SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 21, 2026
Letting the poetry in: Let it be said that the poem in question is coming to us in translation, live and direct from the Russian.
We posted part of the poem in yesterday morning's report. Today, we'll go a bit farther. After that, we'll propose a parlor game:
PeopleYevgeny Yevtushenko
No people are uninteresting.
Their fate is like the chronicle of planets.
Nothing in them is not particular,
and planet is dissimilar from planet.
And if a man lived in obscurity
making his friends in that obscurity
obscurity is not uninteresting.
To each his world is private,
and in that world one excellent minute.
And in that world one tragic minute.
These are private.[...]
If only in translation, the poem continues from there. Beyond that, this is a poem by an anti-Soviet Russian poet. No one would say that it's a scientific treatise.
Still, it challenges us to think about the way we think about people—the way we think about other people, including people who aren't just like us. Today, we've added its non-scientific claims—its claims about the one excellent minute and about the one tragic minute.
We chatted yesterday with a friend about those (private) minutes. For ourselves, we could easily name our "one tragic minute"—it happened when we were fifteen.
The one excellent minute was more elusive. We thought of a minute at age 22, but its selection wasn't as obvious.
It's an intriguing parlor game—the attempt to identify that pair of alleged private minutes. But the poem's opening line remains a possible challenge to those of us who are Blue:
"No people are uninteresting," that challenging statement avers.
Talarico conquered on "Love thy neighbor." More on this topic next week.
Next week: Who is President Trump?
ReplyDelete"Beyond that, this is a poem by an anti-Soviet Russian poet."
Nonsense. Yevtushenko was very much pro-Soviet during the Soviet period. And in the post-Soviet period, when it became advantageous to be anti-Soviet, he became anti-Soviet. He was an opportunist, chameleon.
I noticed you always pick some sweet-talking creep to admire. Why is that?
Somerby is ignorant.
DeleteTrumptard, are you trying to convince us you know something about Yevtushenko when in prior posts you haven't been able to distinguish a ding-dong from a ho-ho?
Deleteanon 1:25 Where do you get off calling Yevtushenko a "creep" Are you not a "creep?" Who do you admire? Putin? Stalin?
DeleteI admire Petr Chaikovsky.
DeleteTo satisfy your curiosity, retard, it's the same reason I call you "retard": he actually was a sweet-talking creep.
Delete...as for Messrs. Putin and Stalin: you're quite right: these extremely successful politicians are exactly the opposite of sweet-talking opportunistic chameleons a-la Yevtushenko. And what of it? I didn't say I admire anyone, creep or no creep. Comprende? Or is this too complicated for a retard like yourself?
That’s good, but you didn’t explain how creepy Yevtushenko was.
Deleteanon - I see now, you get off on calling Yevtushenko a "creep" for the simple reason that (you say) he was a "sweet talking creep." I simply asked - are you yourself not a creep? Your response pretty clearly answered that question. I asked whether you admired Putin and Stalin (the impression I get from your posts and was curious) - thanks for your candor in admitting that you do. Are your opinings too complicated for a retard like me to understand? Yeah, right, have to admit you are a profound one, which makes it hard for retards like me to appreciate. And you guys sure love calling people "retards." Very attractive quality.
Delete
DeleteGees, retard. Yes, I'm calling you "retard", because that's what you are. Will you stop whining already? None your writings so far has done anything to convince me otherwise.
...as for Yevtushenko (for 9:43 AM), if Bob didn't call him "anti-Soviet", I would've probably just let it go. Bob likes that bullshit poem, fine, no arguing about tastes.
But "anti-Soviet"? The guy was the quintessential courtier, all his life. Licking ass, flattering all the powerful, and getting all the privileges.
Oh well.
anon, oh well, this is too tiresome. Enjoy calling everyone a "retard."
DeleteAre liberals good people?
ReplyDelete"University of Washington Students Chant ‘Charlie Kirk Deserved to Die’
“Women hold up half the sky, Charlie Kirk deserved to die”
An old saw says conservatives think liberals are good people with wrong ideas. Liberals think conservatives are bad people with wrong ideas.
Liberals support their POV with programs that supposedly help the needy, regardless of whether these programs actually worked. But, the response to Charlie Kirk's murder shows that many liberals are not good people. They're haters.
Conservatives do not believe liberals are good people. They believe we are demon obsessed satanists with bad intentions toward others.
DeleteLiberals consider conservatives potentially good people who are perhaps stupid, undereducated, indoctrinated by fundamentalist religion, greed obsessed and lacking in empathy. The wrong ideas emerge from that.
The needy are not conservatives or liberals but apolitical and focused on meeting their everyday needs at a basic level. It is a lie that liberals do not care whether programs work -- all programs have a built-in evaluation component to demonstrate their efficacy because that is required to get funding from the govt or private foundations.
David doesn't appear to be able to tell the difference between so-called liberals and right-wing anti-Kirk factions. Liberals are too busy helping the needy to waste time hating Charlie Kirk.
David perhaps doesn't know enough liberals to make a valid generalization about them.
No, he’s only married to, so he has claimed
DeleteThere’s no hate like the kind of Christian Nationalist love Kirk engaged in.
Delete
DeleteThose are not liberals, David. They're something else. Retarded Dumbocrats, wokies, something like that.
They hate everything and everyone; arithmetics is a tool of white supremacy to them. They are completely brain-dead, that's all. And there is nothing whatsoever liberal about them.
There’s no hate like the kind of Christian Nationalist love Kirk engaged in.
DeleteI get it, Democrats are go around trying to improve people's lives because they hate them. Check. I remember a few decades ago when Somerby tried to convince his readers that anything good done by liberals was merely performative, virtue signaling, not sincere empathy.
DeleteIt is the case that when someone lacks a quality, they will assume that others possessing that quality are faking it. Criminals, for example, believe that everyone else is just as criminal as they are, but just pretending to be better.
@2:08 - You are exactly right. Democrats try to improve people's lives. They don't go back and check whether they actually improve people's lives. Just making an attempt is enough for them to feel moral.
DeleteIf they ever did go back and check, they would discover that cities governed with Democratic policies are worse places to live than cities run with Republican policies. They would discover that many liberal leaders care more about power than about really helping people. They would discover that many non-profits are serving as ways to make money for those involved with them.
Fuck off, dickhead
DeleteIt is a lie that there is no evaluation of whether aid programs work. An evaluation component is required for every grant funded by the government, as are audits to make sure funds are spent as proposed. David keeps repeating this lie about Democrats not making sure aid is effective without having a clue about how such programs work.
DeletePeople who work for aid programs are paid salaries for their work, but their agencies must justify that pay is at a fair market rate for each job. Budgets are reviewed before funding. Non-profits are not slush funds. A person who works serving others is entitled to fair pay, just as teachers, doctors, and other service workers earn a fair wage for what they do, beyond the satisfaction of their work.
Are you under the impression that dickhead is engaging in good faith honest dialogue ? Lol 😂
DeleteHere's an example of what I mean:
DeleteJason Riley in a talk Tuesday at the University of San Diego School of Law.
“Racial preferences do more than simply violate our Constitution,” Riley said. “Racial preferences are not simply unjust. They also haven’t worked as intended, and in many cases they’ve been counterproductive.”
Will liberals investigate whether Jason Riley is right? Will they stop supporting racial preferences if they discover that racial preferences hurt blacks?
I say they won't. Racial preferences appear to be helping black people. Appearance is what liberals care about.
No one wants to live in worse cities run by Democrats, because housing there is too expensive, due to the laws of supply and demand.
DeleteYou can't expect a big-government socialist, like David in Cal, to understand how capitalism works.
The most corrupt and inept administration in history was chosen based on factors other than race, if you can believe that the all white cabinet composed largely of podcasters, Fox talking heads, entertainment figures, and anti science fraudsters excluded blacks by chance. Ask Stephen Miller, if you don't believe that.
Delete@1:11 - additional reasons people don't like living in these bad Dem cities are high crime, street garbage, poor schools, lack of good jobs, and high taxes. This is not a coincidence. Democratic policies had these consequences in city after city.
DeleteThe crazy thing about people not wanting to live with higher taxes is that Donald Trump is a pedophile that raped kids with Jeffrey Epstein.
DeleteDiC, Are you really saying that only “Dem cities” have these issues? What qualifies a city as “Dem”? Is it the mayor, or do you also include governing bodies like city councils? Is there some study showing that “Rep cities” fare better in the categories you mentioned? Do cities in general have issues and challenges as cities, regardless of who runs them? You mentioned garbage and high taxes simultaneously as problems. How do you propose that cities pay for garbage pickup? Is there genuinely a lack of jobs? In general, urban areas have far more job opportunities than rural areas.
DeleteDickhead is right. Republican cities, what few of them there are, are better places to live than democratic cities. Dickhead is going to move to one as soon as he dies.
Delete9:27;
DeleteAre you under the impression that dickhead is engaging in good faith honest dialogue ? Lol 😂
David, as a person, is not uninteresting. He contains worlds. Yevtushenko told me that. I must love David as Lincoln Jesus admonished us rather than smugly dismiss him as a mindless reciter of conservative talking points.
DeleteDavid can’t help it. He’s senile.
DeleteDavid has always been a cunt. Now he’s a senile cunt.
DeleteDavid is not now and has never been a cunt. He’s a lifelong prick.
DeleteDavid living with SS and Medicare wants to know if these programs are helping. What a fuckhead!
Delete@5:17 - Thanks for your comment. Can you supply any details on the nature of the evaluation components used for various programs?
DeleteBTW NGOs are not subject to the same detailed oversight that government programs are.
When the government gives money to an NGO, the public loses oversight of where that money goes.
A good example is the research conducted to assess abstinence only sex education programs funded by the feds in schools. Critics long argued that funding such programs, while popular among religious and conservative factions, waste money conpared to more comprehensive sex education.
DeleteResearch on the efficacy of such programs was funded and conducted to settle this ongoing debate.
As an experimental psychologist, I have participated on various grants to perform the evaluation component. An outside evaluator is involved in the design of a study to make objective measures (variables) are included to assess whether the goals of the program are being met. Assessment intervals are scheduled and a final evaluaton is performed at the end of a program. This is used to determine whether an ongoing program should be funded. One study that I worked on evaluated whether providing Hispanic cultural awareness training to hospital dieticians would improve the quality of care for Spanish speaking patients in hospitals in Southern California. It also assessed whether the dieticians felt more comfortable working with such patients as a result of such training. Change of diet is important to recovery after many surgeries and illnesses, so it is part of a dietician's job to discuss continuing care after release home with patients.
Job training programs are funded to serve people who are chronically unemployed and impoverished, by training them in high-demand skills that can be acquired quickly and make enrollees employable, taking them off unemployment insurance or disability. I was part of the evaluation component of federally funded programs and measured whether the people being served were actually the target population, drop-out rates, whether the enrollees felt they were benefitting and whether they were getting jobs. I also assessed longevity on the job and employer satisfaction with the people being sent to them to hire. How much additional training they required after being hired, and how they conpared to hires from other sources (with comparable experience). This info was used to both modify the program itself, going forward, and to apply for future funding. This kind of assessment is routine for federally funded programs.
On the grants that were part of my own research, the proposal format required a section describing the planned evaluation (with a budget and staff bios) as part of the routine consideration for the type of grant I was proposing. Universities and corporations have paid staff to help prospective investigators and administrators, know how to prepare this kind of required biolerplate.
The public doesn't know about this unless they have done it. I'm sure there are other forms of accountability for other types of programs, given that spending money efficiently and as intended if part of government oversight.
I do not know how much of this was disrupted by DOGE. I do know that when someone claims that no one cares whether money is being spent well, they are ignorant. In my own job, while a postdoctoral fellow, I was delegated by my Ph.D. mentor (a researcher) to interface with the govt auditor who was there to make sure money was spent, receipts and invoices were available for planned expenditures, and there was required paperwork on hand, such as informed consent forms signed by human subjects in each experiment conducted. The auditors were rigorous and conscientious, much like tax auditors. Trump may have done away with this. I wouldn't be surprised. Lefties tend to applaud it. It is clearly necessary to have documentation of results, given attacks by conservatives on all forms of spending, regardless of efficacy and importance.
It is completely untrue that NGOs are not required to show how govt money is used.
DeleteI worked for several years for a profit-making research organization in physics, developing and evaluating weapons for the military. The researchers there had govt grants to do their work. Govt auditors visited the firm regularly and it was a big deal when they came, as well as in-between visits, anticipating what they would need to see in terms of adherence to the planned research for each grant. They looked at things like whether classified documents were being handled properly -- the kind of thing that Trump ignored when he stole and then stored classified materials in a Mar-a-lago bathroom and ballroom. We had safes, a security team to monitor adherence, strict rules to follow.
DeleteI am astonished that David thinks everything is loosy goosy when it comes to govt work and govt funded contracts in corporations and universities. Non-profit organizations are also held accountable by those who fund them.
Later, I was a manager in a large computer company with international sales. I had a boss, a budget, and a large staff, also a profit target that our division was expected to meet. I think TV presents a wrong picture of business too. Elon Musk is one guy. If his father had behaved the way Elon does, Elon would have no money to play with to start any of his projects. Trump was only able to go bankrupt so many times because he is a crook. Real firms pay attention to business. They don't shift money from category to category to spend whatever they want on items with no relevance to their business. The bribes that have been paid to Trump and his staff are going to cause ripples of firing and financial consequences for those who have been paying them, whether it is CBS or Amazon. Accountability is coming and the deluge will not be pretty.
Hey Dickhead, go fuck yourself you lying piece of shit.
DeleteCopilot
Do NGOs Receiving Federal Funds Have to Show Their Books?
"Yes — NGOs that receive federal government assistance must keep complete financial records and, if they meet certain spending thresholds, must undergo a federal audit that the government can review.
If David is upset about NGO’s, he must surely be upset about the no-bid contracts to Trump family and donors, and the rampant corruption and lack of accountability in this administration. Surely.
DeleteDavid never provides evidence for any of his boiler plate assertions, but he demands it from others.
DeleteThis is worth watching and thinking about:
ReplyDeletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6_ENp_fO_Y
Working as Intended video
Yevtushenko comes from a collectivist society and has written a poem celebrating individuality. The USA is way more individualist than Russia or the USSR at any point in its history.
ReplyDeleteSomerby has at various points urged that we consider the similarity among people and not the diversity. He has called the diversity "babel" and said that a democracy cannot function with too much diversity, a message consistent with his opposition to immigration and concern about illegals and border control. It seems that Somerby does not really value the individuality that Yevtushenko celebrates.
The valuing of the individual humanity of each person on earth is more consistent with liberal attitudes than the conservative ones Somerby keeps advancing here. I find myself wondering whether he really understands the implications of what Yevtushenko says in this poem.
Somerby doesn't seem to like it when people make their differences part of their unique identities. He also is not on board with the liberal support for civil rights for all in our society, regardless of the things that make them unique (specific and particular, in Yevtushenko's translation). Liberals want our laws and social norms to be tolerant and accepting of those individual differences whereas conservatives want people to conform. Yevtushenko has written a poem about esteeming differences, a poem about freedom to be different because we are all unique in our private experience of our shared world. Somerby's complaints about liberal wokeness contradict that. I do not believe that Somerby and Yevtushenko would be on the same page in a face-to-face conversation about the freedom and elbow room to be diverse in our society (given that the poet objects to the restrictions of his own society).
DeleteI have no idea why Somerby resonates to this poem. It might be the aspect of being "hidden" in one's uniqueness. Somerby is very self-protective in his inability to commit to a point of view in his essays. He might like walking around and having strangers be unaware of his hidden urges and responses to the world. Or perhaps he likes the idea that all people have value and are interesting without having to actually BE interesting or accomplished in any way. It would void the concept of success and failure for a narcissist whose audiences have been smaller than he might like, to feel that he is nevertheless valuable because he is interesing in his uniqueness.
Yevtushenko sought exposure for his ideas in his poetry. Somerby wants to write but is afriad to say what he thinks, so he camoflages everything in conflicting meanings, irrelevant puffery, and images that make no sense. He then, perhaps, laughs at those who seek to understand him, because he has made that effort so difficult. He thinks, impossible, but there is always self leakage in what he writes.
Yevtushenko is the braver man. That is why his readers admire him. Perhaps Somerby is attracted to that bravery too, even if he cannot emulate it.
How is Somerby a narcissist?
DeleteSomerby seems to find “reds” fascinating, and seems to find “blues” quite uninteresting. He’s always wanting blues to go to the local diner to understand reds, but not vice versa. That’s his narcissism.
DeleteHis writing is mysterious, and often inconsistent and incoherent, unless and until you become aware he’s a right wing grifter, then it all makes sense. Somerby’s problem is that he’s only fooling a handful of trolls, but of course they’re faking it too.
How is Somerby a narcissist? His two main careers in his life have been (1) teaching, which involved standing in front of children and trying to get them to pay attention to you, to learn something via the cleverness of your words, and (2) stand-up comedian, which involved standing in front of adults and trying to get them to pay attention to you, evoking laughter with the cleverness of your words. Both are "look at me" professions (along with actors, musicians, models, politicians, now influencers and celebrities with podcasts).
DeleteSometimes people ask why Somerby writes this blog day after day. It is part of one's narcissism to be rewarded by creating a forum where others read and react to what you've said. Another "look at me" moment. When people react to what you've said, you feel validated, important, of consequence in a world where most people are anonymous (Yevtushenko says).
Other people get that feeling by doing good deeds for others, nurturing and caring for them. Or building and making things, designing them, forming wood or metal into something new.
The problem with narcissism is that such people tend not to care about other people other than as observers. It is hard to have relationships without some reciprocity of attention.
Most people would consider teaching children a prime example of nurturing and caring for others, so your post is self-contradictory.
DeleteSome people got into teaching to nurture children. Others do it to avoid the draft.
DeleteBoth are noble reasons.
DeleteI strongly disagree that avoiding the draft is noble. If someone objects to a war, they can apply for conscientious objector status and do alternative service, or protest that war, or self-deport. Those with serious objections (beyond inconvenience or fear) took such actions. We decide as a nation whether to participate in a war, then as citizens we support that decision, just as we pay taxes without evasion, vote with diligence, and obey the laws of our community. This is a reflection of a person's character.
DeleteWe as a nation never decided to attack Vietnam. Our leaders decided that. Somerby chose a good option: stay out of that criminal war, help less fortunate children.
DeleteThis is why it matters who you elect as leaders. Somerby should have prepared for the job of teacher, if he cared about kids.
DeleteHe did prepare: he studied philosophy.
DeleteTeaching kids because you are using them to avoid the draft strikes me as not noble.
DeleteHe could have studied developmental psychology, learning theory, classroom management, American history, like real teachers do. Disadvantaged kids need better teachers not under-prepared ones like Somerby. Unsurprisingly, he has implicitly blamed those black kids for his own deficiencies.
DeleteHell no, we won’t go!
DeleteYou’ve got to throw your body on the levers and the gears. You’ve got to make it stop!
DeleteYou must be a right-wing, war-loving reactionary!
Delete“Unsurprisingly, he has implicitly blamed those black kids for his own deficiencies.”
DeleteThis is a steaming-hot pile of pure excrement. Have you no decency?
Has Somerby no decency? He was the one discussing the intransigence of racial gaps on NAEP. That’s a fancy way os saying black kids can’t learn. Who says that?
DeleteAnd now you deflect rather than defend your indefensible accusation. Pitifully transparent.
DeleteI deflect, I defend, I deny.
DeleteSomerby repeatedly pointed out that even when test scores in math and reading increase for whites and blacks, the gap still remains, leaving black kids lower performing than white kids (or Asian kids). He never discusses Hispanics. He never discussed sociological reasons why poverty and disadvantage might be higher among black families.
DeleteSomerby said that a female athlete who had been accepted on a scholarship to an open-entry college shouldn't have been offered one because she would not be able to succeed there. There was no evidence provided in the news article indicating low academic performance, Somerby just assumed it.
Somerby went out of his way to declare that the improved reading scores in Mississippi resulting from increased spending on education mandated by the State legislature were bogus. He has said repeatedly that claims of improvements in academic performance are scams, cons, not possible. On the other hand, he praised performance of TX schools. So why is it not possible in Mississippi? Perhaps because 40% of the state is black and the status of black education was so neglected that some black children had no schools to attend under segregation. Somerby didn't say.
Somerby said that he supported the rioting parents historically opposing desegregation in Boston because parents should not have to send their kids to school with black children. He also supported the schools banning books by black authors (such as Toni Morrison) because parents should be able to block their kids from reading them -- even though parents were already permitted to opt out of classroom requirements to read such books.
Somerby was against the demands of parents of black children for more seats in NYC's science high schools -- there were only 8 black kids admitted that year. He failed to address the segregated middle schools that were feeder schools into the science high schools. He said that black kids would not be able to do the work, regardless of their interest in science.
Somerby claimed that Ketanji Brown Jackson could not be the most qualified nominee available to fill a Supreme Court vacancy, despite her top grades, high recognition by her universities and clerkship, high performance as a federal judge, and universal praise. He implied that a white man would have been more qualified, although he never explained why, leaving readers to assume that she was an affirmative action promotion and hadn't actually earned her accolades.
Somerby has never understood that diversity is itself an additional qualification because it brings a unique experience (lauded by Yevtushenko) not already represented by non-minority judges on the court.
Consider how a man with negative racial attitudes would feel when the children in his classroom failed to improve after his best efforts. Does he blame his own lack of preparation? Of course not. He assumes that it is the fault of the kids. If Somerby had ever given full effort to learning to teach well, to special problems of reading among kids coming from less literate homes, to identifying learning deficits, to helping kids by relating material to their own life experiences outside the mainstream, to diagnosing and addressing their obstacles to learning, then he might be justified in concluding that the problem lies with the kids, not his own work. I have seen no evidence Somerby did any of that. I have heard him say things like, maybe a 4th grader shouldn't have been shown The Forgotten Village, indicating a lack of understanding of the needs and developmental level of black children of that age. Somerby used to quote John Holt's books and complain about miracle movies showing dramatic changes in attitude by kids when encouraged to write rap poems and express themselves (another aspect of bigotry, mocking efforts to engage kids by relating to their subcultures), such as Dangerous Minds. Unfortunately for Somerby, the film Stand and Deliver is a true story.
DG's knee-jerk defense of Somerby is uninformed, both about teaching and about what Somerby has said in this blog over the years.
Wow. What a blowhard you are.
Delete"He (Somerby) was the one discussing the intransigence of racial gaps on NAEP. That’s a fancy way of saying black kids can’t learn. Who says that?"
DeleteSome elementary logic: if blacks scored zero, then you'd be justified in saying the NAEP scores show they can't learn. If they score lower than other groups, then you may be justified in saying they don't learn as well as these other groups, and you'd want to figure out why.
"Who says that?"
You did. Somerby didn't say black kids can't learn. You put those words in his mouth.
No, Somerby owns it.
DeleteExcessively literal again.
Delete1:59, you're treading close to Slab-o-Tron level. You clocked in at 666 words, compared to Bob's 295.
DeleteActually, you've probably already reached the summit, since I'm quite certain you made other comments on this particular board.
How dreary. How droll. I don't know why you do it. Jesus. Then again, I don't know why I reply. Usually, I just scroll on by, but sometimes...
Leroy
Scroll on by. If you care more about word count than content, why do you read anything?
DeleteLeroy, it’s nothing more than a tiresome Gish Gallop designed to distract from the point at issue, i.e., whether Somerby blames his black students for his “deficiencies.”
DeleteThat’s a no-brainer. Of course he does.
DeleteIt’s creepy to think anyone cares what happened to you at ages 15 and 22, it’s even creepier to think anyone is going to buy into finding Hitler or the slavers “interesting”.
ReplyDeleteIf someone rises from the dead at age 15 (or 22), I'd call that interesting.
DeleteDead is dead. There’s no rising from the dead.
DeleteJesus is a myth.
Religious indoctrination is a form of abuse.
Somerby's memory of something happening at those ages has certainly been distorted over time so that he wouldn't recognize those actual experiences as they really occurred. People create their own myths about their lives. What if the most tragic moment has yet to occur?
DeleteJesus may have existed, and he may have rebelled against Rome. We don’t really know.
Delete
DeleteHe didn't rebel against Rome. He rebelled against his tribal co-religionists of the time; "Pharisees", they were called. Jesus was criticizing them, trying to reform his tribal religion.
All the Pharisees did was self-righteous virtue-signaling, just like what the retarded Dumbocrats do nowadays. Their leaders used Romans to get rid of that dangerous reformer.
...a few years later, some guy named Saul saw a talking bright light, changed his name to Paul, and established a new, universal (that is: non-tribal) religion. The rest is history.
The Romans wouldn’t have crucified him for rebelling against the Pharisees.
DeleteWhat about the money-lenders in the temple? They weren't Pharisees.
DeleteHe didn't have anything against money-changers. He objected to money-changing inside the Temple, allowed (for "donations", I'm sure) by the religious authorities.
DeleteAs for the Romans, their role was to keep order, and they relied on communal authorities to identify the trouble-makers.
What the fuck you fucking idiot 1:38. A bunch of faggots in Rome put the bible together 300 years after Christ croaked.
DeleteCharlie Kirk was my cousin. In private, he was actually an atheist.
ReplyDeleteI didn’t know Charley, but it’s easy to believe he was an atheist, just like Ayn Rand.
DeleteAlso a prick. At least you don't have to see the chud anymore!
Delete"It's an intriguing parlor game—the attempt to identify that pair of alleged private minutes."
ReplyDeleteAll minutes in our lives are private. The notion of "qualia" says that no one can know what others experience in the subjectivity of their minds, even when we know what is happening in the external world.
Asking someone to recall one excellent and one tragic minute says something about memory access, the fluency of recall of some memories over others. Some tragic moments require a therapist's help to retrieve. The memory a person chooses to describe to others may be very different than the one that pops into mind at another moment, given other retrieval cues and prompts.
Yevtushenko is saying that each of us has good times and bad ones because all lives have ups and downs. He is not talking about memory or any contest between the excellent and tragic. Some of us may be predisposed to consider more experiences excellent and fewer tragic. There is an interplay between attitude and the details of one's life. Somerby is obviously an Eeyore. Looking at the highest high and lowest low obscures the general tenor of someone's ongoing experience, which is way more important given the much larger number of minutes involved.
Somerby doesn't seem to think much about what he likes or why he likes it. Thinking probably ruins the emotional reaction for him. That avoidance would make him a poor candidate for therapy. The lack of introspection and insight keeps him locked in his repeating problems. That may be why his blog is so repetitious and he never seems to read new poems or books, or discuss anything he hasn't said a million times before. Besides the right wing talking points.
You were sort of making sense until that last sentence. I guess haters gonna hate.
DeleteYou don't know any more than I do about whether Somerby is being paid as an influencer. Calling me a hater for suggesting the possibility is ridiculous given that many of those who ARE paid influencers are proud of it and not trying to conceal their activities.
DeleteSomerby is senescent. He’s not going to improve, he’s going to get as bad as David.
DeleteAgeist pig!
DeleteMore name calling. Somerby is 80 and his essays are evidence of decline. That is not bias.
DeleteWell, to be precise, it is prejudice.
DeleteNo, it is an assessment based on specific evidence.
DeleteIt is not prejudice to make a negative age-related statement, if that statement is based on Somerby and not a generalization from a stereotype. DG must know this, so his response is more trolling and name-calling.
DeleteYou don’t just disagree with him, you try to persuade us that you are correct because Somerby is degenerating from age. That’s how ageist pigs argue.
DeleteThe fact that you disagree with Somerby is not evidence of his senility. That you think it does is evidence of your prejudice.
DeleteDon’t you have an actual life?
DeleteMy wife is retired now but she used to work for a government facility that made nuclear weapons, and she says whenever Republicans are in power they are eager to conduct a first strike against woke commies and have a new world arise from the ashes in their image, but when Democrats are in power their always trying to get rid of nukes and spend money on infrastructure.
ReplyDeleteI had an excellent minute with a sex worker.
ReplyDeleteNobody cares.
DeleteWhere is empathy? Am I not interesting?
DeleteWhat can you do that any trained monkey can't?
DeleteI can troll a blog. A monkey can’t do that, although AI can.
DeleteShow me a decent example of your trolling, and I'll tell you if you're interesting.
DeleteAnd no, "excellent minute with a sex worker" is not it.
Next time I do some good trolling, I’ll bring it to your attention.
DeleteNo one should look down on anyone else. I’m sure bigots, pedophiles, racists, fraudsters, sociopaths and authoritarians are very interesting people who contain worlds. People who are duped (or let themselves be duped) by sociopaths who proceed to undermine our country should be coddled.
ReplyDelete“No people are uninteresting.”
ReplyDeleteI don’t know, Bob. Gutfeld?
ReplyDeleteWhoa, there is an actual reptiloid in Mamdani's entourage. They ain't even hiding no more...
"The federal government has acknowledged that an Austin man deported to Mexico following a Central Texas traffic stop in April is a U.S. citizen, reversing its earlier position as it seeks to dismiss a lawsuit accusing immigration agents of violating his constitutional rights.
ReplyDeleteBrian José Morales GarcÃa, 25, was born in Denver and is a dual citizen of the United States and Mexico, federal attorneys said in a motion filed Friday in U.S. District Court in Austin. The acknowledgment comes nearly seven months after U.S. Border Patrol agents sent him to Mexico despite his repeated claims that he was American." [MSN News]
Brian Jose?
DeleteMixed Spanish and English names are common here. Welcome to the Western Hemisphere.
DeleteAn unfamiliar name makes you guilty!
DeleteThe Administration has deported or otherwise persuaded around 2 million people here illegally to leave the country. These illegal immigrants were allowed here by the prior administration.
DeleteIn the course of doing 2 million difficult, dangerous chores, they made a few mistakes. The mistakes allow people who have done nothing to feel morally superior to people who are successfully doing a difficult job for the country.
That’s what the Nazis said, dickface
DeleteThe only way to make this mistake was to fail to listen to the guy when he said repeatedly that he is a citizen of the USA. Why would they do that?
DeleteDavid talks about illegals, but the point is that this guy is a CITIZEN, said so to ICE and was still deported. That means this could happen to any of us, at least the ones who are profiled as brown skinned with Hispanic names, like many legitimate citizens in the Western USA, and the East Coast where there are many Puerto Rican people (who are born US Citizens too).
Of course someone is morally superior when they don't make a mistake in the first place, but listen when someone tells them there is a mistake, so that a person who is a citizen is deported and then not returned without a lawsuit. HE WAS BORN IN DENVER! This is not a matter of self-deporting.
I do not understand why the burden of proof is on citizens and not on the ICE agents to prove someone lacks citizenship. There is no law requiring US Citizens to walk around with papers documenting their status, all the time. ICE should have to prove someone is illegal or has overstayed a visa, before incarcerating them. ICE should be required to listen and respond when someone says they are born in Denver, not snatch people using violence and sort it out later in court, after weeks or months of detention. ICE should be required to have some degree of certainty before violating a citizen's right to live unmolested in their own country.
Somerby doesn't consider blue Americans interesting.
Delete“ICE should be required to have some degree of certainty…”
DeleteWhy? When they know they get away with it with impunity because of Nazi symps like Dickhead in cal
If a guy is a citizen but no hablo ingles well enough, he should carry his naturalization certificate in his pocket.
DeleteBut hey, free travel to Mexico and back to Texas. Big deal.
The constitution doesn’t say you have to speak English.
Delete
DeleteIf you weren't a retard, you'd know that I didn't say that either.
Someone born in the USA in Denver, now age 25, speaks English well, even if his parents do not. In fact, he is probably bilingual, which is an asset not a liability.
DeleteThe problem is not that ICE wasn't informed that he was a citizen, but that they deported him anyway. It took 7 months to get to this point, where the govt has finally admitted it made a mistake.
ICE is being given quotas that have encouraged them to sweep up people regardless of their specifics, just to meet the demands placed on them by Trump and Stephen Miller (so they can brag about how many people they have detained). We are now hearing that ICE agents are not properly trained in determining the status of people they encounter.
Asshole Rs gave ICE $200 Billion. Defund this bullshit.
Delete'The mistakes allow people who have done nothing to feel morally superior to people who are successfully doing a difficult job for the country."
DeleteSure, I'll fix that for you:
"The mistakes allow people who have done nothing to feel morally superior to murderers."
There.