THURSDAY: We wouldn't have put it that way ourselves!

THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 19, 2026

Bob Costas was a tiny bit right: "Insane" is not a technical / medical / clinical term. As far as we know, "insane" and "insanity" have colloquial meaning only.   

That said, it's time to tip our hat to Lawrence O'Donnell's recent statements. Instead of rummaging back through our notes, we let AI Overview do the remembering for us:  

Query from The Daily Howler: 

When did Lawrence O'Donnell say that President Trump's apparent mental illness is the biggest story in the world?   

Reply from AI Overview:

• September 9, 2026: Referring to social media posts, O'Donnell said, "It appears the president of the United States is insane," adding, "And that is the single biggest news story in the world."

• October 8, 2026: O'Donnell said that if the president is "insane," it is "the biggest news of the day or any day" and "the most important story of the day because everything else follows from that."

"Insane" isn't a clinical term. But it's hard to see why the general thrust of those statements by O'Donnell wouldn't perhaps be correct.   

From there, we move to what Bob Costas has now a bit clumsily said. Over at Mediaite, David Gilmour does the reporting: 

...Bob Costas Rails Against ‘Sociopath’ Trump in Scorched Earth Rant   

Legendary sportscaster Bob Costas tore into President Donald Trump as a “sociopath” who is “grotesquely unfit” for public office, accusing his administration of rampant corruption in a blistering attack on the president’s character.

Appearing on the Next Question with Katie Couric podcast on Thursday, the longtime NBC broadcaster argued that Trump’s conduct was so outrageous that Americans would struggle to believe it if he were not already occupying the White House.  

 [...] 

Rounding on the president’s remarks and Truth Social posts, Costas argued: “On a daily basis, he posts things and says things that if he was your next-door neighbor, that’s when you’d build a wall because that guy’s unhinged, right? This stuff is obvious. It’s obvious!”

The broadcaster then invoked the fictional character Rip Van Winkle, from the early 1800s, imagining how someone unaware of contemporary American politics might react to his description of the president.

“‘Well, Bob is pretty extreme,’” Costas imagined the character protesting. “‘That can’t be true! I mean, maybe the President of the United States deserves to be criticized, but that can’t be true. The President of the United States is not a sociopath!’”

“Yes, he is! Yes, he is!” the broadcaster said.    

First, he went with the tapioca "unhinged." He finally settled on "sociopath!" That's what he daringly said!

Except, guess what? "Sociopath" isn't a clinical term either! But it comes close to constituting an assertion that the sitting president is (seriously) "mentally ill." 

As a sportscaster, Costas sits on the fringe of a media world which refuses to try to come to terms with the topic O'Donnell called "the biggest news story in the world."  In our view, Costas tackled the topic in several ways which were misguided or wrong, but the others have all agreed not to go near the topic at all! 

Lawrence O'Donnell is valedictorian of an unimpressive class. All the others, Costas included, currently serve as part of an active, highly instructive anthropology lesson.

It's the biggest story in the world! But everyone—all of them—have agreed that they need to ignore it!


37 comments:


  1. Yawn. Your obsession with calling people insane wasn't particularly captivating the first thousand times you announced it, Bob. By now it's extremely, extremely boring.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are the Gold Standard of a fucking useless bore.

      Delete
    2. No, Somerby is.

      Delete
  2. I wish Somerby would look things up that he is unsure about. He says:

    " As far as we know, "insane" and "insanity" have colloquial meaning only."

    But he is wrong about that:

    "Yes, "insane" has a specific legal meaning—primarily referring to a mental state or disease that prevents a person from understanding their actions or distinguishing right from wrong at the time of a relevant event. Unlike its everyday slang use or its former medical use, "insanity" is a legal determination rather than a clinical psychiatric diagnosis."

    A legal meaning is not the same as a colloquial meaning, although the term has an additional colloquial meaning in addition to the legal one and the now obsolete clinical meaning.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Somerby says: "Except, guess what? "Sociopath" isn't a clinical term either! But it comes close to constituting an assertion that the sitting president is (seriously) "mentally ill."

    This is why unqualified people shouldn't make medical or clinical diagnoses, especially using colloquial language. There is clearly something very wrong with President Trump. We need to be demanding that his doctors come clean about his physical and mental health. Some of his symptoms are cognitive while others are physical (the swaying while standing, sleeping, slurred speech, inability to hold still, inability to walk a straight line, odd posture). The people deserve to know his health status and that means administering tests, reaching diagnoses and revealing that info to the public with an interpretation by his doctor. What we have gotten to date is lies.

    I would like to see Congress require an independent examination of Trump, in consultation with his White House physicians, and full disclosure, followed by discussion of whether the president is fit to continue in his job. Somerby has never called for this -- he keeps asking the press to discuss Trump's fitness. Somerby has never approved of removing the president, even back during his two impeachments. He says it would set aside the will of the voters. But can the voters make a decision without the facts about his health? I don't see how anyone can justify keeping Trump in office given his current behavior.

    Somerby confuses health issues with criminal behavior and lack of character. Sociopaths lack character, even when not lawbreakers. Sociopath is not a clinical term, but it is a label used by those who work in the criminal justice system, from cops to social workers to judges. It is part of a sentencing determination of potential for harm, made by a forensic psychologist. There are many high functioning sociopaths who do not break the law or promises to others, but there are also a high number of sociopaths among criminals, who lie routinely (as Trump does), lack empathy (as Trump does), steal and cheat without compunction (as Trump does), break marriage vows and social norms (as Trump does), and cannot be trusted with anything they do not see as in their self-interest (as is also typical of Trump). Criminal or not, a sociopath who behaves this way shouldn't be elected to public office. That makes character an important part of voter judgment, and the news reports of bad character relevant during an election. Trump has never had good character but Republicans elected him anyway. They are responsible for that, whether the voters thought Trump would make them personally rich, thought Trump would do great things (believing his lies), or were just following party line and not really thinking about who Trump is. Character is a legitimate reason to remove Trump, especially when it comes out that Trump was not only Epstein's bestie but a member of his teen rape club.

    Somerby refuses to deal with the consequences of his claims, that Trump has untreated mental illness (Somerby's preferred term for personality disorders, which are not only largely untreatable, but not mental illness and not against the law). Trump (and other people too) have the right to be as disagreeable as he wants. We the voters have the right to not elect him in the first place, but also to hold him accountable for the things he has done that ARE against the law, up to and including treason.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Somerby is an insane sociopath.

      Delete
    2. Take it easy on the AI slop FFS.

      Delete
    3. Nothing in that comment was from AI

      Delete
    4. My comments, including this comment, are from AI.

      Delete
    5. 6:47 Then get a fucking life!

      Delete
  4. "Lawrence O'Donnell is valedictorian of an unimpressive class. All the others, Costas included, currently serve as part of an active, highly instructive anthropology lesson."

    No, none of this has anything to do with anthropology. Just because people are involved, doesn't make this anything close to such study:

    "Anthropology is the holistic study of humanity, examining human biology, behavior, cultures, and societies across time and space. Combining natural sciences, social sciences, and the humanities, it explores both what makes people unique and what humans share."

    Costas and O'Donnell are not doing anthropology and neither is Somerby. He is just complaining because those two journalists (who happen to be anti-Trump) are "unimpressive" and show that, even though there are two of them, "everyone" has agreed not to notice Trump's insanity. This is not an exaggeration, it is an outright lie that has been contradicted many times by those who have cited the various sources discussing Trump's mental status.

    Somerby seems to think it is cute to warp words into whatever meaning he wants them to have, disregarding what they mean to other people. That is wrong to do because words are used to communicate with others. That means the words have to have the same (or a closely similar) meaning to both the listener and the speaker or else there is no transfer of information, no shared meaning.

    For myself, I have no idea why Somerby behaves this way. He could be mentally ill himself, have poor character, be ignorant (largely due to avoiding becoming educated while at Harvard), be bought off by the right wing, or he could be a sociopath himself who thinks it would be funny to conduct his own blogger anthropology experiment (misbehavior for actual anthropologists since they observe, not manipulate the people they study).

    Referring to this as anthropology, when it is nothing like it, is another way that Somerby disparages actual fields of study. He has been doing this for decades, back to when he first talked about "future anthropologists living in caves," a phrase he seemed to consider cute beyond words. It seems to me that the purpose of these recurring complaints is to make himself feel superior to journalists and others with expertise, for not discussing the right things, or not doing it in the right way, or agreeing not to do it even while there are people in the press obviously doing exactly what Somerby has called for, but still failing in some intangible way. Picking on other people is an age-old way to improve one's self-esteem, but the boost is not reality-based so it doesn't last and must be repeated over and over. Again, Trump and Somerby share this problem since they are both narcissists with a sense of grandiosity society never confirms enough to fill that sense of creeping inferiority.

    Other people pump themselves up by helping others. Narcissists lack empathy and are self-focused, so they don't do that. Too bad for them and for all those neighbors who could have used some love.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are an insane narcissist.

      Delete
    2. "Your obsession with calling people insane wasn't particularly captivating the first thousand times you announced it..."

      Delete
    3. Take it easy on the AI slop FFS.

      Delete
    4. Two sentences defining anthropology. The rest is all generated by me.

      Delete
    5. But you’re a bot.

      Delete
  5. Stop Him If You've Heard This One Before

    "I’ve heard this very often from President Trump. I mean, his belief in Putin’s goodwill seems unshakable, even though so far there are no facts to support it."

    - Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk

    ReplyDelete
  6. O’Donnell has never ignored Trump’s mental state.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Responding to an anonymouse who pooh poohed the Greenland treaty
    Geographically, Greenland is perfectly suited to early warning against missile attack, and will form a vital part of Golden Dome. The island also helps us detect — and in case of war, control — Russian access to the Atlantic. Same goes for the Arctic Ocean, which might not seem important now, but with less ice and more resources being discovered, it grows in strategic value every year.

    Geologically, Greenland itself contains rare earths, graphite, copper, zinc, tungsten, and other strategically useful minerals. China throws money around, trying to gain control of all those goodies.

    Previous trilateral agreements allowed for a more limited American military and economic presence, and more or less under NATO auspices. The new agreement allows us to expand both, locks China out, and is basically irrevocable by the other two parties — even in the unlikely event that Greenland ever becomes independent from Denmark.


    https://pjmedia.com/vodkapundit/2026/11/19/its-official-the-donroe-doctrine-just-got-us-greenland-n4959495

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Harry Truman negotiated the old treaty. That was after he nuked Japan. Trump doesn’t have the balls to nuke anybody.

      Delete
    2. Wow, huge triumph for this administration. Convincing Denmark/Greenland not to do business with China and Russia, favoring a NATO ally, was a heavy lift.

      Delete
    3. The most consequential win for Western democracy since the Berlin Wall came down.

      Delete
    4. The people of Venezuela ask the Orange Jesus: So when are you going to start sucking the natural assets out of Greenland to pad your cronies’ wallets and give it a break over here?

      Delete
    5. Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk wrote, "God, protect us from such friends," on X on November 19, 2026, after U.S. President Donald Trump called Russian President Vladimir Putin his "friend" at an APEC summit in Shenzhen, China.

      There is something seriously the fuck wrong with you, dickhead in cal.

      Delete
    6. David is senile.

      Delete
    7. No, David has always been this way. A fucking dishonest immoral piece of shit carrying around a fucking ginormous chip on his shoulder. He has no interest in honest discourse here. I have been reading his comments for at least 20 years and he has called SS a Ponzi scheme more times than I can count. That's not senility. he's a fucking nasty piece of shit.

      Delete
    8. Trump is such a fucking moron, he thinks the guy blackmailing him into being a Russian asset is his "friend".

      Delete
    9. The important thing to remember aside from his colossal stupidity, is he is a stone cold traitor to Democracy who has repeatedly publicly bowed to Putin, and completely stiffed Ukraine. Fuck this treasonous clown. I hate what he has done to the world order.

      Delete
    10. Trump is a fucking con. His whole act is to try to con you, me and the country. He lives his life guided by Roy Cohn's rules. Why can't people just understand this. TDH is the moron.

      Delete
    11. So you think this tweaked agreement will keep the demented fool from continuing to demand they give it to him David? That's not how demented narcissists work silly.

      Delete
    12. David only uses the best medias sources don'cha know?

      "AI Copilot:
      PJ Media is generally rated as right‑leaning to hyper‑partisan right, with multiple evaluators citing low to mixed reliability and a pattern of conservative political bias."
      Get out of the bubble and enjoy life you sick old creep.

      Delete
  8. Brad Slager, conservative opinion writer at Mediaite, is slagging Joe Biden for setting aside a book tour while being treated for Stage 4 cancer. Here is that famous right wing empathy in action. Slager is a piece of shit and Mediaite is no better for running today’s ugly hit piece on the former president.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You think the election would have awakened these assholes (like DiC) up to the fact that people are sick and tired of there nasty ass stupid.

      Delete
  9. How is it possible to be a "tiny bit right"? You can be right about a tiny thing, but rightness is not a matter of what proportion of a fact is correct. Statements are true or false, logically speaking.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Somerby's criticisms of Costas are weird. It isn't what Costas believes about Trump but how he says it:

      "From there, we move to what Bob Costas has now a bit clumsily said."

      It is his language, whether Costas said insane or unhinged or bonkers or one slice short of a loaf. Focusing on finding the right word is a distraction from considering the reasons why Trump is now being called crazy. Trump has always been incompetent, self-serving and grifting, colluding to bilk the public, ignoring the Constitution, allying himself with enemy nations and dictators, an embarrassment to our nation. None of that requires that he be crazy. Much of it is prosecutable because it is illegal.

      Somerby focuses on Costas' way of speaking because he refuses to deal with the reality of what Trump has been doing in office. Job #1 is to remove Trump, not reform the press in their choice of adjectives.

      Somerby sounds like the biggest fool on the planet when he writes this endless series of evasions in which he pretends to be critical of Trump, excoriates some hapless journalist for the crime Somerby himself commits daily -- avoiding the need to remove Trump from office NOW.

      Delete
  10. So Costas didn’t score style points with Somerby. It’s a crying shame.

    ReplyDelete