What are the sources of that disproportion?


When the NBA season resumed, players were allowed to have social justice messages on the backs of their uniforms.

Somewhat discordantly, the NBA and the Players Association created a list of permitted messages. At Bleacher Report, Tyler Conway listed the 29 messages NBA players would be allowed to convey:
CONWAY (7/8/20): "Equality" and "Black Lives Matter" are the two most popular phrases NBA players will use on the back of their jerseys when the 2019-20 season resumes in Orlando later this month.

NBPA executive director Michele Roberts told Marc J. Spears of The Undefeated that 285 of the 350 players expected to be in Orlando have chosen to have social justice messaging on their jerseys in place of their last name. Seventeen players will keep their last name, while the league is still awaiting word from the remaining players.


The players had their choice of the following options for the back of their jerseys: Black Lives Matter; Say Their Names; Vote; I Can't Breathe; Justice; Peace; Equality; Freedom; Enough; Power to the People; Justice Now; Say Her Name; Sí Se Puede (Yes We Can); Liberation; See Us; Hear Us; Respect Us; Love Us; Listen; Listen to Us; Stand Up; Ally; Anti-Racist; I Am A Man; Speak Up; How Many More; Group Economics; Education Reform; and Mentor.
It's a bit like cable news! Performers are allowed to say certain things. But the performers aren't allowed to say anything else!

(Apparently, LeBron James won't be wearing a message. CBS reports that here.)

Admittedly, the NBA's restriction on speech is perhaps a bit discordant. That said, some of the officially permitted messages are perfectly sensible, even highly admirable. That's even true if such messages may perhaps resemble bumper stickers or pointless political slogans.

Players were given 29 options. As we glanced at some NBA games, we were struck by players who chose the slogan, "Say Their Names."

Whose names are they talking about? we wondered. Also this:

How many such names have they heard?

This brings us back to the two disproportions we wrote about last week. At issue is a very important topic: fatal shootings by police officers, and other such deaths at the hands of police.

Again as a matter of basic fairness, we start with an important disclaimer:

In all likelihood, most such incidents do not involve misconduct by police. Wesley Lowery even seems to say as much on page 16 of his book, "They Can't Kill Us All"—a book whose title may suggest that someone is trying to do so.

Most such incidents probably don't involve police misconduct. That said, other such incidents plainly do.

Presumably, it's the names of the victims of those incidents which we most need to hear. But how many such names have NBA players, or anyone else, been permitted or encouraged to hear?

With that question, we reach the first of last week's disproportions. We refer to the vastly disproportionate way such events get covered by the upper-end press corps at the present time.

At least since early 2012, such events have been very heavily covered—if the victims are black. But if the victims are white, Hispanic or "other," such events don't get covered at all!

(We're using the taxonomy of the Washington Post, from its Fatal Force web site.)

George Floyd died facedown in the street as part of what can only be seen as a heinous event. Everyone has heard his name, as is completely appropriate.

That said, Tony Timpa died facedown in the street, and crying, in Dallas—and no one has heard his name! That includes all those NBA players—and we feel sure that most would care if they ever heard Timpa's name.

That was the first disproportion we discussed last week. A second disproportion was accurately stated by Matt Stieb at New York magazine:
STIEB (7/14/20): As CBS News’ Wesley Lowery noted in 2016, the most recent census data shows that there are almost 160 million more white people in the U.S. than there are Black people. White Americans make up around 62 percent of the population, but 49 percent of those killed by police officers; Black Americans make up 13 percent of the population, but represent 24 percent of those [shot and] killed by police officers. According to a database compiled by the Washington Post, 1,301 Black people have been killed by the police since 2015, while 2,495 whites were killed. But because of the vast demographic differences, Black Americans are killed at a rate more than twice that of white Americans.
Some of Stieb's numbers weren't quite right. Beyond that, he didn't mention the very low rate, as a percentage of population, at which Asian-Americans are shot and killed by police officers.

That's part of this serious story too. Such information might even help us think our way through the causes of these disproportions.

That said, Stieb accurately stated a second disproportion. After adjusting for population, black Americans are indeed shot and killed by police officers "at a rate more than twice that of white Americans."

We'll guess the disproportion would drop a bit if statisticians made further adjustments for population—if statisticians adjusted for age, for example. But there's little doubt that black Americans are killed by police at a disproportionate rate.

This leaves us with an important question:

What is the cause, or what are the causes, of this second disproportion?

We'll return to that question after we explore a related topic this week. When we do, we won't be able to answer that question definitively. That said, the current approved message is this:

That disproportion reflects the racism—indeed, the systemic racism—within American police departments.

The NBA would approve that message, as does anti-Trump cable news. But to what extent is that statement true? To what extent can it fully explain that second disproportion?

That would be a difficult question to answer. Below, we'll link you to two analysts who have offered other possible reasons for that disproportions—reasons which move beyond misconduct by police.

We'll return to that topic next week. For today, here's one of the reasons why that question matters:

Somewhere in California, a 7-year-old boy is "terrified" because of the things he's been told. His mother says he actually wants to leave the country, she's managed to frighten him so.

It sounds like his mother is very scared too, and it sounds to us like she may have ingested some misconceptions. That said, it's easy to ingest misconceptions when our upper-end press corps engages in one of its many Storyline-driven stampedes.

Back in the say, people developed a misconception about Candidate Gore being a psychologically disordered liar. People developed misconceptions about Hillary Clinton, and about Susan Rice.

We develop misconceptions all the time. We do so based on the novelized content served to us by the remarkably unimpressive people who sit at the very top of our national "press corps."

They spread misperceptions all the time. In our view, they're doing do now.

If you massively cover one set of deaths, but completely ignore all other such deaths, people will inevitably form certain misconceptions. You may end up with terrified children, and with Hopkins philosophy professors who are afraid to leave their homes.

The New York Times will rush to publish such assessments. Those assessments are straight outta Storyline—and papers like the New York Times routinely run on such fuel.

The NBA is full of decent, impressive people. But, like everyone else, they don't always hear "the whole truth."

We offer this obvious observation as an anthropology lesson—as an overview of the way our species conducted itself in the years before the global conflagration despondent anthropologists already describe as Mister Trump's War.

As a matter of anthropology, the behavior of our upper-end journalists tends to illustrate a very important point. Our war-inclined species, Homo sapiens, was never "the rational animal," as advertised down through the years.

Instead, we were always the tribal animal. We were the animal which worked from preapproved Storylines, repeating preapproved scripts.

At present, the press corps' Storyline is designed to tell us how much they care about matters of racial justice. We've never seen the slightest indication of any such concern in the past.

You can't believe what these creatures tell you, not even about those deaths. They'll cover some deaths, then disappear others. Routinely, they'll invent and recite phony facts about the deaths they do cover.

NBA players don't know these things. If somebody told them, they'd care.

Starting tomorrow: The modern American novel (Franklin County jail)

Sharpton and Cobb plus two more: Should journalists report all deaths which seem to involve police misconduct?

Putting it another way, is it possible that all deaths matter? That's what Reverend Sharpton recently seemed to say:
SHARPTON (7/17/20): The real question you have to ask yourself is, why are whites or blacks being killed unjustifiably by police?...[President Trump] shows no concern about the accountability of why police are killing anyone if it is not justified.
Sharpton almost seemed to imply that all deaths matter! Meanwhile, is the problem of policing confined to the policing of people who are black? Back in June, Jelani Cobb went on TV and said this:
COBB (6/10/20): One other point that I have been making a lot, I have been making all the time, is that one of the reasons that this problem has been allowed to persist is that people have the perception that this is a black and brown problem.

But if you were to discard all of the incidents involving black and brown people, what you would find is, there are a heck of a lot of white people, unarmed white people, who are killed by police each year.

We have a fundamental problem with policing in this country
, whose most extreme violent forms are witnessed in how we see black and brown people treated by law enforcement.
Professor Cobb seemed to say that the problem with policing extends beyond the cases we're currently permitted to hear messaging about. Is it possible that we should hear all the names from all the cases cases where police misconduct occurs?

Finally, we'll link you to a pair of analysts who think the current Storyline is either 1) too simplistic or 2) just plain wrong.

The first just person is Professor McWhorter. You can read his analysis here; he even says Timpa's name.

The second person is Heather MacDonald. Yes, we know—she's a racist and one of The Others! That said, we think she made some basic points in this recent column for USA Today.

Your limbic brain will tell you we're wrong. You'll have to decide for yourself.

The Post and the Times sell Storyline. So does cable news.

Sharpton and Cobb and McWhorter oh my! Is it even dimly possible that current Storyline could be wrong? Could it even be doing significant harm, for instance to 7-year-old boys whose mothers have formed misconceptions?

Please understand that we're just asking! Above all else, we fully agree:

Storyline is our species' great god. Recitation will always be all.


  1. "What are the sources of that disproportion?"
    "But to what extent is that statement true?"

    It's disproportional alright, only in the opposite direction.

    Clearly, dear Bob, the police force is incentivised to avoid tackling "black" criminals, or else they're gonna get this scumbag Wesley Lowery and the whole crowd of race-war enthusiasts on their back.

    So, I imagine the police would often ignore criminals of the Superior Race protected by the liberal cult, rather than perform their duty.

    So, yeah, disproportional, dear Bob.

    "They spread misperceptions all the time."

    That's their job, dear Bob, as they are goebbelsian bureaucrats, working for the liberal Ministry of Truth. Little eichmanns.

    You know this as well as I do, dear Bob.

    1. Still haven't forgiven the corporate-media for saying you were "economically anxious" and not "a bigot", Mao?
      Me too.

  2. Brilliant! Journalists such as Lowery are more than scumbags, they are little Eichmanns. The media ecosystem therefore goes beyond mere propaganda, and enters into the realm of the Holocaust! WE ARE BEING SLAUGHTERED BY THE INFORMATION WE READ AND HEAR!!! Never before had I imagined that things could be this bad. My eyes have been opened. I am all a-tremble.

    I thank you, dear Mao.

    I am Gao.

  3. I do not have a problem with Somerby wondering about the extent of racism, considering discourse and policy is heading in the opposite direction.

    All those moments of wondering will be lost in time, like tears in rain.

  4. “At present, the press corps' Storyline is designed to tell us how much they care about matters of racial justice. We've never seen the slightest indication of any such concern in the past.”

    It’s a pretty safe bet that matters of racial justice have actually been written about and reported on by the press corps “in the past.” Does anyone honestly think otherwise?

    And even assuming for the sake of argument that Somerby is right, it makes no sense to accuse someone of merely pretending to care now simply because they didn’t before. Just because someone didn’t care before doesn’t mean they don’t now care.

    And how does Somerby have access to the minds and souls of “the press corps” to know whether they care or don’t care, and whether the purpose of the Storyline is to show that they care?

    Was the Storyline that Al Gore was a liar designed to tell us how much the press corps cared about the issue of politicians lying? It makes more sense to say that the Storyline was “Al Gore is a liar.” What it was designed to do is anyone’s guess, but it likely wasn’t chiefly to get people to think the press cared about the issue of lying.

    So with the issue of racial justice. Wouldn’t it make more sense to say the Storyline is “there is racial injustice in policing” and that the coverage is designed to illustrate that? Once you bring the press corps’ motives into it, you are outside a factual framework.

    And it goes without saying that Somerby’s juxtaposition of “Al Gore is a liar” with “there is racial injustice in policing” is meant to suggest the possible lying absurdity of the latter.

  5. Murder rates are skyrocketing in cities all over the country. A disproportionate number of the victims are black. Far more black Americans are killed by civilian murderers than by police. Furthermore, those killed by other than police are generally innocent people, unlike most of those killed by police.

    Will ordinary, civilian murder victims ever be the focus of media and NBA jerseys?

    P.S. Our media can't fool black Americans, who see the killings all around them. That's why Trump will get a record high black vote.

    1. Yeah. Actually, it's funny, in a way. The liberal cult decided to out-populist Trump, and their idea of populism is race-riot.

      And so it goes..

    2. I hope he isn't relying on such a surge to win.

    3. Murder rates are skyrocketing?

      More people died of Covid in the last three weeks than were murdered in all of last year.

      Do you think you can fool black Americans into forgetting what Trump's outlandish, ignorant decision making has wrought?

    4. Murder and violent crime are down significantly. You're a liar. I guess that's all you two idiots have at this point. Desperate lying and fear mongering to scare people. You both are evil liars.

  6. Somerby's argument hinges on his assertion that white shootings are not reported by the press. This is untrue. I have seen such deaths reported, including the ones Somerby himself has been talking about.

    It wouldn't make any sense to claim that the police are bigoted against white people and that such bigotry is inflating the number of white killings. I don't believe there is any evidence supporting that idea.

    Somerby also complains that the messages on the backs of the NBA jerseys are limited to a handful of allowed slogans. This sounds a lot like a negotiated settlement to me, a compromise between the players and team management and the league.

  7. Somerby wants to know the sources of racial disparities but he objects to the 1619 Project and doesn't want to hear when anyone talks about racism and slavery and the civil war.

  8. SAVE YOUR MARRIAGE IF YOU LOVE YOUR HUSBAND OR YOUR EX LOVER  . if I refuse to share this testimony it means I am selfish to myself and to the people I love so much whom might have similar problems, my husband left after a little misunderstanding and never came back home at first I thought it was a joke he left me for his mistress outside, all this happened September I am sharing this testimony because Christmas is around the corner and will be a very bad celebration if you don't spend it with your loved one's, so many men will live their wife and celebrate Christmas with their girlfriend, I complained to my very good friend she told me she had such problem in her marriage until she was introduce to DR PADMAN a specialist doctor who specializes in bringing back broken homes and broken marriages DR PADMAN  website: https://padmanspell.com/index-3.html  cast a spell for me in December 2nd surprisingly my husband came home December 6th apologizing that I should forgive him that this will never happen again. With this I will never forget DR PADMAN who saved my marriage. His contact address is padmanlovespell@yahoo.com , https://twitter.com/padman_dr.  WhatsApp +19492293867 you can still save your marriage if you really love your husband  Website: http://padmanspell.com/

  9. Having herpes is not the end of life there many treatment to cure herpes infection with the help of  Dr Alika herbal product.  I was positive to the deadly virus called HERPES and i lost hope because i was out casted and rejected even by my closet friends.
    i searched on-line to know and enquirer about cure for HERPES VIRUS  and i read someone testimony on how he was cured from Herpes virus so i decided to contact the same herbalist Call Dr Alika because i know that nature has the power to heal everything.
    i contacted him to know how he can help me and he told me never to worry that he will help me with the natural herbs from God!
    after 2 days of contacting him, he told me that the cure has been ready and he sent it to me via UPS SPEED POST and it got to me after 3 days!
    i used the medicine as he instructed me (MORNING and EVENING) and i was cured!
    its really like a dream but i am so happy!
    and if you need his help, you can email him on dralikaherbalhome@gmail.com or whatsapp +2348116570358

  10. Having herpes is not the end of life there many treatment to cure herpes infection with the help of  Dr Alika herbal product.  I was positive to the deadly virus called HERPES and i lost hope because i was out casted and rejected even by my closet friends.
    i searched on-line to know and enquirer about cure for HERPES VIRUS  and i read someone testimony on how he was cured from Herpes virus so i decided to contact the same herbalist Call Dr Alika because i know that nature has the power to heal everything.
    i contacted him to know how he can help me and he told me never to worry that he will help me with the natural herbs from God!
    after 2 days of contacting him, he told me that the cure has been ready and he sent it to me via UPS SPEED POST and it got to me after 3 days!
    i used the medicine as he instructed me (MORNING and EVENING) and i was cured!
    its really like a dream but i am so happy!
    and if you need his help, you can email him on dralikaherbalhome@gmail.com or whatsapp +2348116570358

  11. ALS is the worst thing to ever happen to any human being, I could still remember how my dad struggled with ALS for 7 months, i watched him helpless dying slowly almost every day,  22/2/2020 was a day I cannot forget in my life the day I meet with dr babaLola after a brief discussion with him he assured me that he was going to heal my dad, I smiled with faith and gave him the chance to and it took him just 7 days and my Dad’s health was restored. My dad, who was dying slowly and getting weaker daily, suddenly got strength and energy to walk and move his body freely. We went for a test and the doctor confirmed that my dad was well. Feel free to reach out to babaLola today bababolahealinghome@ gmail. com or chat him on whatsapp via +2349059610643 he heals a lot of sickness and diseases such as HIV, herpes-virus, Parkinson, ex back, help to get pregnant, cancer e.t.c  

  12. Am Laura Mildred by name, i was diagnosed with Herpes 4 years ago i lived in pain with the knowledge that i wasn't going to ever be well again i contacted so many herbal doctors on this issue and wasted a large sum of money but my condition never got better i was determined to get my life back so one day i saw Mr. Morrison Hansen post on how Dr. Emu saved him from Herpes with herbal medicine i contacted Dr. Emu on his Email: Emutemple@gmail.com we spoke on the issue i told him all that i went through and he told me not to worry that everything will be fine again so he prepared the medicine and send it to me and told me how to use it, after 14 days of usage I went to see the doctor for test,then the result was negative, am the happiest woman on earth now thanks to Dr. Emu God bless you. Email him at: Emutemple@gmail.com Call or Whats-app him: +2347012841542 

  13. Thanks for sharing this phenomenal post. I must say i enjoyed scanning this wonderful post. It had been very informative and helpful post you tell us, continue to good work. Please visit Call Girls in Kolkata to know why The Call girls in Kolkata are known for their dusky and fair skin tone and you can take the service from any of them according to your wish.

    call girls in Kolkata
    Kolkata call girls
    call girl services in Kolkata
    Kolkata call girl services
    call girl agency in Kolkata
    Kolkata call girls agency
    call girl agencies in Kolkata
    Kolkata call girl agencies
    independent call girls in Kolkata
    independent Kolkata call girls
    escorts in Kolkata
    Kolkata escorts
    independent escorts in Kolkata
    independent Kolkata escorts

  14. I have been suffering from a deadly disease (Hsv) for the past 3 years now, I had spent a lot of money going from one places to another, from churches to churches, hospitals have been my home every day residence. Constant checks up have been my hobby not until this faithful day, I was searching through the internet, I saw a testimony on how Dr Onokun helped someone in curing his (Hsv) herpes disease, quickly I copied his email which is Dronokunherbalcure@gmail.com just to give him a test I spoke to him, he asked me to do some certain things which I did, he told me that he is going to provide the herbal cure to me, which he did, then he asked me to go for medical checkup after some days after using the herbal cure, behold I was free from the deadly disease, he only asked me to post the testimony through the whole world, faithfully am doing it now, please brothers and sisters, he is great, I owe him in return. if you are having a similar problem just email him on : Dronokunherbalcure@gmail.com