. Motives matter.

P— K—
Charlestown, R.I.
The writer suggests we assume the truth of various accusations. As part of the deal, he suggests we assume that Hillary Clinton really did "attack the women her husband was involved with, to discredit them."

By his second paragraph, he has stopped assuming that this is true; by now, he's describing the motives which lay behind Clinton's actions, which he now seems to treat as a fact. He goes on to suggest that her behavior wouldn't be as bad as certain conduct with which Candidate Trump stands accused, partly because of things he himself has said. In the course of this rumination, he helps advance an ugly claim about Candidate Clinton—a claim for which there is very little evidence.

The New York Times is very dumb to publish a letter like this. But then, this is the New York Times, so what else is new?

Did Candidate Clinton really "attack the women her husband was involved with?" Last Monday, the Times gave legs to this extremely murky claim with a 2900-word "news report" which picked and chose among some very old facts with remarkable skill. One week later, the paper publishes a letter which encourages readers to assume that the claim is true.

The news report was horrible work. The publication of the letter shows horrible journalistic judgment.

But then, this is the New York Times. Readers, what else is new?

WHERE THE PISA GAPS ARE: Amanda Ripley wrote a book!

TUESDAY, OCTOBER 11, 2016

Previous report in this series

Part 1—Half the facts disappeared: In August 2013, a former Time magazine writer published a widely acclaimed, much discussed book about the world's public schools.

Amanda Ripley's ballyhooed book was called The Smartest Kids in the World/And How They Got That Way. One point was clear in Ripley's highly readable presentation:

As it turned out, the smartest kids in the world weren't found in the U.S.! Instead, Ripley focused on three nations whose students, she said, had scored remarkably well on international tests of reading, science and math.

Predictably, some of the smartest kids in the world were found in miraculous Finland. The small, middle-class European country had been a darling of American education writers over the prior decade. In Ripley's book, Finland became one of three countries with "the smartest kids in the world."

Ripley also found the world's smartest kids in South Korea. Again, this was no surprise. South Korea is one of three large Asian nations whose students consistently outscore the rest of the world on the the two international testing programs in which the world's developed nations take part. We refer to the Trends in International Math and Science Studies (the TIMSS) and the Program in International Student Assessment (the PISA).

(The TIMSS has a companion international reading test, the PIRLS.)

Finally, some of the smartest kids in the world were said to be living in Poland. This was perhaps a bit surprising, because this is the way Poland's kids had performed on the latest TIMSS math and science tests, whose results had been released in December 2012:
Average scores, Grade 4 math, 2011 TIMSS
United States: 541
Poland: 481

Average scores, Grade 4 science, 2011 TIMSS
United States: 544
Poland: 505
(Poland didn't participate in the TIMSS on the Grade 8 level.)

Given the way the TIMSS scale works, those were substantial score differentials. Now, Ripley seemed to be describing Poland's students as among the smartest kids in the world, with our pitiful U.S. kids sadly lagging behind.

That said, a funny thing happened to people who read Ripley's widely-praised book. Unless they were education specialists, they had no way of knowing what follows. But as they read Ripley's highly readable book, they learned about results from only one of the developed world's two major testing programs.

Ripley discussed results from the PISA. Results from the TIMSS (and the PIRLS) were, in effect, completely disappeared.

Except in a single endnote, the TIMSS was never mentioned by name at any point in Ripley's book. (The TIMSS was only glancingly named in that lone endnote. The acronym appeared, but not the name. The endnote didn't explain what the acronym meant, or what the TIMSS even is.)

Ripley did cite results from the TIMSS at one point in her book (see page 73). She referred to the TIMSS, without citing its name, as "a major international math test." But she did so only to praise the state of Minnesota for its students' high scores on this unnamed "major international test." She went on to attribute Minnesota's success on this major test to certain types of "education reform."

Ripley never mentioned the high scores achieved by American kids in general on that "major international test." In the course of her entire book, she never said its name.

Readers of Ripley's book were never told that there are two major international testing programs. They learned about results from the PISA. Except for that one targeted use, results from the TIMSS were ignored.

A funny thing happened to readers of Ripley's book. They read a book from which exactly half the international data had in effect been banned. Ripley never told her readers why she had sifted the data this way. Indeed, those readers had no way to know that half the international data were being shielded from view.

On its face, Ripley's presentation of data was strangely selective. On its face, it would be strange to sift the available data this way, without any attempt at explanation, in a 1200-word Sunday newspaper essay.

On its face, this selective sifting of data was only that much more peculiar in a 238-page book.

That said, Ripley's selective presentation had become rather common by the time her book appeared. Especially among advocates of certain types of "education reform," it was now common to do what Ripley had done—to cite results from the PISA, while skipping results from the TIMSS (and the PIRLS).

The United States, and other developed nations, participated in both testing programs. Increasingly, though, only results from the PISA were mentioned. Why in the world was that?

Two possible explanations exist. First, it's commonly said that the PISA focuses on "critical thinking" while the TIMSS focuses on "knowledge of the curriculum." On that basis, a person might judge that the PISA is the more valuable program.

That might be a perfectly valid judgment, though it isn't universally shared. That said, Ripley never explicitly made that case in her widely-praised book. Instead, the TIMSS was simply disappeared, except when its results could be used to praise "education reform."

Is that why Ripley dumped the TIMSS? Did she disappear the TIMSS because she feels the PISA is the only valid measure? Does she believe that the PISA is a substantially better measure?

We can't answer those questions. But there's another possible reason why advocates of "reform" stress the PISA while largely ignoring the TIMSS:

American students have scored less well on the PISA!

When compared to their peers in the rest of the world, American students have scored less well on the PISA. They've scored better on the TIMSS. As such, PISA scores can more fruitfully be used to portray American schools as an embarrassing mess—to argue the case for certain types of "education reform."

Is that why Ripley skipped the TIMSS? We can't answer that. What we can do—what we'll do this week—is offer an overview of the way American students have scored on the PISA.

We'll look at "aggregate" average scores on the PISA—at the average scores achieved by American students as a whole. We'll also "disaggregate" those average scores to look at the performance of major groups within our student population.

How have white American kids performed as compared to the rest of the world? How about black kids and Hispanic kids? How about Asian American students? How have these different groups of kids performed as compared to the rest of the world?

We'll explore an additional question. How have America's immigrant kids performed on the PISA? In one of the most deceptive passages we've ever seen in such a major book, Ripley gives the clear impression that Finland was achieving its usual miracles with its (very small number of) immigrant kids.

We'll show you the data which Ripley withheld. Those data will come directly from the source Ripley cited in one of the most deceptive passages we've ever seen in such a book.

How have American students performed on the PISA? It's an important question. Without forgetting results from the TIMSS, we'll explore the answers (plural) all week.

In many ways—not all—the answers may seem depressing. Within the American student population, very substantial "achievement gaps" exist on both the TIMSS and the PISA.

Those very large gaps may speak to our brutal racial history. They may speak to current educational and social practices. But however daunting those gaps may seem, they help define our ongoing educational challenges. They lead us to next week's final set of reports in this five-week series, a set of reports in which we'll examine this topic:

"Where the Challenges Are."

A final word. Most of our educational challenges are found in our classrooms and homes. But some of our educational challenges are found in the lazy, failing-grade work performed by the American press corps.

Ripley's widely ballyhooed book was highly readable. It many respects, it was highly informative.

It also involved journalistic sleights of hand which should have embarrassed a serious people. But alas! When it comes to the way they discuss our schools, it's hard to say that America's press corps can be described that way. As a group, American "education experts" aren't a whole lot more impressive.

Next week, we'll examine where the challenges are. All this week, we'll be taking a look at the PISA gaps.

Tomorrow: The aggregate scores