TUESDAY, OCTOBER 21, 2025
Then he tore into the White House: We’re forced to admit to a
secret belief:
We’re forced to admit to the secret belief that our
nation, such as it ever was, has already ceased to exist—has already come to a
secret end.
“And the war came,” the astonishing President Lincoln said. To our
secret eye, to our hidden ear, we almost think we can see and hear an end of days in these two images this morning:
First image: The videotape of President Trump’s brown bomb dropped from the sky
Second image: The photos of the facade of the East Wing of the White House being torn to the ground.
Let's start with the president's bomb:
When we the people voted last fall, did anyone know that a President Trump, in a second term, was going to issue that insult to those who voted the other way? That he would be posting a vivid image of he himself, the American president, dropping human waste on their heads?
(Why on earth—why in the world—would an American president do that?)
Also this:
When we the people voted last fall, did we know that he would take it upon himself, absent consultation
or wider consent, to revamp one of the world's most famous public buildings?
Did anyone know that he was going to do those things? Also,
is anything actually wrong with either piece of behavior?
With respect to the commander’s brown bomb, Michelle Goldberg saw it a certain way. In full, the startling headline says this:
Trump Posted a Video of Himself Dumping Excrement on Our Cities. It's a Glimpse of His Deepest Drives.
That's what the full headline says. As she starts, Goldberg starts to explain what she thinks she saw in the videotape the sitting president posted:
Trump Posted a Video of Himself...This weekend, I was surprised to learn that Donald Trump seems to see himself in the same way I do: as a would-be monarch spraying the citizenry with excrement.
On Saturday, perhaps stung by the enormous nationwide “No Kings” protests, Trump posted an A.I.-generated video on Truth Social that inadvertently captured his approach to governing. In it the president, wearing a crown, flies a “Top Gun”-style fighter plane labeled “King Trump” above American cities crowded with demonstrators, dumping gargantuan loads of feces on them. Amplifying it on social media, the White House communications director Steven Cheung gleefully wrote that the president was defecating “all over these No Kings losers!”
Before we’re done, we’ll walk you through Goldberg's account of the way that video looked
to her. For ourselves, that image conjured renewed intimations of madness, not
necessarily in the colloquial sense.
For ourselves, that videotape seemed to suggest that the sitting president was perhaps in the grip of some form of (significant) mental illness (whatever that might secretly mean). As she continues her column, Goldberg takes it a good deal farther than that, in a productive way.
Still and all, let the world go forth to the nations! If
the word of others can be believed, quite a few other citizens didn’t see the president's videotape in the way Goldberg did.
Shermichael Singleton, age 35, is a “Republican strategist”
and a CNN contributor. In his appearances on CNN, he is routinely MAGA-friendly
without being obnoxious or deranged in the Scott Jennings way.
We appreciate Singleton’s dignity—and yes, there’s plenty
that Blue America has done, including during the Biden years, that would help
explain why tens of millions of potential voters continue to walk the MAGA way.
We Blues have been very slow to come to terms
with that fact. Meanwhile, if Shermichael Singleton can
be believed, the videotape that the president posted didn’t look weird
to him.
For Singleton, the tape seemed funny. It seemed like satire to him.
Yesterday afternoon, Singleton spoke with Jake Tapper. With respect to the bombardier in chief, this is what he said:
TAPPER (10/20/25): The point that he's making, Shermichael, is that he wishes he could drop feces on his fellow Americans.
SINGLETON: Look, this is what I think. I think a lot of Republicans look at this. And I've texted a lot of folks about it. They thought it was hilarious. They thought it was funny. Some of my Democratic friends thought it was a little over the top. But even they acknowledged to me, "You know, I got to give it to Trump. He is good at sort of goading our side with some of these sort of satirical videos" and other memes that he typically would post on social media. It makes him more relatable to the average person.
Even the Democrats saw it as satire! A bit later, responding
to a Democratic strategist, Singleton described what he saw at the No Kings
rallies themselves:
SINGLETON: Look, I spent about an hour over the weekend looking at some of the images and videos of people who were protesting at the No Kings rally. And it was mostly white people. I didn't see any men. You guys are struggling with that. I didn't see men of color. You guys are struggling with that. I didn't see a whole lot of black people, didn't see a whole lot of Hispanic people. I saw mostly white people. So if I— So as a Republican, I feel pretty confident about midterms next year based on what I saw over the weekend.
He didn’t see any men at all? That almost sounds like
what he said!
Singleton omitted one part of the mantra which has been recited on the Fox News Channel whenever No Kings is discussed. He failed to
say how old the rally-goers were—failed to say that, based on their advanced
age, the rally-goers represent a dying generation which will soon be out of
MAGA’s hair.
Saturday, on The Big Weekend Show, it fell to Kayleigh McGhee White, age 25, to recite that mantra. We've seen it said a thousand times since White introduced it:
WHITE (10/18/25): I don’t have a problem with people peacefully protesting, but one thing I noticed was what the group was made up of. I saw very few young people my age, which I thought was very interesting. This was mostly older liberal adults. And that tells me that this movement on behalf of the Democratic Party is really a dying movement. We’re sort of seeing the last gasp of liberalism as a functioning political party here.
It was mostly older people? We’ll guess that White may have noticed that in her production notes more than in any of her personal observations. From there, she went on to recite the talking point recited all over the Fox News Channel:
She said that President Trump must be “the worst king ever,” given the fact
that the protest rallies had been allowed to occur.
White offered that recitation at 5:04 p.m. Three minutes earlier, Johnny Joey Jones had dropped a verbal
bomb on millions of people who are still, at least technically, his fellow
American citizens:
JONES: Good evening, everybody. I’m Joey Jones, along with Kayleigh McGhee White, Lydia Hu and Dr. Marc Siegel. And welcome to this Big Weekend Show.
We’ve got a big story tonight. It’s a Fox News Alert. Millions of far-left protestors are at anti-American rallies tonight across the country, and President Trump closes out his most successful week ever.
Reading from prompter, Jones said those aging liberals were actually “far left.” Then, he hit those millions with his own bomb:
The rallies they attended were “anti-American,”
he said.
So said Jones, age 39, and movin' on up at the channel. We thought we might be seeing him selling his Dalton, Georgia soul as he opened The Big Weekend Show with that remarkable comment.
In the process, we wondered if we were seeing Jones agree to become the latest “piece of work" as a major well-known nation continues to fall apart.
Our impression could always be wrong, of course. Could it simply be that Jones was seeing things in precisely the way he said?
That said:
Could it be that Singleton’s conservative friends really did see the president's bomb as funny, a form of satire? We don’t really believe what Singleton said, but could
we perhaps be wrong?
Simply put, we the humans aren't all just alike. Yevtushenko started People (in translation) by asserting this:
People
No people are uninteresting.
Their fate is like the chronicle of planets.
Nothing in them is not particular,
And planet is dissimilar from planet.
Planet is dissimilar from planet? Yevtushenko had never seen a Fox News Channel panel at work, of that we can feel sure!
At any rate, the sitting president had pictured himself dropping fecal matter on his fellow citizens' heads.
After that, the walls of the East Wing came a-tumblin’ down.
At one point, Joshua fit the battle of Jericho. Also,
Samson pulled a set of pillars down.
As the headline on her column suggests, Goldberg thought she saw the sitting president revealing his deepest impulses—and doing something disordered. For ourselves, we went looking, once again, for possible glimpses of recognition in the DSM.
Is something wrong with President Trump? What could possibly explain his decision to post that astonishing videotape? Also, what exactly may be going on as the walls of the East Wing come tumblin' down?
Trump supporters thought the video was funny, MAGA adherents have said. Was something more primal being expressed?
With the nation having already reached its end, we're going to take some time this week. We're going to walk you through what Goldberg thought she saw—and we're also going to walk you through what we saw inside the DSM.
We've already told you our secret belief. Will the government ever open again?
We can't honestly say that we're completely certain.
Tomorrow: We landed on "Conduct Disorder"—but what could that possibly mean?
With apologies: The transition from Windows 10 to Windows 11 has us in a formatting mess.
It arrived at a very bad time—near the end of a famous republic.
This nation has not reached its end. It is astonishing that Somerby would say this, much less multiple times, as he does above. Millions of people at an entirely peaceful protest show that the American people are fighting the abuses of Trump and his henchmen.
ReplyDeleteSomerby apparently has no patience. He is willing to surrender without a fight. He has given up and he is pretending that the rest of us have as well, when we plainly have not.
Somerby is like Lord Hawhaw, the German pretend-British propagandists who broadcast to the Allied troops in WWII. Lord Hawhaw told the troops that the war was over, that the should surrender because there was no point in dying in a war that was already lost. He did it in a posh British accent, speaking as a British man with Allied interests at heart.
Just like Somerby does every day here. We've already lost, Somerby says. Don't believe him. Trump's public support is draining away. His dementia is obvious, even to his own supporters. All that remains is to clean up the mess he has made. Trump won't survive the midterms and he will be replaced by a Democrat in 2028. That is inevitable now.
I have no doubt that Somerby has surrendered, given up, is mired in gloom. That doesn't mean the rest of us are. Just as Trump daily loses coherence, so does Somerby. It is time for Somerby to stop blogging and work jigsaw puzzles while gazing on his backyard pear tree and yelling at the kids to stay off his lawn. He could have been one of the protesters last weekend but he believes we are already a failed nation. I have major contempt for a man who would give up his country to the fascists without a fight, as Somerby is doing.
"During the height of his third campaign for the White House, President Donald Trump was reportedly obsessed with helping one of his recently divorced top advisors find a date, and frequently made objectionable comments about female members of his Mar-a-Lago club.
ReplyDeleteThat's according to Zeteo journalist Asawin Suebsaeng, who recently reported that sources close to Trump said he went out of his way to offer "wingman" services to Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Director Russell Vought. Zeteo editor-in-chief Mehdi Hasan wrote in his publication's recent newsletter that he felt he needed "to go take a shower" after reading about what Suebsaeng's sources confided."
Here we see Trump behaving just like Jeffrey Epstein, using women at Mar a Lago to pimp for Vought.
"Tomorrow: We landed on "Conduct Disorder"—but what could that possibly mean?"
ReplyDeleteIt means that Somerby needs to stop playing amateur psychiatrist and leave diagnosis to the professionals.
Odd that Somerby missed the "Sleeping Disorder" that he could have diagnosed Trump with and been correct.
DeleteAlso, how did Somerby miss this one:
"In the DSM-5, dementia is classified as a type of major neurocognitive disorder (NCD). This diagnosis is characterized by:
1. Significant decline in at least one cognitive domain (e.g., memory, language, attention)
2. Interference with daily activities and independence
3. Evidence of a progressive decline over time"
Bob, this is a dead-on counter as to the “No Kings” billing of the protest. It also provides a fair rationale for the poo-poo, if a bit overstated.
ReplyDeletehttps://x.com/thomasmhern/status/1980457632813944980?s=46&t=oYvKLjVc8YzJIvwKoQTYBQ
Somerby has already heard your right wing mockery of the protest. That's why he writes the crap he does here.
DeleteWell, good. Something a bit different from the same ole asinine accusations and insults that anonymices were up writing last night in order to post this morning.
DeleteWhy would it matter when someone wrote a comment?
DeleteI do think those Eastern European troll farm commenters may need extra time to translate their messages from their native languages into English. But that isn't the process for English speakers.
You seem confused about timelines, Cecelia. One cannot respond to something specific Somerby wrote, quoting it directly, until he has posted it himself.
DeleteAnonymices, you have a point that it’s always the same crap.However, they do have to finagle Bob’s criticism of Trump into a defense of him. It’s always asinine reasoning, but it does require some time.
DeleteWhatever you just said, it makes no sense. First, I didn't say it was always the same crap. That isn't my point but yours. Second, I don't think you are using the word finagle properly. Do you mean shoehorn perhaps? Or maybe you mean transform? Knowing the meanings of words comes from doing a lot of reading for a lifetime. Your unfamiliarity with certain English words makes you seem like a non-native speaking troll.
DeleteWhen you write a lot, you get fast at doing it. When you have your thoughts organized in mind before writing, then the words come faster. You can't do that the night before then modify it based on what Somerby has actually written in the morning. It is easier to start from scratch. Just because you write slowly doesn't mean everyone else does.
You still haven't answered how someone can quote what Somerby wrote this morning, while writing the comment the night before. Maybe Somerby writes his essays during the night, or even longer in advance, but the commenters can't write about what they haven't yet seen.
It took Cecelia 22 minutes to write a two-sentence comeback to a response to her own comment. Then another 11 minutes to write another three-sentence comeback that made no sense.
DeleteAnonymouse 12:19pm, you spend your nights preparing a would-be takedown of whatever you think Bob will post in the morning. So your morning posts are as contrived as heck and illogical. No one expects any better. The Soros folks understand the built-in difficulties of this arrangement, but they go with it because it’s slightly better than nothing,
DeleteSomerby seems to be failing to grasp an important concept. Reality does not change because you use different words to describe it. Reality has a life of its own, it exists distinct from our thoughts and beliefs about it. Thinking a rally is anti-American and labeling it as such changes absolutely nothing about the rally or its purpose or the goals of the people participating in it or the number of people who showed up or anything else about that rally. It exists separate from whatever Jones or anyone else says on Fox News about it.
ReplyDeleteBut Somerby eagerly throws away our nation, claiming it no longer exists, because some idiot on Fox is trying to deny the reality of last Saturday's protest.
Hint for Somerby: The nation will no longer exist when you no longer get your teaching pension check or your bank account is confiscated or ICE goons visit your residence and haul you off to their detention facility. Until then, you need to keep fighting against the abuses others are encountering via the loss of their jobs and freedom. Because I have no plans to fight for you when they get around to confiscating your life.
This comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteReality absolutely does change. At least, what you call reality, which is really different interpretations of a particular factual event. The factual event: millions of people, myself included, attended multiple gatherings. Most had made sign; slogans were chanted.
DeleteWere these protesters unamerican? That's the perception of the above facts that the right-wing noise machine will try to create.
IIya, the argument against”No Kings” wasn’t that political protests are innately un-American. The argument waged on CNN was that Trump has done exactly what he promised to do before he was democratically elected. No one has blamed Putin for Trump’s election to this current term… “ No Kings” isn’t an accurate reflection of what went down. Stick with “Dumpf”. At least THAT is fitting in one (bathroom) way.
DeleteThat is 100% bullshit, C. King Orange Chickenshit campaigned on tariffs, but he never said he was going to go around Congress to unilaterally and arbitrarily assign ridiculous tariffs to the entire globe, including penguin populated islands. Also, the lying fascist corrupt orange bastard explicitly denied Project 2025 on numerous occasions. Who the fuck do you think you think you're kidding? He has committed more impeachable offenses almost daily. He wipes his ass with the Constitution.
DeleteSomerby is a liar, stretching to present his preferred narrative about the protests. For example, he quotes Singleton saying that his Democrat friends saw Trump's video as satire and Somerby believes him! That's like believing that David in Cal has a liberal wife. Then Somerby says this:
ReplyDeleteA bit later, responding to a Democratic strategist, Singleton described what he saw at the No Kings rallies themselves:
SINGLETON: Look, I spent about an hour over the weekend looking at some of the images and videos of people who were protesting at the No Kings rally. "
Singleton plainly, by his own words, did not attend any rally. He watched them on TV and looked at photos. He either saw what he expected to see, via selective perception, or he saw edited footage, or he made up a story about the march, claiming there were no men and no people of color.
At the march in Denver, there were very few black people but quite a few Hispanics, contradicting Singleton's selective perception. There were men and women, some children, some old people, but it was not a boomer march. And people kept arriving and leaving during the whole time, so the march was not static, so when exactly did it ever fit Singleton's description?
But here is the problem. Somerby takes Singleton's word for things that are asserted without evidence, when those on the right (from Trump on down to your MAGA neighbor) tell lies with impunity and do not live in reality. For them and for Somerby, it doesn't matter who attended the protests. They lies to discredit it, and Somerby gobbles up and repeats those lies according Singleton a dignity he does not deserve when he is making up details about a march he didn't attend. If Somerby had attended the protest in Baltimore, he would know better than to believe Singleton, who is just another lying conservative on a lying network that tells whatever lies suit their propaganda needs. And that makes Somerby complicit in the lying, a liar himself (whatever definition of "lie" he chooses) because he is misrepresenting reality without fact checking.
"We appreciate Singleton’s dignity—and yes, there’s plenty that Blue America has done, including during the Biden years, that would help explain why tens of millions of potential voters continue to walk the MAGA way.
DeleteWe Blues have been very slow to come to terms with that fact. Meanwhile, if Shermichael Singleton can be believed, the videotape that the president posted didn’t look weird to him."
1. Singleton cannot be believed. Why should he be?
2. It is his job to defend the President by normalizing that bizarre video. It likely does not seem satirical to him, but he has to say so to keep his job.
3. The Biden years were an excellent presidency during which many positive things happened, including coping with covid, repairing the economy after the pandemic, rebuilding the infrastructure, advancing our nation's prosperity. Somerby's denial of the positives under Biden is another lie to justify his complaint that Biden was too old to run again.
4. We blues should have supported Harris more enthusiastically instead of letting Trump creep back into office, but that is not what Somerby means when he said we are not acknowledging why MAGAs are red voters.
5. MAGAs are abandoning Trump in increasing numbers as Trump's behavior gets weirder and he further damages the economy and our nation's world standing.
6. Every ICE action is more violent and more disruptive than any protest. Trump's illegal acts are destroying our government and society. Trump needs to be stopped.
I get it that Somerby's point is that Singleton is reading the same MAGA script as everyone else at Fox, so why then does Somerby praise him and pretend he is not lying? It is Somerby who says Singleton was at a march, not just looking at video, to boost his credibility after he has praised him.
We blues did not create MAGA. We do not encourage MAGA. We are not responsible for Trump winning elections -- that honor belongs to Elon Musk with his $270 million last-minute donation to Trump's campaign. It belongs to the Biden-is-too-old campaign carried out by the right, corporate media, and clueless Dems like George Clooney (with what political ambitions?). It belongs to whoever drove the wedge between Democrats by setting Israel-supporters on the left against pro-Palestinians on the left. It belongs to the bigots (red and blue) who wouldn't vote for a black woman against an obvious incompetent like Trump. But mostly it belongs to every single Trump voter who put that guy into office and now we all must suffer the consequences of THEIR actions, even though we saw and predicted what would happen if Trump become president again.
So, no Somerby, this is not due to anything blues did. It is what YOU did when you thought it would be a good idea to attack Biden and Harris. For that, whether it destroys our nation or harms a lot of people, you are fully responsible. So you need to shut up while you are ahead, join your red buddies and stop maligning the only folks trying to improve conditions -- we blues.
Somerby couldn't criticize the Young Republicans bigoted texts, if he wanted to. What's he going to do, lose the last few people who praise him on his blog?
DeleteAnonymouse 12:04pm, Bob accusers are considered to be clowns by liberals and conservatives. Nearly all of these people come back at you under a regular nym. However, you stay unaccountable from one post to the next.
Delete"Trump supporters thought the video was funny, MAGA adherents have said. Was something more primal being expressed?"
ReplyDeleteWell, this Trump supporter thought it was very funny since it, once again exposes the simple fact that nothing pisses off liberals more than being mocked.
If anyone of the so called late night "comedians" had done a similar video of dropping feces on Trump or his supporters at a rally, every liberal would find it to be the funniest thing ever.
As to your concern that the video was expressing something more primal Bob, allow me to put your mind at ease by quoting Sigmund Freud who said "Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar."
If a kid from a family of Democrats had shot Charlie Kirk to death, every Right-winger would be falling all over themselves trying to get the kid put on the Supreme Court.
DeleteInstead, it was a kid from a Republican family, who thankfully shot Charlie Kirk to death. So the Right has to cosplay that it wasn't the best thing to happen this year.
Something more primal is always being expressed, according to Freud and literary critics. It comes from the subconscious -- the attitudes and beliefs, anxieties and concerns that people are not consciously aware of. The question is not whether there was an underlying substrate to Trump's and MAGAs video, but what it was. Somerby never actually speculates about that. He just hints without delivering.
DeleteThe problem with 11:58's explanation about pissing off liberals, is that we saw the video as a self-own by Trump, not anything against liberals. It is Trump who is flinging poo, like an ape or a baby. We are pissed off because we have such a demented president who has so little dignity on the world stage, not because it was aimed at us.
Lefty comedians are more subtle than Trump's video. Physical humor is the lowest form of humor. Anyone can be made to look foolish slipping on a banana peel. So, no, not the funniest thing ever.
But lefty humor no doubt goes over MAGA heads. @11:58 suggests that Trump's poo is just poo, not anything symbolic. In that case, it is sad that the pilot pooped so much (diarrhea?) and sad that the jet has no bathroom faciltiies. But if the ground is just the ground, then whatever fell on the people below is just an unfortunate accident and Trump is to be pitied. Having empathy, liberals would feel sorry for Trump, not pissed off. That is, if that cigar (which stands for the poo) is just a cigar (actual poo not anything metaphorical).
MAGAs are idiots if they think this is funny. It does sadden me that there are so many idiots in our country and that they are so easily manipulated by Dear Leader and his greedy, corrupt accomplices. The MAGAs didn't even get their gold Trump watches and still they think they are owning libs!
It’s silly to read deep meaning into a single statement. There is an obvious meaning of that disgusting video, namely that Trump would like to shit on the heads of all those people demonstrating against him. It’s childish, inappropriate, and repulsive for a President to deliver such a message in words. It’s even more disgusting to deliver that message in a video.
ReplyDeleteBut there’s really nothing more to say. We already knew that Trump sometimes says offensive, inappropriate things.
BTW at least the video had integrity IMO. I believe Trump really would like to shit on the heads of the anti Trump demonstrators.
People who write regularly, like Michelle Goldberg and Bob, pretend to be experts in any current issue: Middle East, China, finance, economics, climate change, etc. Some skeptics think that they actually don’t know shit about all these topics. Today we have their rebuttal. Goldberg and Bob assert that they DO know shit.
ReplyDeleteA man pardoned by US President Donald Trump for his role in the 2021 Capitol riot has been charged with threatening to kill the top Democrat in the House of Representatives.
ReplyDeleteChristopher Moynihan, 34, was arrested in the town of Clinton, New York, for making a terroristic threat to kill a member of Congress, New York State Police said. He has pleaded not guilty.
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cm2ej7ly369o
Sorry about your travails with Win 11 Bob. What a load of crap, forced to migrate to a new OS which fucks everything up.
ReplyDeleteBeing a Win 10 user myself, if I have to get a new PC I may abandon Microsoft. Sticking with 10 for now, until something bad happens - if it ever does.
Leroy
This has been happening periodically since computers were invented. Progress is not bad, neither is change.
DeleteFrom Tiedrich:
ReplyDelete"yesterday, out of the clear blue, with no warning, backhoes rolled up to the White House and started knocking the shit out of the East Wing.
what the fuck?
Subscribed
we were promised this wasn’t going to happen. remember when America’s Mad King first announced his plan for that gaudy ninety-thousand-square-foot ballroom? he swore up and down that he wouldn’t touch the existing White House. here’s what he said.
“It won’t interfere with the current building. It won’t be. It’ll be near it but not touching it — and pays total respect to the existing building, which I’m the biggest fan of,” Trump said during an executive order signing in July. “It’s my favorite. It’s my favorite place. I love it.”
‘near it but not touching it.’ well, that promise just flew out a demolished East Wing window...
but wait — can Donny do this? no. of fucking course he can’t. there are rules that govern this shit.
Major physical or architectural changes are not up to the president alone.
The White House is a National Historic Landmark, protected by law and managed by the National Park Service.
Permanent alterations (like demolishing walls, expanding wings, or changing the façade) would require Congressional authorization, since the building is federal property.
hold on, what am I talking about, rules? how stupid of me. Donny couldn’t give a fuck about rules. he’s A Very Special Boy Who Gets To Do Whatever He Wants.
besides, who’s going to stop him?
as with much of our government, there are rules and regulations, but no enforcement mechanism. there’s no penalty for flattening the East Wing. no one’s coming to arrest Donny over this. the people who wrote that statutes governing alterations to the White House thought it would be sufficient just to say ‘don’t be an asshole.’
the people who wrote those rules never met Donny Convict. ‘ask permission first’ is a bridge too far for this shitwaffle.
so much of our government was built on the honor system. our founders couldn’t fathom that one day far in the future, Americans would be reckless enough to elect a vulgar pig with no sense of honor."
-------------------------
I think this should be an impeachable offense.
Sending out a video of the president shitting on his constituents for exercising free speech is another thing in that category. No one should have to tell Trump it is wrong. But again, I think it should be a impeachable offense, if only because of the disrespect shown to the people.