Ripley pimps those preferred story lines!

WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 14, 2016

A note on immigrant kids:
How well did American students perform on the 2015 Pisa?

We'll get to that question in time. For ourselves, we haven't yet examined the scores-in-themselves. We're still puzzling about the way the scores are being reported.

This morning, we read the Washington Post's report on the Pisa; we missed it when it appeared last week. At first glance, we were puzzled by the way Joe Heim handled those alleged Chinese scores. Also, by his adherence to a basic rule:

When countries outscore the United States, you lovingly name those countries. When the United States outscores those same countries, those countries will go unnamed.

Heim followed that rule with distinction. For today, let's return to Amanda Ripley's report from the New York Times, a major newspaper which seems to have disappeared the Timss.

Ripley's report appeared on December 8; for our previous treatment, click here. We were struck by the following passage, in which Ripley discusses the miraculous way the Pisa honchos predict which countries are going to do well:
RIPLEY (12/8/16): So how do the researchers make their predictions? The process is not entirely intuitive. They can't, for example, assume that countries that spend the most will do the best (the world's biggest per-student spenders include the United States, Luxembourg and Norway, none of which are education superpowers).

Nor can they guess based on which countries have the least poverty or the fewest immigrants (places like Estonia, with significant child poverty, and Canada, with more immigrant students than the United States, now top the charts). All those factors matter, but they interact with other critical conditions to create brilliance—or not.
Our assessment? With this report for the Times, Ripley seems to have established herself as one of the great, silly propagandists.

In her ballyhooed 2013 book, The Smartest Kids in the World: And How They Got That Way, Ripley included several passages which seemed baldly dishonest. These remarks about poverty and immigration seem to conform to that pattern.

It's true! The highest spending countries won't necessarily produce the highest test scores. No one has ever thought different.

Things start getting murky with Ripley's remarks about "child poverty." On a cross-cultural, international basis, poverty is hard to define and measure. Analysts start talking about relative poverty rather than absolute poverty. Ripley lets this conceptual problem slide in these latest remarks.

Please note: With these remarks, Ripley is batting aside perfectly sensible explanations for lower scores in American schools with lots of low-income and immigrant kids. Within the world of so-called "education reform," such explanations are known as "excuses" and as "reasons for privatization." Propagandists and true believers love the kinds of remarks Ripley is fashioning here.

It's Ripley's remarks about immigration which really give a truth-teller pause. Ripley seems to be working a scam with those comments. Given certain things she wrote in her ballyhooed book, it almost seems that this must be deliberate.

It's true! You can't assume that countries with lots of immigrant kids will be the worst performers—and Canada does make a good example. Canada has lots of immigrant kids, and it does do fairly well on both the Timss and the Pisa.

(Full disclosure: American kids outscored their Canadian peers on the 2015 Timss. You aren't likely to learn such facts from either the Post or the Times.)

Canada has lots of immigrant kids, and it does fairly well on these international tests. But alas! As Ripley knows, it isn't simply how many immigrant kids you have; it's also where they come from.

Canada's immigrant kids are largely from Asia, with its nearly ubiquitous education-at-all-costs cultures. In Canada, immigrant kids actually tend to outscore native-born kids on international tests. That's largely because of the cultural and class backgrounds of those immigrant kids.

In this country, our immigrant kids are more likely to come from low-income, low-education backgrounds. This creates a different kind of challenge for public schools and their teachers. It's perfectly clear from Ripley's book that she understands these basic facts. But there she went again last week, telling roughly half the story in service to preferred story lines from the cult of "reform."

Ripley's book seemed baldly dishonest in more than a couple of spots. Her treatment of Finland's alleged success with its immigrant kids was one of the most glaring such passages.

Ripley seemed to be lying about that success, but she succeeded in conveying desired impressions. For a basic blow-by-blow, see THE DAILY HOWLER, 10/14/16.

Is Amanda Ripley a propagandist? At best, she's a true believer. She does succeed in promulgating standard preferred story lines.

Is Ripley a shill, or just a believer? Either way, the New York Times should be embarrassed for putting her work in print.

In the process, Ripley and the Times seems to have disappeared the Timss. Half the data have thus gone away. There's a name for such work:

Fake news.

11 comments:

  1. that lengthy-time period use of the drug may want to pose dangers.http://musclegainfast.com/leanfire-xt-reviews/

    ReplyDelete
  2. “And so I’m careful not to attribute any particular resistance or slight or opposition to race. But what I do believe is that if somebody didn’t have a problem with their daddy being employed by the federal government, and didn’t have a problem with the Tennessee Valley Authority electrifying certain communities, and didn’t have a problem with the interstate highway system being built, and didn’t have a problem with the GI Bill, and didn’t have a problem with the [Federal Housing Administration] subsidizing the suburbanization of America, and that all helped you build wealth and create a middle class—and then suddenly as soon as African Americans or Latinos are interested in availing themselves of those same mechanisms as ladders into the middle class, you now have a violent opposition to them—then I think you at least have to ask yourself the question of how consistent you are, and what’s different, and what’s changed.” (President Barack Obama)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It could be that race is what is different, but there is also a well-known phenomenon that when people have theirs they don't want to suffer to let others achieve the same level.

      This plays out in the slow-growth movement in small towns all over the country. People buy homes in nice new housing developments, then vote against additional development in their city because it will spoil the atmosphere if more people move there. It isn't about race, but it is about "I've got mine and you can go whistle for yours."

      The problem for people who belong to minority groups is deciding whether an act against them is motivated by race or by other factors. Attribution to race is more likely among people who have experienced previous discrimination. Some minority families socialize their kids about race differently. It is protective of ego to attribute problems to race and not to individual deficiency. To complicate matters, some situations are a combination of racial and other causes. For example, Obama had some real limitations as a presidential candidate AND there were people who didn't want to support him because of his race.

      This quote says "violent opposition" not just opposition. I question whether that opposition that is now "violent" wasn't always violent. I don't see bunches of white people now taking up arms because of minority assertion.

      And then, Obama also minimizes the strong opposition to all of those infrastructure improvements he listed. TVA in particular was very controversial, not least because of the cities displaced by damming rivers. No one had a problem with the GI Bill being extended to Vietnam era vets, who were disproportionately minority or the FHA subsidizing urban housing (despite the creation of unlivable environments in inner cities). No one subsidized suburban housing during its greatest growth in the same way that rent control and subsidized housing supported city dwellers, primarily minority. This idea that minorities never benefitted from these mechanisms in the past is wrong.

      So I have to ask whether Obama isn't distorting history a little to prove his point about discrimination that is more complex than he portrays it. For example, the fair housing movement changed restrictive covenants and redlining by banks and a number of similar practices in the 60s & 70s, when Obama was a child. Pretending that these still exist, aside from isolated wrongdoing that can be addressed by recourse to anti-discrimination law, is unfair to those who worked hard to make progress. And when you ignore progress, it makes everyone feel like there is little point in trying to improve things when the changes don't seem to matter to the people involved.

      Delete
  3. My girlfriend just dumped me. weve ben dating for 2 years. i started seeing her when she got pregnant she was my first girlfriend to begin with and we had ben friends for 8 years. she left me when i cheated on her, And since them i never stopped loving her , we started dating again. now 6 days ago she left me and she never wants to see me again. im not allowed to text or anything. but she will allow 2 calls a month that i can meet “my” daughter since she looks to me like a father. i really want her back and i cant imagine living my life without any of them. how do i handle that situation? i have to seek for solution to bring her back, one day in my office going through the internet i saw a post of a lady giving testimony on how she got her husband back on a website love spell by Dr kelvin it was really amazing to see this so i copy his email id on kelvinspell@gmail.com i explain my situation to him and gave him all the details he requested from me, he give me 3 days assurance that my girlfriend will come back after the spell i was so overwal to hear that so i just keep calm and follow up his order coz i really love my girlfriend and want her back. on the third day after the spell as he promise me, my ex call me also show up in my office begging me to forgive her and accept her back with out no delay, i lift her up with a kiss and was so very happy to have her back all my happiness was from Dr kelvin he is indeed a true man a father and a god sent. plz contact Dr kelvin on his email id direct at kelvinspell@gmail.com or call his mobile number on +2348121907216

    ReplyDelete
  4. Canada's immigrant kids are largely from Asia, with its nearly ubiquitous education-at-all-costs cultures. In Canada, immigrant kids actually tend to outscore native-born kids on international tests. That's largely because of the cultural and class backgrounds of those immigrant kids.

    It's partially because of their cultures. It's also in considerable part to their genetic makeup. It's high time we, as a society, stop pretending otherwise. The evidence is very clear. Eastern Asian people have high IQs. Mestizos do not. Research has shown that this is largely genetic, and not very susceptible to change. If we're going to have societies that work, we need to admit this and plan accordingly.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Come on, Dave the Guitar Player and Jonny Half-Scrum: time to apply your constant pontifications about reaching out to the "Other" with Anon1:139 and his/her/its long-discredited conclusion that genetic makeup is the problem with "Mestizos."

    Walk the walk!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I can’t believe this. A great testimony that i must share to all HIV patient in the world i never believed that there could be any complete cure for HIV or any cure for HIV,i saw people’s testimony on blog sites of how DR Bello prepare herbal cure and brought them back to life again. i had to try it too. and you can,t believe that in just 7 days i started using his herbal medicine. and all my pains stop gradually and i had to leave without the antiretroviral therapy which my medical doctor gave to me. i went to the hospital to do a checkup, the result came out and i tested HIV NEGATIVE. I'm sharing this with you, because i believe there's someone out here who also desire to have this cure. feel free and contact Dr Bello, delay in treatment leads to death. contact him through his WHATS-APP NUMBER +2348147271779, or contact him via email: bellospelltemple@gmail.com,Good luck

    ReplyDelete
  7. I can’t believe this. A great testimony that i must share to all HIV patient in the world i never believed that there could be any complete cure for HIV or any cure for HIV,i saw people’s testimony on blog sites of how DR Bello prepare herbal cure and brought them back to life again. i had to try it too. and you can,t believe that in just 7 days i started using his herbal medicine. and all my pains stop gradually and i had to leave without the antiretroviral therapy which my medical doctor gave to me. i went to the hospital to do a checkup, the result came out and i tested HIV NEGATIVE. I'm sharing this with you, because i believe there's someone out here who also desire to have this cure. feel free and contact Dr Bello, delay in treatment leads to death. contact him through his WHATS-APP NUMBER +2348147271779, or contact him via email: bellospelltemple@gmail.com,Good luck

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am Olivia Miguel, and I base in USA...My life is back!!! After 1 years of Broken marriage, my husband left me with two kids . I felt like my life was about to end i almost committed suicide, i was emotionally down for a very long time. Thanks to a spell caster called Dr Baba, which i met online. On one faithful day, as I was browsing through the internet,I came across allot of testimonies about this particular spell caster. Some people testified that he brought their Ex lover back, some testified that he restores womb,and other sickness, some testified that he can cast a spell to stop divorce and so on. i also come across one particular testimony,it was about a woman called Sonia,she testified about how he brought back her Ex lover in less than 2 days, and at the end of her testimony she dropped Dr Baba's e-mail address. After reading all these,I decided to give it a try. I contacted him via email and explained my problem to him. In just 48 hours, my husband came back to me. We resolved our issues, and we are even happier than before Dr Baba, He is really a gifted man and i will not stop publishing him because he is a wonderful man... If you have a problem and you are looking for a real and genuine spell caster to solve all your problems for you. Try Dr Baba anytime, he might be the answer to your problems. contact the great Doctor through this mail: realhomeofspell@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. I am Miss alisha,From USA. I will start by saying to all that have experience heart break and also cant do with out there lover should please stop here and read up my story, So as you will know how to go solving or getting your ex back from this spell caster..AND AGAIN I WILL WANT TO ALSO TELL ALL THAT THIS SPELL CASTER I WILL WANT TO TELL THE WHOLE WORLD ABOUT IS HARMLESS AND DO NOT HAVE ANY SIDE EFFECT, BUT TO RESTORE AND GIVE YOU BACK WHAT YOU DESERVE, COS WHEN I MEET WITH THIS SPELL CASTER THAT WAS INTRODUCED TO ME BY THE WIFE OF MY BOSS IN MY WORKING PLACE, HE MADE IT CLEAR THAT HE CAN CAST SPELL ON SO MANY OTHER PROBLEMS EXCEPT IN GETTING YOUR EX OR MAKING YOUR LOVER TO LOVE YOU MORE THAT WILL SUITE YOU. Last year December, My lover was cheating on me and was not also give me the attention that a man should give to a woman,And really that was troubling my mind and tearing my heart apart to the extent that i was not concentrating in the office the way i use to before the break up by my lover.And before that incident,I always see how my boss use to love his wife so much. I was bringing to think that i was not doing the right thing to him that will make him love me forever,So i really gathered my courage and went to my boss wife office to ask her the secret that made her husband love her so dearly,In the first place she refused in telling me,She asked me why i am asking her such a question,That if is it not normal for every man to love his wife.I told her the reason that made me ask her about this question,That my lover started cheating on me lately,When i knelt down before her for her to see my seriousness in this issue that i went to ask her,She opened up to me by telling me that i should not tell anybody about what she want to tell me,The wife to my boss started to say to me that she used a very powerful spell on his husband to love her,And the spell that she used is harmless, But the spell is just to make him love her and never to look for any other woman except her. I QUICKLY ASK HER HOW DID SHE GET TO KNOW THIS GREAT,POWER,DURABLE AND PERFECT WORK SPELL CASTER,she said that a friend of hers also introduce her to him. Then i also ask her how i can meet with this spell caster.SHE SAID EVERYTHING TO ME,THAT THE NAME OF THIS SPELL CASTER IS Dr.AZEN .My next question to her was how can i get this wonderful spell caster,She said she is going to give me the email of the spell caster for me to contact him for my problem,Really she gave to me this spell caster email:[azentemple@gmail.com]or what'sapp +2349038299828. and i contacted him and explained all to him,And after every thing that needed to be done by the spell caster, In the next two days, My lover that hated me so much came to house begging for forgiveness and i was so glad that i have finally gotten my heart desire..I was so grateful to this spell caster for what he has done for my life.. So i made a promise to him that i will always come.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I am Miss alisha,From USA. I will start by saying to all that have experience heart break and also cant do with out there lover should please stop here and read up my story, So as you will know how to go solving or getting your ex back from this spell caster..AND AGAIN I WILL WANT TO ALSO TELL ALL THAT THIS SPELL CASTER I WILL WANT TO TELL THE WHOLE WORLD ABOUT IS HARMLESS AND DO NOT HAVE ANY SIDE EFFECT, BUT TO RESTORE AND GIVE YOU BACK WHAT YOU DESERVE, COS WHEN I MEET WITH THIS SPELL CASTER THAT WAS INTRODUCED TO ME BY THE WIFE OF MY BOSS IN MY WORKING PLACE, HE MADE IT CLEAR THAT HE CAN CAST SPELL ON SO MANY OTHER PROBLEMS EXCEPT IN GETTING YOUR EX OR MAKING YOUR LOVER TO LOVE YOU MORE THAT WILL SUITE YOU. Last year December, My lover was cheating on me and was not also give me the attention that a man should give to a woman,And really that was troubling my mind and tearing my heart apart to the extent that i was not concentrating in the office the way i use to before the break up by my lover.And before that incident,I always see how my boss use to love his wife so much. I was bringing to think that i was not doing the right thing to him that will make him love me forever,So i really gathered my courage and went to my boss wife office to ask her the secret that made her husband love her so dearly,In the first place she refused in telling me,She asked me why i am asking her such a question,That if is it not normal for every man to love his wife.I told her the reason that made me ask her about this question,That my lover started cheating on me lately,When i knelt down before her for her to see my seriousness in this issue that i went to ask her,She opened up to me by telling me that i should not tell anybody about what she want to tell me,The wife to my boss started to say to me that she used a very powerful spell on his husband to love her,And the spell that she used is harmless, But the spell is just to make him love her and never to look for any other woman except her. I QUICKLY ASK HER HOW DID SHE GET TO KNOW THIS GREAT,POWER,DURABLE AND PERFECT WORK SPELL CASTER,she said that a friend of hers also introduce her to him. Then i also ask her how i can meet with this spell caster.SHE SAID EVERYTHING TO ME,THAT THE NAME OF THIS SPELL CASTER IS Dr.AZEN .My next question to her was how can i get this wonderful spell caster,She said she is going to give me the email of the spell caster for me to contact him for my problem,Really she gave to me this spell caster email:[azentemple@gmail.com]or what'sapp +2349038299828. and i contacted him and explained all to him,And after every thing that needed to be done by the spell caster, In the next two days, My lover that hated me so much came to house begging for forgiveness and i was so glad that i have finally gotten my heart desire..I was so grateful to this spell caster for what he has done for my life.. So i made a promise to him that i will always come.

    ReplyDelete