GAPS IN CHICAGO: Can Sean Reardon's claim be right?

WEDNESDAY, MAY 30, 2018

Part 2—A quick trip back through the years:
Could it really be true? Could Chicago be the place "where students learn the most?"

That's what the headline seemed to say on the New York Times report. The report appeared in mid-December of last year. Needless to say, it has generated exactly zero discussion.

It has generated zero discussion because nobody actually cares. As is blindingly obvious, no gives a flying flip about Chicago's low-income kids who, or so it seemed we were told, are the students who "learn the most."

No one cares at your liberal journals. Rachel and Lawrence don't care. They would greedily gulp the hemlock before they'd deign to discuss Chicago's kids. We know that because more than five months have passed—and no one has said a single word about the high-profile Times report, which seemed to say that Chicago's kids are the ones who "learn the most."

Briefly, let's be fair. For those who read the Times report—for those who got past the headline and the photograph of the six beautiful little girls in a Chicago elementary school—for those who actually read the report, the Times report didn't exactly say that Chicago's largely low-income, "minority" kids are the students who "learn the most."

That isn't exactly what the Times said. More specifically, the Times report said this:
BADGER AND QUEALY (12/13/17): It’s true that children in prosperous districts tend to test well, while children in poorer districts on average score lower. But in this analysis, which measures how scores grow as student cohorts move through school, the Stanford researcher Sean Reardon argues that it’s possible to separate some of the advantages of socioeconomics from what’s actually happening in schools.

In Chicago, third graders collectively test below the second-grade level on reading and math. But this data shows that over the next five years, they receive the equivalent of six years of education.
By the eighth grade, their scores have nearly caught up to the national average.
The headline had overstated what the report really said. According to the actual report, Chicago's kids "test below the second-grade level" at the end of third grade. But over the next five years of school, the average student in Chicago records six years of academic growth.

Badger and Quealy go on to say, partly through the use of a graphic, that this is the largest amount of growth recorded in any of our nation's 200 largest school districts. In one of their interactive graphics, the reader can see that only a limited number of smaller school districts record more growth from Grade 3 through Grade 8 than the Chicago Public Schools, the nation's third-largest school system.

Summarizing:

According to the Times report, kids in Chicago don't exactly "learn the most." But on average, they record nearly the largest academic gains of any group of kids in the nation during the five-year period from the end of third grade to the end of eighth grade.

The record six years growth in five years time—or at least, so says Stanford's Sean Reardon. The Times report is based on the data from his latest nationwide study.

We've cited Reardon's work many times at this site. Way back when, in April 2013, he became the first person we ever saw break the code of silence concerning this nation's Naep scores—more specifically, concerning the large score gains which have occurred on this "gold standard" of domestic educational testing over the past several decades.

Because no one cares about any of this, no one mentioned what Reardon said. Let's recall the jailbreak he staged away from that noxious silence code. We enter his essay in progress, as he dispels a few myths:
REARDON (4/28/13): Before we can figure out what's happening here, let's dispel a few myths.

The income gap in academic achievement is not growing because the test scores of poor students are dropping or because our schools are in decline. In fact, average test scores on the National Assessment of Educational Progress, the so-called Nation's Report Card, have been rising—substantially in math and very slowly in reading—since the 1970s. The average 9-year-old today has math skills equal to those her parents had at age 11, a two-year improvement in a single generation. ...

The widening income disparity in academic achievement is not a result of widening racial gaps in achievement, either. The achievement gaps between blacks and whites, and Hispanic and non-Hispanic whites have been narrowing slowly over the last two decades.
Say what? Average test scores have been rising—for example, by two years in math by the age of 9? Our public schools are not in decline? As the overall scores go up, the racial gap is narrowing? Could Sean Reardon say that?

Here at this site, we'd been attempting to "dispel those myths" for years when this essay by Reardon appeared—and we'd learned that it can't be done. And sure enough:

Inevitably, no one mentioned what Reardon said when he broke the code of silence that day. That's because no one actually cares about any of this—and certainly not about the lives and interests of Chicago's low-income kids.

In that five-year old essay, Reardon wasn't focused on "racial" achievement gaps. He was focused on the gaps between kids from higher- and lower-income families.

That said, if you read between the lines in the passage we've quoted, you could discern another fact from what Reardon wrote. The average Naep scores of black and Hispanic kids had been growing rapidly too. That explains how "racial gaps" had been narrowing, even as the average American fourth-grader was two years ahead of where her parents had been in math.

When he broke the code of silence, Reardon took a permanent place our radar screen. Five years later, just last month, the Washington Post let an amazing thing occur—the editors let Arne Duncan state the same basic facts:
DUNCAN (4/2/18): Since 1971, fourth-grade reading and math scores are up 13 points and 25 points, respectively. Eighth-grade reading and math scores are up eight points and 19 points, respectively. Every 10 points equates to about a year of learning, and much of the gains have been driven by students of color.

It should be noted that the student population is relatively poorer and considerably more diverse than in 1971. So, while today's kids bring more learning challenges, they perform as much as 2 1/2 grades higher than their counterparts from half a century ago.
Displaying the inevitable ineptitude, Duncan understated the amount of academic growth recorded since 1971. He did so by failing to "disaggregate" those test scores, which also come from the Naep. Had he sifted the data that way, he could have described such apparent advances as these:
Average scores, Grade 8 math, Naep
Nationwide, public schools
Black students only:

2013: 262.73
2011: 261.84
2009: 260.28
2007: 258.90
2005: 254.19
2003: 251.75
2000: 243.27

Hispanic students only:
2013: 271.02
2011: 269.45
2009: 265.90
2007: 264.36
2005: 261.09
2003: 258.13
2000: 251.75
Why have we omitted results from 2015 and 2017? Simple! In the past few years, at the height of Duncan's miraculous reforms, average scores have dropped back a few points for both groups of kids!

We'll post those disappointing scores below. But over the thirteen-year time span we're displaying, Duncan's (standard) ten-point rule suggests that black and Hispanic eighth-graders improved in math achievement by almost two academic years! Unless there's something wrong with those data, black kids were (and still are) way ahead of the black eighth-graders who had come before!

Simply put, the American public has almost never been allowed to hear such facts. Nor have you ever seen anyone inquire as to why that steady academic growth has seemed to come to an end in the past few years.

You've never seen that question raised or discussed! Most simply put, Rachel and Lawrence and other top stars don't care about low-income "minority" kids, and certainly not in Chicago!

The indifference of our corporate elites kept the public from hearing about those very large score gains. That same contempt for low-income kids has kept the public from being told that years of impressive academic gains now seem to have stalled.

Last December, along came Reardon again, this time making a surprising claim about the kids of Chicago. You haven't heard a word about that because, as an obvious matter of fact, nobody actually gives a flip about those non-elite kids. Your favorite stars care about students at Yale!

From the end of grade 3 to the end of grade 8, do Chicago's public school kids really record academic growth which almost goes off the charts? On the other hand, if Chicago's schools are so goldarn good, why were the city's kids scoring so poorly at the end of third grade to begin with?

You've asked two very good questions! Tomorrow, we'll examine the large growth displayed by recent Chicago cohorts on the Naep, from the end of the Grade 4 to the end of Grade 8.

On Friday, we'll offer you some gloomier news. We'll show you why it was almost obscene when a headline told us, in typical fashion, that Chicago is the place "where students learn the most."

You'll hear none of this from Rachel, Lawrence or Chris. Their handlers want you entertained by the nightly excitement of The Chase. When it comes to Chicago's kids, they feel quite sure you don't care.

Tomorrow: From Grade 4 to Grade 8 on the Naep!

The end of an era: Here are the average Grade 8 Naep math scores from the last two test administrations:
Black students only:
2017: 259.60
2015: 259.85

Hispanic students only:
2017: 268.49
2015: 269.47
Why have those scores slid back a few points? We don't have the slightest idea. Also, nobody cares!

26 comments:

  1. I'll give you credit for understanding that any analysis with the word "racial" in it is bullshit, Bob.

    However, your fixation on scores (and especially "average scores") reveals, in my opinion, a typical lib-zombie technocratic attitude.

    Whatever the scores, people growing up in a US inner-city ghetto will not be educated, not in the traditional sense of the word. They will become well-educated in terms relevant to their environment (drug trade, violence, etc.), but not algebra or classical literature.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. anyone growing up an ignorant undisciplined lazy racist trust fund child in the financial capitol of the world will become well educated in money laundering, fraud, sexual assault, organized crime and the art of the con, but he definitely won't know jack shit about algebra or classical literature. And he will remain a Chickenshit lying coward for the rest of his miserable shameless depraved degenerate existence.

      Delete
    2. MY HUSBAND IS BACK WITH THE GREAT HELP OF DR SAM LOVE SPELL

      My husband was flirting with another woman. until he vanished away, I was desperate to get him back, I wasted so much time and money trying to get my Husband back, I tried almost all possibilities to have him back and nothing worked. I became lonely. To make it short, I found a spell caster Dr Sam. I saw the good testimonies about his wonderful work and after reading the Testimonials, I decided I had to try and give it one last try and After the spells, a miracle happened, my husband came home. It was awesome, anyone who needs help, should email him (Supremespellcast@gmail.com Or Supremespellcast@yahoo.com) Or whatsApp him on these number. +2347087462033..

      Delete
    3. ENOUGH IS ENOUGH FOR THE WISE,PROSPER LOAN FIRM IS THE ONLY WAY OUT FROM ANY FINANCIAL DIFFICULTIES { prosperloanfirm@yahoo.com }

      Greetings great mind, It will be my greatest pleasure saving Individuals and companies from extortion, I know not everyone will want to take it upon their self to reveal the bitter truth about online Lending because of insecurity, Time of doing it and all that. I Ryan F. Tyler, an outstanding businessman who reside at Oakland, California has taken it upon himself to share this article to whom it may concern so they can learn and educate their self from it . It's bad to the extend where you see testimonies online about getting a loan and it turn out to be fake. For real i have fallen for that tricks countless time to the extend i lost almost 65,000usd in total all in the name of getting a loan to invest in a very lucrative business. After so many failed attempt of securing a loan, I and my Manager went online to do a thorough search and found this company PROSPER LOAN FIRM +1(816) 366-8769 ) but before giving it a try we also went ahead to make sure they are registered under BBB, check their reviews and also go to their headquarter to confirm their existence and capability.We were so careful because we didn't wanted to lose any dime again and to our greatest expectation they deliver according to their review and grant us our desire loan amount of 510,000.00Usd. A word to everyone out there when it comes to Online Lenders contact only PROSPER LOAN FIRM via email: { prosperloanfirm@yahoo.com } or drop a message to them via text at +1(816) 366-8769 and consider all your financial problems tackled and solved.#SHARE, You can rescue someone from been victimized today, Thanks.//...

      Delete
  2. "You'll hear none of this from Rachel, Lawrence or Chris. Their handlers want you entertained by the nightly excitement of The Chase."

    Hopefully, MSNBC can set aside its coverage of a grave crisis in our democracy to begin their 11,000-part series "Gaps and Scores At Every School District In America."

    That'll bring those swing voters over to "our" side.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Today's TDH post shows the increasing likelihood that Bob has been replaced by a robot. The real
    Bob is probably holed up with his analysts in a cabin in an undisclosed location somewhere deep in the woods of Montana.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Disclaimer: Bob Somerby is not an education specialist. He was a teacher, but we don't know if he was any good at it. Clearly, he didn't like it much, since he left those beautiful kids behind to hobnob with future Big Deals like Roseanne.

    He has never lived in Chicago. He does live in Baltimore, where he was actually a teacher. But he would rather talk about Chicago's public schools.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's weird to me that some people are incorrigible on the point that Bob isn't covering schools or testing or any of the rest of it: he's covering reporting on these things.

      Delete
    2. He doesn't cover reporting. He gripes about reporting and whatever a reporter does, Somerby is unhappy about it.

      Somerby never talks about DeVos, for example, or the press coverage of her term as Education Secretary. He doesn't talk about Common Core or its coverage. He didn't talk about how the press did or didn't coverage the respective education plans for Sanders versus Clinton.

      He mainly mentions college only when describing the elite ivy league backgrounds of reporters he dislikes.

      So don't pretend this blog is about covering education reporting. It plainly isn't.

      People here are responding to the OTHER things Somerby talks about. If he raises a topic it is fair for readers to comment on it. It is weird to me that anyone objects to that.

      Delete
    3. Hey, anon @1:30: Do ya think maybe the newspaper in deepest darkest Baltimore covers education issues there? Ten to one it does. And Somerby might just know a little more about Baltimore's public schools than Chicago's. (or maybe not).

      When Bobby tells us that "desegregation" of urban schools is a terrible horrible offensive liberal idea, is he merely "covering the reporting" by giving us his personal opinion on this topic?

      Delete
    4. Bob is right to be very cynical and it has something but not everything to do with race; it has a lot to do with economics. I'm not sure if he trusts his audience with the full picture, but here's sort of what's going on:

      I attended the scholars program at a high school in Albany Park, Chicago which is a working class neighborhood. The school specifically tried to get diversity so that you wouldn't be the only Filipino kid and feel isolated. It worked great, our honors classes were much more diverse, our school had very little violence, high morale, our bands and sports teams won all kinds of competitions.

      On the other hand, at my brother's high school which had a prestigious International Baccalaureate program, the honors students were entirely White/Asian, and the regular classes are all poor and Black. These internally segregated schools are the kinds that New York Times journalists come from, where they learned to say all kinds of hateful things about Black and Arab people. They suppress it but you can sometimes feel it in the subtext when they describe people from Haiti and Palestine as naive or brutish. They're kind of becoming a laughingstock. Bari Weiss applauded an Mirai Nagasu for her success as an immigrant, with the only problem being she was born in California.

      What Bob is possibly alluding to in all these reports on the fake failing of public schools is that they do have competition that is trying to define the discussion, and it's being interpreted by technocrats who grew up in these racist honors programs. Charter schools, rather than explicitly promote segregation like private suburban schools, work through gentrification of the city. The journal Sociology of Education looked national data and found "The ability to opt out of the neighborhood school increased the likelihood that a mostly black or Hispanic neighborhood would see an influx of wealthier residents." (https://www.chalkbeat.org/posts/us/2018/03/16/an-integration-dilemma-school-choice-is-pushing-wealthy-families-to-gentrify-neighborhoods-but-avoid-local-schools/). These schools also support gentrification by not graduating their students who are disabled or learning English. The only reason to do this is to show higher test scores, although even with this going on they rarely beat public schools.

      All of this hullabaloo is really just a distraction from the fact that by championing these schools, our liberal intelligentsia have helped push Black and Hispanic people out of neighborhoods. "Austerity" and "Competition" just mean gentrification. The villains are not the teachers unions, it is the internal segregation of schools.

      Delete
    5. Just Another Block-Quoting BlockheadJune 1, 2018 at 12:25 AM

      From the Globe & Mail:
      The etymological history of liberal and intelligentsia would suggest the phrase is positive.
      Intelligentsia entered English in the 1920s from the Russian intelligentsiya, which dates back to at least 1836 in its sense of an educated class of people (some sources specify the bourgeoisie) fascinated by and promoting ideas in pre-revolutionary Russia. A 1956 article said "intelligentsia" had long been applied to "intermediaries between local life and wider life."
      The Russian word was probably borrowed from the Polish inteligiencja, which ultimately derived from the Latin intelligentia, intelligence. The Latin verb intelligere combined inter (between) and legere (read, choose); it meant to make choices, to understand. Intelligens, the Latin present participle of intelligere, gave English the word intelligent.
      For its part, the word liberal has led a confused life. Politically, it used to be a rallying cry for those seeking less government and more individual liberty, and more recently has been employed to mean the opposite, a call for greater government regulation.
      But the non-political sense is everything a body might wish. Liberal entered English by the 1300s as a synonym for generous, independent and speaking freely – no surprise, since it originated in the Latin liber, free. By the 1770s, the Oxford English Dictionary records, it had the sense of "free from bias, prejudice, bigotry; open-minded, tolerant." By those lights, the liberal intelligentsia seems a good club to belong to.
      Another thought struck me on reading the phrase. Everyone talks about liberal intelligentsia, but nobody seems to talk about conservative intelligentsia. Yet the phrase exists. A random database check of English-language newspapers over the past 12 months found 164 uses of "liberal intelligentsia" and 29 of "conservative intelligentsia."
      Some of those 29 articles saw conservative intelligentsia as desirable. A piece in the Ottawa Citizen on July 10 regretted that, in Canada, "a conservative intelligentsia is so thin on the ground." But U.S. talk-radio host Rush Limbaugh opined on July 29 that "the conservative intelligentsia, the conservative so-called media inside the Beltway, would have accepted anything" in the debt-ceiling struggle, by which he meant that the intelligentsia didn't have the spine of the Tea Party.

      Delete
  5. "Simply put, the American public has almost never been allowed to hear such facts. Nor have you ever seen anyone inquire as to why that steady academic growth has seemed to come to an end in the past few years."

    Despite the trashing of American education by press and right-wing politicians, parents are very happy with their local schools and typically give them high ratings. They seem to make an exception for their child's school. I believe that is because most schools are competent and doing a good job with most children.

    When you focus on test scores and compare means across strats, you are talking about most children, even when you disaggregate the data. It is still about means (averages). But parents are focused on the needs of their individual children, so those numbers are not meaningful to them. What does matter is the fit between their child and the resources offered by the school.

    College-educated parents also know what it takes to get into college, so they focus on the actual preparation of their child, not just his grades. They are concerned about test scores, but not the ones that assess schools -- the ones that assess individual children, and that is not the NAEP. They worry about other opportunities, such as AP courses, SAT prep, extracurriculars, good math and science classes. NAEP measures none of that.

    It is too early to interpret a decrease in the rate of improvement in NAEP scores as anything beyond a statistical blip, random variation. But if it were a meaningful change in progress, it would be fair to ask whether improvement is linear and whether the low hanging fruit have been plucked and further improvement might require some other kinds of changes. Unless Somerby wants to wade into the weeds and examine what kinds of change produced the decades of increase in scores, he cannot really talk about why the rate of change seems to be slowing down.

    Children don't develop at a constant rate. Their progress mirrors changes in the brain that occur at certain specific times. So their progress is not linear. Why should progress in improving schools be linear either, especially when different states are doing different things? Unless you know what caused the increase in mean scores, it is hard to discuss why that increase is slowing down. I would love it if we could have that discussion here. It would mean Somerby would stop posting NAEP scores over and over again and actually talk about education.

    ReplyDelete
  6. If people trust these scores, they should be asking, "What is Chicago doing right?" Other school districts should be trying to mimic Chicago's successful approach. Media should be reporting one what Chicago is doing that works so well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If you found out that Chicago is spending more time on basic skills in reading and math and less time on science or social science or music or art, would you still thinking they were doing things right?

      Delete
    2. There isn't just one "right" way for schools. However, when one runs across a totally demented spoiled intractable racist little shitpile like little Donny the Coward, the only possible approach is to send him to a black school to let the black principle beat the snot out of the kid before he grows up to be a criminal sociopathic amoral lying sack of shit racist abomination.

      Wouldn't you agree, Traitor DinC?

      Delete
    3. AnonymousMay 30, 2018 at 3:47 PM -- as a hypothetical question, I sure would. Reading and math are so vital in today's society that I would sacrifice various other subjects, IF that were necessary.

      However, I do not necessarily accept the hypothesis, that all these other subjects must be sacrificed in order to teach reading and math.

      Delete
    4. @david: "Media should be reporting on what Chicago is doing..."

      What do you think the story was reporting that Bob is discussing (and criticizing) here?

      Delete
  7. Powerful Effective Love Spell Get Your Ex Back About a month ago I got back to my ex(after 2 and half years separated).Everything was ok and she was the most adorable woman in the world. she spoke about wedding ceremony, how many kids we would have, said that our relationship was the most important thing in her life and he was 100% sure about it…Then he traveled to work in other country for 3 weeks. he changed his behavior completely. he disappeared every night, was saying she had to do some work and would talk to me later, but disappeared the rest of the day and night… no explanation, when I asked why she was disappearing every night, she stopped answering me. she’s ignoring me since last week, April 15. she ignored even my birthday, that was April 16. Not even a message. I wrote to her a few times trying to understand what happened, she read but just ignored me.I feel so bad cause I couldn’t stop contacting and trying to understand what happened.i loved her so much and wanted to get her back, then i was told to contact happylovespell2@gmail.com who can help out with a love spell to reunite your relationship back, so instantly do contact him and give him a try and trust me he did an urgent effective love spell for me and with 46hours promise he made to me, my woman was back, today i testify to you all that you should seek and contact Dr happy for his spell result is genuine sure and guarantee unite and get your ex back save your marriage/relationship problem now, email happlovespell2@gmail.com you can also know more about his spell Blogs site.http://happylovespel.blogspot.com.ng/ Whatsapp/cal +2348133873774

    ReplyDelete
  8. Classic Daily Howler in his element. Thanks for this.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Powerful Effective Love Spell Get Your Ex Back About a month ago I got back to my ex(after 2 and half years separated).Everything was ok and she was the most adorable woman in the world. she spoke about wedding ceremony, how many kids we would have, said that our relationship was the most important thing in her life and he was 100% sure about it…Then he traveled to work in other country for 3 weeks. he changed his behavior completely. he disappeared every night, was saying she had to do some work and would talk to me later, but disappeared the rest of the day and night… no explanation, when I asked why she was disappearing every night, she stopped answering me. she’s ignoring me since last week, April 15. she ignored even my birthday, that was April 16. Not even a message. I wrote to her a few times trying to understand what happened, she read but just ignored me.I feel so bad cause I couldn’t stop contacting and trying to understand what happened.i loved her so much and wanted to get her back, then i was told to contact happylovespell2@gmail.com who can help out with a love spell to reunite your relationship back, so instantly do contact him and give him a try and trust me he did an urgent effective love spell for me and with 46hours promise he made to me, my woman was back, today i testify to you all that you should seek and contact Dr happy for his spell result is genuine sure and guarantee unite and get your ex back save your marriage/relationship problem now, email happlovespell2@gmail.com you can also know more about his spell Blogs site.http://happylovespel.blogspot.com.ng/ Whatsapp/cal +2348133873774

    ReplyDelete
  10. Effective love spell to get your Ex back urgently
    Hello
    I'm so excited share this testimony,
    i sincerely hope my post gets read
    and hopefully helps somebody along
    the line my husband took my case
    to court for a divorce. he said that
    he never wanted to stay with me
    again, and that he didn’t love me
    anymore. So he packed out of the
    house and made me and my
    children passed through severe
    pain. I tried all my possible means to
    get him back, after much begging
    but all to no avail and he confirmed
    it that he has made his decision and
    he never wanted to see me again.
    So on one evening as i was coming
    back from work i met an old friend
    of mine who asked of my husband.
    So i explained every thing to her so
    she told me that the only way i can
    get my husband back, is to visit a
    great spell caster called Dr Ahmed
    utimate, who has really worked for
    her too to get her husband. So i
    never believed in spell but i had no
    other choice than to follow her
    advice. Then she gave me the email
    address of the spell caster, So the
    next morning i sent a mail to the
    address she gave to me and the
    spell caster assured me that i will
    get my husband back the next day.
    What an amazing statement!! I never
    believed so he spoke with me and
    told me everything that i need to do.
    Then the next morning So
    surprisingly my husband who didn’t
    call me for the past seven months
    gave me a call to inform me that he
    was coming back. So Amazing!! So
    that was how he came back that
    same day with lots of love and joy,
    he apologized for his mistake and
    for the pain he caused me and my
    children. Then from that day our
    relationship was now stronger than
    how it were before, So i will advice
    you out there if you have any
    problem contact Prophet Dr Ahmed
    utimate he is real and always ready
    to help you solve your problem
    Email him at:
    Ahmedutimate@gmail.com or call/
    whatsapp: +2348160153829

    ReplyDelete
  11. MY HUSBAND IS BACK WITH THE GREAT HELP OF DR SAM LOVE SPELL

    My husband was flirting with another woman. until he vanished away, I was desperate to get him back, I wasted so much time and money trying to get my Husband back, I tried almost all possibilities to have him back and nothing worked. I became lonely. To make it short, I found a spell caster Dr Sam. I saw the good testimonies about his wonderful work and after reading the Testimonials, I decided I had to try and give it one last try and After the spells, a miracle happened, my husband came home. It was awesome, anyone who needs help, should email him (Supremespellcast@gmail.com Or Supremespellcast@yahoo.com) Or whatsApp him on these number. +2347087462033..

    ReplyDelete
  12. Medialord helped me monitor my husband's phone when I was gathering evidence during the divorce. I got virtually every information he has been hiding over a year easily on my own phone: the spy app diverted all his Whatsapp, Facebook, text messages, sent and received through the phone: I also got his phone calls and deleted messages. he could not believe his eyes when he saw the evidence because he had no idea that he was hacked.i strongly recommend (hacksecrete@gmail.com) text or call him on +1(617) 402-2260 . His services are cheap and affordable , am sure he will help you

    ReplyDelete
  13. REAL ONLINE LOVE SPELL CASTER PRIEST WISDOM THAT BROUGHT BACK MY EX LOVER YOU CAN EMAIL HIM on supernaturalspell@yahoo.com or whatsapp him +2348124644470

    Hello everyone i know there is someone somewhere reading this,My name is lisa donna from USA,I want to share a great work of a spell caster called PRIEST WISDOM my husband and i had a fight which led to our divorce but when he left me a part of me left with him and i was to sad and cried all day and night i was searching something online when i saw people testifying about his great work and i just decided to give him a try i did everything he told me to do and he assured me that after 24 hours my husband will come back to me,the next morning to my greatest surprised a car stopped outside my house and it was my husband i'm so happy he can also help you email him at supernaturalspell@yahoo.com or whatsapp him +2348124644470 ... OR VIEW THIS https://lettalaabourtrelationship.blogspot.com....

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hello,

    I'm Dr Ogudugu, a real and genuine spell caster/Spiritual healer with years of experience in spell casting and an expert in all spells, i specialize exclusively in LOVE SPELL/GET REUNITE WITH EX LOVER, MONEY SPELL, POWERFUL MAGIC RING, ANY COURT CASES, FRUIT OF THE WOMB, HIV CURE, CURE FOR CANCER, HERPES, DIABETE, HERPERTITIS B, PARKINSON’S HERBAL CURE, BECOMING A MERMAID, BECOMING A VAMPIRE, SAVE CHILD BIRTH. They are all %100 Guaranteed QUICK Results, it most work. If you have any problem and you need a real and genuine spell caster to solve your problems, contact me now through my personal Email Address with problem case...Note-you can also Text/Call on WhatsApp.

    Contact me -
    Email: greatogudugu@gmail.com
    WhatsApp No: +27663492930

    ReplyDelete