WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 18, 2026
Along came Talarico: Are these the days of miracle and wonder? (Paul Simon, Graceland album) Inquiring minds might sensibly ask.
Last Tuesday, as part of a larger story, suffering Mississippi turned Black and blue, and a baby-faced seminarian conquered red Texas. He won his race for the Senate by twelve points, and he did so by campaigning beneath this unusual sign:
Love thy neighbor
Say what? "Love thy neighbor?" Again and again, that's what he said, even in his victory speech last Tuesday night, part of which we invite you to gaze upon right here:
James Talarico Victory Speech, 11/3/26
CHRIS: Please help me introduce and welcome Mr. Senator James Talarico to the stage.
TALARICO: ...We just took back Texas. We just proved that all the money in the world is no match for the people of Texas. We just showed that a politics of division is no match for a politics of love.
[...]
People across the political spectrum are hungry for a different kind of politics. Not a politics of hate, not a politics of fear, not a politics of division, but a politics of love.
My faith teaches me that love is the strongest force in the universe.
Love is not passive. Love is not neutral. Love is not weak. Love requires that we stand between the bullies and the bullied. Love requires that we look evil in the eye and not blink. That kind of love has always been a threat to the powers that be. That kind of love is revolutionary. That kind of love is creative.
Hate is predictable. Hate is boring. Hate can't lower our energy bills. Hate can't teach a child to read. Hate can't build a future. But what hate can't do, love can.
Love. Love can turn a student into a scholar. Love can turn a closet into a nursery. Love can turn an enemy into a friend. Love can turn a campaign into a movement. Love. Love can heal what's broken in America.
We can't defeat the politics of division with more division. We can't win that game. We have to change the game.
All you need is love? Long ago, in a bell-bottomed era, the Beatles got there first!
At any rate, with that excerpt from the winning candidate's speech, we gaze on the messaging which stampeded the state of Texas. (To read the full transcript, click here.)
If you choose to watch the 18-minute address, you'll see that his exit music was this pop music tribute to the giant home state:
Ella Langley, Choosin' Texas (Official Lyric Video)
Also, you'll see this message on the candidate's podium:
LOVE THY NEIGHBOR
It's right there on the podium. It's sitting right there. All caps!
That's the messaging you'll be seeing, but you won't be seeing a squish. Elsewhere in his address, the young senator-elect said this:
TALARICO: There is something broken in America. Our economic system is broken. Our political system is broken. Even our relationships with each other feel broken. That's because the most powerful people in the world want it that way.
My granddad was a Baptist preacher in South Texas. And when I was little, he told me that we follow a barefoot rabbi who gave us two commandments, love God and love neighbor, because there is no love of God without love of neighbor.
Every single person bears the image of the sacred. Every single person is holy, not just my neighbor who looks like me, not just my neighbor who prays like me, not just my neighbor who votes like me. I am called to love all of my neighbors the way I love myself.
[...]
Two thousand years ago, when the people at the top hurt his neighbors, that barefoot rabbi didn't stay in his room and pray. He walked into the seat of power and he flipped over the tables of injustice.
As this movement heads to the seat of power, as we head to the United States Senate, we know what this moment requires of us:
Texas, it's time to start flipping tables.
EXIT MUSIC: Choosin' Texas
There's a great deal more in the speech about "the most powerful people in the world" and the political culture they've created. But that's the way he chose to end his speech, with the image of that barefoot rabbi executing what Wikipedia calls "The Cleansing of the Temple."
It's a rather aggressive political image. In a major political surprise, that message stampeded that state.
At the age of 37, that particular wining candidate comes from the state of Texas. He speaks a kind of Biblical language which is recognizable to many groups in that very large state. As we noted last week, Texas is the site of the Houston Rodeo and the trail rides into that giant, sprawling American city—into that sprawling American place.
Love thy neighbor, the candidate said. As we noted in Monday's report, that can sometimes seem like a fairly difficult ask.
Nor are we entirely sure that the American project hasn't already been undermined in a way which can't be undone. In our view, it may be too late in the day for loving thy neighbor to help.
Still, that's what the seminarian said. And despite his cherubic appearance, the hopeful stampeded a giant red state.
Love thy neighbor, the candidate said. But within the modern political context, what did he mean by that?
Tomorrow: More from his address
ReplyDeleteOh man, but seriously, what's this, with getting a hard on from pol's making speeches?
...all due respect, this really is retarded. I see no other way to describe it.
Ghislaine, do you think you spend more time thinking about Democrats jerking off or about Somerby getting a hard-on?
Delete"Love thy neighbor, the candidate said. But within the modern political context, what did he mean by that?"
ReplyDeleteThis should be where Somerby begins, not how he ends his essay. He's been going on about this for several days now, without any attempt to answer this question.
I think Talarico is very clear about what he means. He is not telling us to love the red billionaires oppressing us. He is telling us to band together to oppose the bullies and evil-doers, as Jesus did in his own time. He is telling us to help the needy, which is what Democrats ran on and what we do as a party. Somerby doesn't have the guts to acknowledge that, so he writes a maundering essay that describes Talarico's essay without addressing his point.
Then Somerby says:
"Nor are we entirely sure that the American project hasn't already been undermined in a way which can't be undone. In our view, it may be too late in the day for loving thy neighbor to help."
Voters responded to Talarico with hope. Somerby today stomps all over that hope. He says we cannot do anything to undo the damage (in so many words). Why try, he implicitly whispers. All is lost. Why would any liberal say something like that in the face of this historic victory? Why would Somerby be giving up on democracy before the newly elected replacements to Trump's incompetents even have a chance to take office, much less meet in a newly constituted Congress?
Today's right wing talking point is that we Dems cannot use love to remake our nation, so we might as well just give up. But in Texas, people are taught as children to ask themselves, What Would Jesus Do? Certainly not give up. If someone said to the Jesus of the Bible, it is hopeless, you cannot love away evil, would Jesus have shrugged and said "well, OK then" and gone back to being a carpenter? I find that hard to believe, even when Somerby says it.
So, why is Somerby trying to discourage those of us who think the way to love our neighbors is to help those in need? Why does he advocate giving up and just letting them be? (Get it, another Beatles phrase!) I prefer to think he is doing it for influencer pay, rather than to believe anyone is so venal as to be saying "love those neighbors all you want, it isn't going to save us now," as Somerby seems to be saying today.
Somerby , passing a stranger giving CPR on the street, contributes”I think he might be dead.” Very helpful.
Delete"If someone said to the Jesus of the Bible, it is hopeless, you cannot love away evil, would Jesus have shrugged and said "well, OK then" and gone back to being a carpenter? I find that hard to believe, even when Somerby says it."
DeleteAh, but did Somerby say it, O Despairing One? Go back and re-read. There's nothing like it in the post!
There. I've solved your problem.
Jesus should have stuck to carpentry in any case.
DeleteYou nailed it 2:29, you big dummy.
DeleteSomerby uses the word stampede frequently in this essay:
ReplyDelete"we gaze on the messaging which stampeded the state of Texas..."
"In a major political surprise, that message stampeded that state..."
"...the hopeful stampeded a giant red state..."
Talarico winning TX was not a surprise to those who looked at his opponent (Ken Paxton), a man who broke the law, cheated on his wife, stole a $1000 pen from a colleague and was corrupt from head to toe. Talarico smartly emphasized his own cleanliness before God using Biblical phrases -- of course he won. But was it a stampede?
Stampede definition: "A stampede is a wild, sudden, and uncontrolled rush or flight of a frightened group of animals or a mass movement of people acting on a common impulse or fear." Applied to cattle, the trigger for a stampede is something threatening.
Did Talarico heighten voter fears the way Republicans have traditionally campaigned? Not with a message of Love Thy Neighbor. That is a positive message of community and support. It doesn't encourage people to fear immigrants or communists or trans people. It says we need to have each others' backs and pull together. Yes, that is what people need to hear today, but Talarico didn't stampede Texas voters -- he led them toward a solution that says we can fix what is wrong.
Somerby apparently doesn't hear that message. Why not?
Because you're wrong.
DeleteBob's having fun with the word 'stampede' because he's talking about Texas, which is traditionally associated with cattle, and because 'stampede' connotes the kind of sizable, decisive victory Talarico pulled off.
And these are obvious points that require no deep thought. The only deep thought here was you imagining Bob's use of 'stampede' was designed to reflect negatively on Talarico.
So, you are saying Somerby makes no sense because he uses words simply because they are associated with Texas and not for their actual meanings. In that case there is no point in reading him.
DeleteThey inability to pin Somerby down is why every commenter can hold such divergent opinions about what he intends. That is the essence of bad writing.
Your version ignores what stampede means. You are saying Somerby did that too, in order to give a playful Texas tone to his essay. But how does that fit with the rest of his essay? It doesn’t.
Many right wing Christians read the Bible where Jesus says to love thy neighbor and have apparently decided to reject that advice.
ReplyDeleteIf you listen to the Christian Right leading bullshitters they never talk about the good stuff in the New Testament. They hate Christ being so fucking woke. So good on Talarico for shoving his religion down their hateful throats.
DeleteTo be quite honest, TDH has been extremely disappointing since the midterms.
ReplyDeleteDisappointment is rooted in expectations. Based upon his past performance, I suspect that yours were unrealistic.
DeleteDoes "Love Thy Neighbor" mean the same thing as "Love Thy Enemy"? I don't think so. Neither does Talarico say so, unless you consider flipping tables to be an act of love.
ReplyDeleteThe failures of the Trump administration are unprecedented. There are nationwide threats to air travel, banking, and other aspects of national security within our own country. Asked about them, Trump says "That's life." He cannot even assure us those problems will be solved.
This is what happens when you put billionaires in charge of our government and their only motivation is to make more money.
The Bible tells us not to do that. There are many verses warning us about the love of money. I do not understand why the people in the reddest states, with the most respect for Bible study, have rushed to be first in Trump's eyes. That seems like a big mistake, biblically speaking.
Somerby notes Talarico's use of the Bible in his campaign, but he doesn't fully consider the meaning of such verses. What if you took them seriously and applied them to our current situation, as Talarico may be doing himself? Cynical Somerby assumes it is a campaign ploy, not sincerely held religious feeling. He refers to Talarico snidely as "the seminarian" and ignores his career of public service, then says love won't work, without explaining why. Presumably because we the people aren't up to it.
Democrats have been loving our neighbors as a matter of policy. Biden loved his neighbors. Look what the Republicans are still doing to him. It seems dangerous to love neighbors who won't love you back, but you do it because they need help, not so that they will return your kindness or pay you back in some way. Democrats are the party that does this already because it is our party platform, our view of what governing is about. Why would Somerby claim that it won't work, just when we are on the verge of regaining the ability to implement our ideas? That doesn't sound like any liberal I know -- but it does sound like what a traitor to Democratic ideals would say, a sell out to the right wing.
Somerby doesn't come right out and say it, but he's probably correct there is no such thing as a sincerely held religious feeling.
DeleteDisagree.
DeleteDisagree.
DeleteA non-religious person cannot speak for the feelings of a religious person. I see no evidence Talarico is insincere. He went to seminary!
Delete"Cynical Somerby assumes it is a campaign ploy, not sincerely held religious feeling."
DeleteNot a single word in Somerby's post today supports this opinion.
So, mission accomplished!
There is a bit of a mixed message in today’s post, where Somerby highlights all the times Talarico said the word “love” and then claims it was his aggressive image of the cleansing of the temple that stampeded the state.
DeleteAgree
DeleteThis country’s history is full of bitter political fighting since its beginning.
ReplyDeleteIt’s also full of the legacy of slavery, Jim Crow, horrible abuse of Native Americans, etc.
Yet “love thy neighbor” was always in everyone’s Bibles.
It’s the progressive mindset that has attempted to fix these things, accompanied by resistance from reactionary forces. Same as it ever was.
It's a shame "All Lives Matter" just meant "Shut-up black people."
DeleteSomerby refers to Mississippi as suffering? In what way? He then refers to Colom's victory as "suffering Mississippi turned Black and blue..."
DeleteSomerby appears to think the term black and blue is clever because Colom is a black Democrat, but the reference is to bruising, physical injury, not something good like having a black person win his election.
Words matter. When someone uses negative words like suffering and "black and blue" to refer to a black man's victory, he gives the appearance of lamenting that victory not applauding it. Or at least having things both ways, given that Somerby can deny he meant anything ugly with his negative description (except no one wants to be bruised or to suffer).
This kind of slippery writing is why Somerby appears to be racist, suggesting a few days back that racism is over, while trying also to claim he is happy about blue victories. He doesn't sound happy today about Talarico and he especially doesn't sound happy that Colom won.
I think it's the opposite, @10:26 "Black lives matter" meant "Shut-up white, yellow, and red, people." Nobody was punished for saying "Black lives matter." People faced consequences for saying "All lives matter."
DeleteBTW the people who chanted "Black lives matter" didn't care about most black lives. They care only about blacks who were killed by whites, They didn't give a hoot about about the larger number of whites killed by blacks or the much larger number of blacks killed by other blacks.
Yes, but you are an imbecilic racist, Dickhead, so you thinking is corrupted by your racism and prejudices.
DeleteDavid in Cal,
DeleteIn your opinion, why do you think the people who said "All Lives Matter" while bitching about refugees coming to this country to escape violence and abject poverty shouldn't face consequences for their bullshitting/ hypocrisy?
People got arrested for saying "Black lives matter".
DeleteAll people in our culture care about murders and oppose murderers no matter who they are. It is wrong to say that because murders occur that no one cares about them. We have a criminal justice system that investigates and prosecutes murder and other crimes. It should be race-blind but demonstrably is not. That is the problem being discussed.
DeleteI said “all lives matter” and I oppose Trump’s cruel violence against immigrants.
DeleteI deplore all violence, including violence by Black people against Black people.
DeleteMost violent crimes are committed by men, not people.
DeleteMore men are convicted because our criminal justice system is biased.
DeleteHey David what did the Felon do when he learned the chip guy was fucking a Chinese spy and sold her $20B worth of chips to illegally route to China? He dumped his fucking stock holdings. Is this the reason you support impeaching the treasonous bitch?
Delete2:32 that's laughable
DeleteThe bias in our criminal justice system is no laughing matter.
DeleteIt's no Charlie Kirk being cancel cultured. That's for sure.
DeleteBlack people are disproportionately incarcerated, because of racism. Men are disproportionately convicted of violent crimes, because of gender bias in the criminal justice system.
DeleteI think it also mocks Talarico to refer to his face as cherubic. He can't help how he looks. He is 37 years old, not a baby or an innocent.
ReplyDeletePerhaps Talarico's campaign was helped by his seeming to be someone who will never commit the many sins the Republicans have been caught doing lately. But how is that a fault? There is no evidence he is dirty -- the Republicans would have found it. Talarico overcame $200 million in opposition spending to win.
Somerby and Talarico both spent time as middle school teachers. Perhaps Somerby resents Talarico for being purer of heart than he was, or maybe he resents it that Talarico is so successful whereas Somerby's modest comedy career didn't win by 14 points, the way Talarico did.
Whatever the reason, Somerby seems to have a need to knock Galahad off his horse. The problem is that now Talarico represents us all, so Somerby can't attack him without undermining the rest of us and our lefty values.
"In Catholic theology, envy is usually classified as a mortal sin by its nature because it opposes charity, though it can be a venial sin when minor, involuntary, or lacking full deliberation."
Envy escalates into other sins, such as shitting on the hopes of one's neighbors.
Thanks for straightening me out on today's post. I first read through it thinking it was positively inclined to Talarico.
DeleteBut now that I've read your comment (which includes not a single quote from the post itself) I realize Somerby 'mocks' Talarico, 'faults' him, 'perhaps resents' him, has a need' to knock him off his horse' and is 'shitting' on all our hopes'.
Worst of all, Somerby (accurately) describes Talarico as 'cherubic'. Whenever I want to damn someone straight to hell, I was always describe them as cherubic.
How vile is Somerby. How valuable are your corrections.
@11:00: where in his post does Somerby express anything positive or approving about Talarico?
DeleteSee how 11:30 deflects? Challenged to support the accusation that Somerby “mocks,” “faults,” etc., 11:30 ignores the challenge and throws dust instead.
DeleteThe method:
Delete1. Make a baseless accusation.
2. If challenged, ignore the challenge and dare the challenger to prove that the accusation is not true.
If you are a 37 year old man, is cherubic the look you are going for?
DeleteIn this case, one assertion was made by one commenter, then another came along and made their own comment. Meanwhile, the original commenter was off doing other things in real life, not reading this blog. Then DG conflates the commenters and complains because one didn't answer his complaint about another one's comment.
DeleteThis problem arises because DG frames this as a battle between people, not the examination of ideas. He is "calling out" a person aggressively instead of discussing ideas. The ideas don't know or care where they came from. They can be discussed by anyone without the need to chastise and insult the person DG disagrees with today.
No, 11:30 said that Somerby’s post was positively inclined towards Talarico. I (11:30) disagreed and challenged him on it.
DeleteCorrection: 11:00 said it was positive.
DeleteI am 11:00, and having re-read Somerby's post, I concede there is no statement that is unambiguously pro-Talarico, just as there is no single statement that is unambiguously anti-Talarico.
DeleteBut compare my 'thinking it was positively inclined' to the litany of false inferences @ 10:33. I am the lesser offender.
Look at all the dust that has been stirred up! 10:33 gets to scurry away without defending the accusation that Somerby's envy causes him to knock Galahad off his horse.
DeleteWhoever accused Somerby of having a discernible opinion on something he wrote about on his blog, should have to use a name.
DeleteMy name is Legion.
DeleteMe, I view JD Vance as "cherubic." The ugliest, scrubbiest cherub on erf. He's a Catholic, don't ya know.
DeleteLeroy
Trump is getting tired of Vance criticizing the war on Iran.
DeleteRepublicans tried to get mileage out of calling
DeleteTalarico gay. They never called Lindsey Graham gay. Apart from their blatant homophobia there is an underlying truth. Closeted gay Republicans, especially those with powerful foreign policy positions are at risk for blackmail.
We ourselves did not think of Talarico as a demon, but many of our good friends and neighbors in Texas did. You can’t prove that he isn’t after all.
ReplyDeleteI voted for Talarico because he is a demon.
DeleteI voted for Speed Racer because he's a demon on wheels.
DeleteAccording to our VP, UFOs are probably demons. So you are saying that Talarico is probably a UFO.
DeleteVance is an unexplained terrestrial phenomenon.
Delete‘“The Cleansing of the Temple."
ReplyDeleteIt's a rather aggressive political image. In a major political surprise, that message stampeded that state.’
So, was it “love thy neighbor” or the “cleansing of the temple” image that stampeded that state?
That’s actually a hell of a good question. Here’s another: Are they inconsistent messages?
DeleteYes, they are inconsistent. Is it a loving act to throw over the tables of the money changers? Disrupting their business activities seems hostile to me. I get it that Jesus thought conducting business in the temple was wrong, but it is not consistent with love thy neighbor because it interferes with that neighbor's efforts to support themselves and their family.
DeleteThe money-changers were providing a necessary service for worshippers. Jesus was completely wrong.
DeleteWhat is they were payday lenders charging exorbitant rates?
DeleteThe gospel would have said that.
DeleteThe gospel was compiled by a bunch of smelly romans 300 years after Christ died and went back to being god or some stupid ass story like that. I never paid much attention after I got thrown out of Sunday School for bitching about how idiotic the Bible stories are. Mom whupped my ass, but never made me go to Church again. We both believed sleeping in on Sunday until football starts is sacred.
DeleteMy catechism said that God sacrificed his only begotten son for my sins, only to later report that Jesus now sits at the right hand of God in perpetuity. What, was he a loaner?
DeleteGod forbid you don’t believe in this crap.
I always felt the Father and the Son were overrated. The Holy Spirit did more for me.
DeleteStop Me if You've Heard This One Before
ReplyDelete"Claims by Netanyahu’s Party of a ‘Stolen’ Israeli Election Unravel"
Palestinians are trying to steal Palestine.
DeleteBibi should bomb the shit out of those fuckers.
DeleteMy neighbors are white Christian farmers. I love them dearly.
ReplyDeleteI don't care for them, but my tax dollars subsidize their electricity.
DeleteTheir beans make you fart.
Delete