THE LETTERS: Times readers endorse a treasured tale!

FRIDAY, JANUARY 3, 2020

Disappearing the actual problem:
The letters the New York Times chose to publish strike us as an embarrassment.

For those who want to know how our discourse works, they also seem highly instructive.

The letters, which were nine in number, appeared on Sunday, December 22. Eight of the letters seemed to agree with a highly familiar premise.

This premise was most clearly stated in Letter 4. No one else rose to dispute it:
LETTER TO THE NEW YORK TIMES (12/22/19): The stagnant results of the international PISA exam have spoken: An extensive overhaul in the American education system is desperately needed.
An extensive overhaul of our education system is desperately needed! So said the writer of Letter 4—and essentially, so said them all.

This gloomy conclusion had been drawn from a gloomy front-page report in the Times—a gloomy report which had appeared on December 6.

In her front-page report, Dana Goldstein had painted a gloomy portrait which inspired the gloomy letters. In essence, it went like this:

Our kids' Pisa scores had been so awful that they called for an "extensive overhaul" of American schools. Things are "desperately" wrong across the board, or so these letter writers now said.

We the people have been told this gloomy story forever. Because we read such stories in the Times (and in Washington Post), we very strongly tend to assume that the gloomy story is true.

But what if the treasured old tale isn't true? What if it's grossly misleading? Below, you see some actual Pisa scores in reading, the main focus of the 2018 tests.

These data define a terrible problem. It just isn't the terrible problem those New York Times letters described:
Average scores, Reading Literacy, 2018 Pisa
United States, Asian-American kids: 556
United States, white kids: 531
Estonia: 523
Finland: 520
United States, Hispanic kids: 481
United States, black kids: 448
A terrible problem actually is defined by those terrible data. But it isn't the terrible problem the New York Times likes to describe when it sits down to play with its dolls—when the hapless newspaper tells us one of the stories it very much prefers.

We've included tiny Estonia in that chart because it was the highest-scoring actual country on the 2018 Pisa test. We've included very small Finland because Letter 4 went on to offer standardized thoughts about the reason why fabulous Finland's miraculous schools perform so much better than ours.

Tiny Estonia and very small Finland were the two highest-scoring nations on the Pisa reading test. (Canada also scored 520.) And yes, you're reading those data correctly:

Our nation's white kids, as a group, outperformed the highest scoring countries in the world. Our Asian-American kids scored so high that they should probably all be drug-tested.

This leads us to a question:

Those are actual data from the Pisa reading test—the test from which the New York Times derived and spread a deeply gloomy conclusion. But let's go ahead and be truthful for once:

As you peruse those data, does our education system seem to be a mess across the board? Or is it failing to produce strong results among certain groups of children?

Which of those two is our actual problem? Let's try telling the truth just this once, though we know that the Times never will!

Those terrible data do, in fact, define a terrible problem. It just isn't the problem those letter-writers stood in line to describe, after being prompted by the front page of the Times.

Do our public schools test too much? Arguably, yes!

That said, over-testing didn't produce gruesome results across the board on the Pisa reading test! Neither did the alleged failure to teach phonics, another way those letters claimed that our schools desperately need an overhaul—an "extensive" overhaul, an overhaul across the board.

Good lord! if they only served white and Asian kids, our schools would be the highest-scoring in the world! Or at least, that's the situation those data describe—a situation you'll never see reported in the Times.

Why doesn't the New York Times (or the Washington Post) report those "disaggregated" test scores? It isn't because they're hard to find—those data are highlighted in the official, easy-reader report about the Pisa scores.

Our guess? The Post and the Times are embarrassed by the horribleness of those scores. For that reason, they simply refuse to report such facts. In the process, they seem to describe a sweeping, system-wide problem, a system-wide problem which doesn't exist in those terrible Pisa scores.

It's hard to have sufficient contempt for new orgs which function this way, as all our news orgs do. That said, let's take a moment to think about the people who wrote the letters the New York Times chose to publish.

We'd call those letters an embarrassment for one embarrassing reason. Those letters weren't written by Joe and June Blow. Many of those letters were written by educational specialists—by people who ought to know better.

Letters 1 and 2 were written by long-time education writers. Letter 3 seems to have come from a high school English teacher.

Letter 5 came from "the director of the Right to Read Project." Letter 7 came from someone who teaches English at West Chester University.

Letter 9 is a special case. Its writer, a retired education professor, pointed to a situation which gives the lie to a second recent report in the Times about educational testing.

Her letter was extremely valuable—so much so that we'll postpone our treatment of it until next week. But even her letter had nothing to say about the misleading news report about those Pisa scores. None of these writers said this to the Times:

There you go again! There you go, once again, with one of your treasured tales.

The New York Times refuses to tell you the truth about our achievement gaps. The Times prefers to pretend and suggest that the gaps are rather small—that they can be addressed in certain phantasmagoric, feel-good ways involving "desegregation."

Out in the Hamptons, such feel-good stories sell. In the process, our nation's elites have found the latest way to throw our black kids under the bus, to ignore the actual shape of their needs, their interests, their lives.

If we credit those Pisa scores, our schools aren't failing across the board at all! Instead, our schools are doing very poorly, on average, with our black and Hispanic kids.

Next week, we'll examine some possible reasons for that. We'll also blow up that other Times report, the one which found Mississippi rising on the recent Naep tests.

We'll visit Mississippi next week, hailing Letter 9 as we do. But for today, let's take instruction from the letters the New York Times chose to publish:

The letter writers had read it in the Times. It had even appeared on the famous newspaper's front page.

No one checked the actual data. It didn't seem to occur to these letter writers that the Times might be telling a tale.

They simply believed what they read in the Times! In such ways, our failing, flailing, floundering discourse runs on fictitious fuels.

Next week: Mississippi (not actually) rising

14 comments:

  1. “No one checked the actual data. It didn't seem to occur to these letter writers that the Times might be telling a tale.”

    And it apparently never occurred to Somerby that the letter writers agreed with the Times’ assessment *because they are informed on the subject and find the Times’ assessment accurate.*

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello everyone. I was heartbroken because i had very small penis, not nice to satisfy a woman, i had so many relationship called off because of my situation, i have used so many product which i found online but none could offer me the help i searched for. i saw some few comments about this specialist called Dr OLU and decided to email him on drolusolutionhome@gmail.com
      so I decided to give his herbal product a try. i emailed him and he got back to me, he gave me some comforting words with his herbal pills for Penis t, Enlargement Within 5 day of it, i began to feel the enlargement of my penis, ” and now it just 2 weeks of using his products my penis is about 10 inches longer and am so happy..feel free to contact DR OLU on(drolusolutionhome@gmail.com)or whatsapp him on this number +2348140654426  



















      Delete
  2. “We'll visit Mississippi next week, hailing Letter 9 as we do. “

    It should be noted that Letter 9 makes a bold statistical assertion that is not backed up by any evidence. The letter deserves as much critical scrutiny as the others that Somerby attacks.

    ReplyDelete
  3. ‘The New York Times refuses to tell you the truth about our achievement gaps. The Times prefers to pretend and suggest that the gaps are rather small—that they can be addressed in certain phantasmagoric, feel-good ways involving "desegregation."’

    Just yesterday, Somerby said: “Our nation's giant "achievement gaps" come into stark relief in those horrible data. Simply put, the New York Times (and the Washington Post) refuse to report or discuss such scores.”

    So, yesterday, he told us they refuse to report or discuss the gaps. Today, suddenly, they do discuss them, just not truthfully.

    And there is no story that pretends or suggests that the gaps are small, nor one that suggests that desegregation is the only possible solution to achievement gaps, nor one that claims that reducing the gaps is the only positive outcome of desegregation.

    Desegregation is presented as a positive goal in its own right, one that may be tough to attain. But, if it is desirable and important, why should it not be discussed and promoted? That is how you attempt to change things, by having the conversation.

    Perhaps liberals could just give up on integration. Would that suit Somerby?

    ReplyDelete
  4. “Mississippi (not actually) rising”

    So, apparently those "perpetual laggards in Mississippi” (http://dailyhowler.blogspot.com/2019/12/mississippi-muddle-what-explains.html) really still are laggards, as it turns out.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Replies

    1. My name is Jackie Wicks, I never thought I will smile again, My husband left me with 3 kids for 2 years, All effort to bring him back failed I thought I'm not going to see him again not until a friend of mine told me about a spell caster called Dr. Wilson, She gave me his contacts and I contacted him and he assured me that within 48hours my husband will come back to me, After i did all he asked me to do, in less than 48hours my husband came back started begging for forgiveness and he came back with much love and care, so I'm still surprise till now about this miracle, if you need any assistance from him you can contact him via:
      Email: drwilsonspellhome711@gmail.com
      Telephone: +23409057802867

      Delete
  6. The title of the letters section was:
    “Why Education Reforms Aren’t Working”.

    It is specifically referring to education reforms. One of the biggest, No Child Left Behind, had as an explicit focus the reduction of the achievement gaps:

    “An explicit focus of NCLB, reflected even in the name of the legislation, was to improve opportunities for historically disadvantaged groups of students. NCLB required that states disaggregate math and reading scores for specified subgroups and then sanctioned schools for failing to make “adequate yearly progress” within those subgroups.”

    (This from the Brookings Institution).

    So, the fact that the achievement gaps haven’t substantially changed since the law was enacted would indicate the correctness of the claim: “Why Education Reforms Aren’t Working”. That is, indeed, precisely what is meant here.

    ReplyDelete
  7. 'It's hard to have sufficient contempt for new orgs which function this way, as all our news orgs do.'

    We understand that Trumptards like Somerby have a lot of contempt for news orgs, because … well because they're Trumptards and only like news orgs that support Donald Trump, Roy Moore, Ron Johnson, Devin Nunes and Jim Jordan.

    ReplyDelete

  8. My name is Jackie Wicks, I never thought I will smile again, My husband left me with 3 kids for 2 years, All effort to bring him back failed I thought I'm not going to see him again not until a friend of mine told me about a spell caster called Dr. Wilson, She gave me his contacts and I contacted him and he assured me that within 48hours my husband will come back to me, After i did all he asked me to do, in less than 48hours my husband came back started begging for forgiveness and he came back with much love and care, so I'm still surprise till now about this miracle, if you need any assistance from him you can contact him via:
    Email: drwilsonspellhome711@gmail.com
    Telephone: +23409057802867

    ReplyDelete
  9. My Name is Dr sebi you can Contact Me via Email drsebicurecenter@gmail.com For Penis Enlargement Product to help you get as long as 8inches Long with good Erection. Contact Me Via Email : drsebicurecenter@gmail.com   Via WhatsApp +2347010538590

    ReplyDelete
  10. Good day to all viewer online am so happy sharing this great testimony on how i was checking for solution in the internet then miraculously i came Across Dr.LOSA the powerful herbalist that Cure Numerous individuals Herpes Simplex Virus,so I contacted him base on the testimonies I?m seeing about him on the internet, I was cured too by him, kindly contact him actoday through his email he can help you email ; dr.losaherbalhome@gmail.com and so he can cure types of diseases like,HEPATITIS B,DIABETICS,CANCER,HPV,LOW SPERM CAM HIV/STDS FIBROSIS LOST OF WEIGHT .. all thank to you Dr LOSA for your kindly help in my life his Mobile number +2349056464736

    He cure listed diseases
    CANCER
    HEPATITIS A AND B
    DIABETIC.
    HERPES

    ReplyDelete
  11. Greatest thanks to Dr Moonlight for his herbal drugs that he prepared for me and when i start using it in just 2weeks i was completely cured and that ended my HERPES SIMPLEX 1&2 DISEASE i am so happy and grateful to Dr Moonlight . after reading about him on a testimony of Jason Cash on a blogger. i knew suddenly Dr Moonlight was the right Doctor to cure my HERPES SIMPLEX 1&2 DISEASE. i discuss with Dr Moonlight and he prepared a herbal medicine for me and when it got sent to me in south korean . i used the herbal medicine and 2weeks and i went to check up again. after 15years of suffering from HERPES SIMPLEX 1&2 at last i am smiling once again. Dr Moonlight also has remedy to others disease like COLD SORES,HIV/AIDS,DIABETES.CANCER,HIGH BLOOD PRESSURE AND MANY MORE. I oblige everyone to contact this powerful herbalist Dr Moonlight and be free from your suffering. contact Email:moonlightspellcaster@gmail.com
    Dr Moonlight herbs is the perfect remedy for Herpes1&2, HPV, HIV and other diseases.

    ReplyDelete
  12. LOTTO, lottery,jackpot.
    Hello all my viewers, I am very happy for sharing this great testimonies,The best thing that has ever happened in my life is how I win the lottery euro million mega jackpot. I am a Woman who believe that one day I will win the lottery. finally my dreams came through when I email believelovespelltemple@gmail.com and tell him I need the lottery numbers. I have spend so much money on ticket just to make sure I win. But I never know that winning was so easy until the day I meant the spell caster online which so many people has talked about that he is very great in casting lottery spell, . so I decide to give it a try.I contacted this great Dr Believe and he did a spell and he gave me the winning lottery numbers. But believe me when the draws were out I was among winners. I win 30,000 million Dollar. Dr Believe truly you are the best, all thanks to you forever

    ReplyDelete