MONDAY, MARCH 17, 2025
"Oopsie" and "Boom," two jailers replied: At one time, dating back three decades, Edwin Chemerinsky was frequently seen, on American TV, as a highly regarded legal analyst.
Since 2017, Chemerinsky has been dean of the UC Berkeley School of Law. On March 7, his guest essay for the New York Times. appeared online.
It appeared in print on Monday, March 10. Headline included, Chemerinky's guest essay said this:
The One Question That Really Matters: If Trump Defies the Courts, Then What?
[...]
Thus far, the Trump administration has given conflicting signals as to whether it will defy court orders. On Feb. 11, Mr. Trump said, “I always abide by the courts, and then I’ll have to appeal it.” And that same month, the acting solicitor general, Sarah Harris, wrote in a footnote in a brief to the Supreme Court: “The executive branch takes seriously its constitutional duty to comply with the orders of Article III courts.”
But just one day prior, Mr. Trump posted on social media, “He who saves his Country does not violate any Law.” A week earlier, Vice President JD Vance posted, “Judges aren’t allowed to control the executive’s legitimate power,” implying that the president decides what is “legitimate.” This follows a history of assertions by Mr. Vance suggesting that the president need not comply with adverse court rulings...
Trump and Vance had been broadcasting hints, Chemerinsky said. For the record, Trump is the one who was said to be the child of "a high-functioning sociopath." Vance is the one whose beloved grandmother—she was the stable one in the family—once poured lighter fluid on her husband while he slept and set the man on fire.
(More on the relevance later.)
More on the relevance below! For today, it starts to look like the executive conduct has hit the fan regarding Chemerinsky's fashioning of "The One Question That Really Matters." We refer to the remarkable conduct which occurred, over the weekend, under the cover of various forms of darkness.
Various facts in the garbled case remain in dispute. As we type, the dual headline above the long news report in the Washinton Post is telling Post readers this:
White House official says 137 immigrants deported under Alien Enemies Act
Trump officials said the deportations don’t violate a judge’s order barring use of the Alien Enemies Act for removals—but also questioned the order’s validity.
Paraphrasing those Trump officials very broadly, the deportations don't violate the court order—but so what if they did?
Putting it a different way, Chemerinsky's question has perhaps been called. Along the way, the American nation now stands in thrall to the open mockery of jailers and other masked men. As part of their lengthy report in the Post, LeVine et al. report this:
White House official says 137 immigrants deported under Alien Enemies Act
[...]
U.S. District Judge James Boasberg on Saturday temporarily blocked Trump from using the act to swiftly remove immigrants without a hearing and instructed officials to return any airplanes carrying them to the United States. He ruled after advocates sued saying the administration was denying immigrants due process and putting them in danger.
But early Sunday, Trump administration officials shared video footage from El Salvador that showed shackled immigrants being forced off airplanes at night and into a new mega-prison.
“Oopsie, too late,” Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele posted on X, referring to the judge’s decision, followed by a laughing emoji. Secretary of State Marco Rubio reposted it, and a White House spokesman responded with a meme saying, “Boom!”
Bukele said the United States sent his country 238 members of the Venezuelan Tren de Aragua gang and more than 20 members of the Salvadoran MS-13 gang. He released a three-minute video that showed the alleged gang members escorted off three planes by heavily armed men wearing camouflage as dramatic music played. The men were loaded onto buses and taken to the prison, where their heads were shaved. El Salvador said the United States will pay for the prisoners to be jailed.
“Thank you for your assistance and friendship, President Bukele,” Rubio posted on X.
The American nation is now subject to the open mockery of a Central American tinpot-adjacent jailer. A nameless figure inside the White House added his or her own analysis:
"Boom!" So the masked spokesperson said!
("Ou-boum" was the crucial sound described by E. M. Forster in A Passage to India, a 1924 novel about the terrible difficulties which may be involved in the clashes which may occur between different cultures. You can search right here.)
In this way, the Trump administration seems to have called The One Question That Really Matters. These various actions will be described in vastly different ways depending on where American citizens go for their information and for their tribal messaging.
Under current arrangements, there's no real chance that the large array of basic facts involved in these matters will ever get sorted out. In their lengthy report, the Post reporters do attempt to sort out the facts concerning a basic question:
Did the Trump administration continue to send planes to El Salvador even after the court had said that they must stop?
The facts there will be endlessly juggled. Along the way, the Post reporters also tell readers this:
In exercising this wartime power, Trump called for the swift removal of Venezuelans allegedly involved in Tren de Aragua, stripping them of their right to an immigration court hearing. The act has been used only three times before to bar citizens of hostile enemy governments from the United States, and only during a declared war.
[...]
The Justice Department has said that most, if not all, of those deported under the proclamation were serious criminals, but it did not release their names publicly so that claim couldn’t be independently verified...
The high-profile actions make it clear that the administration will deploy force and fright to remove immigrants from the United States, even if they have to devise extraordinary new ways to do it, such as sending them to a country that is not their home country and putting them in jail.
The White House’s online mocking of the judicial order by the chief federal judge in Washington added to the concern among advocates that Trump’s determination to carry out the largest mass deportation campaign in U.S. history would sidestep legal and humanitarian norms.
That's where the news report ends, with a bit of editorializing possibly inserted. At any rate, one key word there is "allegedly." Two more key words are "has said."
Along the way, the reporters refer to the "online mocking of the judicial order" by the White House. They add that to the undisguised mocking of the American nation's legal order by the Central American strongman.
Were the people who were sent away really "involved in Tren de Aragua?" Such facts will never be clear.
(The endless errors by the DOGE "engineers" may not inspire complete confidence.)
Also, if some of those people have in fact committed crimes, why weren't they arrested and placed on trial? In the conceptual chaos which is certain to follow, such questions will be addressed in some regions, will be swept away in others.
Along the way, the American nation is now being openly mocked by a Central American strongman! He joins the ranks of strongmen around the world with whom the American nation, for better or worse, is increasingly being aligned.
So it may go as cultures die in an Information Age. In a related matter, a second event took place last Friday night.
That evening, on the PBS program Washington Week, Jeffrey Goldberg—he's plenty sharp—had assembled a three-person panel to help him discuss such events. At one point, he turned to Stephen Hayes and the exchange shown below occurred.
We were struck by what was said—and by what was withheld. At issue was the latest of President Trump's highly unusual orations about making Canada the 51st state.
For the full transcript and videotape, you can just click here:
GOLDBERG (3/14/25): Steve, I want to find a diplomatic way of saying this. But, I mean, it's nuts.
HAYES: Crazy.
GOLDBERG: Okay. I mean, it's like, we have our ally, we've had a stable relationship with this ally with a long—we have a huge trade relationship, obviously tourism and interaction, like, across a three thousand mile peaceful border. It seems like a totally extracurricular kind of project.
Maybe it's diversionary. Maybe it's a way of talking about things that he wants to talk about. But what's the—tell us the—
What's the secret? You've got two minutes to tell us the secret.
What is the impulse here that makes him do—say a thing that no American president in our lifetimes, or really any lifetime, would ever imagine? Seizing Canada, taking Canada as a state?
The notion is "crazy," Hayes said. Goldberg said it was "nuts."
"What the secret?" Goldberg now said. What's "the impulse here?" What's the impulse which leads the sitting president to behave in the ways he does?
What's the secret? Why does he do it?
For better or worse, none of the players on the program was willing, or was perhaps sufficiently skilled, to move beyond the merely colloquial with respect to those questions—with respect to the person who allegedly suffered the misfortune of being born to a badly dysfunctional father.
Over here in Blue America, the socialites keep playing it safe. Over the weekend, the strongman—in this case, the strongman Down There—was openly mocking their failing culture as it continued to be disappeared.
Tomorrow: "Ketamine," Goldberg said. But who was he talking about?
That Trump is a Russian asset is the secret everyone knows, but no one is willing to admit.
ReplyDeleteI was at a meet and greet for Trump, and playfully greeted him as Agent Krasnov, and at first he was confused, he said oh are you from the Russian envoy?, and I said not that I am aware of, and then he cracked a weird smile, or so I thought, because he then emitted a LOUD fart, soon followed by a stench so bad you can not imagine.
Delete
ReplyDeleteTalking about crazy, what do you think, Bob, about declaring all the auto-autographed decrees of one crazy brain-dead Brandon null and void?
I'm curious if the Supreme Court will agree with it. I certainly would. What about you, Bob?
You need a software update, Soros-bot.
Deleteanon 10:07, someone beat you to the punch - you came in second today in posting your brainless comment. You need to click more often to see if TDH has posted. Apparently, according to you, it's all right for our POTUS to have persons rounded up on a plane and sent in chains to a prison in El Salvador without giving them a chance to dispute that they belonged to this gang, under some statute enacted in 1798. Not much chance of you getting appointed to SCOTUS, I would think. Meanwhile, I suppose according to you the present POTUS is beyond the jurisdiction of the courts anyway.
Delete
DeleteThank you for the usual totally irrelevant word-salad, Soros-bot. I would expect nothing less from you.
Good, one anon 1:51 - you got the Soros-Bot thing in there - as well as "word salad." You sure know how to make a compelling argument (???). Maybe your assertion would be more convincing if you said things in ALL CAPS.
DeleteAuto-signed pardons - let the facts come out. I don't know whether there is any evidence that the pardons were auto-signed or not, with or without Biden's knowledge,. Or if the validity of the pardons ever comes before a court, they would be upheld. As far as I can tell, you have no knowledge either. This would presumably come up if a federal prosecutor sought to charge anyone who received such a pardon. That would seem to be unlikely to happen, given Trump's distaste for "lawfare."
Well there is that video of Biden explaining why he granted the Fcking Pardons you Fcking Idiots.
Delete
DeleteVideo? Cracka, please. Special Council Hur officially declared him non compos mentis. That's a fucking Special Council! I trust Special Councils.
Nazi bitch. You have no respect for the rule of law, just the rule of a bunch of weird fucking Catholics whose souls are owned by Leonard Leo.
DeleteAre you having a stroke, Arty?
DeleteThe entire Republican Party is a stroke-fest.
DeleteNo, Nazi bitch, are you?
DeleteIt's the Tourette, then, right? It's clear that you're a sick puppy.
DeleteJames Carville said it clearly a few weeks ago:
ReplyDelete"That boy aint right"
Dems seem to be on the wrong side of this issue. It's legal to deport these people regardless of other crimes, because they're illegal immigrants. It's praiseworthy to deport these awful gangsters, even if some other illegal immigrants are deported with them.
ReplyDeleteI must admit that the case has some fascinating legal aspects. It's my understanding that the law Trump applied more or less prohibits a judge from overruling the President's decision. That seems to give the President extraordinary power, since he's the one who decides whether the conditions apply that would bring this law into play.
The sun on the meadow is summery warm.
DeleteThe stag in the forest runs free.
But gather together to greet the storm.
Tomorrow belongs to me.
The branch of the linden is leafy and Green,
The Rhine gives its gold to the sea.
But somewhere a glory awaits unseen.
Tomorrow belongs to me.
Now Fatherland, Fatherland, show us the sign
Your children have waited to see
The morning will come
When the world is mine
Tomorrow belongs to me
Tomorrow belongs to me
Tomorrow belongs to me
Tomorrow belongs to me
Crossing the border isn't a crime. It's a civil offense.
DeleteOn the other hand, stealing from a children's cancer charity is a crime.
Committing fraud under the banner of a University business is a crime.
Somehow, I don't see the guy you elected to be President, due to your insatiable appetite for bigotry, deporting himself.
Another issue where some Dems seem to be on the wrong side
Delete16 Senate Democrats Vote Against Fentanyl Crackdown
Would you like to run for re-election when your opponent can paint you as pro-fentanyl, pro Tren de Aragua?
The sun on the meadow is summery warm.
DeleteThe stag in the forest runs free.
But gather together to greet the storm.
Tomorrow belongs to me.
The branch of the linden is leafy and Green,
The Rhine gives its gold to the sea.
But somewhere a glory awaits unseen.
Tomorrow belongs to me.
Now Fatherland, Fatherland, show us the sign
Your children have waited to see
The morning will come
When the world is mine
Tomorrow belongs to me
Tomorrow belongs to me
Tomorrow belongs to me
Tomorrow belongs to me
David in Cal,
DeleteI love it. I'd like to see the media pound them on this, if they ever get tired of reporting that the entire Republican Party is pro child starvation.
DeleteI am an idiot-Democrat. I love little kittens. I adore little kittens.
Cutting off funding to feed starving children plays like a smart move to Republicans, which is curious because it makes the US look bad while enhancing how others perceive China.
DeleteRepublicans are rotten to the core, and it is not "born in the bone", it comes from their shitty parents.
Don't bad Republicans adore little kittens? How horrible. Bad, bad Republicans.
DeleteRepublicans hate Americans.
DeleteDavid, the law Trump invoked gives him powers during a time of war to be used against the enemy country.
DeleteHave we always been at war with Venezuela?
Republicans hate America.
DeleteD in C - you are way off the beam as far as the Alien Enemies Act - you should read it, 50 U.s. Code, sections 21-23, before opining about what it says. It seems what your guy, who somehow is now our president, has done is a gross violation of that statute. (If you recall, I was the one here who pointed out, in detail, how the stormy daniels criminal case against trump was bogus - unlike you I try to be objective)-
DeleteLooks like we're going to find out who actually signed the Biden pardons that Trump is arguing are null and void.
ReplyDeleteThere is the fcking video of Biden explaining why he granted the pardons you Nazi bitch.
DeleteWhat's to be done about bad Court rulings? Of course the President should obey the Court. OTOH a single low level judge should not be able to control the entire Executive Branch.
ReplyDeleteNow Fatherland, Fatherland, show us the sign
DeleteYour children have waited to see
The morning will come
When the world is mine
Tomorrow belongs to me
Tomorrow belongs to me
Tomorrow belongs to me
Tomorrow belongs to me
you didn't have any problem with one judge in fucking Texas stopping student loan forgiveness, did you Dickhead?
Delete"a single low level judge should not be able to control the entire Executive Branch."
DeleteA single person shouldn't be able to skirt the law, just because they want to.
“ the President should obey the Court. OTOH”
DeleteNo, DiC. There is no “ on the other hand. “ This is the way the system works. Either the President obeys the court, or he doesn’t. There is no OTOH. That you pose it as a two sided argument is part of your problem, in my opinion.
it's not a single low level judge though, that's what appeals are for no?
Delete
Delete"No, DiC. There is no “ on the other hand."
Hmm. But don't idiot-Democrats believe that the President together with a friendly Congress can "pack" the Court? Or is it only true for Democrat Presidents?
It makes sense for Trump to disobey laws and court orders, since Trump is interested in authoritarian rule and seeing how far he can go with becoming a dictator.
DeleteRepublicans did "pack" the court, claiming a rule under a Dem president, and then laughing off the rule under Trump.
DeleteTell it Matthew Kacsmaryk, David.
DeleteQiB, thank you.
DeleteJudge Shopping, Explained
A quirk in the case-assignment rules for some federal court districts allows litigants to choose their judge.
[snip]
Some districts, such as the Northern District of Texas (which includes Amarillo), have chosen never to randomize across divisions, allowing plaintiffs to “shop” for a judge by filing in a division where that judge hears all the cases. Unsurprisingly, conservative activists have flocked to the northern district’s single-judge divisions where they are guaranteed a conservative judge predisposed to issue national injunctions blocking liberal federal policies. What’s more, each of these judges decides whether their court is the proper venue — a decision that is difficult to appeal.
**************
What’s on tap today for us Blues? Democrats are trying to bring murderous raping gangs back from Venezuela.
ReplyDeleteDemocrat party's favorability rating stands at 29% – a record low in CNN’s polling dating back to 1992 and a drop of 20 points since January 2021.
Unfavorable: 54%
NBC News poll: 44% say the country is headed in the right direction under Trump—up from 27% in November.
That’s the highest number since 2012. It hasn’t hit 44%+ since 2004.
Just 7 percent of Americans have a very favorable opinion of the Democratic Party, the lowest number ever recorded.
The Democrats will get a lot of traction with the public for providing 2nd Amendment rights to immigrants.
DeleteThe American public is quickly tiring of white people fucking everything up.
White men invented this country, everything it stands for, and every structure and product that has made its citizens prosperous, and died to defend it. Now the do-nothings sit on the sidelines and carp.
DeleteAgree, in America the blue states/areas provide most of the labor and produce most of the gdp, while those in red states/areas parasitically living off blue states, lazing around in their McMansions and trailer parks, high off Fox News and meth.
DeleteI can retire early and move to a red state, buy a McMansion, and have blue staters foot the bills? Can't wait.
DeleteBut agree, impoverished trailer trash are disgusting. They should stop being poor but it's fun to puff out our chests with superiority, isn't it?
11:32 AM could have added: they were Gentiles.
Delete
DeleteYes Sir, Mr. Soros. I am an idiot-Democrat and I hate the working class too.
People who live in larger homes inherited their wealth, people who live in trailers are kept down by those that benefit from generational wealth.
DeleteIn both cases - red state fancy homes and trailers, they are lazy people, 11:38 is correct, they live off of blue states, much like parasites. Red states also have the highest rates of crime, particularly violent crime, the highest rates of domestic violence, child abuse, drug use, etc.
Rural living is incompatible with Capitalism.
Delete
ReplyDeleteKeep draining the swamp, Mr. President. Don't stop, please, keep draining the swamp.
As long as idiot-Democrats are going nuts and shitting bricks, you're doing alright.
You bought the Deep State's line about Trump draining the swamp? Sad.
DeleteHave a modicum of respect for yourself, and stop being played by the Deep State.
Over the weekend Ukraine destroyed both one of Russia's biggest oil refineries and Russia's gas pipeline to Hungary, prompting MASSIVE uprisings in Hungary, Serbia, and Georgia against their Putin-puppet leaders.
ReplyDeleteThis triggered Trump to illegally invoke the Alien Enemies Act; performatively Trump deported mostly innocent brown people - ruining their lives, in order to give cover to his fear of encountering similar uprisings in America.
Ukraine also shot down another Russian fighter jet, and destroyed an entire caravan of artillery vehicles.
Propaganda from Zelensky the dictator.
DeleteThere are videos on YouTube detailing all this, as well as debunking your Putin propaganda nonsense, you can Google it.
DeleteEvery time Ukro-Nazis start screaming about their great victories, I know they just got trounced.
DeleteThis time is no exception.
Except there's video of all this, so you are just full of shit 11:14.
DeleteEvery time I hear about our "immigration problem", I know another white person just got passed over in the job market by an immigrant, who is a harder worker, and much smarter than them.
DeleteAgree, the real Replacement Theory is this:
Deletea fear that incompetent White men are being replaced by competent women and people of color.
DeleteI saw the videos of the uprisings, and it was indeed massive, hundreds of thousands of civilians protesting. Most Americans oppose Trump, but why are they so relatively complacent? They have been anesthetized by storytelling and worn down by the precariousness of their lives brought on by neoliberalism.
Delete"Most Americans oppose Trump, but why are they so relatively complacent?"
DeleteActually, most Americans love Trump; as he won the presidential election, in a landslide, just a few months ago, despite spending a lot less money, and being viciously opposed by all state-run media.
And indeed there was a minor uprising in DC, after the 2020 (rigged) presidential election. The Democrat party had to deploy 25,000 troops in DC to protect themselves during Brendon's inauguration.
Khalil is a tourist. Deporting him will crush the tourism industry of the U.S., to the delight of President Putin.
DeletePity the poor rapist murdering illegal gangbanger who was occupying America and was then dragged onto a plane and taken to a labor camp in El Salvador. The Democrat judge tried to turn the plane around and was mocked.
ReplyDeleteThe judge had to turn around the plane.
DeleteTurns out the gangbanger filed election papers, first.
The fate of this gangbanger is now in the hands of the electorate, as laid out in the Constitution.
He'll win easily, unless there is a candidate who stole money from a children's cancer charity. Then all bets are off.
"Pity the poor rapist..."
DeleteHow Bob Somerby can you get?
"Pity the poor rapist"
DeleteThis is how we got President Trump, in the first place.
The electorate empowered the executive with great, vast, powers and he is using them.
DeleteYup, Trump using his powers is driving down his popularity.
DeleteTrump is awesome!
The audacity of Trump's actions. Leftists everywhere are in a state of shock and awe.
ReplyDeleteDo it again, Mr. President.
Other than finding a Republican voter who isn't a bigot, Trump can do anything.
DeleteLatest poll has Trump approval on the economy at 41%, disapproval at 54%, showing a steady decline since his inauguration.
ReplyDeleteTrump barely squeaked by in the election, mostly via low Dem turnout and purging votes.
Trump remains deeply unpopular in America.
Somerby, thumb, scale.
ReplyDeleteRinse and repeat.
Ignorance aint gonna manufacture itself.
DeleteSomerby continues his quest to normalize capitulation.
Delete
ReplyDeleteI am an idiot-Democrat, and I loooove government thievery.
It's for the children... For cancerous children... For puppies and little kittens... So, so cute... Excuse me while I cry...
White grievances for President!
Delete11:22,
DeleteThanks for nothing.
It's idiot-Democrats, like you, that are keeping us from de-funding the police.
The police only prevent/solve about 2% of crime, their primary function is to protect private/personal property of the rich.
DeletePolice budgets are full of waste, fraud, and abuse.
Policing in America is a racket, some will fall for it, others will see through it.
The private property of the rich is insured and they can afford private security. Unfortunately for the non-criminal poor their property is left unprotected because police are busy finding violent criminals and drug dealers, but ultimately deciding not to aggressively stop them from invading the next poor person's home because they will lose their jobs thanks to rich white liberals.
DeletePolice are the "private security" of the rich, that is their primary function. Police do very little as far as crime goes, they only handle about 2% of crime.
DeleteThe rich create crime by stealing from the working poor, and then throwing their lives into a tailspin for the smallest infraction (or often invented infractions).
The rich have been stealing from us all for decades, they are the true criminals, having stolen $50+ trillion since 1981, when the Republicans took over our country.
12:43 is correct, policing is a racket.
Facts are under idiot DOGgiE "leadership" Government spending is up over Biden. Crooks and Moran's Inc.
DeleteWe know you love Government thievery, you voted for a convicted fraudster and felon 3 times. Are you people allowed to use mirrors? Idiots the whole lot.
DeleteUkraine is still going strong, same with immigration, inflation, the genocide of Palestinians, and Republicans' desire to cut Social Security and Medicare.
ReplyDeleteTrump has filled his admin with neocons, neoliberals, Christian Nationalists, White Supremacists, Nazi fanboys, incompetent clowns, and sexual predators.
It is unsurprising that Trump ran on "peace", yet while he golfed over the weekend, he killed children by indiscriminately bombing Yemen, and he is trying to aid Putin in Ukraine, and he is funding the genocide of Palestinians.
Who knew?
Somerby knew all this, it was easily predicted, but Somerby handwaved all this away, enslaved by his undying need for emotional comfort to soothe his wounded soul.
Republicans are hell bent on destroying our country to benefit a handful of billionaires.
DeleteYet Somerby keeps whistling his same dumb right wing tune, without a sincere or genuine care in the world.
DeleteTypical of Republicans, lacking integrity is a feature, not a bug.
DeleteSomerby's buyer's remorse over Trump...is DELECTABLE!
ReplyDeleteI voted for Trump because he was willing to demonstrate, even in front of children, how to fellate a man.
ReplyDeleteOooo, that's hot. But which man? Couldn't be Musk, with his botched penile implant.
DeleteProbably Putin, payback for Putin funding all those political pundits with YouTube channels and *ahem* blogs.
DeleteI thought about voting for Trump when he gave money to that 13yo girl he raped to pay for an abortion.
DeleteI thought, hmm Trump is pro abortion, cool.
But then that raping a 13yo thing kind of got to me, I don't know, seems kinda wrong.
So in the end I did not vote for Trump, too many rapes. Got to draw a line somewhere, amirite?
"He shanked it."
ReplyDeleteLOL!!!!
Never gets old.
Somerby describes A Passage to India as a "clash of cultures", what a genteel description.
ReplyDeleteNo, it was not merely a "clash of cultures", it was one country violently dominating and subjugating another country.
Somerby is such a weirdo.
Then Somerby goes on to quote two neoliberal neocons that supported the Iraq War, with Goldberg more a centrist and Hayes a typical right wing loon.
BYD reveals 5 minute EV battery charging.
ReplyDeleteFederal judge orders astronauts to be returned to space station
ReplyDeleteBabylon Bee.
Delete